Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Minister of Social Care, Constituency Empowerment and Urban Development
Chris Sinckler, Minister of Social Care, Constituency Empowerment and Urban Development

The controversial Constituency Councils Act 2009 will be debated in our parliament tomorrow. If passed this will be the second most significant policy rollout of the government since gaining office, free school rides for students being the first. The David Thompson led government appears to be quite comfortable in  focusing on social programs.

The Democratic Labour Party (DLP) eased into office on the promise of CHANGE. Also exposing corruption and ensuring that government resources were more efficiently allocated to benefit the PEOPLE by enforcing government’s financial rules to ensure transparency.

We have listened to the current debate regarding the establishment of constituency councils. Leader of the Opposition Mia Mottley has been quite vocal in her criticism that the councils conflict with the role of the member of parliament which is defined in the Constitution of Barbados. Also the wide range of powers the minister is cited to have in the proposed legislation has many believing that this will just be another opportunity for the Democratic Labour Party to distribute largess.

A read of both the BLP and DLP manifestoes suggest that conceptually regarding the decentralization of the provision of certain services to communities, the two are not that far apart. The BLP committed in its 2008 manifesto to upgrade subventions to community based organization. The DLP in keeping with its focus on social programs are about to debate the act which will soon give life to a key campaign promise.

The BU household supports the government in this imitative that will see the PEOPLE at the community level empowered to solve problems in their communities based on an independent budget proposed at $100,000.00. Of concern however is the enormous powers the government through the minister responsible for the councils will have under the act. Members of the councils are nominated, not elected and the minister will or can have the final say on who gets selected.

The importance of demoting Chris Sinckler from the Foreign Affairs ministry is now plain for all to see. If the roll-out of the councils is done well the Democratic Labour Party will be positioned to widen its support base deliberately or otherwise.

The dilemma posed by the enormous powers promised under the Constituency Councils Act is the knowledge that the Douglas Leopold Phillips’ will want to serve on the councils. Prime Minister Thompson did promise that the fatted calf will be slaughtered soon. This is especially true after having to endure the Beresford Leon Padmore troupe for its fourteen year tenure. How can Barbadians be sure that the partisan approach to appointments will not continue?

We appreciate that the logistics of electing 450 members to complete the 30 constituency councils would generate an expensive administrative problem. We also appreciate that the power of the minister under the proposed act to appoint and or approve nominees may encourage the partisan politics to which Barbadians have become accustomed.

If we are to  judge from the attendance at the town hall meetings to discuss the Freedom of Information Act and other recent government proposals, Barbadians seem timid when asked to participate/feedback in their democracy. What makes us feel that my holding elections to select members for the constituency councils that the results couldn’t be contrived?

Managing government in today’s environment has become a complex affair and demands good attention. An efficient system to manage micro-issues which exist in our communities would free-up central government to the bigger issues of the day. Of importance is the fact that ordinary PEOPLE are suppose to be managing the councils.

We hope that this initiative which proposes to involve the PEOPLE more in the governance of their affairs will not become shrouded in a partisan cloud. This government promised change and they will be judged by the PEOPLE in 2013. If the legislation has to go back to the Attorney General’s Office for amendments then so be it.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. @BU Family…

    Let me please take this a step further…

    Are we impotent?

    Do we deserve to be taken advantage of?

    Empirically, the answer is Yes…

    This answer saddens me greatly….

    *PLEASE*… Prove me wrong!


  2. Adrian Hinds // February 16, 2009 at 1:24 pm

    So J it was devine intervetion? ha ha ha ha. But J wuh is you fixation on things long and hard on a man? and wuh would you seemly wish for such to be on WIV?
    ___________________________

    ha ha halol ha ha ha


  3. And the silence is deafening…

    Do any of you have the guts to stand up and speak out, as I did at the FTC Annual Lecture to call Bovine Excrement?

    (And, please note, not mentioned in any the “Fourth Estate”.)

    Or are you all comfortable bent over, thinking of (and paying to) England?

    Moooo!!!!


  4. Dear Chris:

    Some of us don’t have cars, nor raincoats nor umbrellas.

    I don’t know what they do in the place where you were born but no I’ve never stood in heavy rain for an hour for anything or anybody, and I don’t intend to start.

    Actually when I was small I was told that Bajans are made of salt.

    I have never dared to test the hypothesis.

    If I was at the meeting would you have let a strange Bajan (and some people think that I am very, very strange) sit in your car with you?


  5. When Mia going to run for the leadership of her party? If she does she going to lose people so sick of her doubletalk.

    My friend only after Owing is finished dragging her thru the mud forwards and backwards.

    She really does have ba__ls to be critical of CBC this the same person that willfully set about closing off access to CBC from the opposition???

    It makes me laugh indeed, now VOB the media public relations arm of the BLP played smart and carried it even if under the guise of a paid advertisement.

    I have never heard a more desperate sickening bunch of political misfits than this lot so assembled called the blp opposition.

    To carry a public meeting to the level of a Minister of Government being said of that it took him 10 years to gain a degree just about explains the levels of despair that has set into opposition politics, but I suppose if coupled with the fact that they have already seen one defector in Hammy Lashley who has seen no wrong in the method or programs of this new Government, it irks at their soul if one can suggest that Mottley, Owing etal have a soul, some may suggest it was sold to the highest bidder sometime ago maybe to change the zoning of lands from zone 1 to non zone 1, but that is another matter.

    More importantly is the fact that the person they cast lies on is a 100 times more effective a representative than what was there before, that is true for just about every elected member of the DLP, meanwhile the blp is crying over might have been had they won the Government last year, more stealing more corruption more women getting work for work under mottley, more work for work under Glyne Clarke.


  6. Here is an intersting piece of news for you.
    http://www.independent.co.uk/

    Fast-food nation: KFC bucks trend with 9,000 new jobs

    Britain’s employment map transformed as recession-hit consumers trade down

    By Michael Savage, Political correpondent

    The fast-food outlet KFC it is to create up to 9,000 jobs, providing further evidence that British consumers are opting for cheaper ways of dining out during the recession.

    The chain of fried chicken stores, which currently employs about 20,000 people in its 760 British stores, said it was making an investment of up to £150m in an expansion drive that will see it open between 200 and 300 restaurants in the next three to five years.

    It is the latest high-street fast-food chain to defy the economic downturn with expansion plans after seeing sales in 2009 show a 14 per cent rise on last year. A new drive-through store which opened last month broke the company’s record for sales in an opening week, taking £100,000.

    Other fast-food stores, takeaway chains and budget supermarkets have been expanding their slice of their respective markets as shoppers tighten their purse strings. Last month, the sandwich chain Subway announced plans to open 600 stores in the UK and Ireland, creating 7,000 jobs.

    The pizza delivery service Domino’s recently announced that its sales for last year had increased by 10 per cent as more Britons chose to buy take-away food rather than dine out to cut their outgoings. McDonald’s saw European sales increase by 7.6 per cent during the last quarter of 2008, in the midst of the credit crunch. The budget supermarket Lidl also revealed it was expanding its operations in Britain earlier this month. It is opening 50 stores and creating 2,000 jobs after experiencing its most successful Christmas ever, with takings at the “no frills” store increasing by more than 11 per cent last month.

    KFC will open most of the stores in north England and south Wales, while some of the investment drive will go towards refurbishing its current outlets. Some of the new stores will be franchises, with each store employing between 25 and 40 people.

    “There aren’t many companies who can be so positive in this market so we are delighted to be able to announce this significant investment,” said Martin Shuker, the firm’s UK chief executive. “Our growth strategy demonstrates the strong demand from our customers; consumers clearly still want great quality food but at reasonable prices and that is exactly what we provide.”

    The announcement has also led to fears that more skilled jobs are being replaced by unskilled, part-time positions. Many of the new jobs will be for workers earning the minimum wage of £5.73 an hour. It came soon after the car maker BMW revealed that it was axing 850 jobs at its Mini construction plant in Cowley, Oxfordshire. It is predicted that about 6,750 of the new jobs at KFC will be among bottom level “team members”, such as chefs and cashiers.

    The TUC’s general secretary, Brendan Barber, said the Government should guard against the development of a trend towards the replacement of skilled jobs with unskilled and low-paid positions. “It’s encouraging that profitable companies are using their wealth to create new jobs, rather than hoarding it amongst shareholders,” he said. “Skilled jobs should lie at the heart of the economic recovery and it’s vital that the Government creates incentives for companies to bring more high-skilled work into the UK.”

    Mr Shuker said there would be some skilled jobs included in the KFC expansion. About 900 manager and assistant manager positions will also be created.

    “What we do is encourage as many people as we can to come and work at KFC and develop their career,” he said.


  7. Here is another interesting piece of news for you.

    http://www.independent.co.uk/

    Home buyers up for third month in row

    By James Daley, Personal finance editor

    Tuesday, 17 February 2009

    The number of buyers in the UK housing market increased for the third month in a row during February, providing new hope that property prices may be close to bottoming out.

    According to a new report – published today by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (Rics) – the number of inquiries by new buyers has been rising consistently since November, with most new purchasers claiming they have been attracted back to the market by lower prices.

    Average house prices have fallen by more than 20 per cent since their peak in the summer of 2007, according to the Halifax, and by more than 17 per cent over the past year. However, prices saw their first month-on-month increase for almost a year during January – which supports Rics’ claim that buyers are now returning to the market.

    Rics said that the majority of new buyers have been existing homeowners who are upgrading to larger properties. It said new build properties failed to attract significant interest.

    However, Rics said it was not convinced this represented a permanent change in the market’s fortunes.

    “Interest from owner occupiers is likely to persist over the coming months as those with large deposits look to capitalise on the drop in house prices,” said Simon Rubinsohn, the chief economist at Rics.

    “However, a sharply deteriorating employment picture may … push potential buyers back to the sidelines. To help restore an orderly housing market, the Government urgently needs to address the issue of the availability of mortgage finance. It is essential that guarantees for residential, mortgage-backed securities are introduced sooner rather than later.”


  8. @J: “Some of us don’t have cars, nor raincoats nor umbrellas.

    And yet we live in a country which often experiences rain…

    To share, I, personally, do not own a car. I do, however, own an umbrella.

    It would seem reasonable that one who lives in a country which often encounters rain might invest the BDS $20 to do the same…

    @J: “Actually when I was small I was told that Bajans are made of salt. I have never dared to test the hypothesis.

    Empirically, that’s pretty stupid. Wouldn’t you agree?

    If Bajans really believe that they will melt in the rain, then what hope have we against those who also live in regions with frequent rain, but somehow manage to continue doing business?

    @J: “I don’t know what they do in the place where you were born…

    I was born, raised, and trained in British Columbia, Canada.

    There, we call rain “liquid sunshine”.

    And there, we always got on with our jobs, no matter the H2O present, beating the s**t out of those not prepared to do the same…

    @BU Family…

    I now find myself here. In Barbados. Trying to (and taking some personal risk to) fight your corner…

    But, to tell you the truth, I sometimes find myself frustrated fighting for those who won’t even risk getting wet….


  9. Aaaaaah Chris dont be like that, some of us are worth fighting for.

    Bajans are like this ……… if it doesn’t bother them its not their problem. On the other hand, there are persons like myself and you (plus others) who will represent.

    Chins up CH! lol


  10. Chris i wish you luck. Over the years of blogging, I was often times challenge with the now common refrain “why you don’t return home and stop the complaining from afar?” to which i just laugh. Our island is awashed with persons who have been conditioned to be dependent on one person or the other, usually politicians, and i have seen people die fighting on behalf of this lot, to no avail. I will not be so foolish. This fight requires force in numbers, and until i see people rising up for themselves, I gine stand right here and complain as usual. It is said that the Lord help those who endevour to help themselves. I aint gine try to out do God!


  11. Can someone explain Leonard St.Hill for me? It is written in English yet it remains a mystery as to it’s meaning, it’s points, and even the subjects contain therein. It may have been written well, but it fails significantly in communicating it’s author’s ideas and thoughts. I think Mr. St.Hill is for Community Councils but I am not sure!
    ————————————————-

    Grave danger in sticking to monopoly of governance
    Published on: 2/19/09.

    DESPITE the good for which men are praised, the evil that they do lives after them.

    In this context, it is futile to hope that a Democratic Labour Party administration of the only Government of Barbados, wedded as it is in 2009 to an iconic whim in 1969, would endeavour to promote the restoration of the institution of local government.

    No partisan Dem, Barbadian-born and wholly bred since 1969, would have the basis for comparison of this country with and without the operation of local government authorities duly elected in the usual “democratic” manner, or the efficacy of double member constituencies.

    He or she would not be aware of the petulance that drove the iconic Right Honourable and gallant gentlemen to strip the Mayor of Bridgetown of the establishment of the City Council because there was other means of separating him from it.

    Just as remarkable a disappointment is the dissipation of the resolve of the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) to restore the institution of local government authority during 25 years in power to do so.

    In the ears of the apostles of the democratic icon, the rhetoric of the Preamble to the Barbados Independence Order 1966 rings hollow as the clapper strikes.

    “Whereas with the broadening down of freedom, the people of Barbados have ever since (1651) not only successfully resisted any attempt to impugn or diminish those rights and privileges so confirmed, but have consistently enlarged and extended them:

    “Now therefore the people of Barbados . . . declare their intention to establish and maintain a society in which all persons may to the full extent of their capacity, play a due part in the institutions of the national life.”

    The abolition of elected local government authority is neither the vaunted broadening down of freedoms and privileges enjoyed before 1966; nor their enlargement and extension since then.

    “The price of freedom is eternal vigilance”. Any trend towards monopoly is more ominous in the politics of governance than the management of commerce and trade by private enterprise.

    – LEONARD ST HILL


  12. Agree with you Adrian that Mr. St. Hill needs to write with clarity. As confused as you about his article.


  13. David
    “There is a big question mark about the representation by our MPs.”

    I have to say that most MPs are under-resourced and as a result find themselves under very serious pressure. Representation is definitely (de facto) compromised.

    The Councils can serve to ease that pressure, especially if it offers programmes and empower the groups and organisations within the communities to conduct programmes.

    Now while the proposed establishment and structure may not be democratic in itself, it is still democratic in the sense that if you ask an organisation to nominate a person, then the organisation itself will choose its representative. It would also have a chain of command elected by the group.

    Each organisation has a democratic base and hence the democratic process is in place. BANGO argued strongly that election of persons to sit on the Councils would not target community needs, from the point of view that too many people without an interest may very well find themselves elected on the Council. In such a case, it will become a power struggle with the groups and the organisations; which would become sidelined.

    In arguing this point, we noted that the groups and the organisations which were catering to the community, represents not only interests but effort and initiative to start to do something about a community problem.

    These organisations are in the know in the community and can best bring the community together too. These are the persons who because of their track record are experts in the field, so why alienate them in preference to some “ego-tripper”?

    If therefore we were to genuinely reach the people, then the best way is through communnity groups. The problem is that not all communities have a lot of groups but then you have individuals who do things in the community voluntarily, but the community will look to them for expertise in his/her particular area of skill or expertise or even local knowledge.

    The primary source of policy and decision making comes through the local knowledge and expertise which exist in the communities. You cannot just change; otherwise you may end up with another Pelican Village or Cheapside Market; even Eagle Hall.

    Therefore, from our point of view, it would make practical sense to reach the problems through the people that can do something about them, and therefore allow community groups and those persons with local knowledge (recommended by the community itself), to serve.


  14. We must see the councils for what they are. We should work with which ever Government is in office and certainly if our Government ask us to serve we should serve.

    They take our taxes which is supposed to benefit us and therefore, “B” or “D” we must be vigilant.

    This is nothing more than another Government programme. It just should not enter the arena of democratic ideology; that is not the proposal, the proposal is about change. Its basic principle is engaging the people more. It cannot be seen as anything more.

    Our biggest problem is the inclusion of the political parties on the Councils as Ex Officio members. That is a problem. All I can say is that I hope that maturity will prevail but right now, it is the biggest threat to the success of the Councils and if it is no threat, well then, good!

    As citizens it is our duty to be vigilant. If the system of constituency councils proves to be too political and can’t be corrected, then our suggestion is to leave them alone… but before it gets there, the Council should meet with the Parties separately and not at Council meetings.


  15. The system that went before was based on hand-picking. Even during the time of the BLP, BANGO is on record publicly complaining about the handpicking and favouritism which went on. Too many people were picking their friends.

    Funny enough, when it came to the PM’s Office in its dealing with Civil Society, most times it referred these matters to BANGO. There was still some hand-picking and sometimes a stubborn approach to BANGO recommendations. I think in times like these they wanted the credit, so they would go off and implement the recommendations as though they were theirs. Serious politics.


  16. Leonard St.Hill has written a beautiful piece of prose as usual. It is indeed written in English with correct spelling and punctuation, I must add. It communicates exactly what he wants to say, and very clearly to me. I see no mystery at all with respect to what has been said . But then……….


  17. ROK our fear about the rollout of the CC like most things in Barbados of late is the political partisan climate which seems to be developing at the expense of the benefit of what is being proposed.


  18. David,

    The partisanship is not in the CCs alone as you identified. As I said, the greatest danger to the success of the CCs is the presence of political party representatives on the CCs and this is a deliberate move by Government.

    I heard Dugid complaining about things happening in the constituency that the opposion MPs don’t know about. All I can tell him is welcome to opposition politics… but if ordinary citizens are going to the Government Departments to get assistance, you mean that the Civil servants must call up the MPs and notify them? Would that be professional?

    That is exactly what happened with UDC and RDC under the BLP watch, you didn’t get that help unless the politicians said so. It was the politicians who prioritised the assistance rather than priority going to the most needy.

    Now, Given the nature of the beast, there is no way that two opposing parties will spare any effort to get their programmes bankrolled through the Council unless the budget is allocated into categories and even then, they will want the most out of each allocated head.

    Having a Chairman appointed by the Minister is also a measure of further Gov’t control. A Chairman will be able to overrule an entire committee under these kinds of circumstances. Of course the members of the CCs can complain to the Minister, even go public, if they can get together; so this is a check.

    By the same token, you may find a fair chair, or one who is brave enough to ensure that the people are heard and that they get what they want in a fair share of the resources. It makes the Councils unbalanced and dependent on who is chair.

    The most important thing is what practices will prevail. Right now it is heavily stacked on Government’s side and to them it would make for sensible politics. Hence one can see that Gov’t has not succumbed to a raw democratic process in the operation of the CCs either, most likely out of the fear that they may fall into the hands of the opposition forces.

    How will you get over that when the ruling party has to be always on the lookout for encroachments by the opposing party to make themselves look good or even embarrass the ruling party? Just the nature of politics.

    This comes back to the point of the empowerment of Civil Society Organisations and to understand that Civil Society has to be able to use its freedoms as a check on the partisan politics, despite any provisions in the legislation. This calls for eternal vigilance and brave souls. The question is, are we the people ready and willing to balance the forces at work, or will we just get what we can and come away thankful? The most extreme scenario is that we end up with 30 wars going on all across Barbados.


  19. David

    The option to reply to an individual post that does not attach itself to the bottom of the thread may be a bit offsetting and may cause active bloggers to have to scroll through the thread just to find the latest comment.


  20. Georgie Porrgie // February 24, 2009 at 8:14 pm

    Leonard St.Hill has written a beautiful piece of prose as usual. It is indeed written in English with correct spelling and punctuation, I must add. It communicates exactly what he wants to say, and very clearly to me. I see no mystery at all with respect to what has been said . But then……….
    ===========================
    Would you care to enlighened us on what he meant? I know, I think i do,… but would have preferred for him to be man enought to say it clearly.


  21. […] position on the relevance of the CCs was highlighted earlier. Any entity which is designed to encourage a wider public participation in any democracy […]

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading