David Comissiong – Citizen Advocate

“An idiot is in the House of Parliament recommending that there are 15 – 17000 unoccupied houses in Barbados and Government should look at compulsorily acquiring them to either sell or rent. Pray tell when would THIS government pay the owners for their land. There is currently a plantation about to declare bankruptcy due to compulsorily acquired land and non payment by government. Is this a new form of democracy? Maybe it is time for the citizens to compulsorily acquire unused land and buildings from government and then set the price to be paid whenever they feel like”.BU Commentator Fearplay

Members of the BU household vividly recall at the height of the Cahill debate Senators Maxine McClean and Verla De Peiza  empathic in their condemnation of the BU household for leaking documents. Both of them went as far to suggest the household had committed a treasonous act. The decision to shutdown the Tees Valley 1 and 2 project in the UK has vindicated the BU household and other Barbadians who expressed concern. At the top of the list of concerns raised by Barbadians about the Cahill gasification was government approving the untested technology on a 166 square mile island. Thankfully in April 2016 Air Products- the developer of Tees Valley 1 and 2 -issued a statement to the effect that “additional design and operational challenges would require significant time and cost to rectify” the problem of constructing a gasification plant to process 700,000 tonnes of feedstock every year. The Cahill plant in Barbados was proposed to handle 650 tonnes of waste per day.

Today Minister Denis Kellman under the cloak of parliamentary privilege labelled citizen advocate David Comissiong as an enemy of the state –his crime, seeking a judicial review of government’s decision to approve the construction of the proposed 15 story Hyatt hotel at lower Bay Street. Kellman’s characterization of Comissiong for exercising a right under our law. The BU community was reminded by a family member that there is similar concerns being raised in London about the construction of high rise buildings, to quote him:- “in a city already plastered with “tall” buildings, matters like location, design and impact on character setting are still relevant. Yet we in Barbados supporting Hyatt” – read related article How new skyscrapers including the 1,000ft Trellis will transform London’s skyline.

To restate BU’s concern here is an extract from a BU blog:

If commonsense was not enough to support an EIA as a condition for approval for the Hyatt hotel project, the BU family was directed to the Draft Physical Development Plan (DPDP) dated February 2017 posted to the Town Planning Department website. Not only does the DPDP call for an EIS to be used as a tool to assess proposed development and a condition for approval, also, Heritage Impact Assessments (HIA), Agricultural Impact Assessments (AIA), Traffic Impact Assessments (TIA) where deemed relevant. Here is a quote from the DPDP:

Where ESIAs, HIA, AIS or TIA (Impact Assessments) are required, they shall be completed to the satisfaction of the Chief Town Planner, prior to approval being given. Approvals of development subject to Impact Assessments may contain certain conditions of approval to ensure that adverse impacts of such development are mitigated. 

DRAFT PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN CALLS FOR IMPACT ASSESSMENTS –HYATT HOTEL TO BE BUILT WITHOUT IMPACT ASSESSMENT STUDIES

After suffering through some of the debate this afternoon in the Lower House several of the government members of parliament who spoke did not address the reason raised by Comissiong in his application for judicial review. They saw no need for transparency by including the people of the area in the transaction. To this day Barbadians have not been told how Vision Development Inc proposes to finance the project. Of the 100 million to be invested what will be the net foreign exchange inflow. This is the nature of the politics we practice in Barbados. 

One can only marvel at the statement attributed to Minister of Housing Denis Kellman quoted at the top of the blog.  He made mention of 5×16 to explain the level of occupancy at the GROTTO. Who can translate? Did Minister Sinckler state he is willing to challenge anyone that there was overruns associated with the GROTTO project? Is he challenging the Auditor General of Barbados who was scathing in his concerns? See Special Auditor General Report 2016 – Special Audit on the National Housing Corporation High Rise Apartments at Grotto and Valerie

 

 

134 responses to “David Comissiong Branded Enemy of the State”

  1. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    Calling David Comissiong an enemy of the state is being rather nice to him.


  2. Sorry, David. Run that by me again.,


  3. Kellman like so many others ontinur to show that that talking ideas, and translating them into implementable policy are not the same. Dig into the archives and try to find out why O’brien Trotman was brought back to UDC after he retired. Then fast forward to Kellman’s comments. #governmentatastandstill


  4. @Bush Tea April 25, 2017 at 11:22 PM “somebody gotta eat the lunch when the day comes.”

    Why are we feeding our MP’s expensive lumches anyhow.

    I would stop the free food, and provide 4 microwave ovens, and the MP’s would have to do like the rest of us taxpayers…cook something and bring it from home…and warm it over at lunch time.

    We would save the taxpayers tens of thousands of dollars per year.

  5. Vincent Haynes Avatar

    I wonder if winning an election is worth destroying what little character a person has?

    Hyatt will not be built before the next elections but an urgent desire exists for monies to be disbursed now at all costs…Why?

    Govt. is the largest property owner in Bim and its derelict/unused properties are Plantation buildings,Office buildings,Culloden farm,The Grotto,Lancaster,Coverly,Greens,etc,etc…..why not start with them?

    It appears that as Bushie stated the Minister is about to have a nervous breakdown due to overwork in the cause of his parties re-election.


  6. @David at 8:21 AM I can agree that the political future of Barbados is indeed now but as others have said, our past represents our present just as it sadly presages our future.

    You can call it what you wish: Deja Vu, ‘Ground Day’ or purgatory. But this level of political polarization is not new.

    The trappings and spoils are more conspicuous and the rewards exponentially more significant thus the arrogance, the unvarnished, biased rhetoric and brazen behaviour is decidedly more publicly displayed.

    But there is nothing really new about the basic behavior.

    In sum, as some of said well we have actually regressed to the bad old plantation day politics even as we ostensibly progress with all our material and technological advances.


  7. @angela Skeete April 26, 2017 at 8:40 AM “David Commissiong is making sure his ascendancy to political power is sealed proof while at the same time riding a political wave to depressed barbados progress. Mostly the poor and vulnerable are at high risk if he gets his way

    Dear David:

    Are all of the DLP yardies semi-literate?

    What is angela skeete trying to say in standard English or standard Bajan?


  8. “enemies of the state”: this sounds like something the fellow in North Korea would say. May the good Lord save us from the hands of these Ossie Moores.

  9. Vincent Haynes Avatar

    David

    I thought this was about the assinine statements of the MP re acquiring peoples houses and calling a citizen of Bim undertaking their lawful work a traitor.

    As for the Hyatt…..I do not want to see anymore large hotels as our Tourist industry can best be served by more homestay and bed&breakfast operations,for those upmarket people the odd 5 star hotel already in existence will do.

    If it has to be built it should be done at the old Paradise location as no more beach side land should be utilised.

    As far as brand names are concerned we do not need them in this day of internet availability.


  10. Why bother to try to understand the hyroglifcs of a yardfowl?

  11. Bright Red Cherry Avatar
    Bright Red Cherry

    angela Skeete

    Did not the same Peter Wickham help the the dead king, David Thompson get elected in 2008?


  12. @Dee Word

    There was always crime from the beginning of time so why bother.


  13. Wickham was caught redhanded sowing seeds of untruths by way of a sinister poll only a fool afterr
    those damaging accusations would want to associate with that fool


  14. @angela Skeete April 26, 2017 at 9:19 AM “when one looks at the decay of bridgetown and its environs one cannot but asked the question why is Commissiong fighting tooth hammer and nail to further depressed that blighted area.”

    Why is Bridgetown, decayed, blighted and depressed?

    Why would the Hyatt be willing to put their name on a hotel in a decayed, blighted and depressed Bridgetown?

    How will building a new hotel correct the decay, blight and depression?

    Wouldn’t doing more to correct the blight, decay and depression of the current buildings be a sensible and more economical option.

    And finally if the DLP has held office for 27 years and 4 months since Independence, whereas the BLP has held office for 24 years whose fault is it that Bridgetown is decayed, blighted and depressed?


  15. No sir that’s not my point or intent.

    Yes there was that original crime and now we have more crime. Surely the reason for the first crime is the same or similar for these crimes now and those of the future.

    Solve for the mental state that causes the crime; stop the crimes.

    People like Kellman and his ridiculous remark to call an activist – properly using the legal system – an enemy of the state is reprehensible.

    How do people like him get to represent others? Do his constituents return him to power election after election because they agree with his venom against democracy and free-speech?

    In that sense railing against his nonsense can’t ever solve the ‘crime’ because essentially his ‘crime’ is being supported by others…dare I say…other criminals….and hasten to add like us all who elect these who turn out to be vagabonds.

    A long winded way to say…we have to get to the root of the problem; otherwise we will plaintively rail against ‘these crimes’ until ‘the end of time’! Anyhow, I gone.


  16. Wickham is an opportunist. Yes he helped king David as David had time for him. Frendeul dont have any time for him so he is helping MAM as she has time for him.

    And talking about MAM, she wants to increase the number of representatives in the house from its present 30. Because it would “let civil society to have a more direct say”. I know St. Philip South and I think St. James South or Central is currently over the limit. But I dont think its time for an increase in representatives now.


  17. @Bright Red Cherry April 26, 2017 at 9:52 AM “angela You are playing on the fears of poor Barbadians about lack of jobs and opportunities coming from the Hyatt ”

    We all know very well that rich people do not go into business in order to help poor people or to create jobs.

    Rich people go into business because rich people like money real, real bad.

    And they try to pay as little taxes as possible.

    Business people are NOT Jesus Christ. In fact them most of them are non-believers.

    So let us understand this and then the discussion can go forward.


  18. @angela Skeete April 26, 2017 at 10:13 AM “the voters would not vote for a party that attaches itself to a communist.”

    You still looking for Reds Under The Bed/Communists???

    Lol

    I thought that that foolishness went out of fashion when the Berlin Wall disappeared in 1989.


  19. What we have in Barbados is one man who has embraced his civic duty in a participatory democracy? What does it say about the rest.


  20. What we have is one man embrscj g his political interest albeit by democratic principles which he decries for communist countries.
    However being the double agent he is lets nothing step in his way for his own political aspirations. Not even the barbados dwindling reserves and unemployment can make Comissiong put the best interest of country first. What a maggot


  21. @ David
    What we have in Barbados is one man who has embraced his civic duty in a participatory democracy? What does it say about the rest……?
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Brass…??
    🙂


  22. Actually, what we have is an Erdogan clone in Parliament. Maybe more than one!


  23. David Commissiong is not an enemy of the state nor an enemy of Bajans (nor am I an ememy) but sometimes I wonder if Kellie is on the Asperger’s spectrum.


  24. The land on Bay Street does not look like a large enough plot to construct the monstrosity I saw on DLPTV as the model for the hotel.

    On the VOB news today, there was a report from hoteliers that occupacy was down. So tell me again why we need the Hyatt at this time?


  25. Is there any room for gardens or green spaces?

  26. Bright Red Cherry Avatar
    Bright Red Cherry

    David

    What say you if I suggested that the DLP supporter ought to thank Peter Wickham for helping FJ Stuart become PM again in 2013? Was Peter trying to get the BLP elected or to see to it that Owen was finished politically, once and for all?


  27. Who knows what is truth in this incestuous place.

  28. Frustrated Businessman: enact Facilitation Martial Law! Avatar
    Frustrated Businessman: enact Facilitation Martial Law!

    I would remind you all that construction of Bushy Park racetrack started before the Town Hall Meeting, the closing requirement of the EIA, had been held, far less reported and submitted.

    Hyatt will be the same.

    The genius crooks in Cabinet decided to compulsorily acquire Bushy Park Plantation (for which a price has still not been agreed with the UK-based owner, far less paid) and justify the cost by selling the remaining lands to Maloney and Mallalieu to build 600 houses – DOWNWIND OF THE RACE TRACK! Meanwhile the GOB already owned all the land around the airport which is a designated noise zone.

    Pattern of personalities?

    Mark Cummings is one of the biggest crooks in this country. His department creates a development scarcity through their inaction and ineptitude then he personally profits for ‘facilitation’.

    Hyatt is about teefin’, like everything else Fumble’s Fools do.

  29. CUP Violet Beckles Plantation Deeds from 1926-2017 land tax bills and no Deeds,BLPand DLP Massive land Fruad and PONZ Avatar
    CUP Violet Beckles Plantation Deeds from 1926-2017 land tax bills and no Deeds,BLPand DLP Massive land Fruad and PONZ

    David April 26, 2017 at 1:08 PM #

    Amazing not one person has picked up the point that Londoners are having this same conversation about their skyline. This is a city with many tall buildings.

    In Barbados however we have narrowed the conversation to the political. So you see Jeff, the future is now. May God have mercy on our pithy souls.
    @@

    Yes keep looking up when the fraud is under your feet, Like any of you have wings to worry and where doves fly.Keep side tracking the people David I will bring them back down to Earth.

  30. Vincent Haynes Avatar

    Frustrated Businessman: enact Facilitation Martial Law! April 26, 2017 at 3:30 PM #

    From all indications Hyatt will not be built……why is their an urgency to start it then?

    Does approval allow for the draw down of funds?


  31. Violet Beckles,
    Plse enlighten me about this discussion about high rise building in London. who is hang this discussion?


  32. Not to forget the payment for the land at Waterford to Patrick Bethel. Lands reported to be used for the Del Mastro solar factory.


  33. The land on Bay Street does not look like a large enough plot to construct the monstrosity I saw on DLPTV as the model for the hotel.

    Prodigal it would be a great idea if govt built it on that big space of a backside attached to your body

  34. CUP Violet Beckles Plantation Deeds from 1926-2017 land tax bills and no Deeds,BLPand DLP Massive land Fruad and PONZ Avatar
    CUP Violet Beckles Plantation Deeds from 1926-2017 land tax bills and no Deeds,BLPand DLP Massive land Fruad and PONZ

    Hal Austin April 26, 2017 at 4:19 PM #

    @ We talking Barbados , I talking Barbados and not talking about looking up in the sky , unless looking means, looking up History or searching records to see what was missing or re written to fool Bajans , but not the whiteman , Whiteman had the records first that dont match blackmans records in Barbados for Clear Title,
    DLP and BLP and the DBLP government have to go, All of them,


  35. Violet Beckles,
    This is what you said:

    Amazing not one person has picked up the point that Londoners are having this same conversation about their skyline. This is a city with many tall buildings.

    | asked for enlightenment about this conversation.

  36. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    Silly season come early. How many months of this shiite?


  37. @ NorthernObserver,

    Silly season in Canada too. Political turmoil everywhere.

    http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/kevin-oleary-drops-out-endorses-bernier-1.4086583


  38. Kevin April 26, 2017 at 2:09 PM #

    “Wickham is an opportunist. Yes he helped king David as David had time for him. Frendeul dont have any time for him so he is helping MAM as she has time for him.”

    @ Kevin

    Hartley Henry was also instrumental in David Thompson’s elevation to PM and then he subsequent expressed his contempt for the DLP.

    It seems you would label Henry as “an opportunist” as well.

    Don’t “tell” us that: “Maxine McClean, Tony Marshall and Harry Husbands never try to active stall nor stop a major project that will bring jobs nor enhance the city.”

    Where is the proof to substantiate your suggestion that Commisiong’s actions were undertaken on behalf of the BLP?


  39. As a citizen and taxpayer, David Commisiong did what he believed to be right by questioning the legality of this inept DLP administration’s undertaking relative to the Hyatt project.

    Yet he was labeled an “enemy of the state” by the same Denis Kellman who has been an abysmal failure as a Minister of Housing, as is evidence by non nationals claiming land in Rock Hall, St. Philip as their own, while securing “house spots” for their relatives and friends, blatantly breaking the law, to the admission of AG Adriel Brathwaite, who said he had friends residing there.

    Under these circumstances, who are the real enemies of the state?


  40. NATION NEWS
    Pay regrade
    Published on: 9/25/07.

    THERE was an anomaly relating to the pay of the director of the Urban Development Commission (UDC) for over seven years.
    This has been pointed out by UDC chairman Sir Henry Forde, who in a statement issued late yesterday said that for seven years two of the commission’s employees were being paid at the same level as the director to whom they reported.
    It was against this background that the UDC’s board of directors requested the Ministry of the Civil Service to regrade the post.
    Sir Henry’s comments were in response to the Front Page story in yesterday’s DAILY NATION which highlighted the return of recently retired director, O’Brien Trotman, on a one-year contract to deal with a derelict properties programme.
    On the pay issue, the statement said, “the recommendation of the board and the decision of the Ministry of Civil Service limited the effective date to April 2005 and not the entire period of the anomaly. This was for duties actually performed under the aegis of the director given the scope of his responsibilities.
    “An impression was unfortunately given that the director would be drawing the full amount of salary attached to the post for two years. It must be stated that the entitlement is only the difference between the two grades,” the statement added.
    The statement added that under its Urban Renewal Programme there was a derelict buildings project which for various reasons was never meaningfully implemented.
    “The board therefore concluded that it was necessary to establish a special unit to reactivate and manage a programme designed to rehabilitate the over 1 800 derelict properties across the Greater Bridgetown Area.
    “The new programme envisages the restoration and replacement of buildings through public-private partnerships involving the Urban Development Commission, the landowners, and financial institutions. The commission feels strongly that such an arrangement augurs well for the provision of additional housing for urban residents.
    “The board was of the opinion that with the retirement of the outgoing director, his experience and working knowledge of the complex issues involved in the implementation of the programme would be an asset,” the statement said. (PR/ES)

  41. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    I think this is really a marketing strategy for David Commisiong . He is trying to keep himself in the public eye in order to boost his legal practice.

    Sales must have been falling for his legal practice. And this is a way for him to increase revenue.


  42. Is this the same jackass Carson CaDOGan that gets in here calling the contributors ‘geriatrics’ who are ready to die? hahaha …..well look at this old pop down heffer……lol

    https://www.barbadosadvocate.com/news/carson-cadogan-walks-away-top-award-contribution-community

    Hahaha…. muh belly….


  43. Calm April 26, 2017 at 7:47 PM #

    “Is this the same jackass Carson CaDOGan that gets in here calling the contributors ‘geriatrics’ who are ready to die? hahaha …..well look at this old pop down heffer……lol..”

    @ Calm

    Yet the same Carson used this forum to “big up” a DLP geriatric named Astor B. Watts, who also does not have anything better to do with his time than to spend it at the DLP’s George Street headquarters.


  44. @ Enuff

    Under whose portfolio the UDC fell during the period this article alludes to?

    Be careful how you answer, lest you are accused of “classism.”

  45. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    Is that Carson Cadogan who stalks the blog, older than many of some of us by 20, 30, 40 years….lol

    Being a bottomfeeding yardfowl, using the unfortunate circumstances of people to get 15 minutes of fame in the media….real volunteers and those who engage the less fortunate in the community with service, usually remain anonymous, the genuine ones…I am so not surprised.


  46. Question asked by another. Is this fake news?

    Anyone knows what came of this? Note the article was written in April 2015.

    $10 million facelift for DLP headquarters


  47. Attack
    Once Sir Henry was Chairman that means Hammiela was gone and Mia the Minister. My point though is that 10 years ago the then government was talking about an approach to derelict properties that involved government, land owners and financial institutions according to this article; yet Kellman is behaving like the issue appeared all of a sudden and to make matters talking nonsense about confiscating private property. 10 frigging years!! The Dems really trick(ing) Bajans. Whatever became of the UDC audit and the ped houses that walked away?


  48. @well well

    Not only that, to show what a political prostitute and low life scum bag he is…the day this DLP govt is booted from office, this jackass will not lift a finger to help a fella. All this ‘so called’ charity work is done in the name of politics and a form of ass licking for his DLP masters.

  49. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger

    Calm….Carson is a bottomfeeder, as is normal for yardfowls.

  50. Frustrated Businessman: enact Facilitation Martial Law! Avatar
    Frustrated Businessman: enact Facilitation Martial Law!

    Vincent Haynes April 26, 2017 at 4:16 PM #
    Frustrated Businessman: enact Facilitation Martial Law! April 26, 2017 at 3:30 PM #

    From all indications Hyatt will not be built……why is their an urgency to start it then?

    Vincent, as I’ve typed before, Bim is flush with cash.

    Bajans sold shares in BS&T, Banks, Sagicor, Barbados Farms etc. and have nothing to invest in.

    No local companies have shown growth for eight years of DLP economic buffoonary and no private sector companies are taking interest-paying deposits; in fact, they have returned depositors’ money years ago.

    Meanwhile gov’t has been printing money to keep snivel servants employed creating more liquidity.

    Thousands of Bajans have cash to invest. They were living off interest and dividends that no longer exists and are spending principal to live – back into the system.

    Ironically, the biggest threat to our foreign exchange is not this failed gov’t, it is the economic activity that is likely to occur with all this loose cash under the next gov’t using up foreign exchange to rebuild this country. After the next election there will likely be a ForEx waiting list like in the 90s and black-market ForEx will prove the actual value of our dollar.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading