The following articles were written by Tricia Watson, a respected social commentator, particularly on energy-related issues. The Blogmaster extends sincere thanks to her for granting permission to share her writings in this space. Special thanks are also extended to Peter Thompson for his assistance in facilitating this arrangement – Blogmaster
So who is paying for Barbados’ energy transition? Electricity ratepayers are!
Dear Bajans,
Pull out your light bill. Now ask yourself a simple question: who decided what is on it, and did anybody ask you?
The Saturday Sun Editorial of October 10 says Barbados is on the horns of a dilemma: households squeezed by the “skyrocketing” cost of living, employers wary of wage rises, and electricity costs climbing again.
The Editorial, interestingly, anticipates that Barbados Light & Power (BLPC) will be granted a rate increase when it asks for one in the next six months, and pleads, plaintively, that the increase be reasonable. But what is “reasonable”? And who decides?
Under the law, “reasonable” is a finding based on tested evidence. It is not a feeling or an assumption. In the 2021 rate case, BLPC argued that it deserved an increase because it had gone more than a decade without one.
It used inflation-related arguments to suggest that a $48 million annual increase would simply restore what it had lost. The Fair Trading Commission (FTC), without testing the BLPC’s evidence, ordered an “interim rate” increase, amounting to $29 million per year. We have been paying that unsubstantiated increase for 49 months and we continue to pay.
In its 2018 manifesto, the then Opposition Barbados Labour Party (BLP) promised to “by 2030, transition Barbados to the first 100% green and carbon neutral island state in the world . . .” . As is the case with manifesto promises, the BLP did not explicitly state how it intended to finance the transition, and who would foot the multibillion-dollar bill.
Energy transition
So who is paying for Barbados’ energy transition? Electricity ratepayers are! Every household, shop, church and small business will pay through their monthly bills. Businesses and Government will also pass electricity costs on through the prices of goods and services.
The estimated $4 billion to $5 billion needed to move from roughly 15 per cent renewable electricity to 100 per cent will be collected through base rates, riders and the fuel clause. And remember what is being funded: the existing fossil-fuel plant AND the new, expensive renewable investments, on the same bill.
In principle, I do not oppose the transition. I oppose one that leaves the people paying for it in the dark. This is not just a technical project; it is a political and social one, turning on four questions: who pays, who decides, who benefits and who carries the risk.
• Diagnose the delay honestly
Government and its allies say regulatory delay, meaning particularly FTC rate proceedings, is holding up projects that support national policy, and they blame rate-case intervenors.
As a participant in these rate proceedings, I agree that a rate case that drags on helps nobody, least of all consumers. But delay has many parents: incomplete applications, evidence redacted as “confidential”, late filings by the utility, unanswered questions and, more recently, ministers stepping into the process. Consumers are the only parties not contributing to the delay.
Consider the Renewstable hydrogen project tariff application. With Cabinet’s approval, the Minister of Energy announced that tariffs would be decided by September 15. It is now November, no ruling has been issued, and intervenors in the Renewstable rate case that remains open before the FTC have not been told anything by either the minister or the FTC.
How can citizens be the bottleneck in a process in which nothing is happening? They are not.
Public rate hearings
The practice of public utility commissions holding public rate hearings to regulate rates charged by utilities has been around for over 125 years in this hemisphere. In Barbados, public rate hearings forcing our utilities to prove that they deserve the rates they ask for have been the norm since the 1950s.
In the last full rate case, intervenors tested the evidence, and the FTC reduced the return requested by Barbados Light & Power from 8.79 to 7.47 per cent, ordered compensation for overcollection, and ruled that $100 million taken from the Self Insurance Fund had been unlawfully withdrawn and paid to the shareholder and should be returned to ratepayers. That is scrutiny producing results for consumers – not intervenors causing needless delay.
When a rate case concludes swiftly and approves costs that have not been tested by a rigorous process that includes examination by knowledgeable interested citizens, that is not necessarily efficiency. The phrase “trust us” is not a reliable regulatory system, and “nimbleness” is not a measure of regulatory effectiveness.
That October 10 Saturday Sun Editorial added, in a frighteningly casual manner, that getting a “reasonable” result out of the FTC is dependent “on the articulation of advocates like Tricia Watson” who participate in rate hearings.
This should worry us greatly. A system that leans on a few citizens who turn up, without being paid, without being treated fairly and who are not listened to by the FTC or the Government, is not protection for the consumer. That is a system that requires consumers to rely on hope, luck, or divine intervention for their interests to be represented.
Fairness to electricity consumers must not hinge on who has the time, money and intestinal fortitude to show up and to keep showing up.
• Read the law, not the press release The Government now proposes a ministerial process under Sections 37(4) and (5) of the Utility Regulation Act, which lets a minister exempt specified matters from the Act where he is satisfied the public interest requires it. The Government rhetoric assures us that this ministerial process will not displace intervenors, arguing that the public may still be invited to present their concerns. But an invitation is not the same as a right to participate.
Let me remind you that the Act lets a minister EXEMPT a power producer from scrutiny – it does not empower the minister to step in and set rates in the FTC’s place.
When electricity companies, like the Light & Power, like Renewstable, are exempted from complying with the law that exists to protect electricity consumers, who decides what you will pay, and by what method? What is certain is that in such a case, rates will not be set by the independent regulator, public participation is not guaranteed, and the rates will be decided behind closed doors.
Your only role in such a “system” will be to meekly pay the bill regardless of the amount.







The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.