Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Caswell Franklyn, Head of Unity Workers Union

In 1998, a panel of Law Lords took the unprecedented decision to set aside a ruling of a differently constituted panel of judges of the House of Lords because of the appearance of bias, in an appeal brought by Senator Pinochet, former president of Chile.

The Government of Spain was seeking Pinochet’s extradition from the United Kingdom to face trial for acts that he was alleged to have committed when he was head of state of Chile. He pleaded that he had immunity from prosecution because of his status of head of state when the acts were alleged to have taken place, and that was upheld by the lower courts. To make a long story short, the lower courts’ decision was overturned paving the way for the continuation of extradition proceedings.

Subsequent to the first appeal it was discovered that the wife of one of the panel of Law Lords, Lord Hoffman, was employed by Amnesty International who sought and was granted permission to be an intervener in the Appeal. Lord Hoffman was not a member of Amnesty International, but he had raised funds to assist them to acquire a building.

The second panel accepted that there was a real danger or reasonable apprehension of suspicion that Lord Hoffmann might have been biased. There was no allegation of actual bias, but the panel ruled that the appearance of bias was enough to cause them to set aside the ruling in the first hearing before the Lords.

Just recently, in Trinidad, that country’s Chief Justice was embarrassed into returning the instrument constituting him a senior counsel, what we call queen’s  counsel in Barbados, because it was bestowed by the Government. It was submitted that such acceptance would conflict with the doctrine of the separation of powers, and also there would be some appearance of bias if the Chief Justice were to adjudicate a case involving the Government.

Based on the two examples that I cited above, imagine my surprise when the Chief Justice of Barbados could be seen on the front page of a newspaper receiving honorary membership of the Rotary Club. My head immediately started to work overtime: should I join Rotary in case I am ever at the receiving end of a law suit; or what would happen if I had to go up against one of his Rotarian brothers in court.

Ever so often, we hear unfounded allegations that some of our judicial officers being lodge members cited as the reason why certain cases are decided in a particular way. It does not matter how unfounded these claims happen to be: they would tend to reduce confidence that the populace should repose in the judiciary. I am not saying that the Chief Justice would be biased but I would sleep a whole lot better if he had declined the invitation.

I do not know if it only me clutching at straws or is it that the Chief Justice has exercised extremely poor judgement in accepting honorary membership of Rotary. In my opinion, he should be required to return one of his instruments of appointment: it should either be Rotary or Chief Justice, not both.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

137 responses to “Rotarian Chief Justice! What Was He Thinking?”


  1. FYI…the correct terms are “senior counsel” and “queen’s counsel”, not “senior council” and “queen’s council”. A council is a group of people assembled to deliberate, discuss, etc. A counsel is a person who gives advice on legal matters.

  2. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    Thank you for the correction.


  3. Thanks Paul, made the changes.

    usually Caswell is tight on his presentations 🙂


  4. No problem, gents.

    I agree with the gist of the submission, by the way. I think that the CJ should not expose himself to circumstances of potential moral hazard like this (or even to the appearance of such). He should be like Ceasar’s wife, and be as much free from suspicion of a crime as free from the crime itself. 🙂


  5. To be honest there is reservation on this side as well.

    The Rotary’s philanthropic work notwithstanding it is comprised of the most prominent and high net-worth individuals in Barbado; the people who pull the strings.

    While no one is casting aspersions on his character why place himself in a position when there is a higher probability of recusals on his part as a result of his membership in Roatry?


  6. Perception, perception, perception,perception,perception!


  7. I too agree with the essence of the submission. However, the Chief Justice is just doing what the ‘big boys in Bim’ are expected to do. Such memberships, whether secretive or otherwise, underpin reasons why justice and progress are stymied here in Bim. So don’t be surprised when disputes at schools seem impossible to resolve.


  8. This has been canvassed on BFP. The present case is FAR removed from the two examples you cite. The Trinidad example is ludicrous anyway. How can a Chief Justice be honoured as a senior advocate.? It makes no legal sense…but I suppose the urge for a title in some is insatiable. So far as THIS case is concerned, the CJ or anyone else in public life can hardly be expected to live in a bunker ‘Underground’. The church, the golf club, the parent-teacher association and many more may well make their claims on a man’s LIFE but not thereby his public duty. It is not as if the CJ has secretly

    become a freemason. Then perhaps there would be something to write about. But becoming associated with a charitable organisation openly and frankly is rather to be praised, isn’t it, rather than condemned or made the subject of rather wild speculation? And if a man is amenable to pressures from associates this will happen whether or no he identifies himself with ‘charity’? As for perceptions, well they have some weight but yet may be rooted in bigotry, ignorance and superstition.The earth was flat once wasn’t it?


  9. I notice on the front page of the Advocate that there is a picture of the Minister of Education deep in thought.

    However, it is not the anguished expression on his face which catches my eye but the ring on his finger!!

    http://www.barbadosadvocate.com/todayspaper/default.asp


  10. Since this submission was underpinned by examples from England. It is wise to get the FACTS.
    : Dated 5 November 2009

    “For the last 11 years, anyone applying to be a judge or magistrate for the first time had to declare on an application form whether they belong to the Freemasonary.
    But Jack Straw, the justice secretary, said that as a review had shown no evidence of impropriety or malpractice as a result of a judge being a Freemason it would be “disproportionate”, to continue with the practice introduced in 1998.”

    “This followed two cases at the European Court of human rights where Italian Freemasons successfully argued it was discriminatory to be asked to declare membership of a non-secret society.”
    Guardian , London

    There you have it the Fact is Judges and Magistrates in England can be Freemasons and do not have to declare they are.

    Well done Chief Justice you were open: That shows “Integrity”.


  11. Caswell , I can assure you that if you are a GOOD FREEMASON you would automatically be a GOOD MAN. Too many persons pontificate about freemasonry without knowing anything about it. Freemasonry can make a good person BETTER.
    I can really see no problem with ANYBODY associating himself with any institution which has as its aim or objective a commitment to improving the life of his fellowman.
    PLLEASE STOP THE NITPICKING.


  12. @Yardbroom

    “Well done Chief Justice you were open: That shows “Integrity”.

    Is the foundation of your position based on the fact the induction of the CJ was open?

  13. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    I would suggest that you read the ruling in the Pinochet case. I am not talking about freemasons or any other sect. The House of Lords overturned the first ruling because of the appearance of bias. There was no allegation of actual bias. Lord Hoffmann was not a member of Amnesty International: his wife worked for them, and he assisted them with fund raising, but that was enough to disqualify him.


  14. @ David
    January 19, 2012 ,12:32pm

    He could have been a “full member” if he so wished and no one would have known.
    —————————————–
    In the submission: Quote ” Based on the two examples that I cited above, imagine my surprise when the Chief Justice of Barbados could be seen on the front page of a newspaper receiving honorary membership of the Rotary Club.
    My head immediately started to work overtime: should I join Rotary in case I am ever at the receiving end of a law suit, or what would happen if I had to go up against one of his Rotarian brothers in court.”
    ——————————————

    It was “implied” there was a possibility of bias on the basis of what you saw in the picture.

    Another view.
    (1) In Barbados as in England – from which you quoted – Freemasonary is legal.
    (2) He was not a member as was thought by some on BU before he was appointed.
    (3) He has chosen “HONORARY Membership” and he has allowed it to be known.
    (4) In England Judges and Magistrates can be free masons and they do not have to declare that to the general public.
    (5) It is a question of “integrity”, for some people the Chief Justice can never do right in their eyes. I have no axe to grind, I am for honesty, fairness and integrity.
    Judges in England can be and some are Free Masons and you would never know when you enter court and that is FACT.


  15. Caswell is right!
    Rather than get on with the challenge of REFORMING the broken justice system, the CJ has been spending his time winning friends and influencing people.
    Every cock fight, speech day, church do, parade etc -he at….!! and not a word about plans for reform…

    At this rate he will have too many biases within the flawed system to be any more effective than Justice Moore or any other local Judge would have been.


  16. @Yardbroom

    Would you feel comfortable with trade unionists e.g. Sir Roy et al becoming members of the Rotary?

    The Rotary in Barbados is comprised in the main of the Captain of Industry.

    It is reasonable to assume that the CJ’s membership in such an organisation can be perceived as a conflict?


  17. @ David
    The fact is there are people who were against the Chief Justice when his name was “first mentioned” for the appointment and now they continue in that vein.

    On this issue it does not matter if a man is a free Mason or not it is the “integrity” of the man.
    This is Barbados, a place of favours, nepotism, familial, college, school and class loyalties and one man unless he is Jesus Christ will not change the structure that society. We expect miracles and we appoint men.

    We expect one man to come riding over the hill out of the sunset and change the structure of a society. It is not going to happen like that however, over time people can make a difference.

    A Chief Justice cannot be a hermit he will have a social life, with people he can relate to in many areas. He will not be on the block but a man of integrity will always be that.

    In England being a Freemason on its own is not enough to prevent you from sitting on a case, unless the case was in some way related to Freemasonary, as is the situation with all other matters where a conflict of interest would arise.

    That is FACT not opinion.


  18. @Yardbroom

    Thanks for your perspective but you should note that one does not have to join the Rotary to become part of the social scene in Barbados.

    What is being queried about the CJ is no different to Bush Tea not being permitted to hold certain directorships which maybe perceived as conflicting in his current job.

    It does not mean BT is not a man of integrity but the rule is there to send the right message and give the right appearance of propriety.

  19. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Yardbroom

    You are setting up a straw man just to knock him down. I never said anything about Freemasons in my post. I dealt with the APPEARANCE OF BIAS; NOT EVEN ACTUAL BIAS. If you are honest, you would acknowledge that there is always talk about people in society who exert undue influence on the judiciary. All I am saying is that the Chief Justice should do everything to avoid that allegation being made about him. Accepting the honorary membership of Rotary does nothing to assure the public that it would not be business as usual when it comes to the administration of justice. All the law requires is that there is an appearance of bias, not actual bias. He has set himself up for that allegation to be made against him, That’s all I am saying. Please Yardbroom just understand that.


  20. Note to Minister Ronald Jones, you have on your ring upside down, if you are a freemason, please wear our ring with honour and with dignity. That is a mistake only a new initiate would make, it has a meaning don’t forget that. Don’t just pose with it.

  21. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Undertaker
    I understand that if you see a ship flying its flag upside down that is to signal that the ship is in distress and needs help. Maybe, Jones is wearing his ring upside down to signal that he is in distress and needs help.So please help him: he is out to sea on a dark stormy night, no sight of land with a broken compass.


  22. @ David
    The right message of the Chief Justice will be sent by his “actions” in Court and the judgements he makes and the reasons he gives for those judgements over time.

    We have a lot of talk in Barbados in public of what I will do. But the truth is in private people do the contrary. That is why despite all the talk the “majority” of the population have almost no control over what determines the “real” issues in our society.

    He could have gone the Barbados way, kept quiet about it and then there would have been no fuss.

    The poster gave the impression erroneously the Chief Justice did something which because of Law could not be done in England.

    THAT WAS WRONG IN FACT AND LAW.

    He could have stated an opinion without the recourse of trying to prove something in Law to mislead.

    I have no wish to refer to personal situations which can be different as they do not sit squarely with th “Oath” a Chief Justice takes.


  23. I am ashame of Caswell. The Constitution of Barbados allows fo freedom of association. Doesn’t it? Just like i am free to join your union if I so desire.

    @David

    I am not an English student, but some mistakes are made too often. Comprise is not followed by of.


  24. @Caswell

    I was reading the Constitution or Barbados and it allows freedom of assocation, just like your union members can associate with your union.


  25. @blogger

    Make your points, comments are not crafted with the rigour of blogs.

    Please let us not wander off into the tangential and inconsequential.


  26. This is Barbados.Everybody know or family to somebody.

    The CJ went to High school in Barbados at the same time as a lot of senior lawyers,captains of industry and a whole lot of educated successful Bajans.

    Barbados is too small to create the disconnect that some of you want to see.

    Give the CJ a chance to prove his worth.

    He is a Bajan.


  27. @Hants

    Then many who agree with you cannot use the ‘cooling off ‘argument in the case of Sir David Simmons.


  28. BTW Hants, there is nothing wrong with letting our CJ know we will hold him to a very high standard.

    Bear in mind BU and others like you championed his appointment


  29. @David

    am i not entilted to make any point i feel like, as long as i dont direspect bloogers?


  30. @Blogger2012

    Yes.


  31. New CJ? … courts still operate the same way.

    To me the CJ is about all show every week he in the paper at some social event. Like he living his retirement age/time on the public purse.

    What issues regarding the Judiciary have he address since he took office? The Courts are to slow. However I have this fear that Justice will be dealt with elsewhere.


  32. David the CJ is more removed from Barbadian society than Simmons was.

    I am confident that the CJ will do his job with pride and integrity.

    And yes. you have every right to hold him to the highest standards.


  33. very good arguments and counterarguments between Caswell and Yardbroom. On the subject of “Appearance and Bias” i do sense a tinge of bias directed towards the CJ from Caswell. Even though his arguments are sound it makes one wonder if his arguments are genuine or if they are purely personnel.
    Yardbroom arguments are equally pertinent although it does not really address the Argument via conflict of interest. Giving the political “friendsof friends” Barbados is experiencing i do agree with Caswell and furthermore for the CJ accepting such an award “at this time” does show poor judgement. Their is a thin line between “Integrity and impartiality” and it can become a deicate balancing act to walk one one that many politicians wish they had never crossed.


  34. Had a quick read scan of The Judical ethics Forum and in particular p.37 of the The ABS Model Code of Judicial Ethics. Of course this applys to a different set up but judicvial officers are encouraged “to engage in educational, religious, charitable, fraternal or civic extrajudicial activities not conducted for profit, even when the activities do not involve the law. See Rule 3.7.”


  35. In the present Alexandra situation under what circumstances could Lodge membership make it necessary for the various players to be asked to declare their association?

    Please note, I agree with freedom of association, but in the case of Members of the various unions involved we know who is who and of course they are free to associate …. as are Freemasons.

    What we don’t know is which player is a Freemason …. and which is is not.

    Should we?


  36. @ Caswell
    as for “What was He Thinking” I presume he was not being selfish in lending his name to the Rotarey club. For that was a noble gesture on his part which for all intended purpose can pay dividends by increase of its membership, Afterall who wouldn’t want to be part of an organisation that the CJ is a member i think the overall benefits outweighed the hyperbole which you have espoused to misquote Jones “He ain’t anybody” i am certain that the CJ is no stranger to seeing the many pitfalls some among his colleagues have been lured into. by all accounts judging from what i have heard of him. He is no FOOL!
    BTW i think it is time for you to recuse yourself of any further discussion on the CJ as we all know you have made several attempts previously to discredit him .


  37. I didn’t know that when one accepted the position of CJ it meant that one had to become a hermit holed up in an Office never to interact with their fellow man.Caswell is scrutinizing every move the CJ makes one can say he is on to him like white on rice, some others like Bush Tea chime in that they haven’t seen any reforms yet but he is at every “cock fight”.

    How can an honorary membership in an organization like the Rotary Club pervert the course of Justice? To reduce the argument to absurdity one could well argue that if the CJ turned up at a Foundation Old Scholars meeting or a meeting of the UWI guild then the members of those organizations would enjoy a free pass if they ever had reason to appear before him in any legal capacity.

    The CJ should realise that if he is quoted weekly in the newspapers or appears frequently on CBC giving speeches promoting what he intends to do it may satisfy those who are thirsty for reforms. We have had our share of those who can talk a great game and never follow through; they are respected because they are thought to be doing something, while others who may be working diligently are hardly ever given the time of day.

    If the CJ is seen at events it doesn’t mean that he isn’t doing other things e.g. working to reform the system, performing one task doesn’t preclude doing others, the man can walk and chew gum at the same time. The job of legal reform isn’t the CJ’s alone; it will take many hands on the plow to effect change.


  38. @Casewell. You are capable of getting it so wrong. Rotary is not a political, but a charitable and non-contentious organisation. Amnesty is both contentious and highly political. Rotary does not seek to change the laws of any land, Amnesty does. Rotary does not seek to exert pressure on courts of law, Amnesty does. Finally, the ruling on with Lord Hoffman sat in the Pinochet case was not “overturned”, it was vacated. It was right to vacate it. And the Pinochet case has absolutely NOTHING to do with this matter. I see nothing wrong with what the CJ has done. It is transparent and could not possibly create any situation in which he was forced to recuse himself from a case. Casewell, you would be better advised to expend your efforts dealing with the unions involved in the courts so that the CJ could more easily fire a whole load of the incompetents working there. That would be helpful. This latest of yours has your political slip showing.


  39. Think some are being too harsh with Caswell. We all know the circumstances which brought CJ Gibson to the position. We all know the efficiency of the courts is a mess, some have become offended by the publicity hogging extra judicial activities of the CJ especially when they have not seen commensurate activity in his capacity as a CJ.


  40. yard brroom it is unfair to suugest that persons would find fault in the chief justice’s action because they were opposed to his appointment in the first place. the gist of the opposotion to mr gibson’s appointment was the way it was done by the government and not against mr gibson himself. i do not even know mr gibson but i did not feel that the government having made an error in formulating the appointment should have changed the constitution to accomodate their mistake. now mr brathwaihe is quoted in the press as ready to sit down with the commissioner of police and discuus appointments and promotions ; another mistake at the highest levels which suggest that our keeper of the laws is not familiar with the laws he is sworn to uphold.


  41. @David

    we are not hard on caswell, he professes to be the expert on everything. He should chose which battles to fight, just not post for post sake to be full of himself. Sometimes i admire how he defends himself, but sometimes he is to opportunistic.


  42. Hi balance,
    Jan 20, 2012 @ 6:11am

    I do not believe that people should not criticise the Chief Justice – or the circumstances of his appointment – if they so wish; my response was to a specific article which I thought was flawed and the history “here” BU dictated my reply.

    If someone repeatedly attack an individual it is incumbent on them to get their FACTS right that is “fairness”, it also shows respect to your readership.

    I am sure you are aware as I am the responsibilities of a Magistrate or a Chief Justice – as is the case here.

    When he/she finishes speaking and puts down his/her pen after sentence, the person before them can be taken away and imprisoned for years, away from the public, family, and friends some lives stop there with all that entails.

    That is a heavy responsibility, let us concentrate on the real issues and not try to undermine those men/women who carry that responsibility, unless our reasons are sound.


  43. To Amused:
    As a member of the Rotary, a club which is representative of the fore most business people in Barbados, do you not think it would be wise of the CJ to excuse himself if and when one of the Rotarians come before him. Speak to the issue properly man or woman and stop trying to infuse the discussion with attacks on Caswell. I am of the opinion that no Judge or CJ should a member of any association in Barbados, and that definitely is the same position on the Lodges. Too many of them are members of lodges but do not excuse themselves when their Brothers bring people before the courts. Where do you see true justice come from in these circumstances. With people with your thinking we would always remain just below the status of a Banana Republic.


  44. To Yard Broom:
    If Free Masonry was so loved in Britain, why did the Government have to remove its influence in the Police Force. You could not get a promotion unless you were associated. Still in Barbados, when all of the PS and senior civil servants “sit around the bones of the old man” they determine who is next in line. Take at look at the holders of seniors offices since the 1960s in Barbados. And beg your Dems friends to ease the Fire Service from under the thumbs of the Masons.


  45. A most disturbing picture reared its ugly face in the newspaper that being the p icture of the elderly couples home being “bulldozed by the government. this picture does indeed leave and unplatable taste on ones phyche

  46. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    David | January 20, 2012 at 5:58 AM Think some are being too harsh with Caswell. We all know the circumstances which brought CJ Gibson to the position. We all know the efficiency of the courts is a mess, some have become offended by the publicity hogging extra judicial activities of the CJ especially when they have not seen commensurate activity in his capacity as a CJ

    David
    Thanks for your concern, but I am not offended. I express my opinions and I expect them to be challenged. I respect those who are genuinely critical and I learn from them. The others who are abusive will not see me go down to their level. Most of whom are mindless who rely on other people’s opinions to formulate theirs and are only following the crowd.

    I maintain that I have nothing personal against Marston Gibson. I do not know him: I have never encountered him in any sphere of activity. If you follow all that I have written you would see that I opposed the crass method of his appointment. Next I pointed out that he was not qualified in accordance with the law. I did not pass the law : I just pointed out what it was. If that makes me a villain , so be it. Thereafter I made comments to the effect that he was courting celebrity rather than getting on with the job. Lots of people in the legal profession meet me on the streets and agree with me but are afraid to say so. This time I feel that he is setting up himself for his decisions to be challenged on the ground of apparent bias. I do not expect people like Blogger 2012 to understand the distinction that my post was pointing out: they are too consumed with personal dislike for me as though they think that I care. Their abuse is like water thrown on a duck’s back.


  47. Hi lemuel
    @ Jan 20, 2012, at 8:17am

    I did not say Free Masonary was loved in Britain or implied that .
    I cannot recall the original article to which I posted made mention of the Barbados Police and neither did I.
    I am not a “member” of any Political party in Barbados – BLP or DLP – and never have been.
    I do not ask my friends or colleagues which Party they support….that is none of my business.

    If you have a problem with organizations or various societies in Barbados, it is your right to comment on them as you wish and bring to light what you think is wrong with them.

    I made a point on a “specific article” and gave light to FACTS & LAW.
    not opinion.


  48. @Caswell

    Your post has obviously struck a chord with many people. Here is an email received this morning:

    Reading the article ‘Rotarian Chief Justice! What was he thinking” brings tears to my eyes. In my opinion, it is written by someone who cannot accept that the son of the working class of Barbados can hold such a high office . He has been bitter from the day the appointment was made.

    Does he know that the first black Chief Justice was a cousin of Errol Barrow? Does he know that Dame Nita Barrow was the sister of Errol Barrow? Does he know that Sir Hugh Barrow was the cousin of Errol Barrow? Does he know that Dame Nita was the founder member of Jamaica Registered Nurses Association and remained a member till she died? Does he know that Dame Nita was a member of the Barbados Registered Nurses Association? Does he know that Deighton Ward won a seat to the West Indies Federal Government on the Barbados Labour Party ticket?

    Does he know that David Simmons was a minister of Government in the Barbados Labour  Party Government? Why can’t Chief Justice Marson Gibson associate with a non-political group of people?

    We the people of the Bay Land are proud of you ‘C.J Marson’. Feel free to join whatever group of people you are happy among. We envy the congregation of St. Ambrose Church who are looking forward to hear your lovely baritone voice in the choir.

    I will leave this little reminder to Mr.Caswell  Franklyn…. C.J.Marson has more class than Deighton Ward, who was born out of wedlock to a black field worker and a white plantation owner. Go eat your heart out.


  49. To Yard Broom:
    If you really understood the meaning of the word “fact”, you would be very weary to utilize it. And remember Mr. Broom the Law is that which the controllers of any society put on the Law Books. As to my concern about secret societies and groups who seek to control societies, I would writing fro many years to deal with Barbados, only.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending