David of BU,

Thanks for reposting Dr. Duguid’s apology in its entirety. Again I ask you where in the apology does he identify Donville Inniss by name or as constituency representative (St. James South) for what he alleges were GRIEVIOUS insults hurled at his wife and children.

Donville Inniss called him a fat slob…meaning a fat SLOVEN person or in (layman’s term a fat lazy person)

It is incumbent on Dr. Duguid to furnish the public with the alleged words directed to his wife and children and where were they uttered and by whom.

I AM NOW OF THE UNMISTAKEN BELIEF THAT HE HEARD KERRIE SIMMONS VOICE IN HIS EARS !

I submit that Dr. Duguid’s allegation on the wife/children comment is a LIE or he does not want reveal the true CULPRIT.

If he wants an apology on the fat lazy person comment….then that goes against the views of Captain Sawyer (I like them Big Fat and Thick)

Barbados deserve better…..Dr. Duguid !

David,
Just as I posted in my last post and one few days ago and reinforced by Spaeker Carrington, provocation is only a defence in murder.

I said at the time Dale Marshall as an Attorney at Law sitting next to Dr. Duguid last Friday during the apology should have pointed that out to him.

But is such the chaos and disconnect in the BLP

Secondly, Speaker Carrington pointed out to the House after listening to the tape several times….he is yet to hear where the allege insult about Dr. Duguid family was made and by whom.

Remember this is the same Dr. Duguid that a few budget speeches ago purported to be reading a letter from a lady….when speaker ask him to make it a document of the House….the “letter” turned out to be blank sheet of paper.

Dr. Duguid need to be called out on this one because he has made and continue to make an allegation that cannot be substantiated by the evidence in the public domain.

Of course David…..will still point fingers at Donville Inniss !

Enuff,
It was only last month you and other BLPites were all over this blog and others saying you have all the economic policy prescriptions for Barbados and yours were the best !

Why fret now that rational thinking Barbadians like Ryan Straughan, Pat Hoyos, Dr. Howard , Sir Roy Trotman and thousands of Barbadians voters have pointed out the GIMMICKS and MESS your policies would create.

Owen Arthur is just that a PARRO ECONOMIST…..just interested in selling his ASS…in order to buy TOILET PAPER !

If speaker Carrington has said that provocation is only a defence in murder… then respectfully I beg to disagree with him.

I am sure that if the Honourable member came home and found that man had inserted his dishonourable member in the speaker’s
wife, then there might be some reaction to this grevious provocation.

Although I know a man who witnessed that scene and when the interloper tried to hurriedly put on his clothes, the cuckolded husband said “take ya time and finish…because she is your wife now” (Oh shoot!!! bare trouble, because the interloper already had a wife at home)

But few of us could remain unprovoked in that circumstance.

Speaker Carrington articulated the views of the silent majority. Duguid’s swearing was plain wrong it offended the sensibilities of decent Barbadians. His apology was bogus.
Duguid looking to blame Donville Inniss for his disgusting language is wicked and evil. Duguid should man up as Carrington said.
An unconditional apology was required none was given.
Dale Marshall and Cynthia Forde showed us they are on the same moral level as Duguid they said so.
As old timers say Duguid could give but he cant take. His departure from the House will be a blessing.
The BLP must in the final analysis be held responsible for Duguid’s debased conduct.

Simple Simon,

The test is simple…he who alleges must prove.

Dr. Duguid alleges he was provoked by a DLP Parliamentarian who hurled insulting words to his wife and children….then he must come forward with the name and insulting words.

To plead provocation in the circumstances is indeed a FARCE !

Who / what provoked Owen Arthur when he attacked Terry Ally on the floor of Parliament ?

The history of harrison college is so disgusting and now it is producing a bunch of foulmouthed low class imbeciles, who are unable to take bim out of the centuries long dependecy our descendants will face. Don’t get me started on the fact that none of them can hget the cost of living down, they may as well had gone to school at the pipe and had a modicum of common sense.

Simple Simon,

The test is simple….he who alleges must prove.

Dr. Duguid alleges he was provoked by a DLP Parliamentarian he should / must name the DLP Parliamentarian and state the offending words hurled at his wife and children.

Or else remain branded as a stinking LIAR.

Who or what provoked Owen Arthur when attacked Terry Ally on the floor of Parliament ?

@Simple Simon

It is a pity that David the blogmaster does not permit cursing on this blog.

If he did I would curse you.

Thanks David for saving me from the sin of cursing

Good you were able to resist the provocation.

Simple Simon aka DrM Duguid,

That is all you can do when cornered in your filth……CUSS !

But the TRUTH still remains and stares you in the face !.

The junior runt, William Duguid MP cannot go any further with his provocation defense, he furtherest he can go is to lay a provocation claim against to DLP parliamentarian. The reason is simple, it didnt happen, he knows it didnt happen and if he gives specifics and an audio tape (cellphone recording – thanks to blackberry) makes its way into the public domain then he, Duguid is would be guilty of a more serious offense, openly and wilfully lying to the House, the Speaker and the Nation.

When all of the other options available have more serious consequences, one must quit without looking like a quitter. Judge the actions not the words.

For the love of me I can’t think of one important or useful thing MP Duguid has been responsible for and involved in since his election in 2003 as a MP.

What is the benefit of attacking Duguid anyway? Is he not quitting after this term?

DAVID

In attacking Duguid, we the people let him and all others in Parliament know that they should not and cannot behave as the want and choose in the highest chamber in the land, not without consequences.

Don’t give him a pass. How many down loads has the youtube video received since being published? Does that do any favours to Barbados as a country and our image internationally??

The BLP fell for FS plan hook, line and sinker. A one horse at the savannah runnig by itself does look good until it tire itself out or another horse joins him for a real match race.

In the end, the one phrase that will sum of OSA defeat at the polls will be ” Fruendel call the blasted elections man”

@Fractured BLP

You guys can back off now because it is becoming obvious a hatchet job is being done on Duguid his asinine comment not withstanding.

When did it become ok to support downright foolishness? An insincere apology does not make what was said acceptable. I’m sorry for saying what I said.. BUT!!!!!!!!. What he meant to say that he was sorry that WE (Barbados and the rest of the world) heard him and will continue to hear him (thanks to YouTube).

Well David bring the evidence on the offending DLP Parliamentarian who cursed Dr. Duguid’s wife and children….so that we can apply our hatchet on that individual.

At least you provided a copy of his apology.

Encourage him to provide a copy of the offending insults thrown at his wife / children, where they said, when and by whom.

Defintion of JUSTICE still is : promotion of RIGHTS and punishment of WRONGS.

Show some mettle, David

Inniss denies alleged role in outburst

11/28/2012

Cabinet Minister and Member of Parliament (MP) for St. James South, Donville Inniss has sought to clear the air about the incident involving Opposition MP, Dr. William Duguid, contending that he did not provoke the Opposition MP, resulting in an outburst which was heard during the broadcast last Tuesday.

Speaking to The Barbados Advocate yesterday afternoon, Inniss expressed concern that he was being vilified on social media sites for actions that he did not commit.

“Dr. Duguid has never once as far as I have heard, called my name. I think people are assuming that because he was attacking me in his wrap up speech that I was naturally the one who responded and said something about his wife and children. That is not true,” he said.

He added, “The truth of the matter is, I did not provoke William Duguid, a lot of the things being said, a lot of the statements being made in relation to myself, are totally untrue.”

The Cabinet Minister said that he decided to keep his silence on the matter until Duguid could issue an apology to the country and the Parliament and now that has been done, he has seen it fit to make his position known. Inniss said that he is also having a recording of the Barbados Labour Party’s meeting last Sunday reviewed, given some criticisms that were reported to have been levelled at him.

“… I am happy that he [Duguid] has had the level of maturity to apologise for his wrongs and all I can say is let us all put this behind us and move forward.”

The DLP members in the House are the ones who started the BAD behaviour. Many times they would not allow the BLP members to speak freely. They took the fact the the BLP had lost the election as an encouragement to dismiss every speaker. The retort was ” wunna had 14 years, we dont want to hear wunna. This is where the nasty cross talk by the DLP started. This is where the arrogance of the DLP started and got progressively worst and reaching the level where a DLP parliamentarian threaten a BLP parliamentarian with a gun –telling him that: ” if you is a bad come outside” and now another DLP parliamentarian telling a man about his wife and calling the man a Fat Slob in the process.
These DLP HOUND DOGS HAVE BROUGHT THE HOUSE INTO DIS-REPUTE

The DLP members of parliament aided abetted and encouraged by Freundel Stuart have interrupted the Opposition and insulted them and try to shut them up teasing and bullying them unnecessarily. Donville Inniss has been the chief protagonist with his teasing and school boy antics that he has not grown away from all like now. Kellman rises on numerous unnecessary points of order making debate akin to driving on a road with pot holes. This kind of arrogance by the DLP should be dealt with immediately but I would not hold my breath because the Speaker of the house ???? Well the less said about him, the better.

The more you look at this situation with Duguid, it is coming across clearly that he is not sincere and does not recognise how his verbal assault has negatively resonated with thousands of Barbadians.
Duguid started it, he (Duguid) rose to his feet and started to attack the Minister of Health. How can you pick a fight with a man and then when you disgrace yourself come back to the public and claim provocation.
Duguid needs to know what a real apology is but when you have an opposition leader who cannot guide you on a matter like this , you will get attempts to excuse this nastiness.
As for Dale Marshall, he and the truth have never been good friends.

David (not of Bu)
Your rersponse is typical of a member from a fractured party like the BLP. You guys are so far behind the 8 ball that have stopped calling for elections now that your 15 Point has backfired.

The day the bell is rumg…..owen arthur woiuld be cruelly exposed.

No coming back for him…..he would not be able to explain his misdeeds to Barbadians.

BTW….ask him why he ain’t call the PAC yet….that should provide your first clue.

The speaker stated it best yesterday, all MPs and the parliament have been diminished in the eyes of the public. Yes Duguid has been made the poster boy for this incident but it has only added to the growing public perception that the House of Assembly is poorakey (Arthur’s label).

In a previous post I drew attention to the fact that a mere FIVE SECONDS had elapsed between the time Dr Duguid had taken his set and when he blurted out the very loud , foul-mouthed expletive and questioned who could have ” grieviously provoked ” him during that time? I have always felt that if Duguid was to be credible he would have to go on to say when he was provoked , Where he was provoked and by whom he was provoked . I also made the observation that his ” apology ” was self serving since it was not given without reservation . Yesterday His Honour the Speaker expressed similar sentiments about Duguid’s ” apology “.
Today’s ADVOCATE carries a flat denial by Mr Donville Inniss that he at any time made any comments about Duguid’s wife or children as has been widely suggested on this blog and in other places ; persons , without knowing the facts , have found it convenient to attribute the accusation to Donville Inniss . In this regard we will await a response from Duguid and his allies ,who have found it convenient to allow the public to mislead itself , now that Inniss has issued his flat denial .
The speaker also found it necessary to issue a sharp rebuke to Dale Marshall for his most unprofessional conduct in respect of the dispute between himself and Dr Estwick and which is presently engaging the attention of the Committee of Privilege of the House . Marshall is a former Attorney General , a lawyer , and should know that it is highly improper to make public statements on matters that are presently before such a tribunal . But Marshall’s conduct is a typical example of the kind of conduct recently being displayed by the rudderless BLP ; they only have a NON-PLAYING CAPTAIN so every man is doing as he likes ; acting on impulse . One day you have a press conference by the captain himself ; another day it is a press conference by Miss Mottley and Mr Mascoll ; another day it is a press conference called by the FOURTH ELEVEN team of Marshall and dirty mouth curse bird Kerrie Symmomds ; on another occasion the conference is held by Symmonds himself ; oh how Sir Harold St John must be turning in his grave to hear that man who publicly abused him and whom he refused to endorse as a candidate in Christ Church now being touted as the soul of his once great party ! So what we now have is a collection of confused and bemused political operatives in the BLP , like the builders at the TOWER OF BABEL, not knowing what the other is doing and creating total confusion across Barbados . Every day some other person is coming forward to try to explain something that some other person made a failed and confused attempt to explain .
While all of this is going on the BLP would have Barbados believe that there is something wrong with the quiet , dignified , thoughtful , sincere , and competent leadership of our Prime Minister Mr Freundel Stuart . They must however understand that there has been too much money spent on the education of Barbadians for them not to understand and appreciate the difference between what Barbados CONTINUES to be in the face of harsh , economic times world wide and what Barbados CAN BECOME if the country is given over to a motley collection APPEARING to be united behind a NON-PLAYING CAPTAIN .

Not sure I am locked into this debate as I am at a loss as to why anyone is confused by Duguid’s outburst of vile comment.

Duguid The Philsbury Dough Boy as he is known as by his
BLP colleagues has left no mark of distinction on the corridors of the Lower House prior to his swearing session two weeks ago, for others their mark would have been left by some memorable speech or some memorable piece of social legislation but not Duguid his recognition has come in the form of a vile and nasty curse bird.

Trust me Duguid only acted in a manner as he has seen one of their two leaders act like.

Please cast your thoughts back to October 2010 and the sad passing of our beloved and highly respected for his moral values Prime Minister David Thompson, then there was a sitting of the house to pay tribute to the life and times of David John Howard Thompson and you know that not even at that time could Arthur do the right thing and pay a decent tribute but choose this time to unleash the most vile untruths about a fallen fellow leader of this great Nation Barbados.

Thought having stopped short of telling the the Nation for him to Carry His Mother’s C__T his tribute was almost on par with Duguid’s remarks and like Duguid who received overwhelming support from Forde and Mottley and other BLP that were present that he Arthur he to received the support of those BLP there that evening..

So friends it is clear to me that as a political party the BLP has no Morals Compass for decency and correctness, as Prime Minister Stuart once said as a political party in office they are held together by GREED and in Opposition they are held together by HATRED, as was so clearly shown by both Arthur in his attack of David Thompson at his death and in what was supposed to be a Tribute by the BLP to a fallen Leader, it is no different to Duguid’s vile ranting he too Can Carry His C__T as he has confirmed his uselessness in Parliament.

@Rational Son

Thanks for the clarification albeit he did it one week later.