Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

The breaking news that COB CEO Steve Belle has been suspended by the newly minted Board is not a trivial matter; it is a significant event for members and non‑members alike. A suspension at that level signals an investigation with enough gravitas that the Board felt compelled to suspend a long tenured executive. In the cooperative movement, where trust is key, such a move is of serious concern.

For decades, the credit union movement has been one of Barbados’ few genuine economic success stories – it represents a financial model that has enfranchised many Black Barbadians shut out of traditional banking.There is the potential for the proud legacy of the cooperative movement to be smeared.

And while the audited financials show no material weaknesses or adverse findings, the public does not read audit notes; the public only sees instability. This is where the Financial Services Commission (FSC) should be flexing. The FSC’s mandate is not only regulation but to nurture confidence building. Silence from the regulator in this moment leaves a vacuum that rumour, innuendo, and political mischief will happily fill, especially in the era of social media.

The blogmaster’s suspicion is this a clash between senior management and a new Board eager to assert control. But those “in the know” at City of Bridgetown credit union must understand that even loyal members grow skittish when it comes to who should guard personal savings . A credit union is not an office where decisions are made in a controlled bubble; it is a financial institution where perception alone can trigger a run on deposits.

The matter needs swift, transparent resolution. Any inflated egos in the COB boardroom should be deflated by dispassionate members. A word to the wise should be sufficient.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

57 responses to “COB CEO fallout could destabilize the credit union sector”

  1. Terence Blackett Avatar

    LOOK HOW THE MIGHTY ARE FALLEN

    When certain “DAMNABLE TRUTHS” come to light – everyone on that LIL ROCK & farther afield will know who Steve Belle really is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    At this mo’, I will reserve commentary & allow #LongAwaiting “DUE PROCESS” to take its course given the “UNTOLD” misery this man has caused & the venal sophistry of his actions in ruining someone I love dearly!!!

    WHEN I HEARD THE FANTASTIC NEWS A COUPLE DAYZ AGO – I BURST INTO A PENTECOSTAL FRENZY – THROWING UP TIMBER TO THE MOST HIGH ABOVE

    Like 16th century “REFORMER” Martin Luther who opined that he did not march an army of soldiers up to the gates of the Vatican to remove the “POPE” – but simply “WROTE”, “PREACHED” & “PRAYED” and the Catholic Church “FELL” – then suffered a “DEADLY WOUND” that came to a “HEAD” in 1798, when General Berthier walked into the Vatican – “ARRESTED” the Pontiff & dragged his “ARSE” off to France where he died in exile!!!

    Folks can “RUN DAY – TILL NITE CATCH UP WID EM” (citing my late precious Grandma)!!!

    ALL WICKED BASTERDS WILL HAVE THEIR DAY OF COMEUPPANCE

    The Bushman calls it “KARMA”, but her BIG BRO* is called “VENGEANCE” & He delivers “SWIFT JUSTICE”!!!

    First it was the acting Comptroller of Customs who felt the weight of “POWERFUL” prayers & “PSALMIST RETRIBUTION” – now, the #ShiiiitHead called Steve Belle…

    We all know who’s “NEXT”!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    On that rather simplified note

    IMDUN*


  2. What nonsense from a local reporter!

    One who DARE NOT write a shiite about the $60 million missing from HOPE housing, the $millions unaccounted in STEAL Housing, the saga of Radical COVID vaccines, the ridiculous CARIFESTA ‘spendingmania’, or even about who actually told the Circus that it was OK to set up in the wannabe Botanical gardens…

    However a CEO in a credit union going on special leave, …where members have the benefit of an independent Supervisory Committee, an independent Regulator, …and the all powerful option to call a Special General Meeting to make whatever decisions they choose, is ‘in danger of destabilization’ because a CEO was sent on leave?!!
    What a joke!!

    If this occurred at one of our foreign-owned entities the ‘story’ would have a ten centimeter note on page 15.
    Black people NEVER cease to amaze stinking Bushie!

    A Board of Directors have every right to investigate whatever matters they see fit. This is PRECISELY why $60 million is NOT missing at any Credit Union, and why their accounts are audited and published EVERY damn year.
    It is only obvious that a long-standing CEO, who was actually due for retirement a while ago, would be asked to stand aside while such an investigation is conducted.
    This effectively occurs routinely whenever a CEO takes holiday in a well run organization. If there is nothing to be found out – just enjoy the damn beach time.

    Instead of writing shiite about things that she clearly do not understand, what Ms Bradshaw should be writing about is suggestions that a SIMILAR action be taken in our Parliamentary circles – so that we can have proper investigations into the MULTITUDE of scams being perpetrated on the Consolidated Fund …while even the known CLICO king is still walking bout the damn place free as a bird… apparently on lifetime ‘leave’…

    Steupsss
    Looka piss in the blogmaster’s pocket do!!!

    What a place!!


  3. @TB

    A person in a court of law is supposed to be innocent until proven guilty. You are aware there is a credit committee whose role is to approve loans?


  4. @Bush Tea

    You have posited a self defeating argument. You cannot compare a credit union to a bank. Two different animals.


  5. @ David
    HUH??!! What bank?

    It is about a Board exercising its fiduciary responsibility in Barbados FOR A CHANGE.

    Wunna too accustomed to COVERING UP shiite …until all the money done get thief, the place rotten down (like Four Seasons,) and then there is just ‘Clear Waters’…

    If the Board of ‘East West North South Construction’ or of Hope Housing had acted like COB’s Board, all like now we would either have ACTUAL Steel houses and Hope houses – or we money would be still in the damn treasury.

    When Bushie talk about Bajans being BRASS and encouraging shiite, this is what the bushman means…

    Thank God that our Credit Unions still have leaders of PRINCIPLE and BALLS to carry out their assigned duties fearlessly… even in ‘La La Land’ where idiocy prevails.

    If Belle is truly worth his salt and has indeed done nothing wrong as he says, than what the Hell is there to shout about?
    What other COB CEO would now operate like the HOPE CEO did? … knowing now how the credit union operates?

    What we, especially the damn Press, should shout about is… that our highest Board – shaped as a ‘Cabinet’, clearly has no such balls or principles.

    What an inverted place!!


  6. @Bush Tea

    There is nothing wrong with the Board doing what it has to, the point you are failing to grasp – and the blogmaster’s point- if it is not dealt with swiftly, there will be consequences. It is a financial institution where success is hinged to members/customers confidence.


  7. “…if it is not dealt with swiftly, there will be consequences.”
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Give it up Boss.
    You must KNOW that you are barking up the wrong tree…

    It is PRECISELY because this is being dealt with swiftly by the new Board that this matter is being highlighted. And Bushie’s blind guess is that the new Board is there because MEMBERS wanted swift assurance that their Credit Union is NOT being run like the damn country.

    You want ‘swifter’ than a Board moving to get FACTS after their very first meeting?

    Bushie predicts that all will turn out to be well, Belle will enjoy his holiday …and return to continue the good work at COB.

    What can you say in comparison about HOPE …and STEAL…and Four Seasons… and BWA… and CBC… and BAMC…. and CARIFESTA?

    What a scam!


  8. ‘is ‘in danger of destabilization’ because a CEO was sent on leave?!!
    What a joke!!”

    Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.

    The joke is on the joker. You need to reread the WHOLE article carefully and leave the woman alone.


  9. @Bush Tea

    The blogmaster does not know anything. As of this minute the issue is unresolved. Whether the matter is being dealt with swiftly is left to be seen when the final decision is taken.


  10. Where in the WOMAN / reporter’s report did she mention or slightly insinuated anything about destabilization?


  11. @John 2

    Bush Tea is understandably upset because he has been preaching the benefits of the cooperative approach for years in this space. And most agree that it is an ideal way to approach things.

    What he fails to accept is that a board of the second largest credit union suspending the CEO in Barbados is a big deal, it doesn’t matter if it turns out. All of us hop that it ends well because as stated by the blogmaster, it has wider implications.


  12. Why the need to focus on Caswell’s silence?
    Who have spoken about Hope? Carifesta etc?

    Belle says there is nothing to see – why publish comment about his having ‘done no wrong’? …to send what subliminal message?
    Who commented about the HOPE $millions that are KNOWN to be missing?

    So where is the woman’s report on the Hope project – now YEARS old and unresolved?
    Where is the report on the Radical vaccine scam? …which we only know of it because American courts seem to work…
    Where is the report on the many million spent on Carifesta?

    There is no need to mention destabilization here – the country now has to borrow, beg, and plead for ‘reparations’ as a result of these leakages…

    On the other hand, COB’s is a routine management process that PROACTIVELY prevents things like the lotta shiite that seems to be endemic bout here…

    Such management should be PRAISED and encouraged – not called out as a weakness… at least by those of us with clean hands.

    @ David
    Bushie cares nothing about COB.
    Suspend shiite!! …more subliminal messages…
    …Sending an official on paid leave is STANDARD good management practice.

    It is about a matter of PRINCIPLE!!!
    Bushie calls a spade a spade. If the COB Board’s approach was applied to Barbados, it is clear that we would be a lot more like Singapore…than like a Parro…

    But wunna want to plant sour grass …and reap sweet potatoes – but um don’t wuk so…


  13. @Bush Tea

    Allow us to disagree. When there was discord in the Barbados Public Workers a few years ago, we highlighted it in this space as well.

    It is worth commenting on even if you do not agree. Again, here is hoping the issue is resolved quickly.


  14. Did she lie on Caswell or attributed something to him that was false?
    Did Caswell objected to being quoted -I am sure he was well aware who he was talking to and that what he said/didn’t say would be reported.

    As a one of the longest bloggers on BU you should know about the eye catching headlines . If u call a spade a spade then u should admit that u are wrong and the FEMALE reporter never slightly insinuated anything about “ destabilization “.

    The WOMAN reportS on what she was assigned . The topics that u mentioned are old ( in the news cycle ) unless something new pops up.
    Can u state as a fact that this WOMAN reporter or her company NEVER reported on those topic the u are stuck on? Again , she reports on topics she is assigned / approved.

    I thank the lady for the article and the David for publishing it. I am not a member of COB but I know of member and workers there. Beside that being a member of the public workers and as a Bajan in general it good to know what’s going on

    I would put my head on the block that some of the things that u are writing about that u got the information from the same article.

    The WOMAN reporter did an excellent job! There are other things to report on besides politics and other audiences to satisfy.

    HER job is to help sell papers not satisfy Stinking Bushie


  15. @ John 2
    Steupsss!
    You probably still waiting with baited breath on the PM’s promised a HOPE report too…
    You should call yourself ‘John 2 naive’.
    Bushie don’t have that kinda shiite faith.

    “Mr Belle referred us to the new president, and new Board member Caswell Franklyn was unable to comment on the issue.”
    This is what would have been written if this was about Goddards or even Massy.

    @ David
    Public Workers incident?
    You mean when the FSC attempted to destroy that outstanding institution over what turned out to be a supplementary report that was a few months overdue?
    An FSC that has nothing to say about the TOTAL lack of reporting of the NISSS…?
    That has no comment on the stalled PAC or un-appointed Auditor General or Four Seasons…?
    That actually attempted to support BLPC’s court defense in the case of the missing $100m Insurance Funds that the FTC wants repaid…?

    Skippa…
    Just like the mentally enslaved Press, they too only have teeth when the infringements – or even just the appearance of abnormality – is with Black businesses.

    But Bushie really thought that most on BU were a bit more ‘enlightened…’

    What a place!!

    Anyway – the Boss will be sorting this all out, …and much sooner than we all think.


  16. Bushie

    Man admit yuh did wrong about putting “ destabilizing “ on the WOMAN . YUH JOKER. Instead of going all over the world.

    Yuh lie again.
    First -J2 never wait on anything from a politician. And especially something that have no effect on me.

    2. I am awaiting for u to show where the reported said or insulated anything about destabilization

    3. I also awaiting for u to published here on BU any evidence ( printed or video) of MIA promising anyone a HOPE REPORT .

    Here is my promise to u: Do #3 and I will not comment on BU again


  17. @John2
    You serious???

    https://barbadostoday.bb/2025/03/13/mia-says-hope-investigation-is-still-coming/amp/

    And this is just one found with a 20 second search. There are at least two other times on recall.

    @Bushie
    Only bout hey!

    @David
    The salient point of the post is taken. Moving the top boss responsible for millions of dollar will raise eyebrows. As you say, hopeful swift resolution is best for all.

    Bushie’s point about the 4th estate needs to be shouted from the mountaintops.

    Just observing


  18. @Bush Tea

    Whether you want to admit it or not, how COB responds to this matter could have wider consequences, this cannot be refuted. McClean and others dismissing concerns are exposing a bias by trivializing the matter. We note because of his privileged position, he shared that BELLE was sent on administrative leave and not suspended/

    We wait.


  19. @John 2

    I t is a matter of public record the prime minister promised to commission an investigation into HOPE. She subsequently reported that the delay was due to the Auditor General’s Office handing the files that were required to complete the investigation.


  20. Thanks to David Ellis for highlighting this blog today for at minimum awareness. It brought to light a few things that those responsible should note:

    The importance of clarifying inaccurate information in the public place. In this case public can be defined as COB members.

    The importance of the role of the FSC in its watchdog and oversight role. FSC’s role should not be defined as direct intervention in the issue at hand, but releasing subtle industry building messaging to assuage concerns.

    Lastly but there are others, sensitizing the public/members the awesome responsibility it has to ring fence the core mandate of the credit union, especially from those padding resumes.


  21. I ask for “ where Mia promised a REPORT to anyone “
    I am getting “ Mia promised AN INVESTIGATION in hope”

    In all due respect. REPORT and INVESTIGATION are not the same thing to me

    Can I have where Mia promised that after the investigation she will make the report public?

    I guess u guy are still awaiting the report on the investigation of the gun at airport incident and also the burning of the fire truck

    And yes David I know what u are going to say …… transparency etc and I may agree with u but…..not wishing and hoping with u .


  22. @John 2

    You need to let it go, the PM promised to report back on the issue to the public she serves.


  23. @ John 2
    “1. ….
    2. I am awaiting for u to show where the reported said or insulated anything about destabilization
    3. I also awaiting for u to published here on BU any evidence ( printed or video) of MIA promising anyone a HOPE REPORT .”
    Here is my promise to u: Do #3 and I will not comment on BU again
    ~~~~~~~~~~~~
    On item 3, Please DO NOT keep your promise to stop posting on BU.!!!
    Technically, it was Observing and NOT stinking Bushie who brought the evidence… so you good to stay..! LOL

    On Item 2, The article may not have insulated anything about destabilization, but it was full on INSINUATIONS of wrong-doings and gave strong subliminal hints at “something being ‘rung”..
    As an example…
    “…It is also understood that a board member who voted against Belle’s suspension was busy yesterday trying to garner 50 signatures to call a special general meeting…”

    Such would NEVER be said, in such ways, about ‘other’ businesses by local reporters.

    @ David
    Nobody refutes that “how COB responds to this matter could have wider consequences”.
    Obviously so…!

    But if the Press jump-starts the process with negative insinuations, based on “it is understood that…” – well BEFORE the credit union gets a chance to make a formal statement, then BU’s duty is to provide adequate BALANCE in the meantime …

    The professional thing to do is a short FACTUAL statement that the CEO was sent on leave, and that a statement from the new Board is expected soon.

    BTW… tell John 2 that he should stay on BU…
    …cause he don’t ever believe one shiite that stinking Bushie says…
    LOL
    ha ha ha
    Murduh do!!


  24. @BU

    We must acknowledge that it is a financial institution reliant on customer confidence for its survival. However, it is perplexing that a newly appointed Board of Directors would prioritize sending a CEO on administrative leave as their initial action. Given Belle’s proximity to retirement, it raises concerns about the potential reputational damage. Many stakeholders are closely monitoring this situation, and it is hoped that it will not escalate to legal proceedings.

  25. NorthernObserver Avatar

    Is the issue a rookie Board? They can suspend the CEO, yet to do so without an accompanying statement, immediately opens the door of speculation. Pre-retirement leave? Common these days. Their (in?)actions only open them to firefighting, whether cause is justifiable or not.
    Leaving the suspended CEO to say “I haven’t done anything wrong” only places the Board in defence mode. Rule 1 is to get out in front of news.


  26. @ Northern O
    Wait Boss…
    You is some kinda Psychic or wuh?

    Dat is EXACTLY the problem with Credit Unions in general… rookie Boards. This is the result of a dirty scheme by our Black politicians, to keep credit union Boards permanently in ‘learning modes’ – by forcing ridiculous term limits on Board members -whether members want it or not.

    So, just as a Board member acquires enuff experience to be effective in running a hundred million dollar credit union, the laws and the FSC, stipulate that, no matter how well that director performed, they must step aside and a new person has to be elected.

    This was the genesis of the Public Workers issue last year too…

    The FSC imposes NO SUCH requirement on ANY other type of entity, …but perhaps the politicians and / or the albino-centric businesses represented on the FSC may feel challenged by the unmatchable POWER that the co-op movement can exert if they were to ever catch themselves and wake up.

    A more experienced Board would likely have had the CEO quietly ‘volunteer’ to take outstanding vacation leave – “in order to facilitate an internal audit to confirm that things are as they should be, at the beginning of their new term”.

    At least Bajans are coming to recognize that we have some home-grown Billion-dollar operations that actually have transparency and ethics rules, up-to-date accounting audits, and that show a surplus every year – despite going overboard to serve member needs.

    If only we had a government with anywhere near similar results.


  27. @NO

    Apparently we are learning that he was sent on administrative leave.


  28. Perhaps there is nothing to fret about until details of the case are released..
    Perhaps this is why the details are not being released..

    To clarify it is no big deal to get excited about except to wait and watch for an announcement


  29. That guy in the video speaking about the COB or GOB ?


  30. Murduh! …Sounding more and more like good management to Bushie…
    If only we had similar in government…

    Remember when a new administration told us about various infelicities, and promised investigations and court action once they were elected…
    Seems like that investigation instead produced an ally in ‘Materialism And Money’
    … but we never learned of the great attributes that were uncovered after election.
    In fact a couple of the ‘architects’ of the lost decade are now managers of the new dispensation.

    COB, on the other hand, appears to be adhering to the PRINCIPLES of cooperatives.

    What a light among the political darkness!


  31. @Bush Tea

    Time will tell.


  32. Reading between the lines which is also known as speculating or wild ass guessing based on data and statistical probabilities of CEOs worldwide where majority are old stale pale white males good old boys jolly good fellows, CEOs are often critcised for bullying by disgruntled workers or sexual misconduct allegations by woman who feel they have been ignored or subordinated, overworked underpaid, undervalued etc etc. Or changes may be political due to the new board who want to implement their own regime. An investigation followed by an announcement is due process.


  33. @ David
    Did you see the video of Caswell calling out the NISSS with respect to the payment of pensions to persons who delayed making due claims?

    What a Man among brass nuh!!
    …and it is NOT about himself personally (he got fired so many times that he probably has been struck off the pension roll LOL))

    Can you see why Bushie admires this BB Caswell?
    Do you see why the bushman was predisposed to believe that the COB board (including Caswell) would not be doing shiite…?

    Skippa…
    If we had about six more Caswells – this place would be SOOOOO different.
    …just 12 more balls….!!!

  34. Good men out, crooks olin Avatar
    Good men out, crooks olin

    Let me add a little madness
    COB doing well
    Clear the top men out
    Ease in a few crooks
    COB not doing so well
    4 30-0 in your RH


  35. If there has been a singular constant within co-op culture is the propensity to breed a type of demigod who would have hardly so arrived in the dominant financial culture.

    And once we’ve had long-serving little men/women in perceived positions of power, for too long, feelings of being larger than life seem to become dominant.

    Before this Belle we had a McClean who was no different.

    And its that same culture of co-ops, a culture which at base suggests real economic democracy, which has often been guided by whisper campaigns, plots and other nefarious political means by which boards of directions and members of committees – credit and supervisory – are elected.

    These are par for course we imagine. Still, there are far worse shenanigans which could have been happening.

    This writer recently reviewed an assignment where a much higher orders of malfeasances were occurring within a country in the near-abroad. Where the central bank, as regulator, had to be involved through the imposition of several receivers to manage credit union affairs.

    One union even had a branch where every employee was helping themselves to members’ funds, making loans to their friends based on the assets of other members with the presented co-signors being totally aware. The conspiracy was such that employees were signing off on all manner of criminal malfeasances for one another.

    We’ll like to suppose that conditions within Barbados are no way as dire as those outlined. However, if we come to understand how much worse they can become a high or higher fence would be constructed. These are not the times to rely on notions of honesty!


  36. What a non-point argued by Pacha above!

    In which human organization do we not see the emergence of demigods – wherever the slightest opportunity presents itself?

    Why would a cooperative be any less susceptible to this tendency?
    So why go on to build such a ridiculous strawman – and then to give some nebulous external example – in which you were involved?

    If there is a ‘singular constant’ within the co-op culture, it has been the consummate EASE with which such unsavory breeds have been brought to heel… by supervisory committees, regulators, groups of concerned members, and mostly by the impressive PRINCIPLES that regulate ALL co-operatives.

    It is precisely because of the co-op’s INBUILT democratic systems and transparent methods, that issues are caught early enuff to be addressed BEFORE things like HOPE, STEAL houses, Carifesta, Four Seasons, and such expensive disasters can happen.

    This is a POSITIVE… unlike in what you call the “dominant financial culture”, where secrecy, thieving, bribery, blackmail, and fraud are the ACCEPTED norm – and these are all done ‘quietly and respectably’ – like using ‘political contributions’ cheques and cash.
    Shiite! Up to now we still don’t know what really happened at Greenland, or to the bales confiscated from Carcicot that was under lock and key by the BDF – far less to the $millions gone behind carifesta.

    Instead of praising the clearly SUPERIOR co-operative philosophy, …you gone off with petty name-calling and baseless insinuations – about what is surely a local outstanding success.

    Boss, perhaps one of the most impressive aspects of the co-operative movement has been the emergence of some ‘demigods’ like Keith Bourne, John Lovell, Muriel Parris, Caswell etc… who would otherwise NEVER have had the opportunity to demonstrate HONEST LEADERSHIP traits in any ‘dominant financial culture’… but who, along with HUNDREDS others, have been giants in Brassbados.

    You really let down the bushman in your intervention here.
    Apology accepted!


  37. The challenge for the credit union of today, it seems to have shifted from the cooperative philosophy.

  38. Terence Blackett Avatar

    THE BUSHMAN ARGUMENTS ON THIS PIECE REMAINS SACROSANCT AT A TIME WHEN BARBADOS SEEMS TO HAVE LOST IT INTERNAL METAL. I VOWED THAT I WOULD RECUSE MYSELF FROM PUBLIC COMMENTARY ON THE STEVE BELLE SITUATION GIVEN THAT I HAVE HOMEFIELD ADVANTAGE – KNOWING THE STINKING PILE OF MESS HE HAS LEFT IN HIS WAKE – WHERE FEW BAJANS KNOW THE FULL EXTENT AND THE FULL THROTTLE OF HIS DASTARDLY, NASTY DEMEANOUR

    Be that as it may, given my propensity to speak “TRUTH” (unashamedly, forthrightly without candour or compromised reservation), “AGAIN”, allow me to temper & season my “WORDZ” with a pinch of Himalayan crystal salt…

    There’s a published judgment entitled – Drayton Carter v City of Bridgetown Co-operative Credit Union Limited on the official Barbados Judicial System website…

    The case involved relief sought under section 177 of the Act, plus claims for defamation, (a declaration, and injunctive relief) – and notably discusses vicarious liability principles (citing UK cases like Cox v. Ministry of Justice), which is relevant to arguments that COB as an institution bears responsibility for a “CEO’s INDIVIDUAL CONDUCT”!!!

    THAT SAID

    Permit me to do a paraphrased summary of everything that’s in that judgment…

    CASE DETAILS –

    CV 1090 of 2014, before Dr. The Hon. Madam Justice Sonia L. Richards, decided on 26 February 2019…

    Bryan Weekes represented the Claimant (Drayton Carter)…

    Dr. H.A. Cummins Q.C., R. Forde Q.C., & F. Odle of Carrington & Sealy represented COB…

    WHAT THE CASE WAS ACTUALLY ABOUT –

    THIS IS IMPORTANT!!!

    Drayton Carter was NOT* a borrower fighting foreclosure – rather, he was an “OFFICER” (Secretary) of COB itself, “SUSPENDED” by COB’s internal Supervisory Committee on 2 June 2014 under section [215] of the Co-operative Societies Act…

    He “SUED” seeking an injunction to stop a special meeting about his suspension, a declaration that the suspension was wrongful, and sought damages for “DEFAMATION”!!!

    WHAT THE JUDGMENT ACTUALLY DECIDED –

    This wasn’t a final ruling on the merits at all…

    It was a decision on COB’s application to strike out Carter’s case entirely before trial (essentially, COB tried to get the case thrown out on technical/procedural grounds without a trial)…

    CLASSIC SKULLDUGGERY IN THE BAJAN COURT SYSTEM

    COB argued Carter’s pleadings disclosed no valid legal claim, lacked necessary details on the defamation claim, used the wrong court process, and named the wrong defendant (arguing the Supervisory Committee, not COB itself, was responsible)…

    AGAIN, CLASSIC SUBTERFUGE & DEFLECTIONARY TACTICS

    Thankfully, Madam Justice Richards rejected all of COB’s arguments and allowed Carter’s case to proceed to trial, as she found his “AMENDED” claim properly pleaded, that vicarious liability (whether COB is responsible for its Committee’s actions) was a “LIVE, UNDECIDED ISSUE” for trial, and that COB’s technical objections about “PROCESS” didn’t justify striking the case out – citing Barbados’s own overriding principle that courts should favor “SUBSTANCE” over “FORM” in enabling access to justice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    THIS WAS REFRESHING

    The judgment ends with the “JUDGE APOLOGISING” directly for the “TIME IT TOOK” her to deliver this decision, explaining that the file was “OVERTAKEN BY A BACKLOG” of other, more urgent matters, which is itself a striking acknowledgment on the record of exactly the delay problem I’ve described, even in a current case (WHICH I WILL NOT MENTION @THIS TIME)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    IMPORTANT CAVEAT –

    Madam Justice Richards 2019 decision that only got the case past a strike-out application, doesn’t appear to be a final ruling on the substantive claims…

    A VERY CRUCIAL SIDEBAR SIDENOTE

    The core legal principle at stake regarding Madam Justice Richard’s delay posits the following…

    Since Barbados abolished appeals to the UK Privy Council and made the CCJ its final appellate court, the CCJ will be the last “BUS” stop once domestic remedies (Court of Appeal) have been exhausted, but usually only after a High Court ruling exists to appeal from…

    Barbados’s own Constitution (Section 18(1), with Section 18(8) specifically) guarantees a fair hearing within a reasonable time for “CIVIL RIGHTS” determinations…

    I AM MAKING MENTION OF THIS OUTSIDE OF (YET CONCOMITANT) WITH THE PIECE BY DR PHILIPPS (#NationOfTerrorists)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    The CCJ has repeatedly found that this Constitutional promise isn’t being met!!!

    The landmark 2024 CCJ ruling, cites that in its 2024 judgment (2024 CCJ 19 (AJ) BB), the CCJ used the word “EGREGIOUS” directly, and stated plainly that such “EGREGIOUS DELAYS” is “FUNDAMENTALLY OPPOSED TO JUSTICE”!!!

    To make the pattern concrete, the Court cited its own history –

    In one Barbados case (“REDIFFUSION” – which we all had one in our houses in the 60s, 70s & on), judgments collectively took over [7] years to be delivered…

    In another, (“Gibson’s case”), High Court proceedings took about [15] years to complete!!!

    As far back as 2008, in Reid v Reid, the CCJ found it necessary to set formal performance standards for how quickly judgments should be delivered – specifically because of this recurring #Bajanesque problem!!!

    The 2021 case, given the specific “OUTER STANDARD” number, in the CCJ’s decision, Justice Denys Barrow condemned a [4] year delay by Barbados’s Court of Appeal in a real estate dispute as “SERIOUS” and “UNACCEPTABLE”, and called for an “APOLOGY” to the parties involved!!!

    Justice Barrow cited a colleague’s finding that reasonable delivery time for judgments should be around (PLEASE NOTE THIS* – 6 MONTHS), making the [4] year delay wildly outside that standard!!!

    The 2020 case, “BORDERS ON THE INTOLERABLE”, in yet another case (Knox), the CCJ noted the Barbados Court of Appeal had reserved a decision in 2016 and still hadn’t ruled by the time the case reached them years later…

    CCJ President Adrian Saunders’s panel found that a delay of over [4] years on a fairly “NARROW” legal question – borders on the intolerable – while also affirming the old maxim that “JUSTICE DELAYED IS JUSTICE DENIED”!!!

    The 2025 domestic case, had real financial consequences, as separately, Barbados’s own High Court (“NOT THE CCJ”) set a real precedent for compensating delay directly – where Justice Patrick Wells ordered the “STATE” to pay nearly BDS$300,000 to a man who had a murder charge unresolved for [10] YEARS*, rejecting the GOV* suggestion that BDS$25,000 would suffice, and stating firmly that the state cannot take a decade to bring someone to trial and treat it as acceptable!!!

    FOR THOSE PUSHING* & SMOKING SKUNK* WHILE PUSHING A DOMESTIC TERRORISM BILL – BEWARE THE IDES OF MARCH – an ancient Roman calendar marked by the assassination of Julius Caesar in 44 BC, which transformed the day into a symbol of “BETRAYAL & DOOM” – as the phrase gained cultural prominence through William Shakespeare’s play #JuliusCaesar, where a “SOOTHSAYER” warns the “DICTATOR” to be aware of the #IdesOfMarch!!!

    THE PROPHETS HAVE ALWAYS WARNED*

    Why “ALL” this matters is based on “PATTERN RECOGNITION” – for this pattern is exactly why I’m suggesting that “ALL” earlier treatment of “cases not being ruled on” as its own separate, “COMPENSABLE HARM”, the CCJ, and even Barbados’s own High Court have now built real, “CITABLE PRECEDENT” for exactly that argument – independent of whether you “WIN OR LOSE” – the underlying dispute on the merits!!!

    On that rather urbane judicial note

    #IMDUN


  39. @TB

    How does this matter raised in your last comment connect with Belle?


  40. Bushie

    Is it not a truism that Bajans, in all spheres, have a tendency to aggregate power unto self in the same ways which Mia Mottley has?

    Why is it not possible for you to brutally interrogate that which you so much belove?

    And if you’ve ever observed this as a facet of Bajan culture, why would your “specially gifted people” be immune to dominant cultural norms?

    Yes, the movement has had many people who have given yeoman service even as far back as the days of slavery, but before too. But have we not had similar nationalists in other areas of cultural life as well? And have their presence prevented the cultural degeneration about which you oft opine?

    Added, is this very Barbados not fatally influenced by external forces. And if a local cooperative movement is integral to similar global and regional co-ops, might it not be a fair comment to suggest a higher level of caution based on happenings elsewhere?

    Weeee see that others are putting some licks in yuh tail! Deal wid dem!


  41. @ Terence
    You may need to remind yourself that true righteousness is best exemplified in the face of blatant evil. Recall how Job was tested?

    @Pacha
    Stop pretending that you do not get the point.

    Of course there are Bajans, in all spheres, who have a tendency to aggregate power unto self in the same dictatorial ways which Mia Mottley has!

    No organization is better placed to deal with such skullduggery than a co-op.

    If our PM was operating in a Credit Union, there is NO WAY that the NISSS annual report could be overdue… The members would dump her at the next AGM, or even call a special meeting – given that she arbitrarily just wrote off a BILLION dollars, and mandate the new leader to expedite the report.

    There is NO WAY that a HOPE CEO could have misplaced $60million and walked away along with the minister… There would have been sent on special leave, investigated, and dealt with …RIGHT AFTER the first $1000 got ‘misplaced’.

    Everything is transparent. Even ‘confidential’ Board material is available to the INDEPENDENT supervisory committee, and to the regulator…
    …and there is ALWAYS a ‘Caswell type’ who suspects every move, questions every action, and doubts every promise… forcing full disclosure.
    True democracy! …by the MEMBERS.

    Of course, if the members CHOOSE to be brass bowls, and let the co-op run like the political parties do, as mafias, …then that is their CHOICE!!!

    Recall that people always get exactly what they deserve.

    So while it IS fair comment to suggest higher levels of caution, …all that this requires in a cooperative is for members to EXERCISE their EXISTING rights to information, responses from leaders, respectful service, and active participation in the organizations business.
    COB appears to be doing exactly that.

    Co-ops probably represent the ultimate ‘community-centric’ philosophy that there is.

    What a light in a world of darkness!


  42. @ THE BLOGMASTER

    “How does this matter raised in your last comment connect with Belle?”

    THIS IS NOT ABOUT **BELLE** – THIS IS ABOUT **JUSTICE** IN BAYBADUS!!!

    I could get very “PERSONAL” about “BELLE” et al – but why “MUDDY” the waters!!!

    In due season, all these “DEMONICALLY-POSSESSED CHARACTERS” will be “EXPOSED” – you can put that in your pipe & smoke it!!!

    #JustHoldOn – it’s coming!!!

    BELLE* is NOT* even the tip of the iceberg – considering the size of the “MONSTROSITY” we’re dealing with!!!

    THIS IS SUPERNATURAL WARFARE AGAINST LAWFARE, CORPORATOCRACY, POLIETICAL TYRANNY & A SLEUTH OF EVILS THAT HAVE VEHEMENTLY MORPHED FROM AS FAR BACK AS THE TRANS-ATLANTIC SLAVE WAR

    READ EXODUS 14, VERSE 13 – 14

    #IMDUN


  43. Bushie

    Another case. For this is not the game of checkers about which you are an expert. It’s about chess!

    Weeee see the USDC has just sponsored Chelsea Football Club, front of shirt.

    Weee know that Scott Bessent and the owners of Chelsea, Todd Boley and his hedge fund partners, are all friends.

    Weee know that Bessent worked with George Sorrors to tank the British pound and was involved in a wider range of hostile financial transactions against other sovereign currencies.

    Weee know with certainty that Drumpf has personal and familial interests within the stablecoin, bitcoin and Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) space.

    The above and more are certainties. The following is a conclusion based on priviledge information.

    An information “briefing” which seems to suggest that a wider number of global oligarchs, continuing in their crimes of using insider information to bet on the petroleum markets, are preparing themselves for the “Mother of all Short Positions” against the American dollar itself, making a few well-connected families weathy beyond measure.

    Is it not your co-op barley field which could be the first to burn?

    Maybe Bessent was appointed for this task.

    How can any co-op anywhere deal with these levels of “skullduggery”?

    You have several times suggested that this writer underestimates the gravemen of the circumstances we all face.

    But you, being too much in love with your dear co-op movement, are intent not to see the larger threats to that very movement emanating from external forces. Threats which are by orders of magnitude more dangerous than a demigod here and a demigod there.

    Consider a simple SWOT analysis before a reply!


  44. @TB

    Much of what you wrote did not register with this lowly blogmaster but thanks for taking the time.


  45. @David

    “Much of what you wrote did not register with this lowly blogmaster but thanks for taking the time…”

    There are [2] kindz of people – The Holy Scriptures says: “THOSE WHO HAVE EYES TO SEE BUT SEE NOT” (for whatever the reasons) – God Alone knows!!! “THOSE WHO HAVE SPIRITUAL EYES & SPIRITUAL VISION & CAN SEE AROUND A CORNER”

    #SimpleStuffBruh


  46. @ Pacha
    Wait!!
    Bushie missed the part where you apologized…? 🙂

    As is your wont, you have now changed the parameters of the moot and come up with a completely different argument.
    Just because A > B does not prevent C from being greater than A or B, and even greater than A+B.

    Bushie posits that Co-ops probably represent the ultimate ‘community-centric’ philosophy that there is, and are consummately superior to the albino-centric alternatives. (A > B)

    HOWEVER, in a world that is now TOTALLY CONTROLLED by the albino-centric demons (C), it is only a matter of time before the capitalists, socialists, and co-operative systems are brought to heel by the EVIL forces of our present world.
    One does not need to be a prophet to see this… just look ANYWHERE in the news – or on Utube.

    So in sum, Bushie agrees with everything you said…
    … except your missing apology – for your not agreeing up front, that A>B.
    LOL


  47. Bushie

    We agree on a lot! We see no need for apologia.

    Yes, cooperation or the cooperative ideal was here long before Communism, socialism capitalism and slavery as organizing principles.

    Yours was an argument informed by local circumstances alone. Whereas Pacha just tried to bring other forces or possible threats to your consideration.

    And in so doing, highlighted an arithmetic outside of your equation.


  48. THE STORIES ARE BEING TALKED ABOUT – AS THE DRIP-DRIP OF NEWS REGARDING CROOKED, LYING-ARSE STEVE BELLE CONTINUES

    #WhatsInTheDark……………………………

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading