image
New England Journal of Medicine states there is "good reason to be cautious." – Click on Image

According to the Barbados Government Website the incidence of cervical cancer in the Caribbean is increasing at a rate of 33 new cases annually. It seems that this is a very unflattering statistic which is four or five times higher than that of North America. Last year Dr Eltora Bennett, an obstetrician and gynaecologist reported that the cases of cervical cancer were not declining. She urged the women to engage in early screening, what is commonly referred to as the getting a ‘pap smear’ to protect against cervical cancer.

Bennett explained that despite the easy access to pap smears “we have been seeing about 30 cases of cancer of the cervix per year and that has been constant now” for more than a decade. Cancer of the cervix is a sexually transmitted disease linked to the human papilloma virus (HPV) but early detection through screening can lead to effective treatment. HPV can infect the genital area of men and women, including the skin of the penis, the area outside the vagina in women or the rectum. The incidence of the disease is unacceptably high in Barbados and that’s a fact, she said.

Source: Nation Newspaper

Dr. Bennett went on to explain in the October 2007 Nation Newspaper report that Barbados was moving ahead with the introduction of the Merck Pharmaceutical vaccine Gardisil. According to Dr. Bennet “arcisil prevents the development of the precursors to cervical cancer. In other words, it prevents women from developing cervical cancer. It immunises her against the human papiloma virus,BU checked with a few local pharmacies and verified that the vaccine Gardasil is currently not available – Please note the spelling of the vaccine by the Nation Newspaper is incorrect!

In light of the above we found a recent story submitted by BU family member Carson Cadogan worthy of highlight. We hope the BU family will investigate and share feedback because the scourge of cervical cancer must be tackled through education. The substance of the story which was published in the prestigious New England Journal suggest the following:

  • First, Gardasil’s long-term effectiveness is unclear. Because cervical cancer takes years to develop, critics say the current information is insufficient to determine whether Gardasil works. Bottom of Form “The overall effect of the vaccines on cervical cancer remains unknown,” Dr. Carolyn J. Haug, the Journal of Norwegian Medical Association’s editor, wrote in the New England Journal editorial. “The real impact of HPV vaccination on cervical cancer will not be observable for decades.”
  • Gardasil is also expensive, costing about $400 to $1,000 for the necessary three doses of the vaccine. Studies have not proven how long the immunity will last and whether or not additional shots will be needed, which would raise the cost even higher.
  • And it’s not a slam dunk. The vaccine only protects against some of the viruses that cause cervical cancer, so women still need regular pap.

Source: ABC News

The BU family has discussed a similar issue before regarding how unsuspecting patients can protect themselves from less than state of the art drugs. Is the vaccine Gardasil another one of those drugs which flatters to deceive?

Related Link

Barbadians Should Be Vigilant When Filling Prescription Drugs

121 responses to “Beware Of Cervical Cancer Vaccine Gardasil!”


  1. In 1978 Tagemet came on the market for the treatment of ulcers etc. It was supposed to put the surgeons out of business. 30 years since it has not! Nor has the drugs that have superceeeded it despite the fact that all of these drugs act at known receptor sites and have been designed scientifically.

    I remember when Merck launced finasteride (Proscar) in 1990 for the treatment of prostatic hyperplasia/hypertrophy. The urologist present remarked openly that this drug would put him out of business. Does Proscar work YES and so does Saw Pametto which has the same mechanism of action. But has these agents put the doctors out of business in the treatment of the indications for which they were designed.

    Merk is here again! It has launched its wonder vaccine that is supposed to revolutionize the treatment of cervical cancer.

    A reasonable question in the light of history is “But will it?’


  2. Oh I forgot Vytorin………another product my Merc.

    Certainly this drug reduced cholesterol levels as it was designed to do, but it did not achieve the synergistic effect that it was expected to, nor has it had the effect on reducin plaque.

    Merck again! I wonder why?


  3. All this talk about medical illiterates and trying to put down people who raise concerns is counter-productive.
    This is not a medical site. People are responding to something that affects them and their children.
    Sometimes the people who have been to university put down the ones who have not, yet we often hear of doctors telling patients not to worry about something, they are imagining the symptoms, and when the patient pursues it, there is a serious problem.
    In the end as memries said above doctors, like lawyers practice. Sometimes practice makes perfect. Sometimes drugs are fasttracked on the market and then withdrawn. Sometimes they go through all the tests and are withdrawn.
    If you listen to some of the ads on t.v.


  4. Sorry, I continue:-
    Some of the ads make you wonder which is worst.
    The symptoms you are already suffering or the possible side effects of the treatment.


  5. @Kay

    Re side effects of drugs.

    You have a good point. There are potential and actual side effects to ALL drugs.

    The Pharmaceutical industry does try to eliminate side effects. That is why we have famotidine and ranitide as these were developed to counteract some of the side effects of the prototype in their class- Cimetidine (Tagamet).

    If we take for instance a look at the older antihistamines you will find that they have a wide range of side effects because they actually interact with several types of receptors besides H1 recptors. The newer antihistamines like loratadine tend to interact with fewer receptors than the old antihistamines.

    Sensible practitioners think of all these things when prescibing drugs for optimim effect.

    If a patient has a liver disease , the doctor ought to chose a drug that acts at the same receptor site, but one whose pharmaocokinetics are such that the drug is not elimiated by the liver; or else the drug will accumulate in the body.


  6. @ Kay
    This is not a medical site. But some serious medicine has been taught on this forum by GP this year.

    Now other medics want to give of their time to try to educate the public.

    We / I for one am not sure that folk are all responding to something that affects them and their children or raising concerns. They are a lot of know it alls on this particular thread who know nothing about medicine, and do not understand the significance of the stuff that they find on Google.

    Any one can come in here and cut and pace stuff that they find on Google, which they do not understand, or can not defend by experience or by their knowledge.

    Also there is a lot of unnecessary emotion exhibited by medical illiterates when it comes to medical issues

    Re Sometimes the people who have been to university put down the ones who have not, yet we often hear of doctors telling patients not to worry about something, they are imagining the symptoms, and when the patient pursues it, there is a serious problem.

    So what does this mean? That the doctor was wrong initially? How can a doctor make a diagnosis if a disease has not reached the state where it becomes diagnosable?

    You think we have bad doctors in Barbados? What about the USA where one case I saw in a documentary that took the doctors 50 years to diagnose. I had the diagnosis the first time the patient gave the history.


  7. Don’t forget the stories about patients that have the healthy limb amputated.
    There are good and bad doctors everywhere you go. The same goes for every profession.
    But not everyone has a doctor at home to look after their care, people need to learn about their disease and how to manage it. Diabetes is a very good example of this. And sometimes what works for one person does not help another.


  8. The condenscending behavior of many of the bloggers with medical experience is quite nauseating.That is why Negroman hardly visits a doctor.If not for my company sending me for a yearly examination I will not go to a doctor.
    I try to preserve my health by doing the correct things.No doctor or person who believes that I am inferior to them because I did not visit a university would never never get my hard earn money.
    many doctors using us as guinea pigs to carry out experiments .


  9. Negroman, you are a smart man.


  10. @ROK

    Roger that!

  11. Computer Analyst Avatar
    Computer Analyst

    4 names here posing at doctors – Georgie, Boobie, et al

    4 different people? I have discovered not


  12. […] News » News News Beware Of Cervical Cancer Vaccine Gardasil!2008-08-29 04:38:03Government Website the Caribbean is four or five times higher than … 33 new […]


  13. […] Straps & Protectors News » News News Beware Of Cervical Cancer Vaccine Gardasil!2008-08-29 16:47:23Government Website the Caribbean is increasing at a very unflattering statistic […]


  14. Here is an item that was on the CBC (Canada) news this evening. Please note this is an FYI

    http://www.cbc.ca/health/story/2008/08/29/hpv-vaccine.html


  15. […] BU family had a robust but interesting debate last month on the blog we titled Beware Of Cervical Cancer Vaccine Gardasil! Coming from the discussion a BU family member was driven to the point to question the design of the […]


  16. […] may give their children to build their immune system. We are aware that BU family member ROK has challenged how our society meekly receives […]


  17. Having read the NEJM article, no where in it does it even suggest that the vaccine is “unsafe”. What it debates is if it is effective. More specifically, it debates whether it is effective in large scale public health scenarios.

    All the discussion here about “side effects, dangers etc.”are basically off point in discussing this article.


  18. The Lead Vaccine Developer Comes Clean So She Can “Sleep At Night”: Gardasil and Cervarix Don’t Work, Are Dangerous, and Weren’t Tested
    Author: Sarah Cain LifeWise
    Dr. Diane Harper was the lead researcher in the development of the human papilloma virus vaccines, Gardasil and Cervarix. She is the latest to come forward and question the safety and effectiveness of these vaccines. She made the surprising announcement at the 4th International Public Conference on Vaccination, which took place in Reston, Virginia on Oct. 2nd through 4th, 2009. Her speech was supposed to promote the Gardasil and Cervarix vaccines, but she instead turned on her corporate bosses in a very public way. When questioned about the presentation, audience members remarked that they came away feeling that the vaccines should not be used.
    http://southweb.org/lifewise/the-lead-vaccine-developer-comes-clean-so-she-can-sleep-at-night-gardasil-and-cervarix-dont-work-are-dangerous-and-werent-tested/


  19. Hmm is anyone else experiencing problems with the images on this
    blog loading? I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s
    the blog. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.


  20. Hello there, I discovered your website by the use of Google while searching for
    a related subject, your web site came up, it
    seems good. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
    Hello there, simply was alert to your weblog thru Google,
    and located that it’s truly informative. I am going to be careful for brussels.

    I will be grateful in case you continue this in future.
    Lots of people shall be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!


  21. Hi just wanted to give you a quick heads up and let you know a few of the pictures
    aren’t loading correctly. I’m not sure why but I
    think its a linking issue. I’ve tried it in two different browsers and both show the same outcome.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading