Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Photo Credit: Barbados Today
Photo Credit: Barbados Today

The Fourth Estate plays a critical role to the proper functioning of a democracy, it must. Providing citizens with information which equips them to make the best decisions and at the same time act as a watchdog targeting those who act as gatekeepers of authority and influence in our society. Any attempt to sanitize, filter, manipulate information which it feeds to the public must be rejected as a fourth estate reneging on its obligation. The consequence is a compromised democracy.

In Barbados the media [fourth estate] is heavily self-censored. With the exception of a couple media practitioners there is a lack of respect for the profession by the decisionmakers and general public. It is fair to suggest that media workers demonstrate a lack of respect for themselves if we are to judge their inability to promote a vibrant union or association. The Barbados Association of Journalists (BAJ) does not even have an official website or Facebook presence in 2013 such is the inadequacy of how media workers see themselves.

Related Link: Statement issued by Assistant Commissioner of Police (ag) Crime, Lionel M. Thompson

One of the tenets of a working Fourth Estate is the right to  leverage freedom of expression. However, while accepting that media must have the right to report freely on matters of public interest there are certain universal norms which respected media outlets observe. The requirement of a society to defend public morals and therefore the need to filter OBSCENITY.   There is DEFAMATION of course and a host of others based on jurisdiction. The one of interest to BU is PORNOGRAPHY and in this instance, CHILD PORNOGRAPHY. A simple definition of child pornography is “material that visually depicts sexual conduct by children”.

The arrest of Nation newspaper Publisher Vivian-Anne Gittens, Editor in Chief Roy Morris and Editor Sanka Price in connection with the sex story published on October 26, 2013 has signalled a departure from the norm given the response it has attracted. Many who read the article believed that the Nation had a right to report the matter, where they got it wrong was how it executed.    BU found it surprising how many leading commentators made the point that the Nation newspaper was on good ground to expose the matter and at the same time excuse the graphic presentation of the incident. Win lose or draw a message has been sent to media houses that sensationalizing stories of this nature which involve children will not be tolerated, and this is a good thing.   The time has come to fight back against the decline in standards in every facet of our society. There is one thing which as adults we cannot compromise and that is proving leadership (mentorship) to our children.

It gives BU no joy to see others brought before the Court on such a serious charge BUT enough is enough. BU had the opportunity when we received the link to the sex video to post a more graphic blog, we also had the opportunity to use the Nation’s redacted  image, we did not AND it did not require much deliberation on the part of the BU household. The good from the story is that the sensibilities of Barbadians everywhere have been aroused.  Let us hope it sends a message to the idiots who feel compelled to post all and sundry to social media. To all the schools which are covering up infelicities. To all the parents who are in denial. To the incompetents at the ministry of education who are cheating on their roles as guardians of our education system.

Congratulations to the Police and Director of Public Prosecutions for demonstrating the courage to travel a different path this time around.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

185 responses to “The Nation Newspaper Gaffe: A Case NOT to EXPLOIT Children”


  1. Was trying to make sense of Assistant Commissioner Mark Thompson’s statement in the Friday Nation. Seems to me that he was offering an apology to the country and Nation Newspaper for arresting its personnel and begging for forgiveness for the things that have been done. just doesn’t make sense unless the arrest is only a matter of playing to the hypocritical gallery.


  2. “Let us hope it sends a message to the idiots who feel compelled to post all and sundry to social media.”

    just asking if the publishers of a confidential document which should be known only to the Governor-General, Mr Guyson Mayers, Mr Keith Whittaker, Dean Frank Marshall and the other signatory fall into the above category.


  3. @Mark Thompson “Let me commence by contextualising the Royal Barbados Police Force (RBPF) postulates.”

    Can anybody tell me what this means in English?

  4. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    David

    I saw the photograph that accompanied the story. Maybe, I need more powerful spectacles but it did not appear pornographic to me. All that I was able to see was a boy standing behind a little girl. I also read the article and I believe that the author could have toned it down a little and still made his point. But I saw nothing that was pornographic in my opinion. Because the police and DPP got carried away, it does not mean that either one charged is guilty of any offence. Don’t follow suit and get carried away also: a jury would have to decide because of the nature of the charge, unless a judge upholds a no-case submission.

    Unfortunately, this matter had so much coverage, I wonder if the State would be able to find an impartial jury.

  5. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ Simple Simon | November 16, 2013 at 8:38 PM |

    B S!
    That is the only way to get to the top in this Barbados. Behave like shit and float to the top in a sea of mullets.

  6. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    So when are we going to see a photo (credit to the Nation) of the two men who allegedly made threats against the life of the MoF?


  7. @Caswell

    Note BU stated win,loose or draw this matter will serve as a wake up call.


  8. CAP. 146A
    CHAPTER 146A
    PROTECI’ION OF CHILDREN
    ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS
    SECTION
    1. Short tide.
    2. Interpretation.
    3. Indecent photographs of children.
    4. Defences.
    5. Evidence.
    6. Offences by corporations.
    7. Entry, search and seizure.
    8. Forfeiture.
    9. Punishment.
    L.R.O. 1991 Protection of Children CAP. 146A ss. 1-3
    CHAPTER 146A
    PROTECTION OF CHILDREN 1990-36 An Act to provide for the protection of children from exploitation by preventing the making of indecent photographs of them and matters related thereto.
    Commencement
    [20th December, 1990]
    Short title
    1. This Act may be cited as the Protection of Children Act.
    Interpretation
    2. In this Act, “child” means a person under the age of 18; “film” includes any form of video-recording; “indecent photograph” includes an indecent film, a copy of an indecent photograph or film, and an indecent photograph that is part of a film that shows children; “photograph” includes the negative of the photograph; “premises” includes any stall or vehicle.
    Indecent photograph of children
    3. (1) Any person who (a) takes or permits to be taken any indecent photograph of a child; or children. (b) distributes or shows an indecent photograph of a child; or (c) has in his possession indecent photographs of a child whether or not with a view to their being distributed or shown by that person or others; or (d) publishes or causes to be published any advertisement likely to be understood as conveying that the advertiser distributes or shows indecent photographs of children or intends to do so, is guilty of an offence.
    (2) For the purposes of this Act, a person is to be regarded as distributing an indecent photograph if that person parts with possession of the photograph, or exposes or offers it for acquisition by another person.
    L.R.O. 1991 Protection of Children CAP. 146A ss. 4-7
    (3) Proceedings for an offence under this Act shall not be instituted except by or with the consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions.
    Defences. 4. Where a person is charged with an offence under paragraph (b) or (c) of section 3(1), it shall be a defence for the person to prove (a) that he had a legitimate reason for distributing or showing the photographs or having them in his possession, as the case may be; or (b) that he had not himself seen the photographs and did not know, nor had any cause to suspect them to be indecent. Evidence. 5. On a charge of an offence under paragraph (a) of section 3 (1), the wife or husband of the accused may be called as a witness for the prosecution or the defence; and if so called, notwithstanding any other law to the contrary, is a compellable witness.
    Offences be corporations
    6. (1) Where a body corporate is found guilty of an offence under this Act and it is proved that the offence occurred with the consent or connivance of, or was attributable to any neglect on the part of any director, manager, secretary or other officer of the body, or any person who was purporting to act in any such capacity, that officer or person as well as the body corporate, shall be deemed to be guilty of that offence and shall be liable to be proceeded against and punished in accordance with the provisions of this Act. (2) Where the affairs of a body corporate are managed by its members, subsection (1) shall apply in relation to the acts and defaults of a member in connection with his functions of management as if he were a director of the body corporate.
    Entry, search and seizure
    7. (1) Where a magistrate is satisfied by information on oath laid by a member of the Police Force that
    (a) there are reasonable grounds for suspecting that indecent photographs of children are in premises within the jurisdiction of the magistrate; and
    L.R.O. 1991 Protection of Children CAP. 146A ss. 8-9
    (b) the photographs referred to under paragraph (a)
    (i) are or have been taken there, (ii) are or have been shown there, or (iii) are kept there with a view to their being distributed or shown, the magistrate may issue a warrant authorising the member to enter, if need be by force, and to search the premises within 14 days from the date of the warrant. (2) Where a warrant has been issued to a member of the Police Force under subsection (1), the member may seize and remove any articles that he believes with reasonable cause to be or to include indecent photographs of children taken or shown on the premises or kept there with a view to their being distributed or shown.
    Forfeiture
    8. (1) Where indecent photographs of children are seized under section 7 (2) and a person is convicted under section 3 of an offence in respect of those photographs, the court shall order the photographs to be forfeited. (2) An order made under subsection (1), including an order made on appeal, shall not take effect until the expiration of the ordinary time within which an appeal may be instituted or, where the appeal is duly instituted, until the appeal is finally decided or abandoned.
    Punishment
    9. (1) A person who is convicted of an offence under this Act Punishment, is liable (a) on conviction on indictment to imprisonment for a term of 5 years; or (b) on summary conviction to a term of 2 years.

    submitted in order that opinions can be formulated factually and not speculatively


  9. Caswell Franklyn wrote “I saw the photograph that accompanied the story. Maybe, I need more powerful spectacles but it did not appear pornographic to me.”

    It may not be pornographic but the accompanying story described the photo and the context in which it was taken.

    We are all entitled to opine.

  10. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    Hants

    They were not charged for the article which accompanied the photo. The were charged for publishing the photograph which is said to be “an indecent photograph”.

    >


  11. Someone said we are a bunch a old fogies on BU but this old fogie still has enough powers of observation to notice the beauty of the female detective holding Publisher Vivian.


  12. We await the arrest of the one who has robbed innocent people of millions of dollars but who sits in the main seat of power in George Street.

    We await an explanation from the acting deputy Commissioner of Police on why this arrest should be made.

    This is nothing short of blatant pressure from the DLP to punish the Nation for daring to go against this powerful mafia called the DLP. And we wonder why they did what they did to COP Dottin. Get their people in place to do what they want….I think the time is soon coming for the order to crack heads and shoot some people.

    People, you now know what god you are serving!


  13. BU Congratulations on a well written article. The Nation from its inception was always a paper catering to slander. Even when they report court news with rape victims they go into detail. They are are a shameless bunch.. Hope they get what they deserve. If those students were of a different ethnic group I would bet my last dollar they would never publish it. They should change their name to SLEASY.


  14. @Anne wrote ” If those students were of a different ethnic group I would bet my last dollar they would never publish it.”

    If those students were white or the children of the upper class.

  15. are-we-there-yet? Avatar

    David / Prodigal / Caswell; This incident may, arguably, include the sending of subliminal messages to those who have eyes to see. if one juxtaposes the recent rumours of targeted wiretapping here, it may also be a veiled message to those who write on blogs that an iron fist may be concealed in official gloves. Would love to see RR’s and Amused’s lawyerly comments on that aspect.

  16. are-we-there-yet? Avatar

    Prodigal; What about adding Barbados’ undeniable internet porn business to your short list, or has the statute of limitations run out on that one?


  17. @Prodigal Son November 16, 2013 at 9:56 PM “People, you now know what god you are serving!”

    Neither the BLP nor the DLP is God.

    Neither party is scary.

    And if they give orders to shoot people and crack heads don’t they know that we will fight back. We too will shoot some people and crack some heads.

    Don’t they know that we have guns and bullets too? and collins’ and 2 x 3’s ?

    Stupseee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  18. @ Balance
    “….just doesn’t make sense unless the arrest is only a matter of playing to the hypocritical gallery.”

    Just another “dog and pony show”. This country is in serious “DOO DOO” and the Nation, Police and Politicians just mekking sport. As Bush Tea would say just a bunch of Brass Bowls.


  19. “the good news is……”

    And that is precisely the point. The feature highlighted a matter which is a serious matter of social concern. Had it not done so, we would still have been busily closing our eyes to the activities of the young IN SCHOOLS.
    Thus the effect of section 4 – there was a “legitimate reason” to expose the activity – and, as Caswell says, not by means other than a mere visual suggestion.
    BU contributors are not all of one mind on this and, even if granted the narrow definition of child pornography in the post – which is to focus attention on the activity rather than the intention – the fact remains that there was no evidence of an intention to arouse any of us sexually nor to ‘sell’ the picture for commercial advantage, which are the standard yardsticks for determining that an image is pornographic.


  20. @robert ross “the feature highlighted a matter which is a serious matter of social concern. Had it not done so, we would still have been busily closing our eyes to the activities of the young IN SCHOOLS.”

    This is s lie.

    The matter was already being dealt with by the parents, the school and the Ministry of Education, and one or more editors of the Nation knew this well BEFORE they made the decision to publish the article.


  21. And now that the Nation has published the article, what have any of us done to help our young people.

    We are so damn dishonest.

    Before and after the publication of this article most of us do NOTHING to help our young people.


  22. The case will be an interesting one because the Nation newspaper published the redacted image knowing the video was circulating on FB and BlackBerry Messenger. There was therefore the reasonable expectation that the Nation was promoting the distribution of the video, farfetched but reasonable?


  23. Prodigal Son,

    On the DLP “punishing” the Nation.

    Anyone who reads my stuff will know that I have no special interest in party politics. Indeed, as some may know, since I didn’t get the job of ambassador to China I have been thoroughly disenchanted with politics and am prone to skulk around my law office in Belmont Road tinkering with cross word puzzles and formulating grand plans for the resurrection of Nelson Street as the sophisticated ‘hot spot’ it really is.

    But, I am aware that many on here argue that the Nation is a BLP rag. I am fairly sure that if the BLP were in power they would say it was a DLP rag – which, for some, will speak volumes about what I know of politics. Nevertheless – it did occur to me that this prosecution may indeed have entailed a punitive element by a Government intent on deflecting attention from its own inadequacies. So, PS, this is a long-winded way of saying I think you may be right.

    Oh – and lest someone says I have a vested interest in the Nation , as they do of Caswell, let me categorically deny it and refer them to my letter of some months ago on the issue of Sir Hilary Beckles’ article that it was time for Chris Gayle to be rehabilitated. It was not a kind letter and caused the Nation to issue an apology to Beckles, who had clearly consulted his lawyers, for this bold piece (public criticism of the great and not-so-good) written by “one Robert Ross”. Gee.


  24. Ministry and school handling a problem where sex is involved usually mean that they get together and shut it down to protect the good name of the school. Ask them how many instances of teacher and child sexual activity have they dealt with? And then ask: What happened to the teacher involved? Sometimes the perverted teacher might suffer the punishment of a transfer to another school where he starts all over again.

    >


  25. Simple Simon

    “This is a lie”

    You are being absurdly dramatic. But to play the game “dealt with” precisely how and with what effect?


  26. David

    Have you seen the video? I haven’t. But I am told by one who has – a very ordinary and very nice post office counter worker – that the video displayed nothing more than the Nation picture. If this is true, what would be the point of promoting the video?


  27. Caswell

    As with paedophile priests. Yes?


  28. @Ross

    Promoting the video was an unintended consequence of the Nation’s post and yes the video is less than 60 seconds in duration, and the boy’s action can be described as ‘ monkey handling gun’.


  29. David

    Yes, the ‘promotion’ could not have been other than unintended. Moreover, since the picture showed nothing very much I’m not at all clear how it could be categorized as ‘indecent’. If we say it is, then that’s as much a statement about the prurience of our minds as anything else. There would certainly be insufficient to mount a charge of indecent exposure in either of the children.

    Of course, there are some who say that wukking up is indecent, though a dance form derived from west Africa, and I suspect much of the moral posturing is from people who go to bed only with Bibles.


  30. I remember when a very well respected White expat Bajan had the balls to remove a sign at the Gary Sobers roundabout because a concerned citizens group (of which he was part) thought that it was insulting to NOT mention Sobers’ title in the sign. I remember the picture in the paper with all the other Black members of the group standing back with their hands folded. Of course the White dude was dragged before the courts and charged… the problem was that the charge had little to do with what the gentleman could have been found guilty of.

    Tax payers money was wasted on a trial which was based on an invalid premise. It was for all intents and purposes a show trial, designed to give the public the impression that no one is above the law. I am confident that the same thing is happening here again


  31. Isn’t this case now sub judice?


  32. @Hal

    Yes the matter is sub judice but it does not mean we cannot discuss the matter provided we are sensitive to the need to avoid commenting in a way to prejudice proceedings.


  33. The Jamaica Gleaner agrees with you Baffy.

    EDITORIAL – Barbadian Press Blunder Published: Sunday | November 17, 2013 0 Comments We are not in support of the gratuitous publication of pornography by general-interest newspapers and are vehement in our opposition to the sexual, or any other form of, exploitation of children.

    Indeed, our position is common to the press of the English-speaking Caribbean, and in particular to those newspapers with which The Gleaner has fraternal relations. The Nation newspaper in Barbados is among them.

    Last week, The Nation’s publisher Vivian-Anne Gittens; its editor-in-chef, Roy Morris; and its news editor, Sanka Price, were arrested in Bridgetown, supposedly for publishing “an indecent photograph” of two 14-year-olds having sex in a classroom. If they are found guilty, the trio could serve up to five years in jail.

    The journalists were charged under Barbados’ Protection of Children Act which, like its Jamaican counterpart, seeks to prevent physical, social and psychological abuse of minors. While the State is the guarantor of these rights, there is a legal burden on adults to help in the policing of potential exploitation.

    This newspaper endorses such laws. We, however, have serious reservation about the application of the law in relation to The Nation newspaper and its staff.

    Like in Jamaica, there is a growing concern about the state of societal values and attitudes, and especially the behaviour of youth, including schoolchildren. Sexual activity among students is among the issues being debated.

    Genuine Public Interest

    In that context, children having sex in their classrooms or elsewhere on school campuses is a matter of genuine public interest and, therefore, within the purview of a Barbadian newspaper – as would be the case in Jamaica. That The Nation published a photograph of an incident, with the faces of the minors engaged in the sexual act blurred and unrecognisable, does not suggest an act of prurience that would scandalise public morals, or be deemed the exploitation of children.

    While these matters will now be tested in the courts, we are surprised that Barbadian prosecutors would expend energy, public resources and valuable time in pursuing The Nation rather than more immediate and pertinent issues.

    We hope that there are no political undertones to this matter, and that it does not imply an attempt to rein in The Nation’s feisty independence.

    That would be sad and a reversal of that country’s historic tolerance of, and government respect for, free and independent media.

    Indeed, Barbados was among the first countries in this region to craft a new defamation law that lessens the potential threats to a free press going about its job of informing people and holding before citizens a mirror of the society in which they live.

    Prime Minister Freundel Stuart and his Democratic Labour Party should assure the Barbadian people, and by extension Barbados’ Caribbean neighbours, including this newspaper, that there is no threat to press freedom in that country.

    Mr Stuart will, of course, insist that the prosecutors are independent and free to carry out their jobs without direction or interference from the political executive. In that case, we hope that they quickly return to good sense.

    The opinions on this page, except for the above, do not necessarily reflect the views of The Gleaner. To respond to a Gleaner editorial, email us: editor@gleanerjm.com or fax: 922-6223. Responses should be no longer than 400 words. Not all responses will be published.


  34. There may be some issues in the charges:
    1) Are the individuals indentifiable?
    2) Will the government also bring charges against the source material i.e. the media, whether facebook, youtube or wherever, that the nation sourced the material?
    3) Is there a legal defense in that the alleged acts took place in a public place, hence would have been fair to report fully?
    4) Will charges be brought against the school for failure to provide a safe environment for the children, and ensure their safety? Who will bring these, the parents, an international organization? Will the government be included in those charges i.e. as the Ministry of Education is in charge of the schools?

    This case will very likely end up more than just AG vs Nation.

    Likely an international organization may be brought in to assess the security and safety at schools.

    Rightfully so.

    Just wondering as to the legal aspects?

    That said, who is exploiting the children, the Nation, or society i.e. the boy wukking up behind a grown woman at Kadooment was laughed at by people, PUBLISHED IN THE SAME NATION.

    Teaching the nastiness then criticizing the latest publication? of FACT?

    Hypocritical?


  35. @ Caswell Franklyn
    You idiot how can you disassociate the photo from the story that DESCRIBES THE PHOTO ? They must be taken TOGETHER . But I forgot that the Nation has made you one of its celebrated columnists so you find it necessary to sing for your super . You may feel free to do that but you only expose how shallow you are when you do .


  36. David | November 17, 2013 at 12:24 AM |
    The case will be an interesting one because the Nation newspaper published the redacted image knowing the video was circulating on FB and BlackBerry Messenger
    —————–

    Davod,

    So are you saying that the Government will bring charges vs facebook and the messenger providers?


  37. It was right here on BU that I read a post from former Nation News journalist Wade Gibbons about a story he had written and submitted being purged from the system.That story highlighted the twenty million dollars of VAT receipts owed to the government.They met then and determined that such was not newsworthy.This time around $en$ationali$m determined that John public needed to be appraised of these societal shortcomings.My wish is that they are levied a fine of such a substantial proportion that it takes years for them to recover.


  38. Further, is there or is there not something in the facbeook terms of use that stipulate that all images terin belong to facebook?

    Thus, IF SO, does facebook ‘own’ this image” and thus be liable for it?


  39. @Crusoe

    The matter of the little boy wukkin up on the woman was reported to being investigated, maybe there is more to come.

  40. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    I stand guided, but if memory serves me correctly, the CBC, during the evening news, aired some distasteful pornography. This was a short while ago (under seven years). I will suggest that the DPP and RBPF should still be in a position to bring charges which reflect the intent of fairness, consistency, and justice; what do you think BU?.


  41. @Crusoe

    BU is of the view it will be an interesting case to observe.

    In fact a seminal development.


  42. @George

    If memory serves there was ‘ heavy breathing’.

  43. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    @ David

    “Farfetched but reasonable?”

    Perhaps it would be less ambiguous and not at all ludicrous to suggest farfetched but possible. Reasonable hints at a connotation that has as its lowest denominator the concept of average or some sense of normality. I do not believe that is farfetched, now do you?


  44. Point taken George.


  45. @ BU
    Definitely Sanka went too far with his commentary…..But BU David, beware you we may be next……they have already started monitoring blogsphonesemails and we can pick sense from foolishness re ;Jonesing comment.

    As Prodigal aptly puts it …..
    “This is nothing short of blatant pressure from the DLP to punish the Nation for daring to go against this powerful mafia called the DLP.”

    Soon Carson and Ac will be the only ones writing on BU….


  46. @Old Onions

    There are consequences for what we do, we will have deal with it if it happens.


  47. “We hope there are no political undertones….’

    Seems The Gleanor has twigged the Prodigal Son (and RR) concern also.

  48. retribution falling . Avatar
    retribution falling .

    Maybe this charge will serve as a wake up call for SANKA PRICE who represents all that is low and nasty in journalism . He would probably now consider whether he should continue the smut he publishes every week in the Saturday Sun . Sanka Price has turned out to be nothing more than a scum bag .


  49. Maybe this will serve as a wake up call for the Ministry of Education about the crap which happens in our schools. Yes it happened in our day but are we happen with the current state of play?


  50. Sent from Windows Mail

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending