Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Minister Denis Lowe (1) Peter Allard (r)

What has been exposed by the hair raising report prepared by Judicial Manager Deloitte is the light regard directors of CLICO companies viewed their fiduciary responsibility. Directors followed meekly the dictate of Parris which  speaks to a weak corporate governance system. It is only god’s mercy we have enjoyed a stable financial climate through the years. What other rotten situations are waiting in the wings to surprise Barbadians? A read of the Auditor General’s Report gives a hint at what happens in the public sector. BU is waiting patiently on the newly established Financial Services Commission (FSC) to demand insurance companies like CGI, Trident and others publish timely financials in the private sector.

If one can find reason to laugh at the current situation, it is the suggestion that the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) can easily run a campaign in the next general election on the need for improved corporate governance and transparency! The Democratic Labour Party (DLP) has failed to deliver on transparency legislation although there is still time. Against the foregoing we are concerned at goings-on at the Caves of Barbados Limited.

Those who have visited the Caves since major repair work have been rightly impressed. It must be stated however that Barbadian taxpayers will have to repay a loan of 88 million dollars as a result. There is also a BNB 5 million dollar overdraft which the Caves of Barbados require to support its day to day operations.  In the circumstances the role of the board of directors at  Caves of Barbados is important to ensure taxpayers interest is safeguarded.

BU understands the Caves of Barbados board expires on Wednesday (29/02/2012) but it has been a stormy tenure. It is reported Haldene Dottin in protest resigned as Chairman some time ago. In the circumstances Deputy Chairman Wismar Greaves as required under the by-laws of the company has experienced difficulty in calling monthly board meetings. It appears Minister Denis Lowe, the minister responsible for the Caves of Barbados has issued ‘an order’ that board meetings should not be held until he introduces a new Chairman to replace Haldene Dottin. A copy of a letter sent by Deputy Chairman Greaves in October 2011 to CEO of the Caves Joanne Grant expresses the sorry state of affairs prevailing at the Caves of Barbados. A reminder that the Caves of Barbados is a limited liability company with government as the sole shareholder.

Why did Minister Denis Lowe believe he should prevent or frustrate the scheduling of board meetings as required under the by-laws of the Caves of Barbados? Why has the full board of directors not tender their resignations in protest?  What does CEO Grant of Harrison Cave and Minister Denis Lowe have in  common as employees of the crown? Why is the son of former politician Rommell Marshall still entitled to a Blackberry from the cash strapped Caves of Barbados with a high bill?

In the letter attached there is the notification that Prime Minister Fruendel Stuart authorized relevant parties at the Caves of Barbados to allow Deputy Chairman to call a meeting on the premises. How on earth does anyone anyone have the effrontery to go against the instruction of a Prime Minister?  This is not the first time we have have asked for the resignation of Minister Lowe. His relationship with Peter Allard has generated several unanswered questions. The fact that Prime Minister Stuart has to tolerate such weak performances from ministers to shore up his parliamentary support is regrettable.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

124 responses to “Corporate Governance Awry At Caves Of Barbados”


  1. David

    You should not be surprised by anything that happens at statutory boards and companies owned by Government that are incorporated under the Companies Act. Government might give several reasons for using these types of structures to carry out its business but, I remain convinced that the major reasons for creating these bodies are to enable politicians to get their hands on public money without much oversight, and to enable them to employ their friends.

    Ministers of Government prefer these bodies rather than the Public Service because they can do as they like and they generally do.


  2. @Caswell

    What is puzzling is why straight talker Greaves has not tendered his resignation. Is the stipend that attractive?

    We need to start holding these director’s hands to the fire.


  3. David,

    I had heard that Minister Lowe was chairing the board meetings. Haldane could not take it anymore, it would seem.


  4. @Prodigal Son

    We hope when the BLP forms the next government, certainly looks that way at the moment, Arthur and the BLP seizes the opportunity to improve the governance structure in Barbados. No doubt he will be interested it building his legacy.


  5. David,
    I hope so, I am sick and tired of people not doing the right thing when they get into the office. The lackies who should know better are the ones who give the government a bad name. I just want what is right and good for our fair land.


  6. David

    The way the present Administration is behaving would make it appear as though they have given up, and they are holding the door open for Arthur to return. However, don’t hold your breath for them to improve the governance structure in this country anytime soon. After all, it was the Arthur Administration, in its dying days, that put the Public Service Act in place which is now responsible for devastating the Public Service. A good structure was in place which had checks and balances but, that had to go if the politicians wanted to get their way.

    Those of you who were around in 1982, and following the trends in public service employment, would remember when a politician wanted to have an employee at a statutory board fired. The matter was referred to the Statutory Boards Service Commission. The commission could find no fault with the employee and refused to terminate the employee. The matter was sent back to the commission and again they refused. Since the commission refused to be part of a political victimization campaign, the Minister went to Parliament with a bill to abolish the commission. The bill was passed and thereafter the individual boards have been responsible for hiring and firing usually at the behest of their Minister. So David don’t hold your breath: they like it so.

  7. millertheanunnaki Avatar

    One can now easily conclude that F S is the poorest leader this country has had so far. He had a golden opportunity to sideline the Lowe(st) of the lot whose habits are well known. His long bout of sickness and near death experience should have been used as an opportunity to give him a much needed rest from ministerial responsibilities.
    We beg you Mr. Top Dog, please call elections now. It’s too hard on the people. We not only have the prolonged worst recession to deal with but these scandals one after the other are sapping the spirit of the people and ruining the international image of Bim. We did not vote for this low(e) quality of governance. We as a people can do better. Please Cammie, whisper in your boy ears when he is asleep (If that happens) tonight. We will keep dreaming.


  8. Cave too? Wait till you see what is happening at Serbourne at the management level.

    it is really sad what these ppl are doing.


  9. Well did I not tell you ac …”What next will grace our shores highlighting incompetence” it was not long before some other blunder be in the media, of this admin’s shoddy run,..”holding onto the reigns of a chariot wild horses, at all cost, having no idea what is going on.” (Se. Symmonds)
    Call the elections Mr.Prime Minister (Miller) before more is exposed.
    Give poor Barbados some chance to recover,rather than selfishly thinking of oneself.Longer the wait, the more difficult will be the recovery process.


  10. @ David (not BU)

    What is happening at Sherbourne? Is it that the Minister having a field day? Curiously would Minister Sealy please tell us if the contractor for the new car-park at LESC was the lowest bid?


  11. Is the lowest bid always the best?

    Remembering the insurance contract that was given to CGI by Rommell Marshall when minister of transport.

  12. Adrian Loveridge Avatar

    David,

    THE LESC CAR PARK

    BDS$8.5 million for a 321 space car park.
    At 6 per cent interest that puts a per space (car) per day cost of $4.35 assuming that the car park is FULLY occupied 365 days a year. And thats before capital repayment, maintenance, staffing costs etc.
    Or at a more achievable 80 per cent occupancy, $5.44 per space per day.
    Is Government going to charge the civil servants to park there?


  13. We want it so!!

    That’s why we accept the same warmed over rubbish every five years even though they have proven their incompetence, greed and avarice beyond a shadow of a doubt.

    Not one is ever held to account.

    We need to grow up.

    Maybe it is time for independents and or a third party to step forward and run a campaign on integrity, honesty and transparency.

    For sure, neither the DLP nor the BLP could find a counter.


  14. @John
    No third party will make a difference – it is the nautre of the beast that we are dealing with. As soon as they get in and see what sweets are available, it will be same old, same old…


  15. Being reported in the news that PM Stuart is promising the anti corruption and integrity legislation before his term ends. Even if it is implemented it comes over as being disingenuous so close to an election.

  16. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    And the Top Dog has the “gall’ to say that Integrity legislation will soon be enacted.

    Fool me once shame on you. Fool me twice shame on me. But talking crap ad nauseam, what a stupid people we are to listen!
    We are sick and tired of these idle and empty promises from both parties.

    We want action. You have already made this promise in your manifesto to be implemented within 100 days. Do you think intelligent right thinking people would do anything but take this with a pinch of salt? If you can’t implement something that does not require any major financial resources, not a drain on foreign reserves or need for FDI within a 4 year time frame how do we expect you to implement your knee jerk reaction to the CLICO scandal. Drowning man grasping at straws!


  17. @ David

    The lowest is not always the best price, but what about the second lowest, what about the third lowest? All of this was after a pre-qualification of contractors process, this means that Barbados Conference Services approved the contractors invited to tender but then told the 3 lowest, thanks but your price is too cheap.


  18. Kind of like the contractor who has the contract for the renovations to the main LESC building. What that contractor pre-qualified…………NOT. Was that contractor the lowest bid……….NOT.


  19. @David. Not sure you are right that it is disingenuous. We all saw the draft and it was very tight and well written, BUT, it was just a draft. Personally, I am not surprised that it took so long. When you are opening as large a can of entrenched worms as that, you have to make as sure as you can that you get it right. I always suspected that Thompson’s estimate of the time it would take was wildly optimistic. Completely unrealistic, in fact. However, it is to the eternal credit of the blogs that it has got as far as it has.


  20. @Amused

    The disappointment comes because the BU household and many others bought in to the idea that the DLP was all about implementing change – especially as it relates to transparency legislation and corporate governance. Here we are approaching an election four years hence and nothing.

    Totally fed up by the whole lot!


  21. Caves will be a joke compared to some of the crap the present board is doing at the Transport Board. Imagine that Transtech is being allowed to rape the TB of the few cents it has with its large invoices, imagine that transmissions and parts can be built and bought a lot cheaper but since Transtech and its owner is a huge supporter of the DLP he is being allowed by the board to charge 3-5 times the going rate and no one says a word. The present board along with the General Manager (who is also the DLP Treasurer) are treating this place like their playground and playing with peoples jobs. All these statutory boards are just a “legal” way to put money in the hands of friends and supporters.

  22. millertheanunnaki Avatar

    @ Amused | February 27, 2012 at 9:30 AM |
    So we the ordinary members of the voting public should be grateful that the DLP Administration’s piece of “very tight and well written draft legislation” is at last being resurrected and ready to be discussed in the political talk shop. Why are you NOT surprised that it took so long? Is this so because it is in keeping with the pervasive incompetence and inefficiency of the legal industry in Bim. The change in legislation to get the new CJ on board or the bill to establish the constituency councils did not face such lengthy delays. What is this “can of entrenched worms”? Are you referring to the bunch of “corrupt” people in this fair Christian land who see public service as a fast track way of getting rich and whose crooked wheeling-dealings to short change taxpayers might be severely curtailed or exposed for righteous men to see and pursue in the name of justice?


  23. David, after reading the letter from Mr Greaves, the CEO Ms Grant should be fired, but it is obvious that she is doing the bidding of Mr. Lowe so nothing would come out of it. I makes me wonder how some of these people get their jobs if sitting, standing or on their backs? Just asking.


  24. Driver

    You said,

    “All these statutory boards are just a “legal” way to put money in the hands of friends and supporters”.

    That is only partially correct: it is not legal. The problem is the enforcement of the law. Those in authority refuse to prosecute or even draw the illegal activities to the relevant authorities for fear that they would be going after family and friends, or even lodge brothers. The charge is misfeasance in public office. That is where you have the power to do something but do it illegally. For instance if you are the minister responsible for town planning and you refuse an application for a change of use, the property is then purchased by a friend of the minister and then the change of use is approved. Mind you I am only referring about a hypothetical situation because we know that no self respecting minister would do anything like that


  25. Harrison Cave is located on the property of a number of people, when is Government going to compensate those land owners for the use of their property, which should really take the form of royalties in much the same way as those people who have properties in the vicinity of oil wells.


  26. Whos is the Chairman of the Transport Board? And does he have a consultancy of $10 000 a month with Minstry of Public Works and what does he get that money for doing? Think for a while


  27. Was there a recent resignation from the Sanatation Authority Board and why, and under whose portfolio such a Board falls?


  28. @ David February 26 2012 @ 10:46PM
    I do not know the gentelman Mr. Wismar Graves but i do know Mr. Haldene Dottin very well , he is the type of person that dose not stand for any Bull ….. from no one and that is why he was able to walk away from his chairmanship. Mr. Lowe was able to do as he like when he was the MInister over The Water Authority as the board was not able to function as it should have and the late Prime Minister at the time was unable to do any thing about the the problem , and so it is no supprise that the board at the cave is suffering from the same blockage, and this present Prime Minister seem not to able to do any thing about it . It appares that if u don’t share the same ideology as the Minister then u may find yourself wanting .


  29. Caswell Franklyn | February 27, 2012 at 10:26 AM |
    Harrison Cave is located on the property of a number of people, when is Government going to compensate those land owners for the use of their property, which should really take the form of royalties in much the same way as those people who have properties in the vicinity of oil wells.
    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    On …. or under?

    There are alternative questions as well, some of them frightening.

    Is there a need for Government install a sewage system to prevent contamination of one of the major underground stream flows that feed Applewaithes Pumping Station and the sheet water resource that feeds Belle and Codrington?

    Does the Government need to find alternative accommodation for residents who own land over the cave?

    Are there geotechnical problems which in some areas could produce a repetition of Arch Cot?

    The problem is that having researched deeper and deeper into the system of caves in the area the Government cannot claim ignorance.

    The system of caves is not only a wonderful asset but it can become a severe liability.


  30. @ ?????????

    Workshop Consultant? lmao


  31. @ Caswell, Yes it is the same gentleman that you referred to, and I believe that he is the workshop manager or workshop consultant. Either way he is a concultant to the workshop and also Transport Board Chairman, and yes he went to combermere too, around the same time at the last PM


  32. @ Caswell

    Change of use is not a legal or illegal matter….lol

  33. Caswell Franklyn Avatar

    Enuff

    I never said that change of use was a legal or an illegal matter. I pointed out that misfeasance in public office is when you do something that you had the power to do but you do it corruptly.


  34. @Driver

    If these things are occurring wouldn’t it interest the Opposition? Why are they silent?


  35. David i would think they are wait for the bell.

    ask this question and see how the pack of cards come falling down. who paying back the loan for the car park and the work on the back of Sherbourne?

    wanna want madness, answer and see madness.


  36. @David (not BU)

    Why don’t you answer the question?


  37. because i don’t want to. i just tell you where to look an what to ask.


  38. @ David (not BU)

    The more salient questions are (1) did Preconco do work, pay for work and or supply materials for Minister Sealy when he renovated his house in Rendezvous, (2) did CRS do work, pay for work and or supply materials for Minister Sealy when he renovated his house in Rendezvous?

    Is the answer no or YES


  39. man i don’t believe these guys would be so careless in this day and age to do something like that.


  40. And the ‘R’ in CRS is the Chairman of the St. Michael Central Constituency Council. By the way his deputy is none other than Carson Cadogan who since the revelation of the $3.3 million and other cheques to DT can no longer talk about $75,000 and is MIA.


  41. @david not bu
    “I can’t believe these guys so careless”

    This is the big issue. 6 is half dozen, but after rejecting a previous half dozen you would hope that your 6 lasts a little longer before they went bad. FS has a good heart, but he’ll need a lion’s heart to clean up house. I don’t think that after AX, the GG and the 11 that anyone’s really holding their breath for FOI and Prevention of corruption. Especially when enough gov’t ministers can’t afford to let it see the light of day.

  42. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    The folks over at Barbados free press have an interesting piece;-

    “Now you’ll notice that Owen doesn’t deny that he or any of his fellow BLP members had or have offshore bank accounts. Do you see what I’m talking about? Saying that talk about offshore bank accounts is ‘nastiness’ and ‘a lot of foolishness’ is not the same thing as saying “I have never had an offshore bank account while I was a Member of Parliament.”

    So let’s hear from Owen $ Arthur. Let’s hear him clearly say to the press…

    “I have never had an offshore bank account, whether in my name or another name, while I was a Member of Parliament.”

    Go ahead Owen. Let’s hear you loud and clear…”

    http://barbadosfreepress.wordpress.com/2012/02/28/one-thing-owen-arthur-will-never-say/#comment


  43. @Carson Cadogan

    Do you quote BU over at BFP?

  44. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ Carson C. Cadogan | February 28, 2012 at 7:21 PM |

    Why don’t you just quit through the backdoor while the fire is still in the front room?
    When you address the CLICO /David Thompson scandal we might just hear your cries and provide you with the key to escape.
    Carson, we beg you to crawl back under the slimy rock in George St. before you are squashed by the truth or the bloggers’ salt thrown on you like a slug. And while you are at it, advise mara to resign with dignity.


  45. That car park at LESC is one hell of an expensive car park.

    What was the sense of building a car park before the renovations were complete, has anyone taken a driven up to LESC and seen the number of ground level, asphalt paved car park spaces there are and how many of them are empty most of the time on any given day? LESC never needed a multi-level car park but the contractor needed a project.


  46. @ millertheanunnaki

    Are you planning on going to Haggatt Hall on Sunday for the BLP meeting which is being touted a show & tell all about David Thompson, CLICO and Leroy Parris? I guess in politics even death is is not the way to gurantee that revenge is not repaid.

  47. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    millertheanunnaki(May2012)

    I am simply drawing attention to an article over at BFP.
    I know that is does not show your people(BLP) in the best light, but that is the way it is.

  48. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    millertheanunnaki(May2012)

    I have a towel for you to wipe the egg off your face.

    May 2012, indeed!!


  49. miller & old onions,

    Wait, what rock CCC now crawl from under? Revelations on the dead king on BU had him hiding for weeks and he now come quoting something from off BFP. Man you should be ashamed to talk about corruption.

    To use your words, CCC, let’s hear it for ALL the CLICO cheques made payable to DT, the FALSE invoices that were prepared for work supposedly done. That is FRAUD. The money laundering Thompson Associates engaged in.

    As office manager, she would have been the one who signed the cheques passing on the money to Leroy Parris.

    All the while, after the dead king proclaimed that “I will not lie, cheat or steal!

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending