Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Caswell Franklyn, Head of Unity Workers Union

By now Prime Minister Freundel Stuart should have re-read the relevant sections of the Constitution, the Public Service Act and the Commission of Inquiry Act and realised that he has seriously blundered in his handling of the industrial relations problems at the Alexandra School. He is sticking tenaciously to his explanation that he acted in accordance with the rule of law, but he did not go on to say which law.

I have done a diligent search and I have been unable to discover the particular rule of law that allowed the Prime Minister to intervene in a matter that involved allegations of misconduct by a public officer. Instead, I have found every reason why he should have steered clear of the now infamous Alexandra debacle. Judging from the state of the economy, he had better things to do than usurp the role that was already bestowed on others by the Constitution. It is enough to quote section 94 (1) of the Constitution to show who is responsible for disciplinary matters in the Public Service:

94 (1) Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, power to make appointments to public offices and to remove and exercise disciplinary control over persons holding or acting in such offices is hereby vested in the Governor-General, acting in accordance with the advice of the Public Service Commission.

Allegations of misconduct against public officers are supposed to be dealt with in accordance with the Code of Discipline in the Public Service, which can be found at the Third schedule of the Public Service Act. The code is quite detailed but in essence, if the Public Service Commission (PSC) is of the opinion that an officer has a case to answer in relation to an allegation of misconduct of a serious nature, it is empowered to bring a charge of misconduct against the officer and establish an investigatory committee to conduct an inquiry. The committee consists of three persons, one of which must be an attorney-at-law. It is empowered in much the same way as a commission of inquiry to summon witnesses and administer oaths. If they find that the charge is proven, they would set out to the PSC the reasons for arriving at its opinion and also recommend the penalty that may be imposed. The PSC may then make such decision as it considers appropriate and advise the Governor-General accordingly.

Paragraph 6 (1) of the Code of Discipline sets out the penalties that may be imposed if a charge of misconduct of a serious nature is proved:

(a) suspension on half pay for a period not in excess of 6 months;

(b) reduction in rank;

(c) suspension of future increments for a period not exceeding 2 years;

(d) reprimand in writing;

(e) compulsory retirement; or dismissal

So far there was no role for the Prime Minister.

Instead of allowing the established disciplinary procedure in the Public Service to work, the Prime Minister has chosen to set up a commission of inquiry which would investigate the Alexandra affair and make recommendations to the Governor-General. The question to be asked is: who would benefit from the establishment of such a commission of inquiry? The short answer is other than the lawyers representing interested parties, the only persons to benefit would be any person who is guilty of wrongdoing who is called to give evidence. That might seem strange but the easiest way to escape punishment for any offence is to go before the commission of inquiry and admit to any wrongful act that you would have committed.

Section 13 (2) of the Commission of Inquiry Act states:

No evidence given by a witness to an investigatory commission may be used against him in any subsequent trial or in any criminal or civil proceedings other than a prosecution for perjury in giving that evidence.

The procedure adopted by the Prime Minister for dealing with the Alexandra matter would ensure that any person who is guilty of an offence could escape any repercussions if he tells the truth before the Commission of Enquiry. On the other hand, if the PSC was allowed to do its job, anyone who would have been found to have committed an offence would have been subject to a range of penalties up to dismissal from the Public Service.

I understand the Prime Minister’s frustration over the protracted nature of the dispute. I also understand why he would use every opportunity to make himself look good, to the electorate, ahead of the election. However, I do not understand why he did not allow the PSC to do the job that it was constitutionally appointed to do, after all a new PSC was only appointed days before the announcement of this commission of inquiry. Do you still think that he was right to intervene?


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. It is now a customary convention and best practice for both sides in a protracted industrial dispute to seek the intervention of the office of the Prime Minister when all else has failed. The Prime Minister did not usurp the legal/lawful role of whatever government entity is responsible under the constitution for the hiring and firing civil servants. The PM’s intervention was by invitation from both sides in the matter.


  2. Adrian Hinds;
    Invitation by both sides? Did the Broomes side, which was apparently not consulted, invite the PM to intervene?


  3. thanks Check-it-out.Apparently we think alike alot.
    The PM’s intervention was ill-timed, ill-implemented and ill-political. The commission was a “retreat” position to buy time. Time will tell.

    @Caswell
    In another post I explained teh commission. Delay and diversion. that’s it.


  4. @ Caswell Franklyn.
    Your reference to the Prime Minister’s affirmation that he draws his guidance from THE RULE OF LAW by asking ” WHICH LAW ” , is a clear indication that , unlike the Prime Minister , you do not understand the foundation doctrine which A.V. Dicey described as THE RULE Of LAW . You should seek guidance before returning to engage in ANY discussion on this very intricate constitutional concept .


  5. You may be advised that no degree of “DILIGENT SEARCHING ” will be able to provide you with any crash-course understanding of the RULE OF LAW concept . Rest assured too , that you will not find ” the law ” that the Prime Minister referred to by searching for ” it ” ; the problem is with your own lack of comprehension of what the doctrine is meant to portray . CASWELL , an understanding of the RULE OF LAW requires DILIGENT STUDY ; NOT a DILIGENT SEARCH . Please be guided accordingly .


  6. Come on guys, what made the AX matter a hybrid had to do with the BSTU taking the matter to the CPO and the lack of response from that office. The dispute in its final permutation/phase was technically not between the BSTU and Broomes but BSTU and the CPO.

    It truly was a difficult matter which had become protracted over many years. In fact a diligent and alert Opposition should have come to office ready to grapple with this matter and NOT waited until it reared its head again as they knew it would.


  7. @Casewell. I understand and sympathise with what you are saying, but your argument is not at all solid, with respect. Taking the tone of the comments of “Legalese” aside, he/she (with no basis, I think he) is completely correct and you ought to follow his guidance. You predicate your argument on “an offense” and the follow-on from this “offense”. To my old eyes (and they are very old today) the problem is that you have to prove either that Mr Broomes has breached his contract, OR the teachers have breached theirs. To my eyes (aged) Mr Broomes has NOT breached his contract, BUT the teachers have theirs. In your job, you must be aware that this happens all over the world (not necessarily with teachers) all the time. And that governments, rather than opting for wholesale (or any) firing, try to find a means of resolution, rather than applying the strict letter of the law (and I deny your interpretation of the law in this case). In Freddie Waterman, government could not possibly have found a better person to head the commission – anywhere. I think that a little peaceful resolution, instead of blood-letting, is preferable here. But, let us wait and see what Mr Waterman comes up with. We are a small island and community and while some may say that the PM has acted out of political expediency (which may or may NOT be correct), I say that he has acted in a socially responsible way and as laws are made for society, not society for the laws, my views on your misinterpretation or misapplication notwithstanding…………

  8. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Adrian Hinds

    In your haste to disagree with me, you claimed that it is customary for both sides to ask the PM to intervene. You obviously do not understand what happens in industrial relation in this country. Calling in the PM in an industrial relations that has been developed by BWU when it wants to save face. When the PM is called in, they would have reached an impasse in the negotiations and neither side wants to backdown but are willing to settle. The PM comes in and appears to impose a settlement and both sides claims that they accept the solution out of respect for him. In essence the workers are deing deceived.

    Legalese

    It is obvious that you are a lawyer or legally trained but you are so off the mark with this one. The first civil service commission was established in 1855 as a means to keep politicians out of recruitment and discipline in the civil service. Go and trace your rule of law from there and then tell me if you still prepared to commit your opinion to writing. I am sure after you had the benefit of a researched opinion that David would take down you comments if you ask politely.

  9. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Amused

    Please re-read the post. I was trying to point, among other things, that a commission of inquiry is not the way to deal with a disciplinary matter. If Mr. Stuart had not intervened and allowed the matter to take its course, the same Justice Frederick Waterman could have been appointed as chairman of an investigatory committee by the same Governor-General to inquire the matter. The only difference is the way the PM went no one will be held liable for any wrongdoing.


  10. @Caswell

    Please clarify how the nuances in the Education Act which the PM suggests the Waterman Commission will have the Terms of Reference to scope/make recommendations could have been addressed otherwise.

  11. Observing (and polling) Avatar
    Observing (and polling)

    @david
    They couldn’t

    @caswell
    The issue moved past a disciplinary one some time ago. Strict application of procedures went through the door. If one were to apply “law” and procedures, then we would now be disciplining the minister, both chief education officers, the CPO as well as some of the same teachers, maybe, along with Broome. The original complaint(s) was lost in time and (in)action. Proof and evidence has become debatable. What was black and white has now gone past grey into murky. The commission is the best “overall” solution FOR THE PM, all things considered.
    Sometimes the best of the worst choices is the only choice we have.


  12. @ Caswell .
    So off the mark with what ????? to say that you do not understand the doctrine called THE RULE OF LAW ? The Rule of Law is NOT some Statute which you can refer to as you are inviting the Prime Minister to do ; you may be better guided by Amused . You either understand legal concepts or you do not . If , as in your case , you do not , you should seek guidance and come back . YOU OBVIOUSLY DO NOT UNDERSTAND THE CONCEPT REFERRED TO AS THE RULE OF LAW ; you should go and take up a text book on constitutional law rather than coming back to accuse me of being off the mark . Some concepts are not assimilated OVERNIGHT .

  13. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Legalese

    I know that I will incur your wrath but I can’t put this more delicately. You are a consummate bluffer. You have not addressed anything that I said. Show me where I am wrong according to the letter of the law, not some nebulous concept which you and the PM chose to hide behind. I have pointed out the actual legislation which guides the process. Wheel and come again, you are saying nothing!. Bluff bluff!


  14. @ Caswell.
    I have no problem being called a ” bluffer” if to be so called is to draw a distinction between what YOU understand by ” THE RULE OF LAW ” and what OTHER persons , the Prime Minister and I included , understand by it .
    Maybe you would like to indicate to all of us that you are NOT a bluffer by giving us a ” smattering ” of your understanding of that hallowed concept . I will not hold my breath in expectation of an INFORMED dissertation . Be assured however that you will not incur my ” wrath ” ; only my disappointment that you will continue to plunge into very deep waters where you do not have an intellectual safety belt .


  15. @ Caswell
    The Rule Of Law IS NOT ” the letter of the law ” which seems to be your understanding of it .


  16. It is interesting to watch cawell continue to dig a hole for himself on the”rule of law” most people have given up on his interpretation of law. i am happy to see that those of legal minds are attempting diligently to correct some of his misinformation on lawi finally i gave up on him when he/said that PM stuart wasunaware of some of the laws in the constituation.


  17. @Legalese
    I know you not but your reasoning has reached. Let’s see if the Rule of Law allows the letter of the law to function.

  18. An Observer.. Avatar

    Caswell boy , be guided by Paul Anka’s ” my way ” . It seems that you bit off more than you could chew ; you should therefore do as the song suggests..SPIT IT OUT …you are obviously out of your depth when you seek to tangle with this person who is no ” bluffer ” , but one learnt in the law. Peace as usual .


  19. I am of the opinion that the PM viewed the commision as a way out, politically. Once again he has proven that he does not have the capacity to solve any issues.

  20. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    An Observer

    Even when you use your real name, as a lawyer you tend to mislead. What would make you think that I have any confidence in your interpretation. I hope when you caution me about tangling with this person who is learnt in law, I hope that you are not speaking of yourself. After all you had more schooling than most in the law: four attempts at the external LLB; four years at Cave Hill; and then two years at Hugh Wooding. I think that qualifies you to say that you are learnt in law, but forgive me if I am not impressed.

  21. An Observer.. Avatar

    Caswell boy , no attempt at personal invective aimed at an imaginary target will detract from the fact that you have found yourself in trouble . You seem to enjoy biting off more than you can chew . Yesterday it was an attack on Sir Roy Trotman for insisting on proper treatment for workers at a business , an unusual step by a trade unionist yourself ; today it is an attack on the Prime Minister for holding up the the rule of law , a concept which you seem not to understand , as his guiding light…anybody can be next . by the way , the CV quoted above does not permit identification and no request will be made for yours . Peace as usual.


  22. To Legalese:
    How can one so devoid of any philosophical bearing can come here and under the guise of “great lawyer’, aided and abetted by “an observer” accuse Caswell of stating the obvious. Fruedel Stuart in the Alexandra debacle is not or should not be acting as a judge. His role is not to interpret the law but apply what is actually stated in the existing law, which would be the Constitution and the Public service Act. So remove this philosophical red herring and find better use of your great legalese.


  23. To Lemuel.
    I do not understand what you have said……” great lawyer ” !!! who made such a claim ?


  24. To Legalese:
    When a person such as thee uses words such as “assimulate”, “schooled” and “concepts”, the words great lawyer have to bev appended. You may not have said it overtly, but one can deduce the greatness in the dismissive nature of your repsonse to Caswell. He is and always shall be the “people’s lawyer”. And what a distinction. By the way your philosophical slip is showing through your hubris.


  25. To David
    maybe you can use your superior comprehension skills to assist us in understanding what ” Lemuel ” has posted above ; it is way beyond the ken of a mere mortal such as I .


  26. Man Caswell, if Bushie was you father – no matter your age, marital status or financial independence, the bushman would make it his business to cut your behind for this latest infraction….

    LOL – One gets the distinct impression that you are seeking to destroy the meticulously built image that has been crafted for you here on BU, in preparation for your assuming the critical post of Chairman of the National Supervisory Committee.

    Did Bushie not previously advise you that the role of a leader (PM) goes way beyond the LEGAL? As long as an issue shows the potential to disrupt the established and accepted norm, a good leader IS REQUIRED to intervene for moral, social, strategic and other reasons to get things back on track.

    Where the matter has been as controversial and protracted as AX, perhaps he is wise to enlist a commission. The proof of the pudding will be in the final outcome.

    If the Rule of Law had been of any use, then the PM would not have been needed, and perhaps would have continued to be unaware of the issue…if his press conference and the CLICO report saga is any guide… 🙂

    Caswell, keep out of these items in which you are personally involved NUH!!! …especially to do with AX and Sir Roy… You just planting ground for monkey to run on….


  27. @Caswell
    I have to agree with my namesake and Legalese. You are assuming that the issue is one SOLELY about alleged misconduct by a public officer, which is what it may have STARTED out as but which EVOLVED into much more after December. I however can and would agree with you totally if you were willing or able to state the following for us laypersons

    a) the alleged misconduct and by whom
    b) the grievance raised as a result of that misconduct and by whom
    c) who the grievance and requested action was targeted against
    d) other officers who “misconducted” themselves by not addressing the misconduct in (a)
    e) the nature of the misconduct which arose by not addressing the misconduct
    f) the grievance against the persons in (d) based on the inaction in (e)
    g) who or what the PSC should be mandated to investigate and
    h) who should be disciplined or called to account based on misconduct in (a) and (e)

    Bare in mind the above is only from the BSTU’s perspective, I have not considered Mr. Broomes, nor the MEHRD’s in their attempt to handle the matter in January or before. Suffice to say, the evolved matter is no longer simply one of grievance and application of the Public Service Act or any other for that matter “at this time.” To simplify it to that would totally miss the intention of the PM’s action and render criticism of it null and void.

    The results of the commission will provide a path to the use of the adequate laws (and subsequent appeals) when it completes its findings. You are correct that the PM cannot, should not and will not be a conduit of discipline.

    Just observing


  28. @legalese

    Lemuel has suggested in the three words provided by way of example, such words are to be found in the lexicon of learned lawyers. He has concluded from your use of said words that you are talking ‘down’ to Caswell.

    @lemuel

    Good to see you with us again?


  29. To Legalese:
    Let me be of some help. Those of you who because of opportunity and a smattering of family ties get to assume the role or study of the Law always seem to find no place for lesser morals. So let me quote from Lord Bingham (March 10, 2010). He in his lecture indicated that the Rule of Law is so nebulous; that a definitition has defied great legal brains for some time. We know that your legal brain would not have been one so mystified. However, he did proffer the following definition: “The Rule of Law” is a constitution priciple used by many – lawyers, judges, parliaments, international agreements. He said that it can be described as that constitutional principle where “all individuals and organizations within the state, whether public or private, are bounded and entitled to the benefit of laws prospectively promulgated and publicly administred by the courts.” Quarrel not with Caswell, but chew away at Lord Bingham and the learned gentlemen of legalese in England. I do hope that this was as helpful to me as it was to you, Legalese.


  30. @ David
    My appeal was in respect of Lemuel’s earlier post ; the chronology got confused .


  31. To david:
    I only come when there is something to chew on and I am loving Legalese as a morsel.


  32. To Legalese:
    Where is this philosophical soap box that Freudel stuart is purported, by you at least, to be standing on? Would not every one of us expect that in finding any solution to the mess at Alexandra that the PM would want to ensure that Mr. Broomes is assured of his constitutional rights? Where is the Rule of Law argument you are pushing my friend?


  33. To Lemuel.
    You have hit the nail on the head by quoting Lord Bingham on THE RULE OF LAW . You should therefore appreciate my point when I said to Caswell that he could not be dealing with that doctrine by asking the Prime Minister to indicate which law he was referring to . I can have no quarrel with you . You should therefore seek to impress upon your friend who you rush to defend that he has a warped view of what the concept represents . You may even seek to do it IN PRIVATE . By the way , ” assimilate , schooled and concept ” are everyday words which a scholar like you can ASSIMILATE . is that not true ? LOL


  34. @ Lemuel.
    “……and a smattering of family ties ” ???????????? you got de wrong man fella !


  35. To Legalese:
    Don’t be fooled by my grammar or syntax; for all you know I could have some leaned friend pen these words. I am no more scholar than you are my friend. But I do beleive that more philosophical concepts should be debated here.


  36. @ David .
    you should know by now that it is impossible to talk down to Caswell . I have never known anybody , since reading these blogs , who consistently refers to other persons , whatever their rank , as being foolish , stupid , duncy and all the other derogatory terms that help to distinguish them from Caswell himself as a person of exceptional talent and ability .

  37. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Lemuel

    I am not offended in the least by any comments made by “Legalese” or “An Observer” they are doing their master’s bidding. They spring into action like attack dogs if they think that their political interest is being criticized. They are simply behaving like educated yard-fowls. They search for one scintilla of doubt in any contribution that I make and run off beating it to death as though it was the trust of the entire presentation. In all his rantings “Legalese” has shown a level of hatred that spoils his comments.

    The rule of law as you quoted from Lord Bingham’s lecture absolutely agrees with what I am saying:

    He said that it can be described as that constitutional principle where “all individuals and organizations within the state, whether public or private,
    are bounded and entitled to the benefit of laws prospectively promulgated and publicly administred by the courts.”

    That definition would suggest that the Prime Minister was bounded by the laws promulgated and publicly administered by the courts. The Constitution and the Public Service Act are two such acts that the PM ignored when he intervened in the Alexandra dispute.

    Legalese and An Observer

    I have been abused by professionals: your lame attempts do not deter me (ask Bush Tea) but you are welcome to continue trying.

  38. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Observing

    You are behaving like a lawyer (far better one than “An Observer”) you ask the questions for which you already have answers, but I will play along.

    The Principal and the teachers have been complaining for each other. Without going into the merits or demerits of the charges and counter charges, there are more than enough people to be investigated for at least a bare minimum of dereliction of duty. For example, the complaints of the Principal were ignored by officials in the Ministry of Education going all up the way to the Permanent Secretary; the Chief Personnel Officer did not deal with the matter in a timely manner. All of these officials could have been investigated by the Public Service Commission.

    By the way, everyone seems to be avoiding the fact that any truthful evidence given before the commission cannot be used against the person giving the evidence. As a result, neither Broomes nor the teachers have anything to fear coming out of the commission of inquiry as long as they tell the truth no one can touch them, and that is what the PM’s intervention would accomplish. No one will pay for any misconduct, but could that be the intention? Just asking……


  39. Isnt this the said Caswell that was advising Mary Redman behind the scene to take the mattet to the PM. and during the fiasco was the said caswell in contact with the PM. If his answee is in the affirmative, has he now realized what he realized, or is he an opportunist and has there been a falling out between Caswell and the PM since there was no resolution?


  40. .” Yesterday it was an attack on Sir Roy Trotman for insisting on proper treatment for workers at a business , an unusual step by a trade unionist yourself ”

    i have been unable to deduce from any of the comments made against sir roy that the purported attacks against him were as a result on his insistence on proper treatment for workers. the views expressed against sir roy suggested to me that they were as a result of the venom and belligerence in his remarks and their propensity to insult.

  41. Sunshine Sunny Shine Avatar
    Sunshine Sunny Shine

    Caswell Franklyn

    I am always impressed by your writings but not impressed if you try to proclamate yourself as some all knowing oracle who cannot be subjected to correction. Please tell me that your intellectual capability has led you to believe that you are”way beyond” reproof. Also why are you subjecting yourself to hurling what is obvious belittling remarks to those who are seeking to guide you. Come on Caswell you are bigger than that and this gal always read what you have to say. Right now your remarks are making you sound like an arrogant, untouchable baffoon.

  42. Sunshine Sunny Shine Avatar
    Sunshine Sunny Shine

    should read…..has not let you to believe….


  43. what i find puzzling is mr stuart’s new found passion to belatedly seek recourse behind the RULE OFLAW IN trying to resolve the alexandra dispute.i would have been inclined to believe that the prime minister’s passion for the Rule of law was genuine if he had abided by the RULE OF LAW rather than having to change the constitution to ensure mr Gibson.s appointment to the office of chief justice met the requirements of the rule of law.

  44. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Sunshine Sunny Shine

    I am sorry you feel that way. Don’t be fool by Legalese and An Observer, they are not trying to correct me. They are seeking to attack and belittle me for their own political reasons. I am not aware of the identity of Legalese but I can see his delight in trying to make me look foolish. However, I am aware of the identity of “An Observer” and rest assured he has only the interest of Freundel Stuart at heart. He only springs into action to defend the PM, not to correct me.

  45. An Observer.. Avatar

    @ Caswell .
    You are ” aware of the identity of An Observer ” whom , unprovoked , you continue to vilify by PERSONAL attacks . I wonder whose fire rage you have taken up . Keep swiping ! Peace as usual .

  46. An Observer.. Avatar

    @ Caswell.
    By the way you seem to have some deep phobia with someone having the interest of FREUNDEL STUART , THE PRIME MINISTER OF BARBADOS. Do you consider him unworthy of that high office ?


  47. Don’t you see the P.M is a law unto himself? What he is doing is getting back at the EAGER 11 by going against much of their mouthings, regardless of what the LAW states. Remember how he dissed Donville Inniss with the health care for non-nationals? Now he has dissed him AGAIN among others by declaring Sir Roy said nothing wrong, this after Inniss lambasted Sir Roy on the floorr of Parliament. The P.M has silenced Jones and others, he will leave Sinckler for last

  48. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    An Observer

    Unprovoked! Are you serious? You know me well enough to know that I don’t do the fire rage thing. You keep attacking me for my honestly held views because they don’t coincide with your new found political affiliation. In the past you had high praise for my knowledge of the law, but when I say something that you don’t like about the PM all of a sudden you think that I am an idiot and you pounce. I understand that you and the PM are friends but a true friend tell his friend when he is going wrong. I do no hold your comments against you. Peace as usual my friend.

  49. Observing (and communicating) Avatar
    Observing (and communicating)

    @Caswell
    so you are consistent then in saying that coming out of this mess in December/January, that the Public Services Commission should have or needs to investigate the following simultaneously

    a) Jeff Broome
    b) Mrs. Greaves
    c) The acting chief education officer
    d) The acting deputy chief education officer
    e) the minister of education
    f) the chief personnel officer
    g) Mary Redman

    After which, they can then determine simultaneously whether
    a) misconduct occured
    b) whether it was of a minor or major nature
    c) the course of discipline that merits the nature in (b)
    d) the time and method of carrying out such discipline and
    e) the alternate arrangements, payments or logistical concerns needed to facilitate all the above.

    I think I now fully understand what you have been advocating. I’ll however withhold my opinion on the
    a) feasibility
    b) rationality
    c) desirability
    d) logistical improbability and
    e) political folly

    of it all.

    Just observing.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending