Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Caswell Franklyn, Head of Unity Workers Union

On March 3, 2012, the Saturday Sun published an article entitled, “BWA Sacred Cow”, which claimed that the Barbados Water Authority (BWA) is no longer regulated under the Utilities Regulation Act (the Act) chapter 282 of the laws of Barbados. This in effect means that Fair Trading Commission (FTC) cannot set water rates or hear and determine any complaints about the quality of service provided by the BWA. Any such complaints against the BWA can only be made to the BWA. As the article stated,

“They [BWA] are judge, jury, everything. You have to accept what they say. So water in this case is creating difficulty because of the change that was made in 2009 when it was removed . . . it is creating a lot of problems for the consumers”.

The obvious question must now be: How did the regulation of the BWA get back to this undesirable situation? The answer is not the most honourable thing that the present Government has done.

In order to honour a promise made to the electorate to regulate water rates by the FTC, the new DLP administration published an order to that effect in March 2009. That order was made in accordance with section 36 of the Act which states:

36 (1) The Minister may by order designate the utility services to be regulated by this Act.

(2) An order made pursuant to subsection (1) shall also list the service providers supplying the designated utility services.

However, when Government wanted to raise water rates, rather than allow the FTC to do its job, they did the unthinkable and betrayed the electorate by publishing an order, on June 23, 2009, purportedly under section 36 of the Act, to remove the supply of water and sewage services from the purview of the FTC.

While I readily admit that the Minister has power to remove the supply of water from the purview of the FTC: he cannot do so merely by changing his mind and signing an order. The procedure for exempting a service from regulation of the FTC is set out in section 37 of the Act. He can exempt a service and the service provider from the provisions of the Act on an application from the service provider under subsection 37 (1) on the recommendation of the FTC or on his own initiative in accordance with subsection 37 (3) which states:

The Minister may on the recommendation of the Commission or on his own initiative exempt the utility service supplied by any service provider or part of that utility service from the application of all or any of the provisions of this Act, where the minister is satisfied that the market for the utility service supplied by the service provider is effectively competitive.

Before the Minister could have exempted the BWA he should have been satisfied that the supply of water was effectively competitive. Since he has already given the exemption, he should be in a position to tell the country who are the other suppliers that are effectively competing with the BWA.

When he signed the order to exempt the BWA on June 23, 2009, it paved the way for the board of directors of the BWA to meet, on Friday, June 26, 2009, where they made an order to increase water rates by as much as 60 per cent. The Cabinet then gave its approval on the same day according to the order which was published as S.I. 2009 N0. 69.

I went through all of that to simply say that that the Minister did not have the power to exempt the supply of water from regulation by the FTC as he could not satisfy the condition that the service was effectively competitive. As a consequence, his action should be declared null and void and of no effect. Accordingly, all monies collected as a result of the improper procedure employed by the Government to increase water rates should be refunded.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. So Caswell are you saying that I can sue the BWA? A class action suit too? Geeze I have a whopper of a water bill $904.40 for last month and I am very interested to know how that came about. I feel very sorry for the farmers and the back yard farmers. Life pon dis piece of rock ent cheap at all.


  2. @Caswell

    …where the minister is satisfied that the market for the utility service supplied by the service provider is effectively competitive.

    How does one define ‘effectively competitive’?

  3. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    To answer your question, I consulted with my Oxford English Reference Dictionary. It gives several meanings of the word “competitive” but the one which is relevant states:

    “(of prices etc.) low enough to compare well with those of rival traders”

    The point I am trying to make is that there cannot be competition, much less effective competition, with only one supplier. The Minister would therefore have acted contrary to law when he removed the BWA from the purview of the FTC.


  4. WHY cant I JUST ASKING get a column like Caswell Franklyn
    I got one hundred questions to ask in 100 seconds
    WHO is Caswell Franklyn that he can get a column and not JUST ASKING

    JUST ASKING

  5. old onion bags Avatar
    old onion bags

    What are you saying…..yet another controversy. We had Thompson and CLICO……now you telling me we get rob again ?


  6. @Caswell

    But, is it not true to say that water utilities are usually single entities in a country?

  7. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Onions

    Getting robbed is something to which Barbadians have become accustomed. It seems as though most people could careless. But this is not just a case of robbery: it is also deceitful conduct by the ruling party. They promise to subject the BWA to the FTC and no one can say that they did not honour that promise. The placed the BWA under the jurisdiction of the FTC in March 2009 and then removed it with effect from July 1, 2009. Well at least they managed to honour one promise.

  8. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David (9:46)

    You might be right that water utilities are usually single entities in a country. That being the case in the Barbados context the only way the Minister could remove BWA from the Jurisdiction of the FTC would be on the recommendation of the FTC itself. He had no authority to act on his own initiative. See section 37 of the Utilities Regulation Act. We do not expect politicians to make it up as they go along: we expect them to follow the law.

    Cases like this is where a vibrant consumer body would come into its own. Also organizations like BARP and trade unions should be making sure that the politicians do not get away with this type of abuse that affect the pockets of their members. You don’t have to secure a pay increase if you can ensure that the cost of living does not rise like it has been in the last four years.


  9. A foolish question: How do you know the FTC did not so recommend?

  10. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Good question David. The order that was signed by the Minister did not say that the FTC made the recommendation. The order was published as S.I. 2009 No. 68 and it simply said, and I quote:

    “The Minister in exercise of the powers conferred on him by section 36 of the Utilities Regulation Act, makes the following order”:

    Firstly, section 36 does not confer any such power on the Minister. The power to remove is conferred by section 37 and if the FTC had made the recommendation the order would have said so.


  11. “Also organizations like BARP and trade unions should be making sure that the politicians do not get away with this type of abuse that affect the pockets of their members.”

    What about the about the Auditor-General, mr Franklyn.Doesn’t a situation like this falls under his prview as well or is he going to wait til the government changes to report on this revelation?


  12. @ CF

    Well done for digging up this one. At the least you’ve demonstrated that the statutory language is meaningless in practice. Perhaps you might like to consider the misinformation put about in relation to lump sum payments and annuities under the Occupational Pensions Benefits Act 2011.

    @ David

    It is just this kind of thing that my ‘watchdog with teeth’ – the third force – would have a field day with – a suggestion which went absolutely nowhere.

  13. Observing (and awaiting the inevitable) Avatar
    Observing (and awaiting the inevitable)

    @david
    “Hal Gollop, on behalf of Government,”

    sigh. no comment,

    @caswell
    good job my brother.


  14. A system that allows big business to finance political parties. How is the awarding of a contract to Innotech fair? White businesses are so tapped into the public’s purse that they are a cancer.

    The haste shown by the GoB to increase the rates of the BWA was to facilitate the increase in the base rate given to the BL&P (BWA’s biggest expense by far) as that company was being primed for its eventual take over by Emera. IT WAS A DONE DEAL, soley for the sake of selling Bajan consumers to acquire short term FX… And a commission walked away with millions in fees.

    … F#ck this world …stupse


  15. What about the illegal increase of road taxes.


  16. Wasn’t there a Validation Bill passed for the road tax matter? Successive government have retroactively validated orders, nothing new.

  17. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    Unfaired asked a very good question. Your answer was correct in as much as that is what happened but in order for Government to legally do so, it would have to tear up the Constitution for a number of reasons but mainly because a person cannot be deprived of his property without the benefit of a written law. Government had a written law in place for the first four months when the increased road taxes were being collected (The Provisional Collection of Taxes Act). Under section 3 of that act the increased taxes ceased to be payable after four months if no law is passed. All the taxes that were paid ought to have been refunded. For he remainder of time that the tax was being collected, it was being done so illegally and should also have been refunded in accordance with section 5.

    Instead of refunding the money as required by law, Government passed an unconstitutional validation bill. Government cannot constitutionally deprive a person of his property retrospectively. Money is property.

    When that happened I went to several lawyers, including opposition lawyers, to take the Government to court for my refund. All of them acknowledged that I was right but refused to take the case. I did not have the resources to import one so the matter died for me.

  18. Would like to know . Avatar
    Would like to know .

    @ Caswell
    Since when do you require a lawyer to represent you in court ? I even see murder accuseds defending themselves . You seem to be better than most lawyers . Why would you rely on a mediocre /inferior person to defend you ?


  19. @ CF

    “The matter died…”

    Welcome to the Club.

    @ David

    The watchdog with teeth AGAIN


  20. Water rates before and after the increase are not economic.

    I believe they are low.

    BWA can have no competitors because it would under sell them, even now.

    We would finance the deficit as we do now.

    BL&P and C&W are private entities which would fold were they to sell their product the way BWA sells its product.

    That is not to say that the rule of law should not be respected ……. or that BWA should be privatised.

    I believe it is a mistake for FTC to regulate water rates … and for BWA to be privatised!!.

    Get the inefficiencies out of the supply and run BWA as a private entity would run a business before trying to put it under the FTC umbrella and expect it to perform as a private business would.


  21. On the email sent to BU posted above our research confirms that Gollop has always walked a high road in his career to date. There are a lot of games scheduled to be played in this the silly season.


  22. bro franklyn let me state up front that i have not yet done any research on the matter but if your post is indeed correct, it shows the disdain and contempt which both sides of the political divide have for system of governance in barbados and by extension the people they beg cap in hand every five years to vote for them. the political system seems to be one big fraternity which both parties run as their own fiefdom where they decide among themselves over which issues they are going to put on a show for the gullible supporters or public consumption in general. you mean to tell me that not even one high powered lawyer from her majesty’s opposition was not perspicacious enough to bring this illegal activity to the attention of the public or is it a case of letting sleeping dogs lie in the form of an unwritten truce across the political divide. except for the froth spewed by the opposition leader seemingly for political expediency, what more have we heard of his allegation of the illegal sale of fuel to minibuses by the transport board or the employmentby the BWA of anexecutive chairman contrary to the law. we claim to follow the Westminister Model but do you believe such an unsavoury state of governance would be allowed to go unchallenged in britain either by the parliamentof britain or interest groups. Will the label ‘banana republic’ be apt to describe in the nottoo didtant future?


  23. @ David
    …see why Bushie has Caswell earmarked as Chairman of the National Supervisory Committee now…?


  24. @ David
    It is amazing that this fellow Gollop can become a major decision maker for the Government overnight ; he has lived a very modest life all the years as a BLP supporter !
    This is really the silly season David .


  25. the more concerning thing is that the bwa project manager one STEVEN LINDO has been able to secure his little pick from the project, a brand spanking new HONDA CRV which is reported to be fully-loaded and purchased at approximately $200K.

  26. Rumour & slander Avatar
    Rumour & slander

    @ David .
    It seems that rumour and slander have taken over ….WELCOME TO THE SILLY SEASON . It would be interesting to find out who got disappointed in the tender for the project .


  27. @ John

    “I believe it is a mistake for FTC to regulate water rates … and for BWA to be privatised!!”

    Agreed, BIG time. We can still change a government and by extension have influence over the boards that govern a number of these entities and their management. I would NOT want to give these public servants the opportunity to behave as if they were working as private individuals, nah … They would shaft us all.

    You John, cannot prove that the BWA is still being subsidised and I on the other hand cannot prove that it is not …! But give me the BWA and the NPC in Government’s hands without FTC say so any day, any day, because to do other wise would virtually guarantee a significant increase in price WITHOUT the commensurate improvement in the quality of service delivered.


  28. @David. I am amazed at the accusations against Hal. In my wide experience, he is one of the most honourable and honest attorneys and people in Barbados and, if there is any sort of justice in Barbados at all, should be appointed one of Her Majesty’s counsel very soon – in fact, it is a scandal that he has not already been so appointed, instead of some of the political hacks. Hal was approached by the Government to do a job, which he accepted and which you may be sure, he will perform with his usual excellence.

    However, Hal (a BLP supporter, but a fine and upstanding lawyer first, foremost and always) has a detractor who used to hold high judicial office and who is a close friend and supporter of one CF.

    The silly season is in full flood. A pity the silliness involves attempting to besmirch the name of someone so far above them in every way. Envy is a terrible thing. So unattractive. But the people who really count know the true measure of Hal and are honoured to know and work with him.


  29. @Amused

    The BU household is not familiar with Hal but we are with his son Steve. If one believes the maxim that the berry does not roll far from the tree then Hal must be Ok.

    BU has always been impressed by his willingness to give time to the public by commenting on matters of national interest where demystifying the legalese was required. Let us hope as the silly season descend participants will remember there is no honour in punching low.


  30. David (content of email sent to BU) “Bids for a new office were called for from three firms and Innotech was the sole bidder.”

    in the 70s, an invitatation to tender on renovating a warehouse was sent to 8 contractors all of whom took tender documents.

    Only one of them submitted a bid and it was $200,000 over what it should have been.

    The tender was accepted because it was known that 7 people would have gotten some nice “gifts”. Modus operandi. early effective use of a cost over run.

    This happened in Quebec.

    Food for thought.


  31. Amused

    This whole QC thing and Sen Council thing want scrapping…. and the fact that a citizen would find it appropriate to be part of a political party in its modern post independence form (no nothing about pre- independence) and still be considered as upstanding shows a serious deficiency in the standards that such people are judged by. What has this man done to improve the imaged and substance of the political institution that he is a part of..? Why do people in this practice find it so necessary to be part of a party agenda?


  32. @Hants

    The DLP rode into office on the back of promoting change: do you think anything has changed.

    @Caswell

    In light of the belief that BL&P applied for a rate hike fully aware that there were moves to sell to EMERA, do we have options to hold hands to the fire.


  33. @ David

    This is the salient part of the mischief making emailer “Hal Gollop, on behalf of Government, is making all the decisions without the knowledge of the tender negotiating committee and is changing the fundamental basis of the contract”

    The Tender Negotiating Commitee was appointed by the Board of Directors of the BWA one assumes with the approval of the Minister. Mr. Hal Gollop was appointed by the Board of Directors of the BWA one assumes with the approval of the Minister. The Chairman of the Board of Directors of the BWA is himself a member of the Tender Negotiating Commitee.

    The salient issue is that Mr. Hal Gollop is not a member of the Tender Negotiating Commitee, he has been appointed to represent BWA’s best interest, legally speaking and report to the Board of Directors who may takes action(s) by the authority given to them under Barbados Water Authority Act CAP. 274A. The Tender Negotiating Commitee is a creature of the board for the purpose of carrying out a specific function, that of negotiating. However it should not be expected, nor will it happen, that an Attorney-at-Law who is qualified and experienced would be willing to have a Negotiating Commitee instruct him or her on how best they should advise their client, in this case, the BWA.

    It is clearly silly season. Mr. Gollop, a known supporter of the BLP but also a friend of the PM is the victim of someone who has decided to try and make the suggestion that Mr. Gollop is less that honorable or competent. Bajans know better when it comes to Mr. Gollop.


  34. Anarchy is knocking on the DOOR, has Barbados already let her/him in?


  35. “Bajans know better when it comes to Mr. Gollop”

    And how would you know this …?


  36. @ Hants

    Six firms expressed an interest in the project. Three were prequalified by BWA and its professional advisors. On the day of closing of tenders one firm wrote to BWA and said they could not raise the money necessary to fund the project, they could not meet the requirement. One of the other firms (up North of the island) did not even have the courtesy to send in a letter on the day the tender closed and apologise for not tendering. Inotec was the only tender received and which it seems met all the requirements. The company ( up North of the Island) who did not tender then started a campaign ably assisted by senior DLP Minister to have this company declared, even thought they did NOT bid, the company with whom the BWA should negotiate the project.


  37. To David:
    It seems as if Hal Gollop is doing everything thing the PM wants done to get the AG job and the silk.


  38. Could this be the same Hal Gollop who was part of the team that undertook the St Joseph Hospital Branford Taitt Inquiry? Should he know better, yes.


  39. @ David

    Whatever I personally feel about Mr Gollop and his associates and the tic-tack that is being floated here on the basis of an anonymous email – I hope we won’t carry on with this unseemly by-way until at least someone is straight enough to honour the record with a post. You cannot dismember a body with an innuendo and a conjecture. It’s simply not ‘sporting’ though I do appreciate very well that it’s not uncommon.


  40. @ Editor-in-Chief David,

    You becoming like the Nation?


  41. Public Joe wrote “Six firms expressed an interest in the project.”

    Cost over run can buy 5 bimmers or benzes……. but only in Canada eh!

  42. Rumour & slander Avatar
    Rumour & slander

    Lemuel
    ” It seems HG is doing everything the PM wants to get the AG job and silk ”
    Do you know the man ? Can you say that he does not qualify on MERIT for either position ? Are you just another sniper?


  43. @ Rumour & slander

    I am sure that Lemuel is a another one of the many jealous lawyers in Barbados. If a man is a making a way for him self based on merit, certain people (racked by envy no doubt) think it their place to do everything in their power to assinate the person integrity and character.

    How many millions did Adrian King, the attorney make since the DLP came to power.


  44. Listen, please stop sniping at Hal. He is one of the few in his profession whose ethics and conduct are not open to question, which is a hell of a lot more than the former high judicial officer who is, I am sure, behind this smear campaign. There are somethings that are so unjust as to be sickening – accusations of misconduct against Hal fall right slap bang into that category. I really am not amused. This is gutter behaviour and if this is the thanks that professionalism and integrity receive in Barbados, we have to ask ourselves two questions. First, why so many counsel eschew integrity. Second, why so many counsel end up in politics. Most things I let pass like water off a ducks back. But this is gratuitous scandal engineered I am sure by someone who not only forget his legal ethics, but has no interest in anything but his own self-glorification. Which, let me tell you, is dead, gone and can never be revived.


  45. What is happening in Barbados regarding how work is dished out without obligation to rules should concern all Barbadians.

    Adrian King is a lawyer of no extraordinary repute – certainly operating in the sphere of Gollop – yet the late Thompson saw fit to give him tonnes of work resulting in extrodinary fees. The fact that he is the husband of Natasha King (personal aid to late PM)should not be a concern.


  46. Come on!!!!! what do you expect of Mr Gollop? He’s FS neighbour, FS bwfore becoming P.M used to work in the same office as Hal Gollop. Time that a man do a favor for his buddy and in so doing do one for himself. Remember, the concern among the EAGER 11 was finding no financial supporters for the up coming elections. The DLP through the $ 5 million gift to Innotech, has secured their financing from us. Didtatorship at its best/worse. It seems the DLP would pull any stunt to remain in office, this silly season is going to get real dirty.


  47. @ Amused,

    I have tried to point out that contractors in Quebec conspired to circumvent the bidding process for their collective personal gain.

    You should focus on the possibility and or probability of this being the modus operandi in Barbados as well.


  48. @ The scout

    How could it be gift when everyone, anyone can see the work being done on the project since last year? Innotech done could down that mountain with all the bulldozers, excavators, jackhammers, trucks, bobcats, rollers and drillers.

    surely that is millions upon millions of dollars already done in work. % million my ass, you feel you does just get 5 million so.


  49. laaawd one poll and all kinda ‘new’ apologists on the blog

  50. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    We are going off track. This post is about the increased water rates that are being collected illegally: it is about Government breaching faith with the electorate or you could say deceiving the people of this country. This nonsense about Hal Gollop has nothing to do with the matter at hand.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending