← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Minister of Finance Chris Sinckler imposes another tax on Barbadians
Minister of Finance Chris Sinckler imposes another tax on Barbadians

The government of Barbados has delivered on a promise to implement the municipal solid waste tax on an already overtaxed Barbadian. The tax is introduced in the  Municipal Solid Waste Tax Bill, 2014 as, “There shall be charged, levied and collected on the site value of improved lands”.

There has been a lot of discussion about the tax but BU is confident Barbadians -for the good of country – will dig into savings and ask the bankers to increase limits on credit cards.

Barbadians are aware the government is cash strapped and is currently on a quest to find creative ways (used loosely) to generate revenue by levying taxes hither thither and yon. Some argue successive governments have not done enough to efficiently collect taxes owed to the crown. Several blogs have been posted to BU identifying Courts Barbados, a leading furniture and appliance store in Barbados who owes BD$25 million in VAT.  The article $200 owed has appeared in the traditional press further highlighting government’s leaky collection management system. Minister of Finance Chris Sinckler in his defence recently established  the Barbados Revenue Authority (BRA) whose remit is to efficiency address tax collection.  Government agencies are not known in Barbados for being efficient but the BRA has the opportunity to be a trail blazer.

Barbadians will bombard the call-in shows, post to social media but will PAY the solid waste tax, do not look for any civil disobedience to match the Poll Tax Riots. The tax is a burden to many at this time and was made so by poor implementation. BU understands the tax invoices were mailed on June 15, 2014 and according to the Act were due on June 30, 2014. After a public outcry the authorities announced the date extended to July, 2014. It is inconceivable our policymakers could not have anticipated the window to pay was too narrow and proactively extend the payment date to pre-empt wasteful public discussion.

Many questions have been asked about the quality of decision to impose a solid waste tax. At the top of the list is the obvious decision by landlords who will pass on the tax to tenants.  Then there is the middleclass who have had to give up a significant chunk of disposal income in the last six years to shore up government’s revenue. It is this same group who has to find tuition fees, pay mortgages, car loans etcetera. The end result is a fall in the quality of life for many Barbadians. Often times if it is made clear why a sacrifice has to be made many will gladly do so. Are the majority of Barbadians confident the government by example and quality decision making is on the right path?

What has informed the decision by government to levy a tax on Barbadians who have toiled to create wealth by owning property in the last 20 years? Who the hell penalizes individuals who purchase property especially given the history of the dominant Black population? Senator McClean’s assurance that “… a property with a site value of $100,000 with a solid waste tax of 0.3 per cent means that the property owner will have to pay a tax of $300 per annum. The point I am making is that some people were saying that it was going to be a very large sum of money, but that is not the case. So basically what this tax is intended to do, is help Government pay for the cost of our growing consumption and generation of garbage whether it is household waste or commercial waste.” – Not for everyone does not show sympathy at all. The solid waste bills have started to litter mailboxes.

One can only assume the Municipal Solid Waste Tax describes the sorry state of government’s finances. Who the hell  tax the property of a fledgling middleclass?


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

152 responses to “Fledgling Middleclass et al to Pay Municipal Solid Waste Tax”

  1. Concerned Citizen Avatar
    Concerned Citizen

    Rubbish!

    That’s how Minister of Finance Chris Sinckler is viewing widespread public calls to refund or waive the controversial Municipal Solid Waste Tax on the site value of properties that generate waste in Barbados.

    Sinckler told Barbados TODAY this afternoon that Government had no intention of reviewing the tax at this stage.

    He also said calls by former Prime Minister Owen Arthur for relief on behalf of his constituents in St Peter, which have been echoed by other Barbados Laour Party MPs, was not as straight forward as they may seem.

    Sinckler explained that for individuals to be considered for refunds or remittances, they must be paying the tax in the first place.

    He said that Arthur was misleading the people and he warned that persons waiting for relief in such circumstances and missed their deadline to pay, would suffer penalties.

    He however acknowledged that under Section 5 of the Municipal Solid Waste Tax Act, the Minister of Finance could grant reprieve.

    “If the minister is satisfied on grounds of undue hardship or for any other reason that it would be just and equitable to do so, he may remit or refund the whole or any part of the tax imposed under this Act, including any penalties thereon, payable or paid by any person,” the law states.

    However, the Minister of Finance pointed out that the law did not make provision for waivers of the tax, amidst pleas from the Dairy and Beef Producers Association for its members to be exempted.

    Sinckler also responded to threats by some persons to take him to court to get relief from the tax.

    “The legislation is clear. It says that the minister may, it didn’t say I shall [give relief]. The court can’t make its own law and say I have to give [somebody] relief, because it’s may. It’s just a circus they are trying to create. I analyse, and do an analysis . . . and then I make a decision, based on what the advice is [coming] from the technical people,” he insisted.

    Commenting on reports that the Opposition was preparing to send letters to him on the matter, the Minister of Finance said: “If they are all over the place giving the impression that if they write a letter to me that I have to automatically do it [that is not the case].

    “. . . they have to show the hardship, you pay and then you ask for it,” he said.

    He suggested that there was another story behind the solid waste tax.

    “People have to know that it is because of the failing of the last administration that we are in the position that we are in now. But we have to do this [impose the tax]. It’s either you’re going to tax it on land, or put it on food. Either way it has to be done.

    “And if you do it on imported stuff, it can’t be on imported stuff only, it has to be done on all production in Barbados,” declared Sinckler.

    He blamed then prime minister Arthur for imposing an environmental levy which he said the current government was forced to remove because of challenges faced with CARICOM and the World Trade Organisation.

    He warned:“If we do it that way again, straight to the CCJ [Caribbean Court of Justice], and the CCJ rightfully will say, ‘it is a tax against CARICOM imports into Barbados, remove it’.”

    Sinckler argued strongly in defence of the tax was on land saying “if you have to pay [businessman] Bizzy Williams $30 million to treat garbage to reduce the volume of the garbage going to the Belle . . . there is nothing else.

    “They ain’t no other landfill in Barbados. So if you don’t do waste to energy, and if you don’t extend the life, as it is, of the current cell, we have to take [millions of dollars] to get done. If we don’t do that, Barbados will have a problem where we have no place to put garbage,” he stressed.

    Sinckler said everybody want their garbage collected, but many do not know that it is a nightmare now for the Sanitation Service Authority.

    He said Barbados was now $70 million out as a result of “Mount Stinkeroo” which was extended to its final cell that cost more than $30 million.

    “That’s $100 million that we spent already and then you have turn around now and pay $30 million a year to treat the garbage to reduce the volume so you can extend the life of the landfill, and nobody wants to pay for it,” he said.

    emmanueljoseph@barbadostoday.bb


  2. Caswell again proved right…
    Stinkler is an even bigger idiot than he looks….

The blogmaster invites you to join and add value to the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading