Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Afra Raymond, Citizen Advocate

The following article by Afra Raymond about state owned hotels is timely because of the government of Barbados decision to dump the Barbados Hilton for USD80 millions -it is being whispered. The point Afra raises about the need for disclosure of the agreements between government and the hotel management company in the public interest fuels BU’s concern about the cloak of secrecy by the government of Barbados to dump a prized possession for 30 pieces of silver. It seems like the other day the government of the day sold the national bank to fund the implosion and rebuilding of the historic building at Needam’s Point.

Oh, what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive! (Sir Walter Scott, 1808)

David –Blogmaster

At the end of January 2018, the Ministry of Trade & Industry and its implementing agency, Evolving Technologies & Enterprise Development Company (ETECK), announced the completion of a $7.6M project for the renewal of the Trinidad Hilton Pool. According to the official statements, that project was completed on time and within budget, as part of […]

Read more of this post


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

87 responses to “Implode Hilton, Rebuild Hilton THEN Sell Hilton”

  1. NorthernObserver Avatar

    “DO you think that the GOB really wanted to be in the hotel business on the South Coast?
    GOB went into these area because your private sector was risk averse?
    They call upon the taxpayers to take the risk.”

    enuff said.


  2. What kind of democracy could be allowed to dispose of state assets weeks before an election. An election this government will lose.


  3. If there is no money in the coffers how can they get their buy outs and pensions


  4. This is how forex leaking will force this kind of a barbaric decision.


  5. Pachamama February 20, 2018 at 7:13 AM #
    What kind of democracy could be allowed to dispose of state assets weeks before an election. An election this government will lose.

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    What kind of democracy would put these assets in the hands of the state???

    Answer …… a fascist/communist style democracy …. we call it democratic socialism!!


  6. There’s a saying …..BUILD IT AND THEY WILL COME…. well, I suggest it should be FIX IT AND WE WILL COME BACK…and I mean fix the infrastructure like sewage and roads .

  7. Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim. Avatar
    Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim.

    Just another DLP teefin’ scam.

    Commissions and shares for them and their friends.

    MIA better be ready to prosecute these teefs or there will be no return to business credibility for this nation.

  8. de pedantic Dribbler Avatar
    de pedantic Dribbler

    “MIA better be ready to prosecute these teefs or there will be no return to business credibility for this nation.”

    Way back in time it would be called a Duffus or a Moyne.

    But modern context gets us Coleman (Clico), Patterson or in US context Mueller.

    So yes I too would love to see a new non DLP PM budget a few million for a commission of enquiry “empowered by law” to investigate illegal project bid transactions, graft, ministerial conflict of interests resulting from financial interest with private corporations and all other matters of government financial malfeasance.

    We have a chairman ready to put his reputation for excellence into that role too: Dr. Cheltenham.

    We could only wish!


  9. For the last 10 years I have been hearing that the BLP “tiefing and getting kickbacks”.

    The DLP win the election in 2008 and I have been hearing that they “tiefing and getting kickbacks”.

    Where is the actionable incontrovertible evidence ?

  10. Well Well & Cut N' Paste At Your Service Avatar
    Well Well & Cut N’ Paste At Your Service

    And you will get no end to this fanciful commission….but taxpayers will be bilked in the millions.

    Any chairman for any commission of inquiry should be non bajan…

    Cheltenham is lawyer for the same private crooks stealing from the treasury and pension fund…ask him if he is not the lawyer for crooked cow et al….. friends and business partners and manybe even family with the same corrupt politicians and ministers.

    How will things ever change or corruption be dismantled and eradicated, if inquiries are filled with the same conflicts of interest persons…each and every time.

  11. Well Well & Cut N' Paste At Your Service Avatar
    Well Well & Cut N’ Paste At Your Service

    I could swear the auditor general…each year in his reports, outlines evidence of outright thefts of taxpayer’s money going back years, irrefutable proof and evidence…which is ignored by government and everyone else and quickly forgotten on the blogs.

  12. Well Well & Cut N' Paste At Your Service Avatar
    Well Well & Cut N’ Paste At Your Service

    Bloggers seem to have an attention span and memory retention of two weeks…tops..

    Ah guess that is better than goldfish…but completely useless if radical changes are to be made on the island..

    Lol

  13. Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim. Avatar
    Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim.

    Hants February 20, 2018 at 10:37 AM #
    For the last 10 years I have been hearing that the BLP “tiefing and getting kickbacks”.

    The DLP win the election in 2008 and I have been hearing that they “tiefing and getting kickbacks”.

    Where is the actionable incontrovertible evidence ?

    ………………………………………..

    As I’ve stated here before, I was never solicited for a bribe under the BLP administration.

    Since 2008 I have been solicited 5 times, 3 times supposedly on behalf of ministers.

    DLP gov’t graft is widely discussed in local and foreign business circles with supporting whattsapp and e-mail messages circulated among colleagues.

    If you don’t move in business circles or maybe have nothing to offer the corrupt, you would never be approached or know anyone who has been.

    But, all of the above is irrelevant. The reputation stands and so does the effects; the near-total business development disengagement from this country that has brought our economy to its knees.

    Under the last two terms of BLP gov’t, Barbados had a reputation of having a grossly inefficient civil service that just about paralysed new business and development. Owen Arthur and some of his ministers micro-managed their ministries to barely keep the wheel of progress lubricated and we crept forward.

    In the absence of any DLP management skills of any kind, micro or otherwise, It is obvious to me that the civil service paralysis created fantastic ‘facilitation’ opportunities for the corrupt and corruptible without having to solve the endemic problem for the rest of the law-abiders who would like to function here.

    They were warned. 4 years go Goddard’s told Fumble to make doing business easier or they would disengage. It was obvious to anyone in even the smallest business.

    There was never any chance of economic recovery under Fumble’s Fools.


  14. @ Frustrated Businessman wrote “Since 2008 I have been solicited 5 times, 3 times supposedly on behalf of ministers.”

    Where is the incontrovertible evidence that this happened ?

  15. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ David

    Now you understand what this trained economist was pointing BU to. Choose the persons who man these institutions very, very carefully.

    It does help if the Party has a sound, and carefully thought out philosophy. Then have that philosophy clearly articulated and explained to the Electorate.

    For the most part all the parties are coasting on an ideology whose shelf life expired in the last decade of the last century.

    Where are the millennials? Are they fully aware of the new social ,political and economic environment in which they have to operate going forward?

    The Monday morning cuss out at the stand pipe will not do. We want more.

  16. Well Well & Cut N' Paste At Your Service Avatar
    Well Well & Cut N’ Paste At Your Service

    Frustrated.., anytime any politician, government minister, permanent secretary…lawyer etc approach you again for extortion reasons…tape them.


  17. @Bernard

    You have asked an interesting question about where are the millennials. Clearly this group operates on the fringe of the political system and their support is coopted around election time. How do we realistically expect the system to refresh if this group for whatever reason is disinterested?


  18. Imagine the chaos we would see if the FX reserves are all gone and US$’s have to be purchased on the open market to pay for imports. What we are now seeing is the sale of assets to prevent that scenario.

    Bottom line and where the rubber meets the road….we have to stop the fx bleeding. That by default means cutting way back on the printing of money.

  19. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ David

    One has to mentor the millennials very carefully. We have to put in the time and the effort. There is a tendency to give them things rather than our undivided attention. We look over our shoulders hoping somebody else would do it. But should we not ask: “Why not me?”

  20. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    SETH at 12 :19 PM

    What printing of money what? What do you mean by that statement?

    What about earning foreign exchange?

    What about repatriation of foreign exchange earnings?

    Does it really matter if the imports are paid for out of your “open market”shenanigans, rather than from the official stash of foreign reserves?

    One cannot sell assets for ever. Selling one’s house to feed oneself is never a solution. Earning a steady flow of income is a sustainable solution.
    Does it really make economic sense to sell one asset below replacement costs and true market value, and borrow money to put up two similar assets of doubtful earning capacities ?

    Who are we really trying to fool?

  21. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    SETH

    Have you really analysed the composition of the imported goods/ services?

    How much goes to finance the inputs to the tourism sector?
    How much is spent on inputs to the construction sector?
    How much is spent on the inputs to the Public Utilities ( Electricity, telephones,road building etc)?

    Is it really true to say that the bulk of imports are for consumption?

    It is only necessary to “print money” if taxes are not raised or public sector loans are not taken up,or public expenditure is on unnecessary activities.


  22. @Bernard

    We need to generate more forex by expanding our export earning capacity, we need to manage leakage of foreign exchange and your favorite, we need to infuse the economy with a dose of confidence.

    There is the need to modify behaviors that lean on foreign taste/consumption.

  23. Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim. Avatar
    Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim.

    Exactly Bernard.

    This country is stifled by a useless civil service. The previous BLP administration worked around them, the current DLP administration have failed to do so or address the problem.

    Barbados economy cannot continue to shrink as Seth suggest, it has to grow and the current bureaucratic environment does not facilitate that. The graft is a result of the opportunities that environment created.

    Hants, keep your head up your ass boy, the real world out here is no place for you.

    WW&C, Thompson taught these devils how to teef with legal and professional fees all above board. If he had issued a company invoice and paid the VAT on the money he and Parris stole from CLICO, his cheque would never have shown up on an election podium.


  24. Our little property is valued at US$130,000 per room plus public areas and 1.2 acres of spare land. All indications are that the Hilton would cost at least US$400,000 per room to build, so with 354 rooms that gives an indication of worth. So to agree to anything like US$80 million
    would be grossly understating the taxpayers interest. Remember also that the Hilton has outstanding debts quoted at BDS $100 million mostly due to NIS , so if any amount is written-off and further concessions given this proposed sale is another Blue Horizon (but larger) in the making.


  25. @Adrian

    Sale price is determined based on room plant and revenue earning capacity.

  26. Well Well @ Cut and Paste @ Your Service Avatar
    Well Well @ Cut and Paste @ Your Service

    Frustrated lol…i cant wait for this lot to be kicked out and an independent investigation reveals all the crimes they committed,

    Mia or whomever would be fools not to facilitate a thorough criminal investigation, seeing as even if there was no bad blood between some of them before, there is sure some now.

    9:30 a.m 6
    7 CV0271/2009 Mia Amor Mottley v. National Cultural Foundation
    8 CV0272/2009 Owen Arthur v. National Cultural Foundation
    9 CV0273/2009 Owen Seymour Arthur v. Caribbean Broadcasting Corporation

  27. Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim. Avatar
    Frustrated Businessman: Animal Farm sequel playing out in Bim.

    Adrian, I was recently told by a very large hotelier that new hotels in the Caribbean average at US$100,000 per room and Barbados at US$350,000 per room, not counting the land so your numbers are not far off.

    Hilton is probably worth around US$130 m

  28. NorthernObserver Avatar

    @BC
    Where can we find these numbers?
    “We” travel on roads most days….that is indirect consumption….not just the cost and maintenance of the vehicle used for transport. “We” use (consume) communication services. “We” consume electricity. “We” have shelters, erecting and maintaining those shelters is consumption. “We” consume food daily. “We” consume water and sewerage services daily.
    There is also similar consumption used by visitors.

  29. NorthernObserver Avatar

    “Sale price is determined based on room plant and revenue earning capacity.”

    Sale price is determined by what some other party is willing to PAY the owner, in a manner acceptable to the owner.

  30. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ Adrian at 2:36 PM

    Your approach to valuation is very close to mine.
    There is really no need for GOB to get involved directly in Hotel construction. Past performance is discouraging. New hotel construction and ownership should be left to the private sector.
    The Hilton was supposed to be a flagship in the latter 1960’s for the then underdeveloped South Coast. The return to the taxpayers was minimal directly but invaluable for the demonstration effect it had for south coast development.


  31. NorthernObserver February 20, 2018 at 3:02 PM #

    “Sale price is determined based on room plant and revenue earning capacity.”(Quote)

    Wrong. In the real world, valuation is one thing, sale price another. The sale price is determined by the asking price, what the seller wants, what the buyer is prepared to pay, and what the seller is prepared to accept.

  32. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    Northerner

    We are talking economic value.
    We are also talking about the historical cost of construction.
    We are talking about the replacement cost /present cost of putting up a similar Hilton Hotel.
    We are talking about the Net present value of future flow of revenue of the Hilton Hotel say 30 years.
    Your reference to what a buyer can or will pay is an irrelevancy which should remain in the textbook until we do a fire sale.

    Surely your willing buyer’s offer is and cannot be described as a fair market value?

  33. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    That should be ” is not “.


  34. @Northern

    Yes price is what the market will bear. However, there is science to identifying the price based on ROI criteria.


  35. There is no ‘science’ to return on investment. That applies if it is a legitimate trading business and how much the buyer wants the business, its synergies with any existing business.
    But the value of a business is what the seller is prepared to accept and the buyer is prepared to pay. Everything else is theoretical.
    The difference between the sale of a private business and one that is listed is that you have a lot of shareholders to deal with on the one side, and the owner(s) of the private business, on the other.
    Without diverting, it brings us back to the role of an audit in a listed company; auditors have a public service responsibility with listed companies. With a private company, caveat emptor.
    It is interesting that in the case of Carillion its annual report and accounts were passed at the end of March, and in July, three months later, it issued a profit warning. Clearly something was wrong. Read the reports on HP’s purchase of Autonomy Corporation.
    A few years ago a well-known, young Barbadian lawyer asked me if I could find a buyer for his client’s small hotel; I said I would put word out, and asked for the last three years’ trading figures. Which is normal. He hesitated. I also asked for his rolling business plan, although that was not necessary, it wold have helped.
    To cut a long story short, what he was telling me about ‘a going concern’ as a hotel turned out to be a business that had been closed for some time. I reminded him that what he was selling was a property, not a business. It was the last I heard from him.
    No matter how many rooms he had, if the business was not trading it was simply land and a disused building.


  36. UPPER UPSCALE

    Hilton
    Global Footprint: 572 hotels; 206,635 rooms

    Hilton Take: “The stylish, forward-thinking global leader in hospitality,” this is Hilton’s flagship brand and often ranks No. 1 in terms of its global brand awareness in the hospitality industry.

    https://skift.com/2016/11/02/every-one-of-hiltons-13-hotel-brands-explained/


  37. Hants February 20, 2018 at 4:23 PM #

    Marketing PR.


  38. @bernard

    the point I am making on FX is the same one made by the Central Banks

    “Serious challenges linger for the Barbados economy, Acting Central Bank Governor Cleviston Haynes disclosed today.
    In his report on the island’s economic performance for the first nine months of the year, Haynes outlined a worrying slide in already low international reserves.
    At the end of the third quarter, reserves had reached 8.6 weeks of import cover, which is below the international benchmark of 12 weeks.”

    and on the printing of money as the PM said :

    “Acknowledging that Government should not have to turn to the Central Bank to have money printed to finance government deficit, Prime Minister of Barbados The Rt. Hon Freundel Stuart has however noted that the present
    administration has done so because “government has bills to pay”.”

    So the money the government prints to pay its bills filters its way into the hands of the Barbados population who spend a great percentage of it on imports, be it food, smart phones or cars. Those imports have to be paid for with FX.

    The balancing of FX “ins” and “outs” appears to be reaching a desperation point thus the fire sale price of the Hilton.


  39. SETH February 20, 2018 at 4:40 PM #

    So the money the government prints to pay its bills filters its way into the hands of the Barbados population who spend a great percentage of it on imports, be it food, smart phones or cars. Those imports have to be paid for with FX.(Quote)

    There is nothing wrong with printing money. In fact, if used properly, it is advantageous. Extra liquidity leads to asset bubbles, but this can be controlled either through the manipulation of the base rate, or by taking the money out of the economy from the banks and credit unions. ie increasing capital reserves with the central bank.
    It is now approaching 30 years since central banks have been targeting inflation.


  40. Whoever buys the Hilton will do so as an investment.


  41. Whoever buys the Hilton will do so as an investment.(Quote)

    That much is clear, they will not buy it to put it in a museum. But the metrics must be more than just an investment. It must fit in with their existing portfolio; earning potential must be there. This includes local competition (Sandy Lane, Sam Lord’s, Hyatt, and the numerous other three, four and five star hotels).
    It depends on Barbados continuing to be a long-haul destination for middle class and professional travellers. At present, apart from sun, sea and sand, there is very little to attract top end visitors.
    Top end hotels will not appeal to weekend travellers from neighbouring islands, no matter how wealthy. We badly need a series of boutique bed-and-breakfast accommodation.
    Most people will not leave Europe and North America to eat in local restaurants; to see local entertainments; to visit local museums; to go to local theatres; concerts; etc. Tourism is a package, by that I mean people will do things while here, but they will not leave home just to do those things.
    We have no leisure infrastructure, so once the sun goes down people are left to drink before retiring.

  42. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ Bernard Codrington February 20, 2018 at 3:04 PM
    “There is really no need for GOB to get involved directly in Hotel construction. Past performance is discouraging. New hotel construction and ownership should be left to the private sector.”

    That sounds like the kind of economic talk we expect from BC instead of seeing the public sector as any viable engine of long-term sustainable economic growth thereby providing the resources to facilitate social development.

    Government’s role in a political democracy with a capitalist economic orientation is to encourage and where possible stimulate economic activities to generate enough surplus profits to fund the social services required for social development leading to the ‘good’ society expected by the masses who voted for it

    Let the government be first and foremost the facilitator of economic enterprise and, in some cases, the fillip to economic adventurism by being the willing reinsurance company where the risks are too great to be borne by individual players in the private sector.

    So the question to be posed you- and definitely deserving of an answer- is who or what is stopping the private sector principals behind the Hyatt hotel erection from playing the role you have so ‘precisely’ identified?

    Is it the one-man-band David Comissiong?
    Is it as a result of the failure to find foreign financing backers? Or is it that the NIS easy-funding faucet has been turned off by the mandate given to the MoF by the IMF and the credit rating agencies with respect to the issuing of sovereign guarantees for future investment in matured and sunset industries?

  43. NorthernObserver Avatar

    @Blogmaster (cause HA rarely reads a thread)
    I appreciate the science.
    Allow me to share a conversation with a former classmate who is now CFO of a top 20 Canadian company. They could today, be the country’s largest warranty provider. [my guess]
    After the pleasantries…
    Caller: do you know what the credit rating of your sunny isle is?
    Me: Not good.
    Caller; Not good? You mean junk.
    silence
    Caller: Do you know what my board would do to me if I opened a captive operation there?
    Me: are you asking me for current openings in the CFO field, or contacts in Bermuda?
    Caller: [chuckling] good to know you still have a sense of humour.

    One may choose to forget, the Barbados of 2000 is not the Barbados of 2018. We can calculate replacement costs, future net or discounted cash flows, guesstimates of incentives, projected costs or ROI, blah blah blah.

    When it comes to assets the $$$ size of the Hilton, the BNTCL etc etc, and the seller wants $US, the potential buyers shrink. Add in a CCC rating, and they shrink further, esp the publicly traded entities. Add in certain infrastructural concerns, and they shrink again.

    Just look at the good gentlemen above, whose P&Q has been officially listed for how long? And that is at the lower $$$ end. Moving things in Bim isn’t easy.

    Uncertainty = discounts.

  44. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ Miller at 5 : 21 PM

    You are playing devil’s advocate this evening are you not? You know quite well my position on these issues. So please re- pen them.
    In passing, the IMF and the credit agencies do not give directions to sovereign governments. They merely express an opinion. Sovereign governments take responsibility for their mistakes and actions or in-actions.
    So do not go looking for Bogey men. We are all adults now we need no external control.

  45. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @ Northerner at 5 : 31 PM

    You have made a perfect case for not selling Hilton Hotel at an undervalue. I will be worried when Hilton is not satisfied with its brand name use and management fee of 20% + of gross revenue.

  46. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ Bernard Codrington February 20, 2018 at 5:41 PM
    “In passing, the IMF and the credit agencies do not give directions to sovereign governments. They merely express an opinion. Sovereign governments take responsibility for their mistakes and actions or in-actions.”

    Come on B C, you are not talking to a “D C” (David C).

    Are you implying that both Jamaica and Guyana under IMF-dictated programmes could have done as they both saw fit in accordance with their own political and ideological agendas?

    So why were their currencies devalued to almost cut-plate value?

    So there is no truth in the statement that whoever pays the piper (lender of last resort to bankrupt countries) can call the tune (dictates fiscal and monetary affairs of that same bankrupt country)?

    Given your response to SETH (@ Bernard Codrington February 20, 2018 at 12:50 PM) we are rather concerned about your ability to deal with the realities facing Barbados. In a few months without an emergency bailout from some Chinese or ME godfather we shall soon see who in Barbados would be taking responsibility for what would be unfolding.

    Why is the GoB not privatizing (divesting) its commercial interests in the BNTCL and Hilton to the local private sector, both corporate and individual and are awash (allegedly) with cash holdings lying idle in the local financial system?

  47. Bernard Codrington Avatar
    Bernard Codrington

    @Miller

    I am convinced that our realities may be the same but what you see as a catastrophe I see as a challenge. We have walked a road with more pot holes than this one and with the right people in place and a can- do attitude we prevailed. So sorry, I cannot see the world through your lens.

  48. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ Bernard Codrington February 20, 2018 at 6:42 PM

    You mean the blinkered world of Bajans who believe the rest of the world owes them a living from the same foreign money they have been able to borrow like financial drug addicts from the international loan sharks without improving over time the productive ability to repay in the distance.

    I see the Bajan world through the same ‘experienced’ eyes as SETH and Tron; not those incestuously blinkered by ‘insularly’ small island living with its Mickey Mouse currency for ‘play-play’ (monopoly) money.


  49. @Northern Observer

    Point taken and makes Bernard’s intervention all the more relevant. To sell a national asset like the Hilton, its location, its historic value etc is nonsense.

  50. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ David February 20, 2018 at 7:30 PM

    It is making OSA- with his (in)famous reputation of selling off Barbados to ‘foreigners’ in true parro style- look like a reformed alcoholic who has been ‘dry’ for the past 10 years.

    Who now would dare to refer to that 2012 outlaw and wanted economic bandit as “Seetru Arthur the parro of the BNB giveaway to Trickidadians and the West Coast real estate sales junkie?

    Not even the dearly departed Alvin, ac, CCC or Fractured BLP.

    Privatization has been re-branded under the DLP to “Divestment Looking for a Privateer” to take on a more politically correct sound and appeal contained in a bottle of social-entitlements labeled ‘economic recovery plan made of strychnine ready for mass distribution’.

    The economic evil that men do lives after them while the good is interred in their political graves.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending