Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Worthing Square

The blogmaster has been in town too long to accept the Nation’s headline ‘Outdoor facilities awaiting green light emblazoned on today’s page 3A. There is no doubt in the mind of the blogmaster traditional media is easily manipulated by the political directorate and shadows with deep pockets not necessarily in that order.

Barbados Underground has posted blogs highlighting the ongoing struggle and frustration of Allan Kinch to develop his property located on Bay Street. The blogmaster does not have a bone in the fight, however, there is prima facie case as presented in the court of public opinion to more than hint there is more in the mortar than the pestle.

See related link:

What triggered the Nation newspaper report was a recent fire at the popular Worthing Square. We have been enlightened by Maria Bradshaw’s report that Planning and Development Department (PDD) will take action against Savvy On the Bay (Allan Kinch) this week to block ongoing restoration of the National Trust protected structure which use to be the eye care facility. 

There is so much to unpack from today’s Nation newspaper story. One wonders if the newspaper should not have anchored its story on the fact planning permission concerning the property is mired – deliberately or by design who knows – in a government department since 2012. Senior Minister William Duguid’s barefaced confirmation is in today’s Nation newspaper report. The manipulators of news would have us believe that PDD has been galvanized into action as a result of the recent fire at Worthing Square. 

Two subplots to this story is first the role of Prime Minister Mia Mottley. There should be little doubt that all decisions concerning big works in Barbados must pass Mottley’s smell test. In today’s story Kinch is quoted referring to an onsite meeting with Mottley and AG Dale Marshall in 2021, “I had a meeting onsite with her with the Attorney General present, Kinch said, pointing out that he gave Mottley the undertaking that he would develop 60 feet of parking space as well as a shower and bathroom facility ‘for the people of Barbados’….”she said once you are willing to do that I am good,”…she (MIA) said once you are wiling to do that I am good,”…she told the planners at that meeting to get permission sent out and I (Kinch) am still waiting .

Another of the considerations tagging this matter that should be of concern to Barbadians are the competing developments in the area. We have the start of construction of a show condo unit by Hyatt, there is The Daisy Group whose interest in the locality have largely been sliding under the radar? To identify only two.

Here we are with businessmen applying to develop our coastline, unapproved development allowed to continue for years a stone’s throw from the Prime Ministers office and it takes a random fire at Worthing Square to encourage the Nation newspaper to present a one sided view of the issue. Maybe, just maybe this is the first of a a series of articles to shed light on the matter as a responsible member of the fourth estate.

Money talks and bullshit walks!


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

113 responses to “Conspiracy!”


  1. Outdoor facilities awaiting green light
    By Maria Bradshaw mariabradshaw@nationnews.com

    Two popular outdoor food and entertainment facilities are operating without approval from the Planning and Development Department (PDD).
    Sunday Sun investigations reveal that the Worthing Court Food Garden at Worthing, Christ Church, and Savvy On The Bay at Carlisle Bay, Bay Street, St Michael, have both submitted applications to the PDD for retention but have not received any planning permission to proceed with their operations.
    This newspaper understands that this week the PDD will take action at Savvy On The Bay against the ongoing restoration of the National Trust-listed stone building which was once an eye care facility.
    Worthing Court Food Garden, which was previously a car-park, started operations in 2021 and presently have more than 20 food trucks on location. According to reports, those concessionaires pay from $1 000 upwards in rent monthly, depending on the size and space utilised.
    Over at Savvy On The Bay, there are 14 food trucks and a bar with operators paying $1 500 monthly in rent.
    When contacted, Dr William Duguid, Senior Minister in the Prime Minister’s Office with responsibility for coordinating infrastructural projects as well as the PDD, confirmed that there was no planning approval at both locations.
    Asked if that meant that they were operating illegally, he said: “I can’t say what is illegal or legal but obviously, the process is that you put in an application and once you get permission then you start.”
    He said officials from the PDD had recently visited Worthing Square since a fire gutted one of the businesses two weeks ago.
    When asked if this was a widespread practice in Barbados, to proceed without planning permission, the Senior Minister would only say that there were applications on file at the PDD since 2012 awaiting approval.
    The proprietors at both locations also admitted they had no planning permission.
    Allan Kinch, who bought the lands at Bay Street back in 2015 from Government, said he had an outstanding 14 applications on file at the PDD for various projects but indicated that he had a meeting with Prime Minister Mia Amor Mottley, who is the minister in charge of planning development and Attorney General Dale Marshall, at the site in June 2021.
    “I had a meeting on site with her with the Attorney General present,” Kinch said, pointing out that he gave Mottley the undertaking that he would develop 60 feet of parking space as well as a shower and bathroom facility ‘for the people of Barbados’.
    “She said once you are willing to do that I am good,” Kinch revealed, adding: “She told the planners at that meeting
    to get the permission sent out and I am still waiting.”
    Kinch said he submitted three applications for the Bay Street site, including condominiums, the rebuild of the jetty and the restoration of the old building.
    He estimated that there were more than 100 people employed by the concessionaires at Savvy On The Bay, which is a 24-hour operating facility and which has proven to be a major eatery and entertainment attraction for both locals and visitors.
    Kinch also confirmed that he met with planning officials last week but said they only spoke about the restoration of the building which overlooks the traffic lights on Bay Street.
    “I went to a meeting at the request of Dr Duguid to discuss the 14 town planning applications that have been outstanding, waiting on a decision, some of them from as far back as 2006, over 16 years. When I got to the meeting, they said they are not dealing with any of those, but we are discussing my application for Savvy. I sat down with more than ten Government officials and listened to what the Attorney General had to say and I asked him to put it in writing for clarity so I can respond.”
    Kinch said he was informed he could not replace the roof of the restored building.
    However, pointing out that the building which has already been totally renovated downstairs into bathrooms being utilised by the public, Kinch said he could not understand why he could not replace the roof on an existing building that was built in 1805.
    “They tell me it is illegal to put the roof back on. It is remarkable to learn that if somebody has a house and the roof blew off or damaged that you can’t put the roof back on. So I am waiting to hear formally what it is that they are complaining that I am doing wrong. The building is the first National Trust listed building that the plaque was placed on by Errol Barrow and it is a protected building and therefore it is to be restored to its original state and not demolished or changed.”
    He recalled that when the property was put up for sale by Government it was advertised for tourism development purposes.
    “I was the highest bidder and they got back to me and said even though my bid was the highest bid I would need to pay a million dollars more. I agreed and I put down my deposit and I completed the sale.”
    Kinch further explained that the food trailer application was a limited life application as his intention was to reinstate the jetty and relocate all the food and bar vendors onto the jetty.
    Of the Worthing Square operation, spokesperson Neysha Soodeen told the Sunday Sun that after three years in operation we “have not been given approval as yet”.
    However, she stressed
    that: “Worthing Square was allowed to operate while awaiting approval.
    “It started off as a community project of which we were then told we need Town Planning approval. Plans were then sent into the Town Planning Department and they came in and did their inspection and said we could operate while waiting on approval,” Soodeen said, adding that they also received permission from the Environmental Protection Department and the facility was inspected every month by health officials.
    Soodeen, who indicated that she works for Government as a consultant, emphasised there were no “structures” on the land. “It’s just food stalls there and they are on wheels,” she explained, adding that the operation was started during the COVID-19 pandemic to assist those involved in the food industry.
    “It was really just done as a community project because we had the land but we could not do anything with it because our father had passed away and it was held in the estate. At the end of the day, we can’t do it forever because it is not a profitmaking project . . . . We don’t make money off of it,” she said.
    Questioning the length of time it had taken to get a decision from the PDD, Soodeen said: “Most people do not go ahead operating a business for three years if they think that they are going to be held up in court . . . so we are allowed to operate until Town and Country Planning says yea or nay and if they say nay then we have to close down and if they say yea then we would continue.”


    Source: Nation


  2. “I sat down with more than ten Government officials and listened to what the Attorney General had to say”
    WTF was the AG doing at a meeting of the PDD, where the SENIOR Minister in charge of the PDD was already present + 10 unspecified Govt officials.


  3. We fail to see any departure from the opaque culture generally associated will such developments in Barbados.

    And when we say culture we mean the culture of politics, economics, social. Issues like racism, classism etc. Whether one is seen as a member of the “golden billion” or not.

    We’ve certainly seen other people running down behind successive governments for decades to get approvals from town planning but essentially the ministry of finance or economic affairs.

    We also know that certain people, acting with a sense of entitlement, have a history of seeking to force the hand of government, sermingly acting ultra viresly. This method has not always been unsuccessful!

    Has the country not recently had extreme circumstances where if development projects were to be approved a dead Cow Williams would have had to be the developer. A culture connecting the FIRE sectors directly to foreign exchange earnings.


  4. Yes but be clear on who gets and who does not get these permissions Kinch is NOT one of these people his don’t get approved.
    What happened is others often get permissions for similar projects on nearby lands though they apply years after him.

    https://www.nationnews.com/2010/08/27/blp-column-fairness-and-truth/


  5. It’s worse than you have estimated.

    Some people get turned down, flat out. While others get approved on the same parcel, for a development more at odds with suggested guidelines.

  6. Yolande Grant - African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All Rights Reserved. Avatar
    Yolande Grant – African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All Rights Reserved.

    The ones who give the corrupt permissions, hold the town and planning portfolios.


  7. “We also know that certain people, acting with a sense of entitlement, have a history of seeking to force the hand of government, sermingly acting ultra viresly. This method has not always been unsuccessful!”

    This!


  8. The BU chatterati in full flight. #clueless🍿🍿


  9. 20. Formal Application – 0548/04/2018B (Submitted)
    Applicant(s): CARLISLE INVESTMENTS INC.
    Agent: RICHARD GILL ASSOCIATES
    Address: COPACABANA BEACH BAR,, BAY STREET, , ST. MICHAEL
    Description: (A) RETENTION, ERECTION AND EXTENTION OF BUILDINGS FOR PASSENGER RECEPTION, ENTERTAINMENT AND BEACH BAR PURPOSES;(B) RETENTION OF ROAD WORKS FOR A NEW BEACH ACCESS (C) ABANDWORMENT OF A PUBLIC ALLEY AND CREATION OF A PUBLIC DRANAGE EASEMENT

    Coordinates:
    13.092174902000068, -59.61052382999998


  10. 22. Unauthorised Development – 522/B/0010/2018 (Investigating)
    Offender(s): CARLISLE INVESTMENT INC
    Address: LEWIS ALLEY, BAY STREET , ST. MICHAEL
    Description: UNAUTHORISED ENGINEERING WORKS AND CONSTRUCTION OFA BUILDING WITHOUT PLANNING PERMISSION AT LEWIS ALLEY, BAY STREET, ST. MICHAEL
    Coordinates: N/A
    View decisions/conditions


  11. @Enuff

    You are up early this bank holiday?


  12. Why should permissions sit at Planning from 2012? How does this align with the need to support private sector with best in class business facilitation? The blogmaster notes the period of time straddles both BLP and DLP governments.


  13. @enuff

    Here is the Online Nation chatterati, clueless.

    We are all clueless.

    Online readers blast lengthy wait for permission
    YESTERDAY’S SUNDAY SUN exclusive article on Worthing Court and Savvy sparked extensive debate on the Facebook page of The Nation Barbados.
    It revealed that neither Worthing Square in Worthing, Christ Church nor Savvy On The Bay at Bay Street, St Michael – two areas involved in the food and entertainment service industries – had received permission from the Planning and Development Department.
    Both had submitted applications, but approval had not been granted.
    Here are some the comments: John Eagleson: SUNDAY SUN investigators should perhaps investigate the level of difficulty an entrepreneur has to endure to receive said approval to start either of these popular tourism attractions.
    Probably it would be the root cause or contributing factor.
    Daniel Burton: And how many vendors on the ABC Highway?
    Winston Grecia: What about the unsightly heaps of coconut shells being left on the
    side of the highway?
    Christopher Hadchity: Don’t we also need to get permission and proper planning to vend otherwise?
    Why is vending of food, fruits and vegetables allowed on our highways and byways? Issue the permits and licences and let the people get on with earning an honest living. Obviously, one is not paying attention to what’s happening today all over Europe with the popularity of mobile food business. Why do we insist on one foot forward and two backward? Enough of this old, antiquated way of thinking.
    Dorry Pi: This is what we do. Don’t act shocked that Barbados works exactly how we know it does.
    Jimmy Bishop: From what I understand, it is that all the food trucks are mobile and all have wheels . . . . I like that the reporters in Bim are becoming investigative, but they need to do the whole job and not halfway. I would like to hear the whole story . . . and also both sides of the story . . . . Now I may be wrong, but can a food truck because it has wheels, get permission from a
    landowner, park anywhere and sell food without [Town Planning] permission? Because I think it can.
    De Shortest TallGirl: Something ain’t right and it shouldn’t have taken the fire for authorities to be aware, so bring the whole story.
    Chad Thomas: If they had to wait on planning permission, the business idea would remain in a folder on their laptop.
    Ethan De Freitas: It’s temporary and it’s providing a grand service to Bajans. (KG)


  14. Another thing enuff, the people will always be clueless just take the reluctance of successive administrations to enact FOI for example. Not even to wave it in name only?


  15. Enuff 0702
    What do you mean?


  16. Forgive me, I did not read the comments or the original post. For me, there is no mystery. Peel off the layers and its just a next example of sham, scam, payoff, cronyism and corruption at work.

    It’s all thievery built into a legal framework. Not guns and knives, just public officials . Don’t waste time following the noise and highfaluting discussion.

    Everything is a scam.


  17. In his retelling, “The Elephant in the Dark”, some Hindus bring an elephant to be exhibited in a dark room. A number of men touch and feel the elephant in the dark and, depending upon where they touch it, they believe the elephant to be like a water spout (trunk), a fan (ear), a pillar (leg) and a throne (back).

    It’s lack of FOI
    It’s a slow bureaucracy

  18. Yolande Grant - African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All Rights Reserved. Avatar
    Yolande Grant – African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All Rights Reserved.

    From where am sitting, they all look too sweet..murdahhh!


  19. Enuff
    What do you mean?
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Perhaps you should ask Bushie what Enuff means….


  20. Bushie
    What does Enuff mean?
    😜😜😜😜😜😜😜


  21. @Bush Tea

    What can enuff say to disabuse our minds that patronage defines our political culture whether under B or D? This is the system of government we practice and love it.


  22. That sale should never of taken place to begin with. This government needs to acquire the car park for public use and then move those blockages off the beach so that Bajans can have an unobstructed access to the beach. If Kinch wants to keep the historic building then so be it.

    That beach is one of the heaviest used beaches by locals who walk to the area and they have already lost the use of large slabs of it from December to April.

    If you or I built on a room without permission, TCP would of issued and enforced action against our illegal structure. Why hasn’t this been done with Kinch, is he one of the ” untouchables?”


  23. David,

    EXACTLY!


  24. @John A

    The deed is done, the approval of Hyatt changed your nostalgic thinking.


  25. There a so many issues that a relevant political opposition and NGOs can use to advocate and agitate for better on behalf of an apathetic, cynical and disengaged citizenry. These days it is left to a fragmented few.


  26. John A

    How is Kinch obstructing the public?

    Kinch has provided washrooms and showers, a kids playground, free wifi and entrepreneurs and opportunity to earn for their family. The rates are also reasonable.
    The parking is also far improved.

    He has not built over public land like his neighbors have
    20. Formal Application – 0548/04/2018B (Submitted)
    Applicant(s): CARLISLE INVESTMENTS INC.
    Agent: RICHARD GILL ASSOCIATES
    Address: COPACABANA BEACH BAR,, BAY STREET, , ST. MICHAEL
    Description: (A) RETENTION, ERECTION AND EXTENTION OF BUILDINGS FOR PASSENGER RECEPTION, ENTERTAINMENT AND BEACH BAR PURPOSES;(B) RETENTION OF ROAD WORKS FOR A NEW BEACH ACCESS (C) ABANDWORMENT OF A PUBLIC ALLEY AND CREATION OF A PUBLIC DRANAGE EASEMENT

    Not sure if your agenda but speak the truth!

    Like the fact that the same people who really used the parking were the ones who complained their parking was taken their parking they leased from the government for $0
    If this land is acquired by government it will NOT be for public parking but to facilitate one of those real shadows that’s keeps Barbados stuck in the muck and mire of corruption and entitlement.


  27. @ David

    What i see happening is that Bajans are to be blocked from accesing their own beaches in the name of development and its always by a certain type of person. Maloney in the still of night, bought the hotel opposite Accra beach then we learnt the purchase also included the beaxh land oppsite. Bajans rose up and that access seems to have been protected. Now Kinch goes and buys the property in Bay Street and one of the last accesses to that beach for those in the area is lost too. I am dam tired of watching a few displace the many.

    If this government is truly one for the people, then acquire the carpark are for the generations to come.


  28. @ Equalizer

    The people who use the parking sadly will not complain for they have accepted that this is the way its done. As for an Agenda yes i have one and i will write it for you in capitals below so you understand clearly my position.

    THE LAW APPLIES TO ALL INCLUDING THE UNTOUCHABLES.


  29. Did you miss the part where Kinch offered the government to add 60 feet to the current public access for the public and to put on washrooms showers parking and disabled access in exchange for permission. What you call planning gains?
    Is it not Kinch’s washrooms and showers the same public is using now?


  30. So why John A do you have no issue with those that actually built on public lands right next door?

    And do you know the land was bought from government and plans had to be submitted and the government said the plans were in keeping with what they wanted.


  31. @Equalizer

    Unfortunately we have reached a point on the island where people are fed up and all transactions of this type being highlighted with be file under ‘same old same old, two barbadoses’. It will not matter if intentions are honourable.


  32. @ Equalizer

    So here is my final comment on the issue in the form of a question to you. Its a yes or no answer so no rambling needed.

    Does Kinch have TCP approval for what he has done and has a stop notice been placed on him, if so has it now been lifted and approval granted? I only ask as i seek enlightenment on the issue.

    This question is similar to ” are you pregnant?” There is no half pregnant option. LOL


  33. @John A

    Your question is at the heart of the permissions process we have in Barbados.

    Allow the Blogmaster to ask you a question as well- did Maloney have permission to suffer the public with that encroachment at the entrance of Coverley Villages?

    The point- this is how we roll in Barbados. This is what is tolerated by our elected and unelected officials. This is the culture of how we do business.


  34. John A

    Are you aware that the agreement to sell stated that the government could stop the sale at any time if the government wished to acquire so why did they not stop it then but instead took Kinch’s money and had him pay land tax for years and spend money on the property. The agreement was done under D and the finalizing under B so if B was against this why did they not stop it then. They were fully aware. Was the point only to steal Kinch’s money?


  35. @mariabradshaw

    Are you reading?

    Do you understand how a responsible media house must unpack the facts of this matter how planning permissions are dispensed in Barbados? Appreciate if you can do a follow up this time with a focus on Paul Altman and the shadows he fronts for.


  36. The Earl of Carlisle rules.


  37. John A

    I have a question for you

    When enslaved persons cried out for freedom for justice and for what is right and they were denied should they have stopped there. Because those that made the rules and had the power were only interested in abusing them and using them to gain financially should those who were enslaved have sat and accepted it?

    Sometimes when there is great injustice people must join together against it to effect change.

    I am one for rules and those who know me know that but above that I am one for justice.

    CORRUPTION hurts the poorest in the community and that I have no stomach for. Bajans have been disadvantaged for years first by colonialism and now by those who put on the cloaks of colonizers and act without thought compassion or feeling against their fellow countrymen. Sadly some politicians who think they are smart hide behind race and try to make it seem it s about race whilst they point the finger at one white man when all the while they are in the bed with another.


  38. Bushie
    How yuh spar?


  39. @David
    @Equalizer

    Guys thatis why I say a stand must be taken on this issue.

    How can we expect the man that builds an illegal canteen to respect the law of the TCP when others are seen blatantly doing as they like? You cant expect people to take the rule of law seriously if it does not apply to ALL, both big and small. Under the last government we know it was a brek fuh yuself, so let this government not enforce the law as laid down by the TCP.

  40. Yolande Grant - African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All rights Reserved. Avatar
    Yolande Grant – African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All rights Reserved.

    Pacha..we could not make any of this up even if we tried…this is a whole movie series coming together all by itself, writing its own script…lawd..

    Ya done know i already got the book rights…started a chapter last month, and will now just let the book write itself…..too sweet.


  41. I tried, but I cannot raise my level of thinking to the high level as some of you are able to do.
    Tier 1 thinking is out for me.
    Here you use acronym like TCP, PDD, AG, FOI … in your comments.

    Tier 2 thinking is out for me.
    Tier 2 is where you talk of shadows, ghosts and untouchables and provide snippets of scams that worked out in the past.

    Tier 3 is the best I can do.
    All is a scam.
    And until Bajans start calling a spade a spade and stop pretending that they are engaged in legal transactions these scams will continue. Just one smart and two smart outwitting each other.

    The truth is, many of these government offices could be closed or manned by a single individual with a knapsack to collect the money.

    I refuse to participate in nonsensical palaver.


  42. #NevilleIsdale

  43. Yolande Grant - African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All Rights Reserved. Avatar
    Yolande Grant – African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All Rights Reserved.

    Theo….ya had to at sometime see in clarity of thought…re subject matter…trust me, you are not alone…everyone is now clued in about the collective SCAM that is Barbados and the fact that it can no longer function without corruption.

    Pacha…they did say this was quite possible.

    “First Republic Bank Seized By US Regulators

    The embattled First Republic Bank has been taken over by regulators and will be sold to JPMorgan Chase, the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI) announced on Monday.”


  44. Ya’ll need to pay attention to the picture headers which accompany threads.

  45. Yolande Grant - African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All Rights Reserved. Avatar
    Yolande Grant – African Online Publishing Copyright (c) 2023. All Rights Reserved.

    It is indeed nonsensical same regurgitation i have seen for 11 or 12 YEARS..

    But from yesterday, many more eyes are OPENED WIDE to TRUTH and REALITY…no more hiding in the shadows for corrupt scammers with their sleight of hand ….dem get EXPOSED in real time.

    People are so RELIEVED…

    None have the power to cover it up or stop what’s ahead…


  46. Whose interest is the government covertly protecting? Perhaps if we follow the money we may uncover after a couple of drinks during hobnobbing the truth may be uncovered.


  47. Waru, capitalism or democracy, same thing, is innately a corrupt system.

    Then there are those who will give the misguided quote from the fascist Winston Churchill that all the rest are so much worse, sic

    We will then rejoin by asking why then have the capitalists-democracies spent so much time and energy to establish a governance monopoly.

    For this is the existential phenomenon of these times. The Bushman put it best when he declared this is a good time to be alive.

  48. Yolande Grant - African Online Publishing Avatar
    Yolande Grant – African Online Publishing

    Truth is stranger than fiction…or delusions..

    Not many people can handle truth….but a train load of truth will unload EVAWHERE soon enuff….lawd..


  49. Waru

    Yuh see that fecker, Charlie King, is fixing to be coronated.

    He’d promised months ago that Camilia was not going to be queen but merely king consort.

    Now Camilla is queen of Barbados. Ignore republicanism. Ignore the pledge of the palace.

    Dey even asking “subjects” to make a pledge of allegiance to Charlie. When the reverse should to demanded. That Charlie pledges allegiance to the “subjects”.

    How things have changed. A socalled royal family gives legitimacy to an adulterous man who was partly responsible for his wife’s death. And a queen, a divorcee who was engaged in adulterous affairs for years, including with Charlie. From a criminal family reaching hithertofore unknown levels of decadence.

    These are the Lord’s annointed. Your king and queen. Let’s hear your public pledge😅

    Maybe he’ll get planning permission to develop some of those plantation lands inherited in Bim and held since slavery😄

    Hear the Bajan monarchists singing. “god say our king, god save our gracious king”😄


  50. And on the seventh day. The DON, Mia, exclaimed to her subjects, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.” John 14:6 (NIV)

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading