Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

The blogmaster found the comment posted by Critical Analyzer interesting even if provocative. What we can agree is that pension form in the public service- including for members of parliament – must be given a priority. The issue is compounded with the state of the National Insurance Fund that we are left to speculate.

Pension Reform as the world tries to do it now is only kicking the can down the road with the warmed over soup gimmicks of every few years increasing the retirement age, changing pension formulas and raising contributions rates while government borrowing from the pension funds for their projects.

Our pension reform needs to completely break the mold

1) For every person currently 50 years or less, change their pension age back tot 65 and have NIS pay an across the board universal basic pension (UBP) calculated based on the cost to cover a one bedroom rental, utilities and food for a single pensioner living alone. Anyone wanting more pension at retirement should seek private pension plans and other investment opportunities during their working years if they desire a higher standard of living.

2) Persons 51 and older would remain under the current arrangements with any shortfalls for the year covered by an unfunded pensions tax. This pension tax would eventually reduce and go away as the numbers under the old arrangement die out.

3) Since healthcare is the biggest money problem for pensioners, work on improving the quality and turnaround time for our taxpayer funded healthcare while bending healthcare costs down through novel approaches e.g. a requirement for medical license renewal could be a minimum amount of pro bono work at government medical facilities or referrals for free outpatient surgical procedures.

Critical Analyzer

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

177 responses to “Pension Reform for Public Officer a Priority (including Members of Parliament a Priority)”

  1. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David BU

    Before we abolish any social system we should try to understand that system first. I make bold to say that the recommendations and perceived problems have no bases on facts. You and the promoters of reform are making assumptions that have no contact with reality.
    Secondly the NIS pensions are based on incomes upto a level whether one is employed in the Public or Private sectors. Both these sectors ought to have additional pension plans to make the pensioners income livable. The suggestions you upload are more horrendous.


  2. Forty years is too long. It should be set at 35 and those who want to continue working beyond that length of service should be allowed to. Those who want to retire before 35 should be given an allowance based on their contributions.

  3. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ Damse-Bajans
    That is the current system basically. It is not welfare it is an insured scheme. The Employee and Employers contribute an actuarially computed weekly sum.

  4. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    Has Central Government religiously remit to the NIB the contributions collected from employees and their portion as employers? Are the surplus funds of NIB been prudently invested and the returns and other revenues collected?

  5. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David BU

    Obviously you are not a politician nor a member of Parliament. Why are you so over-concerned about the earnings and pension emoluments of the Politicians. Their professions based on their training could earn them multiples of what you appear to be begrudging them. They provide a public service. This kind of rant will beget more poor rakey legislators. Barbados deserves better,do you not think?


  6. Public workers should be given 5 years notice of proposed changes to mandatory retirement age.

  7. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David BU

    I have had enough of this.

  8. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    .Hants
    How does that benefit the beneficiaries of the scheme.?

  9. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    After reading @VC comment, I was forced to ask myself what are ‘the facts’. There seem to be 3 issues.
    A) Public Employee Pensions
    These are currently UNFUNDED. Neither the employee nor their employer (GoB) have contributed financially to the pension. So annually, out of GoB Revenue (a.k.a the Consolidated Fund) some $450M (+/-) goes to pay these pensions.
    B) NIS. This covers more than just pensions? Without any kind of formal report beyond the current investment of the various funds, we ‘believe’ it is currently underfunded, and there is a proposal to transition to a SOE.
    Other ‘facts’ are largely guesstimates.
    C) Health Care. This is a larger issue than the QEH, the primary hospital. Yet, we have been told the intent is to transition this entity to an ‘independent trust’ (whatever that is).

    So what @CA seems correct about, is we are kicking tot. Modifying public employee pensions by changing eligibility does not address funding, only how much is owed in any given year. Transitioning the NIS and QEH without specifics, we might “guess” is a similar temporary cash flow adjusting tactic, but may not address funding.

    Prior to the last election, I made the crazy suggestion of a ‘cash grab’. This has only been partially manifested, by the Pandemic Levy. We’ll see similar again.

  10. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ NO at 11 :07 AM
    Is it really true to say that under the previous system where the pensions of Public servants were paid from the Consolidated Fund meant that they were not funded. ? Is it true to say that the Public sector employees do not contribute to the NIF?” How different is that from the NIS where current contributors funds finance current pension benefits? It is not kicking the can down the road . It is a national Sou Sou. Plain and simple.

  11. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    The NIS gets into trouble when contributors do not pay their fair share and employers of every ilk do not deposit their contributions and those of their employees. Bottom line ,persons are not enforcing the rules and laws.
    Add to that ?failure to pay rents on properties owned by the National Insurance Scheme.
    changing the Governance structure is not the solution. It is the actual governing that needs tweaking. Right now they maybe twerking. Lol !!.


  12. Finally, the pension costs will be reduced as our many lazy civil servants will finally get less money! I remind you once again that Tron was the mastermind here as well. For years, and especially since March 2020, I have been calling for massive pension cuts and the lowering of actual wages.

    I am therefore pleased that our honourable government is finally taking up my sensible proposals on pensions. However, our government should still work on a plan to reduce civil service salaries. After all, since 1966, civil servants have been living at the expense of our honourable, hard-working minority of businessmen.

  13. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    @VC
    I ‘believe’ the initial intent was the GoB would ‘put aside annually’ monies for pensions. This never happened. Sooo, the GoB knew they had to fund these monies, the employees were never required to contribute. So what is accurate is to say the public pension monies were never segregated and invested. Consequently, it takes a larger chunk of the CF each year.
    I hope I didn’t say that public employees do not contribute and participate in NIF.
    You highlighted two (contribution failure, revenue collection failure) causes of the NIS problems. There are others, like any other entity.
    And you are correct, the structure is irrelevant, if basic governance rules are ignored. But we only like to talk about accountability? We get the cold foot when it comes to enforcement?
    In addition to all the Bonds they previously had, the NIS now has a stash of Series J. Those because various public bodies failed to remit monies to the NIS. (Not saying some private entities are not similarly guilty). Do we know of anyone who has been held accountable and how? (let’s avoid the 61-0).


  14. Of course, our Supreme Leader and her honourable ministers must be exempt from any pension cut. They perform superhuman work every day in the service of the state and the party, while the civil service is in permanent sleep.

  15. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    NO
    There are private corporations that pay pensioners out of current income. Why should it be anathema for the Go B to pay its former employees from the Consolidated Fund.?

  16. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    Please note GoB has in the past paid pensions from the Consolidated Fund. It is more secure. Many professional persons take Public Sector jobs at 75 % lower salaries than they can make in the Private Sector as a trade off. Private sector firms in our history have folded along with former employees pensions.

  17. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ NO
    In the annals of social security schemes. Governments have raided these schemes. Barbados scheme was used as a model of one of the best managed Social Security firms in the Western Hemisphere. So we are back to management and need to elicit what is the cause of our pending decline into inefficiency and implementation deficit.


  18. @Vincent

    All the blogmaster seeks to do is bring awareness to a vexing issue, one that has become an increasing burden on the state re: taxpayers.


  19. @Dame

    Given the state of public finances the defined benefit officers have been accustomed is unsustainable.


  20. @Vincent

    Is the pension fund currently in place managed by who? (Trustees).

    Is there a segregated fund?


  21. @Vincent

    What do you mean why the blogmaster a s concerned? Shouldn’t you be? Are you concerned how tax dollars are spent? Have we not had several actuarial reports addressing NIS. What about at the SOEs many who have not satisfied Auditor General audits?


  22. @Vincent

    The NIS also has encountered challenges with how funds have been invested non performing assets.


  23. It would be rather enlightening to hear our ‘MIA’ friend from London making a renewed contribution to the dire state of pension arrangements in Barbados.

    Hal A had made, over time, some rather interesting recommendations on this very topic.

    Please Mister A. from the Back Ivy, if your logged on, why can’t you come forward and do an SOS for poor Bim and her fast ‘greying’ population including the implementation of (y)our adopted country’s ‘Workplace Pension Scheme’ system.


  24. Miller I never miss the water till the well ran dry
    Hal is a reservoir of knowledge and information
    His input on this subject I missing
    I also would have like to hear his response

  25. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David Bu

    Acturial reports are the norm for insurance companies and pension funds.I am not aware that NiS ever had adverse Actuarial reports. The reports assess the sustainability of the fund as it relates to demographic change s in its contributors and beneficiaries.
    As far as I know NIS responds positively and timely to these concerns.
    Why do you expect the investment portfolio of NIS to perform better than the Financial Market world wide? Did it not suffer from the debt restructuring exercise of GoB?
    I am concerned about the performance of NIS. I receive an NIS pension.But do not intend to panic when I am aware of the difficulties and the sourcse of the difficulties it has experience over the last 10 years. I know better.

  26. Critical Analyzer Avatar
    Critical Analyzer

    @Vincent Codrington March 18, 2022 8:27 PM

    NIS used to be sitting good with our money being invested properly by people of your generation now receiving their well deserved pensions.

    Our NIS now has the same problem all Social Security systems have in every country the world over has sooner or later because of politicians. The politicians cannot keep their grubby hands off the investment funds flush with our money. The temptation is to great to use the loopholes they purposely put in when the social security systems were setup to use our money when times get hard and give us an IOU called a government bond.

    Have you ever heard the saying a government can easily pay its debts because they can simply increase taxes to raise the money they need as opposed to us or businesses that must work for the money to pay our debts and loans.

  27. Critical Analyzer Avatar
    Critical Analyzer

    @Vincent Codrington

    You might have missed Caswell’s Brasstacks contribution today on government pensions but he stated the government pensions the government claimed were unfunded where indeed funded by pensionable government workers being paid 20 or 25% less (can’t recall which one it was) with the understanding that that money was going to their pension.

    The problem is government never setup a separate fund to pay those funds into and they did it from the consolidated fund. Does that sound familiar to you? it is the same thing that happened to the BWA mains repair and replacement fund when it got diverted to the Consolidated Fund.

    Politicians love kicking the can down the road until it is not their problem all the while making sure they are secure if the fecal matter hits the spinning air circulation device in the ceiling.

  28. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    CA at 9:06 PM
    Are the GoB pensioners receiving their pensions every month on time? How does setting up a separate fund improve on the current arrangement? “Kicking the can down the road’ means leaving a debt for future generations to repay. The pensioners are being paid here and now. Yes. They are being paid from the Consolidated Fund from which all GoB pensioners were paid for over a century. In what way does it create a crisis now? Is this another obligation that we decide to walk away from? Who is going to payback the pensioners their 20 to 25 % cut in salaries because of a promise to pay them a pension after retirement? Pensions is a pay as you go scheme. Workers pay the pensions of pensioners. In this particular case the taxpayers.

  29. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ CA
    Pensions are not paid from the returns of investments in a portfolio. The income flows would be inadequate. It is the inflows from contributors that pay beneficiaries. The surplus , if any, is then invested in very risky assets.

  30. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ CA at 8:52. PM.
    I am sorry I missed this intervention. I agree with the points you made there in. The contributors to the NIS and the beneficiaries have to resist any attempt to misuse the NIS funds

  31. Critical Analyzer Avatar
    Critical Analyzer

    @Vincent Codrington March 18, 2022 9:50 PM

    As I said earlier, you have nothing to worry about with your pension as the fund is not likely to suffer a catastrophic collapse while you live but I am under 50 and on the current trajectory, it is likely to collapse under me before or during my retirement if I live that long.

    Funds geared for pensions are supposed to be segregated from other funds and not invested in risky business investments without being able to recoup a significant portion of their investment if it fails.

    I am sure you don’t save money in the same piggy bank you pay your bills and live out of because sooner or later you will have no money unless you are a miser.

  32. Critical Analyzer Avatar
    Critical Analyzer

    @Vincent Codrington March 18, 2022 10:14 PM

    Not the contributors, the politicians. Politicians got handed the largest amount of money to manage and the power to write the laws to use it before they demonstrated they understand the work it takes to earn money or know how to manage money.

  33. Critical Analyzer Avatar
    Critical Analyzer

    Our problem and solution is simple. All government taxes must tax for a specific purpose or government department, not ministry and that tax must be proven to go to that purpose or department.


  34. How poor management of the economy ultimately impacts social security.

    #governance

    https://www.barbadosparliament.com/uploads/sittings/attachments/65be3fbd5c1ad870cc72723d5cd3ee73.pdf


  35. This IMF report mentions the need to have a deep look at SOEs. The blogmaster is to be convinced many SOEs add real value to how government business is conducted. Politicians created SOEs to circumvent central government bureaucracy. We still have to fund pensions!

    https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Publications/CR/2021/English/1BRBEA2021002.ashx

  36. Critical Analyzer Avatar
    Critical Analyzer

    @David

    All SOEs should be run as private companies are run with a CEO, management and staff paid a salary and bonus tied to profits with those profits being remitted back to the government.

  37. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ david BU
    @ CA
    Quot homines ;Tot sententiae. Latin . Virgil.. As many men as enlist ,There are the same number of opinions.
    Yours atre one of many. I think we can agree to disagree. I have discharged my responsibility.


  38. Union’s jump.out of their sleep as if being chased by a mongoose shouting Hell No to the pension Reform
    Lol
    What a ting when the same Union’s settle for a measly 5 percent wage hike for govt workers instead of a 23 percent they fought and marched for against previous govt who then offered them a 15percent after the stink the Union’s raised
    The Union’s are as worthless as nettle
    The whole bunch needs to.be placed in a barrel and pushed out to sea

  39. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    Exist.NOT Enlist. Your precursive algorithm decides that I am a robot and presumes to correct my Eurocentric English ..


  40. @AC
    I see it. You have done it again.

    Now they have regrets and do repent
    Having settled for just five percent
    They know maths to such a degree
    They reason that 5 is greater than 23
    Now they jump out from their sleep
    And search like Bo Peep for her lost sheep
    But once again they fail the test
    Proving themselves utterly worthless
    One must wonder what is their destiny
    In a rudderless boat far out to sea


  41. Happy to report the wonderful service I have received over the course of this week from the many, many much maligned public service officers with whom I inreracted in a crucial matter.

    Came away feeling like I was floating on air!

    Really, we must stop this narrative that says that public workers on the whole do not deserve their pensions! It is not an across the board thing.

    Vincent is keeping his feet on the ground with facts in tow, as usual. Caswell is again stating what I thought we all knew donkey years ago, that lower salaries in the public sector are a tradeoff with pensions upon retirement. Pensions are not a gift to retirees. They are deferred EARNINGS!

    Just as NIS Invalidity Benefit is an extended sickness benefit to which a person contributes and not a pension in the true sense of the word.

    Hence, any reforms should affect only NEW ENTRANTS to the service. That gives persons the time to plan adequately for their retirement.

    Terms and conditions of employment should not be changed unilaterally in midstream.

    To do so will ultimately lead to a legion of impoverished retirees. That will take more welfare money and more staff to administer the welfare

    You will pay one way or the other. The welfare way will be more messy and costly in the end.

  42. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    @VC
    I ask about accountability, and you reply there is nothing amiss with paying pensions out of current income?
    I have no specific issue with paying pensions from current income, they have to come from somewhere?
    And as we have learned from the NIS, ring fencing funds, adds no benefit. In fact it likely just creates a separate pot which can be targeted. And the contributors have only shown minimal concern over its management.
    Best to come from a ‘big pot’. And as long as all gets paid each month, everybody is happy. If and when that changes, then noise will be kept.

  43. William Skinner Avatar
    William Skinner

    @ David
    You are correct ! Poor governance for the last forty years has literally destroyed everything in our country. Look at the infrastructure.
    As I said, months ago, if we are praising any government for having to buy garbage trucks and buses as a priority ; we have retrogressed.
    The NIS is suffering a similar fate. We have been governed by political personalities. To date, our country has been blessed by only two leaders of any substantial merit, even with their flaws: Sir Grantley Adams and Errol Barrow. The others only merit:a barely competent.


  44. @DonnaMarch 19, 2022 11:25 AM

    “Pensions are not a gift to retirees. They are deferred EARNINGS!”

    WRONG. Pensions in the public service are nothing else than a theft at the expense of our hard-working minority of businessmen. Since 1966, the infrastructure has been rotting away, while at the same time we have to feed more and more Aborigines as civil servants.


  45. @NO

    We are back to square one? One big pot that continues to leak. Why bother with governance matters and holding gatekeepers accountable. Let’s vote them in 30-0 and when time is up, vote for the other political party.


  46. @William

    As stated many times by different commenters buying garbage trucks, buses etc is routine stuff, we should be praising developmental initiatives that lead to improve quality of life. We have become so adversarial a people. In the midst of it the political class thrive.


  47. @CA

    The issue is not how they should be run, it is about an inadequate public service structure to ensure quality governance framework and enforce policies.

  48. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David Bu
    Leaks are leaks whether coming from a large pot or a number of small potties
    Moreover in a society of scarce competent professionals small potties are more difficult to manage effectively. They magnify the problem and are neither effective nor efficient.They do take on aspects of sharing the pie. Accountability ,whatever you understand by that,is not the social objective it is a means to an end which is clearly not being achieved. Let us instead make sure we put competent managers in these positions. It is the result that matters.


  49. @Vincent

    What do you think this discussion is about? After decades of mismanagement you expect things to run its course without drastic interventions? Unfunded pensions, SOEs not penalized for producing timely audited statements, ineptness of successive governments not responding to an ageing population. We find ourselves in a states where bidder medicine has to be swallowed because pension contributions are drying up and pension expense is rising. Even in the face of current state of play we still have people not understanding the predicament.

  50. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David Bu

    I agree. This discussion is a clear indication that some people do not understand the real issues that should be addressed.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending