Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Minister of Social Care, Constituency Empowerment and Urban Development
Chris Sinckler, Minister of Social Care, Constituency Empowerment and Urban Development

The controversial Constituency Councils Act 2009 will be debated in our parliament tomorrow. If passed this will be the second most significant policy rollout of the government since gaining office, free school rides for students being the first. The David Thompson led government appears to be quite comfortable in  focusing on social programs.

The Democratic Labour Party (DLP) eased into office on the promise of CHANGE. Also exposing corruption and ensuring that government resources were more efficiently allocated to benefit the PEOPLE by enforcing government’s financial rules to ensure transparency.

We have listened to the current debate regarding the establishment of constituency councils. Leader of the Opposition Mia Mottley has been quite vocal in her criticism that the councils conflict with the role of the member of parliament which is defined in the Constitution of Barbados. Also the wide range of powers the minister is cited to have in the proposed legislation has many believing that this will just be another opportunity for the Democratic Labour Party to distribute largess.

A read of both the BLP and DLP manifestoes suggest that conceptually regarding the decentralization of the provision of certain services to communities, the two are not that far apart. The BLP committed in its 2008 manifesto to upgrade subventions to community based organization. The DLP in keeping with its focus on social programs are about to debate the act which will soon give life to a key campaign promise.

The BU household supports the government in this imitative that will see the PEOPLE at the community level empowered to solve problems in their communities based on an independent budget proposed at $100,000.00. Of concern however is the enormous powers the government through the minister responsible for the councils will have under the act. Members of the councils are nominated, not elected and the minister will or can have the final say on who gets selected.

The importance of demoting Chris Sinckler from the Foreign Affairs ministry is now plain for all to see. If the roll-out of the councils is done well the Democratic Labour Party will be positioned to widen its support base deliberately or otherwise.

The dilemma posed by the enormous powers promised under the Constituency Councils Act is the knowledge that the Douglas Leopold Phillips’ will want to serve on the councils. Prime Minister Thompson did promise that the fatted calf will be slaughtered soon. This is especially true after having to endure the Beresford Leon Padmore troupe for its fourteen year tenure. How can Barbadians be sure that the partisan approach to appointments will not continue?

We appreciate that the logistics of electing 450 members to complete the 30 constituency councils would generate an expensive administrative problem. We also appreciate that the power of the minister under the proposed act to appoint and or approve nominees may encourage the partisan politics to which Barbadians have become accustomed.

If we are to  judge from the attendance at the town hall meetings to discuss the Freedom of Information Act and other recent government proposals, Barbadians seem timid when asked to participate/feedback in their democracy. What makes us feel that my holding elections to select members for the constituency councils that the results couldn’t be contrived?

Managing government in today’s environment has become a complex affair and demands good attention. An efficient system to manage micro-issues which exist in our communities would free-up central government to the bigger issues of the day. Of importance is the fact that ordinary PEOPLE are suppose to be managing the councils.

We hope that this initiative which proposes to involve the PEOPLE more in the governance of their affairs will not become shrouded in a partisan cloud. This government promised change and they will be judged by the PEOPLE in 2013. If the legislation has to go back to the Attorney General’s Office for amendments then so be it.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. The constituency council is an absolute waste of money and time. The proposed duties of the councils as details in the press are the duties I would expect of an MP! Instead of this sham which can only be described as the product of sophomoric thinking, I would propose a constituency commission under the chairmanship of the ombudsman which will report on whether MPs are doing their job. The BLP’s response to the proposed council also show their paucity of analysis and sheer crass opportunism equaled only by the DLP’s response to the republican question some years ago. A pox on both their houses.

  2. Wishing In Vain Avatar

    Your comments about mottley being vocal about the constituency councils does not surprise me in the least, after all this is the same empty vessel that ranted and raved because the DLP provided free bus rides for our children!!!

    As she has been instructed by The Hon Prime Minister Mr. David Thompson that she needs to learn when she should speak and when she should mumble, at this stage of her political struggles she needs to be wiser and more logical, as opposing for the sake of opposing is just downright stupid.

    I fully understand that her struggles are multi tasked after all she finds herself not only fighting the Government in Parliament but she is also having to fight for her survival as Co Leader Arthur and Mascot of Hardwood Housing fame are undermining her every step along the way.

    Despite whatever she attempts to drum up, these councils will take effect and with time we will all see the positive impact that they will have in the villages and communities around Barbados, mottley has nothing to fear as she too will get funds to work with, who know she may find it more worthwhile to spend it on buying and smoking herb on the block with the fellows of which she tries so hard to be one.

    The reality is that mottley has never been nor will ever relate to the grass roots of politics because having been raised in an elite family with a silver spoon in her mouth she does not understand the needs of the poor in this society, hence her harsh words when the free school bus rides were introduced, she would not relate to saving $ 30.00 or $ 40.00 per week as meaningful because that kind of money is small change to her but a massive value to those less fortunate than herself.

    If we cast our minds back it was the same BLP who opposed Independence, Free Education and Free School Meals, so to me mottley and the BLP have a track record of opposing good, progressive, uplifting programs for the betterment of our Barbadian people.

    I honestly think her opposition to the constituency councils is mislaid only because the DLP will be putting in place a program that is people caring and focused on helping those in our society that cannot help themselves, we understand the people’s needs, she does not, as was evidenced by the level of full fledged corruption that she and Arthur fuelled and was part of, NO mottley this is for the people who need the help the most and it not for your type.

    Oppose and speak out when there is sensible reason to do so, when it has value but to oppose because you want to be in the press more often than Owing and get your one ups MAN ship on your rival Owing is just downright stupid.

    I think it is great program that will help empower people to give them their voice in the running of their affairs and any program that empowers ordinary people is a worthwhile, progressive, uplifting program that will get my support and the support of the Caring DLP Government.

    PS Mottlet / Owing always remember why you were evicted from office, your lack of caring for the people and your own greed and dishonesty with public funds, it will take a long time to get anyone (other those of your same ilk) to trust you again.

    Trust is something that is earned and you blew that trust with your corrupt acts, so when you speak to us the people we find you very shallow and very empty because we CANNOT TRUST YOU OR YOUR WORDS.

    Remember that line you mottley took when speaking to the group of Barbadian builders when you were in the heat of the Four Seasons / Chinese workers issue, that they would tow the line or be subject to a VAT and or a TAX audit of, it was that type of arrogance and high handed manner that got you kicked out of office.

    YOUR HONESTY IS SHOT YOUR VOICE IS DOUBTFUL AT LEAST A LIAR AT BEST.


  3. @Wishing In Vain

    You have not addressed any of the concerns expressed some which we believe to be legit. Shouldn’t you be looking forward to the debate to satisfy or take on board the concerns? Say what you want the opposition has a duty to represent the people as well.

    @anonymous

    There is a big question mark about the representation by our MPs. Maybe in some cases the pressure of managing government impinges on their ability to represent the people.

    Also many of the MPs today have no history of the constituencies they represent. A well run CC may supplement what they are doing.


  4. David, a well run CC may SUPPLANT (not supplement) what the MP is doing! Let’s have one or the other but not both LOL.

    Read the proposed duties of the CC in Friday’s Nation. Post them to inform this debate. Any MP not now doing what the CCs are being proposed for, should be recalled. My bad there is no such provision!


  5. We provided a link to the Act which list all.

    Are we happy with the representation of our MPs and public officials?

    It looks like Obama is doing a similar thing in the USA. He is rolling out moves to bring the government closer to the people. We don’t want status quo we want change.


  6. These are an excellent suggestion as they’ll give important citizens like Tech, something to do, when they were n’t chilling which I hope, would n’t be too often, as there’s a great deal which requires to be done!! 🙂


  7. These would be an excellent idea if they had a clear set of responsibilities distinct from parliament. I thought that they’d would have the sort of budgets and structures of local councils. As it currently is, these will become at best a talking shop and at worst an extra layer of politicised inaction. Is it just me or are there bigger fish to fry ? I for one am livid that we do not have a clear economic plan to cope with the financial tsunami heading our way. I do not want to see another meeting of the social partnership, I do not want an “emergency committee” and I do not want words. I want to see unambiguous action. Forget the local councils – they’re a good idea but need some thought. Start protecting the livelihoods of Bajans now.


  8. @james1

    It will be interesting to listen to the debate tomorrow if it is aired. The purpose of the councils is to involve the people more in running their communities. PM Thompson seems to adopting a populous type approach to governing.


  9. @David

    I can’t really see what the great hallabaloo is all about. What is wrong with government taking steps to involve ordinary people in the administration of government business through these councils?

    It is a positive step to delegate responsibility into the community where possible.

    The scheme is not particularly expensive, and even if all are not equally successful, they will at least expose more Bajans to community leadership and may well propel a few national leaders to the fore.

    I also see nothing wrong with government appointing the members. Who in their right mind would want to have a situation where councils turn out to be ‘anti -government’? It is a community arm of the elected government – what elections what?!? we already had those last January.

    I also see nothing wrong with what they are expected to do. It had to be something that previously was done (or supposed to be done) by somebody – did we think that new duties would have fallen out of the sky for them to do?

    We have to start somewhere….
    I say give the scheme a chance – maybe we will see some real action from government through these councils.

    Bush tea is personally much more concerned about the method of appointment to certain boards and influential private and public companies that I am of our elected government naming a council from a list of public nominees….


  10. BT do you trust ANY government in Barbados to adequately oversee any system where they have sole authority?

    What about those councils that are located in the other party supporter territory.


  11. Where does Owing find the guts to talk his nonsense, is his memory so short to forget about the scam that taxpayers paid Danos 3 S $ 117 million for road works and yet still the two main contractors saw the grand sum of $ 60 million out of that vast payment the ones that really did the work collected a mere $ 6 million more that the commission takers did and the rest heading to the pockets of Steven Hobson, Hallam Nicholls, J Danos, Bizzy Williams and He Owing ????
    Nor does he not remember his wayward spending on Gems, Southern Meats, Edutech.
    Nor does he remember his creation of the Rural and Urban commissions that when created the former Prime Minister Mr Sandiford described them as multi headed hyrdrants when one was cut off another rose up.
    Nor does he remember his role as well as mascoll’s and mottleys role in Hardwood Housing fiasco??
    Nor does he remember his role with those cheques he collected for favours???
    Nor does he remember the conversion of zone 1 land to commercial land for his financial benefit???
    Nor does he remember his involvement with the VTL that he and Hallam Nicholls brought into this island???
    Nor does he remember the blessing the he betowed on the sole agent for the gov’t for each and every vehicle brought into this island that he collected a commission on nor the fact that he over aw saw a scam where Sanitation vehicles were sold to the taxpayers at three times the cost of what the would normally cost if purchased directly from the agent????
    Give me a break Owing your corruption stinks to high heavens, you ought to be the last one to preach, you only preach corruption.


  12. @David “BT do you trust ANY government in Barbados to adequately oversee any system where they have sole authority?”

    No I Don’t David!!! But this is not about trust.

    We have to be careful not to oppose everything just for opposing sake.

    I really fail to see any significant down-side to this proposal. The Government seems to be doing what modern, enlightened organisations call empowering work teams in the organisation to allow people at all levels to get involved in problem-solving. These teams are extensions of the current management group.

    As a people development tool alone, this is a useful exercise.

    People from the opposition and the PDP who obviously would want the current scheme to fail, would naturally support the election approach. But how could
    we have a situation where an elected council may represent the opposition, while being sponsored by the government and committed to implementing government policy?

    With respect to your question of representation in an opposition area… Where is such an area David? I was under the impression that with DLP having won the election; we were now all ONE country, with a clear role for the winner to represent us all, and for the opposition to represent us all in keeping the government in check?

    We cannot afford to perpetuate this type of political division in the running of the country at this crucial time.

    You must know of the outstanding work done in communities like Pinelands, Haynesville, Gall Hill and countless others WITHOUT ANY SUPPORTING STRUCTURES.

    I strongly suspect that we will see some of these councils doing phenomenal
    work in their communities eventually becoming models for others to follow.
    The structure will evolve as time goes on, but altogether, it is quite a good start.

    What I do find to be particularly offensive was the model proposed by the PDP representative on brass tacks on Sunday. No wonder no one votes for
    them.


  13. I am for the councils. I have looked at the arguments against it, and deem them to be partisan in nature. I must admit that there is some demagoguery in the current approach, but what government does not attempt to link their future and their legacy to public policy? Such is always baked into the political and governmental cake, and is to be expected. In addition to my view that the current opposition to the councils and in particular the way they are being put together is of a partisan nature, the past views on a similar subject by Owen Arthur and Mia Mottley needs to be looked at. On two occasions while a member of cabinet Mia stated that she saw a need for more parliamentarians, one set to deal with local issues and another to focus on national issues. We all know that over the years Barbadians were force to make a choice between local needs and the national needs of the country. As recent as last week a resident of the arhcot area made such an assertion against Fruendel Stuart. Whenever a parliamentarian takes on a ministerial portfolio, this scenario of local needs taking a back seat seems to become more manifest. Then there is Owen Arthur, very early in his leadership, stated the draw backs of the first past the post electoral system and it’s short comings. On a trip to Boston where he spoke to a gathering of Barbadians, I had a few minutes conversation with him and Rodney Wilkinson where he dismissed a return to local government as too expensive. There has been no demonstrated willingness by the BLP to once again allow average Barbadians to participate in the process of governance, that the DLP did away with in 1969, where again demagoguery was a factor in it’s demise.


  14. Local Government:
    The Constitution makes no provision for local government. For many years prior to 1959 the administrative organ at the parochial level was the Vestry. In each of the eleven parishes there was a Vestry comprising sixteen elected members who were resident property owners. The Chairman was usually the Rector of the parish, or in St. Michael, the Dean of the Cathedral. The Vestries levied taxes on local landowners and used the funds mainly to repair roads and churches in the parish. The qualifications for election to the Vestry were the same as for the House of Assembly.
    In 1959 the eleven Vestries were replace by three Local Government Councils which functioned from then until 1969. The factors which led to the abolition of local government in Barbados (including the need to eliminate exceedingly high overhead charges for administration) and reasons why it should not be revived were dealt with by the Cox commission in it’s 1979 report on page 50. The Commission suggested that wider participation by citizens in the democratic process of Government could be achieved “in the context of a considerable degree of operational decentralization” but failed to say how this would be achieved.

    Page 58 of The Barbados Constitution: Facts and questions booklet 1997.
    This commission was sanctioned by the BLP and chaired by Sir Henry Forde.


  15. This report would have been handed to Mia Mottley then AG of Barbados. But as you read the following exerpts and you then listen to the video clip of Mia during her nomination as the candidate for her constituency in the last election, you get a sense that she welcomes the dependency, and the entitlement mentality that relies on her as the benefactor of good and services. Corn beef and biscuits politics has it’s origins in her family name. When you then look to her current opposition to the Councils, how can you not come away with the believe that her position is nothing more than self serving?

    Report of the National Commission on Law and Order

    Chapter 4 page 47 -58

    4.6.7. Perception of the public about the current inadequacies of governance. The following issues were clearly stated by the public to be affecting the society:
    * community councils do not seek input from community members; * there is an absence of strong community councils;
    * the present scope of Parish Committees is inadequate; There is:
    * duplication of effort among agencies;
    * unequal ease of access to resources;
    * red tape in government;
    * lack of advocacy;
    * political interference;
    * lack of information about available resources and where and how to get them;
    * excessive centralisation of the administration of resources.

    ———————————————–

    4.8. Rationale for community level management “The movement in Barbados away from local government towards centralized government has led the population to expect that government will provide everything.” On one of the Commission’s walkabouts
    in a rural community, we met with over 25 youths, mainly male, who lamented that nothing was happening in their community. When asked why they could not plan programmes themselves, they said that they did not know how, and added: “the politicians don’t help do anything.” This dependency and lack of self motivation paint a very bleak picture of Barbados and captures the duality of socio-political evolution that has served to shape recent experiences of participatory development. The centralising tendency of successive governments has distanced the decision makers from the grassroots, and in some cases, facilitated the co-option of civil society by the State.

    Recently, Dr. Clive Thomas from the University of Guyana, in making a social assessment of Barbadian communities, noted that the civil society process had died. This raises a question of our ability to cope and continue to build social

    http://wm.z1.mii-streaming.net/media/blp/windows/St.Michael North East Nomination/Mia Mottley’s Video Presentation.wmv


  16. http://wm.z1.mii-streaming.net/media/blp/windows/St. Michael North East Nomination/Mia Mottley’s Video Presentation.wmv

    David please fix that space above.

    Thanks.


  17. What I do find to be particularly offensive was the model proposed by the PDP representative on brass tacks on Sunday. No wonder no one votes for
    them.

    ____________________________

    lol! What hurt me was when David Ellis told him that the difference between him and Mr. Marshall was that Marshall could find people who would vote for him whilst no one was going to vote for PEP! ha ha ha lol

    Even funnier was the comment that Mr. Commisong came with he said he had to leave early ha ha ha ha lol!

    Oh lord~!

    These people are trouble ha ha hlol


  18. Yesterday sparks flew when Mottley and Marshall on the DLP side accused Sinckler of not being trueful. The accusation was based on Mottley and Marshall alleging Sinckler had promised that CC members would have been elected, a claim he hotly denied.


  19. ha ha ha ha Marshall obviuosly would be furious, a Constituency council in St. Joseph that is “demagogued” will signal his demise,….he was but a few votes away from D-day without them. He is toasted and he knows it.

    Again if you listen to Mia’s video clip that i posted above and asked David to clean up which he hasn’t done! :),….You will see that she sees herself as the reason for all the success in her constituency, she has been quietly using government resources to buy loyalty over the years. No one understand the Master/client relationship that propel her grandfather to near god-like status in the City of Bridgetown, than her. The CC arrangement is a direct threat to her standing and the way it was derived in St. Michael North East.

    The BLP used the “politics of inclusion” in an attempt to weakened and or kill the DLP so that they could continue in power in perpetuity. demagoguery? yes

    ————————–

    The DLP may end up using the CC (a good thing no matter what) to weakened and or kill the BLP, in the least weakened and or kill Mia’s attempt to become the PM ( another good thing) demagoguery? You bet.

    lol!

    I can’t help but think that Owen and Thompy though not working together, are none the less working towards the same goal. I happen to think um is good fuh Bim. ha ha ha ha lol!


  20. I thought Chris Sinckler’s presentation was out of the top draw, a class act as one would expect from Chris.

    He went about destroying the myth that the Constituency Councils were to be used in the same way that the BLP used URBAN and that they used RURAL and the YOUTH COMMISSIONERS, sadly mottley fell flat on her face when she fell for the old one two on the matter of the YOUTH COMMISSIONERS when she stated that they were not going to be used in the program as a result of a meeting the evening before with the Minister.

    This is a group who masterminded corruption and dishonesty, Politics of inclusion, the RURAL AND URBAN slush funding,GEMS, HARDWOOD HOUSING, DANOS 3S, VECO, the St Peter Development Fund that saw after Owing and his needs and they have the gall to tell John Public about what or what not they should do.

    Dale Marshall was a sad excuse for the person given the task to reply to the eloquent Chris Sinckler, once again his manner and style suggest that he is of the belief that his Sh__t does not smell type, well the sad news for you Marshall is that it does smell, it smells of your previous rein of corruption and dishonesty in office, that is a thing of the past this is a new era, minus mottley and owing’s style of dishonest gov’t.

    My advice to the ruling party waste no time with that empty, devoid bunch of misfits, press ahead with you program to empower the people of Barbados at great haste.


  21. I see over at BFP a Thomas Gresham makes a very sad error and I suggested the following.

    I know that you try to appear educated on each subject discussed on this site and I take my hat off to you because if you were as educated as you pretend to be, you would be heading up Oxford or Cambridge University, and not here delving into dark mistruths and concocted lies, be that as it may.

    In your trivial attempt to downplay the giant leap forward to social empowerment you either skillfully or dishonestly ommitted to factor in that very clearly in the setting up of these councils you will see that a position is made available to seat a representative of the opposition, why then you stray from the path of truth and honesty in your submission??

    When I listened to the call in show today it amazing to me that the councils did not attract any comment , that says to me that the people who elected the gov’t of the day are happy with their management of their affairs and have well and truly signed onto the program for the creation of the constituency councils moreover the only person complaining is the Poor Rakey BLP misfits left stranded under Mottley / Owing fiasco in the clean up of 15 th Jan 2008.

    PS Who is the leader of the opposition??

    It is not clear to many!!!

    Since when do Interior Designers get contracts to build building belonging to Gov’t ??

    Seems only under Mottley, a project on the Harbour road was a Project that was given to a woman who had never built a cow pen but got this project because SHE WAS A FRIEND OF MOTTLEY????


  22. “DLP Money Grab!”

    This is nothing more than a DLP money grab. There is no need for any CC on a 166 sq mi island with 30 MP’s and 23 senators. CC’s are nothing more cesspools of bribery, waste, vote buying and embezzlement.


  23. de gap // February 12, 2009 at 12:26 pm

    “DLP Money Grab!”

    This is nothing more than a DLP money grab. There is no need for any CC on a 166 sq mi island with 30 MP’s and 23 senators. CC’s are nothing more cesspools of bribery, waste, vote buying and embezzlement.
    ==========================
    Look try and explain yourself! How so it is? how so???


  24. De Gap,
    Be more specific. It appears as if you yourself don’t comprehend what you are talking about. When writing on the blog use some thought process before writing.


  25. “Follow the money”

    Tony Hall,

    If you have a problem with the queen’s English Mr. “use some thought process”, that’s not my problem.

    Adrian Hinds,

    Counselors appointed by the sitting MP? Does the phrase DLP hacks mean anything to you? Does anyone remember the Vestry System? Big paychecks will be paid (as determined by the substantive MP) to 15 political hacks in 30 councils (again we only have 166 sq mi). Follow the money…That’s more than the entire US house of representatives! Follow the money…Each council will have a generous budget to be appropriated as they see fit with no accountability. Follow the money…And all this so that DLP MP’s will know what is going on in their constituencies. If David Thompson needs to know what is going on in his constituency, he should try doing a walkabout once in a while…Follow the money.


  26. de gap,
    As much as we would like to take you seriously, is this the same mottley that created the URBAN AND RURAL Commissions???
    Please tell me the purpose and reason for the creation of these two slush funds??
    Funnily enough I am yet to here John Public complain about the Councils but all the complaingis coming from you bunch of misfits called mottley and Owing, actually I also understand that even your warrior Owing is supportive of the setup of the councils, what say you now?


  27. Wishing in Vain,

    Anybody who supports this boondoggle is dead wrong BLP or DLP. Although I believe this is clearly a money grab, even if you believe that a MP needs 15 paid political hacks to tell him or her what needs to be done in the constituency and the best way to satisfy those needs, what possible justification can there be to have 450 paid political hacks serving on councils on a 166 sq mi island with 300 thousand people when we already have 30 elected MP’s?

    The US which stretches from the Atlantic to the Pacific with 300 million people doesn’t have as many people in the house of representatives. 450 unelected hacks will be spending money for days with no accountability to the taxpayers. Then the PM is going to raise my property taxes to pay the bills. Follow the money…


  28. de gap,

    The money spent to set up and operate the 30 Constituency Councils WILL NEVER equate to a fraction of the vast millions you and your party spent at URBAN and RURAL in your attempt to control the power base nor will it come close to the MILLIONS corruptly stashed away in your projects such as GEMS, HARDWOOD HOUSING, DANOS 3 S, VECO OIL STORAGE, VECO PRISON and the St Peter Development Fund.

    You really have some guts to lecture the nation on the rights and wrongs in Government office, you of all Governments that were the masters of gross corruption and stealing, you remember the garbage trucks that we the tax payers paid for at three times the true cost because your friend HALLAM NICHOLLS had to get his and your share??

    You have no creditability whatsoever and it is amusing to hear you try to lecture this new administration on the rights and the wrongs of governance.

    There will be 30 councils that will be there to serve the people of Barbados you can like it or lump it, the rest of Barbados and Barbadians like the plan and want the plan so the few of you misfits of the BLP you have a choice you either get onboard and let the councils help work for you or stand aside and be bypassed.


  29. @ De Gap:

    There continues to be a very wide Gap between your PROPHECYS and any evidence and or thoughts to demonstrate how you arrived at them.

    It is interesting that you mention what pertains in the US regarding government, its reach across the country and it’s proximity to the people. You are very much INCORRECT to suggest that government in the US stops at the Federal level and is in Washington DC only. Far far from it, is this the case. The Concept of “ALL POLITICS IS LOCAL” is alive and well in the US, where you have three main layers of government. We have the Municipal government which comprise of Town and city government a Mayor, and city or town council, or selectmen or aldermen depending on size, region, and history. Then you have STATE government which is comprise of a Governor, a State assembly of legislators and State senators. Then you have the federal government, comprising of the President, and the US Congress of US congressmen and US senators. POLITICS IN A REAL REAL DEMOCRACY SHOULD BE LOCAL, BUT IN BARBADOS FOR A VERY LONG TIME IT HAS ONLY BEEN NATIONAL. It is high time to bring government back to its rightful place.

    The people of Barbados have spoken and it is captured in the commissioned report of law and order. Only a SOCIALIST would seek to deny the people their wish, and I know there are a lot of Castro/Chavis lovers in Barbados.


  30. Thomas Gresham
    February 12, 2009 at 12:06 am
    Pray tell me how you “empower the people of Barbados at great haste” by creating a unique form of representation where representatives are not elected by the people of Barbados but hand picked by the ruling party…..unique to democracies, but common practice in China and the Soviet Union. Please. I dont mind honest political debate. But this is stupidity masquerading as politics.

    I recommend the last poster to step back, close your eyes as to who is speaking and responding and just think about it. You are supporting the notion that to give power to the people you will support hand-picking representatives as opposed to electing them. Now, imagine making this argument in any democracy outside of Barbados…..I have asked proponents of this before, to no avail, to give us a couple examples of other democracies in which local representatives of local constituents are hand picked by the ruling party?
    ==========================

    One of BFP’s intellectuals wrote the above. He sounded very sincere and confident that he and his argument stood on solid ground that was until I briefly showed up to state the following.

    Adrian Says:
    I can easily apply what you said to the position of Prime Minster of Barbados. The parliamentarians who command the loyalty of the most members of Parliament shall become the PM. Words to that effect are in the constitution, and the world ELECT is not to be found near that statemen. So in reality the LEADER in our so called DEMOCRACY is not elected. Further to this was the proposal by the Constitution review commission (1997) chaired by Sir Henry Forde, which favored Barbados becoming a republic, with a Barbadian born head of state to replace the GG, AND THAT PERSON WOULD BE SELECTED BY AN ELECTORIAL COLLEGE concept, not by popular or public elections.

    So here we have a PM not popularly elected as such.
    A Governor General who is appointed

    A propose Non executive President of Barbados in a propose Republic of Barbados that would not be popularly elected. All at the top of government of Barbados, but to do the same at the local level in the same society is said to be idiotic, to be a money grab etc.

    Folks wunnuh decide!


  31. @ De gap:
    Adrian Hinds,

    Counselors appointed by the sitting MP? Does the phrase DLP hacks mean anything to you? Does anyone remember the Vestry System? Big paychecks will be paid (as determined by the substantive MP) to 15 political hacks in 30 councils.
    ==========================

    Who appoints the GG?
    Who appoints the Governor of the Central bank?
    Who appoints the Chief Justice?
    Who appoints Ministers of Government?

    ..and is that person elected?

    Why should they not then be allowed to appoint a local council.

    Why would you appoint the Leader of the country and elect a local council person?

    The way our parliament should work is that all elected members as a group should have the power over appointed persons. They as a group (parliament) have the legislative power (real power) while cabinet (executive) does not, I should say SHOULD NOT, as Owen prove that to be wrong. As such being elected by the people gives you power that is equal to any other elected official. Now would you like to have a situation where a local council member says to the Prime minister and leader of the country I don’t mind you, I am elected you are not? You probably would.


  32. “The DLP’s Banana Republic”

    Adrian Hinds,

    MP’s are elected

    The GG is a figure head

    The PM is elected twice over by the people and the elected MP’s of his party.

    As for having an elected BLP councilor rebuff a DLP MP, that is democracy, checks and balances if you please. Why should Hartley Henry and the other DLP hacks be allowed to get their crummy hands on my money? If they want money, let them go and find honest work to do. Send home the Guyanese and let them cut the canes.

    Also, I never suggested that the US didn’t have state and local municipalities with members who are elected as it so happens. I was only highlighting the depth and breadth of the DLP money grab. 450 political hacks will be getting big fat paychecks, expense accounts, and unfettered access and control of nuff Sir Grantley’s with no accountability to taxpayers. Sounds like Cuba to me. 450….450…450…450…..


  33. de gap aka Henderson Bovell, are you still lurking under the yards of fabric that make up the leader of the opposition pants?

    Grow up and get a life you political pimp.


  34. de gap // February 13, 2009 at 1:39 pm

    The PM is elected twice over by the people and the elected MP’s of his party.
    ==========================

    Please explain How the people elect a person as the PRIME MINISTER? Have you ever seen such on a ballot??

    Could you explain the process in all it’s details that gives the MP’s of the majority party the opportunity to ELECT THE PRIME MINISTER. Indeed is there a process or is IT more likely to be an assumption base on who is the party leader during and after a concluded election exercise?

    When you are done please compare this written and or assumed exercise with what is propose regarding the CC.


  35. @De Gap:
    As for having an elected BLP councilor rebuff a DLP MP, that is democracy, checks and balances if you please.
    ===========================

    ….Even under Barbados’ adaptation of westminster, the cabinet is suppose to be a sub-committee of parliament thereby ensuring that it is answerable to will of parliament. The cabinet must be a parliamentary cabinet and not a prime minster’s cabinet. See Ezra Alleyne on this, who clearly detailed this to be the case, and highlighted Sandiford and Margaret Thatcher who held a contrarian opinion and was proven wrong. Under Owen Arthur the Cabinet of Barbados was so large that by a simple of vote the parliament could not assert it’s power even if it wanted too. And this is so because we know that a PRIME MINISTER IS EXPECTED TO USE PATRONAGE to maintain his position of “FIRST AMONGST EQUALS” so he buys loyalty to maintain his position.

    WHERE WAS THE CHECKs AND BALANCES THEN?

    again those at the top must have free will to wheel and deal as they please but those at the botton must not.

    No matter how much the BLP tries to tell us that they are for the common people they arguments and policy positions betrays them evertime.


  36. “Where have you gone E. D. Mottley?”

    Wishing in Vain,
    There are no Bovell’s in my family. You must have me confused with someone else, and what’s with the name calling? In two words, “no class”; deal with the issues….

    Adrian Hinds,

    I’m not giving civics lessons at UWI. Are you suggesting that because “those at the top…wheel and deal” with taxpayers money, “those at the bottom” should be given equal opportunity to steal our money as well? You take a 6 for a 9 or what? E. D. Mottley is dead, and we should keep him that way, imposters and all.


  37. @De Gap:
    First we tend to keep the dead alive by reflecting on their lives. Mia and Chelterham did that some several years ago, for E.D.Mottley, Mia again in the last election and in an attempt to gain currency in the Bridgetown constituency, sought to draw on her last name and the legacy of the former mayor to curry favour with electors. So you need to tell that to Mia and others that not me.

    Regarding what you hope i could be suggesting so that you could have something to hold onto. The answer is NO. Either elect the PM and the CC’s or Appoint the PM AND THE CC’S. Not one and not the other.

    You cannot in good conscience be arguing for electing the CC’s from a non partisan view of what democracy is all about, and at the same time condone the appointment of the Leader of the country, and give him much power to boot.


  38. So who will be attending the BLP meeting tonight at holders hill?

    Questions fuh dem:

    Did the people elect a Leader of the opposition?

    Did the people elect a Prime Minister?

    If the Parliament of Barbados is to be the supreme legislative body of Barbados, what provisions will be made to make an elected council person answer to the supreme legislative body in Barbados?

    Really why should we elect a council person, and cannot elect a prime minister?

    …and don’t let them get away with that foolishness about the PrimeMinister is elected twice by the people. It is nonsense. A simple retort would be “I have never seen the office or position of Prime Minister on a ballot during an election exercise that I as a qualified Elector can make a choice.


  39. @AH

    We hope a BU family member will have the time to report on the meeting.


  40. Maybe the thought of the rain affected the attendance there this evening but from reports reaching me state that it was very sparsely attended, my usually reliable report is that at its height the max that were there were 200 with five stray cats and two stray dogs sleeping around her, actually one reporter suggested the talk in the rum shop was more enlightening than the political meeting, but then again if Mottley was the speaker the rum shop may prove more informative, as one may suggest that Owing would have been the speaker and the drinker in the rum shop.
    This thing has not yet learnt that she, owing see thru and the rest of them got tossed out for gross corruption against the state and the taxpayers of Barbados.
    She will eventually learn when to oppose and when to lay down ( some would suggest she knows when to lay down already ) but in a political sense that is.
    Opposing just for the sake of opposing is her sickness.


  41. my usually reliable report is that at its height the max that were there were 200 with five stray cats and two stray dogs sleeping around her,
    ……………………………………………………….
    Two stray dogs…..Who was the other stray with you Ha Ha.

    Why are you so concern about Mia. Are you in love with her, cause you can do without mentioning her name.


  42. I just left the meeting… And the rum shop at which the discussion was who spoke the worst! Even two of Mia’s branch members who were paid $50.00 to attend said they dropped to sleep. It was a long, wet, cold night.

    It was just gossip and more gossip. It wasn’t funny, the presentation was poor and the Bees had nothing to say! Why was the meeting called? To say what?

    Owen Arthur’s point about Thompson not signing a CARICOM financial services agreement was a non-point. Why didn’t Arthur sign it? He was the CSME guru and its been on the table for three years!

    It is pathetic seeing and hearing a former Prime Minister – discredited for taking a cheque for $75,000.00 from Clico – trying to suggest he was above board and such a great leader. He just doesn’t get it.

    This government needs to investigate the relations between Owen Arthur and Clico in the 2003 election.

    Did he receive that $75,000.00 in 2003 in exchange for granting Clico its licence despite the deficiencies he said existed in its statutory reserve? And then $42,000.00 more in cash in 2008? And declared none of it on his election returns? What did he mean by saying that he helped Clico?

    When Mia came into the shop she quietly said that if that is true – with a twinkle in her eye – someone should be spending some time in jail. No doubt that wold ease her pain.

    Mia was into her usual hypocritical praise of Arthur – which we all know is false and which she said she had to do. Then the rest of her speech was empty and sad.

    I have heard them and next week I will watch tv.


  43. Let’s be fair, the meeting had about 300 people. Enough to fill the Hall at Combermere – a stone’s throw away and no rain.


  44. One that had the guts and strayed away from your camp and now is INDEPENDENTof the wayward BLP.

    I could not give a damn about the 1000 lbs of blubber but rejoice to know that the good people of Barbados had the sharpness of brain to know to kick she and them thru the door for stealing from us the Taxpayers, I admire them for their wisdom.


  45. If I were a pack of dogs I would not let either the 1000 lbs of blubber or Owing lead me anywhere, it could be fatally dangerous.


  46. Wuh?
    Why did they not just hold a town hall meeting it would have kept the paid supporters out of the rain and dry, shame that they hardly care about their loyal friends to hold them out in the rain when the Hall at the school would have held everyone???


  47. Wuh, you sound real credible. So the meeting was a flop? ha ha ha ha Nuh body does can’t record these comments that Mia is said to have made? It’s about time that we put this known divide between Mia and Owen tuh bed, with proof.


  48. Look Wishing In Vain:

    Ya being dishonest (and I am not usually a Mia supporter)

    I had every intention of attending the meeting last night.

    But at about the time the meeting was due to start the rain came down real, real, hard. A real, real September rain (in mid-February).

    I think that maybe ya should blame global warming for the poor attendance.

    Like most Bajans I don’t like getting wet especially on a chillly, windy, rainy February night) so I stay in my house.

    I would not have gone out in that rain to hear David either (nor you)

    So don’t come of this blog and try to fool the bajans overseas who were not here to see how heavy the rain was.

    The truth is that it was not a light shower. It was a real hard, real long rain.

    Which by the way does not describe any part of you.


  49. So J it was devine intervetion? ha ha ha ha. But J wuh is you fixation on things long and hard on a man? and wuh would you seemly wish for such to be on WIV?


  50. @J: “But at about the time the meeting was due to start the rain came down real, real, hard. A real, real September rain (in mid-February).

    Please forgive me for this J, and the entire BU Family…

    But are Bajans solvent in water?

    As in, is there a reason why rain can possibly be an excuse for why everything should stop?

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending