Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

The person who submitted this article has asked that their name be withheld – Barbados Underground

Former Prime Minister Owen Arthur
Former Prime Minister Owen Arthur

There are a number of conscientious Barbadians who take particular pains to ensure that they keep newspaper clippings. One such person made available to me a clipping from the WEEKEND NATION of FRIDAY, JUNE 22, 1990 which represents the recent and ongoing ALEXANDRA SCHOOL saga as nothing more than a reoccurrence of the events which plagued the COLERIDGE  AND PARRY SCHOOL during the Hallam King administration of that school. The difference this time is that former Prime Minister OWEN ARTHUR and his party seem to be presenting a different approach to the problem this time around which may even be regarded as HYPOCRITICAL.

The newspaper report sought to highlight the Board of Management’s refutation of Arthur’s claim that it was “PARTISAN”. This is what the report says:

“The board responded Wednesday in a statement to comments made by Arthur, Barbados Labour Party representative for St Peter, who, on June 12 in the House of Assembly, described the board as a ” partisan one with partisan interests“.

The board’s statement read :

“the board is of the view that the statement seeks to hold up to public ridicule the professionalism of its members and their proven loyalty and dedication to the best interest of the school.”

“The board of management of the Coleridge and Parry school must state unequivocally that its only interests are translated in the efficient functioning of the school, the welfare of staff and pupils and the academic and other achievements of staff and  pupils.”

“the board has worked assiduously with a view to attaining these objectives and frowns upon any charge, implied or otherwise, which seeks to belittle the commitment of its members “, the statement said.”

Of particular interest is that during the sitting of the House , minister of trade Evelyn Greaves, a former CP student, called on MINISTER OF EDUCATION CYRIL WALKER to ESTABLISH A COMMISSION OF ENQUIRY INTO THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE SCHOOL. Greaves said he was concerned over the last TEN YEARS about the CONFLICTS BETWEEN HEADMASTER AND STAFF AND HEADMASTER AND BOARD. (Sounds familiar?)

Also worthy of note was the contribution of St Thomas representative David Simmons who described CP as “SEETHING WITH DISCONTENT IN ITS MANAGEMENT”, pointing out that THE PROBLEM CENTRED AROUND THE EXISTING REGULATIONS GOVERNING SCHOOLS. Simmons said he knew of four secondary schools where serious problems existed between the boards and the head-teachers, ALL AS A RESULT OF THESE REGULATIONS.

This debate is of interest for the following reasons :

  1. Mr Arthur certainly did not think then that the Government had a ready answer to the problem that could have been put in place in the same way that he now suggests that this present Government may use to solve the Alexandra problem in one fell swoop.
  2. Mr Simmons, the lawyer, saw a problem with the REGULATIONS.

Prime Minister Stuart has on this occasion followed the advice then given by Mr Evelyn Greaves by setting up a Commission of Inquiry into the school and in so doing, expressed the intention to have that Commission make recommendations for dealing with such things as those REGULATIONS which the Arthur government refused to touch even though his colleague,  who later became Attorney General saw them as the major problem with the administration in secondary schools. Arthur’s BLP Government had FOURTEEN YEARS to address that problem.

What now must we consider of the suggested approach of Owen Arthur? He has represented that the problem may be solved at the drop of a hat; no consideration must be given to questions such as the LEGALITY OF THE ACTION. Mr Stuart should probably act as he did with the QUEEN ELIZABETH HOSPITAL FOUR ….FIRE THE HEAD.

Thankfully, Stuart has demonstrated that he would rather be guided by the tenets of the RULE OF LAW. Time and circumstances may well prove him right .


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. Stuart should then have appointed a commission from the start ( if he was an astute leader). His procrastination with “phases” was an example of ineptitude.


  2. Actually, Stuart’s appointment of the commission was a realization that he could not provide a solution that he had originally contemplated- the removal of Broomes. His legal gura probably advised him, after much dithering, that this was probably the best “solution “


  3. The commission is a good ideal and certainly will vindicate either Mr Broome or the striking teachers, however, the approach was quite wrong. In the P.M’s first public address on the matter, without actually saying it, he was bias towards the teachers and ready to give Mr Broome the BOOT. Maybe this was the reason the teachers were so upset, I too expected Mr Broome to have been removed by the end of april at the latest. The P.M erred, as usual, in speaking without thinking. No wonder he speaks so little.


  4. AS the article so rightfully points out the AX boat was sinking for 14 years and OSA did nothing about it. NOW all that OSA is doing is trying to score political points by criticising PM STUART approach and using political gymnastic to do so. OSA all HOT air !
    PM Stuart first and rightfully used all other avenues in dealing with the AX to resolved the AX problem with having to use the Commission as last resort. PRAY tell me what did OSA did in all the years he had expect to march time and hope the problem would disappeared/

  5. St George's Dragon Avatar
    St George’s Dragon

    So it took 12 weeks to get the advice that Broomes could not be removed?
    It looks as though Fumble Through-it, reputedly an astute man and a lawyer, went into a meeting with the BSTU without knowing that Broomes could not be dismissed. That points towards a failure either by Fumble or the Education Ministry staff.
    There is nothing wrong with an enquiry, but the time for an enquiry was when Fumble met the BSTU the first time.

  6. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Thankfully, Stuart has demonstrated that he would rather be guided by the tenets of the RULE OF LAW. Time and circumstances may well prove him right .

    David

    Where did you get that from. If Mr. Stuart would rather be guided by the tenets of the RULE OF LAW, he would have stayed out of the process and respect the highest law of the land – the CONSTITUTION.

    The Constitution puts the responsibility for the Public Service firmly in the hands of the Governor-General, acting in accordance with the advice of the Public Service Commission. When Mr. Stuart or any other politician disrespects the Constitution they should not be praised. Suppose the Public Service Commission does not accept the recommendations of the commission of inquiry: What would happen next?

    The teachers were deceived pure and simple. I just don’t accept that Mr. Stuart could have come to the conclusion that he did after legal advice.


  7. OH! OH! a DRAGON on the ATTACKI! Why don’t you asked some of the same question to the “little short man” de one who say he running for PM when in de past he run away from the hard issues!

  8. Random Thoughts Avatar
    Random Thoughts

    Look the truth is that in Barbados we do not value MERIT.

    We are too fond of getting position/power/money based on who we know rather than on what we know and how competent we are.

    If we would only let MERIT rule, that Barbados would be a 100 times better place.

    We Bajans have EXACTLY the society that we deserve.


  9. @Random Thoughts
    One minor correction…..Barbados would be a 1000 times better place… Otherwise a spot on assessment of our root problem.


  10. we flogging a dead horse here with this one. Good attempt at regaining points for Stuart though… The next elections have already been framed…Just a matter of who will play the hand they have best. i’ll wait the “formation” of the Commission followed by its “recommendation” and then the follow up “action”

    Time will tell

  11. St George's Dragon Avatar
    St George’s Dragon

    @ ac
    My post was about the PM and his preparation – or lack of it – for his meeting with the BSTU. I don’t believe Owen Arthur met the BSTU and “settled” the dispute. If he had, and it had gone wrong, I would have been as critical of him.


  12. Nice spinning! Interesting parallels, the most important one being the recommendation to use a Commission of Enquiry as a solution in the CP case and its clear rejection by a wiser Government and their choosing to use a better strategy to solve the problem, as contrasted with the actual use of a Commission of Enquiry and its acceptance by a PM and cabinet with a different level of wisdom in the current AX case.


  13. The post suggests that it was a DLP administration that met and fairly expeditiously solved the CP problem. Wasn’t it? If so how much importance should we pay to the mouthings of opposition politicians in a situation like this?

  14. Random Thoughts Avatar
    Random Thoughts

    Did the current principal of the Alexandra School get the job on merit?

    Did the then principal of the Coleridge and Parry School get his position on MERIT?

    Were the jobs advertised?

    Were all applications reviewed for MERIT?

    Who applied?

    Were the decision -making processes documented?

    Can we who pay for the whole thing see the documents?

    Did any politician, Cabinet Minister, Prime Minister interfere in the process?

    If so who interfered?


  15. I forgot to add above that I agree totally with Caswell’s statement above.

    The teachers were deceived pure and simple.

    Except that I might want to extend it slightly. I think they were deceived not once but twice. I wonder if anyone is building up a dossier of unfulfilled promises.


  16. Ok, now that you Dems and the author of this piece have the solution to the problem, fix it and let’s move on.

    I am so sick and tired of you Dems moping around………. Owen Arthur was PM for 14 years and did not fix this or that. You have had the government for 4 years, there is a problem, darn well fix it, cause God knows that “wunnah” have nothing else to show for the four years!


  17. Why wait so long to set up the Inquiry?

    You are the government and the buck stops with you.

    The insight that the last government recognized there was a systemic issue is also instructive i.e we have had a crisis of leadership for a long time.


  18. “Time and circumstances may well prove him right .”
    time and circumstances do prove most things right if the right circumstances prevail and wrong if the wrong circumstances prevail.it is therefore the circumstances and not wisdom or folly that can claim the credit/discredit for the otcomes right or wrong. Mr Stuart was drawn into a dispute between the the barbados secondary teachers union and the principal and teachers at the alexandra school largely because of the tardiness/inaction of the chief personnel officer and the other relevant authorities to respond in timely fashion to the teachers concerns of longstanding.Mr Stuart in his wisdom met with the union since the there was no dispute between the principal and his employer the government. The teachers went back to work on the premise that Mr start would be assiduosly to bring reolution to the problemstep by step or in his words in ‘phases’. Lo and behold, to the consterbnation of the entire country except perhaps the most ardent DLP supporters, Mr Stuart announced after after a three month hiatus that he had passed through theses phases and proceeded to dump the unresolved matter in the hands of a commission and one seeks to give him credit for that dithering decision. give me a break man.


  19. “Stuart should then have appointed a commission from the start ( if he was an astute leader). His procrastination with “phases” was an example of ineptitude.”
    EXACTLY


  20. @writer of this blog. Excellent. I really enjoyed reading it. I make no political comment, and confine myself simply to my enjoyment of a beautifully written piece of work.


  21. I find it rather difficult to understand caswell. He was giving the impression during the discourse on the AX that the pm was right to intervene and could have produced result, forgetting due process must prevail. We must recognize that we have access to the CCJ and can get a fast judgement.

    By the way David, Hallan King and his entire family are supporters of the BLP and that is why all the politcal grandstanding by owen at the time. DAVID CAN u ask anyone to supply information on when Mr. King accepted the transfer to the special assigment position in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs .

    Politicians say and do things for politcal expediency both DLP and BLP. I am losing faith in the politcal process


  22. @Blogger2012

    It was in the mid 90s wasn’t it? Around 95 or 96?

    In the PM’s press conference he spoke to naughty clauses in the education act which seems to have made the management of the teaching profession somewhat challenging over the years. If this Commission of Inquiry is able to make pertinent recommendations all the power to it. One would have to suspect that in the Waterman’s terms of reference there will be specific gaps he is instructed to look it. Time is not on the governments side.

    It does not explain however why the idea of a commission should have taked almost 4 months.


  23. all the political grandstanding would continue as the process move forwards we are in the sunrise of an upcoming election and time is on nobodys side.as for the BLP stalwarts nothing the PM does would ever be right . that is the beast that lives within.


  24. @ac

    This is true but there is the political war to be won.

  25. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Blogger2012

    You seem to be fixated with me. I never said Stuart was right to intervene. I said that he intervened because all the persons who were supposed to deal with the matter failed or neglected to do their duty. At which point he felt justified in doing what he did. I understood but never agreed with his actions.


  26. Like blogger 2812 i am confused on Caswell position . given the sensitive nature at that time with the teachers on strike the PM did make the right decision of fore most getting the teachers back to work setting up a commision at that time would not have given immediate reolution on the ongoing strike.the PM actions did prevent further disater.


  27. AC; Does the manner in which the PM achieved the initial objective of getting the teachers back to school suggest trickery or statesmanship by the PM, given that he took an obliquely different approach in the April resolution?

  28. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    ac

    I don’t know what you are confused about. It would appear that all I try I am not making myself clear. I will attempt to do so again.

    1. Barbados is a country that is supposed to respect the rule of law.
    2. The highest law of the land is the Constitution.
    3. The Constitution has set up a mechanism for dealing with the Public Service: it is called the Public Service Commission which is supposed to be apolitical. As a matter of fact it is an offence for public officers to be involved in party politics.

    Rather than try to deal with the Alexandra problem when approached by the BSTU, Mr. Stuart should have told them it is not my duty to deal with these matters and referred them to the Public Service Commission. That is where he started wrong.

    Lest you are in doubt about my position on Stuart himself, let me reiterate. I do not oppose him for political reasons. That said however, I reserve my right to call things as I see them. At this juncture, there is a severe paucity of quality leadership available to our country. I still think that as bad a leader as people are saying, Stuart is still the better than all the current pretenders to leadership of Barbados, both within and outside of his party. He leads by the consent o those that he leads and with that in mind, he is most likely walking a tight rope with those wild boys that he leads just waiting in the wings.


  29. @Caswell

    To be clear you would have recommended similar action in the Hallam King matter?

  30. Adrian Hinds Avatar

    Fat cat public sector working class bajans conspire with their union to fire/seperate another working class bajan, disadvantaging others by their selfish action. Hard press private sector working class bajans can get fired with impunity and their Union seem not to be able to defend them. Do we need more private sector trade union action and less from the public sector ones?

  31. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    I want to be very clear: politicians have no role in handling disputes in the Public Service. However, I do not know when Hallam King was appointed as Principal and could have been in a similar position to Smith at the Lodge School. If King were a public officer, I would have recommended similar action.


  32. @check it out.no i do not at all detect any mischief on PM part in getting the teachers back to work there were goals and objectives to be met and the PM accomplished both it was therfore up to the union to say ya. or nay to return no onewas holding a gun to there faces. One of the objectives being the childrens education and that was the driving force which propele them to return as it is now with the last strke out. .


  33. @caswell does not thePM has legislative power to ovride legalisation when there seriouiness or potential danger which tbe BSTU actions might have caused by the STRIKE therefore by passing the PSC because the matter was seen as URGENT not forgetting that strike actionhad already spread to other schools in support of the AX teachers


  34. @ac
    would the PM as a lawyer and former attorney-general know in January that Broome could not be removed based on emotional utterances and ultimatums?

  35. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Ac

    The Prime Minister has no such power. He was appointed PM not king: he must function within the law. If he wanted the powers that you are suggesting that he has he would have to use his majority in Parliament to achieve such by amending the Constitution. The only other route for him to exercise the powers that you suggest would be for him to persuade the Governor-General to declare a state of emergency.

    David

    By the way, thanks for teaching me how to change the language on the iPad. I am getting there.


  36. @ Caswell
    ‘Where did you get that from. If Mr. Stuart would rather be guided by the tenets of the RULE OF LAW, he would have stayed out of the process and respect the highest law of the land – the CONSTITUTION.’

    If the BSTU refused to meet with the organ governed by MOE close friend of Broomes – the BSTU President being fully aware and cognizant of this fact – should the PM have sent them back to the ministry expecting full, thorough investigation and timely response.

    The PM took the best action irrespective of what his critics think and alarm in private or public.

    It is clear the MOE Jones’ involvement is a conflict of interest. Furthermore Jones acknowledged a report but never acted on recommendations.

    We are people who condemn abuse would you return to the Head that publicly or privately abuse you. I agree with BSTU not to return to Jones for any further discussion for he created distrust and agitated and provoked frustration by not following-up on the report.

    And I agree with the PM to follow the ‘rule of law’ AND, AND to all and sundry I RESPECT YOUR VIEWS.


  37. It is obvious the PM took a sympathetic view to the BSTU in January when he met with them and gave reason for hope that he would have resolved the issue. They demonstrated confidence in such an outcome by returning to the classroom.

    In hindsight Stuart over promised and had to propose a change of plans at the last meeting. The BSTU was disappointed but BU always knew the teachers had to return to work. As observing has always commented the PR of the BSTU was poor and its IR strategy lacked coherence based on what was put in the public domain.

    It is clear the recommendations from the Waterman report (outcome from Inquiry) to be complete by Christmas term is meant to address some holes in the Act i.e teachers and principals appointed to specific schools, role of school boards etc.

    This blog exposes that the Arthur government et al recognized deep rooted problems which had to be dealt with 15 years ago. To Stuart’s credit he seems to be taking the high road but why did he have to wait so long? Why couldn’t the CPO have intervened facilitated by the MOEHR to send Broomes on leave with pay to allow for calm atmosphere at the school? It is easier than transferring 30 teachers.

  38. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Brief

    I agree with you when you say that the BSTU was right to refuse to meet with Ronald Jones but for different reasons. Like the PM, Minister Jones has no authority to deal with complaints about public officers. The Public Service Commission is a constitutionally appointed body that is supposed to be independent of the political class. It is their job to deal with any complaints against Broomes and if he were to be separated it would have been their decision and theirs alone. They are not subject to the control of the Prime Minister or anyone else. When the Government changes they stay in place: they are not supposed to be political. unfortunately, since they only meet once a week they depend on the Personnel Admininstration Division to do the ground work and have been deceived into making the wrong decision. However, anyone that is dismissed has a constitutional right to appeal to the Privy Council who can overturn the decision.

  39. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    Being appointed to a particular school is a thing of the past. Don’t allow yourself to be misled. Each permanent post in the Public Service and the Teaching Service is as they say established. There is no post on the establishment of Principal of Alexandra School. There are a number of established post of Principal of secondary school equal to the number secondary schools. you cannot be appointed to a post that does not exist. Since the Governing Bodies of the older secondary schools were abolished no one could properly be appointed to a specific school. You are appointed Principal and assigned to a secondary school: that assignment can change. if Mr. Broomes had a letter appointing him to Alexandra School, he could not rely on that since he knew or ought to have known that such an appointment would have been illegal. After all he purports to be a leading trade unionist.


  40. @Caswell

    To be clear then are you saying the PM’s reference to naughty clauses in the Education Act you don’t agree? If they are such clauses do you not agree an inquiry is the best mechanism to identify and recommend?


  41. @ David
    “….it is easier than transferring 30 teachers”

    You just disappointed the bushman David.

    Are you advocating that the PM should have taken the easy route to resolve the matter? …in that case it would have been even easier to bribe Broomes with an offer he could not refuse…. A la Onion’s position.

    HOW ABOUT THE FAIR AND JUST ROUTE? HOW ABOUT THE LEGAL and LAWFUL route?

    Perhaps by not jumping to premature and partisan conclusions as advocated by persons with conflicting interest like Caswell, (after his now customary initial delay), the PM will be justified by hind sight to have made the correct decision in seeking to DO THAT WHICH IS FAIR AND JUST.


  42. As long as the ” inflexible -ignorant and hating men” females have positions in this country and have any say, there will be stress and problems at workplaces. Small issues will become large mountains of folly powered by oestrogen and hormonal fluctuations and imbalances because they take everything personal…….

    If women are not controlled in this country, it is woe–unto man . Woman is man’s natural enemy and the Barbadian woman has exemplified this realism to a finer degree than most other Caribbean women who are trained to support their men e;g -St Lucian women; Guyanese women and Martinquan women.

    I love women but I dont like the shyte they do
    I find that here are unnecessarily hard and straight lined and know very little about certains things about life

    This is not an attack on women. This is an attempt to bring foolish men to their senses. Women have a role to play but when roles get twisted like knickers, problems result. There is a reason why women were not allowed to lead. The old men understood them and kept them far from certain things. Now everywhere you look women are trying to ‘muscle in’ on a man’s domain. It is all good ! but trust me , ‘women will mess up everything –Keep them out of certain positions and certain activities. Let them play the roles that they should play but not certain things.

    This is not an attack on women but :
    Why should a teacher refuse to teach a class because her husband might have not stayed at home a particular night ??

    Anybody viewing the AX situation will wonder why there is so much huff and puff coming from those women and really you cannot put your finger on anything
    Answer: The nature of women: They feel they must get their way and that somebody owe them something. They must have -The Last Word !

    I must add Larry Mayers to the list who must speak out against unfairness from women
    Along with Boyce , Nelson , Ellis and Johnson, Larry will add weight to the call to make women know their place.

    BRING IT ON–I AM READY
    NO BARBECUE PIG-TAIL MENTALITY.
    Yuh dealing with –So watch it


  43. @Bush Tea

    The view is based on putting the children first.

    It is about placating the learning environment based on current state.

    It is about being pragmatic.

    It is about the CPO using the King report to remove Broomes from the environment until the Commissioner’s work is done. There is enough in the King report to lay some blame with Broomes.

    It is not unusual in a IR matter to remove the parties from the work environment. It is not practical to suspend 30 teachers hence asking Broomes to go on leave with pay and without prejudice.

    We have to think of the children for godsakes.


  44. David! David!
    The important lesson that the children need to learn is that ours is a just and FAIR society. If you think that by possibly unfairing Broomes because he is an easier target sends the correct message to the children then you are sadly mistaken. You may be shocked at their perspective of the matter….

    There are many complex problems in our lives, and the expediency of taking the easy way out is usually just plain WRONG.

    CASE IN POINT… One easy way to get rid of Porter would be to ban him ( like BFPwould do)… Because it ie their blog and that would ‘solve’ the problem that you are bout to have with Islandgal, ac, and Random Thoughts.

    ….but is the the RIGHT thing to do…?
    …and will you ban him? 🙂


  45. @ observing

    Your comment is speculative on Broomes removal as a bargaining chip for the teachers returned .it was never stated by the BSTU nor the PM so far all we have witnessed is that the teachers had returned in Jan.an no statement or record to support your theory so far.


  46. @Bush Tea

    But removing Broomes supported by the King Report for a period without loss of earnings or benefits. It wouldn’t be a solution but a means to determine the solution. If the MOE could remove the 30 teachers in a way that would be painless the same could be done with them. It is about creating the opportunity to solve the problem.

  47. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    Boomes & Co….take a back burner…ENTER…LIME….these people are not making no sport. But I thought Sir Roy had said some 2 weeks ago it was settled…and Stuart would tell it all that weekend in a Press conference …what happen since then?
    Now ac if they had good sense and call the frigging elections….would they be having these problems. NO..You feel more coming ? ..Girl you all have a poor adviser…who tell the Boss to “hold on till the last tether”..?
    The longer..seems worst-er…leggo

  48. Prodigal Son Avatar

    Caswell,

    You really need to stop saying that Freundel is the best leader we have around right now. My lord, if he is the best Barbados has on offer, no wonder we are up shit street with an express train coming at break neck speed! Freundel was never a leader and will never be a good PM.Was he even a good lawyer?

    Every time I see him, I see Sandie and that brings back all the bad memories. Freundel is not a leader, he met lady luck and the rest is history. If by some strange fate, the DLP is returned to power, I cannot see the wild boys in that party voting for him to be their leader again. Hell no!

  49. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @BU.David: “But removing Broomes supported by the King Report for a period without loss of earnings or benefits. It wouldn’t be a solution but a means to determine the solution. If the MOE could remove the 30 teachers in a way that would be painless the same could be done with them. It is about creating the opportunity to solve the problem.

    Indeed.

    There is clearly tension there. We don’t know what it is.

    But if the “man” (read: Broomes) would simply temporarily exit the equation (with full pay and benefits, of course), then perhaps we can deal with the other problems which are obvious, but which have not been brought forward…

    Hmmmm?


  50. @Caswell

    Isn’t Broomes close to retirement?

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending