Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Police Commissioner Dwayne Gibbs – photo credit Trinidad Express
GIBBS CATCHES SPIES …uncovers illegal tapping of phones, monitoring of text messages and e-mails


By Lennox Grant

An early-morning police raid, ordered by Police Commissioner Dwayne Gibbs, on a secret snooping agency within the National Security Ministry has brought to light an extensive list, including Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar and private citizens whose phone calls, text messages and e-mails have been monitored over five years.…read full article

 

In Barbados we have heard accusations levelled at Commissioner Darwin Dottin that CWC2007 technology was used to monitor the calls of Barbadians. Many of us expressed scepticism which runs counter to the way we have done things in Barbados over the years. Yes we live in a world where the criminal element has become very sophisticated and our security forces need to keep pace.

The above therefore provokes the question – who is guarding the guards.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

21 responses to “Is Illegal Tapping Of Phones, Monitoring Text Messages, E-mails Occurring In Barbados? – Who Is Guarding The Guard? Anderson Bowen Can You Help Us Please?”


  1. […] private conversations was taking place within Trinidad and Tobago's National Security Ministry, Barbados Underground wonders whether the same thing could be happening in Barbados and asks: “Who is guarding the […]


  2. David – it was only a matter of time before a story of this nature surfaced. This has been going on for ages!!!


  3. BU suspects the motivation of the government of T&T to expose wrong doing of the PNM is different for Barbados. The DLP and BLP are peas in a pod.


  4. If true it is about time!

    Cops out?

    Fri, November 12, 2010 – 12:10 AM

    IF RECOMMENDATIONS BY THE POLICE SERVICES COMMISSION are accepted by the powers that be, a new Commissioner of Police and deputy should soon be in place.

    The commission has recommended that senior superintendents Erwin Boyce and Mark Thompson take over the two top posts, replacing Commissioner of Police Darwin Dottin and his deputy Bertie Hinds, who are both expected to take up senior administrative positions in the Civil Service.

    WEEKEND NATION investigations indicate the recommendations were sent to then Attorney General Freundel Stuart now Prime Minister, and the Chief Personnel Officer last August, following internal and public bickering between the island’s two top cops.

    Our information suggests that once the recommendations get Government’s nod, both Dottin and Hinds would take up permanent secretary posts with Hinds expected to have responsibility in ensuring a smooth transition in what would be a major shake-up among the top ranks of the force.

    “A lot has happened since last August, so maybe this has been the source of the delay in acting on the recommendations,” said a source who is privy to the commission’s recommendations.

    The source said that Boyce and Thompson had both earned the respect of their peers for their sterling investigative work.

    They would be catapulted to the top posts over current Assistant Commissioners of Police Tyrone Griffith, Oral Williams, Emmerson Moore and Seymour Cumberbatch.

    Boyce, 51, currently in charge of the Special Branch, is a 31-year veteran of the organisation and the holder of a Bachelor’s degree in history and Master’s in business, with a core stream in human resources management from the University of the West Indies.

    He spent several years in the Criminal Investigation Department and has been credited with spearheading most of the force’s major enquiries into fraud and financial investigations. He declined comment on the reports.

    Outstanding career

    Thompson, 48, one of the force’s top detectives in an outstanding 29-year career, is an attorney-at-law. He is a graduate of the University of the West Indies [UWI] with a BSc degree in sociology and law and an LLB.

    The first Barbadian policeman to graduate with Upper Second Class Honours in law from the UWI, Thompson is currently in charge of the Bridgetown Division, and has also served as commandant of the Regional Police Training College. When reached yesterday he also declined  comment.

    Commissioner Dottin said he was unaware of any such developments while Hinds could not be reached.

    Neither Dr Trevor Carmichael, QC, chairman of the Services Commission, nor veteran lawyer Keith Simmons, his deputy, could be reached. No phone calls were returned.

    Attempts to contact Prime Minister Freundel Stuart last night were also unsuccessful. (cg)


  5. The above story is so incredible that if the major aspects of it turn out to be true we would be seeing a new application of the powers of the Services Commission.

    It suggests that the Services Commissions (I presume the Police Services Commission) investigated a very public falling out of the Police Commissioner and his Deputy, concluded that neither of them could be normally sanctioned and not only recommended that both of them be removed from their substantive posts but reappointed to posts in the General Public Service at the same level as Commissioner. Thus the Deputy was promoted while the Commisioner remained at the same level.

    The report also suggests that the Services Commission recommended the catapulting of 2 relatively junior Officers over at least 3 senior ones to fill the 2 vacancies in the Police Department that would be created by the lateral move of the Commissioner and his Deputy out of the Police Department proper.

    If any significant portion of the story is true it would suggest that the Services Commission is employing a possibly unique method that might cause some confusion in the Police force and it would not be surprising if a number of Lawyers might be now licking their chops at the prospect of being provided with a litigants paradise since there are at least 5 people who might not be amused at the alleged decisions made to either involuntarily remove them from their present posts or to supercede them in their normal expectations to apply for higher posts such as commissioner or deputy commssioner when such becomes vacant.

    Interesting times.

    Suggest the Nation does some more checking of the story. Much of it does’nt seem credible even though it is possible that the Services Commission does have the power to enforce the separate promotions, demotions, etc. which separately might be OK but taken together in one fell swoop could create confusion.

    Is it possible that there is very much more in the mortar than the pestle?


  6. David

    Since this post was sparked by the report on the raid in T & T I read some comments by former PM Manning (see attached) in which he noted that this Branch of the Security apparatus of the State was set up under Panday when the present PM was Attorney General. He indicated that he didn’t know anything about it (which I find difficult to believe).

    However the question is if we accept that it was set up under a previous Administration with the full knowledge of the present PM isn’t it a case of they knowing “where the bodies are buried” and feigning surprise that such a Department existed and the raison d’être for its existence?

    Politrics Trini style

    http://www.nationnews.com/articles/view/manning-unaware-of-phone-tapping/


  7. @ checkit-out “2 relatively junior Officers over at least 3 senior ones to fill the 2 vacancies.”

    If the two juniors have proven their competence and have relevant qualifications what is wrong with promoting them?

    This concept of succession based on length of service is nonsense.
    The Police need competent leadership.


  8. @Hants

    Agree with you. There is the obsolete notion that to be experience is all that it takes to do the job. Dottin and Hinds screwed up and they need to go. We are entering a different time and we want our best leading the BPF as we would any enterprise.


  9. @Sargeant

    There has to be more…

    In Barbados there has to be more…


  10. David

    Wasn’t the policeman who made the allegations in Barbados recently cleared of internal charges? I think I read that he was reinstated with full back pay.

    That ensures that none of the evidence will be heard in an open forum, everything swept under the rug.

    Which begs the question if the present Gov’t discovered that wire tapping of citizens was widespread why wouldn’t they expose it? Or would they then use it to their advantage?


  11. Two reasons Sergeant, cover-up like you stated or the matter is viewed as a matter of national security if made public. Bear in mind there has been some coverup in the Campus Trendz matter by some.

  12. Robert Deschappé Avatar
    Robert Deschappé

    If the story in the Nation newspaper is true, the appointments of Mr. Boyce and Mr. Thompson is a step in the right direction for the Royal Barbados Police Force. Instead, I would have preferred if they had chosen ACP Oral Williams to oversee the transition rather than DCP Hinds (but the Police Force is part of the Civil Service, and Bertie’s party is in power).

    As a former police detective [not in Barbados], judging from their qualifications, outstanding records as detectives, and their overall general characteristics, I am of the opinion that Boyce and Thompson will take the Police Force into the modern era.

    I have stated on this blog that the RBFP needs more qualified officers, specialising in certain areas, so as to enable the police to be proactive in dealing with crime, especially, as it relates to crimes that may be new to Barbados. It worked in the country I grew up in, and we had some very good results in controlling crime. For example, we had officers who had BA (Hons) Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation, who were used in cases where profiling was necessary. Some officers in the Special Branch pursued the BSc Security and Terrorism. There was no need to solicit help from outside the Police Service. Barbados does not have to go to this extreme, but we could equip the force to deal with the challenges of these changing times.


  13. Hi Hants;
    You said at “Hants | November 14, 2010 at 9:58 AM | “2 relatively junior Officers over at least 3 senior ones to fill the 2 vacancies. If the two juniors have proven their competence and have relevant qualifications what is wrong with promoting them?
    This concept of succession based on length of service is nonsense.
    The Police need competent leadership.”

    I totally agree with you that the concept of succession based on length of service is nonsense and I have absolutely no problem with 2 juniors who have proven their competence to operate at a significantly senior level, being promoted above officers who have PROVEN that they are not as capable as the aforementioned juniors to carry out the duties of the higher office. But I think there must be due process and transparency and I’m sure the Officer’s union or unions think likewise. The Nation story does not indicate that there has been a process carried out to seriously evaluate the possible claims that any of the officers might have had for promotion to the top posts in the Police Force. Indeed, reading between the lines it seems as if there might have been an investigation of one problem area and the Services Commission took it upon themselves to right a number of possible wrongs at the same time. Their actions might be absolutely legally ironclad but imho it sends the wrong message insofar as the promotions of the 2 junior officers are concerned. What was the process carried out to evaluate the 6 officers involved and their readiness or lack thereof for promotion to the top posts? Did an evaluation of the 4 officers superceded indicate that any (or all) of them was unlikely to be a competent Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner? Were their imputed political leanings taken into account in any evaluation? Did any of them have relevant degree or higher degree qualification? Did they all do badly in documented performance evaluations? Were only the Law degree and Higher qualifications of the juniors the overweening factors in their being reportedly recommended for promotions?

    The two officers have apparently done very well in their substantive posts but does that necessarily mean that they will similarly do well in the top posts? remember that the current holders of the top posts would both have been highly qualified and yet have found themselves subject to transfer presumably for cause.

    My problem is due process and transparency not meritocracy. If a proper evaluation was done I would have no problem with the reported outcome.

    But of course the Services Commission is made up of all honourable persons and I am sure that they would have taken all these factors into consideration. Lets hope the Unions agree if there is any truth to the details of this story.

  14. Robert Deschappé Avatar
    Robert Deschappé

    @checkit-out
    Lets hope the Unions agree if there is any truth to the details of this story.

    I understand that the police association of Barbados represent police officers to the rank of Inspector. Those senoir officers involved are gazetted officers.


  15. Thanks, Robert Deschappe; I stand corrected. So, assuming the story is true, does that mean that the 4 superceded officers have no recourse and cannot contest the apparent ruling even if one or more of them might have impeccable records and perhaps even a degree or two.

    Just general questions, as I have absolutely no knowledge of the qualifications or otherwise of any of the four officers superceded and just have a vague memory that I heard somewhere that the current commissioner and his deputy were both graduates.

    But doesn’t something seem just a little bit wrong in the Nation report? The posters who have commented on this matter have essentially accepted the report at face value and concluded that it is OK for two persons with degrees and who have operated well in their Junior Posts to be leapfrogged over 4 persons who may or may not have degrees but have presumably operated adequately in their APC posts for years, all in the name of meritocracy.

    One could understand one or two of the APC’s having a documented history of suboptimal performance. But all four?

    I wonder which high school the 2 officers reported to be slated for promotion went to?


  16. There seems to be a game called ‘personalities before principles’ in the RBPF so that in essence principles seems to have gone thru the door but there is still hope.Put a woman in front and see how fast a plan comes together.Same goes for HMP.BDF and every major government agency. Madness? I think not!


  17. One of the most stupid things is to feel that no one can hear what you are saying if you have a private telephone or you own a high tech cell phone or you have the higest speed internet.Are you ever free of illegal tapping(I think not) Big Brother is always listening…..and…..watching.


  18. Interesting to note Bertie Hinds and not Darwin Dottin performed at the remembrance parade yesterday.


  19. @ checkit out
    From what I can remember, ACP Oral Williams is the only officer in the group of four who has a Bachelor’s degree, I think he also has a Master’s. A couple of years ago, Emmerson Trotman was featured in the Investigator complaining that he was being overlooked each time promotions came around, because he worked his way through the ranks and had no formal qualifications. He was promoted shortly after. ACP Cumberbatch spent many years in the CID. Tyrone Griffith was slated to achieve the Commissioner post, but unfortunately, he was on suspension for a number of years because of allegations of the importation of stolen cars. There was also ans alleged altercation at the Holetown Police Station, between him, a RBPF Sargeant, and an officer from Scotland Yard who was investigating the matter. On his reinstatement, Griffith was the recipient of double promotions, which catapulted him to his present rank.

    We definitely need new blood


  20. There is no such thing as illegal wire tapping when the national security of a state is being threaten. The balance ought to be made between the insurance of the civil – rights and civil – liberties with the need to ensure the national security of a state. I surely do not mine the government infringing upon my civil – rights and civil – liberties to ensure my safety.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending