Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by RJH Adams (as a comment)

Comment on the crisis (global financial crisis) has focussed mostly on the US despite this being a global event (and, arguably, it was a French bank that truly kicked things off). You follow that trend. Yet in Barbados, most of the commercial lending system is sourced in Canada. Much play was made locally of a World Economic Forum survey (opinion-based) in October 2008 that ranked Canada first for the ‘soundness’ of its banks.

It makes sense to critical examine that view. That was originally why I was looking at the BIS data referred to above – for the large bulk of the private lending in Barbados is from Canadian banks. Unfortunately, Dennis scuppered the line of thought somewhat with that ‘co-mingling’ point.

Nonetheless, it is curious that the big 5 Canadian banks were all levered as high as their top 10 US counterparts in 2008 (and are much more so today) and yet are, allegedly, so sound. When I say ‘levered’, I mean how much tangible equity (the owners’ money if you like) supports tangible assets. The US banks today are levered at around 20:1 meaning $1 of owners’ money compared to $20 of tangible assets. (down from 35:1 last year). The Canadians are at about 30:1 (vs 37:1 last year).

The fundamental accounting identity is Assets = Liabilities + Owners’ Equity. This being so, a drop in tangible asset value of around 3% would effectively wipe out the Canadian bank owners’ equity (as would a 5% drop for the US). Unless one has very understanding creditors.

And when it comes to bailouts the Canadian are up their with the best of them: their ‘sound’ Big 5 banks received equally mind-boggling aid (in proportional terms) from their government as their US peers: $69bn of mortgage purchases and $45bn of ‘liquidity assistance’.

Some context:

the entire tangible equity of the Canadian banks last year was $68bn – so they have received well over 160% of that in assistance.  I call that an extraordinary price for a ‘sound’ system to pay. So how is it that the US gets all the attention locally? The explanation is not, I think, simply asset quality. It seems more that international media like to tackle the absolute scale the US represents. Local media and comment appears frequently to follow at the expense, in this case, of a relevant Barbadian context.

For all the gross faults of the US system, the moral questions and so on it would be misguided to draw comfort from the fact that we rely on a different nation for our own private credit.  Although somewhat optimistic for Barbados (on the US/UK labour data especially) over the next 24 months it is a fragile optimism. Maybe sovereign bonds will be a pothole as you seem to imply; but looking more dangerous to my mind is the size of likely undisclosed losses on commercial property portfolios held by the major US, UK – and Canadian – banks.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

54 responses to “A Quizzical View Of The Banking Sector”


  1. This comment by Rawdon is refreshingly different from the commentators we have been reading. We thought we should give it highlight.


  2. Asking the local media to stray from what they regurgitate from the wire to report on other activity in the world that directly affects Barbados is asking them to put some effort into their delivery of information and that is simply not fair. Nobody should be asked to work that hard…!


  3. why not ask for the release of the 2008 accounts for

    (1) clico mortgage and finance
    (2) clico general insurance
    (3) clico life insurance


  4. @ Donald Duck, Esq,

    My aunt went to the Treasury Building yesterday to conduct business – where a man was asking about his Income Tax Refunds.

    As it was told to me: the man was politely asked by an employee – “Sir, are you really concern about your Income Tax Refund or wherether the government will be able to pay your salary for December.”

    ++++++++++++

    Wait a minute!!!

    Didn’t the Prime Minister say that the government does not have a cash-flow problem?


  5. Canadians are happy today.Next week could be different but…..

    In the past two weeks, Canada’s six largest banks have reported quarterly profits totalling C$4bn (US$3.8bn), spurring bank executives and analysts to predict a once-in-a-decade opportunity for international growth.

    The last of the banks to report earnings, the Bank of Nova Scotia, said yesterday that it had nearly trebled net profits in the quarter ending October 31 to C$902m.

    Buoyed by the profits and their well-capitalised position, Canada’s six largest banks – Royal Bankof Canada, Toronto-Dominion, Bank of Nova Scotia, Bank of Montreal, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce and the National Bank of Canada – are looking to take a more aggressive approach to global expansion

    Toronto’s main stock index shot higher at the open on Monday as stronger prices for Canadian exports like oil and gold supported the resource-heavy index.

    The S&P/TSX composite index rose 98.46 points, or 0.85 percent, to 11,677.79 at the open


  6. @Rawdon

    Something seems to be missing from your analysis. Accepting your ‘levered’ argument, has the Canadian banking market been able to mitigate that position in some way compared to other markets?

  7. Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados) Avatar
    Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados)

    @Rawdon, I wont pretend to know much about the situation of Canadian banks in Canada, but take a look at some analysis undertaken recently at the IMF concerning those banks’ resilience, and published as a working paper, http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.cfm?sk=23040.0. The abstract reads:
    This paper explores factors behind Canadian banks’ relative resilience in the ongoing credit turmoil. We identify two main causes: a higher share of depository funding (vs. wholesale funding) in liabilities, and a number of regulatory and structural factors in the Canadian market that reduced banks’ incentives to take excessive risks. The robust predictive power of the depository funding ratio is confirmed in a multivariate analysis of the performance of 72 largest commercial banks in OECD countries during the turmoil.

  8. Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados) Avatar
    Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados)

    @Rawdon, see also the press release of an IMF staff visit to Canada in early November, http://www.imf.org/external/np/sec/pr/2009/pr09401.htm. Main point of note for you:
    ‘Financial institutions, while confronted with volatile markets and a subpar economic environment, have proven resilient through the recession, thanks to rigorous regulation and prudent bank practices.’ If you want to contact the mission chief, I can provide his email address if you contact me directly.


  9. I read the abstract and a point to be noted is that it is stated.
    Canada banks have been universal and they have little competition for household savings from other alternative investment vehicles.


  10. The Canadian Bank executives, employees and all the share holders who stand to earn massive bonuses as well as stock gains and increased dividends should send a bottle of bubbly to former PM Paul Martin (not that he needs charity from anyone). Martin as Finance Minister in Canada threw a spanner in the works at the merger plans of four of the Big Five banks in Canada. The Chairmen of the Canadian Banks were not happy as lesser players on the world financial scene (RBC Canada’s largest bank was way down the list of the top financial enterprises in the world) and announced merger plans which would see Royal merging with Bank of Montreal and CIBC merging with Toronto Dominion Bank, poor Scotia was left with no one to dance with.

    The public was not enamoured of any mergers because it was generally felt a monopolistic situation would become worse and jobs would disappear in Toronto because of these merger. Martin decided to cast his lot with the public (and votes) and announced that there would be no mergers. This forced the banks to abandon their hopes of playing with the Big boys and concentrate on the domestic market where they are dominant. There are other banks in Canada (listed as schedule B Banks) but they are merely a blip on the Canadian financial landscape. If the mergers had taken place they would have been knee deep in foreign adventures with serious consequences during the recession, as a result of the non merger they dodged a bullet.


  11. What’s missing from the analysis is the acknowledgment that Canadian banks differ in a major aspect to their US counterparts in lending policy.

    The Americans, in the several years leading up to the sub-prime collapse allowed greed to overtake prudence in their housing loan policy and routinely lent 100% (sometimes more) of the cost of purchase or building of a house. This was driven also by the fact that US banking executives’ remuneration was tied to increases in business written.

    Canadian banks largely followed a policy of lending 75% (or in extreme cases 80% with collateral not related to the real estate) of the acquisition cost. Therefore, most Canadians saved until they accumulated 20% to 25% of a down payment on a home before making a purchase and were actively discouraged from deviating from this practice by their bankers.

    Canadian banks were much more strict in real estate loans than their US counterparts. This is the real reason that they were not hit by large scale repayment defaults, a lesson the US banks have paid dearly to learn.

    We should be eternally grateful that Barbadian bankers’ home loan policy has throughout its history followed the Canadian model rather than the American.


  12. @Hants,

    If someone gave me 160% of my net worth I’m fairly certain I could hold a serious fete too.

    @David, Inkwell,

    It seems to me that Canada faces precisely the same problem as the US/UK: house prices rose (at their peaks) to very high multiples of income – much higher than the US (7 vs5) and not much saner than those of the UK (7.8).

    A large difference is that the Canadian Government has decent PR. They did not bother securitising the debt into subprime, Alt A, prime etc. They merely guaranteed certain mortgages (>80% loan to value) via the Canadian Mortgage & Housing Corporation (CMHC). If you are a lender it is money for old rope. You lend and pass on the risk to the public purse. Prices rise all the while and I suggest that it is analogous (in direction in not degree) to subprime securitisation – except that all the risk sits upon Canadian taxpayers. At least the Yanks shared the pain.

    The CMHA now guarantees circa CAD$650bn – or over half the country’s GDP. You ask how the Canadian banks have been able to mitigate the dangers of leverage. They have not, in my view. They have instead been encouraged to maintain it because much of the risk is being socialised. If anyone can explain to me how else the Canadian property market only peaked in May this year I’ll be content to listen.

    Such a legal/financing system makes bank accounting comparisons across jurisdictions tricky and I do not see a correction or narrative for it in the IMF paper linked to above.

    @ac, Dennis

    Reliance upon the wholesale funding model destroyed Northern Rock. So, of course, it helps to have a large and captive depository base. However, the evaporation of short-term funding was (1) a symptom of the crisis (2) deposits sit on the balance sheet as liabilities and (3) the root problem lies in an asset bubble which affects ‘a’ and oe’ of the a=l+oe equation set out earlier.

    Section II F of that paper recognises this whilst deeming its own lack of focus on the asset side somewhat irrelevant. A lot that is said on liability structure is irrefutable but they underplay the role of public guarantees of mortgages in arriving at the conclusion the Canadian banks are more “conservative”.

    The government guarantees a loan and the bank makes 150 basis points (say), essentially, for free. Interest rates are thus held artificially low (for I sincerely doubt the price of loan insurance is market-based), risk is mispriced, demand for property stays strong and banks continue to leverage up. You can move single transaction risk around but you cannot make it go away. Why a bank that is allowed to shift its risk to the taxpayer gets to be labelled ‘sound’ and ‘conservative’ seems strange to me.

    Which, no matter the operational liquidity offered by a broad deposit base or the buyer arriving with a 20% deposit, tends to explain the massive government assistance put at the disposal of Canada’s banks. And despite it all Canadian inter bank term funding is running at a third of normal levels. That tells most investors that Canada, like the US and UK, has stabilised its system but not solved the problem of excessively-levered balance sheets holding unrecognised impaired assets.

    They got there their own way, which suggests to me that the timing of events may continue to be different to the US/UK. But the challenges are surely identical. The only underlying reason anyone today should invest in their banks is because of implicit and explicit governmental guarantees on their money. And it is worth repeating for those who want to bet that today, the big 5 Canadian banks are levered considerably higher than their top 10 US equivalents.


  13. Also, perhaps this Dec 10 quote from a commentary by David Rosengberg, Chief Economist of Canadian investment firm Gluskinn Sheff, might be of interest:

    IS THE CANADIAN HOUSING MARKET IN A BUBBLE?

    It sure looks that way. At a time when personal income is down around 1% in the last year, we have seen nationwide average home prices soar 21% and last month hit a record high, as did sales. In real terms, home price appreciation is back to where it was in 1989. Of course, back then, interest rates were far higher but then again, the economy was in the late stages of a phenomenal multi-year economic expansion, not making a transition from deep recession to nascent recovery.

    While the Canadian economy is recovering, overall growth is still barely above zero as manufacturers grappled with excess inventories, a strong currency and a soft domestic demand picture south of the border. Employment conditions have improved, but are hardly that healthy, as we saw in the November jobs report where wages and the workweek were both down despite a constructive headline number (half of which were in the education sector, an inherently difficult area for statisticians to adequately seasonally adjust).

    In answer to the question as to whether prices are in a bubble, all we will say is that when we ran some models showing Canadian home prices normalized by personal income or by residential rent, what we found is that housing values are anywhere between 15-35% above levels we would label as being consistent with the fundamentals. If being 15% to 35% overvalued isn’t a bubble, then it’s the next closest thing. We are talking about 2-3 standard deviation events here in terms of the parabolic move in Canadian home prices from their lows. So if it walks like a duck …


  14. @Rawdon

    These matters are little above BUs pay grade but it seems in your analysis you cite the age old debate; the role of government in the market versus capitalist type system as practised in the US.


  15. RJH:

    Not being an economist, just an interested observer, it seems to me that the trigger for a second downturn next year could be the Option ARM market.

    These mortgages seem to have been taken out at the height of the housing bubble, essentially by people who could not afford a conventional scheme, and now the majority of these speculative punts are becoming due for recast.

    Deep in negative equity, on recast the average payment increase is said to be $1053 per month (+63% ).

    28% are even now delinquent at the teaser rates, so defaults come the recast look likely to exceed the 62% predicted.

    I enjoy reading above and between the lines of your posts, and would welcome your opinion on the likely damage caused by AltA and ARM.


  16. RJH is no genius he is simply doing what he is trained to do in a manner that so many equally trained Barbadians are not prepared to demonstrate.

    We are linked to the US by the fact that the currency is pegged, the many Barbadians that have taken up residence there, the few tourists that come every year and BAM, the hype (ABC CBS CNN FOX). Canadian law affords Barbados the privilege of an offshore business sector, and our financial entities are predominantly Canadian. Why is it that it must take a guy with a funny sounding name to expose Barbadians to the real flaws in the fundamental institutions that we depend on? He probably doesn’t even live in Barbados…!


  17. I know that he is Tom’s son… but some people say that the Prime Minister is T(h)omson too…!


  18. @David,

    You stir up all this jargon, put me on the spot and now complaining…?

    Hard to separate government from the market; with the public sector swallowing what bad risks banks have actually admitted to it seems pointless to in any case. How can assessing one side of, say, a Canadian mortgage transaction guaranteed by the CMHC but not its public sector consequences be decent analysis?

    The examples of Iceland, Dubai, Greece, assorted Baltic states and the UK (currently receiving stern words about its AAA rating from Moody’s amid a fiscally delusional pre-budget speech) surely serve notice of that. A great many other nations, even Barbados, might see parallels in their own circumstances.

    @ST, BAFBFP

    No, certainly no genius; largely untrained (but thanks for the assumption); entirely non-resident; guilty on the name; and I’m no economist either. All conditions that may weaken/disqualify informed opinion depending (apparently) on the reader. Indeed, the point that anyone with similar or superior training (mostly everyone as it happens) could put the same view is well made and true.

    Re: ARMS/Alt-As, I know of a properly trained economist (normal first name) who is v good reading on the implications of the resets. One link with a sobering graph is here:

    http://www.hussmanfunds.com/wmc/wmc091109.htm

    and another with little mincing of words is here:

    http://www.hussmanfunds.com/wmc/wmc091116.htm

    His archive has a great deal more.


  19. I hate to be a damp squid but something is not right, like all those people who followed the trend have nothing, and the few individuals that sold them a rope own the whole worlds wealth. Canada didn’t invest as much
    free speech and movement
    the games people play
    p.s. merry christmas


  20. @Rawdon

    Not stirring up at all, only highlighting the circular debate which exists i.e the irrelevance or should we politically correct and say the reactive roles regulators are encouraged to play by governments. Simply put the tail wagging the dog.


  21. @RJH Adams

    The majority of Canadians are comfortable with our financial systems and the way the country is governed.

    Your economic assessment of Canada is beyond my capacity to criticise.

    All I can contribute is that I have property in Canada and Barbados and I have confidence in the Governance and banking systems in both countries.

    Like many other Bajan Canadians I ain’t worried.

    I will leave the worrying to younger better educated persons like yourself.


  22. @RJH Adams,

    Your analysis perhaps does not give enough weight to the impact of the quality of the assets in the equation you cited – Assets = Liabilities + Owners’ Equity.

    Neither does it consider the effect of off-balance sheet liabilities.

    A 3% drop in the “tangible asset value” of a Canadian bank may therefore be a lot less likely than a 5% drop for a comparable US bank.

    Why have you not considered traditional methods of analyzing the soundness and solvency of banks?

    Where do you get your figures on debt to equity ratios for Canadian banks? Are these the figures from the consolidated operations and do they include overseas subsidiaries and branches, and non-bank entities?

    I however certainly share your concern about the potential impact of housing bubbles on Canadian banks, and similarly local banks.

    I think though that the direct link between the housing market and the implosion of US and other banks was significantly exaggerated by the involvement of derivatives, such that the amount of financial instruments involved far exceeded the book value of the underlying real estate. This may not be as significant a factor for the Canadian banks and certainly not for the local banks.

    Having said that, the ratio of 30:1 seems very high. I think if we did the analysis for local banks it would be a lot lower. From memory, and based on my understanding of the required capital adequacy ratio, the maximum ratio of risk weighted assets to equity is 12.5 (this number is comparable to the 30 for Canadian banks).

    I will see if I can find out the required ratio for Canadian banks, and under Basel.


  23. @RJH Adams,

    Like you, I also don’t understand why the Canadian government would have had to provide so much support to their banks. Was this mainly pre-emptive, and was it because of balance sheet exposure to US banks, as opposed to direct holdings of toxic assets?

  24. Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados) Avatar
    Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados)

    @Rawdon, not much to add to your words, except to note that many a good financial mind and much excellent economic analysis have come from persons not necessarily formally trained as economists. I often include Keynes in that band.


  25. My Fellow citizens, it troubles me greatly that the question of the number of Barbadians who continue to lose their jobs – has reared its ugly head again; with the announcement last Friday that unemployment is now in double digits – 10.5% for the third quarter.

    Apologists for the failed policies of the Government – that are neither stimulating nor stabilizing the economy – are free to complain all they want that the Opposition only speak to gloom and doom.

    The truth is that if the Democratic Labour Party’s Members of Parliament were out in their constituencies they would know that this is precisely what an increasing number of their constituents are feeling.

    What does a man who has lost his job and who has a family to feed and children to send to school – have to look forward to from this Government?

    The Prime Minister himself hoisted the white flag with his statement that jobless growth is all we can look forward to.

    It is not an empty statement either, for if we look around the economic landscape, it is clear that the Government has no policies in place to create jobs or save jobs from being lost.


  26. @Rawdon, As your Father would say to the likes of BAFBFP, i.e., when Harold Hoyte while conducting an interview with ‘Tom’ would try provoking him by asking some silly question, Tom would with that ‘smirk’ on his face, dismiss Hoyte’s folly, with;

    ‘Absolutely no truth to that at all…all vicious and malignant rumors…venal, vacuous and venomous…’

    Regarding David Thompson, JMGM did say one night at a political meeting in St. Thomas, in response to something said about Thompson, ‘….that boy needs a father’s hand…’ Unfortunately, he still does…especially re economic matters!


  27. Rawdon you got my imagination peaking now… so what exactly is it that you are trained to do..? Yah certainly had me fooled.


  28. Read somewhere that Canada’s gross domestic debt to GDP is about 35% – isn’t this a healthy indicator? The concern BU has for Canada and by extension the banking sector is the heavy reliance on the US market for its exports. It seems Canada can learn from Australia who has been increasing its business with the Chinese. In other words; diversification.


  29. @Hants,

    I believe Canada’s banking system is sounder than thse of the US and the UK and, of the 3, it is my favourite. It is simply that such a choice is akin to being asked to choose 1 out of my 3 favourite major surgical interventions. But that’s a mere opinion, you are living on the spot and I defer entirely on what Canadians think about it all.

    @Brutus,

    1) I do ignore asset quality which is a very important part of the debate. Unfortunately, I know of no way today to quantify this meaningfully.

    Partly this is due to the complex accounting of banks; partly to the still stressed levels of interbank lending I referred to; and partly because accounting standards (rightly or wrongly) have been relaxed to permit banks the latitude to make long term economic judgements about the value of certain assets they hold (this is more a US issue). The best that can be said is that bank reporting now represents more of an opinion than usual.

    2) Why this asset-side definition of leverage? It is indicative of the risk equity investors face in a market where asset values are still vulnerable. I note that many of the regulatory-demanded ratios signalled few or no issues with banks until it was too late. Again, I am not saying this is a definitive, one size fits all method but, although crude, it has its use.

    The debt to equity leverage measure you mention is probably the key to a long term solution (assuming that the selling of assets continues to be problematic). And there are few ways to delever debt: generate operating cash and pay it down; or swap it for equity. Not much evidence, amid large bank bonus payouts (even in Canada) that this is being taken seriously.

    3) Re: off balance sheet arrangements, Canadian banks have had to shore up their own “special investment vehicles” (BMO is one such) due mainly to investor litigation or threat thereof. Perhaps it is a question of how far they indulged in the practice but it is no secret some of the Canadian majors have material subprime exposure.

    4) The data (tangible assets to tangible equity rather than debt to equity) is from Bloomberg but is easily available straight off the websites of the banks (and is consolidated).

    5) Agree that derivatives have not helped.

    6) Probably have to define “pre-emptive”. In PR terms it was. In financial terms I could not say. $65bn of the assistance (late 2008) was from the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp which bought some of the very high loan to value (>80%) mortgages the CMHC had already written insurance for. Bulk of the rest was “liquidity assistance” along the same lines as that provided by the US, UK and ECB and effectively performed the same function as the (frozen) interbank lending market. Bystander or participant, I don’t know. But that amount of leverage and exposure to falling markets is dangerous.

    @Dennis,

    btw, amazing biography of JMK by Robert Skildesky if you have not read it…

    @Zoe,

    leaving the politics to you…

    @BAFBFP

    Had some decent training for coming in at number 5 with not much on the board (but still no WICB contract).


  30. @Rawdon, I’m not the least into politics…I, like others liked hearing ‘Tom’ with his smooth baritone expound from that brilliant brain of his.

    In light of this foundness for JMGM, I’ve suggested, that may be, CBC TV, who have both Tom and Errol Barrow speeches in archive, could compile on DVD a set of each past PMs most memorable discourses for sale to the public.


  31. Good thinking. Brutus seems to have answered some questions.

    Just a few more points.

    Canada’s housing markets does not seem to be as overbuilt as that of the USA. USA was in building overdrive for a while before the effective crash, which should actually have kept prices down, due to supply being able to satisfy demand, but that did not work, as demand still exceeded supply for various reasons, including speculative buying by persons buying multiple units for seubsequent resale and expected profit.

    Not that speculation does not exist in Canada, but as per Hants/ Brutus above, the prospective buyer actually has to show some form of ability to repay, unlike the situation in the USA few years back.

    Therefore, the demand part of the equation was severly overbloated.

    Secondly, USA citizens can legally drop the keys and walk away in a case of negative value in a mortgage, especially attractive of one has lost a job or has reduced earnings.

    This does two things. Firstly, encourages buying a property greater than one can afford , as you can always ‘walk away’.

    Secondly, it creates a situation where banks are saddled with the whole part of many properties, as many walk away.

    Conversely, in other countries such as Canada, the banks are ‘only’ saddled with the negative effect, unless of course the property owner simply cannot pay the loan repayments.

    So, not only is there an issue of quality in the original asset base, but the issue of manner of resolution then adds another dynamic.

    Further, it would appear also, that Canada relied more on direct mortgage relationships, maybe partly because of the Gov’t guarantees as mentioned above.

    This meant that to some extent, the banks and all subsequent parties ‘know their loan portfolio’, unlike the packaged loan security methods applied in the USA, where subsequent security holders held portfolios of which they had little understanding of the real risks involved.

    That is the problem with the derivatives and relates to the discussion on another thread a while back on derivatives.

    The analysis and pricing of these is very difficult if not impossible, due to the complex mix of product involved.

    Finally, while it is good and certainly mecessary to ask the question regarding stability of economies, especially in light of continuing problems, it does appear that at the current time, as mentioned above, Canada’s macroeconomic state is much better than either the USA and UK’s, thus allows the Government to take action if necessary, to stabilise the economcy in time of difficulty.

    So, while the analysis and alert of a potential issue is warranted and necessary, it does appear that there are grounds to believe that Canada is somewhat an exception to the recent furor, although it will not be exempt from international economic problems.

  32. Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados) Avatar
    Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados)

    @RJR Adams,

    Rawdon, thanks. I take it you mean ‘Return of the Master’, by Robert Skidelsky, Emeritus Professor of Political Economy at the University of Warwick. Would be good reading over Christmas.


  33. Dennis ca’dear man, you can’ find somet’ing a lil’ more entertaining to do? My God man…!

    @ ZOE
    Why would you chose to forget that it was JMGM who shamelessly dragged Barbados into facilitating the US invasion the English speaking sovereign state of Granada and started this useless drain on the tax payers purse called a Defence Force? It is very clear to me from his obvious good sense, that the the guy with the funny name (lol) takes after his mother…!


  34. @BAFBFP You are welcome to your myopic meandering on such historic reality in order to save the very ‘sovereignty’ of the said state of Genada; but…after all….Leftists like you, can only think in convoluted, twisted terms….vicious, venomous, and venal, malignent….true to form…!!!


  35. Oh Zoe
    You Right wing, sponge brain, neo-Western copy cat..!


  36. BAF,

    I was going to refrain from posting on this for various reasons, but in the interests of accuracy, I do not think we should move on without clarification.

    The Grenada ‘invasion’ (if, as is popular, you refuse to use ‘intervention’), was requested by Sir Paul Scoon, the then GG of Grenada.

    This was after the coup leaders had not only clearly ousted the official leader, but had entered into brutality against them.

    Regarrdless of direction of country, how can one justify the brutal execution of an unarmed group, who were not using force i.e. Maurice Bishop and his ‘people’ but merely a threat based on their popularity and political will?

    Murder of a pregnant Jacqueline Creft was past any semblance of normalcy and humanity.

    Whitehead the lawyer, was in Barbados at the time, advised to remain here lest he be personally injured (I know this for a fact) but insisted that he must return as it was his country and he must return to assist.

    He was murdered with the rest.

    The soldiers were ordered to shoot at citizens, including women and children who were marching on Richmond Hill prison to ask for the freedom of Maurice Bishop and the rest.

    Coard and his lot ordered the soldiers to open fire.

    It was on this basis that Barbados and Dominica supported the request to the USA for assistance.

    As noted, Sir Paul Scoon requested assistance.

    Indeed, Eugenia Charles was instrumental in persuading the US for assistance.

    That is the factual aspect of the history.

    Remember that the political landscape was far different then.

    Also of note, is that the Defence Force already existed, it was not set up after that event, which possibly indicates some foresight in setting it up in the first place.

    Now, moving into the present day, the Defence Force plays not only a security role politically, but do remember the role it plays as part of the regional security force.

    Having said that, someone has already accused myself of being a ‘leftist’, whatever that is, on this blog.

    I do not represent anything but facts, humanity, individuality and doing the right thing.


  37. Boy oh boy Crusoe

    I will not treat to your comments as contemptuously as those of the Judeo-Christian Neocon f*rt, but wid Dennis Johnson waiting in de wings, lemme tell you I can’ wait to get started on this subject…! David may decide to pop them into a new thread!

    First of all, the excuse given by the US for committing troops to Grenada was to rescue a few students who were attending the University there…risk all those Grenadian lives to save a few students…Hmmm. I gun pause fah now tah see iffen Dennis gun jump in shoutin’ …!


  38. BAF,

    Yes, there were students there, agreed. I actually met one who got here the night all heck broke loose.

    But, I can say that what is noted above is fact.

    Grenadian lives were not risked, they were lost, at the hands of a few callous butchers.

    That is fact, not heresay. I am the first to condemn needless acts of invasion, but the first to defend international forces where necessary and to not ‘bandwagon’.

    Sorry, skip, but I know the facts here, trust me.


  39. Having said that, I am now out of further discussion on this.

    We can agree to disagree.


  40. Crusoe’s rational, objective analysis of the facts that transpired in Grenada, stand in diametric contrast to the radical *Leftists* rantings of the delusional minded BAFBPF, but, none other can be expected from such deranged minds, whose psychosis, is the desire to shed their hated selves by blurring their individuality in a collective whole (hole), hence their inability to discern truth and facts from their warpped mentality.

    Continue on BAFBPT, with your gutter filth, cess-pit, disoriented mindset!

    You are not worthy to engage in any meaningful discourse!

    So it be!!!


  41. Crusoe

    I have no desire to change your opinion on what may have gone on in the back ground, but to join you in boasting of some involvement I too took a couple of people (wounded by shrapnel) to the QEH.

    Now correct me if you must, but Barbados had a Regiment (a Colonial remnant) before all of this took place.

    It is my contention that the now Barbados Defence Force was developed to protect the Government in power from civil unrest full stop; in any event it is simply not equipped to do anything more. Any proffering of the notion that it protects the public in general is just an argument by extension.

    What happened in Grenada is referred to today by official policy makers in the US as “Regime Change”, plain and simple. Haitians, Nicaraguans, Cubans, Panamanians and Guyanese in the region are very familiar with the concept. Tom Adams was afraid of the possibility of a similar civil development happening in Barbados, hence the BDF… still a waste of tax payer’s money as the major overseas threat to Barbados has always come from the sea; for example in the form of trafficking, and we have always had a Coast Guard…!

    Now what I would love to get my hands on is official documenting of the extent and nature of the involvement of the US Government and propaganda machinery in the events leading up to and including the executing of the seven people.

    Paul Scoon, reminds me of Hirohito Emperor of Japan, a spineless survivor, thirteenth man on the team.

    Eugennia Charles had no legal right; my God I am so tired of hearing about this “Coalition of the Willing” scenario popping up when ever the US is up to some mischief.

    Years afterwards, former Sec of State George Schultz claimed that the US believed that a “Soviet Triangulate” was being established (Cuba – North, Nicaragua – West, Grenade – East). So what in God’s name does any of this have to do with students and nice Grenadian people..? When the invasion took place Pravda reported that the action was taking place in SPAIN…!

    The official story does not cut it..! And wow, what a charming sight seeing the Grenadian Prime Ministers holding ceremonies to celebrate the lives of the GI’s that died trying to kill airport construction workers…. nice little Prime Ministers that trek every year to the US to celebrate July 4.

    My God…!


  42. Zoe

    By the way, I am an Atheist. Unlike Christians we don’t forgive, we simply forget..! I dun faget ’bout you long time…!


  43. BAF,

    I am not ‘boasting of involvement’, just aware of the facts.

    But, you have your opinions, maybe you should tell them to Jacqueline Crefts child.

    Oops, sorry, you cannot, that baby was murdered in the womb. along with the mother.

    Not by US troops either.


  44. Crusoe

    Bet you didn’t know that Maurice Bishop came to Barbados a couple of weeks earlier and took out insurance so that in the event he got killed his estate would get a little something. Of course the Life of Barbados agent took his money and neglected to tell him that in the event that he was killed in the manner that he eventually was his estate would not receive one red cent. Yet another casualty of war. I hate it when culprits like LOB and the USA evade scrutiny after the fact and are just allowed to carry on smartly..!

  45. Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados) Avatar
    Dennis Jones (aka Living in Barbados)

    @BAFBFP, I certainly can, but as one has a lot of free time and moods are more relaxed, it’s good to get one’s teeth into some things that are soporophic and not called turkey and black cake :-).


  46. @BAFBPF, If you are the self-proclaimed *atheist* that you say you ARE….then WHY do you continue to invoke *HIS* NAME???!!!

    “….my God I am so tired of hearing…”

    “My God…!”

    Demented Leftists!!!


  47. Zoe

    Dont twist your knicks, it’s just a phraseology, my God…!

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending