Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Posted by Ping Pong as a comment to BU blog – National Insurance Board Responds To Public Concern

Stephen Lashley, Minister of Culture

In the last week, newspapers report that the government has made two assaults on the concept of the citizen’s right to property. The first assault was the attempt to pass the Antiquities Bill and the second, the declaration to compulsory acquire the land of one person so as to benefit another citizen.

The situation with the Antiquities Bill is extremely disturbing. The Senate raised many cogent questions about the bill which were accepted by the Government senators. It strikes me odd that Minister Lashley, who is an attorney, could not recognise the constitutional issues raised by Senator Newton and neither could any of the other 29 MP’s (i.e.both BLP and DLP) when the bill was passed in the lower house. That the bill (in identical form) was first presented by the previous BLP administration is testimony to the lack of any philosophical mooring by BOTH political parties to defend and act in accordance with the Constitution or any other publicly stated set of values in the interest of the common good other than expediency, appeal to the lowest denominator and laziness.

To reinforce my disquiet, today’s newspapers report that the Government intends to compulsory acquire part of the property of one individual to make available to another private interest. This is an unsettling use of the State’s power to compulsory acquire property. To my knowledge, such power has been exercised to the direct benefit of the public i.e to allow the building of a school, heath centre, police station, roads, public housing etc. That this power is now to be exercised to the benefit of a privately operated company is a most curious development.

However, laudable the intentions, the words “thin edge of the wedge” comes to mind.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. This smacks right on to dictatorship;which of the government ministers have a share in “B’s” ? You can’t take land from a private citizen to benefit another private citizen, but what makes it worse is they are competitors!!!!!!!!.
    The DLP is behaving like the BLP in their third term in office, they have become VERY ARROGANT. Therefore that scares me for the failed bill just sent back to the lower house, there is no where in that act that can stop the government from walking into my house and taking what they want; THIS IS DICTATORSHIP. We the voting public MUST put a stop to this runaway arrogant attitude this government is developing; it must be nipped in the bud.


  2. First they tricked us by the talk of lowering prices and we voted for them, then prices went through the sky; I’m still awaiting that shipment of fruits and vegies that the Late P>M said was loading when he made his maiden speech at the opening of this parliment. Then the Finance Minister said he would not raise the rate on property taxes, but then we were tricked again, he double the value of the property,hence many people are paying twice as much as they paid before. Now they want to invade your house and remove ALL the antiques our great grand parents left for us This government STINKS>


  3. Why was this bill brought back after being shot down under the last government?

    Could the time of the CPO been better spent drafting the FOIA and Integrity Legislation?


  4. This bill also stated that if you have something over fifty years old you will have to take a photo of it and send it to the museum or whosoever that is in charge. Well I am going to send some photos of myself posing real sweet fuh dem., might even skin muh tail at de camera too. Stupse. This bill is a whole lotta shoite…if dem did really concern bout Antiquities why didn’t they do something with Sam Lords. Dem feel day people gine come running forward to tell dem bout what dem got in their house dat old? Well everyone over fifty should do like me, send dem photos mooning.

    Several years ago, a friend of mine had her house demolished by the authorities claiming that they were taking her land for the sewage project in CH CH. Well she happened to talk to someone who worked for that project and asked why they wanted her land. She was told that was not true that they had looked at plots in that area and decided that they would not be suitable. she then asked for a letter stating that. She was doing some volunteer work for an International agency and while in the basement a box fell. A UN pamphlet fell out, it was about women and minorities around the world whose rights were being violated by Governments. She picked it up and read it. She had the ammunition she needed to fight her case. She made some investigations , she learnt that it was a private individual was behind the acquisition of her land. She got a lawyer and promised that this case would go to the International Court in the Hague if they had to, well they backed off. She now has to rebuild her home on that spot. We are living in very dangerous times. We have to pay attentions to the type of people we elect.


  5. @islandgal

    Do you concede there is a need to protect the history of Barbados?


  6. David the history has been lost a long time ago and whatever is remaining has been left to decay!


  7. When they went begging for Bridgetown to be made a world heritage sites this bill was one of the things they promised they would implement.
    Something is really wrong in Barbados. First they want to give our NIS dollar to private investors now they are using the law to take land from a business man, not to build a school or pavilion, but to give to another business man.
    We were told all sorts of things to get up to vote for this government but EVERYTHING they said they would do they have now turned around and done the opposite. It has gotten to the point now that none believes anything any government minister says. Ask Mr. Burns at Redjet. All the while we have a lame duck Prime Minister who seems not able to control his ministers


  8. We do not need a law like this, what is needed to educate the population about the preservation of our history. To also encourage them to donate / loan to the Museum. Forcibly taking peoples properties / things will only make enemies. Many of our antiquities have long since been exported to all parts of the world. Whatever is remaining , remains here because they are locally owned and treasured by the owners. What this might encourage people to do is not to report anything and go underground to protect their belongings. The Antiques shops here have very few true antiques today , many are replicas and some are downright rubbish passing off as antiques.


  9. When we collect all of the peoples’ jewelery,silver and heirlooms we could always sell it to the Trinis, like we did the nation’s bank which was born out of the Post Office Bank.


  10. Talking about preservation of our history, what has been done to improve Bridgetown,the Garrison and the island in general since we were accorded the status of World Heritage Site, except for a lot of hot air from our politicians,absolutely nothing. I would not go into details, but a walk through Bridgetown and its environs, will give the word SITE a new meaning.


  11. Sec 12, p.12 of the proposed bill seems to be the cause of the out cry.


  12. Sec 12, p.12 of the proposed bill seems to be the cause of the out cry.
    Looks like a page from Stalin’s “dekulakization” programme in the Ukraine and the North Caucuses circa 1929.


  13. This is the result of having a Delinquent Leaderless Party.


  14. Most frightening that the Antiquities Bill made it past the lower house filled with lawyers, who should know better, to be rejected by the Senate, thank gosh at least someone has half a brain.

    What kind of jackass drafted a bill that gives free reign for a government official to enter private premises whitout a justifiable warrant.

    Wunna joking?

    Or yuh think because bog countries get away with ignoring rights y’all could do it too?

    Anyone loooking to my proeprty without my permission is a trespasser and will be dealt with accordingly.

    So, even if passed, only an idiot would take that job. Wunna would learn where barley grow.


  15. Suppositioning I had an antique cricket bat and said official came to my property DEMANDING it?

    He would get it…………and would have to get it extracted by an expert used to dealing in suppositories.


  16. “today’s newspapers report that the Government intends to compulsory acquire part of the property of one individual to make available to another private interest.”

    I feel like running a department store and I feel like having it located right on Broad Street. I’ll ask my MP or my party to compulsorily acquire the ground floor of Cave Shepherd for me so that I can run my competing business right there.

    Or so that I can run a successful supermarket I’ll ask my favourite MP’s to compulsorily acquire for me the new Carlton Supermarket that is being built in Black Rock, and while they are about it acquire the store’s customer list for me as well.

    so that I can run my store without first putting in 30 years of effort and hard work.

    Why work hard when I can get my favourite MP’s to fix up things for me.


  17. I have in my posession at least 4 items (all with provenance) a document (60 years old) a utilitarian/decorative object (more than 100 years old) a piece of furniture more than 100 years old, another more than 60 years old and even though I can see why the government would and should forbid me to export or alter or destroy these items I don’t see why I if I (b) make a false statement to the Director as to the existence, location or discovery of an antiquity, an object that reasonably appears to be an antiquity or relic is guilty of an offence and is liable upon summary conviction I don’t see why in my old age I should be should be subject to to a fine of $100 000 or to imprisonment for a term of 2 years or to both.


  18. If this bill passes I expect to spend the rest of my old age at Dodds.

    And by the way what if my grandmother gave me these objects because she appreciated that in her old age I wiped her behind for a dozen years?

    We know that most MP’s spend no time wiping thier grandmother’s behinds.

  19. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    It’s really sad and a total disappointment that the current political directorate and their bureaucratic minions are the products of free Secondary education and in most cases free University education. If this is the result of EWB’s & Cammie’s gambling experiment may God have mercy on our souls! There is a saying: “Cheap things no good but Free things worst! Is this what the hardworking people- many now dead and gone- gave their sweat, toil and tears to produce? Those cane field workers, servants and maids, lightermen with their “goadies” from lifting 100 lb bags of sugar and committed teachers of yesteryear who made untold sacrifices to educate this bunch of arrogant and pompous band of “fiddlers” dressing up as black minstrels and misleading the people they ought to be serving and helping.


  20. I feel like selling fast food, so I want the government to acquire all 14 brances of Chefette for me. If they do they will never have to worry about finding money to run their election campaigns agian.

    If they fix me up good, I’ll fix them up good too, for life.

    And I don’t care if them is “B” or “D”

  21. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    David

    Thank you for posting a copy of the bill. I have read it and I really can’t believe that our members of parliament could have become so arrogant. No right-thinking person could possibly defend the excesses that the Government proposes to legislate in this Antiquities Bill. This bill sounds like something that would be done under Mugabee not Freundel.
    By the way, “relic” is defined among other things as
    (i) is a botanical or any other organic remain
    (j) is a human remain
    I really don’t know what they are. When a person dies, what’s left are called “REMAINS” LOL

    Front page of the Weekend Nation screams, “LAND ROW Businessman to fight Government’s acquisition” and as if to say a picture is worth a thousand words they juxtapose a picture of Col. Muammar Gaddafi. I would have expected this type of behaviour from Gaddafi not from an elected government of Barbados.


  22. World Heritage Site

    Gave the Ministry of Culture something to brag about, actually kept them busy for a while. Now what are they up to? Why are they receiving salaries again?


  23. “Where the Director receives information or believes that an antiquity or relic exists and that the antiquity or relic is being kept or has been discovered on any private premises” This Cummings woman now got real power …

    So how she gun approach all dees relics in Parliament and on BU (like Random)


  24. What is puzzling is why the government would try to push this bill through the House with little changes reported having been done to it.

    The other point of note is that it was the Senate and not the Lower House where the bill was stuffed. Some on BU have expressed concern at the size of the frontbench which makes groupthink that much easier.


  25. The winds of change are upon us from sea to shining sea . Power Corrupts! Absolute Power corrupts Absolutely. So get from behind your monitors get in touch with your rep. Scream in their faces . Take a page out of OWS. Stop cowering down. forget all the Talk! and intelligent get down and dirty in front of the Pariliament building after all your propety is under seize by YOUR GOVERNMENT. The one who promised to SERVE and PROTECT. We can become the oversight committe.


  26. CANT you people see that this Government is doing some very questionable things that seem to defy commonsense and that seem to question whether the Government wants to be relected?
    CAN such actions as this Bill, the unnecessary pressure on pensioners with reference to the change in the drug formulary/pensions cheques to the bank and now the VAT on complimentary tickets along with all the other draconian measures introduced since 2008 and the poor handling of economic matters generally WIN this Government the next election ??????????????????

    JUST ASKING
    JUST ASKING
    WHAT DO YOU THINK ???

    JUST ASKING
    WHY dont Freeduel Stuart call elections like how Jamaica’s new prime Minister is calling election????
    WHY doesnt he hand over to Sinckler who would become Prime Minister and then call elections like in Jamaica??????

    JUST ASKING


  27. @ac

    The bill is stalled again this time under the administration which followed. In there is some learning for the people on the quality of governance.

    It should be interesting to listen to the VoB program on Sunday morning to a well put together panel – Minister Lashely, Dr. Henry Fraser et al.


  28. In May of this year Minister Sinckler – Finance and Minister Lashley – Housing visited B’s to “give their support”. Now we know why two MP’s neither with responsibility for the environment were there.

    After the cameras left and behind closed doors the “deal” for the expansion of B’s was done. The meeting went something like this:
    Bynoe – I see some land up the road I like.
    Sinckler – That is why I brought along Lashley, as you know the Government brek, but Lashley tells me he can use the Land Acquisition Act to take the land.

    Sinckler – remember if this gets out blame Thompson. Everybody loved him and since he’s dead he won’t be able to defend himself.


  29. Why would the present administration try to pass a bill like this one ? Dem feel Bajuns foolish? That is political suicide ! It is either dem reel stupid or dem ent know dem fronts from dem backs. Stupse…… This bunch is a dangerous bunch of people who are willing to legalize thiefing. Bajans pull wunna breeches up and start sharpening wunna blackleads. Mek sure wunna reddy tah cast wunna ballots. ONE TERM AND DAT IS ALL !

    AC I agree we got to get in front of parliament and tell dem how we feel. This Government has really lost their way.


  30. Excuse me. the Gov’ment never professed to having a way …


  31. As I understand it, right now if you discovered arawak remains, or say slave artifacts on a construction site, there is nothing preventing you from taking them home, keeping them or even selling them to someone outside of barbados. As far as I understand a person doing this would not be doing anything illegal, and no one really has the authority to investigate or do anything as there is apparently no legislation.

    I am told that this bill is not fundamentally different from that passed in Jamaica and a number of other countries.

    It is certainly legitimate to debate the details of any bill and seek to protect citizens. But I am not sure I am happy about the above-mentioned state of affairs either.

    Are some of those protesting loudly in possession serious artifacts?


  32. @TE

    It is understood that we need legislation to guard our treasures of historical significance. The national interest must always precede that of the personal.

    In Barbados what we have is a very narrow band of people who stand to be affected.

    The issue is Sec 12, p12, how can this be redrafted to make the role of the Director of the Museum more palatable.


  33. I can live with that discussion, unfortunately thats not really the issue thats out there.


  34. @TE

    Agree and it is why the government should have learned from the debate which took place under its predecessor.

    Isn’t this what good governance is all about?

    One may recall that much of our cricket audio and video recordings can be found in England and not Barbados or the West Indies.

    We need to slam the door shut because history making never stops.


  35. To me a major underlying issue is the reporting style of the main stream media.

    The media seems content to print stories without providing readers any sort of background or reference points. I am used to media stories providing resders with some sort of background to an issue rather than simply reporting the views of particular individuals. So much of our “news” is simply, so and so, said this or that.

    I have given little thought to the issue of antiquities and know little or nothing on the issue. By printing the comments of those opposed to the bill and providing readers with zero background or reference information, the intial and possibly lasting impression of the bill has been shaped around the worst aspects of the bill. Instead of the journalists doing background research on the issue, the persons on the other side of the debate must now come out and do the journalists’ work for them. We have actually allowed the media to place the onus for informing their readers on other parties.

    Obvious questions that could have been researched and included in the article with the various comments would have been whether or not any caricom countries have a similar bill, are there similar powers, how has that been handled, what has the experience been and so on.


  36. @TE

    The government in this case is to be blamed and directly Minister Stephen Lashley whose responsibility this falls under. He would have had an insight into the kind of comment generated when the BLP led the bill and he has repeated, ignorance. Coming to the public after the fact has when negative sentiment has taken root makes the noble objectives of the bill secondary.


  37. To me the media does its thing the way it wants to do it and then blames affected parties for poor PR management. The reporting of this issue hardly smacked of a constructive attempt to highlight issues with a view to improving the bill. It has come across to me as a good story to sell papers and another opportunity to give the government a black eye.

    The antiquities story would likely never have been reported simply as he said, she said in the NY times without any sort of background and context around the comments.


  38. We have little or no idea what context the Minister provided to the bill, the media has not provided it. The thing only became a story when some high profile persons made comments that made good copy.

    I am told that the nation has not even asked the museum for a comment on this issue. If this bill had passed with little opposition, we probably would have heard very little about it and any positives, whether the ministry had highlighted them or not.


  39. I guess you are right David, in this media environment persons should spend a disproportionate amount of their time on PR,and do the media work. So much for the real work they have to do.


  40. Personally, I find the “call and response” journalism disappointing.


  41. @TE

    Sound bite journalism is here to stay. It mirrors a society which filters almost everything in dollars and cents and the political.


  42. BU David wrote “In Barbados what we have is a very narrow band of people who stand to be affected. ”

    Not so David.

    Almost every Barbadian family will be affected by this legislation. as the legislation defines relics and artifacts as anything over 50 years old, so we are not only talking Arawakian or slave or old plantation relics here.

    David I am just an ordinary, black working class Bajan, but right there in my kitchen cupboard is my mother’s 70+ year old handmade motar and pestle, make by a Speightown mortar and pestle maker. Mortars and pestles are are an important part of our African culinary heritage. They are an important part of our culture and our language. Where do you think the saying “there is more in the mortar than the pestle” comes form. Do you think that a younger generation who has never seen how a mortar and pestle works will understand what that saying really means? I don’t know that anybody is making mortar’s and pestles anymore. I don’t know that since the advent of electricity they are used in Bajan cooking anymore. I certainly don’t use mine. But it is mine. It does not belong to the state. I may want to give it to Little JOhnny when I did. I may not want to give it or sell it to the state. The state did not help my mother to acquire it or to maintain it. Our family has kept it safely for 70+ years. Who is to say that the state will do a better job that my mother and me have done?


  43. And the legislation in intended to reman on the books in perpetuity, so anything yu buy now may in 50 years time become an artifact and can be seized by the government.

    So suppose you buy a carving form the Rastaan in your village, and in the future rich peopl start collecting and exporting ths man’s art, in 50 years time the carving yu bough for $20 may be worth $2,000 or $200,000 and the state will have the right to seize it from your children or grandchildren. And I don’t see anything in the legislation about the state paying a fair cost for the item(s)

    I think that w e fool ourselves if we sit at home abe believe that this egislation only affects the rich white peopl on the plantations. It has the etential to affect al of us.

    For example if yr great grandfather went to Panama and helped to build the Canal and once a month for 10 years he worte home to his parent or girlfriend or wife and those letter were kept by that perosn, those love letters now more that 100 years old may be an important resourse for historians who are researching the Barbados migration to Panama, and the State will have a right to seize then under this legislation


  44. @Random Thoughts

    The debate we are having about this bill reflects our immaturity about the need to preserve our history and heritage. If we don’t have trust in our government who is elected by the people then our focus should be on fixing our system of government instead of displaying selfish tendencies.


  45. David the page is being troubleosme at my end, sliding away from me so that I cannot edit. So sorry for the posting above which clearly I would have edited if I could.


  46. There are many media outfits that their sound bites and much more.

    For example, a certain well known economic commentator continues to make claims about the level of public sector employment since 2008, which a certain newspaper prints, despite public information to the contrary.


  47. In the 1960’s some people who wer said to live on the “base” in St. Lucy came around rural Bajan villages encouraging people to sell their old and old fashioned furniture and to buy new and modern.

    My paternal’s grandmother’s Bajan mahogany 4 poster bed was sold by a cousin that way. The bed may have been almost 100 years old at the time, and would certainly be 100+ years now and is likely sitting in some other people’s museum or stately house far away alledgely a part of someone else’s heritage. The replacement bed of course did not last as long as a snowball in hell.

    Recently Little Johnny made a statement that caused me to see that Little Johnny although very well educated, studied history uo to university and thing, even so Little Johnny does not understand Bajan domestic history. Little Johnny believe that my siblings and I had been raised sleeping on the floor. Little JOhnny did not know until I told mhim that even my grandparents even though rural working class Bajans had good mahogany furniture, maybe because the family for years produced a number f carpenters and joiners, who had access to one of Barbados’ finest mahogany woods. We must not forget David that most of Barbados fine mahogany furniture (and Barbados’s stately homes) were made by the hands of our black craftsmen. So we must not fool ourselves taht we were nothing and nobody.


  48. So we must not fool ourselves or allow othere to fol us that we were/are nothing and nobody and that we own nothing of artistic, cultural or heritage value.

    I gaurantee you that almost ever Bajan family owns something, a letter, a documnent, a lamp, a vase, a mortar and pestle, a chair, a bed, and old fashioned pint pot. a steel yard weighing instrument, that is covered by this legislation. Our grandparents may not have owned pearls (and it scares me that the Minister of Culture so misundertands the situation) but they al owned and cherished and took really good care of almost al of the items that are of value in Barbados’ domestic history. Not pearls, but furniture, joi


  49. Not pearls, but furniture, tradsemen’s tools, juke boxes, chattle houses etc.

  50. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ Trained Economist:
    If the provisions of the Bill are innocuous and Bajans have nothing to fear why did the Senate delayed the passing of the Bill and referred it for review and comment? It was not the Press who attempted to scuttle the legislation nor the opposition since they don’t have the numbers to do so.

    Or are you implying that those appointed sages do NOT know what they are doing?

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending