Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by John A

How many of you remember the old drawing books that had numbers on a page? You would start at number 1 and the go to number 2 and by time you were finished a beautiful picture would appear on the page.

Just a few weeks ago the local hotel building czar proclaimed that the shortage of labour (at his prices) was hampering the building of all these newly promised hotels. Shortly after that the free movement of people was announced from certain territories. Coincidence I am sure, but thus it unfolded none the less. 

Construction workers in safety gear are working on a building site, with wooden frameworks and scaffolding visible.
Source: BT

Now suppose we moved to another dot and considered maybe that they were other reasons that this hotel building boom had not yet started. A few months ago at a lunch I ran into an old family friend whose family has operated a small hotel for years. In the conversation he mentioned that the family was thinking of selling the property, but it was not as profitable as many believe a hotel is. Yes they do ok in winter but then they suck salt in summer, hence ending up with a low average occupancy percentage over the year. He then went on to say that the growth in Airbnb and the competition from private home owners had also cut into his business. Wait hold on, where did I hear that name Airbnb in the news recently could this be the next dot?

It was recently by share coincidence, announced in the news that Government would be clamping down on the local Airbnb operators (hotel competitors) with new laws to “ensure a quality product.” Well from what I have read, a bad Airbnb doesn’t remain in business too long with entities like TripAdvisor out there. These review blogs could mek you or brek you real quick! Ah another dot maybe? So is this about protecting our global image or is there another agenda in play here?

Right to a next dot now, what could a government do to help to ensure a better profitability for any foreign investor coming here to operate a locally built hotel? Let me think pun dat one for a while before commenting. Would a smart builder risk building a hotel with the hope that he could catch a foreign hotel investor under the current climate of alleged high labour cost and stiff competition from airbandb, when coupled to the low annual occupancy rate we currently achieve in the industry? Let me tink pun dat one for a while too. 

So my question as a simple shop keeper in St Farlip is this. Is this going to become a situation where the sharks eat all the sprats leaving only sharks to live? Will local sprats be protected in an environment where sharks roam free and the fisherman simply focus on catching and removing the nuisance sprats? This ecosystem don’t sound safe for a small man like me to swim in. I going have to rethink my idea about fixing up the back room as an airbandb and offering tourists that stay there free drinks pun a weekend as part of my package! DE SHOP INN DINER AND LOUNGE may get put on de back burner now!

In closing when you connect the dots what do you see?

Disclaimer: The above story may be fictional or em might not be, so tek what dey with a pinch of salt or not, its wunna choice! The writer does not practice party loyalty, so if any faithfuls are offended that is wunna problem not mine. Besides em is only a story, or is it?


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

121 responses to “Let’s Connect the Dots: Fact or Fiction”


  1. As usual run to the political


  2. It is PM Mottley who ran the political by broadcasting a 4 minute video on the eve of the important event.


  3. @ David

    Don’t be baited by those here to deflect from the issues. The ISSUES raised by many not only you or I, voice valid concerns over the rush to introduce this free movement, to the point where it illegally started.

    So if it was illegally started do you honestly think that any of the concerns voiced about other operational issues are not valid, when the actual movement begun under failed legal precident? No four minute public statement can’t change dem realities neither.


  4. @J0
    “With the above in mind it is clear to see that VINCI is not interested in leaving their family and 37% better cost of living to live under ur conditions for 35% extra .”

    I hope you get this explanation. Water in a bottle does not flow anywhere. However, if the container is removed, the water will flow in all directions.

    You should not compare the two conditions.


  5. The0

    If y the water is on a hill and u remove the bottle it will flow in one direction 🤣🤣

    No I don’t get it . What two conditions did I compare?


  6. This hot and sweaty implementation of freedom of movement between four countries with anaemic population growth rates is a win win for the ideologues and politicians that want to appear progressive. Let us see what Anthony Wood has to say on the matter.

    Free movement considerations

    by ANTHONY WOOD THE OPERATIONALISATION of the free movement of nationals policy among Barbados, Belize, Dominica, and St Vincent and the Grenadines commenced on October 1. Various statements of rationale have been advanced in justification of the new policy.

    Roosevelt Skerritt, Prime Minister of Dominica, noted that the free movement “allows us (the four countries) to fill gaps in critical areas, while giving our own citizens greater access to opportunities across the region. It is a win-win for all”.

    David Comissiong, Barbados Ambassador to CARICOM, asserted that “full freedom of movement could help to retain talent within the region by creating greater opportunities for young people to live, work and grow across borders”. He suggests the policy could help in reversing the Caribbean’s persistent brain drain, one of the region’s greatest challenges.

    One of the staunchest proponents of the new policy is Prime Minister Mia Amor Mottley, who provided numerous statements of its justification.

    First, “the promise we made to ourselves in the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas was always more than a (six-month) visit. It was about allowing our people to move freely, without hassle, across our family of nations”. Second, the policy “will benefit Barbados economically, socially and professionally”.

    Third, the new arrangement is “love translated into policy and integration where ordinary people live it every day”. Fourth, “the move supports jobs, supports public services and supports our future”.

    Fifth, “all we’re trying to do is to make it possible for ordinary citizens of our countries to move. Those who have money don’t need this, those who have companies don’t need this”.

    Prime Minster Mottley also linked the new policy to the issues of skills and small population size, noting that one of the greatest fears is Barbados running out of skilled labour, and that many Caribbean countries were underpopulated.

    Minister of Home Affairs Wilfred Abrahams suggested that the freedom of movement policy must be viewed in the context of Barbados’ demographic reality: declining population, death rates outstripping birth rates and an ageing population.

    Regional development

    The statements of rationale for the new free movement policy can be summarised as follows: fulfilment of a promise, addressing labour market shortage, response to the regional development challenge occasioned by the brain drain, facilitating the improvement in the lives of “ordinary” citizens, boosting the size of the population and improving the macroeconomic performance of the participating countries.

    A firestorm has followed Prime Minister Mottley’s announcement of the commencement of the new policy on October I. The strident opposition to the policy has focused mainly on the timing, legal and political issues, and its relationship to the new immigration and citizenship bills. Specifically, the opposition forces are contending that a selfish political motivation is driving the new policy rather than the reasons expressed in the various statements of rationale.

    However, there are serious social and economic issues that have not been addressed by the proponents of the new policy and the opposition forces. A careful examination of its impact from a social and economic perspective is paramount, given the social and economic realities in the participating countries.

    The suggested framework will focus on Barbados but is applicable to the other three countries. Key aspects of the country should be considered, including the state of the economy, labour market, housing, education, health service, infrastructure and society. The first consideration is the impact of an influx of mainly ordinary citizens (since, as Prime Minister Mottley noted, those with money and those with companies don’t need the new policy) on the economy with the following structural weaknesses: unbalanced sectoral growth with the economy overreliant on the tourism industry and to a lesser extent construction, low productive base, weak export capacity, high trade deficit, low productivity, low rate of innovation, lower than desirable levels of private sector investment, high taxes, high public debt and sizeable annual debt service, inefficient state-owned enterprises, and the projection for growth to slow to between 1.8 and 2.0 per cent in 2026.

    Labour market

    The second consideration is the impact on the labour market. How will the new policy affect the labour market with an announced low unemployment rate of 6.3 per cent; high level of underemployment, especially among university graduates; high youth unemployment rate in the neighbourhood of 20 per cent; low labour force participation rates, especially among females; and the flight of young, tertiary-level trained, productive workers to extra-regional economies in search of better opportunities?

    Other important questions related to the labour market should be considered. First, has a recent national manpower survey been undertaken to identify the skills gaps in the economy? Second, has the Government, in collaboration with the private sector, developed a mediumterm, private sector-led growth strategy so that the post-secondary education system can be structured to provide the required skills over time? Third, has the administration considered the labour market situation in the other three participating countries in the new arrangement? For example, the unemployment rate in St Vincent and the Grenadines was 18.1 per cent in 2024 and youth unemployment 41.42 per cent. The figures for Dominica in 2024 were 13.04 per cent and 34.7 per cent, respectively. Can the Barbados labour market accommodate the likely influx of workers from Dominica, and St Vincent and the Grenadines (and Belize to a lesser extent), given the state of their labour markets?

    Fourth, the view that the new policy is necessary to deal with labour market shortages and address the development challenge caused by the brain drain should be examined in the context of the provisions in the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas and the bilateral arrangements Barbados has with other non-CARICOM countries.

    The Revised Treaty, signed in 2001, granted rights for skilled nationals (University of the West Indies graduates) to move and work freely across member states. Over the years, the categories of workers entitled to such rights expanded from university graduates to include nurses, teachers, artisans, agricultural workers, domestic workers and security guards. Such a move, along with Barbados’ ability to access other foreign workers through bilateral arrangements, for example, Cuba, China, Ghana, ensures that labour market shortages are dealt with fairly expeditiously within the managed migration system.

    It is, therefore, logical that domestic factors are fuelling the brain drain phenomenon in the region rather than the restricted movement of nationals.

    The third consideration is the impact of the new policy on housing. How will it affect the housing market which is struggling to provide solutions for lower-income earners?

    The fourth is the impact on the education system. Is the public primary and secondary system equipped in its fullest dimensions to accommodate increased numbers of students during the early stages of the educational transformation programme and beyond?

    The fifth consideration is the impact on the public health care system. Is the system equipped to provide emergency health care and primary health care services to locals and people migrating to Barbados, given the current state of the public health system?

    At social level

    The sixth consideration takes cognisance of other realities at the social level. These include worrying levels of violent and other crimes, and concerning levels of dispossession and poverty, as families continue to bear the brunt of high food prices and the high cost of living.

    The important concern is the extent to which the social challenges will impact the incoming CARICOM nationals and vice-versa.

    The final consideration is the impact on the infrastructure. Has the Government undertaken a carrying capacity study to determine, within reasonable limits, the optimum population (inclusive of tourists) the country can sustainably support over time, taking into account the limiting factors like access to food, availability of housing, school places, access to health services, state of technology and other infrastructural provisions such as roads, transportation and water distribution? The ability of the protective forces and the judicial system to maintain internal order is another important factor.

    Without such a study, attempts to increase the population through migration (and tourism simultaneously) could place tremendous strain on the country’s resources and devalue the quality of life of citizens.

    Anthony P. Wood is an economist, and former lecturer in economics, banking and finance at the Cave Hill Campus of the University of the West Indies. He was also Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development in the Owen Arthur administration.

    Source: Nation


  7. Another perspective.

    Free to move, not free of fear

    IN BARBADOS, the announcement of full free movement among Barbados, Belize, Dominica and St Vincent and the Grenadines has triggered a mix of optimism and unease. On one hand, many Barbadians see this as an historic step towards deeper Caribbean integration – part of the longstanding dream of “one Caribbean”. On the other hand, there are public concerns, voiced openly, about potential pressures on jobs, public services, social infrastructure and security.

    These concerns are not entirely surprising given Barbados’ small size, fixed resources and sensitivity around employment and migration historically. In parliamentary or media commentary, ministers dismiss the alarm, saying the country will not face an uncontrollable influx. They note that Barbados has a declining and ageing population and thus the movement of nationals might help offset this trend, bringing needed human capital.

    Given that Barbados has always been protective of its labour market and cautious of migration flows, commentators warn of “back‑door migration” concerns and of popular resentment if locals feel disadvantaged. Thus, while the broad goal of regional mobility is popular among many, the immediate domestic anxieties are very real.

    Turning to the other states, the sentiment is more uniformly hopeful, though tempered with pragmatic realism. These citizens tend to view the policy as offering new horizons. Some expressed the hope that it reduces the necessity of migrating to far-off places (United Kingdom, United States and Canada) and keeps talented people within the region, which has been a long-standing brain-drain concern. The narrative is optimistic, more progressive and less fearful than in Barbados, although there are some caveats, such as security, registration and system checks being implemented.

    It is useful to set this decision in a broader global context. Several regional blocs have instituted free movement (or near free movement) regimes. The European Union (EU) is obviously the exemplar, where citizens of member states may live and work freely across state borders. Implementation spanned decades, with phases of labour mobility, rights of establishment, cross-border social security coordination and sectoral harmonisation.

    They encountered issues such as labour market competition, social service burdens in stronger economies, “welfare tourism” fears, migration surges from poorer to richer states, and political tensions (for example, “Brexit” in the UK). Governments dealt with these by transitional arrangements, labour market tests, registration requirements, social security contributions, coordination of benefits and quotas for some time.

    In the Caribbean, the Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States (OECS) is the regional precedent. Among six independent states, full freedom of movement (for nationals) has long been in operation and provides a testing ground. There have been no limitations placed on access to “contingent rights” relating to health and education, nor have there been reports of adverse impact on any OECS country as a consequence of full free movement.

    Therefore, the lessons from other regions suggest that free movement tends to bring benefits (larger labour pool, more dynamism, addresses demographic decline, more efficient allocation of human resources), but also demands robust supporting systems (immigration, labour market, social services, data collection, security, registration and coordination). When governments fail to prepare, the fears (service overload, wage suppression, local resentment, social tension) can become real. So, the fears have a rational basis but are not automatically validated by empirical experience elsewhere.

    Did the Barbados Government err by not passing appropriate legislation before the start? Possibly not a fundamental error, given that the CARICOM protocol allows groups of willing states to move ahead; but in practical governance terms, Barbados may have been better served by ensuring a full suite of implementing legislation (immigration, social services, labour, registration) was passed before the start date.

    This raises significant risks: ambiguous rights for incoming nationals, uncertainty for employers, possible exploitation by unscrupulous actors, lack of clarity for social services and possible legal challenges. In short, the Government has moved the policy ahead, but whether all the supporting frameworks are fully established is less certain.

    Barbados finds itself in a pivotal role: its success or failure will be watched region-wide. The risk is not so much the policy per se but whether the Government has the legislative, administrative and service infrastructure in place to manage it smoothly. If Barbados demonstrates a well-managed roll-out and positive outcomes, it will strengthen its leadership and the credibility of the free movement agenda, and could benefit handsomely.

    If problems arise, the sceptics gain ammunition and the public trust will be tested, making it harder for other states to join and for the broader vision of a fully mobile Caribbean labour market to advance.

    Professor Troy Lorde is an economist and Dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences at the University of the West Indies, Cave Hill Campus. Email troy.lorde@cavehill.uwi.edu

    Source: Nation


  8. @J0
    I knew you would not get it. If I attempt to explain, then you will not get again.

    I will not cause you any more pain….. I am not in the sins department but If I can still misquote a famous guy “Go and think some more.”


  9. I have difficulty where folks will point to the EU and suggest that a Caribbean union will have the same impact on the local economies.

    How can I say this without offending someone, without facing accusations of being brainwashed or afflicted with mental slavery. The economy of the EU in no ways resemble that of the Caribbean community.

    We make the mistake of thinking that taking ’11’ countries in the Caribbean is the same as taking ’11’ countries in Europe. It is not that simple; it is not a swap of a Duracell battery for an Eveready battery. This simple mistake has us comparing ourselves to Singapore though we are running second to that country in almost every category.

    Whilst Europe has las large drug manufactures, our drug manufacturing scheme may turn out to be nothing more than some scam. This is one failing that we have … great ideas and proposal are often subverted, diverted or are outright scams. Remember the vaccine fiasco which if it came off would have given one man ‘national hero’ status as he saved us.

    Where are our vehicles and electronic giants? Where are ….

    Don’t just listen to the hype, the fancy speeches and the well crafted articles… I implore you, think for yourself; face the truth

  10. NorthernObserver Avatar

    A former BU regular, often said, the PM doesn’t do details. But, she does DO.
    The move to a Republic was a DO. The details still haven’t been fully sorted out. But she knows, if you don’t DO, you’ll end up with Wood’s proposal of a Study, or similar. And five years later, you’ll still be studying, or consulting or proposing.
    The choice of participants in this free movement deal are rather interesting. It leaves Barbados as arguably the pinnacle of the 4. Why didn’t Guyana or T&T or Jamaica sign on?
    As Washington sabre rattles in our backyard, this and other of their many moves, have made their actions to neuter the IMF and World Bank less newsworthy. Especially given their dislike of the term Climate, and one of the newer IMF funds, in which Barbados played a major role. Or concepts like swaps, if based on anything related to Climate.
    Meanwhile, we have T&T oddly welcoming Washington. The discussions within Caricom must “most interesting” these days.
    And we have a PM who has a reputation to uphold. Lest we forget, she has a future too.


  11. David

    U prefer Mia didn’t make the 14 mins speech? Ok I know that’s not what u mean. As I told u before everything Mia do is political and you know u love we anytime Mia – the political animal she is

    JA. Was firing political preemptive shots from the beginning and when his back is is against all he does is blast off about political this and that and bout he is an independent thinker blah blah blah. Tell him to deny or point out where I erred or is wrong in my analysis . BU HANSARDS will she he always pull the political card when he has to defense …..and u ( David ) always run and give ur son a cop out

    JA

    Us to argue the u can’t go on one factor, u have to take all the factors into consideration. Yet he want to take the factor of the 35% as the only factor when the historical factor point forward Vinci staying home even with the 35%available . You just can’t swallow when it’s pointed out that ur propaganda is wrong / flawed because u either blinkered, got jaundice or suffering from hepatitis D 😳

    More propaganda was the foolish bout the police certificate. Again Barbados has a history or protesting against this type of unfairness. Central bank is one the jump to mind and the most recent on at community college. Independent thinker but seem to be very ignorant

    It expected the people will have concerns. The one about NISSS could have been one ( I could have also been propaganda )
    I point u out to the what the minister of labor said. Where is my thanks ?

    @ T0

    If you referring to the 35% and 37% I have no problem removing the 37%. The 35 was the main thing. The 37 is a fact but in that sentence it was just a throw in = I could have said something like with their construction boom in place or just left it off .

    Going outside now it warm up to reap some sweet potatoes and do some fall clean up.


  12. @John A

    If that is what you took away from the reference to the brief video presentation from the usually loquacious Mottley, knock yourself out.


  13. @ David

    What I took away was a ” all of we is one” and without free movement our economy and NISSS will perish.

    First again let me stress this island has grown admirably between 1966 and now, with between 275000 and 285000 Bajans as a population. Of course the Stuart and Sinkyuh years hold the record for little growth and no pay raises. Truly a remarkable achievement! But I digress, back to the topic at hand. The NIS also grew from formation to its last published audit financials during the period from its inseption to then. The tampering from both parties started in a major way with landmark economics from Sinkyuh, who forced over 1 billion dollars in worthless paper on the NIS. This party followed that by writing off rougly $1.3 billion from the fund, while cutting what they were left with from rougly 1% to 7% annualy. This free movement is no more than a hope that by roping in some foreigners their cash flow will improve, therby saving them from having to refinance the fund. Em is dat simple.

    As for the economy, now unless you calling our Governor of the Central Bank a liar, Barbados has been posting steady economic recovery since Covid. So where is the evidence that our economy is faltering coming from?

    The solution is stop dipping in the dam NISSS money like if em is part of the consolidated fund. Let the NISS issue a certificate every year stating PAID UP 2024 for example and make that certificate form part of doing business in Barbados by tying it to all TIN NUMBERS, VAT AND PAYE NUMBERS, be they private or company employed. Dat is what computers and systems are there for. Of course pensioners and those not working will be exempt from this exercise. This will also bring comfort to employees as to if their employers have paid in their contributions.

    What is being introduced here has no rules, no way of follow up and no way of ensuring that new comers comply with the NISSS or any of our other state requirements. Why not, because we are hoping these persons will do the right thing and line up to register once they clear our port of entries.


  14. “What is being introduced here has no rules, no way of follow up and no way of ensuring that new comers comply with the NISSS or any of our other state requirements. Why not, because we are hoping these persons will do the right thing and line up to register once they clear our port of entries.”

    Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

    More ignorance. Addressed by the minister of labor in the same article I mentioned earlier. They initial restoration at the port of entry

    If they don’t do the right thing then they cannot benefit from Barbados NIS. Examples of this …… the Covid bail outs ( I am not 100% sure )……the fisher folkes after the hurricanes and the solidarity check.

    @ David

    I did not watch the video. I saw that everything I thought I had typed didn’t go through and was cut off at political ….so u may have mistaken what I had intended to say . The cut off incident may have happened at my end


  15. T0

    If tell me what is the two things I should not contrast may help a little. It could be the percentages or it can be the water in the bottle and the water with the bottle removed.

    Xxxxxxxxxx

    A. Well well well …..after all the hallaboo a few yrs ago about how INFLATION over the year made bajans poorer to now come back and admit the from independence to 2008 Barbados / bajans PROSPERED ,,,,, welll welll welll ….. what a ting !!!!

    BU HANSARDS with the “ cheese cutter and coke from 1909” 🤭demonstration


  16. “Let the NISS issue a certificate every year stating PAID UP 2024 for example and make that certificate form part of doing business in Barbados by tying it to all TIN NUMBERS, VAT AND PAYE NUMBERS, be they private or company employed.”
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    @ John A

    I agree with your suggestion.

    Tax and NIS clearances are mandatory requirements for the renewal of PSV permits, including hired vehicles, mini-buses, limousines, tour buses, and all categories of taxis.

    Remember, using TAMIS, the tax identification number (TIN), represents personal tax numbers for individuals, and VAT and PAYE account numbers for businesses.

    If TAMIS is used to its ‘maximum efficiency,’ especially to identify the tax base, monitor and facilitate compliance, would empower the BRA with real-time data for better policy, administration, and enforcement.

    However, I believe both the tax and NIS systems need improving, and the persons troubleshooting issues, require more training.


  17. @ John A
    The BARRIER to your suggestion is not technical.
    It is political.
    Your plan would mean that EVERYONE would now be subject to financial scrutiny and transparent review.
    How would certain ’transactions’ be explained…?

    Why do you think we have no Integrity and Transparency legislation?
    … Because we have been unable to copy what most others have ALREADY done…?
    … Or because no Mafia outfit operates as a transparent meritocracy?

    You would need to create a Committee – appointed by the Don, to ‘determine’ who gets the “PAID 2024” stamp… and who are exempted.


  18. @Artax

    Your commonsense and easy-to-implement suggestions can help with efficient revenue collection, but how many in the political directorate will be affected?


  19. @ Artax

    We need to improve and exploit all of these revenue measures to the fullest before we talk about the NISS needing more subscribers from other territories. We have all the revenue the NISS needs right here, we just have not maximised our efforts to tap into it. What I propose is a broadening of the NISS net which would then also capture any new participants if a controlled immigration plan was implemented in the future.

    The other thing I have a major issue with is this none contributory pension being paid by the NISSS. If you don’t contribute you should not be paid a cent from the NISS. ALL this does is open a door for further delinquents to exploit.


  20. @ Bushie

    The approach our leaders are hoping for with the NISSS is equivalent to you having a bucket with nuff holes in it, but putting two hoses in it instead of one and hoping it will help fill it.


  21. @ John A
    Good analogy…

    Except that one of the ‘holes’ drains to a number of private buckets …and is highly resistant to patching…

    The OTHER holes include some gross inefficiencies, however if these get patch, then the main hole would stand out like a sore thumb…

    A special kind of ‘repair’ would therefore be required to stem the NISSS leakage.
    Pacha got one…. A French model…

    You got that kinda ‘Patch’…?


  22. @ David

    It’s not only the political directorate, you must also consider those individuals who manipulate the systems they control to derive ‘financial benefits’ therefrom.


  23. Good point Artax, the forgotten auditor reports support.


  24. Once again treat the symptoms and ignore the cause.


  25. @ John A

    ‘Not me and you and that non-contributory pension issue, bozee.’ 🤣🤣🤣

    Seriously, however, I wholehearted agree with you that people who DID NOT contribute to the NIS fund, SHOULD NOT BENEFIT therefrom.

    Unfortunately, I was criticised and given a lecture about ‘community centricity,’ and society is based upon helping others, while your CONTINUAL comments on the issue have so far gone FREE of CRICTISM.

    But, as I’ve mentioned in previous contributions, in this forum, it’s not about WHAT is written, but MORE SO about WHO wrote it. 😔

    I’m trying my best to understand how those persons who are advocating for full freedom of movement, are comparing the Caribbean region with the EU.

    The EU, for example, coordinates national tax policies across member states to ensure fair and transparent taxation, combat tax evasion, and promote economic efficiency within the Single Market.

    What co-ordinated tax policies have been implemented by CARICOM or its member states to ensure a similarly fair and transparent taxation, and promote economic efficiency within the Caribbean Single Market?

    Telling a Bajan ‘to go and look for work’ in St. Vincent,’ is essentially suggesting jobs are not available in Barbados……

    …… telling a Vinci to come here for work, is suggesting jobs are available here.


  26. @ Artax

    I agree with everything you have stated. If the state wanrt to pay non contributory pensions to persons who have worked and never paid in a blind cent to NIS, then pay them from the consolidated fund in the form of a social payment. How the hell you going pay a pension to someone that never contributed a cent to a pension fund from the said pension fund? What sort of foolishness is that?

    Also will our newly formed citizens at 67 not also be eligible for this non contributory ” pension”? What is to stop people from these islands coming here say for free heart or eye surgery then going back home after expensing our system? The EU right now got it hands full with this freedom of movement. I read Switzerland and Germany are two who have already started to address it.

    Look make the dam NISS more inclusive by implementing what we have suggested and enhance our tax collection by plugging the holes that exist. Start there then come back and talk bout free movement. If you don’t it is two hoses trying to fill a rust out bucket.


  27. @Artax

    Isn’t it about the philosophical path a government prefers to pursue? In other words it is not a right way or wrong way. A good example is our approach to have a dollar that is pegged to the USD.


  28. @John A

    What is your take on the fact the NISSS is not a segregated fund, meaning the government is the last resort to honour pension and all its other obligations in the context of economic development and performance.


  29. FYI, State Pension payments are paid based on the contribution you made during your working life

    Is this just another goldfish or red herring that is getting the anti immigrant BU lobby’s panties all twisted again just like their reasoning

    The Hate that Hate made
    The end result of stereotyping people is they get punched kicked beaten lynched and killed for false accusations of raping women by stupid hysterical people who believe lies on top of lies slurs and slanders misinformation manufactured by worthless freeloading shyster politicians which should be nipped in the bud

    Fish are surrounded by water to live and breathe but do not even realise they live in water.

    Animals and Man evolved to live and breathe the spiritual energy of the earth air and heavens but do not realise they are surrounded by this energy that created all things wise and wonderful

    Stupid and foolish people do not even realise they and live and breathe the lies deliberately constructed to fool them by design

    Sea of Love, Sea of Dub, Step It Ina Africa

  30. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    @Bushie
    “because no Mafia outfit operates as a transparent meritocracy?”
    You need to stop. The Mafia is the most transparent of performance based operations.
    You really think DI, or his private sector enablers would still be here in the Underworld?
    Couldn’t take that risk.
    Also why there was no action taken in Bim. Two very different codes of conduct. Both involved in illegal acts, just different rules.


  31. @ John A

    There is a wide range of DIVERSE industries in the EU, including, for example, manufacturing, (which encompasses a wide range of activities, such as automotive, chemical, industrial and agricultural machinery, food and beverages), …… and energy – the production and supply of electricity and gas, in addition to a growing focus on renewable energy sources such as solar and wind.

    Germany, Netherlands, Italy and Slovenia, for example, are the headquarters for the manufacturing of several vehicle brands.

    The Volkswagen Group, comprising of Volkswagen, Audi, Porsche, and Skoda, are manufactured in Germany.
    Stellantis, which includes brands such as Peugeot, Fiat, Chrysler, Jeep, and Opel/Vauxhall, is headquartered in the Netherlands, with plants in Italy and Poland.
    Ferrari is in Italy, and the Volvo Group, Sweden.

    The European Automobile Manufacturers Association is the main lobbying and standards group of the automobile industry in the European Union.

    Although there is a manufacturing industry in the region, (e.g. Jamaica and Trinidad), most territories RELY MAINLY on tourism.

    A guy living in Italy who has both qualifications and experience in Automotive Manufacturing Technology, for example, has more opportunities across the EU, because of the several brands of vehicles manufactured there……

    …… as opposed to CAREER CHOICES in the Caribbean that are essentially LIMITED to tourism, agriculture, and construction.


  32. @ David

    I would like to see the fund more protected from the state dippers for sure, but if they were publishing up to date INDEPENDENTLY AUDITED financials, it would make me more comfortable. We also have a much bigger issue with the fund though and that is the need for an independent audit on their asset base. So all the commercial property held, is that up to date in terms of value? In other words has the depreciation annualy on these buildings been booked and does their value represent a true market value?

    The true financial position of the fund has been neglected for so long, that we don’t know if or when finacials are presented, that all these adjustments would be reflected. In other words what is THE PEOPLES LIFE LINE actually really worth?


  33. “FYI, State Pension payments are paid based on the contribution you made during your working life…”
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    ‘Absolutely correct.’ 👏🏽👍🏽

    However, the word, “NON-CONTRIBUTORY,” is self-explanatory.

    ‘That yuh ent contribute nutten.’ 🙂

    “NON-CONTRIBUTORY PENSION” is simply a payment to individuals who do not qualify for a standard CONTRIBUTORY pension, because they’ve either NOT CONTRIBUTED to the NIS Fund……

    …… or paid in enough to meet the minimum contribution requirements.


  34. @ Artax

    Yes the EU does not lack industry. My point is though that the wealthier countries in there have been the magnet for movement. For instance right not Rome is a location that travel blogs warn people to be very careful when there, because of the presence of pick pockets and scammers from other European countries. The authorities there try to arrest these criminals but as fast as they remove six, eight more show up the following day.

    Switzerland now according to an article recently in Reuters, is now looking to restrict the movement of people from the EU. Reuters stated ” while the accord faces a lengthy ratification process” a start has been made.


  35. Aaahhmm. Excuse me to those against non contribution pensions …. Are u all in support of me and other that paid into the NIS and left before the eligible time be paid back our money with interest for all the year that it was in the NIS coffers?
    Ah mean fair is fair


  36. @ David

    “Our approach to have a dollar that is pegged to the USD, is simply a macroeconomic policy.


  37. @Artax

    Do you deny that a macroeconomic policy is underpinned by a philosophical view point?


  38. There is the EU for this that wanta push failure
    And then there is the USA = each state operates like a country with own parliament etc.

    Cari integration is still in it infancy and if allow to grow may one day adopt a common currency.

    Xxxxxxxxxxxxx

    I don’t agree with the say about telling Vinci to go bim or baje to go Vinci for whatever reason. I see it as freedom of choice for freedom of movement.
    A baje if the choice arise can choose to stay in bim unemployed or travel to another country to work if there is a job available to them there.

    My friend son when uwi in Trini came back to bim and couldn’t find a job in his field. After a while he headed back to Trini and is living there 20+ years now (T$ about 3+ to 1 bajan).

    Free movement in caricom was one for yrs now it just that it’s not to the stage as USA as yet . Hopefully it will get there in my lifetime.


  39. @ David

    So the single registration of professionals act has not been finalised hence those persons CANT NOT move freely right now, is how I interpret Mr Commisong’s defence.

    Yet we were told that ANY person from these territories could move, live and work in ANY of the participating countries effective October first. So if at the time SOME PERSONS as Mr Commisong is now confirming, still can not move freely 21 days after the pronouncement, then it follows that the initial claim of ANY PERSON made on October 1st was indeed a false one. I cant see based on the above what he is trying to defend, when he confirmed that the accusation made has now been proven to have been correct AT THE TIME IT WAS MADE. Clearly the 21st is after the 1st at least when I went school at Brumley.

    Also can Mr Commisong furnish us with a list of who makes up PROFESSIONALS under the freedom of movement act? I mean I had a plumber brek a bill off in me the other day and when I questioned it he told me ” boss I is a professional so you got to pay.”


  40. @John A

    What Commisiong’s clarification statement and others made post October 1 have shown is that there was no clear communications plan. The fact that two major professional associations in Barbados seem unaware is a case in point.


  41. @ David

    Not only that we have only ” heard” from two professions. Mr. Commisong et al need to publish the full list of those persons deemed as PROFESSIONALS by his government. They are way more than two categories on this island that I can think of. The point is Mr Commisong has no point in terms of a defence based on the timeline and facts released during said timeline.


  42. “Do you deny that a macroeconomic policy is underpinned by a philosophical view point?”

    @ David

    I have some reservations about it.


  43. Straughn: A matter for Climate Fund

    Barbados ‘has no funds in Blue Green Bank’

    by MARIA BRADSHAW

    mariabradshaw@nationnews.com

    NO MONEY has been placed in Barbados’ Blue Green Bank (BGB).

    So said Ryan Straughn, Minister in the Ministry of Finance, as he responded to an article carried in the last SUNDAY SUN which revealed that Pegasus Capital Investors, the accredited entity for the much-touted Blue Green Bank, was being sued in a United States court amidst allegations that it perpetrated a fraud against the BGB.

    Straughn said he was not aware of the legal matter.

    “I must confess I read it with great interest . . . . I was completely taken aback by the content of the article. But needless to say, just to be clear, no monies have been put up yet in relation to BGB because Pegasus was appointed by the Green Climate Fund (GCF) to do the kind of legwork, if you like, with respect to the setting up of the bank.

    Collaborative project

    “They were paid by USAID (United States Agency for International Development) as part of a technical assistance programme, $2.5 million, which was pledged by USAID, which covered their expenses in relation to the formation of the bank. But the GCF, nor the Government of Barbados, we’ve not actually put any monies yet into the bank,” he said.

    The BGB is a collaborative project between the Government of Barbados, the Green Climate Fund, Pegasus Capital Advisors and the Rockefeller Foundation to fund climate-resilient and low-carbon initiatives in Barbados. These projects include green affordable housing, resilient roofs and transport electrification.

    Complaint

    Fintech Leaders Fund have filed the complaint in the US District Court Southern District of New York against Pegasus and its principals – Craig Cogut, his wife Deborah and son David – charging that they engaged in violation of the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organisations Act (RICO), fraud, negligent misrepresentations, aiding and abetting and unjust enrichment.

    The complaint alleges that the defendants implemented a scheme to secure substantial amounts “potentially, hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars”, in public and private funding by fraud and bribery in a scheme alleged to have targeted the GCF, the Barbados Government, USAID, the International Monetary Fund, the Rockefeller Foundation and the Inter-American Development Bank as well as other victims.

    The case was dismissed twice but Fintech is appealing.

    Straughn told the MIDWEEK NATION that a board was constituted for the BGB.

    “We are about to get things in motion with respect to getting the actual bank set up. So that was actually a quite interesting read because Pegasus is really GCF’s representatives, not the Government or anything. It was just their representative, given that GCF has, I suppose, strict guidelines about how their monies will be used. So, therefore, they were appointed to be able to ensure that GCF’s ‘investment’ was consistent with GCF’s spending regulations.”

    Asked if Government was now concerned about Pegasus’ involvement, the minister stressed that Pegasus had no management role in the BGB.

    “Pegasus is GCF’s representatives and therefore that really is for GCF to decide how they deal with them. But as far as we are concerned . . . they have no management of the institution. So to be clear, they did all the internal policies and guidelines with respect to how the bank should operate and that type of thing, which is very different from any management capability. So I just want to make that clear.

    No management role

    “Now, as a prospective shareholder [who] will have eligibility for appointing somebody to the board, they will have to decide who they want to represent them on the board. But in terms of management of the institution, that will rest with the board being able to recruit the people to manage it properly.

    “So in short, no money has been transferred yet to capitalise the bank. We intend to do so in the shortest possible time once all the final paperwork is completed. People sue all the time in the United States, as you know, so I read it and I was like, ‘Okay.’”

    Source: Nation


  44. Gonsalves: It’s already Caricom law

    PRIME MINISTER of St Vincent and the Grenadines Dr Ralph Gonsalves has declared that the full free movement arrangement among Barbados, Belize, Dominica, and his country is already enforceable under CARICOM law – even though it has not yet been debated in some participating Parliaments.

    Meanwhile, Vice-Chancellor of the University of the West Indies (UWI), Professor Sir Hilary Beckles, says while CARICOM has made notable progress toward regional integration, the free movement initiative still has a long way to go before it can be deemed fully realised.

    They were both speaking online yesterday during the UWI Chancellor’s Forum.

    Gonsalves said once regional leaders agreed and signed the relevant protocols on October 1, the decision became binding as part of community law under the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas.

    “We have gone to Parliament in St Vincent and the Grenadines to put the legislative frame in place,” he said. “But even if we hadn’t done so, we are prepared to do it administratively. Once the Heads of Government had agreed and signed the requisite protocols, that became part of Community law and took precedence over domestic law.”

    Criticism

    His position runs counter to recent criticism in Barbados from the Opposition Democratic Labour Party, which has questioned the legality of Barbados’ participation in the initiative. Opposition Leader Ralph Thorne charged that Government acted “without parliamentary approval” and accused Prime Minister Mia Amor Mottley of overstepping her authority.

    However, Gonsalves’ interpretation aligns with that of Attorney General Dale Marshall, who has defended the move, arguing that Cabinet approval was sufficient while the supporting legislation makes its way through Parliament.

    The Vincentian leader cited the 2013 Shanique Myrie judgment of the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ), which he said reaffirmed the supremacy of regional law in matters agreed upon by CARICOM Heads of Government.

    “Community law is not only the treaty or the laws passed by our parliaments. It also includes the interpretations handed down by the CCJ, which is the only authoritative, supranational institution in the Caribbean integration architecture.”

    He said the October 1 agreement merely extended what already existed within the Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States (OECS), where citizens travel and work freely using only photo identification.

    “The four countries within CARICOM are really now doing what the OECS countries had been doing for quite some time. It doesn’t make sense that we have the free movement of goods, services, and capital, but not of people.”

    He urged regional governments to avoid restricting “contingent rights” such as access to health care and education, saying these benefits were essential to make free movement meaningful. “If you don’t have the requisite bundle of contingent rights, you’re going to have limitations, Countries that try to put a brake on these rights are making a mistake,” he warned. Gonsalves further noted that migration could help offset declining birth rates across the region, which he described as a looming demographic crisis.

    Historical challenges

    Sir Hilary reflected on the historical and structural challenges that continue to hinder the region’s ability to function as a cohesive economic and political unit. He noted that despite its shared identity and cultural heritage, deep-rooted divisions persisted – many of them inherited from colonial systems that were designed to serve imperial rather than Caribbean interests.

    He said the concept of free movement, though being vigorously pursued under CARICOM, was not new to the region’s history. The Vice-Chancellor traced its origins to colonial “free port legislation”, which was used by European powers to facilitate the movement of labour and resources across their territories for profit.

    Sir Hilary said that while the Caribbean has since redefined such mechanisms to serve its own collective purpose, the region was still grappling with the “internal contradictory forces and headwinds” – many originating outside its shores – that kept member states divided and hesitant to embrace full economic and social unity.

    Source: Nation


  45. LOL
    Pegasus sounds a lot like Radical.


  46. Surprising is that Straughn given his role in our government would ‘confess’ to being unaware.


  47. We make the mistake of thinking that taking ’11’ countries in the Caribbean is the same as taking ’11’ countries in Europe. It is not that simple; it is not a swap of a Duracell battery for an Eveready battery.

    XXXXXXXXX

    SIR, PLEASE GO TO THE TOP OF THE CLASS.

    100/100


  48. @ David
    @ John A

    An issue that’s notably absent from these CARICOM discussions, is the lack of a reliable, efficient, sustainable inter-regional transport service, which seems to have ended with the demise of LIAT (1974) Ltd., and emergence of LIAT20.

    We’re all aware travelling through the region remains a hurdle that’s somewhat difficult to overcome.

    What are your thoughts on an inter-regional ferry service, something regional heads of governments have been ‘all talk and no action?’


  49. @Artax

    We commend you for maintaining focus on this issue of intra-regional transport through the years. While it may be an extreme perspective, it is plausible to argue that freedom of travel and intra-regional transportation should be a key prerequisite to REAL or functional integration. The troubled operations of LIAT (1974) will likely cause a gun-shy approach among Caribbean Community (CARICOM) members during this period of economic challenges. In the opinion of a lowly blogmaster, intra-regional travel serves as a crucial ‘performance indicator’ of a successful integration project – since there are no active projects on the radar to make this a reality expect a business as usual culture with little material change.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending