Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

The person who submitted this article has asked that their name be withheld – Barbados Underground

Former Prime Minister Owen Arthur
Former Prime Minister Owen Arthur

There are a number of conscientious Barbadians who take particular pains to ensure that they keep newspaper clippings. One such person made available to me a clipping from the WEEKEND NATION of FRIDAY, JUNE 22, 1990 which represents the recent and ongoing ALEXANDRA SCHOOL saga as nothing more than a reoccurrence of the events which plagued the COLERIDGE  AND PARRY SCHOOL during the Hallam King administration of that school. The difference this time is that former Prime Minister OWEN ARTHUR and his party seem to be presenting a different approach to the problem this time around which may even be regarded as HYPOCRITICAL.

The newspaper report sought to highlight the Board of Management’s refutation of Arthur’s claim that it was “PARTISAN”. This is what the report says:

“The board responded Wednesday in a statement to comments made by Arthur, Barbados Labour Party representative for St Peter, who, on June 12 in the House of Assembly, described the board as a ” partisan one with partisan interests“.

The board’s statement read :

“the board is of the view that the statement seeks to hold up to public ridicule the professionalism of its members and their proven loyalty and dedication to the best interest of the school.”

“The board of management of the Coleridge and Parry school must state unequivocally that its only interests are translated in the efficient functioning of the school, the welfare of staff and pupils and the academic and other achievements of staff and  pupils.”

“the board has worked assiduously with a view to attaining these objectives and frowns upon any charge, implied or otherwise, which seeks to belittle the commitment of its members “, the statement said.”

Of particular interest is that during the sitting of the House , minister of trade Evelyn Greaves, a former CP student, called on MINISTER OF EDUCATION CYRIL WALKER to ESTABLISH A COMMISSION OF ENQUIRY INTO THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE SCHOOL. Greaves said he was concerned over the last TEN YEARS about the CONFLICTS BETWEEN HEADMASTER AND STAFF AND HEADMASTER AND BOARD. (Sounds familiar?)

Also worthy of note was the contribution of St Thomas representative David Simmons who described CP as “SEETHING WITH DISCONTENT IN ITS MANAGEMENT”, pointing out that THE PROBLEM CENTRED AROUND THE EXISTING REGULATIONS GOVERNING SCHOOLS. Simmons said he knew of four secondary schools where serious problems existed between the boards and the head-teachers, ALL AS A RESULT OF THESE REGULATIONS.

This debate is of interest for the following reasons :

  1. Mr Arthur certainly did not think then that the Government had a ready answer to the problem that could have been put in place in the same way that he now suggests that this present Government may use to solve the Alexandra problem in one fell swoop.
  2. Mr Simmons, the lawyer, saw a problem with the REGULATIONS.

Prime Minister Stuart has on this occasion followed the advice then given by Mr Evelyn Greaves by setting up a Commission of Inquiry into the school and in so doing, expressed the intention to have that Commission make recommendations for dealing with such things as those REGULATIONS which the Arthur government refused to touch even though his colleague,  who later became Attorney General saw them as the major problem with the administration in secondary schools. Arthur’s BLP Government had FOURTEEN YEARS to address that problem.

What now must we consider of the suggested approach of Owen Arthur? He has represented that the problem may be solved at the drop of a hat; no consideration must be given to questions such as the LEGALITY OF THE ACTION. Mr Stuart should probably act as he did with the QUEEN ELIZABETH HOSPITAL FOUR ….FIRE THE HEAD.

Thankfully, Stuart has demonstrated that he would rather be guided by the tenets of the RULE OF LAW. Time and circumstances may well prove him right .


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. Agreed David,
    Therefore the “sin” is inaction on the part of those who commissioned the King report. those are the one whose heads should be rolling right now, plain and simple. The action would not have been separation (immediately), but a wise and politically aware union could have easily prosecuted Broomes, Jones, the Ministry and the CPO with an open and shut case, long before reaching the PM’s desk.


  2. @checkit-out

    Let us agree to disagree. There was enough in the report to indicate a hot bed of discord. Couple this with alleged communications sent by Broomes to the MOE, there was enough for a good manager (MOE/CPO) to act.


  3. David;

    I forgot to mention above that to be actionable in the way you suggest, the report should have had significant proof that Mr. Broomes had committed acts that contravened the regulations under the Education Act and his contract that governed the actions of a principal. It had nothing like that in it. It was merely a collection of mainly unsorted and non-statistical anecdotes about Mr. Broomes and even suggested that Mr. Broomes had done a good job in maintaining and even progressing the School’s performance.

    This is no spin. Read the report.

    There is no way it could have been used by an unbiased authority in a law abiding country to separate the man from the school. Again, if it was such, as the PM seemed to have thought initially, he changed his tone when it must have been pointed out to him or he himself realised, that he couldn’t use it in the manner he had intended and had told the nation.

    Don’t you recall that he used the report as his main justification for not following the tenets of natural justice and meeting with Mr. Broomes.


  4. @ Caswell
    You are the one to take a much needed rest ( Bushie recommended that you did from the start remember?)
    That you think the PM should NOT intervene solely on LEGAL grounds speaks to your limitations as an administrator/ manager.

    There are other grounds on which a leader WILL need to get involved in an issue – for example on MORAL grounds; in the NATIONAL INTEREST; as a arbitrator etc.

    Your strength is in focussing on the rules and regulations, but (believe it or not) there are sometimes BIGGER considerations.

    …so back back Frankie


  5. David;
    How do you know if there is a hot bed of discord at most secondary schools in Barbados where the Principal is trying to maintain a tight ship. Can you identify one such where the Principal has no problems with some of the BOM, or some of the Teachers or any of the support staff? That famous phrase in the King Report does not actually condemn Mr. Broomes. Indeed it could be interpreted as suggesting he is a good strong headmaster fighting to maintain standards.

    RE. the alleged letters, Mr. Broomes has one story and the Chief Educ Officer has another. afaik, its still one person’s word against another. There has been no definitive word on who is right on that score. Insofar as the other claims against Mr. Broomes that were highlighted in the report, there have been, imho, a number of defences against them by Caswell and others on this blog. They are disputable and not proven.

    Anyhow, let us agree to disagree.


  6. Just this last one. David, you may be right that there might have been enough for the CPO to have taken the matter forward. But such action would have been immedately met by legal action by Mr. Broomes, which if the CPO’s action were based on the deficient report, would have been almost certain of success..

    The only reasonable action re. the report, was essentially to throw it out (Which the PM has now done without saying so) and collect the necessary purpose designed information through the Commission of Inquiry which the PM has indicated will be done


  7. @Bush
    I am glad that u have educated caswell that there more to rules and regulations. The longer he stays in an argument the more he shows his tail. He has lost the battle on this issue long ago and trying to remain relevant. He continues to undersestimate some of the skills of some of he bloggers knowledge of administrative law. I say no more on this. I admire your resolve to show him he cant bully anyone into submission. Dont u see he cant handle me so he reagards me as stupid and that is when i am at my most dangerous level to show up his ignorance.

    @Check
    Nice response to David. Your response answered the question he posed to me, You see sometimes we can agree, and sometimes we can disagree. R U a lawyer? LOL


  8. Blogger;

    Of course we will disagree on occasion. I tend, perhaps wrongly, to look at things from a somewhat moralistic standpoint that is oftimes not in tune with current thinking.

    I realise that question (are you a lawyer?) was tongue in cheek, covering many angles, but I am just an old Civil Servant dinosaur who, I think, worked with you many years ago and was impressed with your ability, drive and forward thinking, in terms of preparing for the future re. advancing your education, building a home for investment purposes, etc. The door incident was at that time and was probably merely an example of thinking outside the box to solve a problem using the available materials. But of course the PS intervened to solve the problem in a different manner. But Blogger, I might have misidentified you,and if so I will apologize and retreat.


  9. “There are a number of conscientious Barbadians who take particular pains to ensure that they keep newspaper clippings. One such person made available to me a clipping from the WEEKEND NATION of FRIDAY, JUNE 22, 1990 which represents the recent and ongoing ALEXANDRA SCHOOL saga as nothing more than a reoccurrence of the events which plagued the COLERIDGE AND PARRY SCHOOL during the Hallam King administration of that school. The difference this time is that former Prime Minister OWEN ARTHUR and his party seem to be presenting a different approach to the problem this time around which may even be regarded as HYPOCRITICAL.
    I have a newspaper clipping as with the headline -EX-MP RAPS PM’S PROJECT.STUART LABELS SOCIAL PARTNERSHIP AS A “PHILOSOPHICAL ABSURDITY.’
    Former parliamentarian Freundel Stuart has charged that the first Prices and Incomes, Protocol of the 1990s was designed to apease the owners of capital at a time when there was a flight of capital out of the country. In addressing a meeting of Young Democrats at party Headquarters Stuart said;” The object of capital and the object of labour are completely contradictory. owners of capital see labour as a cost and will try to keep that cost down as best they can. If owners of capital are trying to keep the cost down, they will either pay very low wages or or employ very few people.Persons in that inseure situation cannot work in partnership with the owners of capital.It does not have the sanction of history behind it.
    just providing alittle balance but politicians on both sides of the divide will continue to get away with such statements because we fail to hold them accountable because of party affiliation.


  10. Balance; Notwithstanding that I consider this discussion is headed by an essay that is a good example of pure spinning and that I agree with what you appear to be saying; i.e that one should take with a grain of salt, the statements of those who might have had one view several years ago and have now changed that view, especially when they were not in power at the time they expressed these contrary views. I think that FS’s views re. the early 1990’s were probably spot on as exemplified by the current industrial relations climate.

    I wonder if FS is subliminally trying to prove the points he made above?


  11. checkitout the irony of the situation is that mr stuart praised the work of the social partnership in an address to the BCCI about two months ago . Therin lies the hypocrisy.


  12. Balance; Prime Ministers are apparently forced, by circumstances, to do such things. Stretching the truth and hypocrisy are par for the course.


  13. @CHECK

    i AM A RETIRED RELIC SO DONT TRY TO IDENTIFY ME, BECAUSE WE DONT KNOW EACH OTHER. I GIVE MISLEADING INFORMATION AT TIMES ABOUT MY IDENTITY.


  14. OK Blogger2012. I stand corrected. Mistaken identity for sure. The person who I thought you were could not have retired yet. But then you said you sometimes give misleading info about your identity.

    Hmmmm….


  15. @Balance

    Dont understand ploticians say things to appease the audience. People say positive about you in front your face and on paper, but that phone call which you wont know about is the killer. This society is riddled with hypocrite.


  16. Balance; Totally agree with Blogger 2012. Politicians as a genus behave exactly as he’s said above. I have numerous examples of such behaviour.


  17. @ Balance
    As for the MG comment it is all about interpretation. and the other whatever he mentioned in New York could have been generalise however for you and Caswell to infer that the PM knoweldge of the Constituiton the foundation on which our country of laws stand is farfetched and should be as PM STUART would say “punishable by laughter”


  18. @check

    now onions ask if i am verla depeiza. This getting interesting.


  19. ac no wonder Mr Stuart is now hoisted on his own petard having the unenviable reputation of punishment by laughter on a daily basis even by DLP supporters.Trust you to pathetically try to extract fiction from fact. i have never heard about Mr Stuart as a reconized Attorney-at-law. One of the dire drawbacks of our system of governance is that unsuitable persons can be trust into powerful administrative positions without the necessary, knowledge, skills or training that the position demands. Mr Stuart clearly up to now has proven to be one such person and Sir Brandford is on record as saying that some of the persons holding Ministerial positions are not deserving of the posts. The difficulty confronting this country as elections draw nigh is that the talent in the opposition leaves much to be desired as well. God save the Queen.

  20. An Observer.. Avatar
    An Observer..

    @ David : re PM Stuart .
    “Appeal Judge Frederick Waterman is to be the sole commissioner . Frederick Waterman sticks across Owen Arthur’s throat like a fish bone ” . What beautiful imagery . would you say that PM Stuart intends to see Mr Arthur choked over the Alexandra affair ? Peace as usual .


  21. Observer; I was also struck by that section of the report and the imagery. Reading between the lines with a magnifying glass it struck me that Stuart’s imagery and words could be construed as implying that he had a very good idea of the ultimate decision that the Commissioner would be coming up with since he felt it would stick in Arthur’s craw. Surely not a good position to put your sole Commissioner in, even if by implication only.


  22. An Observer

    Like checkit-out the statement by the PM did not go unnoticed. It reminded BU of the statement by the PM at his recent AX press conference when he suggested he had forgotten Waterman’s role on the Bench in the QEH matter Political chicanery perhaps? …lol.


  23. David; It appears that the PM often stretches the literal truth for literary effect and verbal imagery.

  24. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    I am still not clear what government is hoping to achieve with the establishment of a commission of inquiry. Everyone knows the genesis of the problems. To my mind, all that would be achieve is that some persons would be embarrassed and for the duration the public would be in for some entertainment.

    The Commission of Inquiry Act states at section 13 (2) :

    No evidence given by a witness to an investigatory commission may be used against him in any subsequent trial or in any criminal or civil proceedings other than a prosecution for perjury in giving that evidence.

    It seems to me that all a person has to do is: go before the inquiry; tell the truth; admit to all manner of wrongdoing; and there would be nothing that they could do to punish him for any wrongdoing. That might seem a bit simplistic and I might even be incorrect in my understanding. I would be grateful for any clarification.

    If I am correct, it would make me wonder if that was not the intent of those who advised the Prime Minister to establish the inquiry in the first place rather than let the constitutionally appointed body, the Public Service Commission, to do its duty. Again if my understanding is correct, the Public Service Commission would be precluded from taking any disciplinary action against anyone who went before the inquiry and admit to wrongdoing in his evidence.


  25. @CAswell
    “I am still not clear what government is hoping to achieve with the establishment of a commission of inquiry. ”

    Delay and diversion.

    Mission accomplished.


  26. Observer; No truer words have been spoken on this issue.

  27. An Observer.. Avatar
    An Observer..

    @ checkit – out .
    You will have to examine when the statement was made .. Mr Arthur stated his view of the Commission in very strident terms AFTER it was announced who is to be the Commissioner ; certainly Mr Stuart is entitled to comment on that view which suggests that the Commission will be a waste of time . Is that not reasonable ? peace as usual .


  28. […] Alexandra 2012 The Reincarnation Of Coleridge And Parry 1990 […]

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending