Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Caswell Franklyn, Head of Unity Workers Union

On March 3, 2012, the Saturday Sun published an article entitled, “BWA Sacred Cow”, which claimed that the Barbados Water Authority (BWA) is no longer regulated under the Utilities Regulation Act (the Act) chapter 282 of the laws of Barbados. This in effect means that Fair Trading Commission (FTC) cannot set water rates or hear and determine any complaints about the quality of service provided by the BWA. Any such complaints against the BWA can only be made to the BWA. As the article stated,

“They [BWA] are judge, jury, everything. You have to accept what they say. So water in this case is creating difficulty because of the change that was made in 2009 when it was removed . . . it is creating a lot of problems for the consumers”.

The obvious question must now be: How did the regulation of the BWA get back to this undesirable situation? The answer is not the most honourable thing that the present Government has done.

In order to honour a promise made to the electorate to regulate water rates by the FTC, the new DLP administration published an order to that effect in March 2009. That order was made in accordance with section 36 of the Act which states:

36 (1) The Minister may by order designate the utility services to be regulated by this Act.

(2) An order made pursuant to subsection (1) shall also list the service providers supplying the designated utility services.

However, when Government wanted to raise water rates, rather than allow the FTC to do its job, they did the unthinkable and betrayed the electorate by publishing an order, on June 23, 2009, purportedly under section 36 of the Act, to remove the supply of water and sewage services from the purview of the FTC.

While I readily admit that the Minister has power to remove the supply of water from the purview of the FTC: he cannot do so merely by changing his mind and signing an order. The procedure for exempting a service from regulation of the FTC is set out in section 37 of the Act. He can exempt a service and the service provider from the provisions of the Act on an application from the service provider under subsection 37 (1) on the recommendation of the FTC or on his own initiative in accordance with subsection 37 (3) which states:

The Minister may on the recommendation of the Commission or on his own initiative exempt the utility service supplied by any service provider or part of that utility service from the application of all or any of the provisions of this Act, where the minister is satisfied that the market for the utility service supplied by the service provider is effectively competitive.

Before the Minister could have exempted the BWA he should have been satisfied that the supply of water was effectively competitive. Since he has already given the exemption, he should be in a position to tell the country who are the other suppliers that are effectively competing with the BWA.

When he signed the order to exempt the BWA on June 23, 2009, it paved the way for the board of directors of the BWA to meet, on Friday, June 26, 2009, where they made an order to increase water rates by as much as 60 per cent. The Cabinet then gave its approval on the same day according to the order which was published as S.I. 2009 N0. 69.

I went through all of that to simply say that that the Minister did not have the power to exempt the supply of water from regulation by the FTC as he could not satisfy the condition that the service was effectively competitive. As a consequence, his action should be declared null and void and of no effect. Accordingly, all monies collected as a result of the improper procedure employed by the Government to increase water rates should be refunded.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. @ Caswell Franklyn,

    Thats the problem with a freeness. You don’t get to decide the direction the post will take.

    The commenters do.

    In a few months the people of Barbados will have the opportunity to punish the Government and the next Government can decide to repay what you claim to have been collected illegally.

    David you tracking Windies and IPL?lol


  2. @Caswell

    A few questions were posed to you above.

    Also there is the opportunity to discuss other things which allow us to peer behind the veneer of how we do business in Barbados.

    It all comes together.


  3. @ David

    Sorry this won’t do. CF and I have tried to steer the Gollop thing to another forum. You have asserted that you accept Gollop’s integrity. And yet you say to CF that it is right to “peer behind the veneer” and that all things “come together”. Well maybe you’re right, maybe it’s pay-back time; and it was BU who posted this thing in the first place anyway and so it is BU who must take responsibility for it. But essentially you have thrown Gollop to the dogs though you say he’s honourable. That is a little mealy-mouthed isn’t it? Or are you hoping it will all blow away on a side-wind?


  4. @ Amused

    You damage your man by pointing fingers at hypothetical others.

    @ David

    Or is THAT the idea….to point the finger at the usual suspect?


  5. @robert

    You always come out on the wrong side of these matters.

    BU has been following the buzz that there have been alleged irregularities how the BWA contract was awarded.

    All we are doing is pushing to get information our unorthodoxy not withstanding.

    BU has indicated that Gollop’s reputation is not in question here.

    Based on some of the exchanges so far we have found out a little more than was first known.


  6. @ David

    To allow a few jealous people to use this blog with the single intention of trying to ruin Mr. Gollop’s good reputation is a shame and does nothing positive for BU in the long term. You of all people know that Mr. Gollop’s only crime is being a friend of the Prime Minister. You should do the right thing and stop this from continuing.


  7. @ David

    The only irregularity (your word) is that the builder from the North, a sponsor of David Thompson et al cannot accept that his plan to secure the project via a cancellation of the tender in favour of a directly negotiated contract with the BWA, did not work despite promises from some in Bay Street. The same builder was able to get Cabinet to award the Villages at Coverley project while the project was still out to tender.


  8. @Giga Soul and robert

    For the record, the comment posted was removed.


  9. @ David

    Your response is a cop -out. The style has been tried before by you – attack the sense of the awkward question. OK – so the right side is YOUR side? And you are judge and jury on the question of integrity? In fact, according to you the case is closed. And Public Joe seals it. Good. I’m glad for HG. Has it “come together” now?


  10. @Giga Soul

    So where do we go from here? If we had transparency in government dealings citizens would not have to be pimping for information which should be legitimately in the public domain.


  11. The problem here of course is that what ever is found out on BU apparently has no where else to go but to remain on BU.

    Man talk ya talk do … reputations my ass. Once yah name lawyer you is fair game ’bout here … There is no smoke without some kinda a action goin’ down … ha ha ha


  12. @BAFBFP

    Have you given up?


  13. @ David

    Just seen your blog re removal. I’m glad.


  14. @ BAF

    ‘But Brutus says that Caesar was ambitious. If it were so, it was a grievous fault and grievously hath Caesar answered for it……………so were they all, all honourable men’.

    Don’t forget the party.


  15. David

    Laugh wid muh nuh … ha ha ha


  16. But Ross we talking ’bout lawyers, what does honor have to do wid anything … ha ha ha


  17. @ BAF

    I know. And that’s the ‘rub’.


  18. @ David
    I am still amazed that Gollop could be the centre of any alleged dealing on behalf of the government’s fund raising for the election and find the posting of SCOUT particularly nasty . Being the FRIEND of the Prime Minister seems to have bestowed all kinds of privileges upon this man who was formerly a virtual unknown in the political arena . I have since heard that he used to be a staunch supporter of David Simmons in St Philip and St Thomas . Maybe this provides a good enough reason for the present smear campaign . Or is it that persons no longer appreciate what TRUE FRIENDSHIP means . How can you seek to smear a man for being somebody’s friend ? the mind boggles !


  19. At last! A Barbadian candidate for beatification! Hal-lelujah!.Do give the panegyrics a rest. It’s beginning to make me suspicious.


  20. Giga Soul your post may21, 8.38 suggests your soul is getting restless. stop whining. that has always beenpart the nature of the political beast which masquerades foe governance in barbados.carlton brathwaite and richie haynes were branded for their closeness to mr barrow, mr thompson branded mr hallam nicholls in haggatt hall for his closeness to mr arthur and mr david bryan of the advocate was branded because ofhis closeness to mr tom adams, poochan and racketeer clarke were branded because of their closeness to mr deighton mottley. so do not let the results of the polls get you disheartened. be comforted by the gospel according to mr michael lashley, ‘polls do not vote’.


  21. hants since we are all over the place talking about company up north and such like; can you update me on the status of the pickering project in the north since the sod was broken by mr thompson.


  22. BU reported a long time ago that the plug was pulled on the Pickering Project although Kellman denied it.


  23. @Amazing

    Barbados is becoming increasingly politically polarized a la Jamaica.

    Good people are staying away from the political arena.

    Did we read something in the press where CBC’s Socaholic launch was cancelled because their theme colour was red, BLP colours?

    Our society is in decay and it is why Caswell will always be able to find stuff to highlight. Who cares anyway? It is why our politicians can do what they do.

    The whole world is beginning to implode, the signs are there. Social unrest will start in Spain next and the UK possibly.

    Globalization has made coming events a big issue for Barbados and the Caribbean. We need to wake up.


  24. … Uh to what …? To the fact that the Capitalist approach to development where partisan participation by exploitative entities has completely corrupted the process? (Wait there gotta be a simpler way to put dat …)


  25. @BAFBFP

    Keep fighting, keep on with your inputs wherever. Our voices are being heard, might even be upsetting a view.


  26. “BU reported a long time ago that the plug was pulled on the Pickering Project although Kellman denied it.”

    i was not aware. can we put this down then as another lie, trick, unfullfilled promise, white elephant. you mean to tell me after the launching of this project with much glitz and glitter, this has been another case of promising much but delivering nothing. you mean no homework was done before submitting the idea to the public.

  27. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    @ Caswell
    NAD workers walk of the job in solidarity of co-worker.

    The requirement of 4 o’ levels being a prerequisite for promotion to position of Supervisor…said to be at the center of the matter. Are they really relevant to the position .v experience and know how (20yrs)…Could this be another unfortunate ‘fish bone’ at this time ? Your take.


  28. @ David

    On “who cares anyway”

    I’m sure you’re right. It’s why not even BU has considered the ‘watchdog with teeth’, the con relating to the Occupational Pensions Benefits Act and the ways in which the Bail Act is being subverted – well unless it’s time to go soft on remand prisoners in order to get at DS. Do we control the agenda or does the agenda control us?


  29. @robert

    Feel free to submit something. It is all a matter of resources.


  30. @ David

    “Barbados is becoming increasingly politically polarized a la Jamaica.”

    I can agree with your statement, but I do not think that we have gotten to the extent of Jamaica. I have observed systematic changes in the way people are approaching politics now-a-days, especially during the last 6 years or so, and it reminds me of St. Kitts and Antigua. There are strong divisions between parties in those islands, and more so in St. Kitts. However, on closer examination, I realized that the political culture has been influenced and redesigned by a political strategist, common to the three islands.


  31. @ David

    I understand about resources. It’s simply that when I mention these things – and often to you – no-one says anything. I realise, of course, there may be all sorts of reasons for that. Even with the Law Commission thing, it all got side-tracked by someone with a hang-up as much as I love him. You see, despite my fish-nor-fowl status (which may actually be salutary) I am actually committed to change and, to be totally airy fairy, to everything that is good and beautiful including the business of waking up. I think you understand that – well sometimes.


  32. “However, on closer examination, I realized that the political culture has been influenced and redesigned by a political strategist, common to the three islands”
    xeres- do not forget St Vincent; the octopus like tentacles of the masquerading political consultant to the Democratic Labour Party unashamedly remunerated out of the taxpayers of Barbados coffers for doing work for his political organisation without a whisper of disdain from even the opposition benches again calls to mind the bankruptcy of the system of governance in barbados. mr gonsalves wanted to to ascribe to him some nondescript post at the public’s expense too but the foolish vincies as we would say sensibly would have none of it unlike us wise bajans who foolishly accepted it. Has anyone ever researched his certification in this political consultant nonsenseor is he a hoax.apart from his brief sojourn in the journalism field and his association with AL-Hart, he is not reconised. yet he can g all through the caribbean posturing as a political consultant and we say the caribbean leaders brilliant.


  33. A surety turned up at District A today on behalf of her daughter. She was wearing a skirt which dropped below the knee. The Prosecutor pointed out to the Magistrate that it was a ‘jeans skirt’. The Magistrate sent her home to change it. Has this country gone totally MAD?


  34. RRoss…..this just goes to show how common sense ain’t so common at all. Now it boils down to the type of material the skirt is made of and the style. The magistrates have now become Fashion judges. How the hell can the fabric of a skirt worn by a surety determine the credibility of that person?


  35. We live in a society built on observing standards no?


  36. “We live in a society built on observing standards no?”

    Yes David a dress code for the poor and one for the rich. If it were a white person would it have the same results? We are soo backwards that we cannot decipher what is decent and indecent , what is acceptable and unacceptable.


  37. @islandgal

    Just checking to establish that you are ok with maintaining a standard. Now we get into the realm of interpretation 🙂

    @Caswell

    Notice in the news there is industrial unrest brewing at the BWA.

  38. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Robert

    The administration of the courts and the Registration Department has gone awry. They make up rules, usually stupid ones, as they go along. This nonsense with a jeans skirt is just the tip of the iceberg of ignorance that goes on there.

    If you want to see madness, go and apply for a death certificate. They will want to know why you want the document and your relation to the deceased. A registry is a place where public document are kept. The only restriction on having acces to those documents should be if the applicant can afford the cost. It is not the Registrar’s business what you want to do with the document. But they have instituted an inquisition for persons who apply for the services of the Registration Department and no one in authority is willing to restrain the excessive behaviour that passes for administration of that department.

  39. Random Thoughts Avatar
    Random Thoughts

    Quoting islandgal “The magistrates have now become Fashion judges.”

    And in truth NOT ONE of our judges and magistrates can be called an elegant or a fashionable dresser.

    Do you ever see them once they take that gown off?

    As the young people would say “They crying man!!!!”


  40. R Ross

    As a public service please provide the names of the Prosecutor and the Magistrate so that we can make “mock sport” of them


  41. David wrote “Social unrest will start in Spain next and the UK possibly.”

    Montreal

    http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/massive-montreal-rally-marks-100-days-of-student-protests/article2440155/


  42. @ Hants
    …..and the schools in Spain started today


  43. @ Sarjeant

    The magistrate was a lady. It was NOT the prosecutor who drew the attention of the magistrate to the offending garment. It was a constable from the doorway. Consider the dress code on saturdays – flip flops, jeans and open shirts are de rigeur for attorneys. Apparently justice is blind at week-ends.


  44. There are curious rules about leg crossing too. Magistrates, attorneys, probation officers, prosecutors may cross and uncross – but not witnesses, complainants, defendants and, indeed, anyone else. It is a very serious offence to place the elbow on the back bar of a bench in the ‘public’ body of the court. So yes – it is all about observance – in other words pretence.

    @ Islandgal

    I’m told that skin colour is not a determinant of the application of the rigours of the dress code.

    @ David

    I suspect that (narrowly) it is a question of interpretation as you suggest. There is a notice forbidding jeans – but I think I’m right in saying that there’s nothing about ‘jeans skirts’. So as Islandgal suggests, it’s all about fabric which, as she says and as we all know, is a determinant of credibility. Why don’t we wear jeans on sundays at St Splotts?


  45. @ CF

    Yes, I’m sure you’re right about making it all up as they go along. How often do you see a smiling face in that building?


  46. Kamla returns to T&T
    Belgrave to be GG
    Dudus sentencing hearing today
    Gabriel to return home

    Four headlines in one of our Nations daily newspaper. Am I too old fashioned in thinking that a Prime Minister of a country deserves to have the title before her name?
    Same for the GG designate Justice Belgrave?

    I guess Journalism school has changed.

    Apologies for the diversion


  47. I have seen the skort (skirt/shorts) cause a problem the other way around in court.

    The complaint was made to the wearer of the skort that no shorts were allowed in court although the hem was below the knees by an authority figure wearing an extremely short skirt, halfway up her thighs.

    I expected fire works as the lady in the skort has a way with words and could only chuckle quietly when she looked the authority figure up and down, asked “…. And what about your mini skirt?” … then turned around and left the authority figure to figure out an answer!!

    Never heard the answer!!

    That day I added a new word to my vocabulary … skort and I realised that those put in authority are not always up to it.

    It is sad really.


  48. @robert

    Your reluctance to name the prosecutor and others involved speaks volumes why the problem will remain.

  49. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    Some time ago, while in opposition, David Thompson said that they were some foolish magistrates. I am tempted to agree and extend it since the magistrates did not make up that absurd rule. It is silly because there is no such thing as a “jeans skirt”. A jeans is a hard-wearing trousers made from denim or another cotton fabric, for informal wear.

    Jeans is a style of pants: the lady would have been wearing a denim skirt. To be complete, the Compact Oxford Dictionary of Current English defines denim: A hard-wearing cotton twill fabric.

    Power really goes to some people’ heads.


  50. It is a Denim skirt.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending