Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Jeff Broomes, headmaster of Alexandra School

In response to a BU query about the Alexandra matter which continues to simmer, the following  comment was made by a blogger.

“There is of course an obvious political element attached to the AX matter. But what of the other elements? Maybe the erroneous view was held that PHASE 2 would be the removal of Broomes by whatever means . Did you ever consider that the next phase was to get the PSC [Public Service Commission] activated to perform its constitutional function? There is now a new PSC in place. You however keep referring to the political element involved in these matters; let me suggest to you that there is ALSO A MORAL ELEMENT involved. Any good leader must see to it that, among other things, every effort is made to pass on VALUES to the society. Good leadership must not only be concerned with doing what at the time is EXPEDIENT; it must also be concerned with doing WHAT IS JUST. This would necessarily take me into a discussion on JUSTICE to which i shall return at some future convenient time …”

Rising concern about Alexandra comes against the background that Principal Jeff Broomes has excluded the 30 striking teachers from a “eight-day Easter Academy”, presumably to bring children affected by the strike up to speed. By his [Broomes] action he has buffed the teachers proposed plan to organize Easter classes. Clearly Principal Broomes by his actions is going against the spirit of compromise.

Of interest is the report that teachers selected by Broomes to participate in the ‘eight-day Academy’ are to be paid $30.00. Who will pay the teachers? It is no secret teachers are compensated for several weeks for vacation by virtue of being teachers. Why aren’t those teachers who participated in strike action at the beginning of Term II not part of the Academy? Didn’t they promise to make back up the teaching time which was lost when they were striking? Wouldn’t the Easter break provide an opportunity to make back up this time?

Given that it was reported that the striking teachers were still paid for the period of time they were on strike – is it asking too much that they put back in that time now over the Easter break WITHOUT ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION? Can the Board of management of the Alexandra School and by extension the taxpayers of Barbados afford to be paying “extra compensation” for teachers who will still receive their normal salary covering that period anyway? Both the taxpayers of Barbados and the affected students at Alexandra School are the weaker as a result of this sorry state of affairs. Who is at fault and to blame for this mess – the Minister of Education? the Alexandra Board of Management? the Prime Minister who gave his word that a phased resolution for the unrest at Alexandra was on the way in a phased approach?

Its quite clear that there is still some element of dissatisfaction and uneasiness as it relates to the solution to industrial unrest by the teachers at Alexandra School. Its also obvious that the Phase II factor has not taken root as yet. It is also interesting to note that Chief Education Officer Laurie King in response to the media recently when asked about the Phase II factor mentioned by Prime Minister Stuart, suggested that his ministry is working diligently to ensure the proper atmosphere is achieved at the school and further that his department was not aware of any Phase II approach.

Clearly the solution to the current Alexandra imbroglio was never about a slam dunk solution as many Barbadians have been conditioned to believe. Is this another case of the Prime Minister working quietly behind the scenes to deal with the matter? If we take the intervention of the blogger quoted above then the sensitivity of the matter would pre-empt public discourse at this time. The Prime Minister finds himself in another unenviable position where he may not be able to comment on a matter which has political import with a general election on the horizon.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

  1. old onion bags Avatar

    How now Brown Cow……..Big Joke Bob Hope…!


  2. evidently whatever measures are being put in place to ensure a good working enviroment is not working. however if legalities are standing in the way of Broomes removal there is not much the PM can do and has done outside what he did in getting the teachers back to work most of us had aheightened perception that mr Broomes would be removed sooner rather than later without real or hardened FACTS

  3. old onion bags Avatar

    morning gf ..so we dawned suits and now tag team again right ?we gine give them hell..lol ac and onions partners instew…tag babes..

  4. old onion bags Avatar

    @ ac
    Stupessssssss there you go again with your Perceptions foolishness…girl what has become of you ? Should have read your above comment before proposing mine.


  5. good mawn bf i don’t know for sure if we are on the same page except on the removal of Broomes as the political wheels start to grind AX again.


  6. onions you need to cool down. you must give credit where credit is due and realise that getting rid of Broomes might not be as easy a task. Broomes is an albratross which is tied around the heads of teachers and maybe just maybe he has LAW on his side so what should the PM do what’s best for a few or what’s right for a country.


  7. Off on a tangent a bit…but can anyone tell me who are the members of the new Public Service Commission?

    Thanks!

  8. old onion bags Avatar

    Barbados is quickly becoming a dichotomy of haves and have-nots..friends and friends-not. We need impartiality, All this pussy footing, and hands holding will be addressed one day coming soon remember that .

    Oh what a tangled web we weave,
    When first we practise to deceive!

    Sir Walter Scott


  9. How the hell can the Prime Minister remove Mr. Broomes without removing the striking teachers too? Is the teacher who didn’t teach for close to a year teaching or not? Could it be that the letter about her behaviour could not be found at the Ministry of Education because her husband is Deputy Chief Education Officer?


  10. The senselessness of this matter continues.

    Timetable ‘shared with teachers’ Alexandra principal Jeff Broomes. Sat, March 31, 2012 – 12:03 AM
    Alexandra School principal Jeff Broomes said he not only shared his timetable for the Easter academy with his staff, but organized the classes on the orders of Minister of Education Ronald Jones.
    Speaking to the SATURDAY SUN yesterday, Broomes said, in response to the 30 Alexandra teachers who have declined to be part of his eight-day Easter Academy for CXC students starting Monday, that on February 27 he shared, in writing, the timetable with the staff, but on that same morning one teacher placed a notice on the board asking others to indicate interest in other Easter classes. 
    “This occurred after the same teacher had heard the principal’s plans and not on the previous Thursday as is now being claimed,” Broomes stressed.
    The teachers, through the Barbados Secondary Teachers’ Union (BSTU), said Thursday they had decided not to work in the Easter Academy in the interest of avoiding further conflict, while BSTU president Mary Redman said the academy’s classes had been designed by Broomes without consulting the relevant year heads and heads of department, and only covered nine subject areas.


  11. @vanhimist

    Here are the new commissions:
     

    New Service Commissions’ Appointments
    By Cathy LashleyPublished: March 8, 2012

    Newly appointed Chairman of the Judicial and Legal Service Commission, Chief Justice, Marston Gibson (FP)
    New members of the Service Commissions have been announced by the Chief Personnel Officer.
    The Chairman of the Public Service Commission is David Bowen; while members are: Calvin Springer, GCM; Sir Everton Weekes, KCMG, GCM, OBE, LL.D; Keith Simmons, QC; and Canon Noel Burke.
    Those appointed to the Police Service Commission are: Chairman, Dr. Trevor Carmichael, QC, SCM; and members: The Very Reverend Dr. Frank Marshall, CBE; Miriam White; Keith Whittaker; and Neville Lewis.
    Appointees to the Judicial and Legal Service Commission are Chairman, Chief Justice, Marston Gibson; and members: the Chairman of the Public Service Commission or his representative; the Hon. Frederick Waterman, CHB; Madam Justice Sandra Mason; and Madam Justice Maureen Crane-Scott.
    The appointments took effect on February 10 this year, and persons will serve for a period of three years.
    cathy.lashley@barbados.gov.bb


  12. Taken from BU
    “Rising concern about Alexandra comes against the background that Principal Jeff Broomes has excluded the 30 striking teachers from a “eight-day Easter Academy”, presumably to bring children affected by the strike up to speed.”

    Taken from Nationnews, which BU cites as the source:
    “President of the Barbados Secondary Teachers’ Union (BSTU), Mary Redman, said the teachers took the decision in the interest of avoiding further conflict at the already tension-filled St Peter plant.”

    Cmon BU. Cmon.

    And not everything is political in the context of the governance of the country. You have a group of teachers who hate the Principal and are trying to get him removed. You have a Principal who is an authoritarian.

    Conspiracy theories are always more entertaining though.


  13. I ask simply what is the REAL problem that Mary Redman has with Jeff Broome ? I have heard it said and seen it reported that there were teachers many of whom were the striking ones who were opposed to his appointment as head and vowed never to work with or support him.So this is now really taking things to a ridiculous level.They said that they would give back the lost time to the students so what is the problem ! Get on with teaching the people children !! You were paid during the strike and you should be more than willing to do this now FOR FREE!!

  14. old onion bags Avatar

    Come now all…..what we are seeing unfolding before our eyes is nothing more than the ” REDRAWING of old battle lines. The teachers under Mary Queen of Scotts have awoken (vacation comin again)as Stage I has come to an end.Jeff Broomes (photo op) has thrown down the gauntlet and PM Stuart had been notified….your time is up .Stage II ..with dispatch again boys n girls.


  15. @ David .
    ” The senselessness of this matter continues ” .
    I should like to thank you for the prominence accorded to the extract from a previous posting of mine on this Alexandra matter . I sincerely believe that it presents the opportunity for readers and contributors to this blog to examine another side to the very complex situation that has been created . It should be clear too that the complexity and , by extension , the confusion has been greatly exacerbated by the continuous actions of an ” ERRANT ” SCHOOL PRINCIPAL who seems to take great delight in fostering a DIVIDE AND RULE system of governance in that institution for which he holds responsibility . The story reported above from the SATURDAY SUN is one other case in point .
    Any person who possesses a smattering of an acquaintance with timetabling in our Secondary Public schools will advise that it is an exercise that is undertaken by the DEPUTY PRINCIPAL in collaboration with the department heads and year heads . That Mr Broomes has , at this time , decided to jettison this practice and set up his own timetable for the functioning of the Easter vacation classes , WITHOUT ANY INPUT FROM HIS DEPT. OR YEAR HEADS can only be seen as an act that , IN THE PRESENT CLIMATE AT THE ALEXANDRA SCHOOL , MUST LEAD TO FURTHER CONTROVERSY . Easter vacation classes for fifth form students have long existed in our schools ; that vacation has always provided an opportunity for teachers to do some extra coaching especially for students writing overseas exams . One must wonder if , at any time , Mr Jeff Broomes ever comes under the influence of any of his FRIENDS OR ADVISORS that may assist in steering him away from INEVITABLE SELF DESTRUCTION .
    The reported setting up of the ” Easter Vacation Academy ” also raises an issue worthy of the most careful consideration . It has been reported that teachers for this Academy are being conscripted at a fee of $30 per hour ; the finance for this has been provided through a grant by a benefactor in the area . Mr Broomes will be well advised that even though the grant has been made TO THE SCHOOL , that school is NOT AN INDEPENDENT LEGAL ENTITY . The school is just another department OF THE GOVERNMENT OF BARBADOS and must necessarily account to the AUDITOR GENERAL for any money / finance passing through its coffers . Money given to the school as a grant cannot be seen as money given to Broomes TO BE DISPENSED AT HIS PLEASURE . Let Mr Broomes be warned . it is noteworthy that the BSTU has distanced itself and its membership at the school from any involvement in the so-called ” Academy ” . It should not be forgotten that they have been benefiting from the advice of legal counsel throughout the whole exercise .
    This Alexandra matter will only be resolved after a level of commonsense and good judgment are displayed BY ALL PARTIES CONCERNED . Outside of that the PSC will have to act DECISIVELY . As it now stands there is the grave danger that sound judgment is being taken over by EGOMANIA . In addition , the Nation newspaper will be well advised that no one stands to benefit from its continual trivialising of the matter by its constant publication of queries about the implementation of a so-called PHASE 2 . Peace my brother.

  16. old onion bags Avatar

    @ an Observer
    Very well comprehended and penned.I hope ac takes note how not to be incoherent…Broomes is an ass, and should GO. What he intends is to rival Hallam King….but he is making too many errors…all can see it.

    See you at Cawmeer then this evening Ole friend ?


  17. @An Observer

    There is the other view that the 30 teachers excluded from the ‘Easter Academy’ appear to be AX’s most senior teachers (department heads). One may conclude that the children are being shortchanged by not benefiting from their training and experience given the need to do makeup classes which resulted from the strike action.


  18. @ David
    ” there is the other view….”
    This is exactly the point . The most SENIOR TEACHERS in the school have been effectively ALIENATED from the management of the school . Add to this the reported information that the DEPUTY HEAD has been prevented by him from functioning in her role as deputy and you have the true picture of a modern-day megalomaniac running amok at that institution . THE PSC MUST ACT .
    @ Old onion bags .
    Unfortunately a pressing engagement will hinder any opportunity I may have to visit that shrine and pay obeisance on this occasion . Please do justice when you pay your own respect by giving a gracious bow on my behalf ,my friend . Should THE MILLER be present I hope that he too will act accordingly .
    Re : ac.
    It is my view that we may all learn and benefit from each other’s strengths in the business of continuous education . We must not forget that and must strive to make a daily advancement in our knowledge . Peace my brother.


  19. Phase 2 is the Easter Vacation.
    Phase 3 is Term 3.
    Phase 4 is Summer Vacation.

    Freundel will do nothing. Freundel is an unsure batsman. He knows not if to swipe, hook, defend or duck. But he will be stumped for being out the crease.

    I feel so short-changed by the DLP. stupse. and the inaction of Freundel further compounds the problem. Jones give a go-ahead for classes, Freundel say the teaachers will make up teh time voluntarily. More confusion in the DLP .

    They just need removing. sick and tired of the now.


  20. @MeHandsTied

    Have you read with understanding that the matter of Broomes now falls within the purview of the PSC?


  21. The problem is not if BROOMES should be removed but how does the PM go about having BROOMES removed without legal ratifications .onions you sound like a child who wants to get his own Way without rhyme or reason. if it was as easy as you think it .there is no doubt that Broomes beligerant and outlandis attitude is not going to change and added to the problem may be friends and influence but the question of how to remove him is going to be a real struggle for the PM to undertake


  22. @ Me Hands Tied.
    “Freundel is an unsure batsman “…
    you have demonstrated that you are an uneducated UMPIRE who must never be allowed to stand over the stumps or at square leg .


  23. The problem is evident that the AX situation has reached a stalemate and the longer it goes on the BSTU might again resort to Industrial action. but the question remains “what options does the PM have moving forward in order to PUT the AX situation to rest once and for all maybe you onions can answer that. i await your response.


  24. @ ac
    You keep questioning how the PM will have him removed …FOR THE LAST TIME…PLEASE UNDERSTAND .. THE PM DID NOT APPOINT HIM ; THE PM THEREFORE CANNOT REMOVE HIM . Old Onions understands that ; I hope you would . Peace my friend.

  25. Observing (and asking) Avatar
    Observing (and asking)

    @observer (clarifications)
    Timetabling is a function of the principal, not the deputy. “Alternative” timetables is the duty of the deputy. Easter classes cannot be considered “timetabling” in the strictest sense of the word. Also, the $30 is payment to teachers, not a fee for students, acquired through the school’s good graces and redirected from a summer program to easter. Also, the Principal controls the programme (and hence financial direction) of the school. Money comes in, programmes are assessed, priority determined and money is disbursed. The only “error” maybe the funds not passing thru the board but a check at ALL schools will show this is the normal (though erroneous) practice for extracurricular fund raising.

    @all
    Commenting on this matter at this stage is a futile effort. We await “stage 2” knowing all the damage that has been done, that continues to be done with the parties “forced” to exist in tense fractious circumstances and that may be done to 3 of our critical sectors. Blame will come later but a solution is needed sooner rather than later. Broomes is on “solid legal ground” much to the chagrin of many. The new PSC board may well act, but justice must be served, evidence must be used and the illusion of head hunting must not come into play.

    Observing and waiting.


  26. Ok square leg umpire ac
    You have begun to talk sense first time now in months (B.vs.D)…..just goes to show you are no fool..anyway….there is no easy answer. We have create a position ..shelters,perks, etc and all for a GENTLEMAN…and along came a rogue.Now it will be difficult to pry his ass.. without hurting some fingers….son of a fisherman convert my bot bot..

  27. Observing (and waiting) Avatar
    Observing (and waiting)

    I feel moved to add too that Broomes is clearly head and shoulders above Redman, FS and the DLP when it comes to managing public perception and “propaganding.”. Whether this is food or bad is a matter for later debate.


  28. I could not be a PM because I would fire Broomes ( if he refused an offer of early retirement ) and let the courts deal with any wrongful dismissal lawsuit.

    PM Stuart is level headed and and has taken the least disruptive option by giving Broomes,the teachers and all involved time to work out a solution.

    Time offer Broomes a retirement package or fire him with or without cause.

    Then restructure the management of Alexandra school and give the STUDENTS a chance to complete their secondary school education successfully.

    Does the PSC have qualified experienced Human Resources staff?


  29. @ Observing ( and asking )
    You may successfully that EVERY single activity in the school is ” a function of the principal ” . take that to its logical conclusion and see what we will get .
    All of us who have any association with secondary schools in this country .
    By the way , what is an ” ALTERNATIVE TIME TABLE ” ?


  30. @Hants

    Can identify with your frustration.

    What the AX matter has exposed is the ease with which sides are drawn influenced by political colour.


  31. @ Hants
    Best solution I have heard so far…..like CLICO..this will take years tied up in Court…GOOD ONE Hants!


  32. @ observing ( and asking )
    The gremlins have struck . ( correction )
    You may successfully add that EVERY single activity in the school is ” a function of the principal ” . Take that claim to its logical conclusion and see what we will get . All of us who have had any association with secondary schools in this country know that the DEPUTY PRINCIPAL assumes responsibility for timetabling .
    By the way , what is an ” ALTERNATIVE TIME TABLE ” ?


  33. Thank you observer for clarifying the point concerning as to who is responsible for Broomes removal .as it is apparant that politics of one upmanship has clouded the vision of those who believes it is a decision left soley in the hands of PM staurt to resolve. However if the situation remains as is the reality is that PM stuart would be blame So in as much as i am in favour of PM Stuart taking a clear and concise approach a meaningful and define resolution should be reached sooner rather than later


  34. ac …if the PM fired him…that is IT..Period ..doan talk..You know who he is D PRIME MINISTER….so cut D crap.1!!!!


  35. Seems to me the principal is a hands on principal.He seem to take no crap from anybody either at the school or on the board of management.I saw a contribution somewhere which suggest he wrote a letter to the chairman of the board forbidding him to enter the school’s compound.Now lo and behold the same person’s name is on the list of members of a new board.Yes,it’s a grave concern at AX with people turning red at having to step aside when a clean sweeping broom kicks up a lot of dust.

  36. Observing (and teaching) Avatar
    Observing (and teaching)

    @observer
    As you have sought to do elsewhere so will I now. Timetabling is the legal duty of the principal, not the deputy. If he/she delegates it, so be it. Alternative timetabling is required in instances of disruption to the school (meetings, exams, emergencies etc.). I never inferred that every aspect of the school is a function of the principal, I simply noted his legal duties specific to the issue at hand. Also, were we to consistently take things to their “logical conclusion” we may be in murky waters in other debates on BU. You’ve been a strong proponent of upholding the law and legal technicalities so I’ll say again, legally, Broomes is on solid enough ground. Managerially, professionally and personally may be another story but neither of those are enough as is, based on available evidence to crucify him without significant ramifications..

    Hants, I with ya 100%, but the PM has to wade carefully since he assumed FULL responsibility for the matter and its conclusion. If played wrong this bouncer could be a mini-CLICO. I still maintain that this should not have reached his desk.

  37. Observing (and waiting) Avatar
    Observing (and waiting)

    @richard
    Not just “any” new board at that.


  38. FIRED with effect ..as of mid night tonight>>>>>>>THE WAY 2 GO

    STOP PUSSY FOOTING…SHOW as a ACTION MAN…BOOM


  39. @Onions

    We all know you are being disingenuous with your last comment.

    Were the PM to do as you suggest the political fallout for the government would put a smile on your face.


  40. @ observing.
    You obviously wish to deal THEORETICALLY with what for YEARS has been a matter of PRACTICE in our schools . Please do us a favour . Check the first TEN secondary school teachers from outside the Alexandra school on this matter and get back to me . Until then , peace my brother . But be further advised that LEGAL action is heavily influenced by considerations of PRACTICE .


  41. @Observing (and teaching), “the PM has to wade carefully”

    More importantly is what happens to the children while he is wading.

    Children in Barbados are already inundated with enough distractions and sub cultural influences.

    School should not be a political battleground for ego-maniacal adults.


  42. @ David
    How could that be when the majority of people wants Broomes to go>>>>A POLL PLEASE.

  43. Observing (and waiting) Avatar
    Observing (and waiting)

    @observer
    No need to check ten schools. Its in black and white in the laws of Barbados whose duty timetabling is. How they go about it is up to them. I hope u would agree based on the consistency of your submissions elsewhere that a “habitual practice” does not make something “right” if there is “law” or “legal process” that regulates it. Likewise because something is not preferable or publicly acceptable that doesn’t infer “wrong”.

    Just observing.


  44. the pm can fire no public officer


  45. @ David
    On the contrary..had I not hang up my political cloak..on this one..I would have been more cautious with my advise..and less practical


  46. The main problem with this AX issue here on BU and elsewhere is the 30 or so persons who clearly would like to see Broomes fired and FS similarly dealt with shortly afterwards. This little group have been repeating themselves with monotonous consistency in an attempt to should like a crowd.
    – That does NOT include Hants who just happens to know nothing about management 🙂

    To everyone else, Broomes is just an over eager head teacher who probably wanted to be a army sergeant in his youth.
    Like many other bosses, some of his employees hate his guts while others like him and yet others don’t give a hoot.

    If FS foolish enough to get more involved in this situation then Bushie can supply a long list of other Bosses with whom large numbers of employees cannot function properly, and who therefore needs to be “separated”.


  47. Cheezon bred Bushie
    Ya mean the passage of time has done nothing to you or your response.
    Army Sargeant for the army, Headmaster for teachers..masculine COCK ..feminine HEN…masculine BUSHIE ,,feminime..I ent kno ?.. ALIEN may be .
    Point is square peg in round hole. Q.E.D


  48. i have it from good authority the the principal is responsible for time tabling and the deputy is responsible for alternative timetabling. thats a fact.

  49. Observing (and waiting) Avatar
    Observing (and waiting)

    @bushie
    Dem need u at d round table when decisions getting mek man.


  50. I would advise Mr. Broomes to stay away from the press and let that red deveil Mary continue her wish, as head of the union she can speak for her teachres. You have been advised by BAPP to stay away from the press, those are the persons u want to support you, please dont anger them.

    Hants u aint got a clue about the eucational system in barbados as it presently is constituted so speak the issues in canada.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending