Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

In Barbados, there was a time when no word beginning with “P” generated more fear than privatisation. It became the focal point of political warfare, dominated public discussion and left thousands of public servants wondering whether their jobs would be retrenched in a nation heavily reliant on government employment.

The quote from a 2016 BU article serves as a reminder for those with short memories.

Overriding the privatisation debate has been a disagreement over the proper role of government in a capitalist economy. Proponents view government as an unnecessary and costly drag on an otherwise efficient system; critics view government as a crucial player in a system in which efficiency can be only one of many goals.
In the case of Barbados we are being forced to adopt privatization tactics because traditional economic prescriptions continue to fail. For those who say no we point them to the reports of the global rating agencies and our own Caribbean Development Bank.

Barbados Underground –The P Word Resurfaces (2016)

These days, the P-word has acquired a different significance. The phrase ‘economic paradox’ is now frequently invoked to explain the strange contradiction between glowing economic reports from Dr. Kevin Greenidge and the growing frustration of ordinary Barbadians.

However, a far-reaching political paradox is emerging. While confidence in government appears to be weakening, the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) continues to consolidate political power, creating a widening gap between electoral dominance and public trust.

In the private sector, employees are assessed against measurable targets linked to organisational objectives. When performance falls short, deficiencies are identified, accountability is assigned, and corrective action is expected. Government operates differently.

In Barbados, the size of the Cabinet and the diffusion of responsibility across ministries can make it difficult to determine who is ultimately accountable for policy failures, project delays, or unfulfilled promises (why does the electorate have such a high tolerance for unfulfilled promises from politicians in Barbados?). The result is a system where political loyalty may be more visible than measurable performance, and where poor outcomes do not mostly result in consequences.

The performance of Cabinet ministers in our system of government is linked to politics. There is that P-word again. Our ministers are held accountable only by the Prime Minister Mottley. She can reshuffle or dismiss them. Seeking her nod is all that matters.

Currently, and there should be no argument, we have a popular political leader in Prime Minister Mia Mottley. She has also extended her popularity to the international arena. However, one suspects other members of parliament are far less popular. The political paradox is that we have a popular leader where the Barbados public has separated Mottley from the incompetence of the members of her obviously bloated cabinet.

Mottley continues to snuff out political opposition green shoots. Recently, former independent Senator Dr. Crystal Drakes was spotted as a member of a government delegation in a faraway land. Mottley is gaming the political system like any political animal will be tempted to do.

Barbados governance system – like the economy – is at a delicate stage. There is not sufficient dispassionate debate on the issue, even in this space. The intelligent among us can only avoid the issue for so long. The next P-word we may be discussing is political payback.

Decisions made for short term political gain will eventually come back to bite us in the Posterior.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One response to “P-Word Haunting Barbados”


  1. Constitutional gap that must be filled

    This article was written and submitted by Sonje Greenidge, a director of the Integrity Group of Barbados.

    On the morning of February 20, two people took the oath at State House as opposition senators in a country whose House of Assembly contains no opposition at all.

    Ryan Walters of the Democratic Labour Party (DLP) was seemingly sworn in without a single party official present. Karina Goodridge, who leads Friends of Democracy, took the oath alongside him. President The Most Honourable Jeffrey Bostic later said that his decision followed a sleepless night of wide consultation, adding that, “Regrettably, I could only appoint two.”

    It was a considered outcome and arguably a more representative one than a single party’s nominees would have produced. It was also the product of one person’s judgment on one night, because the mechanism that ordinarily fills those seats had nothing to act upon.

    When Barbadians voted on February 11, the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) took all 30 seats in the House of Assembly, with roughly 70 per cent of the vote against about 27 per cent for the DLP, on a turnout of around 41 per cent. CARICOM observers judged the poll peaceful, orderly and transparent.

    The difficulty lies not in how the votes were cast but in what the result has left behind. For the third consecutive election, Barbados has no Leader of the Opposition.

    Official Gazette

    The Constitution did not contemplate a vacancy that endures for an entire term. Two Senate seats are customarily filled on the Leader’s advice, and Section 75 permits the President to act at his own discretion where no leader exists to advise him.

    The Official Gazette confirms that this is precisely what occurred in the cases of Walters and Goodridge. The same section carries consequences well beyond the Senate. As the Constitution stood at Independence, the Prime Minister must consult the Leader of the Opposition before recommending a Chief Justice, or members of the Judicial and Legal Service Commission, the Public Service Commission and the Police Service Commission. In the Leader’s absence, the Prime Minister’s recommendation suffices on its own.

    Consultation was never a veto. Where the leader does not concur, the matter returns to the Prime Minister, who then advises the head of state. What a vacancy removes is the moment at which a second political voice is asked, on the record, about the individuals who will oversee the courts, the civil service and the police. When the next such appointment arises, no one outside Government will have been consulted, and the public will have no means of knowing whether the question was ever posed.

    The history is instructive. In June 2018, after the BLP’s first clean sweep, Joseph Atherley, a member elected on the Government’s own ticket, crossed the floor and was sworn in as Leader of the Opposition.

    Twice in eight years

    After the 2022 sweep, nobody crossed, and the President was obliged to fill the opposition’s Senate seats herself. Ralph Thorne assumed the post in February 2024 and held it until this year’s election. Twice in eight years, therefore, the opposition has been produced by defection and not delivered by the electorate.

    That is the backdrop to the first measure of the new Parliament.

    On February 24, the Government introduced a constitutional amendment on anti-defection. It passed the House of Assembly the same day, with 29 votes in favour and one member absent, and cleared the Senate on February 27 by 15 votes to 3, with the support of independent senators. It requires a member to

    vacate a seat upon resigning from the party under whose banner he or she was elected, upon being expelled from it, or upon crossing the floor.

    Prime Minister Mia Amor Mottley described the bill as simple, a matter of mandate integrity and stressed that it does not govern how members vote or stifle dissent.

    Its critics raise three concerns that merit a hearing. Dr Ronnie Yearwood of the Cave Hill Faculty of Law, writing for ConstitutionNet, observes that expulsion is a trigger, so that a seat may turn on the internal rules of a private party and not on any decision of Parliament. He notes that a member declared to have resigned or been expelled has 14 days to commence legal proceedings or forfeit the seat. And he points out that the amendment affords no opportunity to sit as an independent. The BLP’s own constitution permits expulsion for writings or utterances inimical to the party’s best interest.

    His fear is that a party leader could engineer a vacancy, in a House where checks are already at their weakest.

    Yearwood is a former president of the DLP, and he reports that the Barbados Bar Association and other legal commentators share his reservations.

    What the amendment portends for the office of Leader of the Opposition is a matter of inference, but a reasonable one. It does not abolish floor-crossing.

    It obliges a member who crosses to face a by-election, which the Constitution requires within 90 days of a vacancy.

    That raises the cost of the path Atherley and Thorne trod, and it puts nothing in its place.

    The Government has promised a more comprehensive answer in a new republican constitution. On February 24 the Prime Minister said that the full document would come before Parliament within two months.

    By late June she reported that the review commission’s final report had reached the President and she expressed the hope of having a new constitution in November or soon after, followed by public consultation.

    As of late September, the report had not been published and the timetable for consultation remained open. The 60th anniversary of Independence falls on November 30 and that date is the measure of the promise.

    Whenever the document appears, three questions should be put to it. Does it settle in law how the largest party outside government is recognised when it holds no seats?

    Does it guarantee opposition Senate seats and opposition consultation in appointments, in place of discretion?

    And does it safeguard the independence of backbenchers from vacancies engineered by their own parties? The Parliamentary Reform Commission retained first-past-the-post, under which a party may win a quarter of the vote and hold nothing. If that persists, the institutions surrounding it must compensate.

    A government returned by this margin is entitled to govern. But a country of this size ought not to depend on the goodwill of its government, or on one President’s sleepless night, to ensure that someone is formally placed to ask difficult questions.

    Source: Nation

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending