Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Barbadian taxpayers have for years acted as lender of last resort for LIAT 1974 Ltd. Since the public and contentious relaunch of LIAT 2020 Barbadians down millions are none the wiser the current state of the deal. The local Opposition parties and other civil society actors appear to be unable to walk and chew gum at the same time. The following questions have been asked by BU Commenter John A on behalf of Barbadians taxpayers. If we do not who will?

– David, Barbados Underground


  • HAS LIAT 1974 LIMITED BEEN LEGALLY DISSOLVED AS OF YET?

  • UNDER THE ARTICLES OF LIAT 1974 LTD ARE THE LIABILITIES SERVICED BY THE COMPANY OR ARE LIABILITIES GUARANTEED BY THE SHAREHOLDING STATES?

  • WHAT IS THE TOTAL ASSET VALUE AS OF TODAY FOR LIAT 1974 LTD AND WHAT ARE ITS OUTSTANDING LIABILITIES?

  • IS THE LIABILITY FOR SEVERANCE UNDER LIAT 1974 LTD NOT A CORPORATE LIABILITY UNDER THE COMPANY ACT AND IS THEREFORE A LIABILITY THAT MUST BE MET BY ITS BOARD OR BY LAST RESORT ITS SHAREHOLDERS BASED ON PERCENTAGE OF SHAREHOLDING?

  • IS BARBADOS A MINORITY SHARE HOLDER IN LIAT 2020 LTD IF INDEED IT EXIST?

  • HAVE CERTIFICATES OF RELEASE BEEN GRANTED TO BARBADOS BY THE CDB AND OTHER FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS AFTER ANTIGUA ACQUIRED OUR SHARES?

  • AS A CONDITION OF THE SALE DOES BARBADOS HAVE ANY LEGAL RIGHT TO REPAYMENT OF LOANS BY ANTIGUA PREVIOUSLY GUARANTEED BY BARBADOS THAT WERE NOT GRANTED CERTIFICATES OF RELEASE FROM THE LENDERS?

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

75 responses to “LIAT 1974 Flying Under the Radar”


  1. @John A

    Thanks for your questions about the status of the share transfer from LIAT 1974 to 2020. The answers to the questions do not seem to have been posited in the public domain. We have to believe CDB with best in class standards of operating would have signed off on the deal because the requirements of the release was satisfied. The challenge we have identified is that (former) shareholders of LIAT must demystify the transaction for us.


  2. @ David.

    Don’t expect anyone in power to touch this issue though. Lol


  3. @John A

    They will if it becomes a wart.


  4. u will get the answers if Barbados and St. Vincent continues to play tough with Browne forcing his hand to take them to CCJ


  5. If you look at its correspondence, Twitter account, Facebook page, official website, advertisements etc, apparently, the airline is using the name: ‘LIAT (1974) Ltd. (Under Administration).’

    https://twitter.com/LIAT_1974Ltd/status/1332059049374797824/photo/1

    https://twitter.com/LIAT_1974Ltd/status/1335225470237937666/photo/2


  6. So, what if Browne takes BGI and SVG to the CCJ?

    Okay, let’s assume he does that and it is found both territories are within their legal rights to ask LIAT (1974) Ltd. (Under Administration) to apply for flying rights, because the authority under which LIAT (1974) Ltd. operated became invalid when the airline suspended operations in March 2020 and subsequently went into administration. Then, what happens?


  7. Your supposition starts with Browne not winning
    What if he wins
    Then what


  8. Browne contends that nothing has changed
    He flew into barbados earlier and was giving landing rights
    No change in agreement between him and barbados was signed previously
    The old agreements holds until 2024


  9. Your supposition began with Browne winning. That’s why I asked supposed he doesn’t.

    If he wins…… he wins. Then, the Court would decide, based on the law, what both territories have to do.


  10. How can old agreements apply if it is a new entity.


  11. Apparently, the Barbadian government believes the approval is invalid because, in their opinion, LIAT (1974) Ltd. (Under Administration) is a different entity from the LIAT (1974) Ltd. that existed prior going into administration.

    But, You or I are not in any position to determine whether or not “the old agreement holds until 2024,” unless we have all the information. So far, we’ve only heard one side of the story …….. from Browne and Seaforth, which you obviously seem to believe.

    I prefer to be a bit more objective and wait until I hear SVG’s and BGI’s side of the story. If the matter does go before the CCJ, then we’ll have to wait on the Court’s decision, after both sides presented their arguments.


  12. Browne says it is still using the same agreements and Liat has not changed except for reorganizing its debt


  13. Reorganizing its debt and down sizing


  14. That is not a correct statement from Browne as LIAT has also had a change in ownership. What is unclear is what liability are the original shareholders still exposed to if indeed the old entity is still trading. Also if the old entity is still trading have the original shareholders been released from liability?

    Goverment needs to come clean and lay the facts on the table with us on LIAT and our continued exposure in it.


  15. Well until govt opens hand Browne side of the story remains the only story heard
    Any how why didnt barbados and St. Vincent make all their concerns known to Browne since their last meeting about the re organization
    Why after several flights did Mia and Gonsalvezs decided that Antigua has no landing rights
    How come the other islands where Liat is flying have not forward such concern if the agreement are no longer valid


  16. Come on, what “several flights” are you on about?

    Seaforth said LIAT before the borders were closed in March 2020, LIAT transported nurses from Cuba to here. You must bear in mind BGI was still a shareholder government at that time. He also said the airline had flown here about 2 or 3 weeks ago and had a scheduled flight last Monday.

    In the absence of the relevant information, how do you know whether or not governments of the other islands expressed any concerns about flight approvals? Or, are you suggesting because the others islands on LIAT’s schedule MAY NOT have expressed concerns, BGI and SVG should have done likewise?

    BGI and SVG are contending LIAT (1974) Ltd. (Under Administration) is a NEW entity, while Seaforth and Browne are saying it’s not.


  17. Also how about Brownes contention on the freedom of movement for Caricom nationals between countries via Liat
    I believe Browne has legal standing unless the two dissenters can prove otherwise
    Further more Browne states that unlike other carriers These two govts are asking to be paid upfront landing fees
    Personnally Gonsalves and Mia might have placed barriers with certain intentions
    Rather than being diplomat them two behaves like rag a muffins


  18. What an ignorant statement. We have to see the info, the evidence to inform discussion.


  19. Until those two Govt expose its hand Browne has legal standing
    The law can be an ass don’t u forget that
    Btw it is storming how many umbrellas did u open today
    I could see u shuffling back in the rain
    Duffus


  20. Come on, Browne contending “freedom of movement for Caricom nationals between countries via Liat,” is nonsense. When LIAT was grounded between March and when it recommenced flights about 2 weeks ago, CARICOM nationals had other choices of airlines to move them freely between the islands.

    As long as Mottley is involved, you’ll obviously “believe Browne has legal standing.” Could you please explain what legal standing he has?

    I’m at a loss as to how you came to the conclusion the Comrade and Mottley are behaving “like ragamuffins,” when, from around 2016 and throughout this entire LIAT debacle, Gaston Browne was the person who was ‘shouting across the sea’,’ making all types of wild accusations, threats and just being downright arrogant.

    Mottley’s involved so, I know where you’re going with this. But, I’m not going to follow you.


  21. I also see where this is heading


  22. “Eastern-based Libyan forces have intercepted a Turkish ship under a Jamaican flag”

    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/12/8/eastern-libya-forces-seize-turkish-vessel


  23. @ David.

    The thing is St Kitts or anyone can right off the debt between them and LIAT but what about the debt between st Kitts and the CDB along with other lenders that they would of signed as guarantor for on behalf of LIAT?

    I Keep saying we need to be told the true bullet we are going to have to swallow to be out of LIAT. it is not just us forgiving the LIAT debt it is the cost of us then having to honour the guarantees we signed as shareholders that we need to hear about. LIAT debt may be pocket change compared to what we owe as a guarantor.


  24. @John A

    Of course. You should observe the party faithful have steered clear of this posting.


  25. @ David.

    Lol i told you that from early that this is not an issue they will touch.

    This like the NIS, a can full of worms only waiting to get open.


  26. @John A

    The more you think of it there has to be a story of why Allan Chastenet the businessman refused to inject money in LIAT 1974.


  27. Chastenet knew well what was in the worm can and had no intention of taking st Lucia into it. Time has proven he made the right decision.

    As i told you before if this topic was about a politician that thief money from LIAT you would of had 300 comments already. We get treated how we are because we demand no better and the politicians kmow it. We prefer discuss trivia than matters that affect us as a people. The politicians know this only too well and throw distractions at us and we bite at them everytime. Pitiful really.


  28. Don’t you see neither the unions, the opposition or the press are asking any questions either? One would of thought with the union members at LIAT not being paid their due that the union would of been at the front of the line asking questions, but dem like church mice too.


  29. @ John A

    Shouldn’t we be demanding that the deal with LIAT be made public? Shouldn’t parliament be told the details? Who advised the government on the deal? Who drafted the deal? Who negotiated it? Why all the secrecy? Where does the buck stop?


  30. @ Hal

    I guess they feel they owe none of us an explanation as no one is asking for one. As you say all the time the press is poor in terms of doing their job and the unions and opposition are no better.

    The questions that I have asked require simple answers. The problem is once anyone touches them the worms will leave the can. The unions talk about dwindling membership, but if this is an example of how they pursue their memebers interest then God help them.


  31. @ John A

    Let us start from the beginning. Which department was responsible for the LIAT deal? Who in that department was in charge? Well, stand outside his/her home day and night until they come up with answers. That is an everyday strategy of the tabloids where I am.
    But there is a style in Barbados that if people ask uncomfortable questions there is a long pause, a moment of silence or they change the the topic. Watch out for it.
    Secrecy and silence, as Bajan as cou-cou and salt fish.


  32. @ Hal

    Yes we are seeing that clearly on this issue. Lol

    My concern though is do you think the unions understand their job in a post covid environment or are they going along business as usual too?


  33. We know the unions are about wage increases which dates back to supporting field workers.


  34. @ David BU

    The party faithful has already touched on this issue. Remember, they told us Browne has legal standing.

    On a serious note, John A is correct.

    Look at how Gonsalves handled the LIAT issue. He remained calm, (unlike Browne), and said he would accept Browne’s offer to purchase SVG’s LIAT shareholdings for EC$1 and was prepared to write off the airkines EC$14M debt, including outstanding landing fees, on condition ANU pays SVG the value of the debt that the Gonsalves administration guaranteed on a loan arrangement with the CDB, for the purchase of three ATR aircraft when LIAT was into a re-fleeting exercise

    The Comrade essentially told Browne, “let’s value the planes and the amount of money which we owe the CBD on these planes, pay me that and I get out of it (LIAT) and you do what you want to do.”

    We are yet hear how the Mottley administration intends responding to the request to write off LIAT’s debt owing.

    The developments with LIAT shouldn’t be treated as though it’s a matter of national security. Politicians make all types of decisions with public assets and investments…… and ignore our calls for transparency by withholding information from the public.


  35. @ Hal

    If the goverment were a board of directors for a public company in the UK and we the populace were share holders in that company, what you think would of happened over the LIAT issue?

    So why then do politicians feel that as our appointed board members with the responsibility GIVEN to them to run COMPANY BIM that we do not deserve to know the facts about our investments?

    This really vexifies me. Lol


  36. @ John A

    The days of the old industrial trade unions are over. They must move on to attract young professionals and gig workers, the Uber and Silicon Valley workers.
    We call them IR 35 workers, because of their tax code. As I have said before, professional association are rising just as fast as the old trade unions are dying.
    Plus HR departments are providing many of the benefits that unions historically fought for. In my old work place we had 14 A four pages of benefits for new employees.
    It is done through annual appraisals and can range from shares in the company to training, both to help them to carry out their jobs more efficiently, and to prepare them for promotion. These could range from in-house courses to external degrees.
    Message me with your details and I will send you a book on the new trade unionism free of cost.


  37. When a firm is in admin, it’s debts are consolidated and creditors are identified and paid dividends from it’s estate below par possibly as low as circa 1¢ or 2¢ per $1

    It can still operate as DiP (Debtor in Possession) business entity but when it comes out of admin it needs to have a profitable accounting ledger and/or credible business partners involved in merger and acquisitions deals such as takeovers, mergers or reverse takeovers, or it can be forced to go into bankruptcy again

    When Pan Am went bankrupt Chapter 11 it was protected from creditors for a limited period to allow it to reorganise.

    However, it had agreed to merge with American Airlines, but the day they came out of Chapter 11 bankruptcy, American Airlines pulled out of the deal and Pan Am was forced into Chapter 7 bankruptcy aka liquidation and had to sell off nonexempt assets to pay creditors. I heard there are some Pan Am planes mothballed in the desert and Delta bought most assets which includes international and national routes they owned.

    Reading between lines and extrapolating projections heard through grapevine, if Barbados scored airline routes to Mama Afrika, it could then become a hub to other Caribbean nations to link up with Afrika.

    I Am I Said, Kinky Fly


  38. @ John A

    I believe sometimes you’re a bit unfair to the trade unions.

    Recall, in June this year, NUPW’s acting general secretary Delcia Burke, met with some of LIAT’s Barbadian pilots who were being represented by that union, and raised concerns with LIAT, in connection with them being on lay-off for about three months without pay and subsequently being notified the lay-off period would be extended.

    In response, LIAT publicly stated the NUPW was NOT a RECOGNISED bargaining agent for any of LIAT’s employees and insisted the pilots were represented by the Leeward Island Airline Pilots Association (LIALPA), which is registered in Antigua and Barbuda. The airline’s official said it was in discussion with LIALPA on all issues regarding the pilots.

    Another problem here is, bear in mind, LIAT’s employees are/were employed by an Antiguan registered company. When the airline suspended its scheduled passenger services during border closures, most of its employees, including pilots were apparently laid off in accordance with Antigua labour laws.

    Could you please explain what you expect any Barbadian trade union could do under those circumstances?


  39. @Artax

    Agreed, bear in Browne is arguing the point LIAT pilots recruited from across the regions should be treated as Caricom public servants to benefit from regional financial support. Creative thinking or is this suppoetsdome where.


  40. @Artax

    I was speaking to unions in general. However have the local trade unions been in touch with the Antiguan union to attempt to chart the way forward?

    Also I believe the unions should be at the forefront of getting to the bottom of the financial reality of LIAT, as this will help them to better dictate the road forward. My concern is the unions and the opposition don’t seem to be demanding answers on this issue. Also dont forget Browne has indicated that the Barbadian workers should go to the Barbadian goverment for their severance, thereby making it a local concern now. His suggestion we know is ludicrous as LIAT is a LLC, but none the less it was made and I did not hear it challenged locally by those that should of done so.


  41. @John A

    Unless the NUPW is able to callout workers to support the pilots it will be ignored by the government of Barbados. Are we aware the NUPW has alliances with other unions in the islands? If the answer is no then same.


  42. @ David.

    My point is where is voice for the Barbadian workers in all if this?


  43. Left to me NOT A LIAT will be allowed to land here until our people are paid!
    We are one of the most profitable routes for them hit them where it hurts!


  44. @John A

    You may be flirting with contravening the RTOC.


  45. In principle an employer cannot tell employees who will represent them. Most they can do is ask for a vote and if the majority want a particular union, then it is that.
    If not they should walk out and unions at the airport should ban handling their flights. That is traditional trade unionism. Don’t re-invent the wheel.
    The elephant in the room is the so-called Social Partnership, that monstrosity.


  46. @ David

    Brown has gotten what he wanted and his people are smiling. We have been forced to swallow debt I assume and our people who worked for LIAT will face Xmas without what is due to them. I would take my chances with the RTOC.


  47. (Quote):
    Apparently, the Barbadian government believes the approval is invalid because, in their opinion, LIAT (1974) Ltd. (Under Administration) is a different entity from the LIAT (1974) Ltd. that existed prior going into administration. (Unquote).
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    That’s a very interesting ‘view’ of the corporate status called “Under Administration”.

    A corporate entity ‘Under Administration’ does not absolve that entity of any financial responsibilities to its ex-employees who must be treated as ‘Preferred Creditors’ much like any duties and taxes due to the ‘State’ but ranking after those creditors holding security or lien over the assets of the financially dying corporation/company like the CDB.

    The $64 million question is:
    Are the ‘shareholder’ governments of LIAT (1974) Ltd trying to w(r)iggle their way out of their ‘fiduciary’ commitments to the company’s ex-employees the same way the operators in the hotel sector in Barbados are trying their utmost to evade paying severance by telling their severed staff to look to the NIS?

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending