Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by Yardbroom

letstalk If recent events are indicative of the public mood, it seems we are afraid of having a “proper debate” about homosexuality in Barbados.  We must address this situation because if we do not, opinions will become hardened and polarized, making it impossible for “understanding” and a meeting of minds.

To have a proper debate, those whom we oppose should be allowed to have their say.  We have not got to agree to a position held to listen to the speaker; it is our right to disagree and disagree we should, if that is our strongly held stance.  However, to personalize the issue by using names to substantiate  our stance is sometimes not productive; we rarely convince others by clubbing them over the head, they may cower in fear, but they will never be convinced of the rightness of our case.

As in some heterosexual relationships, homosexual ones can be challenging, so challenging that one is tempted to ask, where is the love?  Is it beyond us to show some compassion to those relationships we do not understand and cannot agree with?  Is it fair to invoke a religious position to entrench our views?  I do not know.  If the debate is opened it is possible to allow those we have never heard before  express a view.

They will only enter our house if the door is open.

Giving an audience and listening is not necessarily agreeing with what is being said, but it strengthens the reasonableness of our attitude, and gives us time to reflect. Of course there is the alternative view that all such unions are an abomination and are against strongly held religious views and nature, and cannot be reconciled with “good conduct.”   Perhaps we could use the last two words of the last sentence as the “leitmotif” as to the way “we” conduct ourselves in a mature debate about homosexuals in Barbados.

Let us concentrate on the issues not on individuals, if no personal names are used there is  a better  chance  of having an “honest and open debate” with compassion, yet underscored by  strongly held principles.

The door is open we are listening…


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

229 responses to “Public Faces, Private Lives: Homosexuality in Barbados”


  1. David I hear you plan to ban me too…Help somebody! Help! I gun get ban again… Walass.. Murdah


  2. @Carlos

    After that monologue I am yet to see how homosexual activity will affect my marriage or that of any other heterosexual, how it is evil to want to end discrimination and violent activity against homosexuals. Can you not step outside of that religious box for one second and tell me and all the other blog readers how homosexuals will cause despair and corruption outside of the very limited context of what you consider to be morally correct. Imagine that I am a militant atheist. Now tell me how homosexuality is going to turn my world upside down.

    “Radical homosexual activists readily acknowledge that the redefinition of marriage is just a tool in their greater agenda to reorder society.”

    My word, reorder society how, because the men or women next door are married my marriage will fail or mean nothing, that is hilarious and horribly insecure.

    “Once marriage is redefined for same-sex partners, it opens the Pandora’s box to be redefined for any assortment of individuals. After all, if two men or two women have the right to be married, why not two men and three women, or one woman and a dog and a chimpanzee?”

    In some cultures men are legally allowed to have more than one wife, extending to same-sex is not too far from this so I see no problem and I reiterate what does this have to do with you or me or society as a whole? Where will the crumbling come from, you want everyone to have your belief system and that is not what law is about, it is about fairness to all. As was once said the biggest threat to marriage is infidelity and divorce.

    “This is a recipe for the absolute destruction of any sane society, and will surely bring God’s judgment on any people that go in this direction!”

    There we go again, the God thing, I believe in God but forcing other to do the same is just as evil as you say the homosexuals are. I think most persons have no clue what it is to be a true Christian and to live and let live. I am sure after all this long talk about how homosexuality is wrong and nasty etc, most persons have had premarital sex, lied, cheated, stolen, took advantage of fellow man to get ahead, etc, so why this two faced attitude. I don’t believe a lot of things are correct but if I know I am doing the right thing for myself I can only advise not force and so many persons want to force which is evil in itself. Think about it. Judgment is individual not collective so what you so worried about? I would be more concerned about the upsurge of blatant promiscuity and the pornographic culture.

    Think about this, if homosexuals were able to come out and be open about who they are and what they do I believe it would make society a better place, you would be able to tell the sheep from the goats and work to suit. Men won’t have to get trophy wives and women trophy husbands to protect their public image and then run around with other men or women, I am not saying it would not happen cause most humans are naturally promiscuous but I think however some of the sneaking around would decrease.

    Additionally I am so tired of the human : animal comparison and nature etc. Humans do sooooooo many things animals do not do and the human ability to reason is what sets us apart. Most animals do not love, lust, feel the need to take care of their children after they are grown, feel the need to have life long bonds, have sex just for the fun of it, eat more than the daily necessity, wear coverings (clothes) to hide their organs, groom themselves in the form by applying ‘unnatural’ products etc, exercise to improve outward appearance and that is just a few things. So according to previous analogies since these things do not occur in the animal kingdom they are unnatural and should be done away with.


  3. If we were to judge from the comments on this blog there are some interesting times ahead when this matter is finally places squarely in the public domain. No wonder Mia had to back-off and former Prime Minister Arthur had to rescue her.
    We have been reading a fair share on the issue of homosexuality and we stand by our position that different cultures apply a different moral code. We accept that some people are born with screwed up hormones and we should recognize these citizens for the biological quirk and treat to it within our health and social services. What the earlier discussion/comments did not fully explore is how we can prevent our young boys from being led down the path to homosexuality. It is well documented that many boys in the adolescent stage go true identity crises which can be the onset of a ‘prehomosexuality’ stage. It is at this stage that our young boys with professional counselling can be saved. These are normal boys who because of several factors become lost in an identity crisis. They are ridiculed at school and in other social circles they operate for being different and retreat into themselves. It is for this reason that we have refused to accept that homosexuality is a normal condition. Unfortunately because of the strong homosexual agenda which has gained enormous momentum because of political pressures (homosexuals now occupy key positions in developed societies) many of our boys in the ‘prehomosexual’ stage are being sucked in to this lifestyle behaviour.
    Are there not several documented cases of homosexuals who have converted to the straight life?
    For those parents in the BU family, here are some of the early traits you can look for which may clue you to the fact that ‘prehomosexual’ stage is being experienced, usually between the ages of 2-4 years old – (Preventing Homosexuality: A Parent’s Guide, Dr. Joseph Nicolosi).

    repeatedly stated desire to be, or insistence that he or she is, the other sex

    in boys, preference for cross cross-selling, or simulating female attire. In girls, insistence on wearing only stereotypical masculine clothing

    strong and persistence preference fantasies of being the other sex

    intense desire to participate in stereotypical games and pastimes of the other sex.

    strong preference for playmates of the other sex.
     
    Given the above it makes sense that the homosexual lobby has targeted the age of consent to leverage their position. The age of consent in Canada is 14, 16 in the UK, 15 in Sweden, France, 12 in Spain, Holland, Malta and Portugal. Seems incredulous to the BU household that children at such a tender age should have that kind of control over their bodies.


  4. You can start my not labelling homosexual behaviour as abnormal. If young boys knew this might really be “just” a phase then it would not be a big issue.

    They would not feel the need to invent a gay identity to explain their behaviour, it would just be something that happened, and they might go on to have heterosexual relationships when they are older.

    But you idea of what homosexuality is is rather warped David… there are lots of men who act like straight men and have sex with other men that act like straight men.. this who feminization trip you are on only reflects a small portion of the male homosexual population.

    I notice also that you only seem to be worried about the young boys. Given what Devil’s advocate said about male views of patriarchy and homosexuality I don’t think that it is a coincidence.


  5. Just a little addition here. Female humans require that male humans reach a standard (specific to each female) before there is any consideration of a sexual encounter. Height, level of education, bank/asset balance, colour, attractive face, package size, family name etc.

    Few males have that luxury. I put it to you that fewer than 30% of the Barbadian male population are qualified to readily get sex from the opposite gender without having to pay for professional services. Those who do a lot of dating pay a hell of a lot more and end up amateur services, but pay you must.

    So unless you have information to prove otherwise, either you allow the males to seek their own comfort or allow the professionals to work as they have been doing since time immemorial. Incidentally those of you who qualify to easily get women will some day get old and I understand that unlike women, men’s desires never wane.


  6. @Cynic

    You obviously did not read our comment correctly. We mentioned identity crisis and if not managed properly leads to prehomosexual behaviour. We gave a comment from a male perspective and we can do the same from a female but whats the point?

    By the way has the elusive ‘gay gene’ been discovered yet?


  7. David BU,

    You obviously had your minds made up from the get go! You were never interested in healthy discussion in order to “understand” the homosexual life. There is no middle ground with you and i for one feel decieved.

    If you and others continue to rant and rave about homosexuals and thier potential to destroy your “pure” and “normal” heterosexual population, then i think you should also have a solution to your problem.
    “WHAT THEN WOULD YOU WISH TO SEE DONE ABOUT IT?
    Just spit it out and be done with it!


  8. David,

    While I agree with your points for the most part, there are a lot of genes that have not been identified as yet so that does not mean it does not exist. I believe that in some cases homosexuality can be prevented but not in all. It is one of those environment plus predisposition things it seems.


  9. MME

    “ahhh… I understand now Rok… you are one of the physikoi :-)”

    I really don’t understand that label. You see, you think you are better than the animals. I believe that is a western view. You think animals don’t long for partners? that they don’t have any sense? that they are guided by what, the nose?

    The animals are part of the ecology of this earth and what they do keep it going. When a Lion hunts a deer, you think it is without skill? In a lot of cases what the animals have, we don’t have; including wisdom and atheletic ability.

    Actually, with all our brains and intellect, we impact the earth more severely than our lesser intelligent wards. Talk about social behaviour, tell me about the cats??

    We are no more than animals with larger brains. Yet we use less of it than animals. We do so much things subconsicously, emotionally, compulsively, characteristically, that we struggle to keep them in check. We are probably the most promiscuous, the most barbaric; all the brains!

    Every living thing has a role. The only thing we could do is study the animals and live like them. They have a lot of wholistic talents and practices and if we are damned enough to interrupt that, the experience is, “woe betide”.

    We like to see ourselves as above everything because of this intelligence, but this intelligence is leading us to destruction; so I ask the question, how valuable is this intelligence? What would you prefer to be, a rich man or a wise man?


  10. ROK, says, “What man does is as much a part of ‘nature’ and ‘natural law’ as any other living thing. It may not be an accident that homosexuality is on the rise. Are you willing to consider this?”

    First, any serious research over ancient civilizations, reveal that there is an ‘inherent’ ‘Natural’ law within mankind, that directs him for the most part, towards what is the right and moral thing to do, especially with regard to his sexuality, in order to preserve his species.

    As Professor Craig A. Boyd so aptly says, in his well research book, ‘A Narrative Defense of Natural Law Ethics/ A Shared Morality’ ” Natural law morality boast one of the longest genealogies in the history of ethics. From the ancient Greeks down through the Middle Ages to today, professional philosophers, Christian theologians, and many lay people subscribe to some version of natural law morality which maintains that there are some basic truths about human nature which require the prohibitions of some values and the pratice of others. Natural law theorists believe that they can discern in human nature – and its various inclinations and desires – a basic orientation to the good that all people pursue. These inclinations, when rightly understood and ordered, direct us to some activities and away from others. There is, on the natural law perspective, a basic desire to seak peaceful coexistence with others since peaceful communal life is a necessary condition for pursuing other goods. Prohibition on murder, lying, and adultry are all seen as violations of the ideal for “human nature” since they thwart the peaceful coexistence of humans in community. Moreover; natural law theorists also contend that all human societies know these precepts to be true regardless of particular cultural contexts since they all require peace as a basic good for communal life. These specific principles which ground various prescriptions and prohibitions can be discovered by all people without regard to cultural or religious diversity.”

    The point is, as Boyd states, this ‘Natural Law Morality’ historically, has always been the basis for any ordered society, regardless of the cultural or religious diversity.

    Our Creator, the one true and living God, has placed within mankinds ‘nature’ no matter how ‘fallen’ it is because of ‘Sin’ some inherent understanding and desires, to do the right thing, in order for any society to function rationally, and coherently, and one of the very basic premises for such order, is the God ordained union of Man and Woman.

    I make absolutely no apologies whatsoever for my personal conviction re the Historic Judeo/Christian World View, for it is the only world view that maintains a ‘Logical Consistency’ ‘Empirical Adequacy’ and ‘Experiential Relevance’ over the entire range of history, in spite of all of it failures, because as Almighty God declares in His Divinely Inspired Word:

    “For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who SUPRESS the TRUTH in unrighteousness, because what may be known of God is manifest in them, for God has shown it to them.”

    ‘For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so they are WITHOUT EXCUSE.”

    ‘Because, although they knew God, and they did NOT glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became FUTILE in their thoughts, and their FOOLISH hearts were DARKENED.”

    “Professing themselves to be wise, they became FOOLS.”

    Listen and read carefully what is next identified, after Idolatry (v.23).

    “Therefore, God also gave them up to uncleanness, in the LUSTS of their hearts, to DISHONOR their BODIES among themselves, who exchanged the TRUTH of God for a LIE, and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever. Amen.”

    For this reason, God gave them up to VILE PASSIONS, For (what?) even their WOMEN exchanged the NATURAL use for what is AGAINST NATURE (Lesbianism). Like wise also the MEN, leaving the natural use of the woman, BURNED in their LUST for ONE ANOTHER, MEN with MEN, committing what is SHAMEFUL, and receiving in themselves the panality of their error which was due.”

    “And even as they DID NOT like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave (released) them over to a DEBASED mind, to do those things which are not fitting.” (Homosexuality & Lesbianism) being filled with all unrighteousness, SEXUAL IMMORALITY, wickedness, covetousness, maliciousness, full of envy, murder, strife, deceit, evil-mindedness; they are whisperers, backbiters, haters of God, violent, proud, boasters, inventors of EVIL things, disobedient to parents, undiscerning, untrustworthy, unloving, unforgiving, unmerciful; who knowing the righteous judgment of God, that those who PRACTICE such things are deserving of death, not only do the same BUT ALSO APPROVE of those who practice them.” (Romans. 1:18-32) emphasis added.

    This is NOT some emotional, subjective analysis, this is from the Word of Almighty God, sounds like it was written yesterday, describing mankinds condition and plight, and it is getting worst day by day, throughout the world, it HAS no colour, as SIN permeates all of mankind.

    To RE Engineer, I simply ask you. Would you like to have a man/man, or woman/woman relationship, sanctioned by our Laws, living next door to you, for your children and others, to witness this kind of VILE unnatural behaviour, which is what would be allowed if the present world wide thrust for such sanction is allowed to come into our region.

    Think this through logically, coherently, listen and read God’s Word, and hear His judgment on such matters!


  11. @Jinx and others

    Because BU has a well known position as far as homosexuality is concerned it does not mean we cannot facilitate a discussion. What you should do is to pick at out arguments.

    We have declared our hand and stated that we respect homosexuals but we don’t agree with the lifestyle and feel that as a society we need to discuss and arrive at middle ground.


  12. Yes, and you declare it
    over
    and
    over
    and
    over
    and
    over
    That is why we have discerned that you have a political agenda and have told you that it is not a principled stance that we perceive in you.

    Enough already!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  13. @Carlos

    There are a lot of things that I would not want my children to see, but alas, research has shown that over sheltered children tend to make poor decisions when it comes to the real world. Stopping homosexuals from getting married or denouncing their existence as human beings is not going to stop my children from seeing homosexual activity. My children would be taught to reason for themselves and reach their own conclusions, persons smoke weed on a nightly basis not too too far away from my home, children see that all the time, I too saw it as a child but I realised quickly that it was something I would never do and I have never had the desire to do it. My parents raised me to think for myself and do what was best for myself and it stayed with me throughtout university, field trips, sports trips etc. when I had ample opportunity to do as I pleased. Additionally I do not drink and my parents do, I think it is a repulsive habit, however it is all up to the individual. I truly understand your concerns, but this is 2008 not 1950, the fire and brimstone thing no longer works, the control of religion is losing its grip and rightfully so, judge not lest ye be judged. I have lived with persons of many different religious beliefs and it really opens your eyes to a world outside of the christian community, makes certain things very clear. Laws and religion do not go hand in hand, it is totally unfair and unjust, one cannot force another to have their belief system. And I reiterate, please give me a reason to condemn homosexuals, tell me how they will adversely affect my life and that of my friends and family that is not steeped in religious and moral credences.


  14. David,

    Your position implies that there is something innately wrong with homosexuality. What is wrong with it? other than the personal distaste which it engenders in you?


  15. Many people have known as friends and family, gay persons. I have had the honour to befriend and to work with gay persons who, in my own real Bajan experience, have done more for Barbados than I, or David BU, can ever hope to do. Smoke that buddy.

    There are gay persons in Barbados who have greater intellect, greater wealth, greater sensitivity to the down-trodden, greater contribution as public servants than I will ever have.

    So David BU, just how is your track making Barbados any better, come tell us now? You wrong BU, and you are doing wrong to a grouping of innocent people who also want to make a contribution to the welfare of this country.


  16. Re Engineer

    Carlos has done his best to give the reasons why. Carlos is guilty of one thing, he quotes the the philosophers as thought they are the authority. He also quotes the Bible without understanding that the same Bible is written within context and that there is a universal application.

    It is dangerous to use the Bible to demonstrate anything so here is my analogy. “If you put your finger in acid, it will burn.” However, when I decide to put on a pair of gloves that will protect my hand from the acid, where has that rule gone today? It now has qualifications.

    Of course we know the process. Men set down their ideas as theories until they are proven different. They are but ideas and you can’t come and quote them as a given fact. men’s behaviour change, societies adapt, science has made a lot of these so-called natural laws less deceptive and so to speak, found ways to put their hands in the acid safely. Of course it does not take away from the original observation but it brings a different perspective. So when a man put on gloves, what, he cheating the rule?

    I always say that if it was at all possible to plant a sixth form student of today, into Biblical times, he would become a God. He would heal the sick, become a great inventor, and like Christ, bewilder the authorities and even claim a kingdom of his own. He could claim not be of that world too.

    We have to learn to think for ourselves. We cannot let white influenced philosophical bases keep us in the dark ages while they eat of the fat of this world. What do you say to the fact that MUCH of your quotes were said at a time when men did not wash too often? There was no piped water


  17. Carlos
    “There is, on the natural law perspective, a basic desire to seek peaceful coexistence with others since peaceful communal life is a necessary condition for pursuing other goods.

    Our Creator, the one true and living God, has placed within mankinds’ ‘nature’ … some inherent understanding and desires, to do the right thing, in order for any society to function rationally, and coherently, …

    “For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, ….”

    As someone who has Comanche, Sioux, Cree, Chickasaw, Carib, Inuit and Aboriginal ancestry who tried this coexist thing with Judeo Christians I say

    “What Almighty Rubbish”


  18. Man, the shaking of tamborines and thumping of Bibles not done in hey yet?


  19. Carlos

    You serious:
    “It is sad that some people don’t even understand the difference between what is an ’subjective’ view, from ‘objective’ truth.”

    What is the objective truth? Please talk about an objective view. Objective don’t have no monopoly on truth.


  20. David, thanks for trying to bring some rationale to this most serious issue.

    Re Engineer, I’m extremely disappointed (but not surprised) that a man of your educational brackground has obviously failed to, NO, not failed, ‘chosen’ not to reason through what this issue is all about, but then again, the very ‘Authority’ God’s Word, clearly describes those of your ilk, yes, from a secular perspective, very well qualified, but regarding matters of a ‘spiritual’ nature, scoffers at such ‘Truth’ and why is this so, lets hear from God’s Word why people like yourself, and this is not intended in away way as an attack on you personally, not at all, just a emphatic comparasion from Almighty God’s Word, contrasting the ‘natural’ man with the ‘spiritual’ man.

    The ‘natural’ man cannot grasp, nor understand the deeper things of Scripture. “But the natural man (psuchikos de anthropos, the unspiritual man) does not receive ( does not accept, rejects, refuses to accept) the things of the Spirit of God. (Why not?) for they are foolishness to him, nor can he know (understand) them, (Why not?) because they are spiritually discerned. ( 1 Cor. 2:14).

    It is only too obvious, today one notes certain on the intelligentsia who sneer at Christ and Christianity in their own blinded ignorance, he cannot know them then ( ou dunatai gnonai) he is not able to get knowledge. His helpless condition calls for pity in place of impatience on our part, though such a one usually poses as a paragon of wisdom and commiserates the deluded followers of Christ; men of intellectual gifts who are ignorant of the things of Christ talk learnedly and patronisingly about things of which they are grossly ignorant.

    It is the ‘unspiritual’ man like BAF and others, who are constantly twisting, misrepresenting and malignning the text of God’s Word, making the Lord Jesus Christ sound like some passive humanist. Quite the opoosite comes from The Saviour and Lord, where there are numerous references to the enmity, hostility, and opposition which the world displays towards Christ, the believer, and His Church, Jesus said;

    “The world…hates me because I testify of it that its works are evil” (John. 7:7).

    He also made it clear that the world hates His disciples, because they are NOT of it (John. 15: 18-19). The same theme is repeated in Jesus’ high-priestly prayer (John. 17:14). The reason for the diffferent understandings, perceptions, is that different ‘spirits’ are involved. To those who have accepted and received Christ as personal Saviour and Lord, we are told:

    ” Now we have not received the spirit of the world (evil system) but the Spirit of which is from God, that we might know and understand the gifts bestowed on us by God” (1 Cor. 2:12).

    The clear unmistakable message from God’s Word, is that the things of Christ involves a mindset or frame of reference completely different from the world’ s way of viewing things, and it has nothing to do with secular education, yes, this is important, but not when it comes to ‘discering’ understanding and comprehending things of a ‘spiritual’ nature. They are simply foriegn to such a ‘natural’ person, and therefore he cannot (or has chosen) not to accept them.

    There are many well documented cases and stories of men and women, who were enslaved to the life styles of Homosexuality and Lesbianism, who were forgiven, healed, delivered and set free from this terrible vice, by none other than The Lord Jesus Christ, for He loves all of us, He died in our ‘place’ so that we all could be reconciled to our heavenly Father, adulterers, fornicators, drug addicts, you name it, none are excempt from His mercy, Grace and love, if we are but willing to come to Him, Jesus, for He will forgive us, and give us eternal life. John 3:16, is God’s universal invitation to ‘ALL’ people, not religion, but a personal relationship with Jesus Christ.

    The world is in crisis, mankind is in utter chaos, and Jesus Christ is the Only answer, the choice is ours, to either receive Him, or reject Him.


  21. I just was reading the online edition of People magazine where the lead article is about an Ameicna singer, and a born again Christian at that, who has just told his fans that he is an avowed homosexual. This particular sing also just fathered a child with a 50 year old woman through the artificial process. To me this is a very sad story, for here you have a 50 year old woman who allowed herself to carry a child for a gay man half of her age. The mother of this child could die before the child reaches adulthood, and then the child would have to live with this homosexual whose genes fathered him through artificial insemination. This is a sad story. You gays want to do your sinful behaviour and then turn around and say you have children. So sad. Think of the shame you bring to a child when the rest of the world finds out that the child’s father is a homosexual. I would invite you all to the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God in beautiful Georgetown, Guyana, for you all to have the annointing, but I am afraid you might fall for the pastor. But I would like to say if you ever get the chance you should attend a crusade by Prophetess Juanita Bynum, for you will be healed and blessed and get the annointing that you your selves would chuck up the sinful lifestyle and give your heart to Jesus. Jesus second coming is soon, you see what is happening to the US.


  22. You people that go around preaching your doom and gloom only bring great disrepute to the Christian religion. Remember Dr Moon?

    You walk around mis-interpreting the Bible and always end up by saying how much the world is in crisis and how soon it is going to end. You have been doing that for centuries without any proof. Get interested in this one, “The Kingdom of God is at Hand”. That is your ending of the world.

    You talk about respecting others but that is lip service. There is a total disrespect and even scorn in your tone.

    Let’s put it this way. Christ said that the way to the father is through him, yet he also said, he who is not against me is for me.

    I have recently seen a doctoring of new translations of the Bible. It is not the first time it would have been tampered with… but Christianity is far too intolerant of its brothers and sisters of other faiths. There is no respect. That is not what Christ taught and contrary to Carlos’ belief, there is no deep meaning of the Bible, that is what you say when you come to what you can’t explain and try to throw the book into some fairy tale spin.

    The only deep meaning to the Bible is understanding use of language and this becomes further problematic with translation because the English language is too stiff when it comes to concepts. Further, the time span between the writing of the scriptures and its translation makes accuracy very questionable; especially the condition in which a lot of it was found. Disintegrated, whole chapters lost but still appearing in the Bible.

    So even in translation there are serious literary complexities. Given all these mistakes and complexities, where do you really stand. How do you know that the part you relying on is not doctored? How accurate are you? So who you fooling? There is much of the Bible that you just have to toss through the window, because you will never know the real truth.


  23. Dr Love; sorry


  24. Sad that BU’s David does not see that these raticles and the way they are presented serve only to promote HIS anti-gay agenda as opposed to allowing honest discussion. The fact that after all these posts he can still right such drivel and prehomosexual tendancies. I maintain that he does not KNOW any homosexuals. if He did he would not right so much nonsense. The internet is wonderful in that it allows everyone to researchj anything and it is very possible to read about sidesof this issue. But if you insist on a position while disregarding all other evidence and opinion why even have the discussion.

    Facts: The Ex-homosexual movement HAS NOT been successful in that most exhomosexuals revert! I dont think going from being a homsexual to being a married man with children who sleeps on the side with men is success is it???

    Facts: many homsexuals have felt this way since birth

    Facts: Many str8 men go through bisexual phases ( such as when in jail)BUT these are Str8 men who revert back to hetersexuality eventually

    Facts: All gay men are NOT effeminate and never were!

    Facts : All lesbian omen are NOT masculine!

    It is disengenuous to use the age of consent as a gay agenda issue when it is clear that heterosexuals are the main proponents of these laws. How underhnad can you get!

    You continue to demonize a group of people to make your position because in truth you have no sound basis to deny them their rights other than pure hatred.

    See how simple that was!!!


  25. sorry about the typos…


  26. David, from reading you posts you seem to think that a few men having sex with men is going to destroy the human race.

    Lets examine if that is a rational premise.

    Homosexuality is seen in nature, and exists as a phenomenon of a stable minority of the population. There is no reason to suppose this might be different in humans.

    Secondly the greatest threat to humanity isn’t from under breeding, but from over breeding. It stands to reason that a slightly higher percentage of non-breeding adults might be a good thing for the long term survival of the human species.

  27. Sir Bentwood Dick Avatar

    David you said ‘The age of consent in Canada is 14, 16 in the UK, 15 in Sweden, France, 12 in Spain, Holland, Malta and Portugal. Seems incredulous to the BU household that children at such a tender age should have that kind of control over their bodies.’

    Please clarify, is that consent child to child only?

    Now, there is simething I can agree with you on.

    Those ages are way too low, ridiculous.

    Sure, in the middle ages it was acceptable but now?

    The issues of responsibility, choice and consent are what need to be focused on.

  28. Micro Mock Engineer Avatar
    Micro Mock Engineer

    I sense that the emotionally charged responses on both sides of this debate are beginning to wane… seems like a good time to jump back in 🙂

    … RE Engineer, I really like the rational analytical approach you bring to BU… your question on how the private sex lives and lifestyle-choices of consenting adults could adversely affect you, seems a reasonable one.

    To the extent that the behaviour or personal choices that others make may impose societal costs, we can, as individuals, be adversely affected… even when there is no form of communication or physical contact between us and those who make these choices. This is ALWAYS true in the presence of economic commons, and therefore of particular concern in social democracies such as ours.

    Now I realise that to invoke this argument, one would have to demonstrate that a particular behavior or activity presents a tragedy of the commons (or shared health care, and civil society costs). In this instance, one need only do a little “Google Scholar” research… you will be surprised at the voluminous body of scientific literature that speaks to the harmful physiological, psychological and sociological impacts of homosexuality. I would list a few publications here, but that would add to an already long post… and individuals can easily check for themselves. If you need ideas on keywords to use in your search try combinations of ‘homosexuality’ with: ‘suicide rate’ (20,300 search results), ‘anal cancer’ (7,840 results), ‘breast cancer’ (10,800 results), ‘drug and alcohol abuse’ (28,000 publications), ‘childhood abuse’ (21,800 results), ‘psychiatric care’ (20,300 results), ‘medical care’ (32,000 results), ‘lifespan’ (5,170 results) etc. I implore those of you who are genuinely interested in this subject to review the scientific literature accessible from Google Scholar… carry out those keyword searches I have suggested, randomly pick some of the results, and read the paper abstracts… the scientific literature is replete with evidence of the deleterious impact of this lifestyle on a disproportionate number of individuals who practice it, and society as a whole, insofar as society is forced to bear some of the associated costs.

    There is, in my opinion, also a strong moral/philisophical case to be made relating to the issue of sexual complimentarity between genders, its benefits to society and the undermining influence of same-sex relationships… but I’ll pause here.

    Except in those instances where it may bring about direct harm to others, I do not generally support or encourage that legislation be used as the primary means of discouraging behaviors that impose high societal costs , whether it is homosexuality, smoking or drinking alcohol (… especially drinking alcohol LOL… hiccup)… but clearly a ‘live and let live’ approach is not an appropriate strategy either. We must encourage and promote those behaviours which bring greatest benefit to society as a whole, and do so in a manner that shows compassion for those whose ‘non-beneficial’ behavior may oft times be (or have been) influenced by factors outside of their control.


  29. Micro Mock Engineer ,

    Suely you would recognize that alot of those health risk, especially the psychological ones are a direct result of socities hostility towards gay people. If gay people were accepted and respected members of society then they would not have the same degree of psychologial problems.

    An similar situtation can be seen in England, where black caribbean men are reported to have higher levels of psychological disorders. Is that because black men are more prone to them? of course not. It is because black men face great sociatal stress.

    A disctinion needs to be made between the cultutal aspects of a gay life style, promoiscuity and drug use are two prevelant behaviours in the uk, and inherant behaviours.

    I agree that there are cultural to the gay sub group that need to be changed (as there are for any sub group), but that is not the issue, the issue is the morality of homosexual relaionships, which are inherantly no more harmful thanheterosexual ones.


  30. Micro Mock Engineer

    I thank you for finally bringing a rational argument to the table, I was just telling myself I have had enough of this particular blog since persons can’t seem to see past their personal beliefs, feelings and opinions.

    I do agree with you in terms of the ‘harmful physiological, psychological and sociological impacts of homosexuality’ though I must agree with Cynic in the respect that the psychological and sociological impacts are mainly societally inflicted the same can be said for obesity and other conditions and behaviours that are deemed anormal by society.

    “There is, in my opinion, also a strong moral/philisophical case to be made relating to the issue of sexual complimentarity between genders, its benefits to society and the undermining influence of same-sex relationships… but I’ll pause here”

    I agree with you there, although it is highly entrenched in ones belief system and yes I know it is your opinion. I would also like to add that looking on the scientific side maybe homosexuality is a way to keep the population in check, just maybe because it is going crazy right now.

    “We must encourage and promote those behaviours which bring greatest benefit to society as a whole, and do so in a manner that shows compassion for those whose ‘non-beneficial’ behavior may oft times be (or have been) influenced by factors outside of their control.”

    I am in total agreement. I have no more to say on the matter.


  31. Cervical cancer, pretty much 100% the result of heterosexual activity without condoms, is the highest incidence of cancer here.
    In fact it has quite a high mortality and public health cost; and is spread through sexual activity.

    Let’s get real.


  32. AIDS is pretty much 50% female vs male in Barbados, and is largely the result of sex without condoms.

    Lets get real


  33. @RE Engineer and Micro Mock Engineer

    It is understandable that your training would want to package all issues devoid of emotion. Unfortuanately human beings are not always so inclined.

    @me

    Do a google for “Michael Swift, Age of Consent homosexual” he use to work for the popular Gay Community News. He addresses the age of consent agenda, it was not made up by BU.

    Final note, in the USA which is used as the bastion for equality for homosexuals, 14 states are getting ready to fight same sex mariages. Also recent polls show that 56% of Americans are against the same sex issue. Now compare that culture to what we have in the Caribbean: where do you think that percentage is going to register?

    We are going to have a problem when this matter comes up whether we want to admit it or not, its a culture/moral conflict at work.


  34. would also like to add that looking on the scientific side maybe homosexuality is a way to keep the population in check, just maybe because it is going crazy right now.
    ————————————————–
    And to those who object to homosexuals having children is not a child better off in a home with parents who love him/her whatever their gender than with no resident father and a bunch of half siblings- which so many children have to cope with as well as being fobbed off with grandma if the parents new partner objects to his presence?


  35. Thanks ‘Micro Mock Engineer’ for directing those die-hard intellectually dishonest, bible- bashing unbelievers to the hard scientific facts, re some of the kinds of extremely deadly effects such a lifestyle has on those that pursue such practices, not to mention the cost to society.

    When these scientific facts are woven together with Almighty God’s pronouncements on such abominable life styles, then we can see why ‘His’ Word states:

    “Who knowing the righteous judgment of God, that those who practice such things are deserving of death,” (Rom. 1:32a) (physical death, and ultimate eternal death, separation from God)

    To ‘ROK’ Yes, your very statement, “…the same Bible is written within context and THAT THERE IS A UNIVERSAL APPLICATION.” Is a sound and factual refutation to your very contention against its absolute binding authority on all men, every where.

    You see, ROK, when you ask; “What is objective truth? Please talk about an objective view, objective don’t have no monoply on truth.” Really!!

    Well, God’s Word is absolute, exclusive, objective ‘TRUTH’ and it does not need anyones approval, to be so, just try disobeying its teaching, imperatives, as mankind has so resolutely done throughout history, which is replete with the sordid and utter chaos that has resulted from such rebellion.

    Secondly, God has allowed modern scientific research to ‘confirm’ that this is in fact so, that ROK, is ‘objective’ truth, can you be ‘objective’ enough to realise this fact?

    Facts are stubborn things, and only the stubborn refuse to accept them.

    So be it, for those whose feet, are firmly planted in mid-air!


  36. “We must encourage and promote those behaviours which bring greatest benefit to society as a whole, and do so in a manner that shows compassion for those whose ‘non-beneficial’ behavior may oft times be (or have been) influenced by factors outside of their control.”
    ——————————————–
    The best way to do this is by emphasis on family values not slamming homosexuality.
    Children are most harmed by dysfunctional families abandonment and lack of love than by homosexuality.
    Men would do well not have control and to not father children that they have no intention of helping to bring up.
    Women dont bring children into the world to keep a man – it won’t.


  37. TIme for new topic


  38. Carlos,

    You are clutching at straws. I refer you to the contributions made by MME, Re Engineer, Cynic and Art above.

    You would like us to believe that when you go against God’s will, you are damned. I would like you to know that before you can even reach there you have to find out the truth first. It is nearly impossible to do so comprehensively. You always have to take a position when you come to crossroads andhow do you know which of the raods is correct?

    Take a sample here of some small hurdles. This is only the tip of the iceberg. You want research, I am going to bring you the research. Little by little and hope that your sanity is still intact when I am finished.
    ****************************

    Choosing a Bible Translation
    by J. Kristen Edscorn

    Fifty years ago the King James, or Authorized, Version of the Bible was considered by many to be the only reliable translation and choosing a Bible involved selecting the binding and color. Today, dozens of English translations are available. So, how does one decide which is best?

    First, we need to recognize that there is no one translation that is the best. Even the writers of the New Testament books quote from several Greek translations of the Old Testament. Today we have no perfect translation, but there are a number which are very good. The real question is: Which is best for our particular needs?

    About the King James
    So what is wrong with the good old King James Version? It probably is the most beautiful, elegant, literary English translation that will ever be produced. In fact, it contributed a great deal to the formation of the English language. Modern translations usually lack the poetry of the King James because modern biblical scholars are more scientists than artists.

    Nevertheless, there are two major problems with the King James Version. First of all, when it was translated in 1611, there were relatively few Hebrew and Greek manuscripts available and they tended to be recent and less accurate. In the nearly 400 years since then literally thousands more manuscripts have been discovered, ranging from small portions to complete copies of the Old or New Testaments. Many of these are very early and more accurate.

    Secondly, the English in the King James Version is not at all the same language spoken today. Both the vocabulary and grammar have changed considerably. As a result, a reader often must retranslate the King James into modern English in his or her mind. For many people, especially children, reading the King James Version is like reading a foreign language.

    So Which is for Me?
    Which brings us to the numerous modern translations. Most of these have been produced by fine scholars using the many thousands of manuscripts available today. Different translations are better for various purposes.

    If you are interested in serious study of the Bible, including grammar and vocabulary, you will want a more literal translation, such as the English Standard Version, New King James, or New American Standard. However, it is always good to compare several translations, especially for passages that are difficult to understand. If you are interested in reading the Bible in large blocks, you probably will prefer one of the freer translations (not necessarily less accurate), such as the New International, New Living Translation, or Contemporary English Version.


  39. Sorry Carlos. Read the entire page here:
    http://www.firstpresb.org/translations.htm


  40. Lets talk about tampering and tinkering.
    *******************************

    Version Information
    The New International Version (NIV) is a translation made by more than one hundred scholars working from the best available Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek texts. It was conceived in 1965 when, after several years of study by committees from the Christian Reformed Church and the National Association of Evangelicals, a trans-denominational and international group of scholars met at Palos Heights, Illinois, and agreed on the need for a new translation in contemporary English. Their conclusion was endorsed by a large number of church leaders who met in Chicago in 1966. Responsibility for the version was delegated to a self-governing body of fifteen Biblical scholars, the Committee on Bible Translation, and in 1967, the New York Bible Society (now International Bible Society) generously undertook the financial sponsorship of the project.

    http://www.biblegateway.com/versions/?action=getVersionInfo&vid=31


  41. You want the facts. Here are some more.
    **************************************

    One basic problem inherent in Bible translation is that we do not have the original manuscript of the Bible, but copies of copies of copies… and this causes many problems because translators do not know which of all these copies is correct and which is not, since none of them are identical. The differences are not very significant in the Old Testament, but they are in the New Testament. According to research, “about 3 per cent of the Bible’s texts varies across all the manuscripts. Nowadays, we have about 1,500 complete or partial manuscripts of the New Testament.” (http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/robert_beecham/whichbib.htm). There are two main approaches to solving this problem. The more common one is called the ecletic approach. Scholars put together a text from all the available manuscripts using various rules to sort out differences. For example: what do the oldest manuscripts say? What do the majority say? What do the best say? Which reading is more likely? But this approach is not accepted by many people, for it gives too much scope to human judgment. Another approach that has been used in the past is that of Ivan Panin. In 1890 Ivan Panin, after his conversion from atheism, discovered that the entire Bible was full of hidden numerical patterns largely based on the number seven. This discovery had two major implications. First, it gave striking proof of the inspiration of the Scripture. Every sentence, every word and even every letter had the divine seal upon it. The patterns could never have been placed there by human wit. Second, it gave him a method of deciding in every instance which was the correct text; and this numerical theory even enabled Panin to resolve ambiguities of punctuation (ibid). However, Ivan Panin’s work has been almost entirely ignored by academics.

    As most people know, the Bible in its original untranslated form is a collection of ancient writings; the New Testament in Greek (though parts may have been previously written in Hebrew or Aramaic and then translated into Greek), the Old Testament in Hebrew and Aramaic, some passages of the Old Testament, mostly in Daniel, spanning many cultures and more than a thousand years. The 66 books into which the Bible is divided represent “a greater variety of literary styles e.g. historical narrative, prophecy, poetry, instructions and exhortation etc. than any other piece of literature in the history of mankind” (Snell-Hornby et al., 1998; 275). This variety of text types makes Bible translation a hard task for the translator, especially when translating into languages which do not have a long literary tradition.

    Another problem that many translators face in Bible translation is that the Bible is addressed to a huge variety of people, e.g. theologians, adults, children, believers and non-believers, etc. And as Snell-Hornby states, the Bible is written for different uses, i.e., for both readers and listeners (ibid, 275). Thus, we could say that it is very difficult for a translator to translate the Bible since s/he must ‘reproduce’ an equivalent text in the Target Language, which can be ‘used’ for the same purposes as that of the Source Language.
    http://accurapid.com/journal/18bible.htm


  42. Same reference as last but very interesting example:
    **************************************

    Many words found in the Bible have lost or changed their meanings, and some of them no longer have modern-day counterparts. The Greek of the first century uses verb tenses and prepositions, that have no real English equivalent. Biblical Hebrew often uses word repetitions and a poetic structure, which are difficult to convey in another language.

    For example, Genesis 32:20-21 is translated in most English versions like this:

    “…For he said ‘I will appease him with the present that it goes before me. Then afterward I will see his face; perhaps he will accept me.’ So the present passed on before him, while he himself spent that night in the camp.”

    But the Hebrew original reads something like this:

    “…For he thought ‘I will pacify his face with the gift going ahead of my face; and after that I will see his face; perhaps he will lift up (or ‘receive’) my face.’ The gift crossed over ahead of his face, but he spent that night in the camp.”

    Peneh, the Hebrew word usually translated ‘face,’ occurs five times in the original of this passage, not just once as implied by the English translation. That this deliberate repetition of peneh is not a mirror detail, but a key word in this passage, can be seen a few verses later in Genesis 32:30, which reads:

    “So Jacob named the place Peniel (from peneh = face and el = God), for he said, ‘I have seen God face to face, yet my life has been preserved.’”

    Few English translations convey this, however.

    Another example is Genesis 2:25-3:1. English versions read something like this:

    “And the man and wife were both naked and were not ashamed. Now the serpent was more crafty (or ‘subtle’) than any beast of the field which the LORD God had made…”

    What is not apparent in this English version is that the Hebrew words translated ‘naked’ (arom) and ‘crafty’ (arum) are identical in spelling and pronunciation in this passage, and they serve to connect the two verses. The best attempt I have seen to convey this aspect in an English translation was to make the words rhyme:

    “And the man and his wife were nude… Now the serpent was more shrewd…”

    As these two examples show, the translator often has to choose between translating the original text word for word at a risk of being unclear (as with the phrase ‘he will lift up my face’), and translating the meaning of the passage at the expense of losing the richness and poetry (and hence even some of the meaning) of the original.


  43. Hold on BAFBFP, This topic now start


  44. The controversy
    *************************************
    Translators of the full-Bible edition of Today’s New International Version (TNIV), released Feb. 4 by Zondervan, have tampered in similar fashion with something infinitely more sacred, evangelical Bible scholar/theologian Wayne Grudem says.

    By employing gender-neutral language, translators have edited the Scriptures in a manner that is both inaccurate and unnecessary, says Grudem, research professor of Bible and theology at Phoenix Seminary in Scottsdale, Ariz., and co-author of “The TNIV and the Gender-Neutral Bible Controversy” (Broadman & Holman, 2004).

    “They are changing a historical document [the Bible],” Grudem said. “It is like someone writing about Bob Dylan’s song from the 1960s, ‘How many roads must a man walk down, before you call him a man?’ and deciding that people today wouldn’t understand that Bob Dylan was using an example of a specific man to teach a general truth, and therefore telling modern 18-34 year olds that Bob Dylan wrote these words in a song: ‘How many roads must a human being walk down, before you call them a person?’

    http://www.bpnews.net/bpnews.asp?ID=20139


  45. This is the real problem with the translations:
    **************************************

    Bible language researcher Michael Marlowe is critical of the translation techniques used in the GWT, and feels it takes too much liberty in simplifying the original Greek and Hebrew texts. In so doing, argues Marlowe, the translators have deviated from the original emphasis of scripture.[9] They argue there is a place for translations that can simplify these terms, but GWT is one of a growing number of new translations of the Bible that uses a paraphrasing method which goes beyond the aim of a pure (literal) translation, which may result in difficult, misunderstood terms and produces a translation that also interprets the scripture.

    Marlowe more generally questions translation methods such as Closest Natural Equivalence when he writes:

    “[The methodology’s] pretensions to ‘scientific’ principles of linguistics are dubious, as has been pointed out by numerous linguists and biblical scholars. It results in a simplification of the text in which important features of the Bible are erased”[10].

    Wikepedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God's_Word_(bible_translation)


  46. Amazing quote:

    “We have not tried to reproduce the complex structure of the special songs such as in Exodus 15 and Deuteronomy 32, as we do not think that that would make sense in English.”


  47. Hope that point is made. Let us now look at the condition of the original sources.

    I hope that you note that the Bible contents are a collection of writings spanning thousands of years and who is to say which pieces were “inspired by God”.


  48. Interesting quote. Had to get this in. Not diverting but coming back to sources. Here is a Biblical quote which is baffling.
    *************************************

    “Then they said, “Come, let us build ourselves a city, and a tower with its top in the heavens, and let us make a name for ourselves, lest we be scattered abroad upon the face of the whole earth.” 5 And the LORD came down to see the city and the tower, which the sons of men had built. 6 And the LORD said, “Behold, they are one people, and they have all one language; and this is only the beginning of what they will do; and nothing that they propose to do will now be impossible for them. 7 Come, let us go down, and there confuse their language, that they may not understand one another’s speech”
    *************************************

    1. Why would the Lord have to come down to see man’s tower? Omniscient?

    2. Who is this “us” he is referring to? Is this a power sharing something that the Lord had to get consensus from his peers?

    3. Is it strange that the Lord would sow seeds of wickedness among man. Cause them not to understand one another; for building a tower? How much higher are our skyscrapers?


  49. I also refer you to this blog for some blaring abnormalities:
    http://destee.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-33948.html


  50. Sources of the Bible: the Dead Sea Scrolls. At the link below is a photograph specimen of the condition of the scrolls. These were not the first scrolls to be found either but these contain over 1000 documents, most all fragmented:

    “One of the most important apocryphic works of the Second Temple Period is Enoch. According to the biblical narrative (Genesis 5:21-24), Enoch lived only 365 years (far less than the other patriarchs in the period before the Flood). Enoch “walked with God; then he was no more for God took him.”
    The original language of most of this work was, in all likelihood, Aramaic (an early Semitic language). Although the original version was lost in antiquity, portions of a Greek translation were discovered in Egypt and quotations were known from the Church Fathers. The discovery of the texts from Qumran Cave 4 has finally provided parts of the Aramaic original. In the fragment exhibited here, humankind is called on to observe how unchanging nature follows God’s will.

    “The Book of Enoch is a pseudoepigraphal work (a work that claims to be by a biblical character). The Book of Enoch was not included in either the Hebrew or most Christian biblical canons, but could have been considered a sacred text by the sectarians. The original Aramaic version was lost until the Dead Sea fragements were discovered.”

    http://www.ibiblio.org/expo/deadsea.scrolls.exhibit/Library/enoch.html

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending