Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Alair Shepherd QC
Alair Shepherd QC

One does not have to read Tales from the Courts to know that the judicature is in shambles. One did not have to listen to Attorneys-at-law Sean Lewis and Naomi Rochford on Getting Down to Brasstacks today to appreciate how dysfunctional our court system has become. For those left in doubt, a senior lawyer skinning his botsy at a judge last week sealed it.

The 64k question being asked by many since the incident which has gone viral is what would have provoked a senior lawyer who wears silk to behave in such an undignified manner. BU has tried to make sense of the information hitting our inbox and here is what happened between The Hon. Madam Justice Sonia Richards and Attorney-at-law Alair Shepherd QC.

The case in question involved the Commissioner of Police and several police officers, consequently many lawyers attended court that fateful morning. BU understands the case was scheduled to be heard by Madam Justice Margaret Reifer, who had recused herself, therefore the matter was rescheduled for Justice Sonia Richards for 9.30AM.

Related Link:  QC Showed Judge His Silk

Several of the lawyers concerned with the matter including Alair Shepherd QC arrived at 9.30AM. BU understands the judge arrived about 12.30PM.  Shepherd of those present appeared to have gotten riled up at having to wait 3 hours because he shouted aloud, “Hooray, hooray, she has arrived at last.” The judge asked him if he was addressing her, to which he replied, “You want me to repeat it? Hooray, hooray she has arrived at last.” Madam Richards then walked out of the court.

Madam Richards then called the lawyers out to the corridor with the exception of Shepherd and had a discussion with them. The fireworks began when Shepherd joined them in the corridor and released a verbal assault directed at Justice Richards for daring to do the unthinkable i.e. holding what the legal fraternity refer to as ex parte discussion with the other lawyers.

BU acknowledges another view posited by Caswell Franklyn which may be read HERE and HERE. If what Caswell posits is correct one would have thought that Justice Richard’s clerk would have ensured all counsel engaged in the matter were informed of the reschedule. Something smells rotten in Denmark. Surely a senior counsel merits all courtesies.

BU is on record condemning Alair Shepherd’s botsy escapade. The fact that he felt aggrieved at having to wait 3 hours while wearing silk to get the ear of the sitting judge is no excuse.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. @Hal Austin | April 16, 2013 at 6:00 AM | What criminal act? Please specify – name and identify it for us please, since you seem sure that there was a criminal act perpetrated.

    @Caswell Franklyn | April 16, 2013 at 7:26 AM |How am I a backstabber? A backstabber is one who says one thing to your face and another behind your back. You rhetoric is, stylistically, almost identical to that of your master.

    @millertheanunnaki | April 16, 2013 at 7:41 AM |Always a pleasure and always undeniable.

    @Well Well. I tend to agree with you on Crane Scott to the extent that she is likely the best of a pretty bad bunch and give her the benefit of the doubt that it is difficult to maintain excellence when surrounded by mediocrity.

    @Bushie. Believe me, the respect is most certainly reciprocated. I believe in admitting if I think I am wrong and fighting like hell when I think I am right. Note that I say “think” as there are no absolutes that I know of. With few exceptions, the BU family is like that – and that commands respect. Maybe the justice system should try it.

    @pieceuhderockyeahright! As I said, Alair is not a good friend of mine, but nonetheless I find him entertaining company and very pleasant, although, also, as I said, I sometimes have reservations about him professionally. Whether wittingly or unwittingly (and my instinct is the latter) Alair has done the justice system a signal service and opened the door for other counsel to walk through, although not, hopefully, by mooning people. Also you raised the issue of conduct at Cave Hill by the wife of Kenny Anthony and how the police did nothing. I think you may find that that particular incident was covered by diplomatic immunity and the police would not do anything without causing a diplomatic incident in which they would be found at fault.

    @Sargeant | April 16, 2013 at 8:08 AM | You are, in my view, right. There was no criminal act. Also remember that Alair is actually a top class criminal counsel. It is unlikely that he would expose himself (no pun intended) by committing a criminal act. Then too, the police officers would have to factor in undoubted repercussions for false arrest.

    @Baffy. Your are so right. Do you know Peta Alleyne? Can you bring it to her attention? I would certainly attend. I would also be really interested to know who they would get to play the role of Alair Shepherd. Any thoughts? Maybe a reality show contest on CBC is an idea to find just the right person? Could be very interesting viewing.


  2. @watching

    We have all the symptoms to show that the judicial and police systems are exploding but a political dip stick wants to give the main actors who are partly responsible a pass. Even with serious matters you look to gain political mileage, a true definition of a paling cock.


  3. @ Islandgirl246

    “I will be kissing yellow, yellow and will be kissing nuff fellow”

    I taught dat you had spurned my advanced for life but here you are giving me annuder chance.

    “I will be wearing blue, blue and looking to kiss you too”

    As you can see I am both romantic and poetic and vying for your hand still ( de madam is going to be out de island, no pun intended, from Saturday wid de women’s fellowship)

    I hope that Bushie don’t see this causing he like he got a crush on you too, not the bush lawyer fellow, his intentions towards you are suspect, especially when you always referring to he cutlass, which bring to mind an ole joke but I doan want to insult you delicacies, I want to impress you wid my good manners to whichin I was wondering if you would sen me de rest uh you cell phone number since I only got de first 3 digits 246


  4. @Pacha

    You always see red when BU uses a current state/perception to define a problem. Reference to silk is only to suggest that conventions/norms in this case predicts a behaviour that when deviated from will raise questions.


  5. @ David
    It is this very adherence to the behaviors you favor that in themselves represent the cultural destruction of Barbados. This innate assumption about the rightness of the establishment leaves no room for betterment. To make things better we ALL must to be prepared to ruthlessly and relentlessly interrogate the established order. We have to be prepared to revisit old thinking, institutions and systems.This is what you lack the intestinal fortitude to do. And we will on this day predict that your alleged interest in ‘change’ will only result in a waste of time as it has in the past. This is the central reason why we see red. We hope that that red would indeed be the blood of some who have no ability to create a better future for us all.


  6. @Pacha

    Your encouragement is noted.


  7. @ David
    We have long noted your adherence to the establishment, in true Bajan style!


  8. @Pacha

    Indees, it is a characteristic which motivated the conceptualization and launch of the Barbados Underground.


  9. @amused

    Diplomatic immunity CANNOT BE INVOKED IN CRIMINAL ACTS!!!

    @Watching

    Huh?

    You just bowled this old man a google, in-swinger bouncer in one ball!!!

    David[BU] was able to discern that you were making a statement about the recently held general elections but I “am no as swift of mind as he” and must admit that I am still struggling at the sentence where you were rambling on about this never happening under an Obama administration.

    So if I am to understand you correctly Wanting, what you are saying in plain English is that Fumble is not the rightful winner of the Recently concluded general election but Obama is.

    Further to this Wanting (a brain) you are also saying that since the United States is still a colony of Britain, queen Elizabeth is the rightful owner of all the slaves, including Kunta Kinte and Alex Hailey

    I have to go and take my insulin shots but soft awhile I shall return to decipher the anagrams related to the Guy Fawkes traitors on BU and the conspiracy that is forming here in these cyberspace walls by the asslickers, a thing which I must quickly add I agree with you about, Mark Fenty is right when he said I am a certifiable madman

    Whuloss……Baffy help Waiting (to be institutionalized) nuh?


  10. @Hal

    There will be no discipline of AS. He has thrown down the gauntlet that any attempt to come after him will be met with a full response. Whether you respect his action (mooning a judge) he is very comfortable in that world.


  11. @ David

    Disagree! BU is merely a leaver for the slaves to vent while protecting the real enemies from facing our ire. It is no more than a 21st century sophisticated intelligence gathering agent serving the powers that be.


  12. Rihanna was right after all when she noted we Bajans favourite word.

    The artists/poets/writers are always, always prophets.


  13. @ Caswell
    “What nonsense are you talking? Amused is constantly attacking me….”
    **********
    So..?!?! What is new?
    Man Caswell “people attacking you” is like throwing water on a duck’s back…..from small people were wont to attack you!!
    …you mean you ain’t get accustomed to that yet…? Bushie actually thought that you relished such attacks….

    Listen Cas, your strength lies in how much you know about all kinds of administrative rules, how well you understand them, your guts in standing for what YOU THINK is right, and your signal disregard for status.
    Such characteristics REQUIRE that you not take criticism personally even when it is…. You spend a lot of time judging others (including a lotta big fish) ….how can you expect not to be judged yourself?
    ..man tek it easy! Amused has his heart in the right place. Your ‘war’ with him is what Colonel Buggy would call friendly fire (wunna on the same side)

    @ Islandgal
    Leave out Caswell for Bushie. No one is perfect…not even the bushman (as you will find out if things work out for Bushie after Reggae on the Hill 🙂 ) …Bushie buying two extra pints of Hoad’s best goat milk for that engagement….
    Hello…yellow… 🙂

    @ Pieceuhderock…
    ….you better wear red ya hear? …cause dat may be the colour of your shirt anyhow – when Bushie finish wid the 2×4 in ya tail…..

    If you know what is good for you….keep way from anything yellow…


  14. What is wrong with people like Hal Austin, David and all the rest who are misreading events is a lack of creativity. If Alair Shepherd knows, by his demonstration, what is wrong with the legal system, we have previously argued that he should be given the authority to transform that system – if we are serious. If we are not serious our unstudied reactions would elicit punishment as if Shepherd is the slave and we – the master. That is not a reality we recognize.


  15. In my earlier submission at 10.01p Apr 15,I posited that Shepherd has no case to answer,having apologised to the offended judge.Shepherd,in our culture,is understood to be an attorney in good standing and his apology would have been the catalyst for closure in so far as the incident is concerned.
    As to whether there would now be earth shattering improvements in the Judicial system of Barbados is left to be seen.It is clear that the politicians made a big mistake in appointing Gibson,Chief Judge.The best he can do the system is to remain in South Africa .
    Btw is it coincidence that the incident between Kenny’s wife and the police sargeant came up?Is there a connection with Kenny ?


  16. @pachamama

    Balance!

    Sometimes one can see a chink in David’s armour when he speaks to a specific subject but barring what is a human trait in all of us the mere fact that he has built, and zealously maintained this site, against past and current attempts to find out who these numerous dissenters are is testimony to the fact that he is not part of the establishment as you are claiming.

    Waterfalls are birthed by the inexorable fall of water in a weak zone in a river’s bed over millions of years and while it might be my hope that some change will come, in my lifetime, 81plus x equals? the x being an indeterminate in this equation, I for one will gainsay that he is part of the status quo.

    As long as he pays the web hosting fees, does not sell BU and keeps our IP address and identities safe he remains part of the potential solution and change for good campaign

    Observe that he has not banned Baffy for life nor do a David Ellis on my brother in arms.

    On the other hand who is to say that we just don’t come here a stroke our intellectual egos like cyberspace penile organs?

    Why if we had an equivalent cyberspace Commishoner of Police, one who had the sense to identify and detain the correct suspects, notwithstanding his illegal wiretapping practices, all of us would be facing charges of intellectual masturbation in cyber land!

    Keep up the good work David


  17. Everyone knows of Alair and his propensities……………..if he threatens to go ghetto on whomever thinks they can reprimand, punish or discipline him, I think it’s safe to say that he will come down on them like a ton of bricks and let us all know their dirty secrets…………..let’s see who has the bigger, biggest balls.


  18. @David
    I don’t understand it! There are some people who contribute to BU who don’t seem to have anything positive to say about: 1. The POLITICIANS; it has to be ALL, even though the emphasis is on the Government (DLP, since they won the election ) who they see as crooks, thieves, liars, and all manner of evil, 2. The COUNTRY, which they see as going down to everlasting hell in a wheel barrow, and even where they enjoy the freedom of speech that enables this blog to exist free of persecution and prosecution, 3. The ECONOMISTS (government), because, as far as they are concerned, they don’t seem to have the answers to anything and are Stupid (even though all economists learn the same thing,) but in their opinion, the economists for the BLP seem to have the answers; even though they were in power for fourteen years and left the economy in a sorry state .4. The Barbados Police Force (especially the Chief of Police,) who in their opinion is the most incompetent of all. (didn’t they say this about other Chiefs of Police; remember “Me Hands Tied”) 5 The COURT SYSTEM and the Administration of Justice. In their opinion the Chief Justice is everything bad under the sun, and the DPP; ( who was also DPP under another administration.) should be replaced. 6. The EDUCATION System; under which they were all educated, but has now become (because their wishes have not been fulfilled), in their opinion, cumbersome and out of touch with the times, even though our scholars continue to shine brighter and brighter not only here but overseas in all spheres. 7. The GOVERNMENT itself, who they say can’t govern , even though it has come through the worst recession, intact and still progressing, despite all the predictions of doom and gloom, that begun immediately after the BLP were defeated in 2008
    I think that many, or all of them should heed the words of Mark Anthony in “Julius Caesar” who reminded Brutus that; “the fault, dear Brutus, lies not in our stars, but in ourselves.” All these people should take a deep breath, take a step back and ponder on these things.


  19. I forone is still waiting to hear a statement from the Bar Assoiciation condeming such unethical behaviour especially when such rules and guidlines are part of the code of ethics and standards than governs good conduct……….Standard Principle dictates such a response is neccessary


  20. Alvin, dear child……………..you sound like a politician to me, taxpayers don’t pay politicians to be stars and would much prefer see bang for their buck…………..can’t sweep anymore dirt under the carpet and fool the masses.


  21. @Alvin

    You are correct that on the BU we focus a lot on the underbelly of what affects our society. If you are looking for the feel good stuff tradition media is your better bet.


  22. Will the members of the judiciary ever grow these kinds of ethics.

    http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/judge-holds-contempt-cell-phone-trial-article-1.1317250

  23. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    pieceuhderock@10.07 am

    Well said!

  24. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    I should have added , as usual.


  25. LOL @ David
    Alvin is in search of a propaganda medium for his Party. Ha Ha Ha

    It is somewhat flattering that BU is seen to be so influential. At the same time it is misguided to expect that a forum created to provide TRANSPARENCY and an INTEGRITY FOCUS on behalf of the masses would suddenly want to assume the role of lackie for those who need to be monitored.

    @ Alvin
    Skippa, even “David de Boss” does have to be on his P’s and Q’s on BU…..far less a bunch of dumb jokers playing politicians.

    BTW
    Anytime you see leaders who do not VALUE INTELLIGENT CRITICISM, you are looking at jokers – destined for failure.
    ….tell Bushie any other place where criticism has been as forthright, open and objective than has been the overall case on BU…..shiite man, even ac makes sense occasionally (when there is no moon)

    @ Carson
    You doth protest too much.
    You were successful politically. Why bother continuing this demeaning bickering???
    You just like Caswell. You beat the People and you like you want them to like you and to respect your arrogance too?
    Shiite man…. Be magnanimous in victory nuh!! Invite the criticisms and RESPOND by dealing with the good suggestions made….
    …the whole damn country would benefit…as would your party.

    @ Islandgal
    What happened?
    Bushie still waiting for the call for Sunday lunch….. De bushman had to open a tin o’ sardines after waiting fuh de call til Sunday night…..
    ….you done know that Bushie now looking for the full works .. ….including appetizer and dessert…. 🙂


  26. Bushie……you really want Islandboy to shoot your kneecaps nuh. How the hell I gine introduce you to he????

  27. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Bushie

    I challenge you to produce an example where AC was making sense. If she did and I doubt: I would have missed it.

  28. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Bushie

    You see there is no Islandman: just a boy, no real man would tolerate her. She likes old men and boys that she can beat.


  29. Bushie and Caswell
    Leave My Friend Island alone.


  30. Lemmie…. thank you Caswell is hard up and into bald pooch cats but dem scarce so he and Mrs Palmer are buddies. But wait he working? He thiefing nuff time I hope the boss man ketch he!

  31. DR. THE HONOURABLE Avatar
    DR. THE HONOURABLE

    What would be the Outcome if the Judge had hoisted her garments and reveal her derriere to the goodly gentleman and asked him to kiss her somewhere on her anatomy ?

  32. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    I just read Alair Shepherd’s 1/2 apology. It was not sincere simply because he attempted to justify his action. He should have said that his behaviour was inexcusable and I offer my most sincere apology. Instead, he offered up some crap about the case being extremely important touching on the ability of the RBPF to discharge its duty. The administration of the force is not his business: he was there to represent the interest of his client. Those charged with the responsibility of administering the force seem not to be too concerned with its administration: they are hellbent on removing the Commissioner.

    The police force is not being administered properly and that is enough justification for him to invite a judge to kiss his backside. He surely needs his head examining. Maybe, I just hit on the real reason for his conduct. That is the only reason that would adequately explain his behaviour. I understand that Dr. Ermine Belle specialises in treating this type of behaviour. He should make an appointment before its too late.


  33. Caswell……..who is going to arrest Alair if he is representing the COP??, tell me who do you think would even want to reprimand him in that incestous system.


  34. did caswell call AC name. O.k. Caswell u asked for it and iam gesturing u an AS with gas and all………Pooooopppppp; how is that for a little Common sense.

  35. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Well Well

    I cannot answer that question, and that is unfortunate: it says that if you have a certain standing in this country, you could get away with anything. I remember going to court as a witness and the Magistrate saw the hair on my chest because the top button on my shirt was undone: I was not wearing a tie. I apologised for the distraction and buttoned the shirt. I suspect that she was aroused at the sight and could not keep her composure, I am not bad looking you know.

    Seriously though, the hair on my chest offender the court and almost got me thrown out, and clowns are trying to justify Alair’s deliberate abuse.


  36. http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/judge-holds-contempt-cell-phone-trial-article-1.1317250

    Caswell………you may or may not have seen the above link from earlier, judges do have that judicial power to even find themselves in contempt of court and act accordingly…………you and I both know that is not something we will witness in our life time in Bim……………………however, they also will not reprimand or discipline each other because of all the secrets and dirt that can be thrown around……………….everyone else is fair game………see the above link, if you did not do so earlier.

    Alair is deliberately abusing cause he knows what he knows and that is they better not mess with him.

  37. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Well Well

    Thanks for the link. You would celebrate your 250th birthday before you see something like that in our courts.


  38. Caswell…………..I think so too………………as funny as it is.


  39. Has there been any comment from the Barbados Bar Association which led by Andrew Pilgrim QC?


  40. Caswell Franklyn | April 16, 2013 at 5:33 PM |
    I just read Alair Shepherd’s 1/2 apology. It was not sincere simply because he attempted to justify his action. He should have said that his behaviour was inexcusable and I offer my most sincere apology. Instead, he offered up some crap about the case being extremely important touching on the ability of the RBPF to discharge its duty. The administration of the force is not his business:
    ———————————————————————-

    Well said and to know this piece of sh#t is going to get away with it makes me want to puke. A block boy would get lost away in jail for merely cutting he eye at a judge. I have no time for Shepherd and his ass lickers. If his lewd rude display to the High Court judge ends here its like getting away with murder. Next time a low waist pants showing the crack in his ass ZR man appears in court for bewsing a cop he can use Shepherd’s pathetic red herring excuse and tell the judge to f%#k off. Justice must be blind if its to be embraced by all.


  41. Looks like the Justice System needs a serious overhauling! A progressive society such as ours should not be handicapped by a dysfunctional legal system. There must be a remedy for the malaise that permeates the Courts.


  42. Well now that the standard apology has been rendered we would expect the truculent comments to subside and a prosaic normalcy to return. Any glimmer of an opportunity to transform would have been lost and the forces insistent on the maintenance of the status quo would have won. This in itself comes as no surprise as these are the same forces which have been defeating progress for 500 years. A lot of the old boys may have died but they have all kinds of sophisticated minions thinking, breathing and speaking for them. The dead continues to defeat the living.


  43. We have not had any condemnation coming from the Attorney General and government, Church, Women Groups, Bar Association, Media Houses etc.

    What is wrong with us? The very act which Bush Tea et al have described as disruptive becomes ineffective because key actors in society do not give two hoots.


  44. And I am taking note that all those affected by the gross respect are all black, yet they cannot lift a finger…….talk about balless.


  45. Island
    I hope you notice how Well Well and Caswell agreeing; now he has a friend he shall leave you alone. I now have to work on the Bushman.


  46. Who is listening to the rubbish being uttered by Peter Wickham on the airwaves of Barbados on this matter.

    No wonder!


  47. We can now deduce by the loud silence in regard to no reprimand, punishment or disciplinary action taken against Alair, that he knows everything about each and everyone of those ball-less, gutless members of the judiciary and will let it all fly if he is provoked.


  48. David
    Peter normally protects his people. Need I say more about Alena Shepherd.

  49. Gabriel Tackle Avatar

    @Dr The Honourable
    The lady’s derriere used to be the most prominent and delightful part of her anatomy in her student days,although based on the submissions of the blogs,such talent would have been wasted on the silk.


  50. Having said all of that, the problem still stares us in the face, what are we doing about our judicial system? What are we going to do about the issue with the police? Are we going to wait until the police says enough is enough and slow down further in carrying out their duties and let the crime fully take over this Barbados? A rising crime rate will do nothing for our economy. Its a real political mess.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading