Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Posted by Ping Pong as a comment to BU blog – National Insurance Board Responds To Public Concern

Stephen Lashley, Minister of Culture

In the last week, newspapers report that the government has made two assaults on the concept of the citizen’s right to property. The first assault was the attempt to pass the Antiquities Bill and the second, the declaration to compulsory acquire the land of one person so as to benefit another citizen.

The situation with the Antiquities Bill is extremely disturbing. The Senate raised many cogent questions about the bill which were accepted by the Government senators. It strikes me odd that Minister Lashley, who is an attorney, could not recognise the constitutional issues raised by Senator Newton and neither could any of the other 29 MP’s (i.e.both BLP and DLP) when the bill was passed in the lower house. That the bill (in identical form) was first presented by the previous BLP administration is testimony to the lack of any philosophical mooring by BOTH political parties to defend and act in accordance with the Constitution or any other publicly stated set of values in the interest of the common good other than expediency, appeal to the lowest denominator and laziness.

To reinforce my disquiet, today’s newspapers report that the Government intends to compulsory acquire part of the property of one individual to make available to another private interest. This is an unsettling use of the State’s power to compulsory acquire property. To my knowledge, such power has been exercised to the direct benefit of the public i.e to allow the building of a school, heath centre, police station, roads, public housing etc. That this power is now to be exercised to the benefit of a privately operated company is a most curious development.

However, laudable the intentions, the words “thin edge of the wedge” comes to mind.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. Quoting BU David “If we don’t have trust in our government who is elected by the people ”

    But David you know as well as I do that the people get the government they deserve, and you know as well as I do that democracy is not a flawless system (and no I don’t know of any better system either) but democracy is not perfect and sometimes we the idiot people elect an idiotic government, and so in general we don’t want to give any government to much legal authority over us just in case a few years after the election we realize that we have made an asinine mistake and need to throw the rescals out. We just don’t want the government encasing us in a piece of legislation from which therre is no escape.

    And David it is folish to trust your government more that we trust ourselves.

    And David this legislation clearly shows that our government does not trust us to tkae care of teh god stuff our grandparents left to us and teh government is saying let us do it for you and my questinis why?


  2. The debate has already been shaped.

    Could the ministry have gotten out in front of this, maybe, but I doubt. Without the negative and salicious angle I doubt the nation for one would have been interested, they hardly reported on what was said as the bill went through the lower house..

    It is typical for the media and persons to take the best or worst aspects of an issue to make the case for or against the issue, thats the way we tend to argue issues in BIM.

    Without someone or some body having powers can we protect artifacts? We can have a debate on what constitutes an artifact?

    Do the provsions of the bill follow acceptable international best practices as those by the BSS? A slightly sophisticated newspaper would have raised issues this like this as aprt of its story?

    Newspaper stories without background and context is the norm, “news” is he said, she said, research is a foreign language for the nation newspaper for sure.


  3. My own research suggests that the powers in this bill are mild compared to those in egypt. But they haev a lot of relics.


  4. Davis I am a person who likes to look around me. Som eyears ago in Austraia and Canada the governments of those countires told the native peoples that they were not good enough to look after thier own children, notwithstanding that the native peoples of Australia had been looking after thier own children for 50,0000 years, and in Canada for more that 20,000 thousand years. Some shite missionaries came along some of them priests and nuns who never gave birth to nor raised a dog flea in their lives, next thing these people who thought they knew better were beating and sexaully abusing and starving the native people’s children’s and depriving the children of thier parents care and lovce.

    So no David I don’t believe that my government ofr the Director of teh Museum can take beter care of my fgrandmothere’ stuff than I can.


  5. @Random Thoughts

    You know nowadays it is all about greed.


  6. Quoting Trained Economist “Without someone or some body having powers can we protect artifacts?”

    Maybe I should call myself educated historian?

    The someone who is currently protecting my family’s artifacts is me. And before me was my parents and grandparents and great grandparents. We don’t need an incompetent government someone. Why do you feel that somebody would be better that us at protecting our own stuff?

    Tell me trained Economist which idiot it was at CBC that destroyed the video tape of Barabdos’ 1966 Indepentendce flag raising ceremony. And don’t tell me that the original tape exists, because I know for certain that it was taped over because some idiot maybe a trained economist made a dscision that it was old and we are short of tapes or money to buy new tapes and we will tape over the only original tape of our Independencr ceremony that existed. The tpae currently used by VBC is a put together hodgepodge when the idiots reaized what they had done.

    And you are telling me to trust a government or a body?

    The same government and same bodies that oare truly incapble of taking care of one of the most important items in Barbados’s recent history.

    Don’t take my word for it. Ask CBC, or ask the MInsiter of Culture?


  7. @TE

    Where have you been living? Do you expect reasonable objective reporting from the typists masquerading as journalists? Some of the provisions in the bill may certainly be debatable (one wonders what the LOO and his two able assistants one a former AG and the other a prominent lawyer were doing).

    The museums of the “important” cities of the world and the private collections of rich individuals are filled with treasures looted from poor nations. Even a European nation (Greece) is still trying to reclaim the Parthenon Marbles taken to London by Lord Elgin in 1812. Recently I read where the US returned a statue to Italy (after it protested) when a private collector tried to sell it at auction for millions of dollars turns out that it was taken from Italy illegally. I think there was a thread on BU which dealt with African artifacts in London which the British Gov’t had refused to return to the country of origin. Fact is all countries try to preserve their heritage, how can Barbados protect its heritage if there are no laws governing such?

    I have longed come to the conclusion that many comments here are not a reflection of sober thought but are a result of political grandstanding. Sometimes one needs to put country first.


  8. Much of Barbados’ domestic history is still in the heads and hands and homes of black working class Bajans. Maybe the trained economists of this world is hoping that we do not know this.

    The history of the big migration to Englind in teh 1950’s is yet to be written.. Who do we think own the hundreds of thousands of letters which were written home?

    Historians have barely scraped teh surface of the Panamanian migration, the time when 40% of Barbados’s young men left. Who do you think owns the Panama documents? Although I saw one with my own eyes at teh Schomburg Museum


  9. Looks like some Government members are about to follow to the the letter this bill. They are trying to take some old relics out of the House………Namely Gline Clarke and Rawle Eastmond and some whispers of Owen.


  10. Sargeant understand that I have no objectin to government’s preventing the destruction of or export of Barbados’ cultural heritage. Government should have passed such legislation on December 1, 1967.

    But I object to the though processes that says that government can take better care of an object than I can, and that consequoently government has the right to permenently deprive me of such object, and that government is under no obligaton to offer me compensation.

    So if government discovered an oil well on my roperty should I move out and let government and the oil companies take posession and should I expect nothing in return?


  11. December 1, 1966. Day after Independence.


  12. David can I call myself Educated Historian, even though I may neither be Educated nor Historian?


  13. Random Thoughts

    I on to you like flies on, well what ever flies like to be on … You really expect foolish people like me to believe that dey had videa tapes back in 1966 …? Now wah kinda idiot you tink I is?


  14. @Sargeant

    Your last comment hits the nail squarely on the head. One wonders who feel most threatened by the legislation, the Professor Frasers and the like? i.e the collectors


  15. In other words the original would have to be pun somet’ing else …no?


  16. Sargeant

    What heritage has Barbados got that could be so important … a couple of clay pots in the ground and mahogany furniture? You don’ think that this whole thing is a “necessary” distraction?


  17. re:defamation=they will only go for sobs who speak their mind eg ^bafp

  18. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    Trained Economist:

    “My own research suggests that the powers in this bill are mild compared to those in egypt. But they haev a lot of relics.”

    What a quantum leap! How can you ever compare this little rock where the original (Amerindian) artifacts and relics have already been destroyed or plundered with Kemet? May Amun Ra forgive you!! A civilisation going back thousands of years and the birthplace (other than Sumeria) of many modern-day cultural, religious and political art forms and mores. Egyptology is a discipline in itself undertaken only by the bright and gifted.
    Trading in Egyptian relics and artefacts- whether legal or illegal- has been a massive business over the centuries, involving billions of dollars and collectors of all kinds from Napoleon to Hitler). You must have heard of Howard Carter and his patron Lord Carnarvon?

    It’s stretching it a bit much to expect Barbados to have ‘draconian” laws and regulations regarding the handling and protection of the few relics that stretch back less than 200 years. Most of the relics that existed in the old great houses have already be looted and exported to countries with more ‘sophisticated taste for antiques, e.g. England. The legislation should be tightened to protect those relics and antiques already on display, e.g. Sunbury House and the other great houses bought from overseas or made by local craftsmen.


  19. egypt has a lot, we should be very protective of the little we have.


  20. @Sargeant

    This maybe the link you referred to in your comment.


  21. I have traced my house back to the 1850’s is that now a relic? De rocks dat de house build wid are relics? So I havta sell it tah de Museum or de Govement?


  22. Gimme $2 million and we can talk !

  23. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ trained economist:
    “egypt has a lot, we should be very protective of the little we have.”

    I am all for the protection of the little relics we have in the Island. But I feel that this care and protection is best left to Old Joe Citizen and family as convincingly pointed out by Random Thoughts in an earlier thread.
    If the government can’t even maintain or forced private citizens to maintain buildings of historical and architectural interest how we expect them to care and look after antiques and relics taken by them. By the way’ antiques require tremendous care and attention if there are to remain” attractive antiques”- no pun intended! Who is going to take care of these relics while they are the subject of a administrative matter or court case?
    More so, the government and its executing agencies can’t even enforce the run-of-the mill or day-to-day laws and regulations. How can we expect them to police and enforce this piece of “sophisticated” legislation the breaking of which would most likely involved more sophisticated professional criminals like the CLICO and similar white collar violations.


  24. @BAFBFP

    What heritage has Barbados got that could be so important … a couple of clay pots in the ground and mahogany furniture?
    ****************************
    Looks like the Gov’t wasted a lot of that “free” education on you.

    The history of Barbados didn’t start when the Portuguese first landed on her shores or when the English followed them, or when the slaves followed. It was settled before and although much of the remnants of the original settlers has been destroyed what should happen if an enterprising Bajan decided to explore some caves ( and he would have to be enterprising cause Bajans aint going into any caves) and discovered some artifacts left by the Caribs or Arawaks? Should he be allowed to sell them to the highest bidder? Or should they be in a National museum where they right fully belong?

    I think you should write Freundel a cheque, in the memo section write
    “ repayment for free education”


  25. Awight awight Sarge,

    So potery found in caves is more valuable than pottery found in the ground… The Arawaks and the Caribs leff their stuff all over the Caribbean so if you don’ find them here yah bound to find them elsewhere.

    I ain’ writing Freundel no cheque. I want Freundel to be a man and stand up against the international monetary system and propose to take Barbados and the rest of the region in an alternative direction. See wah gun happen to him … regime change my brother, and fellas like you calling he a i’grant dictator who deserve wah he get …! (Now who the free education get wasted on Sarge …?)


  26. @islandgal246

    I have traced my house back to the 1850′s is that now a relic? De rocks dat de house build wid are relics?
    *******************
    “Don’t look back something may be gaining on you” (Satchel Paige), you never know what’s around the corner but I live in an area which although incorporated into a larger town some die hard locals still refer to as “The Village”. In my not so infrequent walks I see some houses with plaques noting the year of construction.

    They are designated as Heritage Homes and the owners can’t change some elements of the construction without the approval of the municipality. When you buy one of these homes you buy it with the full understanding that this is the way things are, we live in a “tear down” world so many things are destroyed unnecessarily. I have seen whole buildings being moved by massive trucks replicating the moving of chattel houses in Barbados circa 1960’s because they stood in the way of developments and the Gov’t stipulated that they must be preserved “as is” and relocated at the developer’s expense.


  27. Sarge

    By the way,
    Freundel is a Relic
    Owen is a Relic
    George both a dem is relics
    but Ronald is a DEMON!

    I got the basis for a calypso fah next year …


  28. Hammy want Lashes
    Steven want Lashes
    Michael want Lashes
    but Ronald is a DEMON


  29. What is a necessary distraction and can Part 2 of the bill be considered as such. Some of people on this blog want to to do away with the present system, But then again it makes one shudder as to some one of the nonsense REf: Baf says .
    Part 2 of the bill if one takes it at its word one can’t help but wonder what the government is thinking. People have a right to be outraged. Well then the writers of the bill might have been stoned drunk or very high. they are no provisions included or exemptions. Part 2 is as written is as clear as the nose on your face.Btw my nose is 102 years could that be consider as relic or antique

  30. Random Thoughts Avatar

    BAFBFP “… You really expect foolish people like me to believe that dey had videa tapes back in 1966 …? Now wah kinda idiot you tink I is?”

    Sorry not video tapes, but reel-to-reel or whatever recording mechanism was used in those days. It has been taped over and what we see now is a hodge-podge. If you doubt me ask the MInister of Culture to ask (1) if the 1966 flag lowering and raising ceremony was tape recorded? and (2) and if so what has become of this tape recording?

    And these are the same people who want authority to take our stuff?

  31. Random Thoughts Avatar

    Quoting millertheannunaki “sophisticated professional criminals like the CLICO ”

    Nothing sophiticated nor professional about what went down at CLICO.

    It is just that we Bajans too like to believe the financial fairy stories.

  32. Random Thoughts Avatar

    We forget our plain old common sense and let people fool us that there is such a thing as $10 million dollar “a letter of comfort”

    Instead of asking wha da?

  33. Random Thoughts Avatar

    We ler people fool us into believed that if the Minister of Finance writes off a $19 million dolllar debt to the Turf Club that is not the same as having $19 million less in the tax pot for our other pressing needs.

    And we pretend that we can’t ask.

    Why?

    And how come?


  34. @ David

    You asked: Why was this bill brought back after being shot down under the last government?

    Because the government is on pause, and after being on recess they needed something to debate on resumption.Two new pieces of legislation in nearly four years, and guess what the House is yet again on break.


  35. Random Thoughts

    You can’ tape over reel to reel, I think I know wha’ you gettin’ at but it don’ mek sense accusing without a technically sound position …


  36. Up to the late ’70’s there was an original 1927 or thereabouts Ford Model A car still running about. Since the death of the owner in the ’80’s ,there is no trace of this car. It was probably shipped out in a container to the USA or Europe. Its relics like these that we also need to protect and preserve.

  37. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Trained Economist

    You are coming over as a trained apologist for the Government. I don’t care how many countries have similar legislation, this bill is plainly and simply very bad law. I understand the Minister to be saying, never mind what the bill is saying: it is not our intention. What happens when the Minister is dead and gone and there is no one left to say what the Government intended. I guess that people would have to rely on the actual words of the legislation. I don’t think that we would have to wait so long though: the words of the bill are pellucid and that is what the courts would enforce.

    When Government has collected all the family artefacts: they will come after the family jewels. However, I will have to protest because even though mine are over 50 years: I am still using them.


  38. I think Caswell Franklyn should be banned for indecent behavior


  39. it easier to beat up mon me than to deal withnthe issues


  40. mileranu atleast you seem to be reading my comments but do not blame mr barrow for free education it originated from wynter crawford’s congress party and was introduced bt the grantley adams govt and expanded by the barrow govt with mr tudor as minister of education. i have a pit toilet and i was thinking of onating it to mr antiquites lashley collection but on second thought i would keep it because the way things going i might have to resort to using it sooner rather than later.


  41. Sarge…… The government is not really interested in preserving old houses it seems they are after stuff they can easily carry in a truck or pocket. My ole house wouldn’t interest dem at all. I have even found some ole coins h’a pennies and some wid King George pon em. Eff dem want dem, dem cud come and get dem. Dem somewhere out in de yard. Found one wid Queen Victoria too. Ah gots some antique bottles too ah find when fixing de roof of de out house, seems like dem did likes dem likker in dem days. Oh and ah thow out de double seated latrine seat dat ah found in de latrine dat de wood ants got to. Oh shoite ah got more tings too but ah ent saying nuh more .


  42. And de rasthole dat Hant tawking bout paintings dat de poor peoples can’t buy should be fuh de public tah see. What paintings? Wid big fat white men an wimmen? Or de prints wid de African slaves toiling in de fields? Prints I say because de originals are back in Hingland in some Manor owned by de decendants of the slave owners who owned the plantations. And wha happen tah de tings in at Sam Lords? Axe Grant whet dem is, dem did burn in de fire?


  43. understand the dilemna we are in -i am appalled that in this enlightened day and age so called bright intelligent men as their contributions on the forum sggest will be willing to give more power to a bankrupt discredited political form of governance becuse of their allegiance to a political organisation. shame on them.


  44. Caswell I accept and conceded from the outset that if there are problems with the bill they should be dealt with.

    My argument since has been that I don’t think we have had a discussion on any specific details of the bill that need fixing, which would have been useful. What we have had is a rather edgy and almost destructive critique. I

    I don’t feel much more educated on the issue and I think the media let us down. They provided little or no context to the stories they ran. henry Fraser did a much better job in the advocate this morning.

    EVen a potentially technical debate about obscure antiquities bills descend into a partisan political cuss out,from whcih I have learnt little so far.


  45. Well trained economist. Must one spell out in details what previous governments and present intentions are. Where is the oversight committe !BTW read what Karl Watson said in the Advocate today! maybe it would open up your eyes a little. Being pretentious and partisian is not the way to go

  46. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Trained Economist

    The media would only let you down if you expected better from them: quite frankly, I don’t. The print media is about selling ad space: broadcast media is about polluting the minds of our youth as their first objective and next they are about selling ads. My suggestion is that those who are interested in the debate should read a copy of the bill, as I did. After reading the bill I became very fearful because of potential abuse of people’s rights that can flow from a strict interpretation of the words of the bill.

    I have even considered voting for the DEMS in the next election, but now I am having second thoughts as a result of this bill and the proposed acquisition of land at Vaucluse. A WORD TO THE WISE IS ENOUGH.


  47. ac, I want you to point the partisan and pretentious comments I have made on this thread.

    Seems like on this blog now that if you don’t join the bandwagon and rubbish every and anything yu must be partisan.


  48. Caswell,

    what do you understand to be the intent of the bill?

    what specific changes would you like to see that would achieve the intent while addressing the concerns raised?


  49. As Caswell has been saying over and over, the INTENT of the bill is of no relevance. What is important is the EFFECT of the bill.

    And THAT is to empower a government to seize private property based on arbitrary guidelines which in any event, they decide.

    How much debate does itbtake tonsee that as idiocy?

    The significant point to note here is that a Minister of government who is a lawyer, seems to see it fit to support this bill based on “his government’s (present) intentions.” LOL


  50. @Bush Tes

    To be fair to the Minister he indicated that the language will have to be tightened.

    Why it will take over 5 years God knows.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending