Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

The following posted to BU blog Lisa Marshall – Retrenched Worker from the Transport Board by Concern Bajan

On the issue of discredit….can you recall some drivers of the Pelican Terminal went to the Nation to highlight issues of great concern, which not only impacted the workers but general public at large? The Marketing Manager tried to discredit these drivers in the same article, noting that drivers were issued with memo books, which they are to log any defects and have them repaired. She went on to say that if the drivers drove defective units it was solely there choice…..talk about discredit to peoples character.

Mr. Tony Marshall was a moderator on V.O.B call in program “Down to Brass Tacks” at the time…he took it on himself to go into TB, where the Quality Assurance Manager took him to the department – where Ms. Marshall was assigned, and showed him the memos of defects that was made by the drivers. he forgot to show him the ones that were torn to shreds on mornings and the unit issued to another driver, with the remark, “he would drive that”…..destruction of character.

The following sitting of parliament saw former transport minister Mr. Glyne Clarke, stating that many drivers came to him with complaints of being force to drive defective units for fear of victimization. Then minister Mr. John Boyce, in an effort to discredit the former minister, stated, and its a document of parliament, that the drivers are issued with memo books and he knows for a fact that they make many memos. Again, he too forgot to mention to parliament of many of the defects are repaired…. The issue I have with Mr. Clarke’s statements were, when he was minister the same thing was taking place and was never addressed…..even parliamentarians discredit each other.

The BWU once wrote a letter to the then GM of TB, which was in relation to drivers from the outside depots making memos for defects, and the units went to Weymouth, stood there for 2 to 3 days and came back with the very same defect…In response, the GM replied by way of a letter in which the very first paragraph stated, “its not the policy of the Management of the Transport Board to have defective buses on the road..” Yet when these drivers try to do their job in a professional way, the are branded by the same managers as not wanting to work….is this discredit to one’s character of hypocrisy of a person.

Everyday on the call-in programs, people try to discredit these workers, and not one of them have any idea what these workers go through on a daily basis on the job. Then people here try to defend the management for not paying workers their due BY LAW…they are the ones who made the law…these workers were retrenched on the 3rd of March, given letters stating the would be paid all outstanding monies by April 28 – not part of but all…It took workers to go to TB headquarters making noise to get funds the first week of September, with a promise to have the remainder by September 10. Today is September 11, the workers have not yet gotten the remainder…if this was a private company the government would be insisting that the workers be paid.

This is not about which political party you like, it about right and wrong.. In January when questioned by the media, the PM stated that the severance money is not a problem. The Minister of Finance, stated that the monies are there for the retrenched workers and they will be paid in a timely manner. If the monies were there in January, why is it an issue in September for people to be paid what is rightfully theirs,

I dare anyone from the TB to say I am lying about anything I post here….I will deal with the BWU when I am ready….there is a lot more to the TB retrenchment program….


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

75 responses to “Public Safety Possibly Compromised – Transport Board Drivers Forced to Drive Defective Units”


  1. […] Public Safety Possibly Compromised – Transport Board Drivers Forced to Drive Defective Units […]


  2. The plan by the Minister of Transport and Works, Mr Michael Lashley, to merge some aspects of the privately owned mass public transportation sector in Barbados (privately owned minibuses, coaches, etc) with some aspects of the government run mass public transportation sector, is clearly a badly cobbled together and ill conceived one.

    Mr Lashley must be condemned in the strongest terms for attempting to bring more chaos and confusion to this very important mass transit public transportation sector itself and to the wider country.

    The Minister already knows that the private operations of this sector have been founded, structured and maintained by many fundamental attitudes, beliefs, principles, strategies, objectives that are far irreconciably different from those which the government run Barbados Transport Board have been founded, structured and maintained.

    The Minister already knows that these things cannot be so easily glossed over, de-emphasized, or ignored by him and anyone else in any attempt to merge some of the privately owned operations of this sector and some of the government run operations into one spatial administration, without another barrage of unnecessary legislative regulatory financial insurance terminal MTW and other changes and adjustments – and problems of such sectoral and intersectoral natures too – being brought to the operations and cultures of both sub-sectors and the wider country.

    The Minister already knows too that there have been fundamental and deep-rooted social behaviourial physical problems facing the private minibus zr sub-sector (from a lack of serious discipline by some operators, to a lack of proper terminals), and too knows that there have been fundamental and serious financial and maintenance repair problems at the Barbados Transport Board (from a plethora of deficits, to a multiplicity of defective buses).

    Whilst some efforts have been made recently by the relevant people to deal with some of those problems, it is clear that the Minister, his jack o lantern DLP Government, and the others within the minibus zr sub-sector should have been expending greater time, energies, assets in greater bids to seriously successfully tackle and wrestle the vast majority of these problems to the ground, and the vast majority of financial( interest taxation etc) social developmental problems in the country to the ground, and should have been expending such time, energies, assets etc on assisting in the bringing about of the greater rationalization of the mass transit public transportation sector of this country, rather than seeking to carry out a joke experiment – that if really implemented – that is clearly bound to fail in the long run.

    PDC

  3. Sunshine Sunny Shine Avatar
    Sunshine Sunny Shine

    Development is a measure of a country’s economic soundness and the manner in which its citizens are treated. In other words, a country is measured primarily on two components: economic development and human development. The latter of the two measures various aspects of human development (the access the population has to wealth, jobs, education, nutrition, health, leisure and safety – as well as political and cultural freedoms etc). IF we take into account the matter of health prior to the current economic debacle that is seriously interfering with the islands standard of living and the quality of life,there was a time when we could easily bragged about our impeccable health care system. In the current climate we have a health care system that has taken a plunge for the worst due primarily by the leadership negligence of a Barbados Labour Government who held the reigns of for 14 years. And a DLP government who has continued in the foot print of its predecessor but are better liars and better destroyers of lives than the previous administration

    I


  4. The Minister said that the money was there in January. And you are asking why payment is an issue in September. Maybe you should check the history of the Minister’s pronouncements and it would become apparent why there is a problem.

  5. Sunshine Sunny Shine Avatar
    Sunshine Sunny Shine

    In the context therefore of safety, we have always had a problem with crime but nothing of the magnitude we are faced with today. The crime situation has spiral and the safety of a society is being plunged into fear because the confidence in the law enforcement agencies to do a meaningful and efficient job is compromised by the states misplaced priorities; refusal to change, amend, enforce, revamp, redeveloped and punish all aspects of law enforcement administrators and its weak structures as well as its poor backward judiciary. It means therefore that Barbados developmental when measured, has suffered immensely from gross neglect, misplaced and misguided priorities. The consequences of these actions are now manifested in the suffering of its people and an escalation of crime, which by all intents and purposes will continue to rise.

  6. Sunshine Sunny Shine Avatar
    Sunshine Sunny Shine

    The written article has its implied view that speaks to the neglect of the state towards its citizens and obvious insensitivity it has shown towards the job losses and dues owed to these former workers. The quality of life that has been affected by government’s position and refusal to pay these workers is made even worse when claims of travel expenses for contingents and other ministers (including the ministerial prime) going on missions mounts up in the thousands if not a few millions. The frustration levels, stress and fear in the hearts of these workers and many others are recipes for serious antisocial behaviour of all kinds. The government thus has shown and is showing their regard for the quality of life and the standard of living of its citizens, when compared to the quality of life their are sharing at “their own expenses” and the expenses more so of tax payers (both legitimately and illegitimately). When a government does not show care or blatantly make statements that show that they do not care, its citizenry will no longer care as well. The next inevitable conclusion will be chaos and social unrest in all forms.


  7. I am confused.
    Can somebody point me to the income/expenditure accounts for the government. Surely the taxes etc collected by them is accounted for somewhere?
    It is humiliating for a nation to renege on lawfully entitled payments. We have already had the unedifying sight of a government minister begging a landlord/contractor to let workers into a building that they cannot afford to pay rent for.
    You really could not make it up.
    Where are all the tax dollars?


  8. @ Caswell Ffranklyn

    Caswell you know what; I am more than aware of the minister’s pronouncements.

    Lets see….timely, it is eminent, it is forthcoming, shortly, in due time…just to mention a few….But you know what, all these little phrases are relative, not one is subjective.

    Apparently these people seem to think that the old phrase, ” Bajans got short memories” relates to all Bajans. If this is so then I am Barbadian and not Bajan. But they should also remember the one that says, ” a promise is a comfort to a fool”, and not all Bajans are fools, so becareful of the promise you make and when you make them.

    Someone here mentioned the merging of the TB units and private units using the terminals. Let me say this now, over the years of my life I have studied people and how the react to somethings. And the ministers of government have went to universities to study the same. What am I getting at you may ask, this is it. These people have mastered the art of telling people what they want to hear, and once the people hear what they want, they would defend it at all cost. Hence, the reason why we have so many people defending the misguided, miscalculated, under achievements of this administration.

    Mr. Morris Lee have been trying for the last 20 or so years to get his hands on the TB….it appears that he has now gotten a fingertip on it, by telling the government to give them 100 of the units they have to operate. “Public Safety Possibly Compromised – Transport Board Drivers Forced to Drive Defective Units” – this is the title given to this post by David. Believe you me, if you think because of what I posted earlier, that SAFETY IS COMPROMISED give it to Mr. Lee and you will see what compromise really is.

    This is a man that sent a bus for inspection and less than an hour after returning with a passing grade, went down a hill, luckily with only driver and conductor, had no foot brake, no emergency brake, wheels that was on for inspection was removed and the old one re-installed. That conductor is now deceased, but I still have contact with the driver, who up to last night was discussing the said issue….Becareful what you ask for Bajans.

    I have said a lot, and most critical, so let me offer something now….the cost of maintenance was mentioned here also. The TB management would do all to defend their high maintenance cost, even discredit the drivers. But if we truly want to reduce the cost of maintenance, we need to start at the root. It is easier, cheaper, and takes less down time to change a crown wheel in a differential than changing the whole differential. TB does it backwards, they prefer to change the whole differential, and you tell me of cost.

    UCAL about 7 years ago, charged $75 dollars to change a flat wheel in the yard at Weymouth, if they have to come to you then the cost was about $150. What tyre shop you know that charges these kinda fees. 6 inches of damage on the side of a bus, and they charge for a whole panel. And we are still speaking of repair cost.

    They need a proactive preventive maintenance program and not the present reactive program, stop victimizing workers for highlighting defects and deal with them as they are highlighted, nip it in the bud, as this will reduce the cost of maintenance.

    I have rambled enough here for today….I will close by stating that the TB simply needs proper management to put programs in place and stop hiring managers because they are supporters of the administration. Get people who are truly qualified for the job. The present set needs to go.


  9. Perhaps these drivers need to take a leaf out of the book of another mid ’60’s., Transport Board driver ,who, after making a complaint, not to the Workshop, but to his supervisor,about defective brakes , was asked to take out the bus, whereupon he did. He drove the bus straight into Central Police Station, which was on his route , and it was detained , by the police ,until workshop staff was sent to collect it.


  10. Safety was compromised a long time ago when the Transport Board buses were exempt, the mandatory MTW annual inspection. I do not know if it still obtains, but this action is / was just as bad as what has been said pertaining to Mr Lee.


  11. Concern Bajan But if we truly want to reduce the cost of maintenance, we need to start at the root. It is easier, cheaper, and takes less down time to change a crown wheel in a differential than changing the whole differential. TB does it backwards, they prefer to change the whole differential, and you tell me of cost.
    …………………………………………………………………………………………….
    And what better way to start, by re-establishing the Transport Board’s own in-house workshop. It is not in the interest of those private entities who now repair the TB’s buses to cut costs.


  12. If we want more money to spend on social services including transportation, healthcare and education, get rid of the army. Follow the lead of Costa Rica who figured out some 65 years ago that it would be wiser to spend the money that was being spent on the military, on healthcare, education and environmental protection. We have a police force, isn’t that enough.? We are a tiny little island. What value does the army give to us.


  13. @ SITH.
    Colin Browne
    Senior Environmental Health Officer
    BarbadosHealth, Wellness and Fitness
    It would appear that the above should be taking action on your concerns.
    I’ m sure if there was a Death due to government defective vehicle someone should answer, best hope it’s not a wealthy international..


  14. What do you expect from any country when a ‘Piss Poor Government’ is in charged. A government which is incapable of seeing the errors of its ways; a government which is incapable of leading by example, a government which is tainted from the top down; a government which has tunnel vision;a government which is tainted from the core.

    What do you expect , miracles?
    “The proof is in the pudding.”
    When one has a workforce managing key sections of a business, which has no management skills; allowed to make decisions how that business should be managed, is this not the beginning of a failed business.

    The transport board has been managed in principal by above means for many years, It was kept going by millions of dollars being plough into it to keep it afloat, year after year….’Taxpayers money..’

    What do you expect when a ‘UNION’ is in bed with a government? Who can you turn to?

    There is ONLY one of 2 ways to make amends.

    To Privatise OR to rid the transport board of the entire management and have it managed by person/s unaffiliated with a political party.

    While on the subject,please allow me make a few statements of cost of running the transport board.

    One needs to look carefully at (a) the ‘type of buses’ being bought for transporting people. Those MARCOPOLO buses are obsolete.The name ‘MERCEDES’ is tag not in keeping with the product.

    There is an urgent need to have a workshop qualified and managed by a board for the sole purpose of maintaining buses for public purposes.

    My final point is this! There is an urgent need to have a decent road network for public buses and private transportation.

    One can travel the length and width of the country to see for themselves, the kind of roads on has to travel, with many main roads worse than ‘cart roads’.

    Those ministers responsible, please get out of your air-conditioned offices and see for yourself, the deplorable condition of many of our roads which the taxpayers have paid. THE ROADS ARE DANGEROUS.


  15. @ Paradox
    Those ministers responsible, please get out of your air-conditioned offices and see for yourself, the deplorable condition of many of our roads which the taxpayers have paid. THE ROADS ARE DANGEROUS.
    …………………………………………………………………………
    Tell me about it. As recently as yesterday I traveled the St Andrew, St Joseph , St John and St Philip area, but by far the St John’s roads, if they may be described as such, are the worst in the island. I drive a vehicle that has proven itself from Alaska to the Falklands Islands and from California to China, but is no match for the roads in St John, which caused me previously to a pretty penny in repairs.
    Which leads me to ask the question, why do we pay road tax? The government is not repairing the roads , or replacing the their street lights on the various highways when they become damaged.For us motorists,the dollar has long been devalued. The government neglected roads causes considerable damage and wear to our vehicle tyres, suspension, and braking systems, yet when we have to replace these items prematurely, we are kicked in the arse twice , with the added imposition of the VAT tax on these items. We have to pay VAT on vehicle insurance, gasolene and diesel. It would not surprise me if the motorists in this country are not collectively pumping more money into the government coffers than the hoteliers, but no one will consider us for any concessions, or even value for our money.


  16. Colonel Buggy,
    Dont worry, the minister said today there will be a ten million dollar stimulus for road repairs. Corey played the skeptic and told the minister that we have been hearing this…….soon, shortly, in a few weeks refrain……..and yet nothing happens! I laughed, Corey asked him what prompted him to call Brasstacks……gave some flimsy answer! Dems are an embarrassment!


  17. I was under the impression that the Transport Board had an efficient Quality Assurance Department. Surely all defects reported on buses should go directly to the Quality Assurance Department, whose inspectors would then verify the nature of the defect and then advise the repair facility which is slated to carry out the repairs, the precise nature of the work to be done. If during the course of that work, further repairs are found necessary,then the same Quality Assurance Department, would have to carry out a further ”floor” inspection, and authorise the additional work be done.
    When the repair work is completed, the Quality Assurance Inspector, inspects and verify that all the work carry out, has been done satisfactorily, before putting that unit back into operation.


  18. The city called London benefits from a transport system referred to as The Docklands Light Railway (The DLR). It is punctual, efficient, inexpensive, driverless (controlled remotely) and only requires the presence of a conductor. This could be trialled in the centre of Bridgetown.

    There are many reasons why roads in Barbados are in a state of disrepair. The fine design details required to build roads that will last are not considered during the design process; the delivery method of are so-called road builders during the construction process is highly questionable. In the UK we have roads built by the Romans which are still in use!

    I would ask the government to carry out an external review on those organisations that are responsible for building the roads in Barbados. They are certainly not getting value for money.

    @ Colonel Buggy, I am opposed to the expansion of the motor car in Barbados and would like to see its presence scaled back. With regard to are terrible road surfaces: I suggest we should look at reverting back to the horse and cart – I’m being serious!


  19. @SITH
    We have a police force, isn’t that enough.? We are a tiny little island. What value does the army give to us..
    ……………………………………………………………………………..
    Pretty soon we will be asking a similar question of the Police, given that fact that many people in this country,and the government at times, appear to be a law unto themselves.
    What I would like to know is what is the real purpose of a Justice of the Peace. At the last count we have got almost 1400 of them, evenly spread across communities.


  20. @ Exclaimer
    The old road builders built better roads in Barbados, like the Romans , for horse and carts.Many are still in use and in better condition than some which were constructed in recent times. In the old days before we had commercial rock crushers , men used to dynamite the hard rock faces of the gully cliffs, and used this extremely hard rock as bedding for roads,and rolled it with a heavy steam roller throughly. Today’s builders use marl as road bedding, and when it rains the water seeps through the hairline, or gaping, cracks in the road, making the underlying road bed soggy, and at times pushing the white marly solution up to the surface.
    Joes River bridge at the top of the East Coast Road,in St Joseph, was built by the Artisans of the then Highways and Transport without the aid of ready- mix concrete in the early 1950’s, to take a Maximum Vehicle Weight limit of 9 Tons,more than the weight of any vehicle on the island at that time. Today some,60 years after, that bridge which was located on a river bed, is still in almost perfect condition, given the fact that for 5 or 6 days a week, constantly all day, this bridge has to accommodate overladen, 30 to 35 tonne trucks, coming out of the sand quarry in St Andrew. We have the Technology, and know how , today , but not the commonsense and aptitude.
    Today’s Ministry of Transport, is responsible for weeding the sides of the roads. This is an exercise in futility ,as the debris is never removed from the side of the road . But this was not so in former times, when the forerunner of the Ministry of Transport, employed men with donkey carts, whose task it was to remove the weeded debris immediately. ( Actually it was the donkey which the Government employed and not the man) Today with all the Bob cats, Back Hoes and fancy Mercedes Trucks, we cannot get the job done. So there is some merit in going back to the horse and cart.


  21. I was under the impression that the Transport Board had an efficient Quality Assurance Department. Surely all defects reported on buses should go directly to the Quality Assurance Department, whose inspectors would then verify the nature of the defect and then advise the repair facility which is slated to carry out the repairs, the precise nature of the work to be done. If during the course of that work, further repairs are found necessary,then the same Quality Assurance Department, would have to carry out a further ”floor” inspection, and authorise the additional work be done.
    When the repair work is completed, the Quality Assurance Inspector, inspects and verify that all the work carry out, has been done satisfactorily, before putting that unit back into operation.

    Sir, let me see if I can deal with this in a way that all will understand. The Quality Assurance Department at TB is not efficient nor effective, therefore it is not productive. What you have described here is how the department was meant to work.

    If you make a memo for one defect and while that is being repaired another is found, one of two things happen. 1) The driver is asked to make another memo for the new defect, very rare to never. 2) The defect is left until someone makes a memo for that defect, often to almost always.

    When the workshop finish repairs, no one from the Quality Assurance Department never, let me say this one more time, NEVER, checks to verify that the defects were addressed. This unit is assigned to a driver and put straight into operation, and the driver would be the one to tell if it was addressed. The problem with this Sir, is that because of fear of victimization some drivers would take the unit and drive it no matter the defect and pray to end the days duty incident free. So when this unit then gets back to the person/s who made the memo, and they highlight it, they are branded as not wanting to work. Since everybody is an expert on TB operations and you have doubts about what I stated, ask any driver of TB and not managers, as we already establish managers would try to discredit the workers for self preservation.

    Paradox, i beg to disagree about the type of bus. The management is the main cause of the maintenance bill of these buses. Let me ask you a question Sir. Have you ever seen any other institution buy brand new vehicles and before they put them in to operation, you have a mechanic put them on a ramp, turn down the revs, and say they are protecting the unit. Check any automatic vehicle with a rev counter, the vehicle is driving at a velocity of 60 KmPH and the rev counter is under 2000 revs. After these guys do their stuff with the unit, you have the unit driving at 60 KmPH and the rev counter is a 3000 revs. Tell me who causing the problem, the manufacture or the driver, I dear not say management. But common sense would suggest, that if you lower the revs then you make the units work harder…I will deal with this another time in more detail once I remember.

    What I would agree with, is that TB should have it own workshop. Only a mad person would have a business which depends heavily on vehicles, have such a large fleet, and a private workshop. That arithmetic just don’t add up. But guess what, I don’t have a degree.

    On your issue Sir of exemption to the annual MTW inspection. I do not agree in the first instance. This was done at the time when Mr. Richard Dawe was the QA Manager, and was recognized to be more than qualified to carry out such inspections and was of trusted integrity. Since the departure of this gentleman from TB, the units were once again visiting the Pine for the passing grade. The issue you need to investigate would be the integrity of the inspectors at the Pine.

    e.g. I was shown a unit which just came from the Pine with a passing grade, and had holes in the floor. The driver told me he complained of this before the unit came off the road to be prepared for inspection. If this was a mini-bus, the owner would have to get it fixed for the passing grade, or do what we know many Bajans do. I will deal with that later also..

    Finally Sir, I agree that when you have a union, who is in bed, the kitchen, and living room with government, and the doctor is government, you should have very next to no confidence in your rights being respected.


  22. I was reviewing the C.O. Williams Construction website and had to raise a chuckle. In the first paragraph I spotted two spelling mistakes: priviledged and th.

    The site lauds the company’s “dynamic synergy of local know-how with international standards of procedure and technology.” I look forward to this outstanding company making a breakthrough in the much larger North America market.

    In Cow we trust.

    http://www.cow.bb/road_construction.html


  23. I am presently dealing with a case where a bus went in for repairs and subsequently returned to the driver. When he was driving along the body separated from the chassis injuring him. He was on injury/sick leave for seven months. Apparently, the mechanics did not secure the chassis to the body.

    The amazing thing is that during the redundancies, the driver was sent home because he had too much sick leave (seven months). That was confirmed to me in writing by the Human Resources Manager. Mind you it is contrary to section 30 of the Employment Rights Act to dismiss an employee who was absent from work for a period of not more than one year, although he was certified by a medical practitioner to be incapable of work throughout the entire period of absence as a result of an occupational disease or a work-related accident.

    They could not fire him while he was on certified medical leave but they used that leave to dismiss him when he returned from work. Worse of all it was approved by the BWU.

    >


  24. @ Caswell
    Would you support the TB management if they had dismissed the employee who was responsible for putting the bus back on the road?
    Had the mechanic been in-house, would you have supported firing him and possibly his supervisor?


  25. @Colonel Buggy

    What are your thoughts about Concern Bajan’s comment regarding the workshop. What are international transport boards/authorities doing, outsourcing?


  26. Well Mr. Franklyn, he is not the first, and believe me he is not the last…this is a regular occurrence. The situation of which you speak, is one which I maybe aware of, so let me go further. The similar situation I know of, I was made aware that this driver was branded as not wanting to work after he repeated complained about a suspension noise with a unit he was driving a few years ago. This unit was taken from him, issued to another driver who happily went along with the unit ignoring the noise. The result was a complete differential separating from the back of the bus, causing the back to drop in the road at Holetown, just outside the Limegrove Mall. There are case of brake linings separating after returning from having brakes realigned. – You’re In Safe Hands With Us.

    I was also made aware of a driver who was driving a unit for months that was leaking. This driver; brought a beach towel from home and used it in the area above him which houses the fuses and other electrical components to stop the water from wetting him. Rather than address this issue TB put that unit out of service only after it was found to an air leak which they could not get fixed.

    Let me give one more. A driver constantly complained about the steering of a particular unit, and as usual, this unit was issued to another driver who then complained about brakes. The unit was found to need new brake linings and was sent to Weymouth. The driver that was bringing this unit for repairs has an incident where the whole steering pole separated from the rest of the steering mechanism causing the unit to run off the road at Two Mile Hill. Imagine the happening the previous morning while the unit was coming from Bayfield.

    The BWU happily sanctioned the retrenchment of these drivers. There were three former shop stewards at TB – two of which is still there, and they are members of the General Council of The BWU. One is reported as saying during the retrenchment, “this is time for the management to clean TB…..


  27. Oh for some investigative journalism. We know VOB and the Nation finest and a few others read BU, what more stories do they need to inform the public?


  28. @ David

    Don’t get me wrong. If you can outsource at a cost that is comparative to you having your own workshop then that is O.K. But when there are such a large difference in cost, then is it truly worth it.

    If you have you own in-house workshop, you may pay a mechanic say, $800.00 wkly. In two days he changes the brakes on four to five units, at a cost of less than that weeks pay, because he still have three days left. The private workshop pays their mechanic a similar wage, so they charge you for each wheel separately then add the administrative cost. Just to change a bulb has a cost to it, a transmission repair is normally charged for taking out and put back separately, then the repair of the transmission is a separate charge. Do you honestly think this would be cheaper, considering the size of you fleet.

    Check any of our major garages in Bim. My car had slight damage to the front fender and the garage said the will need to paint the adjoining door, bonnet and fender to have the color look uniform. That was O.K and understandable, the problem was that each of those areas carried a different price. At that time the bonnet was $450.00, left from door – $400.00 and the left front fender was at $300.00. And mind you, depending on the side of the car (left or right) the price changes.

    Again David, if we are going to go the outsourcing route, lets us have a rate that is really comparative to having our own in-house workshop, and not to outsource to put monies in someone pockets.


  29. Within the state government here in the United States, there is a Maintenance-Department -Section, which oversees the operational maintenance of the vehicles for all of the state agencies within the state government.

    Shouldn’t monthly maintenance checks be conducted to ensure the safe operation of the buses in Barbados? So with this protocol in placed, there ought to be little or no concern regarding the safe operation of the buses in Barbados. I don’t know of any country in the developed world that doesn’t have this check in place.


  30. @ Dompey
    Are you suggesting this is a first world country, where everyone is responsible for life and death decision’s – like a ships captain – or a Government Bus Driver where people are accountable..?
    Or are you trying to teach us something else…? You know the old saying ” IF YOY CAN’T DO TEACH.”


  31. There is no logical reason why Transport buses should not be in good repair and buses running on time.
    There can be exceptions due to breakdowns and traffic accidents etc. but clearly there has been continuous mismanagement and /or incompetence.

    A bus is not a spacecraft.

    The management of the Transport Board must be collecting enough data to know what is required to provide a reliable bus service.

    Managing the repair and maintenance of gas and diesel vehicles in 2014 is not difficult. We have phones,computers,internet, FEDex and DHL.


  32. @Concern Bajan

    Noted, we have had revelations on BU about the role of Transtec providing workshop services. And we know UCAL has suffered cashflow problems because of government / TB unable to settle invoices in a timely manner. Commonsense suggest there is an opportunity to improve cost efficiency.


  33. Can anybody comment what has the insurance company been saying about the accidents occurring and likely to occur because of poor quality assurance?


  34. @ David
    Was the workshop not “privatized” in order to address efficiency, cost, stealing and other problems in the first place?
    Obviously we have bigger problems than the ownership of the damn thing….


  35. @Bushie

    This is the point and the lack of accountability by the BWU who is a major stakeholder in the arrangement. The inability of BWU to represent this matter surely addresses a bigger problem as you suggested.


  36. @Hants

    You have applied a COMMONSENSE analysis to the issue BUT you need to factor the TB is the most politicize statutory corporation in Barbados. It is how money is made by many.


  37. @Hants
    Managing the repair and maintenance of gas and diesel vehicles in 2014 is not difficult. We have phones,computers,internet, FEDex and DHL.
    ………………………………………………………………………………….
    Where there is a will, there is a way. We haven’t got the will, period.
    Managing a varied fleet repairs and maintenance is, however a little more complex, than looking after a personal vehicle,or placing an order on Amazon or e.Bay.


  38. Colonel Buggy there are people who are quite capable of managing complex transportation systems.

    The management of the Transport Board is paid to provide a reliable bus service regardless of the complexity.

    David has already alluded to the Politics and profit taking.


  39. Bushie

    Re: Your comment at 8:59 AM.

    Why would I support management if they had dismissed the mechanic. When he fixes a bus, there are at least two other persons who certifies that the work is done properly.

    >


  40. David | September 13, 2014 at 11:05 AM |
    Can anybody comment what has the insurance company been saying about the accidents occurring and likely to occur because of poor quality assurance?
    ………………………………………………………………………………………..
    David, first it has to be proven that the accident was caused by poor quality assurance. Who are going to inspect the unit after an accident to verify this? The Licensing Authority’s Vehicle Inspectors? Did you read what Concern Bajan had to say about them? And I totally agree.
    Then we have qualified degreed Mechanical Engineers, who may be called upon to carry out such inspection, but in many cases, his knowledge of motor vehicles may be less than a 4-year apprentice.
    We have no real inspection standards in Barbados,and therefore , unlike in the UK, no mechanic or vehicle inspector or others could be held accountable for any accident due to a a lack of proper maintenance procedure. However a driver, may be charged for driving a vehicle that is not in compliance with the Road Traffic Act or Regulations.
    In the UK,the various police forces have policemen who are highly qualified in the field of Automotive Engineering, and carry out random vehicle inspections on vehicles, and if they suspect that any Transport organisation, is skimping on maintainence, or that an MOT Inspection centre, like ours in the Pine,is not doing its job, they will wait outside the works and carry out a full inspection on some of the vehicles leaving those locations. Further more, the UK Ministry of Transport Inpectorate has the authority to enter any transport repair facility, to ascertain , the standard of repairs, and the quality of tools and machinery used .


  41. LOL @ Caswell
    No straw men Caswell!

    Let us say that the mechanic fouled up the job, likely not for the first time….
    Let us say his supervisor did not bother to check…as if this ever happens….
    Let us say the quality assurance man was busy eyeing the Marshall girl and just signed off the papers….

    …THEN …would you have supported management in firing their collective asses?


  42. IF we don’t have a QA culture at the TB and Barbados what comfort level do we have at the recent revelation the plan to integrate PSVs in the national transportation service?


  43. Bushie

    Only the person who signed off. But in Barbados the guy who walks around with the clipboard signing off and giving instructions, in most cases, knows next kin to nothing about auto mechanics. Most likely, he would be someone who was sent in by a politician.

    Let me give you an example. In 2008 when sanitation workers took strike action in support of the acting general manager who was dismissed, management claimed that the workers blocked the entrance to the landfill with the vehicles and sabotaged the equipment so that no one could access the landfill.

    The senior mechanics with the clipboards could not diagnose the problems and the landfill remained inaccessible for the duration of the strike. When the strike was over, the workers just put the cap back on the spark plug and the equipment started with the first attempt. For clarity, the spark plugs caps were not removed from the vehicles; they were just lifted off the spark plugs and allowed to dangle.

    >


  44. Does anyone in the Barbados Government do their Job? Or is it just prestige. A few weeks ago a ( English man) BT worker was stabbed to death in St Lawrence Gap. According to his family, no one has been arrested in connection with the crime.
    Last year and English tourist was killed by an unregistered jet ski operator, no action…
    If these sort of things were to happen in a first world country we would expect better.
    If ( of course I dread ) some Bajan school children died due to a faulty Bus, what would happen, no one responsible … or would this also be swept under the carpet and into the “old boys club” court system, locked off for a few years ..
    As my international friends are now realising, this county is getting worse.
    Fraud, corruption ….but most of all lack of accountability are becoming part of the fabric of Barbadian society. With people like Mr King simply pissing down the audiences back telling them its raining …
    I suppose if someone in his family was run over by a Government Bus, he would just – pay a $50.000 retainertake – wait say 10 / 15 years and take the Government to court. While continuing,
    to work for free…..


  45. Life Changer +

    I have a concern or rather a fear that a bus would run off the road and kill people because the driver went to sleep at the wheel. You see, they sent home too many drivers and as a result some of those remaining have to double up, that is, work two shifts back to back. The money is good but some drivers only double up out of fear that they would be next on the firing line.

    >


  46. @ Caswell.
    It would seem that you have also been made to suffer via Governmet oversites. Your reputation precedes you…
    I do dock my cap to you, but unfortunately it does seem the DLP and indeed this site has a lot of questions to answer to regarding its “funding.” While we both know certain government officials, lets just say, do what they have to to survive and can be bought or sold. Transparency, is long overdue, these power games being plaid by a certain few, and there effects ( repossessd car in your case, property deeds in mine ) are part of their collateral damage. I have no doubt that your hands are tied, so to speak, but we are more than confident in a more level playing field shortly.
    ” STIR THE MUDDY WATERS AND SEE WHAT RISES TO THE TOP.” So form the www these co conspirators will be seen for what they are… It’s our Human right to have justice!


  47. Caswell Franklyn, do a little more to accomplish the day objectives, seems to be the battle cry of most employees in toady world brother. I am employed by the state government here in the US and since the economic- melt- down, I have found that I have to do a lot more work to accomplish the day objectives.


  48. @Life Changer +
    I am still waiting to hear the underlying cause of the private bus accident along the Joy Road, in St Joseph in July 2007, which claimed the lives of 6 persons and injured 37.
    Such information, would go a long way in helping other vehicle operators, not just bus operators, to avoid similar pitfalls.


  49. @ Caswell Franklyn | September 13, 2014 at 1:24 PM |
    Not many companies in Barbados are faced with this very worrisome problem,of Driver Fatigue, as for most drivers, its a straight 8-5 day job. Some companies whose drivers work extended hours, have 2-man crews. When driver fatigue hits you, you drop off to sleep without any warning. It has happened to me and even the jolt and the noise of the impact were not enough to wake me up. My co-driver poked me in the side and informed me that I had just written off a parked car.


  50. @Colonel Buggy | September 12, 2014 at 11:57 PM |,
    I am in agreement with your critique of the poor construction methods employed by are “master” road builders.

    Imagine my surprise when I purchased today’s Advocat newspaper. The headlines read “6.5 million for road repairs” and stated that Cow and his band of merry men, Infra Inc., Rayside Construction and Braithwaite’s Construction will be the major recipients of this government’s largesse.

    I would hope that the government has carried out due diligence on the above companies and has demanded that the quality of the repairs carried out should be on par with the standards of a first world country.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading