Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by Cat Eyes

.

Clorinda Alleyne, CEO, Public Workers’ Co-operative Credit Union Limited
  1. How is it that the CEO of this credit union makes almost $20,000 per month, inclusive of allowances. More than the Prime Minister of this country?  More than what some executives of private sector banks and insurance companies earn; more than some executives who have to perform and are appraised on performance. She also receives leave passage – the type that longstanding civil servants receive- holiday with passage paid for by the members. They have smartly sat down and crafted an exceptional salaries and benefits package for Alleyne who adds no value to the institution if you were to review her performance. Her salary is almost 6 thousand dollars more than her deputy the Legal Counsel. Those gaps in salary ranges are highly unusual. The CEO of the PW credit union has no financial qualifications, save for the credit union courses, and was a less than stellar attorney before joining the organisation as its Legal Counsel, yet through the machinations of Paul, and certainly not on ability or skill she is the head of this organisation.
  2. The CEO has a chauffeur who is paid out of the organisation’s coffers. The reasoning was that she was suffering from dizziness so she could  not drive. For five years or more this has been occurring. It was suggested that the driver, who is a messenger at the credit union, be paid the overtime for chauffeuring her, out of her salary. He also picked up her children from schools that are within walking distance of the credit union..
  3. For over three years Paul Maxwell, who was laid off from Cable and Wireless and worked nowhere, spent most of his time at the organisation and drove to and from the Credit Union in the car assigned to Alleyne, while she was driven around in another vehicle. The organisation’s car was in the possession of a non-executive director for over a year – being serviced etc. with members’ money – and nothing was done about it.
  4. When Caswell’s trip was cancelled, we the members lost approximately $10 thousand dollars in non-refundable expenses which were paid. His trip was cancelled out of spite, and we all know who was behind it. They have absolutely no regard for how our money is spent, as long as their end is achieved. So ” … cancel his trip, who the hell cares if the members’ money is pitched into Maxwell Pond as long as he does not go anywhere we are happy.”
  5. For the past decade some very bright and independent minds have left the institution because of the actions of the “musical chairs” Board. The management  staff complement then becomes a compliant, mentally sterile, ethically devoid group of trip hunters who take the lavish salaries, the healthy profit sharing and say “yes sir, yes sir, three bags full” and grin all the way to the salary counter. Petrified to object to anything.

My recommendation is that the whole Board face a no-confidence motion. Also, people like Cedric Murrell, who have proven to be major disappointments in the manner in which they have condoned this behaviour as members of the Supervisory Committee, should be permanently off.

The function of the Registrar of Cooperatives has functioned in this case just as the Supervisor of Insurance functioned with CLICO. THEY DID NOT FUNCTION!!! Couple their inaction with a complacent, greedy membership which seems to have no concept of what a credit union should be and no comprehension of their responsibility as members, and we have problems.

In moving forward, members would have to petition/agitate for Paul Maxwell to be forbidden to serve on any decision-making entities related to the credit union. They are currently making plans to establish a new company that will be providing services to smaller credit unions, and another unemployed clique member, Dean St. Hill, is tipped to head that company. Paperwork is with the Registrar. Members need to put their foot down.

It is unfortunate that this matter had to be aired here. But that is what happens when people feel they have no voice in the forum that should listen and act. I certainly hope it does not undermine public confidence in the institution, which by and large is a great one. But this development is a result of a lapse in the vigilance we all knew used to be the hallmark of successful credit unions.

Get to the AGM, demand answers- do not allow Paul and company to use by laws to block discussion (and threats of legal action from the bully Alleyne). Organise, and do like them and get a lawyer to go with the group if you can. And when you get your answers, petition, move motions, do whatever you can to bring the freewheeling by that group to an end. Take back your credit union.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

329 responses to “Barbados Public Workers Cooperative Credit Union Members Urged To Take Back Their Credit Union From The Few Who Have Hijacked It”


  1. @DisiClean

    We are talking about the risk mitigating policy/system a small credit union would have to implement to manage those risks not the manager.


  2. David
    Is the Broad Street building the same one that Caswell spoke about?


  3. @Clone

    Yes!


  4. David,
    I am still lost but forced to concede after that one.
    Nice switcheroo. 🙂


  5. @Bush Tea-nice! @Brutus, the PEARLS standards only make reference to specific performance indicators. The operational issues were raised at the Board level. The members of the Supervisory Committee who raised them were canvassed against and systematically taken off. As said earlier one was put out of the organisation after it was alleged that the individual was responsible for making the credit card information public, an allegation that should have been challenged.
    The credit card information came to the floor at the 2008 AGM. The accusations were denied. Alleyne then shut down further discussion with threats of legal action, and unfortunately nobody pursued the matter. Pursuant to that intervention the Registrar requested limits be placed on the cards etc (as was mentioned earlier). It has never been done.
    The examples given over the past couple of days are but a tip of the iceberg of all the actions that mitigate against good corporate governance.
    The fact that we do not receive patronage refund and the implementation of rules to limit dividends indicates that the minds that would sit down and orchestrate outrageous salary packages, perks and positions are the same minds that would seek to ensure that there is enough money to play with that you do not miss it.
    The organisation will only continue to be strong if we the members remember that we must continue to be vigilant.


  6. As far as the debate re the salary of the CEO is concerned: The current ceo was never offered that salary! She, Paul and the BOD set it. You all obviously do not get the picture yet.
    The lady came in as the Legal Counsel. She is currently the CEO and there is now a six grand gap between her salary and the second in command. The salary of the second in command is in keeping with the correct salary ranges for executive management of the institution.
    HR 101 dictates that the salary you receive in an organisation depends on the work you do, your qualifications and what the company can pay.
    In this instance you have a lawyer at the helm of a financial institution who cannot interpret balance sheets, or comprehend any spreadsheet of relevance without the assistance of an accountant. That is common knowledge. All of the deficiencies are common knowledge. Most CEOS in like position usually have a professional accounting designation or at the very least a qualification in business management (other than the credit union qualifications that are gained from one and two week trips each year.) The credit union paper is fine for an emerging institution or to bolster any other business/finance qualification a person may have. Not for a multi million dollar institution such as this one. Each prior CEO up to 2006 or 2007 was qualified to the hilt and not one saw a 15 grand salary furthermore 20 grand.
    When last has the membership heard or seen of any innovative developments coming from public workers? Housing projects are being launched for BUT; BWU already has one. Public workers introduced ATM cards in the nineties and opened a fabulous building; bought a building for 6m that was on the market for two years after it was first advertised for 4m; bought CLICO Mortgage Finance recently without the members’ input. Where are the member benefits here? An increase in the asset base?
    Where has our philosophical compass gone?
    The members can decide based on what they are observing, of they are getting value for money.


  7. @Cat Eyes

    As far as the debate re the salary of the CEO is concerned: The current ceo was never offered that salary! She, Paul and the BOD set it. You all obviously do not get the picture yet. The lady came in as the Legal Counsel. She is currently the CEO and there is now a six grand gap between her salary and the second in command. The salary of the second in command is in keeping with the correct salary ranges for executive management of the institution.

    If the above is true then members should have a problem with the decision making process that is at play.

    A CEO of a 643 million balance sheet COMPANY who can’t read a balance sheet?

    Don’t believe it!

  8. smooth chocolate Avatar
    smooth chocolate

    @Cat Eyes | June 5, 2011 at 6:29 PM |

    “… you have a lawyer at the helm of a financial institution who cannot interpret balance sheets, or comprehend any spreadsheet of relevance without the assistance of an accountant. That is common knowledge.”

    now that statement alone gives me goose pimples..from my line of work, i fully understand the enormity of that statement and if it’s true…heaven help us members


  9. @smooth chocate

    All it means it that others are making the financial decision or advising accordingly.

    So far one has to say the balance sheet of the BPW credit union seem ok but…


  10. Cat Eyes
    I am with you all the way.
    Can the concern group get an attorney to help with sorting out the questions for the AGM that would not be exposed to legal threats from the board?
    By the way I am coming to the meeting and encouraging others to read the comments on BU so as to sensitize them of the seriousness of this AGM. Who are the candidates that must be voted against


  11. @Clone

    Please note the following details which are available on the website:

     

    Please download the AGM Notice and Agenda

    Please download the AGM Letter to Nominees

    Please download the AGM Nomination Forms

    Please download the AGM Biography Form

    Please download the AGM Affidavit Form

    Please download the AGM Guidelines

    Please download BPWCCUL BY-LAWS as of June 2008

  12. smooth chocolate Avatar
    smooth chocolate

    @David | June 5, 2011 at 6:54 PM |
    “All it means it that others are making the financial decision or advising accordingly.”

    that is the worrying part…that is a serious issue and have serious implications…yes it might seem ok but is it?and if it is..should circumstances change for the worse for the one interpreting for the CEO… who will protect our assets…i am getting more and more concerned as i read these comments


  13. Cat Eyes | June 5, 2011 at 6:29 PM |

    “HR 101 dictates that the salary you receive in an organisation depends on the work you do, your qualifications and what the company can pay”

    I agree with your line of thought, make no mistake, we are on the same side, but I disagree with your detailing of HR101. This Lawyer CEO, had she been working for a law firm and drawing the same kind of salary, she would have been expected to be bringing at the very least, the same kind of money into the company. A partner in a law firm earns far more for the firm than she is paid. A CEO of a company, in my world in NO DIFFERENT. You understand the difference between your opinion and mine ?


  14. @BAFBFP I understand what you are saying, but what I submitted is theory. You would of course adapt the theory to suit the particular situation.


  15. @Insider- causing unnecessary panic and confusion by shouting that the institution will collapse is reckless. Where is your proof? That it needs proper management and supervision is clear, and I think we all realise some house cleaning is in order so that we preserve what is a good thing.


  16. @Insider

    Your comments were removed.


  17. @Cat Eyes – telling the members the truth as far as the mismanagement at BPWCCUL goes is NOT unnecessary nor is it causing confusion. The members ought to panic. If all said on this blog is fact, and I know that the vast majority of it is true, can you explain how long the BPWCCUL will last as a going concern? You have blatantly incompetent managers creating shell companies (often without member approval) which are managed by minions of the same incompetent managers; millions being embezzled by board members and their cronies on travel, credit cards, etc; dividends/interest declining; interest rates going up; members being blocked from asking about the misappropriation of their own money; and persons being fired for doing their jobs; consultants being hired to rubberstamp unsustainable and corrupt management practices and you think this is causing unnecessary confusion? Credit unionism is one of the best things to happen to Barbados, but it has been hijacked. Nothing but strong decisive action on the part of an informed membership will stop the malaise, persons who want to intellectualise and smooth it over are contributing to the decay. The credit union is in critical condition. Get rid of the Maxwell/St. Hill/Alleyne/Murrell cancer cells… they are deadly.


  18. Can you explain why those comments were removed?

  19. old man river, Avatar
    old man river,

    well.boy de ceo of de public worker. gettin more money than de prime minister, oh la, wonder what de prime minister to say bout that, well boy de river gettin hott,de talk is boute de bee meetin, mia and owen, tonite…..


  20. @Insider

    You should read the comment policy.


  21. Don’t worry David, anything posted is known to be true. If it is true, there can be no malice.

  22. Wishing In Vain Avatar
    Wishing In Vain

    This discussion should be one that the officials at The City Of Bridgetown Credit Union should be paying very close attention to, as this should be a means by which they can use to help put their books in good order sooner rather than later.

    A good start would be ending the large payouts to Lynette Holder and Carol Roberts, sadly this Nepotism that exist with the Carol Roberts / Lynette Holder and Mia Mottley connection has led to a most unhealthy outcome where Carol Roberts has acquired a very large loan from the said COB Credit Union and has not been paying the loan off.

    If you put this in perspective and remember this is the same Carol Roberts who was taken before the courts previously for a non payment of a debt, how now can she be entrusted with yet another large loan on which she has already defaulted was this the result of a relationship of Roberts / Holder and Mottley ?

    They should go another step forward, having removed Holder and Roberts have they also sought to address the setup whereby Ms Mia Mottley was the ONLY lawyer getting any of the work that was there to be had at The COB ?

    How does that look to have this COB Credit Union entangled and entwined as this one is and all the functioning of the COB being controlled and dictated by these three and only these three close lady friends ?


  23. This situation makes me recall the story of David who in his wisdom was asked to adjudicate on the matter of determining the real mother of a baby.

    The creators of this blog would have us believe that they are operating in the best interest of this institution. They would have you believe that this forum is the only way that the ‘concerned coalition’ can raise issues of concern to members.

    You would be very surprised to find out in fact who this concerned coalition is. You are being manipulated in a way you cannot even begin to imagine.

    There is however a group who is very committed to this institution and there are things that could be said that would surprise many of you greatly regarding very real transgressions of these persons who would so manipulate you…but we don’t want to cut the baby in half to prove a point, we would rather that this institution survive this attempt at a real hijacking.

    Consider the intentions of those who would rather see the organization brought into shame and utter disrepute in this way rather than use the many legitimate channels at members’ disposal to bring real issues and concerns to the fore.

    No such concerns have been raised through any of these means. This is the first and last post I will write on this blog and this is indeed a very sad, bitter and unnecessary moment in the history of our credit union.


  24. I am certainly no supporter of the BPWCCUL, but I must say be fair. THIS ARTICLE, I AM SURE WAS PUBLISHED BY CASWELL FRANKLYN. HE CAN’T FOOL ME. HE IS THE ONE WHO WAS UNEMPLOYED MANY YEARS AGO AND WAS A MEMBER OF THE BOARD. HE HAS NO QUALIFICATIONS; HIS POPULARITY IS A RESULT OF HIS ABILITY TO BE ASSERTIVE. HE IS THE ONE WHO WAN BANNED FROM THE CREDIT UNION; NO WONDER HE IS CALLING ON OTHERS (BETTER THAN HE) TO BE BANNED.

    DAVID – Please let this one go through.


  25. @ Cat Eyes
    I agree with you when you asked” When last has the membership heard or seen of any innovative developments coming from public workers?” One must ask WHY? Does the organization even have a Marketing Department? Is it still based at the Credit Union or elsewhere?
    On another note, I must reiterate another point made earlier regarding members attending the meeting. Attending and just asking questions is pointless if no one is actually going to move a motion to make changes. Furthermore, if enough members do not support the motion for change the entire exercise would have been a waste of everyone’s time (except the current BOD and Management of course). Once again, they win.
    You can all attend and argue all you want but it is ONLY the FINAL DECISIONS and ACTIONS TAKEN that are important in any meeting, whether private sector, public sector or credit union.

  26. Just Only Asking Avatar
    Just Only Asking

    @David

    Under no circumstance should a ceo of a credit union earn more than a prime minister who presides over an economy that is bigger than that of the credit union. I wonder how the salary of the CEO of this credit union compares to that of Governor of the Central Bank.

    I find tha in organisations in Barbados there are rules for the Meads and the Persians. What is happening to the Crdit Union movement, how can our money be used to pay for a driver for the ceo, including overtime. WHERE is the oversight by the Supervisory Committee. Every one of the Committee members should be removed from office, including Mr. Murrell, who I thought had spine, but it is clear that he is in it for the ride
    .
    Members dont talk, act we have a lot of people in this country who are afraid of their shadows. We should scrutinise every one that is nominated and ensure that those who represent the staus quo are not elected. Come arm yourself with the rules and do not back down, you are entilteld to ask questions and receiveie answers. Ensure that you get a copy of the audited statements before hand, and if they are only ready on the day of the meeting, have the meeting post-poned so that you can study them.

    DO NOT TALK ACT. THE POWER LIES WITH THE MEMBERS

  27. Just Only Asking Avatar
    Just Only Asking

    @Blessed

    I respect your point of view, but sometimes the only way members can have an understaing of what is going on in their movement is through whistleblowing, what I am interested in is whether what is said is true or not. My allegiance is to the huge investment I have there, I dont want a clico or Enron in Barbados.

    I dont intend to suffer like what happened to one of the ladies who had invested all her savings in trade confirmers and end up in the mental, because i will end up in HM prisons or DODDS and some one will end up not above the ground.

    So you can spout your pretty logic, but members should be able to determine what is fact from fiction, and those of us who have the ability to peel of the skin to get at the facts should do so for those who might be too timid to ask questions at the meeting. This debate is good for corporate governance which should be prasticed in all institutions.

  28. Just Only Asking Avatar
    Just Only Asking

    The Ceo is not brining in anything to the orgnisation and does not deserve the pay because the movement has over 650m in assets. The movement did not have to compete with the banks, the many government concessions allow it to grow. now that some have been removed, let us see what is going to happen.


  29. Hi it is the same thing going on in Guyana with the Guyana Public Service Union. Maybe this is becoming a Caribbean thing


  30. Blessed
    I am a member who wants to be informed before the AGM. I have read and commented on the views put forward by those opposing the board.
    Can you please put your knowledge of why you feel that we are being manipulated by persons who want to hijack the movement?
    While you are at it please deny or confirm what was said of the CEO salary.


  31. @blessed | June 6, 2011 at 12:57 AM |
    “The creators of this blog would have us believe that they are operating in the best interest of this institution. You would be very surprised to find out in fact who this concerned coalition is. ..You are being manipulated in a way you cannot even begin to imagine.”

    you could only be a foolish dog. you have in effect said that these allegations are true but they should not come out because the institution is more important than the members whose money, have made the institution what it is. you would have to be the very CLORINDA ALLEYNE or one of the others who are now starting to feel threatened. my money is in there and i am mad as h…l that i am getting next kin to nothing in terms of dividends or interests what you choose to call it and others are getting the hog’s pie because of my savings? i was persuaded to join when i had just entered the civil service. when i think of it, it is not different from the bank. if the union has become what i am reading then it means, i don’t have to be obligated to keep it going. i always had the impression that the union was a win-win situation for the poor or middle class who the bank turned their nose down on. what’s the point now? what i’v read does not appear to be allegations either, i will be at that meeting. i will withdraw my savings. i did not joint to fatten a small set of cows, i join so that my black brothers, sisters and me could all take part of the perceived fatten cow. my history lessons taught me that it was mandated that the white should have more than the blacks in Barbados during slavery. that perception came right thru the 20th century. when we went to the banks to borrow, we were usually turn away, the credit union was created to block that hole, to help us get homes, etc. i know of one person who join because they were single and raising 2 children without support. they would go to borrow about a $1000 just to buy groceries etc,. they could do no better. the loans officer would carry them along so scruffy that eventually, they withdrew membership and join another one. i know of another who lost their job, had a loan with the credit union and another union. they went to Public Workers to explain the situation and also to inquire if they, inspite of their situation could withdraw $100.00 from their shares. they had no money to feed their children that day.. the answer was ‘no’. they went to the other credit union, (same day) explained the situation, that credit union (COB) was so concerned with their plight that inspite of the fact that they owed money, they were allowed to take (not borrow $1000) from their shares. that is what a credit union is about, you must care about your members, not just threat them as cattle.


  32. In Barbados there is a culture of silence which lingers even in the face of wrong doing. At the end of the day it will be left to the members to decide how they want the credit union to run.


  33. @David: “In Barbados there is a culture of silence which lingers even in the face of wrong doing.

    Do you have any insight into why this is so?

    Second question: In your opinion, is this a healthy (long term) position to take?


  34. Smooth chocolate,

    You have a right to information on your loan with the credit union. You need to request a statement of your loan from inception to present. You are entitled to it by law as a borrower.

    It will show the amortization of your loan to date. Based on the figures you gave, $15,000 repayable at $395 per month, (you didn’t state an interest rate), but even at a rate in excess of 20% per annum, such a loan should have been repaid well within six years, provided that payments were made consistently. Get a statement and get someone competent to analyse it for you.


  35. @Chris

    What are your thoughts on the matter? We know it is not healthy.


  36. @David of BU: “We know it is not healthy.

    Could you expand on that?


  37. @BU.David. BTW, you ignored my first question which was in direct response to your statement. Let me please repeat it…

    BUD: “In Barbados there is a culture of silence which lingers even in the face of wrong doing.

    CH: “Do you have any insight into why this is so?

    ….


  38. @Chris

    A Bajan has an innate characteristic which abhors conflict. Protect the status quo at all cost. The conservatism inherited from the British adds to the mix.


  39. @David: “A Bajan has an innate characteristic which abhors conflict. Protect the status quo at all cost. The conservatism inherited from the British adds to the mix.

    I truly and deeply appreciate this honest answer.

    But, with the deepest of respect, it doesn’t answer the fundamental question…

    Does this position scale on an international playing field, knowing that the “masters” are no longer looking out for you?


  40. @ Smooth Chocolate

    Seems to me that you have paid up to $24,000 on that $15,000 loan that is still no where cleared. Get some financial advice, man. Yuh being robbed. You probably would have done better at a commercial bank.

  41. smooth chocolate Avatar
    smooth chocolate

    @Pat | June 6, 2011 at 6:34 PM |
    “Seems to me that you have paid up to $24,000 on that $15,000 loan that is still no where cleared. Get some financial advice, man. Yuh being robbed. You probably would have done better at a commercial bank”

    it will have to do that as i kept telling myself tht something isn’t adding up but it’s only with these allegations that i’m starting to wonder if some impropriety might be going on with mine and could be others too. we just get the loans, sign, the money is deducted and we do not look back

  42. smooth chocolate Avatar
    smooth chocolate

    @Inkwell | June 6, 2011 at 4:39 PM |

    the interest rate is 11.75%


  43. This feels a bit like a Doctor Who episode.

    Except, like, for real….


  44. Let me share this unimportant situation. Being a member for so many years, children being youth savers, the BPWCCU Ltd was solicited to assist the students of a tertiary institution in finalizing their end of course project. They were flatly refused with no dialogue, no interest shown. Yet there is so much money flying around and only token gifts are given. Why only these petty fees and not really trying to assist those who need assistance especially in the youth who are showing promise. But then again we realise that you get assistance only if you belong to the clique.


  45. @smooth chocolate: “the interest rate is 11.75%.

    That might be considered to be usury rates.

    It is certainly above the rate charged to the banks who are lending.

    Hmmmm….

  46. smooth chocolate Avatar
    smooth chocolate

    @Christopher Halsall | June 6, 2011 at 7:07 PM |

    i will ask for a copy of my loan statement, after which i determine my next option. i am really unsettled about the affair


  47. seem rather weird. Given the 15,000 starting in 2005 with 11.75% interest and repayments @ 395 a month. The loan should have taken at most 4 years with constant payments. http://www.bankrate.com/calculators/mortgages/loan-calculator.aspx .some good explaining is need there.


  48. @smooth chocalate

    On the very BPW credit union website there is a loan calculator where all you have to do is plug a few numbers to get the result you want.


  49. @David: “On the very BPW credit union website there is a loan calculator where all you have to do is plug a few numbers to get the result you want.

    Might you go out of your way to provide a URL which works?

    http://bajan.wordpress.com/2011/06/04/barbados-public-workers-cooperative-credit-union-urged-to-take-back-their-credit-union-from-the-few-who-have-hijacked-it/loadcalculator()

    …doesn’t.


  50. actual page http://www.publicworkers.bb/loancalculatordaily.cfm

    Using the selected amount of $395.00 it will take 4 years and 1 month to repay the 15000 after making 48 payments of $395.00 and one payment of $85.48.
    The amount repaid is $19,045.48. The total interest paid is $4,045.48. The total interest paid is $4,045.48.
    Disclaimer: This information is provided for guidance only. The Credit Union reserves the right to vary these loan terms and conditions.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending