Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

CCJ Justices

During the recent sitting of the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) in Barbados, BU has received information from a credible source that the CCJ justices met with Barbados’ judges and expressed to them their displeasure and dismay at the state of the Barbados courts. While the CCJ placed all the blame at the feet of the Barbados Judiciary, BU feels that the Registry must share this blame equally.

The source of the massive build-up of 3,500 cases that have remained unheard for years, or part-heard for years or on which judgements have been undelivered (reserved) for years stems from the time of the appointment of Sir David Simmons as chief justice, it can be revealed.

Prior to the appointment of Sir David Simmons, cases were motored through the courts by the lawyers themselves, who had to answer to their clients for delays or a failure to adequately prosecute matters.

However, Sir David changed the Civil Procedure Rules so that cases were assigned to judges, in actual fact and practice for the terms of the natural lives of each judge so assigned. This has created a situation where the Registry is able to blame the judges and the judges in their turn have a scapegoat in the Registry.

And both judges and Registry are playing this situation to the max to the detriment of litigants and taxpayers. Indeed, to the detriment of our off-shore investment industry which, as was recently noted by Opposition Leader Owen Arthur, has fallen off to crisis point. Although Mr Arthur stops short of laying the blame squarely where it belongs – on the shoulders of himself and his appointee as chief justice.

Several recent examples have come to light where judges clerks have telephoned counsel to advise that decisions will be given on a specific date at a specific time, counsel turns up in court only to be told that the judge is, variously, on holiday, out of the island, sick, not ready, etc.

Effectively, this means that counsel that have already juggled their schedules (usually on less than 24 hours notice from the judge’s chambers) have their time wasted and then have to bill their clients for their time which in good faith they had every reason to believe would be well spent, but in fact proves to be a complete waste of time and money attributable SOLELY to the judge in question.

In one standout case which has for the moment to remain nameless, delivery of a reserved judgement was scheduled with counsel turning up in court to receive the judgment (a judgement that had been by then reserved for over TWO YEARS) on a case that had been started almost 10 years ago. BUT, the call to receive judgement occurred not once, but several time……and this is the NORM! So if you have two counsel on each side, each of which is charging $500 per hour, litigants are being charged $4,000 for each occasion times the number of occasions.

Meanwhile, BU has ascertained from several counsel (some of them silks) that when they write to the Registrar, no response is even forthcoming – not even by e-mail. And the same thing from the judges.

But the favourite excuse of the judges for not providing judgements is that the Registry has not yet typed them up. This is the lamest of the lot. In other jurisdictions, judges read their judgements and orders that they have written by hand and copies of these handwritten judgements are then provided to counsel, pending the fully typed up version. These judgements bear witness to the crossed-out and initialled and re-drafted work of the judges – AND THEY ARE ENFORCEABLE so as to expedite the delivery of justice. But why should the Barbados court system try to expedite justice?

And all this rot set in solely during the tenure of Sir David Simmons who now, along with his political lobby, seems intent on trying to persuade a far from credulous Barbados public and NOT as the result of the total mess made by Sir David, but due to the failure of Chief Justice Gibson.

Unfortunately for Sir David, the very transparency of Chief Justice Gibson and Gibson CJ’s willingness to highlight the inherited problems he is facing and to discuss freely the solutions he would want to see put in place, have made Sir David’s tactics subject to universal condemnation. Likely out of most proper professional ethics, however, Gibson CJ does not mention the most effective solution which we all know is to fire 75% of the judges and the Registry, starting with the Registrar, all (or most) appointed by or on the advice of Sir David Simmons.

It is a sad circumstance that, Bajans having been raised from the cradle to respect judges and their support organisation, the Registry, now have no respect for them whatsoever, above all Barbados’ former chief justice.

Let those judges reflect that as they drive around Barbados with their official cars and police drivers and go into court with everyone bowing, the thought on every Bajan mind is that they are a bunch of freeloading parasites whose monumental egos and incompetence have ruined our justice system and our off-shore industry and who, rather than making any effort to support the efforts of the Chief Justice, are actively campaigning with the loser whom he replaced and exposing Barbados to international disdain, the ruin or our off-shore sector and the open and aggressive censure of the justices of the Caribbean Court of Justice. Almost every civil case that has come before the CCJ from Barbados has drawn uncomplimentary remarks on Barbados’ judicial system from the justices of the CCJ. One is hard-put to find any appeals from Barbados in the judgements of which the CCJ has not commented negatively on the length of time involved in the Barbados courts.

This is shameful and unacceptable and it clearly high time government provided the back-up to the CJ to take extraordinary measures to dismiss the persons responsible, rather than have these parasitic incompetents spending their working lives doing nothing but drag Barbados down both reputationally and financially and then expensing the taxpayers for the remainder of their lives to pay pensions to them.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. @ David

    But you’ve side-stepped – we’re on different planets – and so discussion of this issue is utterly futile.

    But now I see you’re factoring remand prisoners. Great. Let’s have a post on that.

    Someone made the point recently that we expect too much from one person – that by reason of office we give them ‘greathood’ status and so feel let down when we discover they’re not.

    I think we are expecting too much of one man. Remember he actually has to deliver judgments and much besides. But that prompts me to say that maybe what is needed is a non-judicial executive officer who would work with the CJ to deal with ALL this sort of thing. I don’t mean the Registrar….someone less ‘within’. Alternatively, you might have a Law Commission which scrutinises matters like delay as part of the over-all reforming process. We’ve discussed that.


  2. @ JBO

    I have never suggested any of the things you mention. BUT see what I just wrote. You are totally wrong – I do NOT think DS is Superman, nor anyone else.


  3. @check

    Relax, relax and stop with this mistaken identify. it detracts from ur reponse.

    David will tell u that i do not attack, unless i am attacked. As i said if i find something illogical in what u r saying, i will pounce on it and it is for u to prove what i am sayinf is wrong, but dont isuslt my intelligence, even though i am not intelligent,


  4. @robert

    It doesn’t matter what the problems are for the purpose of this discussion, the office of CJ has to get it done or step aside.


  5. The age-old political cop-out. A commission. Okay, since some want it, let us have a royal commission, but let us call it instead a “tribunal”. The Barbados Constitution provides:

    84. 3. A Judge may be removed from office only for inability to discharge the functions of his office (whether arising from infirmity of body or mind or any other cause) or for misbehavior, and shall not be so removed except in accordance with the provisions of subsection (4).

    4. A Judge shall be removed from office by the Governor General, by instrument under the Public Seal, if the question of the removal of that Judge form office has, at the request of the Governor General, made in pursuance of subsection (5), been referred by Her majesty to the Judicial Committee of Her Majesty’s Privy Council and the Judicial Committee has advised Her Majesty that the Judge ought to be removed from office for inability as aforesaid or for misbehavior.

    5. If the Prime Minister (in the case of the Chief Justice) or the Chief Justice after consultation with the Prime Minister (in the case of any other Judge) advises the Governor General that the question of removing a Judge form office for inability as aforesaid or for misbehavior ought to be investigated, then –

    a. the Governor General shall appoint a tribunal which shall consist of a Chairman and not less than two other members selected by the Governor General in accordance with the advice of the Prime Minister (in the case of the Chief Justice) or of the Chief Justice (in the case of any other Judge) from among person who hold or have held office as a judge of a court having unlimited jurisdiction in civil and criminal matters in some part of the Commonwealth or a court having jurisdiction in appeals from any such court:

    b. that tribunal shall enquire into the matter and report on the facts thereof to the Governor General and advise the Governor General whether he should request that the question of the removal of that Judge should be referred by Her Majesty to the Judicial Committee: and

    c. if the tribunal so advises, the Governor General shall request that the question should be referred accordingly.

    6. The provisions of the Second Schedule shall apply in relation to tribunals appointed under subsection (5).

    7. If the question of removing a Judge from office has been referred to a tribunal appointed under subsection (5), the Governor General, acting in accordance with the advice of the Prime Minister (in the case of the Chief Justice) or of the Chief Justice after the Chief Justice has consulted with the Prime Minister (in the case of any other Judge), may suspend the Judge from performing the functions of his office.”

    “Misbehaviour” is constituted by inordinate delays in the delivery of judgements that leads to the denial of justice in contravention of the Constitution Article 18.8.

    We need no commission of enquiry. All we need to do is to examine the case files at the Registry, ascertain which ones have completed hearing and when and if decisions have been reserved for an inordinate length of time, refer the names of the offending judges to the Tribunal to have said judges removed.

    Really very simple. The rules are there and all that needs to be done is to apply them!!!!

    Article 84.7 is instructive in that judges can then be appointed on a temporary basis to replace those under suspension, pending the outcome of the deliberations of the Tribunal.

    Now, what could be simpler?

    @Bushie and Blogger2012, you guys are on a roll and I am thoroughly enjoying it.


  6. @Amused

    Thanks for educating bloggers again, it is clear that no one likes to bell the cat in this country. We look for reasons why something cant happen,

    I could recall while attending high school, my headteacher would always tell me that the berries from the tree in the court yard were going to fall on my head regularly. That was because I used to challenge the headtecaher when something didnt song logical or if I had my own interpretation of an event, particulary that relating to histroy. It however turned out that she was wrong althought i wanted to be a lawyer and if i had suceeded, perhaps the said berries she had spoken about might have fallen on my head, bust as a lawayer and not as a criminal,

    By the way, i am enjoying the discourse with check it out. I see Bushie like he run Jonh. Bushie why you dont leave John, check it out and caswell.

    peace my brother.


  7. I note that Amused has declared victory in this skirmish of words. I think I should also declare victory and move on and I will at the end of this piece.

    Anyhow, back to Bush Tea, David, Amused and Just being Objective who made comments that appear on the surface to be totally objective but on closer examination leaves a lot to be desired re. factoring in the real environment in which the Barbados Justice System operates.

    The thread that connects the contributions from all the above is that poor Leadership by the CJ transcends all other factors involved in our apparent moribund Justice system. There is an attractive ring to that supposition, especially since it is apparently considering the Barbados Justice system to be analagous to those used in many management systems in Metropolitan countries. Thus if a football team is doing badly fire the coach. If a big business enterprise is doing badly fire the CEO.

    I don’t know if the current Justice system in Barbados can work in this way at present because of its antecedents and the Public Sector structure in which it is firmly based. Perhaps Amused and RR and an Observer and AnonLegal and any other BU lawyer or wannabee lawyer could advise us.

    My understanding of the Barbados Justice system is that it is a megalithic, anachronistic one based on 19th century precepts, customs and practices that ill suits it for survival in the 21st century and, taken together, almost imbues it with a life of its own that slowly and surely responds negatively to any effort to effect meaningful change, Judicial inertia if you will.

    I think DS tried to drag the Barbados justice system into the 21st century and that certain elements of the system ensured his apparent failure as they will ensure the failure of anyone else who tries to set up a new system that seeks to constrain powerful people in a manner to which they have not been accustomed and that they have not willingly bought into. He appeared to have concentrated on such things as providing the new Law Courts to ensure the comfort of those using the system, modernising the IT system or rather setting up a comprehensive IT system, bringing in ADR, hiring more Judges and adjunct staff, training professionals and adjunct staff, setting up new rules of conduct and, I’m certain, the lawyers on the blog can add several more improvements which he introduced and found funding for but that appeared to be stillborn. eg. He also appears to have put a number of people oriented innovations in train based on my reading of his speech that David linked to near the beginning of this blog.

    As someone stated earlier on the blog, there was push back from the stakeholders in the justice system. I believe that pushback was essentially to ensure that those stakeholders did not lose status or material benefit from accepting a new system. The Lawyers really like it so. Change will only lead to some losses for them and must be resisted in the way they know best, i.e. inordinate delays.

    As I hinted earlier, imho, poor leadership could only be ascribed to the former CJ if it can be proven that, having access to all the resources, carrots and sticks that could control and propel the Justice system forward, he had failed to act or had acted improperly.

    I think he acted in an adequate way as allowed by the system.


  8. @ David

    In order to demonstrate your integrity, will you kindly explain to Amused what I meant by a “Law Commission” and briefly outline the discussions we’ve had on this and your then response to my proposal.


  9. @ Check-it

    I don’t know you other than through what you write. I want to say that I regard you as an honest, sincere and highly intelligent person who writes very well. It’s been a pleasure doing business with you here and I wish you very well.


  10. @robert

    From memory it came out of a discussion about how local legal beavers could be used to review existing laws many which we know to be irrelvant. BU was on the side of using outside help to bring technology to bear in collaboration with local talent. You and Chris were of the view a cross functional team of local legal luminaries should suffice.

    http://bajan.wordpress.com/2012/04/24/cost-of-the-use-of-money-too-high-in-barbados/


  11. @ David

    Yes – thankyou. But I think the record shows – to be very clear about this – that after some uncertainty you agreed that the issue relating to outside help concerned only the use of technology without bearing on the composition or functions of the Commission. I think CH’s role was only to pinpoint what seemed like a disagreement between us about who should do what.


  12. David said:

    “BU’s position is simple, the buck stops with the CJ.”

    I have a problem with this statement.

    I think that merely pointing a finger at the guy in charge is a lazy diagnosis. That approach does not involve any real analysis of what truly needs to be changed in order to improve the system.

    We need to start appreciating that if the problems within the court system were easy to solve, they would have been solved a long time ago. I for one have made several suggestions on how to improve the system. I haven’t seen any of those suggestions implemented. However, I recognize that there could be factors, unknown to me, that prevent my ideas from being executed.

    For example, it is my personal view that the courts are under resourced. There are too few judges. To add insult to injury, the remuneration of Barbadian judges appears to be too small to attract leading jurists from the private bar to the bench (no disrespect to the Judges currently serving).

    I am tempted to ask “Why don’t the powers that be appoint more judges (even if just to act)?” “Why don’t they pay the current judges better?” etc

    On the face of it, these may seem like valid questions for me to ask. But I realize that the Chief Justice is working within a budget and perhaps the money isn’t there to pay additional judges or persons to act as judges.

    Here is another example. I have continuously stated that I think that the drafters of the “new” Civil Procedure rules made a mistake when they did not incorporate automatic referral to mediation. That would have, at the very least, prevented the current back log from getting any worse.

    But I again appreciate that a lack of resources may be the reason automatic referral to mediation was left out in the first place. In other jurisdictions, there are Dispute Resolution Centers that are fully staffed. Those centers ensure that the mediation process runs efficiently. Barbados does not seem to have such a center and it may be that no one has any interest in investing in one. I can’t blame the Chief Justice for that, can I?

    My point is this: Rather than just blame whoever is in charge, maybe we should consider the possibility that it is a lack of resources rather than poor leadership that has been causing/worsening the problems in Barbados’ court system.


  13. Robert Ross; Thanks very much for the accolades. I try my best but sometimes I think that the effort is like spinning top in mud. Anyhow, I tried. It was actually enjoyable crossing swords with Bush Tea, particularly, because I consider him to be arguably the best longstanding blogger on BU, and who with very few well chosen words and in a style of his own, can zero in on the meat of any discussion and always make sense.

    I was on the tag team with him re. AX and opposed him on this one. Perhaps on the next one we may be on the same side again. But it really doesn’t matter. I think such discussions ensure that the quality of David’s BU is maintained at a high level.

    Re. your contributions here, I found that there were excellent, consistent, unbiased, thoughtful and well put.

    Over and Out.


  14. @Anonlegal

    Everything in your last comment maybe true but if the system to get better there must be leadership from the person entrusted with the responsibility to lead. Last check the CJ position is responsible for leading the Judiciary. It is up to that person to lobby and or fashion available resources to deliver justice to Barbadians. How the CJ uses the office to achieve the goal is how we the people must evaluate his performance.

    The reason why this government hired a CJ from outside the inner ring was in response to the view that local candidates would have had the albatross of small island relationships and lack of experience to re-engineer the administration of the judiciary given its current state.


  15. The majority of you seem focused either on vilifying Simmons or defending him.

    Politics and elitism dominate this blog but only BushTea has acknowledged the most important reason for correcting the problems in the Justice system.

    Justice delayed, especially to an innocent person is a scourge on a so called almost first world country.

    All de lotta long talk and Simmons and the $400 per hour gang eating steak and innocent people eating prison food.


  16. @ Checkit-out
    “…..poor leadership could only be ascribed to the former CJ if it can be proven that, having access to all the resources, carrots and sticks that could control and propel the Justice system forward, he had failed to act or had acted improperly.”
    ********************
    LOL
    if we accept your standard as outlined here, any idiot can be a good leader…. or more correctly, it will take a special effort by a complete fool to be classified as a poor leader,,,,

    Come on Checkit, if given ‘access to all the needed resources’ what will the ‘leader’ be bringing to the table…?

    Great leaders are those who work with what they have, often against great odds, to achieve the goals set. Your excuse for the former CJ may even be tenable if he could claim to have been surprised by the extent of the challenge he would face.
    DS CAN’T claim such ignorance. He knew what he was facing; He knew what obstacles he would encounter; and he should have known whether or not he had the balls for the job.

    Long and short – he did NOT. It is actually quite simple. 🙂 the obstacles were too much for him, and he failed to achieve the goals set. It will now take someone with larger testosterone manufacturing facilities to overcome the challenges and achieve the set goals.


  17. LOL @ Anonlegal
    My point is this: Rather than just blame whoever is in charge, maybe we should consider the possibility that it is a lack of resources rather than poor leadership that has been causing/worsening the problems in Barbados’ court system.
    **********************************
    Brilliant.

    Since it is all explained, we can all continue to wallow in mediocrity as the system grows increasingly inefficient.

    ……but wait! this is from a LAWYER right? ..one of those who MAKE MORE MONEY from long drawn out cases?
    ….who can afford to take on more work than they can do – because finish dates are unlimited….
    ….who would NEVER find himself or his family up DODDS on remand..?

    RIGHT!!!


  18. Bush Tea; You’re mostly right in your characterization of that paragraph which you uneeringly zeroed in on. I can only claim that I was tired when I wrote it and was in a hurry to finish off the post to sweep the yard etc., in preparation for a visit by some of my wife’s friends.

    What I should have said was;
    ….. poor leadership could only be ascribed to the former CJ if it can be proven that, having access to ALL the resources, carrots and sticks that could control and propel the Justice system forward, he had failed to combine and use those resources to the fullest extent possible to significantly improve the system

    Note that with that prescription, you, amused, et al, would have to be in a position to show that he had access to all the resources necessary to move the system forward and had failed to do so before you could claim his poor leadership was responsible for the state of the justice system. Granted, he had better access to hard resources than any of his predecessors by virtue of his connections to the ruling party in the first part of his tenure that would have been spent primarily in developing strategies, identifying monetary resources, training avenues, etc., but in the second part he would have been swimming against a strong tide.

    Perhaps you should look at his performance in phases and see how you would rate him in those phases and overall. (I know, you would say he was poor throughout.)

    I’m sorry, none of us on this blog has that data and can categorically and truthfully say that his very arguable poor leadership is solely to blame for the current state of the Justice system.

    And I noted you said above …the obstacles were too much for him…... I agree and they would have been too much for most. Lets see how your boy MG does in a situation where most of the preliminary work has been done for him. For argument’s sake suppose the BLP wins the next elections in 2013 or whenever and MG fails to make significant inroads into improving the Justice system at the end of that term, Given that he started out with much of the conceptual and infrastructural groundwork already completed by DS, would you also ascribe his failure to poor leadership only.

    Uh really dun now.


  19. @ Checkip-out
    Bushie dun too…
    ..case rested.

    As for MG, his name is already penciled into Bushie’s book of failures 🙂

    …based on his slow and indecisive start and the growing likelihood that he will become ensnared in the whole mess, Bushie will be hugely impressed if MG shows himself to have the requisite spherical requirements.

    Now if BT was the CJ here is how it would go down….
    Month 1 – meetings with stakeholders and a review of the stats.
    Month 2 – A study of similar jurisdictions to review results and methodologies
    Month 3 – brainstorming sessions with key players
    Month 4- The Plan for change finalized and targets set
    Month 5 & 6 – identify about 6 idiots in the system and fire them (there are ALWAYS idiots available for such an exercise. 🙂 )
    Ongoing – Publish results (eg performance levels) and continue the lookout for more idiots…
    Month 4-12 Legally but mercilessly crush all efforts to sidetrack the plan
    month 12 – Brag about the Unbelievable results achieved….

    Easy as 1 to 12…..


  20. Something checkit-out intimated which is as true as John 3:16. If an Owen Arthur led government were to win the next government there is no way MS will be allowed to outshine DS. It means that MG will definitely have to make his moves before the government changes.

    We rest.


  21. I ask again…

    1. What was the backlog of cases in 2002?

    2. Of the backlog in 2010, how many cases had merely been filed and how many were ready for hearing and for how long?

    Until answers are provided to those questions nothing has been demonstrated – and we are left with opinions, whims, superstitions, bigotry and prejudice – in short, the usual agendas. We expect so much from others. What satisfies us in ourselves?


  22. @Anonlegal.

    You say that we should not point a finger at the person in charge. I say that is balls and you know it.

    You say that if the matter was easy to fix, it would have been fixed. That too is balls and you know it. It IS easy to fix. Just follow Bushie’s recipe. Fire a few people. But as Bushie says, this requires balls, as the primary concern of CJ Simmons was POLITICS not JUSTICE and he was careful to do nothing to rock a boat that, frankly, needs capsizing, draining and completely refurbishing. The Justice System is supposed to be independent legislative body. However, by appointing someone directly from the legislative body as CJ, this independence was severely compromised and the holder of the office, instead of shrugging off his legislative role and political habits, brought them right into the justice system.

    Agree that there are too few judges, but also state that the judges are making no effort to move things along. Agree that some of the better brethren ought to be asked to serve temporarily to clear the backlog. OR senior counsel from overseas brought in temporarily. Just to clear the backlog. I like the idea of the overseas counsel best, as they are uncontaminated by the political invasion of the justice system that took place under Simmons.

    I will not comment on the remuneration of judges, but will let the public decide. Judges are paid about $120,000 per year, in addition to serious perquisites like official car, trips overseas as taxpayer expense, driver, gas etc. So you might say that the cost of the package to the taxpayer is almost triple the actual salary. And there are many overseas opportunities for judges to supplement their incomes from taking a variety of assignments overseas – things like speaking engagements etc. At least, these opportunities did once exist for Barbados’ judges, but they have so debased the coinage of their office, that these opportunities, like our off-shore sector, are drying up. After all, what law school wants to put some idiot who cannot give a decision and apparently has no knowledge (like RR) of the principals of Magna Carta to talk to groups of students? Or to sit on commissions?

    You say that you think that the drafters of the new CPRs made a mistake when they did not include automatic referral to mediation. Well, you may be right, but I DISAGREE. I agree that all family law matters should first be referred to mediation by the CPRs – on that I am certainly willing to agree 100% with you. But that ALL cases should be referred to mediation is, to my mind, merely adding an additional expense to the litigant who has to pay for this mediation, before then turning around and paying for the whole judicial process. I will agree that judges should examine all non-family law cases and come to a determination with counsel on each side on the likelihood of a settlement being achieved through mediation. BUT, if you give judges the automatic right to determine whether cases ought to be referred to mediation or not, then you are providing them with just another means of delay. Also, as you well know, mediations are carried out without prejudice. Therefore any evidence arising during the course of a mediation is inadmissible in a court of law, should the mediation fail. Then there are the costs of mediation, which are not inconsiderable, and are generally borne 50/50.

    So yes, I really do strongly agree with automatic referral to mediation in family law matters. But it cannot be automatic for all civil matters. ADR is an alternative, not a universal panacea. It is alternative to the courts, not in place of the courts. Finally on that point, I ask you to cast your eye over CCJ Appeal No CV 7 of 2010 between DELYS O’LEEN COLBY DEC’D BY D.V.B. COLBY, EXECUTOR APPELLANT and FELIX ENTERPRISES LTD and FELIX BROOME INCORPORATED RESPONDENTS [2011] CCJ 10 (AJ). I believe it was yourself who drew this to my attention here on BU last year. I was away from the Island at the time. As the CCJ presents the case and if you had been the judge at first instance, would you not have considered that this case ought to go to ADR? I know if I had been the judge I would have called counsel into chambers and strongly urged them to take the matter to ADR and some support for my position at the time would have been welcome. BUT, at the end of the day, in a case like this, they HAVE to have the right to refuse ADR. Even if by pursuing the matter in court it will end up being a Pyrrhic victory for one side and a disasterous loss for the other side.

    On another point, although I am aware that there are dispute resolution centres in other countries that are staffed and funded through the courts (as in Canada) may I point out that these are used for FAMILY law matters. In areas of law like corporate litigation, private mediators are used – and the costs are borne equally by the parties, including the cost of the mediator. Also, the findings of the mediator, should one side not agree with the results, are NOT admissible as evidence once the matter goes back to court. It is a privileged proceeding and the judge cannot be informed of or take into account the findings of the mediator.

    In sum, therefore, while agreeing with you that a lack of resources has contributed to the backlog, it has only done so to a very small percentage. The main problem lies with the fact that judges are simply not doing their jobs, either through sloth or incompetence and that 90% of the blame for this MUST fall on the boss who, having the means to remove unsatisfactory judges, has failed signally to use those means.

    @Hants. Criminal law is not my area of expertise. I agree with you that the periods of remand are shameful. However, once a criminal matter is referred to the High Court (Criminal Division) there is no waiting for years for a decision on a hearing. It is a matter for a jury. Guilty or not guilty. Then it is up to the judge to pronounce sentence. The problem, as I see it, lies with the timely scheduling of cases for trial. And that is the job of the Registrar and the buck stops with HER! The solution is simple. Apply Bushie’s excellent suggestions.Fire her!

    @Blogger2012. If you don’t think it is too late in life, get thee to law school. I thought that you were a lawyer.


  23. I said “The Justice System is supposed to be independent legislative body.” That should read, “The Justice System is supposed to be independent of the legislative body.”

  24. Just being objective Avatar
    Just being objective

    @ David
    ” If an Owen Arthur led government were to win the next election there is no way that MG would be allowed to outshine DS .”
    David if you wish to seek perfect corroboration of that view , get that ADVOCATE SUPPLEMENT and read it ; THERE IS NO WAY DS WOULD ALLOW MS TO DO ANYTHING THAT MIGHT APPEAR TO OUTSHINE HIM .That supplement clearly demonstrates that he has devoted his life to creating the impression that there has never been a better , brighter , more competent , better equipped person in the field of law than he . Do yourself the favour and get that ADVOCATE SUPPLEMENT OF SUNDAY DECEMBER 9 ,2001 AND READ IT .

  25. Just being objective Avatar
    Just being objective

    @ David .
    The intimate details of his ENTIRE LIFE could only have been made known by Simmons himself so there is no doubt that he prepared the Supplement .
    TALK ABOUT SELF SERVING !! READ IT .


  26. everytime one looks around one sees the mass blunders left in the wake by the OSA administration and then we have people like Bush TEA coming up with these cockie manie plans on how CJ marston ought to fix them in 6mths,all them backlogs is a disgrace to the judicial system and whoever was in charge either was asleep on the job or did not know what they were doing. bushie you must be dreaming to think that 14 years of neglect can be fixed in 6mths or even a year!


  27. @Just being objective

    Sounds like it would be a good read. Maybe if Bryan is reading the blog he can email it to us.


  28. IF the Nation newspaper were to have printed what has been perpetrated here as FACT we would have convulsed and the tsunami would have engulfed the island. Look what happened when they published FACT – the tremors from the famous dildo are still with us. Witness Amused’s belated discovery of the word ‘balls’. Well, it’s his post so it’s understandable I suppose


  29. Some of us have big, educated balls and some of us have small, uneducated balls.


  30. @ Amused

    And some of us have both big educated balls and education.

    BUT I do want to congratulate you most sincerely. Today you acknowledged you don’t know much Criminal Law. Three days ago that would not have been possible. and so whatever else we have achieved here we have seen your first growth to reality about yourself. Who knows – by the end we may even find integrity…and that would be nice. Well done!


  31. I said that “Criminal law is not my area of expertise.” I never said that I “……don’t know much Criminal Law.” Anyway, enough of this. I am BIG and EDUCATED and I have never understood why some men who by their own admission are small and uneducated choose to take on (or perpetuate) the characteristics of those pre-adolescents who suffer from an inferiority complex.

  32. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @Amused: “It IS easy to fix. Just follow Bushie’s recipe. Fire a few people. But as Bushie says, this requires balls…

    But it also requires empirical data on performance, to avoid “wrongfulness dismissal” claims.

    Hopefully this new building we’ve all paid for, with computers everywhere, is able to collect such simple data….?


  33. @Chris. I agree with you. How not? And this data, with the new building and the computers, ought to be very simple to compile. I have no doubt that you could design a programme for just that in very short order. But between providing the hardware and the software and actually getting the staff to utilise both…….. So, orders have to be given and reasonable deadlines set. I believe that this can be done at the rate of 30 files per day per person x 10 people. About 12 working days. Now, you might argue that this is too much, so make it 20 files per person per day x 10 people. 17.5 days. At an 8 hour day, this works out at half an hour per file. Even if there are slowdowns for whatever reason (sickness, improperly sorted files etc.) 60 days is more than enough to do the whole job. Now, Chris, I may be wrong, but surely a programme like Excel could then tabulate and sort the data in less than an hour once it has all be input. I defer to your expert opinion, of course. But if I am right, then Bushie’s solution is not at all unobtainable. In fact, it might even be worth the expense of bringing in a private sector firm to do the job, then it is sure the job will be done on time.

  34. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @Amused: “But if I am right, then Bushie’s solution is not at all unobtainable. In fact, it might even be worth the expense of bringing in a private sector firm to do the job, then it is sure the job will be done on time.

    It’s called a “dash board”. And it is trivial to implement.

    I would be happy to provide my expertise, “pro bono”, to help Barbados.

    Please let me provide a link to page for one of my hobby sites, where geeks try to find factors for Mersenne primes: http://www.gpu72.com/reports/overall/graph/month/

    Wouldn’t it be cool if the CJ could see, in real time, what his charges were doing?


  35. Yet again the issue of competency of the judiciary in the CLICO matter has come up. Could it be that our judges are not sufficiently competent to discharge this matter in a timely manner given that CLICO is under judicial management?

  36. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @Amused: “In fact, it might even be worth the expense of bringing in a private sector firm to do the job, then it is sure the job will be done on time.

    Sorry… You’re a lawyer. Must read your language carefully.

    Why do you assume that a private sector firm will do the job on time?

    Separate question: do you also assume that the job be done on budget?

    Time. Cost. Quality. Choose two.


  37. @Chris. In referring to the Private Sector, I was referring to you. I have every confidence that you could do the job properly, but don’t suggest you do it pro bono.

  38. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @Amused: “I have every confidence that you could do the job properly, but don’t suggest you do it pro bono.

    And I thank you for that.

    My point was, this can be done easily. And there are many “returning experts” who would do this for very little money, or even for free. Or, if you need to pay someone, pay some small consulting fees to those who have Barbados’ interests’ at heart.

    We don’t need to contract out to an “away” firm to implement something which is easy to do (and yet we seem to; constantly)….


  39. @Chris. I remember you attending a Light and Power hearing with ROK. I would say that, from that alone, you have Barbados’ interests very much at heart. I suspect that ROK would join me in saying that you are one of us, whether you were born here or not.

  40. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @Amused: “I remember you attending a Light and Power hearing with ROK.

    Yeah. For three weeks. Along with Douglas Skeet. And several others.

    Read 1200 pages of background.

    It was all for not; the Company ended up getting almost everything they asked for. As adjudicated by the FTC. And then they sold themselves off to “away” interests…

    But we’re here now…

    And, interestingly, we’re no further along….

  41. Just being objective Avatar
    Just being objective

    @ David.
    I am sure that Caswell Franklyn would keep a copy of that Advocate Supplement and should be only too willing to make it available to you . But you must not forget that it is THIRTY ONE PAGES long and would present obvious difficulties to reproduce it for the benefit of BU readers . But please, get it and read it . And having read it please let BU readers know whether or not you agree with my assessment of it .

  42. Just being objective Avatar
    Just being objective

    @ David
    I wonder if people like OBSERVER , AMUSED , BLOGGER , BUSHIE and ONIONS have read it . If any one of our readers has read it please make sure that robert ross gets a chance to read that supplement .

  43. The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall Avatar
    The entity who used to be known as Chris Halsall

    @Jbo: “If any one of our readers has read it please make sure that robert ross gets a chance to read that supplement .

    We sometimes get lost in games.

    What supplement is so important to read?

  44. Just being objective Avatar
    Just being objective

    @ Chris Halsall
    You must have been asleep ..LOL..I refer you to the post at May 1 at 10 : 55 a.m. on the 31 page supplement published by the BARBADOS ADVOCATE of Sunday , December 9 ,2001 and entitled ” TRIBUTE TO SIR DAVID ” . Happy reading.


  45. @ David

    As you know, from the outset I have worried about the substance of this post. The root of the concern and, indeed, the root of the post is the allegation – from a “credilbe source” – that CCJ judges expressed “displeasure and dismay” to our judges, at a meeting with them, at the “state of the Barbados Courts”. From this premise – a hook onto which to hang something more – there followed the standard vitriol about Sir DS in the context of delay. You yourself added that anyone who looked at the CCJ website would find similar criticism – as if to say that the CCJ is prone to utter ex cathedra condemnations of us freely and for all to see.

    I said of all this that I did “not trust it’. Of course, I know that criticism has been levelled at our courts in individual cases which have come before the CCJ and rightly so. But that criticism, in terms of the website, has to be researched thoroughly by examining the reports in individual cases on the site. Moreover, it seemed incredible to me that the CCJ judges would have insulted us so dramatically in the way the post suggested. This is so at variance with understood diplomatic norms, and the ordinary rules of hospitality, as to beggar belief. It is also at variance with all the kind words which the President of the Court had to say about us.

    Accordingly, I did a little research of my own at, for present purposes, the fount of all wisdom.- and this is what I discovered though some of it I already knew:-

    1. THERE NEVER WAS ANY MEETING WITH THE JUDGES.

    2. THERE WAS A RECEPTION ON THE MONDAY AFTERNOON WITH SPEECHES AND COCKTAILS AT WHICH JUDGES, LAWYERS AND OTHERS WERE PRESENT.

    3. THERE WAS A MEETING WITH SOME MORE SENIOR MEMBERS OF THE BAR ASSOCIATION AT WHICH THE CCJ INDICATED THAT LATER IN THE YEAR IT WAS PREPARED TO WORK WITH THE BAR TO DISCUSS STRATEGIES WHICH THE BAR MIGHT EMPLOY TO UNDERSTAND BETTER THE CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES AND SO CONTRIBUTE TO REDUCING DELAY.- A COMMON FEATURE IN OTHER JURISDICTIONS – MORE AGGRESSIVELY.

    So David, it seems that I was right to say ‘I don’t trust it’. THE POST WAS PREDICATED, IT SEEMS, ON A LIE. This does not altogether surprise me. But it is very sad indeed that the BU family should have been duped like children in this way to satisfy someone’s personal agenda.


  46. @robert

    BU will stay with our source which has delivered in the past.

    Of course you are welcome to go with yours.


  47. @ RR
    Quote”
    BU has received information from a credible source that the CCJ justices met with Barbados’ judges and expressed to them their displeasure and dismay at the state of the Barbados courts.
    ****************
    …so your research was able to distill EVERY conversation between the the CCJ Justices and the Barbados Judges? and to determine that no such mention was made…?
    Can’t you see that this statement is merely incidental to the actual issue?

    You must REALLY think that we are a bunch of idiots that we would need to rely on the pronouncements of the CCJ to know of the problems in our courts…..
    Only DS and about two other persons would be expected to question the likelihood of the CCJ judges raising the matter of the state of our courts in a historic meeting in Barbados….. what the hell else would you expect them to talk about? religion?

    ….you have now gone past grasping at straws…. you are now getting into other floating stuff that tends to accompany drowning men… especially when they are scared and confused….


  48. @ Bush Tea

    ‘Scared’ – ME? LOL.

    You know, so many seem to respect you. I’m trying to work out why.


  49. @ David

    Yes David – mine was the best possible so I will.


  50. @RR
    Not “Scared..”. .. May be it is just “confused” then 🙂

    “Many respect Bushie..”. LOLOL.
    LIKE WHO?
    Onions?
    Islandgal?
    ac?
    Or
    …Caswell – who won’t even fart on Bushie’s job offer

    Man RR again you are wrong on a basic issue…. Take a break do…

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending