← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Mia Mottley, Opposition Leader
Mia Mottley, Opposition Leader

Less than one year after the last general election and the sense in the BU household is that the country continues to be gripped in election mode. This is despite the Democratic Labour Party (DLP) having won the general election albeit by a narrow margin of two seats. The inability of the Stuart led government to bring Barbadians together and get on with improving the lot of the country has been a bane to many. To some the narrow result confirmed the disgust which the electorate has with the two main political parties.

Here is the flipside. BU is not convinced by  the alternative proposals which were championed by the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) during the last general election campaign. There was the privatization argument which backfired, however, the thrust of the BLP’s offering is centred on maintaining a service economy read tourism and international business. Not to forget the promise of a more aggressive offshore oil exploration program. The BLP faithful appear not to accept that the world has changed post-2008. Barbados ‘leveraged’ a global economic boom where there was easy money to be borrowed from capital markets. A significant percentage of the billions left in foreign reserves by the BLP represented borrowings which will have to be repaid. The adage that one has to earn your way in the world means that a borrowing strategy was not sustainable.

The BU gang has been harping for years that the Barbados downward spiral can be tracked to a lack of leadership. In case the BLP hacks have forgotten, the economic indicators started to flag during Owen Arthur’s third term. There is evidence that Arthur and the BLP struggled with the economic conditions which had become harsher.

We have been observing Mia Mottley very closely after she regained the leadership of the BLP in January. Immediately on her taking over we heard about a newbie member of parliament Edmund Hinkson clashing with veteran George Payne. This matter as ridiculous as it is made it all the way to the Barbados Courts. A routine expectation of any leader is that he or she must be able to keep charges in line. Although the traditional press reported recently that Hinkson has made overtures to Payne, up to the time of writing this blog the matter of Payne vs Hinkson remains unresolved.

Another issue which many have forgotten goes back to when Mottley was rejected by her parliamentary colleagues in 2010, the so-called gang of 5 affair. Although the motion was defeated BU recalls Mottley accused her party of not allowing all members to vote at the BLP Annual Conference and she eventually gave way to George Payne who continued uncontested as Chairman.

Related Links:

The question therefore is: does Mottley intend to revisit this matter now that she is Opposition Leader? If she does not should the public regard her 2010 contribution as a rant? Or is she afraid of what some still regard as her tenuous position as Opposition Leader.

The final issue we have concerns about centres around that famous press conference when Tyrone Barker suggested the Arthur faction was dissatisfied about how BLP party money was managed during Mottley’s tenure as Opposition Leader her first time around.  As far as BU is aware Mottley has not responded to the veiled accusation of malfeasance.

In our view Mottley as Opposition Leader has not demonstrated strong leadership to close the issues mentioned and several others which we have not. BU has been focused on the DLP and government because this is where the buck stops. The BLP needs to step up. Why are Barbadians happy with Opposition parties winning governments by default?


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

71 responses to “A Ring a Ring o’ Roses: BLP DLP Same Party”

  1. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    Wait, let me put on my glasses and read this again.

    This article actually sounds “fair and balanced”.

    This is the old DAVID pulling no punches.

    Me Like!!!


  2. a Damascus moment! ac not one to crticise…..however MIA mottley leadership so far is a failure seems like she is contented to limp to the finish line. with Barbados in the grips of financial difficulties one would think that she would take advantage of a disadvantage opportunity that the DLP govt has been handed, however what I interpret from her behaviour is a leader who is afraid to confront hard issues , her voice on issues like CLICO has gone silent .could it be that what might have appeared to her as a quick and solvable issue in the first initial stages she might have had to reconsider her position resulting in a close mouthed approach from her present stance


  3. Another blight………………………………………………………..

    The island’s main seaport of entry is in major financial difficulty, forcing management to review all aspects of its operations, to ensure it remains viable.

    General manager of the Barbados Port Inc., David Jean Marie, also told Barbados TODAY this evening that he shut down the port half-day today to have a general staff meeting to apprise workers of the challenging situation being experienced, in light of the current economic downturn. Jean-Marie said the Port was in the process of restructuring its debt, including measures to reduce its substantial pension liabilities.

    The Port boss also said he was frank with the employees in telling them of the state of affairs, as well as the overdraft operating position.

    “Just like other companies, we are facing challenges. I spoke [to the staff] about our short and medium-term plans to procure the necessarily cargo handling equipment as well as the [proposed] Sugar Point Cruise Facility,” he added.

    “We are reviewing the way the organization is functioning and will be taking all steps required to ensure its viability. We are examining all aspects of the Port operations,” pointed out Jean-Marie.

    The executive would not be drawn into saying whether or not any of the anticipated steps included laying off workers.

    He however told Barbados TODAY the Port was experiencing declines in cargo, noting that when there was a downturn in the economy, such would be reflected in the operations of the facility.

    The general manager explained, though, that while his organization was facing major financial challenges, it was still able to pay wages and suppliers, and honour its statutory obligations.

    He said the one bright spot was an expected increase in cruise arrivals.

    “We are putting measures in place to facilitate that, including the use of Shed 3 as a temporary home porting facility,” asserted Jean-Marie.

    “The Port has invested substantially in its workers’ certification. We have extensive training to certify all port workers in port operations, as well as occupational health and safety,” boasted the administrator.

    The Port boss also referred to a “small” profit which it made in 2012……………………………………………………………….

    What next? The airport??????

    emmanueljoseph@barbadostoday


  4. I have been following politics for a long time.

    I would admit that the DLP has succeeded in brainwashing most Barbadians and they would prefer to give the DLP a chance than to face facts that the DLP of the Barrow era is not the DLP that the dead king strung together to win an election. Whenever the DLP messes up, those who support the party, instead of calling them out we hear this constant refrain that the BLP and DLP are the same.

    Hell NO.

    What do we really want from the BLP? They lost the election, they could not match the money the DLP had to buy the election. If this was a fair election, the DLP could not have won. I heard a man said on Brasstacks that people went out and voted to prove Peter Wickham wrong. These people got money and did not care about the soul of Barbados.

    The BLP discussed issues, they dared to touch the issue of privitisation and the wicked Dems found a way to demonise the BLP and their supporters believed them. Mind you the worst minister of finance was in favour of privitisation until he got read the riot at by the party.

    Well, the Dems got what they wanted…………….and we are where we are today. Stop blaming the BLP.

    The DLP is no more unified than the BLP. We hear stories daily of those cabinet members do do not attend cabinet meetings when certain members are chairing the meeting, we hear of a certain member who would wait until all of them are gathered before he enters the room. The only thing that is keeping this DLP together is to get to their pensionable date, nothing else. So stop fooling people that the Dems are all of this together.

    The Dems won as they like to boast, if they cannot do the job, if they had any decency or care about Barbados, they would resign. Stop blaming Mia, she is not the problem and yes I agree that Hinkson was wrong, he only gave fodder to the critics!

    The Dems won, let then govern! They are know it alls, they dont want advice from anyone……goodness me!


  5. @Prodigal Son

    There is no way the BLP should have loss the general election. It says a lot. Even as at today, many Barbadians are undecided if a general election were to be called. Your party needs to fix the problem.


  6. The Mahogany Coconut Group put forward that the very close election result, was a prime opportunity for these two parties to form a government of national reconstruction and immediately level with the citizens and move forward as a collective , to solve our island state’s problems. We were laughed at because the pathetic apologists of the BLP/ DLP did not grasp the magnitude of what was on the horizon. Once more we call for a government of national reconstruction .


  7. The Westminster system of government we practice breeds adversarial politics.


  8. David

    Are you able to put out a call to Barbados Port Inc including its GM, David Jean Marie and its Chairman, David Harding as how many millions and millions of dollars they have paid to SMI and or Gline Bannister for consulting, designing and studies for the new Cruise Pier project, Sugar Point aka Honey Pot?


  9. So what exactly are you spaying prodigal?
    You still don’t get it?
    WE ARE IN A GLOBAL RECESSION.
    the port will slow down, the airport will slowdown,
    The banks will slowdown….
    Eventually, even Freundy will realize that there is not enough money to continue paying hoards of government employees just to be ’employed’….

    Every country is facing this problem. However many are having a easier time because:
    – they did not waste money during the better times
    – they did not put all their eggs in one fickle basket
    – they are currently taking SENSIBLE steps to address efficiency and productivity.
    – their citizens have NOT divided themselves into two opposing camps shouting shiite at each other…
    – their people are not brass bowls.

    No point in blaming the DLP only!
    That is like a beach bum blaming the present welfare system for his failure when he ignored years of opportunities at school to create success paths for himself….

    Why not let’s come up with a common bipartisan plan of action for the country…?
    …oh ! hell! THAT would be no fun would it?


  10. No point in blaming the DLP?

    So why you all keep blaming the BLP and not the DLP who has messed up this economy since 2008.

    The DLP has borrowed over 4 billion dollars since the came to government more than the BLP borrowed in 14 years. The DLP has to be blamed….they kept spending and spending and spending. They have a spending problem. You cannot earn $100 a week and spend $1000. Sheer madness from people who had not a clue how to govern!

    We have been offering the DLP ideas since 2008 and they dont want to hear……… the CBB governor and the DLP said that their MTFS was the ONLY way and then came and told us it failed. Remember how the PM pooh pooh Clyde Mascoll and OSA’s ideas? Hard ears they wont hear, own way Bajans will now feel!

    What bipartisan talking what…..you would be wasting your breath again!

  11. PLANTAION DEEDS FROM 1926 TO 2013 , MASSIVE FRAUD ,LAND TAX BILLS AND NO DEEDS OF BARBADOS, BLPand DLP=Massive Fruad Avatar
    PLANTAION DEEDS FROM 1926 TO 2013 , MASSIVE FRAUD ,LAND TAX BILLS AND NO DEEDS OF BARBADOS, BLPand DLP=Massive Fruad

    Prodigal Son | October 14, 2013 at 10:20 PM | @ both are Crooks and we will say that for ever , If you need to vote 3rd party and see the 3rd party tell you who all the crooks are by names , For you all will not listen to Plantation Deeds , All you beat around the bush,
    David now seem like he sick of both parties but Violet Beckles and Beatrice Henry Know both BLP/DLP are massive crooks taking turn raping the people of BARBADOS,
    Why pay taxes in land when the land not yours and the GOVT have crook books and cooked the books and no one is eating ,
    The people know the truth and still hope not to pay rent , So now all will sink to to bottom of all hell. To many dam lies and this is the real deal ,
    You all seem to love lies better than truth , Lies and liars will just give you all more pain ,,, VOTE TRUTH NOT PARTY ,,,, VOTE THE C.U.P.
    MAYBE THEN YOU ALL WILL GET SOME BLESSINGS .
    LIES, LIARS , CROOKS AND SCUMBAGS DLP/BLP AND THE LAWYERS IN BOTH HOUSES ,, AND THOSE APPOINTED TO BE PAID OFF , NOW THE BWMS AND THE RR s,,,,


  12. Bi=partisan what,,,Bush TEA not even in heaven,,,reason why Gabriel was kicked out.. Control is the horse that drives the wagon,,and further more it is hard to teach old dogs new tricks,,added to that the opposition is so fractured in their approach as to who should be leader and can’t even see to agree ,on that one issue ,,just imagine having both sides under the same umbrella trying to agree on anything, ,,govt shut down if u ask ac,, kaboom,,, we all dead fuh sure…..


  13. I saw the PM on the CBC News this evening on the Myrie case. And HE is the leader of a nation? Why is it that this concept of “national security” is ever on the lips of this government? We had it with Garcia, now Myrie. Are these people simply puffed up? What are they REALLY afraid of? Is it a sign of their littleness and the poverty of their vision? Err….what vision?


  14. Mia Mottley and the BLP are a waste of time.

    The money Prodigal allowed to be dumped in St, Andrew is when he should been shouting from the rooftops.


  15. @ ac
    That is precisely why we are in this quagmire. Looking for cheap political gain at the expense of the people to satisfy crass party needs. Believe it or not right now we have a one party state ! These parties have been in business for a half century and yet they cannot claim to be nothing more than the pot calling the kettle black.While the Bs talk about good economic management they forget the $700,000.000 in over runs. While the Ds talk about a society and not an economy they end up with a $400,000.000 deficit ! A government of national re construction will be focus on Barbados and not Roebuck or George Street.
    Hamilton Lashley can jump from party to party without any problem. Clyde Mascoll. who brought a no-confidence motion against the BLP can end up as their Junior Minister of Finance; Delisle Bradshaw contested an election for the Ds then slipped back into the Bs. We can go on and on. That is possible because there really is no difference.
    In order to lift a country , leaders must first demonstrate an ability to lift themselves. The mess we are in is a problem for ALL of us and our children and grand children. Let us move away from petty party squabbles and do what’s right for our island state.


  16. David at least you are trying to be balanced even if it is comical :-). Press on my brother.


  17. @enuff

    Are you trivializing the concerns mentioned?


  18. What are the real issues impacting on the competitiveness of the Tourism & Hospitality sector? despite a weekly tourism column I am not sure we are really any closer to a real understanding of the issues.

    As a person outside the sector I see a tired product, a plant quality that does not match the price point and no energy or urgency among property owners to adjust their business models and operations to higher energy costs.

    Are more government subsidies in the form of lower taxes really the answer? That seems to be the solution preferred by the sector’s mai n lobby group.

    We need a revitalized tourism sector, what are the real issues and sustainable solutions?


  19. @Observer

    Where is the rollout of the government’s White Paper? Don’t you think this would be a good framework to guid strategic planning in the private sector?

    Looks like MAM has issued the government with an ultimatum if you read todays’s the Nation headline

    BLP: Be warned
     
    Mia Mottley (FP)
    TUE, OCTOBER 15, 2013 – 12:12 AM
    THE BARBADOS LABOUR Party (BLP) has thrown down the gauntlet to Government: show how you will rescue Barbados, or it will.
    And the Freundel Stuart administration has until the end of the day to show its hand, or the Bees have promised unspecified action.
    This threat was made by Opposition Leader Mia Mottley during a Christ Church West Central constituency meeting on Sunday night at Deighton Griffith Secondary School in Kingsland, Christ Church.   “There are some matters that we will wait to hear on this week and if we don’t hear what we need to hear, and if we don’t see corrections in Parliament on Tuesday, then we will do what we have to do because this country is a law-abiding country,” she said.
    Please read the full story in today’s DAILY NATION, or in the eNATION edition.


  20. I really do not know what the article is intended to portray or whom it is intended to appease but for those of us who have had to endure a significant reduction in our standard of living since 2008 and with things expected to get ‘WORSER’ with the introduction of the municipal tax and with the inability of the hospital to access drugs readily for its patients and with the possibility of babies dying and with the rejection of our bond offer on the international market and with the prediction that we will be the only country expected to record no growth this year and the next and with a seemingly divided cabinet over the implementation and/or non-implementation of policies; am i to understand that we are duty bound to stick with incompetence. The country did not vote for the Barbados labour party to run its affairs but the Democratic labour party and Governments are thrown out of office when they do not perform not retained because of some non-descript notion that the opposition has not proven it can do better.
    In addition, to his credit Mr Arthur did warn that there were storm clouds hovering over the economy of Barbados and there was much work to be done and the promises made by the DLP were unattainable. Nevertheless, he was rejected and the DLP was given two terms to do better . Sadly they have been unable and the recession card has been played out and there are no more cards to play.

  21. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    The unions are also part of the problem.


  22. @balance

    As usual instead of stating your opinion on the issues raised, agree or disagree you go off on your soap box. Your response is symptomatic of what is wrong with Barbados.


  23. Here is another example of poppycock. When has the PAC ever function in a decent manner?

    Prime Minister Freundel Stuart (FP)
    TUE, OCTOBER 15, 2013 – 12:10 AM
    CONVINCED THAT Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has been functioning like a “kangaroo court”, Government is moving to repeal legislation governing this watchdog body.
    Prime Minister Freundel Stuart made this disclosure on Sunday night during a meeting of the St Philip North branch of the Democratic Labour Party (DLP) at Hilda Skeene Primary School.
    “Within the next few weeks a bill will be carried to Parliament to repeal it, get it out of the way and get the Public Accounts Committee back onto a platform of decency . . . ,” he said.
    Stuart spoke of the PAC “hounding” and “grilling” witnesses, and operating outside local traditions and jurisprudence. He also complained of the processes and committees of Parliament being “perverted”.
    Please read the full story in today’s DAILY NATION, or in the eNATION edition.

  24. Equal Rights & Justice Avatar
    Equal Rights & Justice

    Barbados can be the leader in the region in making an industry out of marijuana and hemp its the way the world is going and we could be one of the first to tap into ah 300 billion dollar industry making products from the plant ,cause sugar dun dead ,until bajans face it ,the world is in ah shift and is changing either get wid it or get left behind remembering the old way and trying to maintain it

  25. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    @ David

    It matters not what the DLP does at this time, it is clear that Barbados is already tired of the deception, lies, and propaganda that has come from this once forward looking political party. Unfortunately, and given PM Stuart’s mouthings and doings, it is clear he is no decent man and his interests are not about bringing the best to Barbados, but achieving longevity for the DLP. It is shameful that after spouting talk of accountability and transparency, the DLP would seek to ‘cover up’ and hide the infelicities of the most incompetent Cabinet in the history f Barbados. Sad, sad, sad!


  26. @George

    What is ‘sad’ is that many Barbadians feel helpless when looking at the options available BLP DLP.

  27. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    @ David

    I can assure you that, for the most part, it would be reflected that by a significant proportion, the quality of MPs emerging out of the BLP have far surpassed those on the other side. Nonetheless, I believe that we should be calling for a higher standard of representation across the board. I am no fortune teller, and I do not know if a third or fourth party would appease the situation given that the resource pool remains the same despite that the BLP may attract more quality individuals.
    To put a long story short, it is sad that we are now accepting mediocre performances and endorsing incompetence by re-electing a failed government.


  28. @George

    Please address the issue of the quality of representation to which you referred. Do you have thoughts as to causal factors? Is it a case of general public withdrawing from public service because of perceived ‘issues’ at play? Perhaps the party machinery has become too ‘undemocratic’ and corrupt?


  29. George
    The primary and singular objective of a political party is to get elected and then institute change. The BLP was unable to get themselves elected in 2008 and again 2013, so which party really is the failure?
    Despite Mia’s mouthings everyone in Barbados including a lot of BLP supporters know that it’s virtually impossible to win a General Election with her as the prospective Prime Minister.


  30. “What is ‘sad’ is that many Barbadians feel helpless when looking at the options available BLP DLP.”

    really now David? Listening to the Bajan public i think you are wrong on that point but time will tell all.

    Today should be very interesting.

  31. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    @ Under sea
    Come to the surface. The DEMS will do well to survive 2014.


  32. David apropos of Balance

    I see that I am not the only person to find himself the butt of your insults.
    “You are what is wrong with this country”, you know, might just mean slagging off those you don’t agree with and then talk and talk and talk, Everyone, but everyone, on here has their prepared positions, their prejudices, their superstitions….even, God forbid, YOU, the “old David” in CCC terms. Is the concept of ‘insult’ at the root of “strong leadership”?

    So far as I read him, Balance, is, for the purpose of the post, on the other side. So what? His language is moderate; his intent clearly honourable; his substance mindful; and, for the purposes of a blog, that is surely enough. It is pretty well as creative as it’s going to get. Or don’t you think so? In this so-called BU family, we really don’t all have to take your name do we? I can’t imagine you would really want that.

  33. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    @ David,

    Not running from your query or statement of representation as that is something best reflected upon based on political culture and customs in tandem with the relevant laws. Indeed, it would be interesting for persons on BU to indicate in a sentence what is their key thinking on representation.


  34. @David (not BU)

    The issue is not whether the electorate is forced to return to the BLP. The bigger issue is that it would have been done based on default.


  35. MIA go sit down do….. a lot of poppycock and huffing and puffing not gonna get we anywhere. FOR GOD SAKE WE ARE TALKING ABOUT SOLUTIONS not GIMMICKS or political grandstanding and performing for yardfowls. STOP WASTING TIME WITH OUTLANDISH THREATS. the DLP Has alreday shown there hands .HOW ABOUT OPENING UP YOURS FOR ALL TO SEE. STUESPSE..


  36. Barbados is at the crossroads economically and politically, Barbadians and the international community are fedup with both the BLP and the DLP. I’ve been calling for it for some time now, we NEED a GENUINE alternative administration to run this country. In the mean time, i don’t see the DLP being able to do anything to remedy the present situation, therefire, either both partieds put their heads together and listen to the advice of each either, or give the BLP a chance to show how they can get us out of this mess. In the mean time a new party with new ideas must emerge to put this country in a new direction of growth.


  37. We must stop the partisan politics and become patriotic polit individuals


  38. YOU june boy gott to be kidding. THE leadership of THE BLP can.t even get the party to be unified. The members always squabbling about personnal differnces. Half the party want MIA for leader the other half want OSA and YOU up in here asking for Bajans to give the dysfunctional BLP another chance .YOU GOT TO BE F..nG NUTS NEGRO


  39. It is with great concern that I read the mouthings of this the worst Prime Minister EVER on the PAC. Is he for real?

    The Dems have been touting him as this honest man and a man of integrity. He cannot be. Why the hell he wants to change the PAC? Does he have something to hide?

    I have a friend who has always been saying that this DLP aint interested in Barbados only in getting rich and I am inclined to believe my friend. Imagine Freundel Stuart wants to trample on the rights of Barbadians to know what their government is doing.

    Instead of bringing the Integrity legislation, an issue on which they were elected in 2008, he want to shutdown any right Barbadians have to know what their government is doing.

    Bring the legislation, Freundel, I hope that this will be your downfall!


  40. David, the negative growth outlook is driven by the impact of the long overdue fiscal consolidation, but also the perceived lack of competitiveness in our key sectors tourism and international business, and the threats to rum as well. The challenges to these sectors are not primarily due to any mismanagement by any administration, there are global factors and management failures in the sectors themselves. We now need to find avenues for growth.

    Can cultural industries and renewables serve as catalysts for new sources of growth? Where are the new managers and entrepreneurs? Who is the Butch stewart of bim?

  41. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    PRODIGAL SON

    Go and get your nap.

    You are boring people this bright morning.


  42. The headline of the above thread says: “A Ring a Ring o’ Roses: BLP DLP Same Party”

    While it is true that these two intellectually politically backward bankrupt parties are essentially the same, or similar, ideologically philosophically psychologically, etc there can be no gainsaying what the author of the headline is, et al, really telling many people on BU,

    1) that he believes that there ought to be – by him and a few others – no redundancy surrounding the two,

    2) that there must be a resort – by him and a few others – to a reductionism (to eliminate any confusion over preferences by some people over any diachronic synchronic differences) in support of his and their attempting to foist his and their own hidden agenda on others (that he and they really supports both these idiotic ramshackled factions at the same time), and

    3) that there ought to be – by him and the said few others – really an equalization, or a neutralization – to a great extent – especially of the gross corrupt unsavoury bahaviours of each of them against the other, especially when in government.

    Therefore, what the author is saying otherwise is that – in the main – and in an abstract sense – the existence of one ought validate the existence of the other.

    What rubbish!!

    Worst, is that the author is framing such things on an entirely false assumption that – in the minds of especially those unsuspecting uncritical people of whom he directs his title – the BLP and the DLP are legitimate politically, when it is clear they are not – when close to 40 per cent of registered voters in the last elections did not vote for them or any body else.

    However, what we in the PDC are saying is that the time has come for the broad masses and middle classes of people to – as soon as possible – PERMANENTLY REMOVE the DLP and BLP from the political governmental landscape of this country, and to instead install a very disciplined, progressive, nationalist, developmentalist, coalition building, people centered regime to manage the affairs of this country at the highest and other levels of this country.

    PDC


  43. @Observer

    Have we ever had a Butch Stewart in Barbados even when the market was bullish?

    Many of our bright lights in business over the years have been in the distributive and retail sectors.

    Unlike some of our neighbours our entrepreneurial spirit is low.

    BU notes the Cultural Industries and Development bill introduced today in parliament.


  44. Ac
    It is because of political yardfowls from both parties that this country has become sterile. We need to be more matured and call a spade a spade irrespestive of who call you a BLP or DLP, at the end of the day, this is our country and we have to leave it for our offspring, the decisions we make now would determine what we leave for them.

  45. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    OFF TOPIC

    Another CCJ Judgement.

    CCJ Corner: Perception vs reality

    Published on October 15, 2013

    By Shara Reid
    Norman Manley Law School

    Sandy Lane Hotel Co. Limited v Brigitte Laurayne [2013] CCJ 1 (AJ)

    In a case which Justice Hayton called “a sad case where emotional feelings have clouded rational judgment,” the CCJ gave judgment in favour of the Sandy Lane Hotel in a wrongful dismissal claim brought by a former employee, Brigitte Laurayne.

    Mrs Laurayne was employed as Director of Leisure and Spa. When the hotel sought to appoint an Assistant Director to perform the day-to-day running of the massage and beauty treatments, Mrs Laurayne began to feel that she was being squeezed out. She sued the hotel claiming that she had been constructively dismissed.

    The hotel argued that the new hiring was done to lighten Mrs Laurayne’s work load and improve the standards and quality level of their spa facilities. There was no written contract and so, the Court looked at the evolution of the position of Director of Leisure and Spa over the years to find out whether it could be said there was a constructive dismissal.

    After examining the evidence, the Court concluded that there had been no substantial change to Ms Laurayne’s position. Even after the appointment of the Assistant Director, Mrs Laurayne was still in charge of the management of the spa and the Assistant Director would report to her. Therefore despite Mrs Laurayne’s “odd perception of the situation” the Court could not find that she had been dismissed and judgment was given against her.

    This summary is intended to assist the Caribbean public in learning more about the work of the CCJ. It is not a formal document of the Court. The judgment of the Court is the only authoritative document and may be found at http://www.caribbeancourtofjustice.org/wp-content

  46. Pilgrims Of The Dark Avatar
    Pilgrims Of The Dark

    The BLP annual conference will be very interesting. Will OSA and his faction support MIA or will they sit on the sidelines patiently waiting for the opportune time to deal her another mortal blow?
    At least this time around we know its not going to be OSA’s hand on the handle of the sword, its more likey to be Kerry ‘Box Knife’ Symmonds who will politically decapitate MAM. This is looking very familiar a la 2011.


  47. Stay in the dark, yardfowl. Worry about David Estwick’s next move!


  48. MAM chairperson of the BLP unopposed


  49. PS,
    Is his next move to MOF?

    Chaucer
    Will that make her safe in the context of a political challenge?


  50. Its about the party first not MAM

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading