Submitted by Peter Thompson MBA, CFRE (Ret.) Management Consultant
A note on who is talking
I am not an economist. I am an entrepreneur. The difference matters.
An entrepreneur is to an economist what a novelist is to a literary theorist. Every novelist writes from some theory of how stories work, whether they can explain it or not. Don’t dismiss the theory. But only the novelist gets read. The same is true here: entrepreneurs are the ones who change things in the real world, and they still need to understand the theory underneath what they are doing.
So this is a working theory, the kind you build in order to act on it. It rests on two ideas.
The first is that the story of Barbados’s development since Independence is the story of a people walking away from the plantation one step at a time. To know where we stand, you have to know which step we are on.
The second is that we are tiny. However much energy we spend splashing about in the global economic ocean, we make only small ripples. Our one real chance of progress is to understand the big waves moving through that ocean and position ourselves to ride them.
Before either of those ideas, we have to be honest about where we are now.
There is no paradox
People keep calling Barbados’s economy a paradox. The government reports reassuring numbers, yet most Bajans don’t feel that reassurance in their lives. How can both be true?
It isn’t a paradox. The statistics the government likes to quote (the debt-to-GDP ratio, the level of international reserves, the GDP growth rate) are accurate and misleading at once. On their own they tell you nothing about who is earning, who is falling behind, or whether the country can pay its own way. To see that, you need to look at how income is distributed, which is what measures like the Gini coefficient track. It says a lot that we hardly ever discuss those measures in public.
Take the Central Bank’s latest Review of the Barbados Economy. It reports that “Real GDP expanded by an estimated 1.4 percent, compared with 2.3 percent in the corresponding period of 2025.”
That is a generous way to put it. A more honest version would say the growth rate collapsed by almost 40 percent in a year. The economy is still growing, but it is slowing down sharply, and the government’s sentence is written so you notice the growth and miss the slowdown.
Then comes the important part:
“The non-traded sector grew by 1.8 percent, as expansion in business and other services and in wholesale and retail trade outweighed a marginal decline in construction. In contrast, the traded sector contracted by 0.6 percent as tourism and manufacturing activity weakened.”
Those calm words hide the most important split in our economy.
The traded sector is the work that earns money from the rest of the world: tourism, manufacturing, international business, anything a foreigner pays us for. The non-traded sector is the work that mostly moves money around inside Barbados: shops, local services, construction, government.
Think of Barbados as a household. The traded sector is you going to work and earning a salary. The non-traded sector is the allowance you give your children for doing chores and keeping their grades up. Both matter. A household where nobody does chores is a mess. But only one of them brings money into the house.
Last year we raised the children’s allowance by 1.8 percent while our salary fell by 0.6 percent.
It gets worse in an island economy. A large share of our wholesale and retail growth is the sale of imported goods. Every bit of that growth sends foreign exchange back out of the country. So the allowance isn’t just growing while the salary shrinks. Most of the allowance is being spent at a shop owned by strangers.
A household can live that way for a while by borrowing or running down its savings. It cannot live that way forever. That is the real state of the Barbados economy: we are indulging our children by handing out allowances while our actual earning capacity is going down the drain.
Not a problem the government can solve
The usual answer is to blame the government. The deficit is too large, the ministers are incompetent, the next election will fix it.
Government deficits are not our main problem, and looking to government for a solution is itself part of the problem.
The root cause of our economic problems is an incompetent private sector that is rooted in our tragic plantation history.
Look at how a seventeenth-century Barbados sugar plantation was organised. The people who did the basic productive work, cutting cane and working the soil, were at the very bottom. Everybody above them depended completely on that work: the house slaves, the rangers, the tradespeople, the merchants, the clergy, the planters. All of them lived off the labour of people they tortured with whips and chains.
The mental slavery that this has imposed on us is contempt for productivity. On the plantation, being productive meant being at the bottom. Being close to the great house meant safety and status. Productive work is no longer just agriculture, but the attitude has spread to all of it. Ask what a young Bajan’s family wants for them and very often the answer is a secure government job with a good pension. In plantation terms, that is a great house job. It is close to power and protected from the field, and it depends on someone else producing.
Government is not a productive force and was never meant to be. It redistributes, regulates, and provides services. Blaming it for our chronic lack of productivity is like blaming the referee because your team can’t score.
We also misunderstand what politicians are. We treat them as our leaders. They are our representatives. The history below shows the same thing again and again: every real step forward was led by people outside government, and the politicians who mattered were the ones who understood what was happening and followed well.
Leading is our job, not theirs.
The map: walking away from the plantation
If the plantation is where we began, development is the distance we have walked away from it. Every era since Independence can be placed on that walk.
Step one: from field to house (tourism, 1960s onward)
Dipper Barrow’s wish never to see a single cane blade in Barbados again is usually told as a joke or as stubbornness. It was neither. It was the wish of a man who knew what sugar had done to his parents’ generation and feared it would do the same to their great grandchildren. Sugar was the field, and Barrow wanted us out of it.
Tourism was the way out. But don’t make the mistake of thinking Barrow invented the tourism economy and led the country into it. He didn’t. He was led by people like Ronald Tree, the wealthy outsider who built Sandy Lane, and by local entrepreneurs like Victor Marson and Hugh and Elaine Walcott, who took the risk of building hotels and businesses before anyone knew it would work.
They were also riding a wave none of them created: the explosive growth of jet aviation. When jet airliners made long-distance leisure travel cheap and fast for the North American and European middle classes, a small island a few hours from New York, Toronto and London suddenly had a market. Barrow’s own background mattered here. He had flown with the RAF in the war and understood aviation better than most heads of government, so he knew the size of that wave and what it would take to bring it to our shores.
Tourism brought a real rise in living standards for a great many Bajans, and that deserves credit. But on the walk away from the plantation it is only one small step. In plantation terms it moved us from the field to the great house. The work is cleaner, safer and better paid, and it is still service in someone else’s great house.
Not all tourism is the same. Working in massa’s house is very different from owning the house. Renée Coppin and Kenmore Hutson bought and restored Byde Mill, a historic Georgian plantation house, and turned it into a restaurant, events and wedding venue, spa and cultural space. That is Bajans owning the great house and selling the experience to the world on their own terms. If you have not been, you are doing yourself and Barbados a disservice.
Compare that with the large foreign-owned all-inclusive model, of which the Royalton in Holetown is the latest example. That attrocity keeps the guest’s money inside the resort walls, sends the profits overseas, and offers Bajans the service jobs. It isn’t a step forward. It drags us back toward plantation servitude, with slightly nicer uniforms.
Step two: from house to bookkeeper (international business, late 1970s onward)
The next step came under Tom Adams with the growth of the offshore financial sector, which we now call international business. In plantation terms it was a promotion from the great house to the plantation office, from serving to keeping the books.
The wave this time was information technology. As finance went electronic, money no longer had to sit where it was managed. A small, stable jurisdiction with good laws, sound regulation, educated professionals, and a network of tax treaties could manage capital it would never physically hold.
Adams did a great deal to build the legislative and regulatory framework, and that work was essential. But again the politician was not the source of the idea. He was led by industry experts such as Sir Trevor Carmichael and Ben Arrindell, who understood the business and what the sector needed.
That step was real progress. Accountants, lawyers, administrators and compliance officers are far more skilled and far better paid than hotel staff.
Still, look closely at the metaphor. The plantation bookkeeper had a good job, but the books belonged to someone else. Most of the capital that passes through our international business sector is foreign, and so are most of the decisions. We keep the records and collect a fee. And just as tourism depends on decisions taken in airline boardrooms, the bookkeeper’s job depends on rules written elsewhere. Global tax reform, blacklists and the global minimum corporate tax are the owners changing the terms. Waves don’t last forever.
Since then: forty years of small steps
Since the promotion to bookkeeper we have made only small, incremental progress. We have polished the house and tidied the books. We have not taken the next step.
This is why the traded sector is shrinking. Both of our main export engines depend on waves that have peaked and on assets we don’t fully own. We are still living off two steps taken a generation or more ago.
The two tasks
So the theory leaves us two tasks, and both belong to entrepreneurs and the society at large, before they belong to government.
Task one: find the big waves
We can’t make waves. We can only read them. The question for every Bajan entrepreneur, investor, educator, student and policymaker is which large forces are reshaping the global economy now, the way jet travel did in the 1960s and electronic finance did in the 1980s.
Some candidates:
- Artificial intelligence. AI is changing what a single skilled person can produce. One person with the right tools can now do work that used to need a department. For a country of under 300,000 people, that changes the arithmetic. Scale matters less, and skill and judgement matter more.
- Remote work. For the first time in history, a Bajan can sell skilled labour to an employer or client in Toronto, London or Lagos without leaving home and without the money passing through a hotel or a foreign bank. That is traded-sector income earned by individuals.
- The rise of China and the wider move of economic weight toward Asia and the Global South. The buyers, lenders and partners of the next fifty years will not all be the ones we have dealt with for the last three hundred.
- Something else. The energy transition, climate finance, the African market opening through the continental free trade area. A theory like this shouldn’t pretend to know which wave is biggest. It should insist that we look.
Task two: picture the next step off the plantation
The second task is to decide where we are walking. On the old plantation, who stood outside the field-house-office hierarchy? Who earned on their own account?
- The skilled tradesman (and tradeswoman). The cooper, the mason, the blacksmith, the carpenter owned their tools and their skill and could sell that skill to more than one buyer. Today’s equivalent is the skilled professional who sells directly to the world: the remote developer, designer, analyst, writer or engineer, using AI as the modern toolkit. Someone who owns their own tools is no longer a servant.
- The merchant. The merchant bought, sold, and took risks across borders. Today’s equivalent is the Bajan business that makes or sells something foreigners want to buy, and owns the brand, the customer and the margin, not just the job.
- Something else. Perhaps the owner. The final stage of leaving the plantation isn’t getting a better job on it. It’s owning the productive enterprise and deciding what it makes.
Whatever we call the next step, the test is the same three questions. Does it earn foreign exchange? Do Bajans own it? Does it make us more productive rather than just more employed? Byde Mill passes. The all-inclusive resort fails. A remote software developer billing a Canadian client passes. A government job, however secure, fails.
Leading them
None of this is a policy agenda for government, though government has a part to play. In every successful step so far, a Barrow or an Adams improved the runway after entrepreneurs had shown where the planes would land. Good governments follow well.
The waves are already moving. The question is whether Bajans will read them, take the risk, and own what we build, or whether we will keep trying to raise the children’s allowance while the household salary falls.
The politicians are not our leaders. They are our representatives. It is our job to lead them.







The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.