Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

There is a cricket saying, if a batsman does not watch the ball carefully onto the bat, bad things are likely to happen. The local news will be consumed with the resignation of former prime minister Owen Arthur from the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) after being a member for 43 years for the next week or two. Arthur’s resignation – which took many Barbadians  by surprise – has triggered a flood of speculation about how it will influence the porakey political landscape of Barbados. Sadly we have found yet another politically motivated event to distract from the important job of rebuilding Barbados. Has anybody noticed Barbados dropped from 38 to 59 in the Human Development Index?

The imposition of the Municipal Solid Waster Tax (MSWT) on Barbadians by the government has proved to be the most controversial government initiative since the 8% salary cut on civil servants salaries in the 90s. Coincidentally, that austerity measure was also imposed by a Democratic Labour Party (DLP) government battling to manage in harsh economic conditions. What the MSWT has done is to provoke a greater level of interest by the public in how government is managing the affairs of the country. It has resulted in a strident call by ordinary Barbadians for government to be transparent in how decisions are being made. The MSWT is good for Barbados because it aggravated Barbadians to march, again. Because of the muni tax Barbadians were able to force the government to claw back on a policy measure which was signed-off. The tax forced a former prime minister of fourteen years, and a member of a political party for forty three to resign. The wreck caused by the muni tax is a work in progress.

Owen Arthur’s resignation will hog up the news space with stoking from the DLP spin doctors because it removes the spotlight from a government labouring to find ways to spur the economy. BU will not be distracted from the issue which has been the catalyst for unprecedented rising public discontent in the government. Unless there is dramatic improvement in the economy between now and the next general election the discussion will be whether Mara Thompson and Dennis Kellman will retain their seats, two DLP safe seats.  The BLP, currently in disarray, has time on their side to fix the wrongs.

There is a strong feeling the MSWT is unjust and unless the government is able to convince Barbadians otherwise this will be an issue on the next general election platform. What makes this issue upsetting for many is the refusal or inability of the minister of the environment Denis Lowe to effectively interact with the public to answer many valid questions and concerns.  No where in the world will a government propose to build a USD300 million Waste to Energy Plant using new technology (plasma gasification) and expect to implement as a business as usual project.  The discussion which is currently taking Barbados by storm should have been encouraged by the government BEFORE the decision to sign a MOU with Cahill Energy. Any sensible government would have engaged a more transparent approach to introducing the technology of plasma gasification to Barbados.  Even more disgusting is the flat refusal by Lowe to engage the most visible NGO on the environment in Barbados , The Future Trust.

It is interesting that two large initiatives the government has launched are being championed by two ministers who are not very forthcoming with sharing information with the public.  The government has placed a lot of store on a renewable energy program and a waste to energy initiative, BU agrees with the approach, but Ministers Denis Lowe and Darcy Boyce are two of the lease likely to win the hearts and minds of Barbadians on any issue which require a champion. If the government of Barbados is interested in being transparent it is advised to take the job of effectively communicating with Barbadians more seriously.  Frankly, Barbadians have become very frustrated at the corn beef approach adopted by BOTH political parties to secure popularity. This is the age of social media which has fuelled a different expectation how Barbadians want to be informed.

We hear from Jepter Ince  – his shortcomings notwithstanding – more than Darcy Boyce and Denis Lowe, why?


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

197 responses to “Solid Waste Tax Good for Barbados”


  1. I find it difficult to resist the writer’s basic premise; and would only ask again, in my innocence, whether there is any causal link between the tax and the Cahill project.


  2. David — Your DLP slip is showing !


  3. Wily Coyote……your lack of comprehension is showing !


  4. O.K. David have it your way.. U need to get a handle on reality..Friday demonstration (if)so be called proved nothing.it was quickly demoted to its rigthful place of a political rally with lack of good reason and causes for change.mia brought charges against govt which were unfounded and in so doing marched thousands of people on to a stage of lies and deception.the traversy and tragedy of this march is that in end mia was placed under a microscope and was fully examined and exposed by two of her colleagues as a champion of nonsense ..and which many and all by now have agreed there is no chance for repeal..the news media some who had jumped on the mia bandwagon have found itself caught up in this deception and needless to say this story has been magnified not by the numbers but by the climatic input embroiled by the truthfulness of OSA..yes there is plenty of houecleaning to be done both by media and the BLP and this story would continue to make headlines.with OSA being the story


  5. David,

    This is good ”What makes this issue upsetting for many is the refusal or inability of the minister of the environment Denis Lowe” as for many other Ministers.

    That said, there is much more of concern, agreed that the Solid Waste Tax is just one symptom, in itself of inept management.

    On that – is it equitable? How can churches and charities pay it? How can businesses survive when things are already rough? Is it logical? No, when will it be collected? December, if that? Nothing in Treasury until then?

    No, illogical for practical reasons.

    The environmental levy made more sense. Increased VAT made more sense.

    This is just blatant ineptitiude, trying to apply an unjust and illogical solution to a basic problem, lack of government revenue. It is not really about waste, this is about lack of government revenue. And they are straw grabbing, THAT is what is worrying people.

    The other thing, major to this, is the complete lack of effort by government to trim their own expenses, whilst burdening the taxpayer with more and more.

    Continuing frequent expensive trips by Ministers, continuing a large portfolio of Ministries when we all are trying to cut back and affording less and less, is arrogant, insensitive, hurtful and does nothing to improve the economic situation.

    A case of ‘do as I say and not as I do’.

    That is why the public is…

    ‘;Going With MIA’!!!!

    ‘Like it or lump it’, one may cogitate on that in the course of one’s perambulation through the labyrinth that constitutes the compositions of these blogs.

    😉


  6. Robert Ross..if u read OSA statement u would have got the answer..u too was led and misled to march under a banner of political deception…well about three thousand.funny how this number becomes significant in that so many can be easily duped.


  7. Many who march it was not only about the solid waste tax, it was the realization the government is leading the country effectively and therefore not executing.


  8. ac | July 27, 2014 at 7:28 AM |

    O.K. David have it your way.. U need to get a handle on reality.

    Ooooh, that’s rich.

    .Friday demonstration (if)so be called proved nothing

    On the contrary, (just as you are doing now).it proved that Government could not care less if people marched, screamed, sat quietly and complained.

    It proved that they care not….. for the opinions of the good citizens of ‘This Fair Land’.

    The march did not matter to them. They ignored it. The opinion of thousands did not matter to them. They ignore it.

    At least Jonesy did not ‘crack heads’!

    One thing to be thankful for …………..thus far anyway.

    Ouch!


  9. David, any truth to the story of a minister who allegedly put 5 million in a family members bank account, the family member passed away, and the siblings now want the money as part of the estate???


  10. @Crusoe

    BU posted a blog covering the story. Unless we get a sight of the bank records or a family member comes forward Lowe is safe. We understand his brother went to the Nation newdpaper with the story but they have not published it.


  11. David,

    In a case (speaking hypothetically of course), that a persons’ estate is being settled, anything in their accounts go according to either will or the estate laws.

    Thus, those with an ‘interest’ (for example family) in such estate would be safeguarded by the rules therein. Surely?


  12. @Crusoe

    In this case the crap will rise to the surface, eventually. A PM preaching integrity may want to use the opportunity to send a message that there is a different kind of leader around.


  13. @ac
    3000 DUPED???

    What bout the 50,000+ REALLY DUPED, SCREWED, ROBBED, DECEIVED, TRICKED,SWINDLED, HOODWINKED,HOAXED, DEFRAUDED,
    CHEATED, DOUBLE CROSSED by an INCOMPETENT and CORRUPT bunch last election?????????????????????????????????????????


  14. @Moneybrain

    Still on the warpath about the Ontario Election……


  15. MoneyBrain | July 27, 2014 at 8:21 AM |

    ac

    What bout the 50,000+ REALLY DUPED, SCREWED, ROBBED, DECEIVED, TRICKED,SWINDLED, HOODWINKED,HOAXED, DEFRAUDED,
    CHEATED, DOUBLE CROSSED by an INCOMPETENT and CORRUPT bunch last election?????????????????????????????????????????

    ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
    for what it is worth,,,,,,,,,,,,,usual political poopycock……….steupse………get serious………steupse………..anyhow so sorry to hear about your plight,,,,,,,another reason to put on your marching boots,,,,,,i guesss……….

    @ david……..
    Your called for integrity…another one of the dismal failures demonstrated by MIA on friday as she march her way on to being classified as a megalomaniac …simply for the lack of being truthful……….an issue which would haunt her political ambitions,,,,,,,,


  16. Anyone remember that there was talk of a Mangrove Pond Landfill Gas-to-Energy Project. The goal being to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the Mangrove Pond Landfill utilizing a landfill gas control system. Construction of a 2-5 MW electricity generating plant or a
    Leachate Treatment System.


  17. Integrity is the refusal of this government to implement transparency legislation, integrity is a prime minister promising to do something about election irregularities he witnessed and has done nothing about it as he promised.


  18. @Sarge
    Lil difference between these fuggers!

    Left handed teef versus right handed teeeef


  19. I listened to Owen Arthur and wondered. What his demeanour said that his speech didn’t – I think he’ll not be content sitting as a back bench BLP Member for St.Peter.
    A break away Labour Party as his next move?


  20. @ac
    I marched out of Bim in 1980 BUT certainly wont be marching back in at retirement and bringing my $Millions wid muh! Tom chase me way wid 70% TAX! Proves the best “education” aint worth a rass if U dont have COMMON SENSE! Poor Tom, liked him otherwise and knew Bree fairly well.

    ac, I would tell ya best of luck BUT U wont be able to devine the difference!


  21. A splint away party by Arthur and co would be a dagger in the back if the BLP and greatly impact chance to be elected.


  22. The left hand know what the right hand doing , this tax and this plant.Government is so stupid, this will be an environmental disaster and a colossal financial failure.

    Light and Power feeling the pinch from private solar and looking for an excuse to hike their rates.What guarantees that BL&P will snap up the opportunity to buy more power at a profitable rate from this plant , yet competing with their own operation.

    Power rates will go up though promising to be cheaper to those who stay on the national grid .Has the demand for power increased so significantly that we need this plant to add to the national grid when indications show that private demand on the grid is slowing even by BL&P own’s admission ?

    If the plant supposed to be fed from the excess garbage,what happens to that garbage until the plant is finally finished?Can Barbados supply this plant continually to return a profit on investment?If the plant isn’t profitable then the tax will have to go up again to subsidize the plant.

    This tax and the plant dont make any sense.


  23. Flawed analysis, flawed conclusion or as they say in the tech world and in keeping with the subject GIGO ( Garbage in-Garbage out).

    This was purely a political event orchestrated by Mia who saw an opportunity to leverage her popularity and she jumped on the opening provided by Comrade Bobby to achieve same. Bobby didn’t care about transparency all he cared about is that the tax was too onerous.
    Judging from the reaction from various sources this is a pocket book issue and I don’t care where you live people don’t like to pay taxes but the author wants to ramp it up as an issue of transparency and I can see from the wording of the article that the author’s pet project is an organisation that was not consulted.

    The people of Barbados are being played as pawns by a cynical politician who it seems will stop at nothing to achieve her ends. She knows that none of the recent measures taken by Gov’t will not be reversed under a BLP Gov’t and her alternative for this tax was dismissed as worse by none other than the economic guru and former PM credited with pulling Barbados’ nuts out of the economic fire.

    Integrity and transparency are important but trying to paint this march as a consequence of inaction on those fronts are to put it mildly – a stretch.


  24. The key is for the energy produced by the WTE plant be sold at a lower rate than produced by BL&P and two, that the government pass on the savings to Barbadians. This is one of the reasons why people marched and are concerned, a lack of transparency.


  25. @Sargeant

    Nonsense, it does not mater if MAM’s motive is political, her march is aligned with how ordinary people feel.


  26. […] news will be consumed with the resignation of former prime minister Owen Arthur from the … Continue reading → visit main […]


  27. Moneybrain…….not even I would want to take you on this morning, you are sharp and ready…….fools rush in……lol


  28. David……actually, that’s the least Owen Arthur can do for Barbados right now, mentor a new political party, show them the pitfalls…….he owes Barbados and taxpayers that much, anything else and he would just be collecting a former PM’s pension and an MP’s salary at taxpayer’s expense……he owes the people big time


  29. @WW
    It never ceases to amaze me how people have great faith in Pol Parties and Pols. Dem wusser than USED CAR Salesmen! Dem only good for PULLING WOOL over peeps Eyes.LAUGHABLE!


  30. @Nostradamus

    Are you following this story? What is the latest with the Sluice Gate at Graeme Hall? Does anyone believe this nonperforming minister of the environment can efficiently oversee the implementation of a 600 million Waste t Energy Plant? Bear in mind Oistins is held up as #1 tourist spot in Barbados.

    Sewage water stink at Oistins

    Sewage water stink at Oistins MICHELLE PAYNE showing water running at the back of some of the stalls. (Maria Bradshaw)

    By MARIA BRADSHAW | Sun, July 27, 2014 – 12:08 AM

    DIRTY SEWAGE water is surrounding several stalls at the Oistins Bay Garden, and angry vendors say it is causing them to lose sales and customers.

    For the past four weeks, vendors at the popular eating and entertainment complex have been sweeping out the water, hosing down their stalls and even sprinkling sand on the offending outflow, but their efforts have failed to alleviate the unsanitary situation.

    The water is seeping out of wells which are connected to the stalls. Vendors whose stalls are located at the back of the complex are the ones most affected.

    Pointing out that the National Conservation Commission (NCC) was responsible for clearing the wells, vendors charged that the agency had been tardy in addressing this situation.

    Please read the full story in today’s SUNDAY SUN, or in the eNATION edition.


  31. @David
    Nonsense, it does not mater if MAM’s motive is political, her march is aligned with how ordinary people feel.
    ++++++++++
    Now I get it see which way the wind is blowing and try to get to the head of the line but don’t offer any solutions….


  32. David wrote “Does anyone believe this nonperforming minister of the environment can efficiently oversee the implementation of a 600 million Waste t Energy Plant”

    Yes he can. He has an army of competent civil servants to deal with the implementation.

    As long as he get’s praise from the investors he will leave the real work to others and do photo ops.


  33. I forgot to add to my comment “read between the lines”


  34. @Hants

    Stated tongue and cheek right? Have you spoken to a PS recently about how how they view many of these ministers? The words used are not complimentary.

  35. Outside Observer Avatar
    Outside Observer

    1991-193, we marched with 20,000 strong against tougher austerity measures and what happened? NOTHING.
    Marching and demonstrating was effective back then because we did not have the mediums such as BU, Facebook to further express our discontent.
    Today, we have such mediums and I’m sure government is already totally aware that Barbadians are unsatisfied with what is going on with the economy through these mediums .


  36. @Outside Observer

    BU keeps reminding all that it is a process, what transpired years ago adds to what happens in the present to define the future.


  37. Politics aside.

    We need to focus on the fact that Barbados has a gargantuan ongoing problem with waste.

    Waste to energy makes sense unless we can do like Toronto and ship garbage somewhere else.
    That won’t happen.

    However the single biggest problem Barbados faces is lack of transparency.

    There is always the cloud of corruption when Government makes deals without fully informing the public.

    Transparency, Freedom of Information and Integrity legislation MUST BE IMPLEMENTED.


  38. Can you imagine tourists and Barbadians returning for Crop Over having to enjoy fried fish and other delectable offers at Oistins but offended by the raw stench of odours from sewage? Isn’t it ironic some of us are concerned the government is not serious about the environment?


  39. @ Well Well

    it is a time for a new set of people neither DLP or BLP but independents to come to the front of the melee, from now, and offer themselves for public service.

    It is painfully obvious that this lot of BLP and DLP-ites have lost their way and besides the teifing of the peoples money to line their impoverished backsides and the megalomania as they seek to become Prime Minister or Ministress, they are bereft of any intellectual ideas.

    For the most part, were it not for their bevy of speech writers, generally the Permanent Secretary, the DPS or the senior technical officers in the various ministries, the public would see them as the real jackasses that we have collectively elected to the HoA.

    It is now 2014.

    A change will come by 2030, it is the change that is occasioned by the wheels of time and the Harbinger of Death when all of us ole fogeys will be dead and the “we going wid Owen crews” those of us who vote/voted for party irrespective of the dearth of ideas that said party relished, will all be caterpillar food as opposed to being the walking, breathing dead.

    Unfortunately, the younger more educated, wiser youth that are now coming up CANNOT wait 16 years, why man the cuntry will be dead in another year if viable alternatives are not employed/deployed to stave off this economic famine that we are experiencing at the hands of the DLP.

    Now here is where I deviate slightly from the rank and file.

    Take a serious look at what is happening today across Bulbados within the private sector, the SBA, the Chamber of Commerce, the opposition and the rest uh dem institutions.

    Tell me if one uh dem, instead uh talking jobby whenever dem get a chance, tekking de lead and doing anything to show that they know what dem talking bout?

    By their works shall you know them!! and i am of the opinion that if even now that we are at our darkest hour, if them is all the economic gurus and saviours of the economy that they is pretending to be, show we whu wunna got!

    Stop talking bout how incompetent de DLP jokers is and show de res uh we dat wunna gots de ability to mek it work. It is not sufficient to say that “I have the cure” or like Benny Hinn to push people in dem forehead and topple dem over, let me see wunna mek the body of a cripple straight again, grow back legs dat deformed or amputated, then I will believe in wunna.

    Until den, wunna is jes as impotent as de DLP skunts


  40. @IslandGirl246

    “your lack of comprehension is showing !”

    As the saying goes — I’VE FORGOTTEN MORE THAN YOU’LL EVER KNOW.

    I’ve read most of your posts and they appear genuine, however comprehension of the issues and the countries situation is not a strong point. Like most Bajan’s you have trouble seeing the forest for the trees.

    The WASTE TAX fiasco is just the latest Bajan iteration of the deeply in-bedded MIS-MANAGEMENT(past & present) that exists in the country. Bajan’s have to ask the difficult QUESTIONS and then carefully evaluate and think about the answers they receive and not take the politicians answers at FACE VALUE. Bajan’s have not yet learned to think for themselves, especially those graduates from UWI with the BIG JOBS and no experience.

    The country is SLOWLY slipping into a state of ANARCHY, the quality of life is falling, business are FAILING, the economy is collapsing, tourism is faltering, offshore banking is headed up the island change to more favorable(corrupt) countries, crime levels are up, NIS is broke, Infrastructure is deteriorating and the list goes on.

    I was impressed to see Bajan’s out MARCHING, maybe finally they are starting to recognize how dire the situation is.


  41. “Hants

    There is always the cloud of corruption when Government makes deals without fully informing the public.

    I hate to inform you its not a cloud(puffy virgin white etc.), its REAL CORRUPTION at it`s BEST.


  42. @pieceuhderockyeahright

    Agree with you, we must have a vision and then have leaders to get us there to borrow a line from Hilary Clinton.

  43. Life changer + Avatar

    @ David.
    I would like not only your comments, but some of our highly informed bloggers to genuinely “ANSWER” this…??
    Dont you think there are many drawbacks to having our Attorneys & Q.C ‘s dominate politics. Attorneys and politicians seem to be of the most hated and least trusted groups of people, on our streets, as the large number of “BLOGGS”at their expense will attest, and this may be at the root of some of the public cynicism towards politics in Barbados and elsewhere.

    Although ethical conduct is considered central to both professions, they both seem to exhibit a higher than normal rate of professional misconduct and breach of trust, in our peoples perception if not in reality. For many attorneys and politicians, the point is to win at all costs – in trying to win on behalf of their client, or in trying to get elected, they often seem to push aside their convictions or sense of right and wrong in favour of expediency. Much of the vitriol directed at our attorneys and politicians is directed at their rhetorical flair – they are good at selling things and telling people what they want to hear. One cannot help but ask “YOU ALL” the question of what makes an attorney particularly well-suited to running this country, as opposed to running for office. Many of our elected officials important duties involve running the economy, allocating resources and budgets, and analyzing policies based on their inputs and expected outcomes, yet lawyers have less experience at this than businessmen and economists (the next most common professions in politics). When it comes to deciding on whether to join a currency union, how to direct a trade negotiation, whether to cut taxes or how to design a social program, our attorneys appear dangerously under-qualified compared to businessmen and economists, and oh, of course they get paid whatever- as in the case of legal matters, only they need a retainer they are that confident….

    Thanking you in advance for your timely responses.


  44. @David an excellent piece. if I could like this a million times I would.
    What we have in Barbados is an exploitation of the loose check and balances. DLP and BLP protects each other and use theatrics as well as threats of exposure to win votes. N

    We can all feel proud that Uncle Sam knows it all and it’s only a matter of time.


  45. @ Hants

    We acknowledge as you have said we have a problem with waste but this is a simple as “1, 2, 3 (4)”

    One. Cut back my ingrunt fence from the front road 4 feet.
    Two. Dig four holes in de ground and concrete dem sides, lef a way fuh water to drain out or evaporate away. Mek sure dat dem got covers
    Three. Have de ingrunt government distribut four coloured bins which will hold diffrunt contents, Red fuh metals, yellow fuh plastics/styrofoam, green fuh organics and blue glass
    Four. Give an incentive fuh dem peoples dat build de bings demselves a tax credit

    Set up a factory where some uh de 3000 retrenched workers can extrude de coloured bins fuh dis project.

    Go to IDB or UNDP/GEF fuh grant or udder funding for dis Green Cities initiative

    Separate people garbage at source and STOP THIS SHITE UH PAYING SOMEBODY MILLIONS UH DOLLARS TO DO WHU MY GRANS DOES DO WHEN DEM FINISH WID DEM FOOD.

    We too freaking highfaluting and dat is why we asses hey at this crossroads, ruled by visionless BuhKvunts!!


  46. @Life Changer

    Our system of democracy does not deselect any individual based on profession/vocation from offering themselves to serve. What we need is a more robust governance system with an active transparency system.We get this and man of the lawyers who cause gridlock in the current system will be exposed for what they are, parasites.

  47. Outside Observer Avatar
    Outside Observer

    @ David,
    Point taken. We should note Professor Howard view in today’s Sunday sun. Can two respected economic gurus be wrong on this initiative ? Me thinks in light of government’s latest concessions on this tax, supported by the academics, government may be winning the political fall out on this one.


  48. @ pieceuhderockyeahright ,

    I Live in Toronto and we have a 3 bin system and it works.

    Bajans like to copy North American lifestyle so why not copy a system that would be good for the Island.

  49. Life changer + Avatar

    The “waste management” reality in most places of the world equals no separation, no controlled collection. Dump your stuff next to the street outside the village, like your ancestors always did, and you’re fine. When all the efforts to burn fail (which they usually do), cover the remaining pile with a thin layer of earth and ignore the horrible smell. The method has been around for centuries and it worked very well until recently: Self-sufficient agricultural societies traditionally took all their goods from nature. Because those goods were 100% biodegradable, nothing happened when they were dumped – they simply returned to nature. This is the tried and tested waste management system of the developing world. The problems began when 20th century inventions were injected into this system, inhibiting the cycle from continuing to function the way it used to. Plastic packaging, oil containers, tires, batteries, electronics – they all interfere with nature’s absorption capacity. In the same way these products originate from an artificial production cycle, they require an artificial treatment at the end of their lifespans. However, even as fast as these “new” products conquer new markets, the awareness of the need for a change in waste management is inversely slow.
    Perhaps, we should all take care of our rubbish. We already have our 10 cent bottle collectors, why not organic collectors. Place an exta bin outside your house, at a simple cost for all biodegradables. People need to learn how to help themselves. We have two compost bins in our garden and convert all our organic waste back to the garden.

  50. Outside Observer Avatar
    Outside Observer

    @ Hants
    This easier said than done. We have to engender a disciplined culture of household garbage separation. It requires a change management process starting with the young ones in the schools where they will take and nurture this behaviour into their adult lives.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading