Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Shridath Surendranath "Sonny" Ramphal
Shridath Surendranath "Sonny" Ramphal

The comment by Shridath ‘Sonny’ Ramphal a couple months ago when he used the term ‘intimations of ethnic cleansing’ in a speech referring to Barbados’ new immigration policy has not rested well with Barbadians, perhaps to many surprisingly so. Barbadians from all strata of society continue to show amazement that a man of his background would have used such inflammatory language in the prevailing climate. The fact he based his comment on a Nation newspaper editorial makes it all the more mind-boggling.

The Nation newspaper carried a report today citing Ramphal as rejecting the interpretation being applied to his now infamous reference to ethnic cleansing. Interesting to note Ramphal in the report refused to deliver an unqualified apology to Barbadians. Ramphal’s response to the strident criticism after he made the injudicious remark would have come two months later. The delay is most regrettable and only served to further inflame the sensitivity of Bajans. Of interest also is the fact he has come public a couple weeks after Rickey intimated in his weekly column that Ramphal would ignore public calls to address the matter.

Prime Minister David Thompson at party conference on the weekend,for the first time addressed the Ramphal statement. Here is a snippet from his address:

Barbados is a democracy. We invite and encourage criticism, debate and discussion on topical issues,” Thompson said. “[However] . . . as Prime Minister of this country I have had as much as I am willing to take as far as the unfair and unwarranted maligning of Barbados and Barbadians by those to whom we have extended a welcoming hand is concerned. There is precedence for dealing with such ingratitude. I am saying today ‘enough is enough’!” – Nation Newspaper

There is no doubt the scathing remarks by Prime Minister Thompson coaxed Sonny from his nest. He could ignore Lincoln Lewis but how could he ignore our Prime Minister?

If it were not apparent before it should be now that Bajans will be as tolerant to being crapped on especially by those who reside in Barbados at our invitation. Barbadians have historical accepted the labels of passive, generous and tolerant when compared to our neighbours. To those who we have given freely of our hospitality should we not expect them to demonstrate sensitivity when such situations arise?

Oh no Sonny! The damage has been done. Your legacy has been tarred forever in the minds of many Barbadians. You took too long to respond. Even with your tardy retort you let slip the opportunity to deliver an unequivocal apology to Barbadians for the emotional stress caused and the destruction to goodwill earned over several years. Your lack of the situational awareness required at a time ,which merited you to exercise diplomatic skills accrued after many years as Secretary General of the Commonwealth has caused many Barbadians to ponder.

The issue of Ramphal’s indiscretion should not be addressed in isolation. The role of some of our regionalists and academics must come under the microscope. Some of them have used their websites to pour scorn on Barbados at the expense of addressing the Ramphal comment. Did we not hear Norman Girvan, Annalee Davis and George Braithwaite in an interview with a Jamaican radio station refer to our Immigration Department as using Gestapo like tactics? The other issue is the role of the Barbados media and specifically the Nation Newspaper in this matter. Why have they not published the Lincoln Lewis letter to Rickey Singh? Given the stature of Lewis as a leading trade unionist and General Secretary of the Caribbean Congress of Labour the refusal to print his letter or even part is unprofessional.

Let the word propagate that disrespecting Barbadians with the casualness of the past has come to an end. We will make mistakes; do the right thing and accept responsibility and let us move on. The very ideal promoted by Ramphal over years to promote regional integration is being undermined by his divisive and inflammatory statement. Despite the Nation report citing Sonny’s retort the issue remains unaddressed.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. Can you read? The man never said that Barbados was engaged in ethnic cleansing, he said no Caribbean PM would countenance it.

    If this blog was in the US it probably would be on Rush Limbaugh’s blogroll.

  2. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    It is always a sadness when, however propelled, our societies are caught in a downward spiral of separateness with fellow West Indians cast as „outsiders‟; those times when, as Annalee Davis (the Barbadian Researcher) has described them, we become “locked into nationalist crevices … and exclusivist cultural legitimacy”. We are at such a time, and both policies and practices are deepening Caribbean divides. „The knock on the door at night‟ is not within our regional culture; still less are intimations of „ethnic cleansing‟. No Caribbean leader would countenance such departures from our norms and values; but all must not only believe, but also act as if they believe, that we forget our oneness at our peril; whether the „otherness‟ that displaces it is an accidental place of regional birth, or otherness of any kind. I say „accidental‟ because in the Caribbean the age-old process of trans-migration has made us all family: as a great Barbadian regionalist, the Rt. Excellent Errol Barrow, reminded us twenty-three years ago – concluding in his practical common-sense way that: “If we have sometimes failed to comprehend the essence of the regional integration movement, the truth is that thousands of ordinary Caribbean people do in fact live that reality every day. … we are a family … and this fact of regional togetherness is lived every day by ordinary West Indian men and women in their comings and goings.”
    So indeed it was; and for a very long time. My great-great grandfather on my mother‟s side came to Guyana from Barbados looking for land and settlement, and found them – and so it has been up and down the chain of island societies that free movement fused into one: freedom curbed ironically with the arrival of our separate „national‟ freedoms.
    10
    But the roots of those family trees are now spread out in the sub-soil of the Caribbean. Social antipathy and divisiveness deny them; but DNA‟s defy even Constitutions. “CARICOM is at risk”, we have been warned. So it is; and few are blameless. Political leaders, in particular, have to be less casual about CARICOM, less minimalist in their ambition for it, less negative in their vision of it. Its foundations have been built on our oneness; not on the geography of a dividing sea. The Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas is not just embellished parchment; it is the logic of that oneness in a world which threatens our separate survival. And the revised treaty is not all; there are international Conventions to which all CARICOM member states are parties that are relevant to our rights and obligations to each other as human beings, much less family. The Caribbean Community is now our regional mansion within a global home. We have to make it more secure and habitable – through reaching goals like the CSME (or even the CSM), and reaching them together.

  3. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    Wesley Gibbons is the president of the Association of Caribbean Media workers. He had the following to say. May 28th 2009

    • Wesley Gibbings on May 28th, 2009 at 3:26 am
    I understand the call for an extended amnesty arrangement under the current circumstances. The ‘ethnic cleansing’ of Barbados is being quietly replicated in other territories (complete with the racist flavour given it in places such as Barbados and Antigua). So, what we are dealing with is urgent and requires a united and creative intervention. Mr Commissiong is attending to the problem with this in mind.
    But greater attention should be drawn to the fact that there is a commitment by 12 Caricom nations to extend the free movement provisions of the CSME to all Caricom citizens by the end of 2009.
    Of course we know nobody has been serious about this, given the difficulties we have experienced with the initial five categories of skilled nationals under the Treaty. But we ought to have perhaps been having the CCJ busy with class action suits geared toward testing the integrity of the revised Treaty of Chaguaramas and its application in signatory states with respect to the already ‘approved categories.’
    Politicians cannot continue getting away with this kind of dishonourable behaviour in the region. This region of immigrants has always been a ‘warehouse’ for the good and the bad of the world. That, in a sense, is what makes us so unique and perhaps even special.
    Wesley


  4. Ramphal’s running for cover following the sundown comments of the Barbadian PM is proof positive that these people only recognize absolute strength. The black Caribbean leadership have been allowing a coteri of rabid Indianist to dictate their way, and guilt trip them into giving the Nelson’s eye to their prejudice. They need to issue sundown warnings to Jagdeo and all of his supremacist posse.

  5. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    Anon:
    Yes he said no caribbean leader would coutenence it.

    countenence
    n.
    To give sanction or support to; tolerate or approve:

    He also went on to say

    “but all must not only believe, but also act as if they believe, that we forget our oneness at our peril; whether the ‘otherness’ that displaces it is an accidental place of regional birth, or otherness of any kind.”
    ————————————————

    So what is he saying? That some action or activity betrays what caribbean leaders may not “countenence” or say they believe? What might that action be?


  6. So Adrian,

    having disproved the ethnic cleansing arguement you now move the goalposts to regional integration generally?

    stupse!

  7. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    Shridath says that he was responding to a Nation news article or editorial. Tony Marshall read the article in question today on the call in program and could not find any reference to “ethnic cleansing” and is at lost as to how Shridath made the connection.

    Shridath in his speech made no mention of a newpaper article, however, just one paragraph before he gets to his now infamous comments he says……

    “our societies are caught in a downward spiral of separateness with fellow West Indians cast as „outsiders‟; those times when, as Annalee Davis (the Barbadian Researcher) has described them, we become “locked into nationalist crevices … and exclusivist cultural legitimacy”.

    It is known that Shridath visits and makes comments to articles publish on Norman Girvan’s website. I think his latest comments were made on August 16th in response to an article written by Girvan himself.

    There is a recording of Analee Davis on Girvan’s website speaking to the issue of raids and deportations of guyanese etc.

    Wesley Gibbons on may 28th on Norman Girvan’s website, clearly stated that ‘ethinic cleansing” was occuring in Barbados. Ramphal gave his speech on June 25th

  8. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    @anon
    Nothing has been disproved. The goal posts are still in place, but the goalie (shridath) is yet to save a goal.


  9. CARICOM is an organisation of sovereign states. Each one retaining its sovereignty as it suits them.

    It is one thing for the citizens of the CARICOM countries to want free movement of people, but within the present arrangements of CARICOM it will never happen unless CARICOM becomes one geopolitical space.

    To suggest that Barbados was/is doing something unholy within the relationship could only be self serving to those who said it.

    Further it is a very irresponsible position to hold because it refuses to recognise the imbalances in the economies and the inequalities in such matters as governance, trade, social services and even ethnic differences for which each has become characterised; both negatively and positively.

    Furthermore, when one Caribbean country could be so underpopulated and still have its citizens running from it to a densely populated island, surely could not just be unreasonable but downright unacceptable.

    If governance was a balanced matter then this would not ever happen. See how under a colonial system, freedom of movement in the anglophone Caribbean was never an issue because it was one political economic space.

    Before Barbados could be criticised for its immigration policy, all those countries that refuse to come under one monetary system and who refuse to give up their sovereignty to a Caribbean nation and a Caribbean Government ought to be seriously chastised.

    Quite simply put, if they want freedom of movement, then do the right thing.

  10. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    But Rok Analee Davis dismisses all of what you say with the following.

    “locked into nationalist crevices … and exclusivist cultural legitimacy”.

    Indeed if you read all 11 pages of the speech Shridath gave on June 25th, you may come to know him as a man that does not have any real appreciation for national borders or the soveriegnty of the individual caribbean countries.


  11. @AH
    “Analee Davis dismisses all of what you say with the following.

    “locked into nationalist crevices … and exclusivist cultural legitimacy”.

    If Annalee Davis is such a big researcher, then she should be telling us something about the keys to unlock. Simply to provide the lock without the key is very unprofessional of the locksmith.


  12. BAFBFP

    Like you becoming a distraction now. You pushing your luck.


  13. By her own admission Annalee Davis is a Videographer. She would have said so at Solidarity House at the screening of her On The Map.


  14. An unreserved and full-some apology to the Barbados Government and the citizens of Barbados is required nothing else is adequate or satisfactory.

    This matter will “never” go away until that is given.

    Let us examine the passage for context and what precedes the words “intimations of ethnic cleansing”.

    …”Our societies are caught in a downward spiral of separateness with fellow West Indians cast as outsiders”…

    He is obviously speaking of the “West Indies”, where in the West Indies? Due to recent events there is a “perception” held by the Guyanese Government” that Guyanese are seen as outsiders in Barbados.

    …”The knock on the door at night, is not within our regional culture; still less are intimations of ethnic cleansing”…

    When you tie the two together because of what precedes it, it difficult to come to any other conclusion.

    …”No Caribbean leader would countenance such departures from our norms and values”…

    This is a clever device, the person to whom he refers is not really a “Caribbean leader” or perhaps not even a “leader” at all in his estimation.

    It is a matter of context, what precedes the words “intimations of ethnic cleansing and the general overall tone of the passage; coupled with events that were taking place in Barbados over immigration at the time.

    It is nothing but an absolute disgrace.


  15. In an earlier blog: open letter to Ricky Singh. I questioned David as to why he had accorded credit to Thompson’s recent statement at his party conference with regard to those who were been critical to Barbados and its citizens.

    Here is what I said ………
    “What exactly has he (Thompson) done? Deeds and not words are what the people demand. Thompson will get credit only when he tackles head on the immigration issue. When you have an unruly guest in your home they have to be removed. Thompson knows what has to be done and must be brave. This is a defining moment for Barbados. Barbados future is been played out right now.”

    My message to Thompson is to commence the pruning immediately. For this pruning to be effective only the stump must remain in the ground. This stump should constitute only those who share a love for Barbados, who have successfully integrated within the host community and have contributed towards making Barbados a better place.

    We all know which group presents a threat to Barbados. Their numbers must be culled. If they are illegal immigrants they must be removed. The government should ensure that the law permits them to go back forty years. All cases would have to be reviewed. If they fall into the criteria as stated in paragraph three, than they should be granted a resident permit, but not given full nationality.

    Thompson should not worry about how such action would be viewed internationally. This group has established roots in every country that has had the misfortune to accept them. They do not identify with their country of residence; they are only interested in self. I can assure you that this problem is universal.

    It’s time for Thompson to show his manhood. Deeds not words.


  16. Some very fullsome commentary and phrases that will no doubt need more parsing. “My message to Thompson is to commence the pruning immediately. For this pruning to be effective only the stump must remain in the ground. This stump should constitute only those who share a love for Barbados, who have successfully integrated within the host community and have contributed towards making Barbados a better place.” This is a great notion, though ‘host’ should be clarified. Some of the lovers of Barbados are hosted abroad and have no intention of coming back to Barbados, they have said. So, are they IN or OUT?

    The door now seems opens to foreigners who meet the criteria, which will calm many nerves. I know that many of the foreigners would integrate better if they felt the welcome of this sentiment. Who would want to be cut off from the stump?

    I do not think that “It’s time for Thompson to show his manhood.” is appropriate. Lewd behaviour is already a serious social problem and I would not like to see it condoned by the head of government, in a manner of speaking.

    Good that Annalee’s credentials are clarified. She can of course talk or write outside her profession.

    Finally, if Adrian reporrted that he watched some men in a field and one threw a white ball at another with a big stick, who then ran to a white sack and slid in the sand, and heard an umpire say “Safe”, could Adrian write about “intimations of a game of baseball”? The word baseball need not appear in his description but what is going on seemed patently clear. Am I out in left field?


  17. BTW is e-mail notification on or off for this thread? If off, I wont bother with an e-mail address on comments.


  18. @ Anonymous

    You are been mischievous and are probably playing the role of been a devil’s advocate.

    I will attempt to answer some of your questions that you have posed directly or indirectly:

    “Host” = ancestors of African descent who shed their blood toiling for their masters in sunny Barbados – period. I do not distinguish between those Bajan Africans who live in or outside of Barbados. I will grudgingly admit that some will argue passionately that they are Bajans. The question is this: did their ancestors shed their blood to claim heritage of this island?

    The use of the word manhood may have been badly employed. However the symbolism is clear.

    Anonymous the world in general is hostile to those of African descent. I have lived and experienced this in the many places that I’ve either lived in or visited. We Bajans can never become complacent. For many of us it’s Barbados or bust.

    Beware of Trojan horses.


  19. X-Man, call it devil’s advocate if you like. I prefer to call it thinking things through.

    Good to get the clarification of ‘host’. Again, if Bajans do not feel that they fit, will they be able to appeal before they are stumped? It may be embarrassing later to have to try to reconstitute the population.

    What of mixed African Bajan-other Caribbean (with clear slave background), or mixed African Bajan-white European and descendants?

    If a Bajan’s ancestors only did nice work in the masters’ houses will they be included?

    So, white Bajans are definitely OUT?

    Beware of Trojan horses. Indeed. What tests will be done to establish Bajan-ness. DNA is part. But what of slave records, burial and birth records? Can these be relied upon. Will there be a database one can check?

  20. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    Sir Shridath was very clear in what he said and in what he wanted to say. By the way the entire speech is still available at NormanGirvan.info, and I have a copy of the full speech. Indeed he said “No Caribbean leader would continence such departures from our norms and values. But the very next sentence partially apportions blame for actions that apparently to him seems to be “INTIMATIONS” of ethnic cleansing. “but all must not only believe, but also act as if they believe, that we forget our oneness at our peril; whether the ‘otherness’ that displaces it is an accidental place of regional birth, or otherness of any kind.” So who is he talking too? What is he talking about? Who is acting as if they do not believe in “our oneness? If he is now to afraid to say it I will for him. He targeted the Government of Barbados and insinuated that it’s actions by way of it’s manage migration policy forgets the Caribbean oneness. For him to now suggest that he was criticizing an editorial is to at variance with the very contents of the speech he made . In his interview with David Ellis Sir Shridath suggested that we look not at his statement but at the reasons that led to the editorial. Ricky Singh in his attempted defense suggested the same. Clearly he believes it and this is probably why he cannot bring himself to apologize. We are not fools Sir Shridath, your speech was well written and well delivered there was no ambiguity then as to it’s meaning and there is none now. All you have done is with these latest comments is to dig yourself deeper into a place you do not wish to be. Those commentators who sought without success to defend Sir Shridath by suggesting a misunderstanding of the word intimations are not doing themselves any favors.

    Intimations:
    A hint; an obscure or indirect suggestion or notice; a remote or ambiguous reference; as, still less are intimations of ‘ethnic cleansing’

    ———————————————
    x-man don’t be sidetrack by that anonymous commentator.


  21. I think the symbolism of ‘manhood’ is very ambiguous, given some recent discussions on this blog and I would not like you to be cast as someone who is spreading rumours. I think that clarity dictates that you revise that remark, at least for the record, and not leave it in the hands of some sagacious lawyer types.


  22. @ Anonymous

    The time for talking is over. Deeds not words are the orders of the day.

    The clamour for action has been voiced by the vast majority of Bajans. Thompson knows what path he has to take. Yes he may be timid; but he’s certainly not a fool. The pruning will commence – soon.

    A philosopher may feel comfortable hiding behind the facade of semantics. However it is always the people, on the ground, who are the drivers of social change.

    As Brother Bob (Marley) said:
    “He who feels it; feels it most.”

    @ tall boy
    I have made my final comment to Anonymous.


  23. Brother X-MAN, where is it that “The clamour for action has been voiced by the vast majority of Bajans” has been voiced? The election results dont show such clamour. The CADRES poll showed lots of support for immigration policy but what is the clamour. Anyway, most of the commentators want to discredit Mr Wickham and his DLP commissioned poll.

    Why are you taking notice of Tall_Boy? Is he some kind of handler for you? Talk of independence? Action of dependence?

    Emancipate yourself from mental slavery…Another Marley special.


  24. @Anonymous Anonymous // August 27, 2009 at 7:48 AM
    “I think that clarity dictates that you revise that remark, at least for the record, and not leave it in the hands of some sagacious lawyer types.”

    Are you a Blog Police or Blog Investigator? I say no more. Chupese

  25. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    We have not dealt with the comments of Analee Davis in this whole thing. She was very explicit in her definitions of what SHE WAS TOLD are the actions of Immigration officers, about a room at the airport, about lack of Leadership etc.

    The opinions that are being formed of us in the other countries are to a large extent the doing of Analee Davis and George Brathwaite.

    Listen to her and Norman Girvan June 1oth.

    http://creole-chant.blogspot.com/2009/06/nationwide-radio-postcast.html


  26. You people are all mental, really sick people, and very racists. You do not want the Guyanese East Indian there, and that is a fact, and let me tell you it does not take much to push a people into ethnic cleansing, and from all appearances you were heading in that direction, so it was wise for the Guyanese newspaper to interject whatever they said about ethnic cleansing. You got caught with your pants down and your leader can hollar all he wants about hospitality and welcome of Guyanese to your island, but the fact of matter is that there is proof that Guyanese are singled out for harsh treatment there. You only see Guyana as black and Indian, and I have stopped on BWIA at your airport where your immigration thought I was smuggling myself to the Miami, pathetic you to think that. Well you know what Guyana is not only black and Indians there are others too, and I guess you were thrown for a loop silly people of Barbados. Leave Sir Shridath alone, and who cares about the stupid West Indies and its small minded citzens, go to hell we are Guyanese and South American, and Ruel you are tratior and a racist, you go to hell too.


  27. Sapadillo, you are making me sob. When Adrian tells people what to do no one calls him the blog police or anything like that? When he writes “we must find out…” and goes off to delve where delvers go, I do not hear “Mr. Hinds, why don’t you just mind your business.” When he says to the administrator that he will be umpire of a post no one objects.

    It may be a conclusion that BU is really Big Up for Adrian. In fact, I did a good read over the past week and Adrian clearly gives more instructions to any and everyone one than anyone even David.

    Even when Adie mentions ‘weening off” (sic) BU and looking for a place to restart, David does not write “Oh no, Adrian, don’t go” What does that tell you? One conclusion is that David does not give a hootie. Or that Adrian is more driver than passenger.

    So, Sapa, what gives? Only people who dont think cannot figure things out.


  28. We are clearly missing the point when we continue to focus on Ramphal, Singh, etc. While we are rampaging at this level, ordinary Guyanese are suffering and real bad.

    What we need to do is help our Guyanese brothers and sisters and focus on the wrongs, the atrocities and the corruption going on in Guyana, starting from the office of the President. I do not believe for one moment that the Guyanese diaspora prefer to be away from Guyana. They have lost their home.

    We should therefore stage massive protests against the Government of Guyana from right here so that Guyanese citizens can freely protest without being intimidated by Guyana’s police and secret squads, etc.

    This would effectively turn the attention to where it wants turning and ease the pressure off Barbados’ immigration policy, but most important is for Guyanese to feel safe returning home rather than the fear that is driving them out.

    We should then in turn encourage other Guyanese in other Caribbean islands and wherever they are to mount protests as well. Place the pressure where it is supposed to be. Even lobby for the removal of Jagdeo as Chairman of CARICOM.

    We need to send a message to the President of Guyana that he can’t sit on a festered sore with impunity. Of course, he is so arrogant that he will probably not budge but the effort is worth it at least for Barbados and the Guyanes diaspora.

    Who knows, maybe the pressure may mount a bit further, for example lobbying for aid to be denied or for USA to pour on some pressure. Also get some help from the International activists groups like ILC, UFPJ and Chapter 19 who are launching large protest against such things as the massacre of the Palestinians, Haiti, etc. and anywhere that they are human rights abuses.

    As Barbadians and Caribbean peoples, we have to get up and seek justice, it will surely not be handed down. I am willing to come together with whomever is willing. I done know that I will end up doing all the work, but if people show they are willing I will do the work. I too old for one-man protests now.


  29. Actually, Mr .R. King, “We are clearly missing the point when we continue to focus…” is a common problem with many of these discussions. I have followed the long talking on “Psyche…”. If you look there is a lot of looking at trees and not much focusing on woods at all. Even when people are pointed to some key issues the tendency is to go ferreting around and collecting grains of sand and way “Look what we got.” Look at the sum totals of many of the discussions. Do you really see a clear bringing together of a clear picture or just lots of talking that one could say has concluded anything. It’s a real question so dont get all squiffy and rant on about being black, white, inside, outside, etc.


  30. @ROK

    You make a good point but why do you think we have been questioning the role of the Nation newspaper?

    Why do you think mash up has advised Lincoln Lewis to visit Barbados and demand air time to air his perspective on the issues?


  31. @David,

    The intention for Lincoln to visit Barbados seems to be to clear the air. When he done, he may find it even more life threatening to go back to Guyana though. So what would we do?

    Don’t get me wrong, I welcome his visit whatever the outcome, but we should use the occasion to seek justice. Let us pool some money and find a place for him to stay.

    Find two trusted people to open an account so that BU family, if inclined and the general public could just go and deposit their contributions. That would protect their anonymity.

    I would suggest Doug Skeete as one such person whom I can vouch for. We must be able to find another person.

    We can call it the “Save Guyana Fund”. Come on guys, we must be able to rally around our people and not let this divide and rule keep conquering us.


  32. @LIB
    Come out of your closet. Don’t feel embarrassed, we are loving and forgiving people. Man you losing all your exposure with this anonymous thing.

  33. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    Excellent Idea ROK. This approach will also serve to demonstrate to the region that what Analee Davis and George Brathwaite may have represented Barbados and Barbadians to be is not the case. I am in. We should continue to call on Shridath and Ricky to address the concerns that Guyanese may have against their Government.

    BTW: If LIB is welcomed back, I will leave. lol! I kinda like his new role of barking through de window like a lil loopy dog. ha ha ha lol!

  34. Johnnie Too Bad Avatar

    I reluctantly enter this discussion, because I believe that Sonny mis-spoke and is probably not big enough to apologise. Hey, sure we have a few Indo=Guyanese in our country, nothing to be afraid of.(and before Tall-boy tell you folks, yes I have a Guyanese maid to help the wife out, at decent wages too, no exploitation here)
    These folks are economic migrants in search of betterment for their families. Now which of you christians would deny them the right to feed their families.
    What our politicians and leaders ought to be doing is to find ways of solving the problem.
    The clamour for blood from some of you is nothing short of ethnic cleansing. I say if they want to come, let them come. What are a few Guyanese going to do to Barbados?


  35. sonny arrogant as ass. he mean he not apologising. he big up. bajans below he. he living comfortable in barbados and like he believe he can insult bajans and get away with it. bajans should write the government and call for him to be put out. we do not need his type here. he can go to guyana. we want rickey singh put out too. to hell with them.

  36. Johnnie Too Bad Avatar

    Sylvan don’t we tell people that we have freedom of speech and we are a democratic country, so you planning to put out everybody that don’t hold your views. Let the man talk he talk do. He and Rickey don’t care, it is the ordinary Guyanese that suffering and looking for work. (I plan to open an agency supplying Guyanese labour to Bajans)

  37. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    Slyvan:
    Shridath said, whether he is in Trinidad, Guyana, Jamaica, or Barbados, he is in his West Indian Home. So how are you going to put de man out of his home? Shridath has no uses for national borders. Which means he does not believe in the revise treaty of chaguaramous, in its entirety.


  38. X-Man I totally agreed with your comments that no special praises should be heaped on Prime Minister David Thompson until definitive action is taken to rid this country of all illegals especially the Indo-Guyanese scums.

    The Prime Minister has only issued idle threats and nothing else.The Prime Minister must come out and publicly indentify the person or persons he had meant when he made his statement about certain individuals bad-mouthing Barbados.If it is stinking Sir Shridath Ramphal,musty Norman Faria or the journalistic whore Rickey Singh come out & say so.Be a man.Those three Indian muskateers were not afraid to mention the name Barbados when they were maligning Barbados.
    Musty Norman Faria,stinking Sir Shridath Ramphal & the journalistic whore Rickey Singh who are all residents of Barbados should be given their walking papers.Whatever status those three scoundrels have in Barbados should be revoked with immediate effect.The likes of those three Indo-Guyanese human waste & degenerates along with all the rest of the stinking Indo-Guyanese must be given their walking papers out of Barbados.

    Talk done we want action.All musty Indo-Guyanese must leave Barbados now.

  39. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    Negroman, Thompson’s comments although not mentioning names was nevertheless clear on who he meant.


  40. If Tom was P.M., those comments about Barbados would not have been made. Talk done!


  41. @AH
    You don’t recognise sarcasm when you see it? I am sure it would hurt he to use that handle here again. He got too much pride and he shamed faced.

    As for you, you ain’t going nowhere. You at home here while you out in the cold, so I don’t mind you. BFP ain’t got nothing to offer you but suppression and discrimination… If you left BU you would sit down and cry whole day for a year; 24/7/365.

  42. Johnnie Too Bad Avatar

    Negroman, you bitter, you spitting much blood, why the personal attacks. As professionals, are they not entitled to live and work in any of the member states. That is what freedom of movement, labour and capitaL is all about. Ask your guru Tall-boy, I am sure he will enlighten you about the harmonisation of the CSME. Whats with the name calling. David Thompson much smarter than wunna fools, how he gine borrow money internationally if he planning to carry out a policy of ethnic cleansing?

  43. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    So why, I asked, was he questioned by a journalist in Georgetown during last month’s 30th Caricom Summit, about his reference to “intimations” (the operative word) of “ethnic cleansing”?

    Ramphal replied by pointing to the Nation’s editorial of June 17, in which was located a surprised warning against “a disturbance of the existing equilibrium among races, a hallmark of Barbadian life”.

    Perhaps, said Ramphal, rather than “becoming very emotional and judgemental” about his reference to “intimations of ethnic cleansing”, those really interested may wish to inquire of the Nation what led to its editorial comment about “a disturbance of the existing equilibrium among races in Barbados”.
    ————————————————
    where did Shridath get his “intimations of ethnic cleansing”? We know that Analee Davis, Norman Girvan (Shridath very good friend) and two Jamaican radio personalities agreed on what Analee was TOLD, amounted to “Gestapo like” tactics. We know that Ricky Singh made mention of “Apartheid like” and we know that Wesley Gibbons president of the Association of Caribbean Media Workers clearly refered to “ethnic cleansing in Barbados”. Is it really a mystery where Shridath got it from? nah!

  44. Johnnie Too Bad Avatar

    Adrian, Sir Sonny mis-spoke. We all make mistakes sometimes. For that you and Negroman want top send him packing. Leave the man alone, you have laboured that point enough.

  45. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    ROK // August 27, 2009 at 12:23 PM

    @AH
    You don’t recognise sarcasm when you see it? I am sure it would hurt he to use that handle here again. He got too much pride and he shamed faced.

    As for you, you ain’t going nowhere. You at home here while you out in the cold, so I don’t mind you. BFP ain’t got nothing to offer you but suppression and discrimination… If you left BU you would sit down and cry whole day for a year; 24/7/365.
    ————————————————-
    But I did. I responded as such to dare him, poke fun at him, redicule him and give him more false fodder for his diatribe that I am leaving to go somewhere.

  46. Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy Avatar
    Adrian Hinds aka Tall_Boy

    CARICOM’s DREAM CAN BE A NIGHTMARE FOR SMALLER COUNTRIES

    By G. A. Dwyer Astaphan

    http://www.sknvibes.com/Commentary/Index.cfm/383

    There seems to come a time in the affairs of every developing country when its citizens start to develop a sense of deep concern and insecurity with regard to foreigners coming in and taking up jobs and doing business.

    At least, that has been the Caribbean experience in modern times.

    We know that the history of the Caribbean is punctuated by migration.

    And we are essentially a region of immigrants, most of who have their roots in slavery or indenture.

    In addition to the inward migration, there has been much internal (intra-regional) migration, with workers (especially) moving from territories of lesser, to territories of greater, opportunity.

    This movement of workers has served, not only to assist with manpower resources and economic development in the already better-performing territories, but also to relieve the social, economic and political pressure in the under-performing home territories of the immigrants.

    Major regional recipients of migrants over the past 100 years or so have been Panama, Cuba, and the Dominican Republic ( earlier on), and Trinidad, Puerto Rico, the USVI, the BVI, St. Maarten, Anguilla, Antigua, Barbados, St. Lucia, St.Kitts & Nevis and the Cayman Islands (more latterly).

    And, of course, over the past 60 years or so, there has also been a mass exodus to the United Kingdom, France, Holland, the USA and Canada, in search of a better life.

    However, over the years, as it became more difficult for Caribbean people to migrate to Europe, North America and the US and UK Virgin Islands (and St. Maarten seems to be tightening up too), greater pressure has been exerted on the failing Caribbean economies to stay afloat and avert disaster and on the better-performing Caribbean economies to receive migrants from their under-performing counterparts.

    And let us not forget the relatively recent matter of the large number of deportees from the USA, a number which is likely to increase under President Obama.

    We should note that the larger their number, the more difficult it is going to be for them to assimilate into societies of which they know little. So there will be an increased risk of them engaging in criminal activity, thus exacerbating an already awful crime situation in those countries. This will only further drive frightened law-abiding citizens to find an exit route, and it will create even more pressure on the better performing Caribbean territories.

    In fact, this pressure has already become institutionalized within the framework of the CARICOM arrangements which, inter alia, are intent upon merging all of the economies into a single one that allows free movement of capital and labour.

    Interestingly, however, as I write this piece I am unable to recall any CARICOM member state having a referendum for its people to decide upon these matters of free movement. Maybe it has happened, but right now I cannot recall it.

    Instead, what has happened is that leaders and some experts have been declaring that their proposed single economic space with free movement of capital and labour is the only salvation for the region.

    Especially leaders of countries which, because of their own chronic under-performance, rely on their citizens’ ability to migrate in order to help avert further instability and chaos at home.

    But here is a question.

    If the people could enjoy better economic, social and political circumstances at home, wouldn’t less of them want to migrate? After all, home is home!

    So would it not be better for all concerned if, in addition to better leadership coming from governments and other stakeholder groups in countries like Haiti, The Dominican Republic, Jamaica and Guyana, there could be a special, sensible and compassionate effort by the region, by the various international institutions and by the G-8 countries to transform and stabilize those four larger Caribbean nations instead of emptying them of their populations which they would desperately need in order to recover, grow and stabilize?

    Would it not be fairer if smaller, better governed and better performing, but also very fragile and vulnerable countries such as Antigua & Barbuda, Barbados, St. Lucia and St.Kitts & Nevis were not put under all of this pressure of having to take up burdens on their physical and social infrastructures, created in no small measure by mismanagement in, and in relation to, the larger countries of the region?

    How can free movement of capital and labour be beneficial to these smaller islands in the prevailing conditions of the region?

    Is it not better to be supportive of movement, but only on a managed basis, as Barbados’ Prime Minister, David Thompson, is advocating?

    Already Antiguans, St. Lucians, and Kittitians and Nevisians, like Barbadians, are developing anger and resentment over their perception that jobs and other opportunities in the lands of their birth are being taken away from them by foreigners.

    Already they are saying that politicians, having lost the goodwill of many citizens, are courting CARICOM immigrants and using them, where their numbers are critical (and it does not take a lot in a small place), in order to get, or to hold on to, power.

    Already many people in these smaller islands have begun to feel cheated.

    For example, Kittitians are very upset at the thought of themselves, their relatives or friends, being laid off from their jobs, or even unable to get jobs, while they see foreigners, both from CARICOM countries and beyond, ‘making a bread’ here in St.Kitts doing the same or similar jobs.

    They are fuming mad when they see foreigners who are studying at universities here in St.Kitts holding down jobs, and getting away with, with or without work permits, while they, the locals, go unemployed.

    And speaking of foreign students, happy as we all are to have them, and we want more of them to come, many, many homeowners who depend on the rents from these students to maintain their mortgages are expressing deep concern over the fact that local hotels at Frigate Bay have opened up their rooms to students on long-term rentals, thereby depriving the homeowners of critical rental income.

    The homeowners understand the economic crunch, and they want the hotels to remain open, but they feel exposed and vulnerable. And they want explanations and assurances. They feel that without guidance, they could lose their homes, and a crisis could develop.

    But let me go back to the CARICOM thing.

    While free movement of labour is of concern, so too is the matter of free movement of capital, and what is referred to as “rights of settlement” whereby a business from any country can essentially set up shop in any other country, and do so on an equal footing with a local company.

    This could be a formula for death and destruction for enterprises in the smaller islands, especially smaller enterprises, because not only will they be unable to compete in their own countries, but they feel that they cannot, and will not, get a fair shot at the market in Trinidad, Jamaica and so on.

    CARICOM’s dream is at risk of turning turn into a nightmare for the smaller countries, and on its present path, it can create a level playing field, yes, but a level playing field of losers, bringing down surging, smaller countries to the level of the rest.

    The people and the businesses in the smaller Caribbean territories are under a lot of pressure. And it seems that they cannot take much more.

    And quite apart from CARICOM, we see local businesses in some of these small countries already acing collapse, as developers and others from outside of the region move in and crowd them out of a living.

    Let us look, for example, at the heavy equipment business in St. Kitts.

    At least one provider has a ‘for sale’ sign on some of his equipment.

    He and his colleagues are being put to a disadvantage, because whereas they have to pay duty on their equipment and spare parts, the developers do not. This inequity renders our locals uncompetitive, and such an arrangement is simply untenable, especially in a man’s own country.

    The developers bring in their equipment, they retool when necessary( duty free, of course),and they also bring in operators, which further deprives local operators from getting work and it also discourages young locals from becoming operators.

    So what ought to be a situation of growth opportunity for locals with these developments is turning out to be quite the opposite, as locals are blocked out of the action, whether as contractors, (or sub-contractors) or as operators, mechanics, etc.

    It is also reported that developers sometimes bring in somewhat defective equipment, upgrade it with duty free parts, and after some use, send it back home (where duty free concessions are not available) in an improved condition and with a higher value.

    It seems to be that the prudent and fair thing for Government to do is to revisit its policy and also the arrangements governing all present projects which utilize heavy equipment, in order to give our local businesses a chance to stay afloat, and in order to keep the sector strong and to maximize economic and social local value added from these projects.

    The developers would pay less, and the locals would earn, and learn, more.

    Indeed, as a general principle, when developers engage our government in talks, they should always be told that certain aspects of the works must be reserved for locals.

    In my opinion, and I am not xenophobic or in any way bigoted, there are too many businesses being conducted by foreigners that can and should be reserved for locals.

    As a proud, little developing country, we have to ensure that our people, who are our major investment and our major hope, are empowered in the process of designing and building the new economy.

    If it is not to be that way, then why are we wasting time educating and nurturing our children?

    Because they will not get their fair chance at jobs and as entrepreneurs in the land of their birth.

    The people of this country are now at the stage where they are deeply concerned about these things. And that is not a good thing. Positive action is required.

    Until Next Time, Plenty Peace.


  47. Johnnie Too Bad // August 27, 2009 at 11:43 AM

    Sylvan don’t we tell people that we have freedom of speech and we are a democratic country,
    ****************************************
    JtB,
    …yes we do tell people that. However if we intend to be able to continue saying that, then we must take CAREFUL steps to PROTECT that freedom and democracy.

    Many of us still believe in fairy tales – where everyone lives happily afterwards…
    The REALITY of our world, however, is the laws of the JUNGLE. Where goody-two-shoes- like you end up as nothing but meals for the wolves of this world.

    If we in Barbados built our house in the way that WE LIKE…

    If we in Barbados have opened our doors to all and sundry to visit, study our ways, be part of our world….

    …Are you and others like you now calling on us to allow these invited guest (whose own houses were burnt down by their own tactics) to now come here and impose their failed tactics on us?….

    What let what man talk what talk what!??

    If we were REALLY smart we would declare a SERIOUS policy of cleansing!! – maybe not ethnic, but certainly CULTURAL ….

    Seriously…
    What result do you expect when a happy flock of sheep open their welcome gates to a bunch of rabid wolves…? …and then invite these wolves to dictate the new rules…..

    …Man hush yuh mouth do…. and listen to Negroman and sylvan…


  48. @ROK
    A good suggestion but needs to be supported by the Guyana community. It would validate the notion of that group being labeled economic refugees.

  49. Johnnie Too Bad Avatar

    Good try Adrian, I greet you with one word, harmonisation of wages, prices, standards etc.
    Our leaders took some bold steps towards CSME without taking the people with them. Few of our politicians understood what was at stake and so the chance was lost.
    Rightly, the people did not clamour for referenda to decide how we proceed with the CSME.
    It was and is obvious that people from Guyana, Jamaica, Haiti and others would relocate if they could to a higher wage economy and so it is their right to do.
    Where the whole has been underscored is that lack of vision and creative thinking has brought this calamity upon us.
    Lack of proper debate, paucity of genuine information, weak leaders have all come together to derail our progress. It is time regional leaders along with the captains of industry and commerce begin a process of internal generation of new jobs and stop waiting on Mr.Foreigner to invest in our countries. Since our leaders have no interest in the solution of our problems, it does not take much to see that they are in themselves the major obstacles to our progress.

  50. Johnnie Too Bad Avatar

    Bush Tea , the only rabid wolves I see are Negroman, Tall-boy et al who want to send the few Guyanese packing, You also likened us bajan to sheep, figuratively speaking, but hey, in a democratic country just as you have the right to speak so should I. I am no goody six shoes but I am a man of compassion, care and consideration for other human beings.
    I once had a great grandmother born into slavery whose favourite clamour was, when you sell all you have you will in turn need to buy all you want. (I translated in modern day english, she spoke in a broken Ashanti dialect).
    Today it is Guyanese, what if the tables turn in the next 20 years and we are forced to export some of our people to Guyana?

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending