Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Minister of Social Care, Constituency Empowerment and Urban Development

To be frank BU was somewhat floored to listen to Leader of the House Minister Chris Sinckler request an adjournment of the House until 19 October 2010, a break of about two months. The closing of the doors of the House of Assembly comes at a time when the country remains in the vice grip of an economic recession.  It also comes at a time when the country remains expectant given the non delivery of the annual Financial Statement and Budgetary Proposals.

Didn’t the House have a recess for four weeks not too long ago? Is it a ploy to kill time until the return of the one who easily defines primus inter pares on the government side?

The day will be remembered for how the troops rallied around Minister of Housing Michael Lashley who has been under the hammer in recent days.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

67 responses to “Government Pulls Stumps For Two Months”


  1. Dear Robert,

    Our tax revenues have not been reduced as a result of the recession (why does nobody look at the numbers?) You would expect them to have been reduced, it would be normal, but as a result of significant tax rises in the 2008 budget and some in the 2009 budget, tax revenues in 2010 are around the same levels as in 2007. This is remarkable and quite unique around the world where 90% of deficits are a result of Governments deciding, unlike our own Government, to keep tax rates the same and allow tax revenues to fall with the recession.

    Our deficit has arisen as a result of expenditure jumping sharply – around 20% plus increase in Government expenditure since 2007. This jump in the level of expenditure is not related to BOLTs as they were largely already in expenditure levels – under the revised figures presented by the Governor- by 2007. So this is new expenditure.

    Trying to make a good job of this mess, some Government spokesmen argue that this was all part of a cunning plan to keep employment up, even though it was never presented as this, or debated as this, or a result of some study. If indeed, it was all part of a cunning plan, then this plan has us spending something like $250,000 to $500,000 on every job saved assuming that the budget expenditure kept unemployment from rising between 3% and 6% of the workforce. This does not seem very cunning at all. It seems like the kind of cunning plan you would get from Baldrick in Blackadder. Rich, developed countries seem to be able to generate jobs for far less and I do not think a job down at the NHC or NCC, or the Hospital pays those kinds of rates, but you can never be certain in this country of ours.


  2. Given the degree of confusion our DLP stalwarts have managed to sow let me reprint the unadulterated numbers, without any spin, from the “Review of the economy for the first six months” by the Central Bank Governor, Table 4: “Government Fiscal Operations”.

    Total Government Revenue:
    2007: $2441m,
    2008: $2519m,
    2009: $2467m.

    In the first five months of 2010, the number is $1017m and if we kept at that rate through the year, revenues would be $2439m.

    So from 2007 to 2009, where we have full year figures, there is a small rise in revenues and to 2010, it looks likely that revenues will be approximately the same as in 2007. My interpretation of that is that the 2008 and 2009 budgets raised tax rates sufficiently to offset the drop in tax revenues you would normally expect in a recession. Almost every other government around the world has refused to follow this path because they believe it would deepen the recession.

    Total Government Expenditure:
    2007: $2566m,
    2008: $2928m,
    2009: $3164m.

    The first five months of 2010, total expenditure is $1306m and if we kept at that pace through the year, expenditure would be $3134m.

    So from 2007 to 2009, where we have full year figures, there is a jump in annual expenditure of $598m or 23.3% and the 2010 figures so far suggest a similar outcome despite the medium term fiscal plan.

    How much of this expenditure increase is the result of an increase in capital expenditure (like schools, drains, etc) as opposed to annual recurrent expenditure like salaries? Very little.

    Capital expenditure:
    2007: $241m,
    2008: $287m,
    2009: $283m.

    In the first five months of 2010, capital expenditure is $107m and if we kept this pace up, total capital expenditure for the year would be $257m.

    So from 2007 to 2009 where we have full year figures, capital expenditure has increased by about $20m-$40m per year or by 4% to 7% of the $598m increase in the deficit.

    I am no fan of BOLTs but here is the frightening thing. The Government deficit is now so large that it is the equivalent size of building EVERY YEAR a new prison, a new ABC highway, a new coast guard, a new Justice building with all the attendant cost overruns. That is why we have been downgraded once by the credit rating agencies around 12 months ago and since been been put on negative credit watch for a further downgrade to below junk status. But I am worrying needlessly and everything is so fine we do not need a budget to set tax rates or announce new initiatives and we do not need parliament to enact any new policies to deal with anything, because, Jepter “Physical” Ince is helping out and so it is all going to be all right. Kingston here we come.


  3. Natasha | August 18, 2010 at 10:30 AM |

    The figures behind the Government’s medium term fiscal strategy were blown out of the water two months ago. Deficits, debt, expenditure are all higher than levels they were supposed to be being reduced from. No wonder. Can anyone remember what measures were going to be enacted (can’t enact without Parliament of course) to achieve this fiscal plan? Besides of course sinking the economy with higher taxes.
    _______________________________

    Natasha, the government is saying that they have a medium term fiscal plan to deal with the issues you have highlighted and that there is no urgent need for a budget because they do not intend to raise taxes. I am willing to give them the benefit of the doubt for now. Perhaps if David Thompson were in better health we would indeed have had a budget by this time but he is not, and the reality is that the government has chosen this path.

    The Estimates have been laid in the House and since you are so adept with the numbers you can tell us what government’s revenues, expenses and fiscal deficit are expected to be for this year. So we will have to judge them on how well they implement the measures outlined in the medium term fiscal plan and if they can reverse the negative trends.

    Government’s plans for repositioning the economy are outlined in their medium term development plan. So again, we will have to judge them on their ability to execute this plan.

    Having said that, the plans are quite ambitious and they are attempting to achieve many things that were not achieved by the previous BLP government over three terms. These things would have been necessary in any event, even if there were no global recession and even if the BLP were still in power. This includes for example capping transfer payments to the QEH, Transport Board and UWI and hopefully forcing those institutions to be more efficient.

    Now I have argued on this blog before that government is doing a piss poor job of telling people that there IS a plan and explaining it. So it is easy for others to come in and say that government has no plan and do not know what they are doing. I guess they (government) only have themselves to blame for that.

    Furthermore, given what I have seen so far I am not totally convinced that they (the party in power) have what it takes to really transform the country or that all of them really want to. We only have to read the ongoing comments on this blog about the QEH dispute. But the BLP did not have what it takes either.

    So I think we all have a vested interest in seeing the government succeed. If they do not though, I think it will be as much a reflection on the people of Barbados as it is on the Government of Barbados.


  4. @ natasha
    The further point can be made that the expenditure spent on increasing staff you have to find the money again next year. It will do nothing to bring increased productivity as the gov’t work will not earn foreign exchange or generate further jobs.
    If you check Peter Boos letter to the editor outlining all the things that are wrong in the economy, and look at the medium term plan whose targets cannot be met; the collossal scandal in Clico and further scandal in Housing with Lashley; and if you have no inkling of what else to do – would you not go in hibernation for two months andhope it all blows away. pray, that somebody comes to take control again or hope that things get better.

    The truth is they have no plans,no ideas and therefore no work for Parliament. Other parliaments meeting regularly, some more sessions than usual to continue to put in place strategies and adjusting as you go along to manage the crisis along with the normal parliamentary work. The DEMS get the toy and now don’t know what de hell to do with it. The next thing an idiot with a toy does when he don’t know what to do is break it. Let parliament close, hopefully they can’t do more damage.

    Somebody needs to take out an injunction against Lashley and Clico to prevent the further transaction of business.


  5. Dear Brutus,

    You place much emphasis on the Government’s Medium Term Financial Plan.

    But I wonder if you have read the plan. It is a nice plan with many lofty goals, that everyone DLP and BLP alike would sign up to and have argued, but it provides very little in terms of how they are going to achieve these goals except for general exhortations that would have been made by any Government in Barbados. Let me copy out aspects of the “How” of the plan to achieve the biggest deficit reduction we have every achieved:

    First are the set of general exhortations that every Government has made for the past 40 years to little effect:

    • Increase the efficiency of procurement of goods and services.

    • Re-evaluate current programmes of ministries and government agencies.
    Strategies

    • Adopt a more aggressive approach to the collection of taxes

    • Modernise the Customs and Excise Department.

    • Increase dividend yields from commercially focussed government corporations.

    • Establish a strong debt management capacity.

    • Make greater use of sources of external, concessionary, and grant funds.

    There is one institutional recommendation, which is to:

    • Establish by 2010/2011 the Central Revenue Authority in which all revenue collection agencies are brought under one umbrella. I have a feeling this is an old plan that has been there for a while, but I may be wrong.

    And there are the areas of priority and fiscal management that show the Government to have the same broad plans of the previous Government which they attacked so heavily in Opposition.

    • Place greater emphasis on the foreign exchange sectors of the economy, such as tourism and international business (for which read financial services), with the objective of raising the growth level. No mention of agriculture here.

    • Facilitate greater use of Public-Private Sector Partnership (PPP) arrangements in financing capital projects (BOLTs are the most common form of PPP).

    • Broaden the VAT base. (This will raise the cost of living)

    • Increase excise taxes. (This will raise the cost of living).

    In reality therefore this much heralded plan which the Government says will achieve a balanced budget (therefore reduce the deficit of current expenditure over current income by $600m per year) basically says: we have no new ideas. That is effectively what will be said when we go to the IMF next year: Please sir, please help us because we have no new ideas and we have run out of money….

  6. Robert Deschappé Avatar
    Robert Deschappé

    @ Natasha

    Your analytical skills and in-depth knowledge brings refreshing substance as it relates to these matters.

    Brutus mentioned that a capping of transfer payments may lead to an efficient management of government institutions. But what we have to be aware of is bureaucratic inefficiency. The bureaucracy is the body of non-elected official and administrators who operate government institutions, agencies, statutory corporations, etc. As citizens of this island, one of our concerns should be that as the government grows, the bureaucracy may become more powerful than the executive, legislative, and judicial branches, (an example is the situation at the hospital between the Board and BAMP). We should also be aware of how bureaucratic behaviour effects economic decision making. It can be concluded that the government bureaucracy tends to be inefficient because of the absence of the profit motive. When a government agency performs poorly, there is no competition to take away the market share, and there are no shareholders demanding a reform of operations because of declining profits. This is mainly because taxpayers are very poor substitutes for shareholder pressure, since they do not exercise their right to demand such reforms from the politicians. Each year the typical government response to this situation is to request and try to justify a larger budget in the estimates. The tendency is to use the size of the budget and staff as an indicator of the agency’s success, in the absence of profits as a measure of performance. In other words, the basic incentive structure of government agencies encourages inefficient management because, unlike the private sector, there is a lack of incentive to be creative or cost effective. Instead, the bureaucrat’s mode of operation is to be extremely cautious and make all decisions in accordance with the general orders. Such behaviour may maximise prestige and job security, but it usually fails to minimise costs.


  7. @Natasha,

    I have indeed read the plan, and I believe there is a lot in it that we can support – which is why I take objection when people say that this government does not have a plan. And why do we need new ideas when there are so many OBVIOUS old ideas that have not yet been executed? The new ideas will just get added to the long list of things to do someday.

    So I think that the discussion should be about whether we as a nation will be able to implement the plan. This is where the points raised by Robert Deschappé are important. We desperately need the key elements of the plan to be implemented but it will require national effort and real change by all of us, so I can see it will be a challenge because a lot of us don’t want to change. So for example neither political party has shown that they have the ability to really deal swiftly with bureaucratic inefficiency and perhaps it is something that will take years, even decades, to change.

    People seem to think that the government needs to be doing a lot more right now, but I don’t think we should be looking for quick fixes that just postpone the inevitable for a few more years. We need to deal with the underlying structural problems in the economy and in the society and this can not be done in a few months.

  8. Robert Deschappé Avatar
    Robert Deschappé

    In her contribution, Natasha focused on the DLP’s medium term financial plan, as it relates to achieving a balanced by reducing current expenditure by $600M per year. Is achieving a balanced budget a reality or only an economic theory?

    However, the theory of rational voter ignorance is a reality. The supply side of the political market consist of politicians, appointed officials, and bureaucrats, while special interest groups and voters constitute the demand side of this market and are subject to (as described by economists) rational ignorance (which may be defined as a voter’s decision that the benefit of becoming informed about an issue is not worth the cost). We all know that during an election campaign, the candidates seldom talk about the issues. (These are attributes so well characterised by Carson C. Cadogan: contributors commenting on the economy, and he is asking about Owen Arthur’s attendance at parliament).

    What the candidates realise is that the majority of the voters will make a calculated decision not to judge them based on an in-depth knowledge of their position on a wide range of issues affecting the country. Many voters choose the politicians based on party affiliation, how they appear on television, or if they “ramble articulately” like Dr. Don Blackman. Many voters do not take the time to analyse the politician, his commitment to any issue that is for the development of the country and its citizens, or if he has made any progress in implementing any policy to substantiate his beliefs. Check Chris Sinckler’s position on the EPA pre and post elections. Or even Hamilton Lashley, who has successfully identified himself with the poor, “down-trodden” and marginalised persons in the society (e.g. Rastas), but to date he has not implemented one policy to help these people who readily support him.


  9. Team Barbados Labour Party will hold a public meeting this Sunday night from 7:00 p.m., until 11:00 p.m., at Heroes Square.

    Come and hear our caring, competent and committed Team, which includes Opposition Leader Mia Mottley, Deputy Political Leader Dale Marshall, former Prime Minister Owen Arthur, M.P., for St. George North Gline Clarke, Senator Elizabeth Thompson and Dr. Jerome Walcott – address issues that you care about and are important to you.

    With “Barbados Adrift,” it is “Team Barbados Labour Party to the Rescue.” Come and hear what the Dems do not want you to know. Join “Team BLP” and let us work together and put our country back on track.


  10. Thank you Robert and Brutus for your responses.

    It is so true that we have strutural problems, but I think they are far deeper than bureacratic inefficiency. They are about the State nudging the private sector through legislation, incentives and penalties to being more dynamic and competitive and more inclusive. At the end of the day the bulk of our growth has to come from the private sector. It is about delivering important and critical public services like education, health, housing, transport and social services in a way that gives citizens more influence, power and choice and is competitive and efficient, perhaps through a partnership between State and private sector in certain parts.

    But these things do not happen by exhortation. They happen through detailed plans, ensuring people are empowered and responsible for the achievement of these plans. Do you think the Irish/Singapore/Hong Kong Plan says we must develop our international business more? No. It is a detailed plan as to exactly how to do it and they go out, find the businesses they want, sink their teeth into them and do not let go. The medium term fiscal plan is not that and there is no detailed annexes or background plans.

    I have seen a thousand and one plans like these which list a whole series of nice to haves and does not once address why the same things we have been trying to do for forty years have not happened, what the forces are that are stopping these things happening and how we are going to overcome, deflect or rechannel these forces. Remember all that stuff in opposiiton about tackling the structural reason for the high cost of living, challenging the supermarkets, investigating the supply chains……The Government is not dealing with any of this seriously which is why the plan will be like all other plans made in the same way.

    I am retired now, when I was working `i used to say that you can tell whether a plan was a plan or a nice list of nice to haves when it spelled out all the nice to have things we were not going to have as a result of a positive choice of going for something else. When you have a long list of things in which no one could ever say no to, where there is no controversy, no choice, no price tag, it is not a plan, it is a prayer. And the problem is, that we tend to tolerate nice sounding, unimplemented plans when the good times are here, but now that we are sliding dangerously in terms of public finances we need plans that have credibility and in being credibly implementable will do something quick to defend our credit rating (a defense of whcih is part of the plan).


  11. Brutus

    You and I did not read the same medium term plan. The one I saw was short on strategies for the various sectors; it failed to outline as pointed out by natasha, how they would go about getting the results. It has figures that have not been realised and therefore require a revision for it to be credible in speaking to our reality. And the workers gone home, and taking their vacation time, after four weeks of sick leave. Symbolic of the crass and irresponsible attitude of some workers in barbados today towards their organisation. Like I said bereft of vision, ideas and strategies, might as well shut shop.


  12. @Bajan Truth,

    The strategies for individual sectors are in the national development strategy. I assume that the detailed plans have to be worked out at the level of individual ministries, government agencies and statutory corporations, etc. I don’t know if these individual plans exist or not – the government hardly says anything about the main fiscal and development plans so the fact that we have not heard anything about detailed plans does not mean do they not exist or are being developed.

    So for example, the QEH seems to be working on implementing their plan and we can see how that is going. The BWA is surely working on theirs although we have not had an update recently. As had been reported in the press UWI is already moving to reduce expenditure. How involved do you think cabinet should be in these matters? My view is that they should put competent, qualified people on the boards and in management, give them broad policy direction, and leave them to do their jobs.

    If by workers going on vacation, you mean Parliament, I am not sure what acts of Parliament are needed over the next few months that will make a major difference to anything. However feel free to volunteer any suggestions you have.


  13. Agree with Brutus. It seems Natasha and Bajan Truth have a circular argument going on here. The medium term strategic doc is just that, strategic. The operational/tactical plans need to be addressed by the relevant departments.


  14. Dear Brutus,

    Now, now, Brutus, you are a fair man, but you are not being fair. Examine your argument. First you say you are confident that the Government has a plan, it is called the Medium Term Plan and there is no need for more, like a budget or Parliament to pass new bills.

    Then when we discuss the plan, you say it is strategic and there ought to be more detailed plans, but you do not know if they exist as you, and I and nobody else in the public have seen them and they have not been debated in Parliament and they appear not to need any Parliamentary approval or passing of any new bills or acts.

    Why are the Governments of the USA, UK, and many others rushing through extensive legislative measures to try and deal with their fiscal and economic challenges? Why dont they follow our approach and adjourn Parliament, and be satisfied with Medium Term targets with no public debate of detailed plans? And the UK and US Governments are rushing around without even being on negative credit watch….


  15. Natasha,

    I was told that Government has no plan and does not know what to do – I disagreed and said yes, there is a plan. I took pains to point out that implementation was the key factor. It was said that the plan does not have enough detail – I said the detail should be somewhere else. I pointed out this government shares very little information with the public so we would never know if detailed plans exist or not.

    Why would the detailed plans have to be debated in Parliament? The expenditure side has already been debated and passed in the Estimates. What further acts of Parliament do we need in the short term to deal with the level of debt and the fiscal deficit, unless taxes were going to be increased?

    Give us examples of what the US and UK Governments rushed to do to address their fiscal and economic challenges that could work here. I will try to respond without discussing whether these things actually worked or not, but it will be hard.


  16. Dear Brutus,

    To say “Give us examples of what the US and UK Governments rushed to do to address their fiscal and economic challenges that could work here….” is perfect proof that the Government and its supporters have no idea. They probably do not genuinely know what others have done. They probably do not examine this on a daily basis, assessing how initiatives could be adapted and amended, despite the rating agencies saying we are in a worse shape.

    If you really want a list, if you really have no idea, if you have really not ever considered them before saying that asserting that the Government has a plan, even if it has no details and it looks like everyother plan, then, I shall provide you with one, the same one, that anyone who spends less than an hour on the internet could do.

    The problem with Government, dear Brutus, all Governments of all stripes, is that when upstanding people like you stand up for them, they merely undermine you.


  17. Alex Fergusson
    Most politicians are of the view that Barbadians really have short memories. I think they are making a big mistake. The voter ranging from 50 – 35 in age will make some of you sweat.
    Now tell me how the now caring Mia Mottley and Owen Arthur and Glyne Clarke can be critical of the Ministry of Housing after their dismal fourteen years running the same housing ministry. Remember that it was under that government that Al Barack contract for building the Warrens building and he was not paid.
    Now here comes Michael Lashley and in two short years and has so much to show. Country road was there with the steel turning rusty, Tweedside road was there in bush. Now the houses there look pretty for so.
    He is being targeted on a minor issue because the population is not responding to your cry on the economy because they are educated enough to know that the world is under economic pressure.
    I also to bring to your attention that Indar Weir will make the BLP lose so much support with his ignorance on Fridays as BLP speaks. It should BLP St Philip North speaks because he promotes himself and his functions even bringing over deaths in St Philip north like Larry Mayers on mornings.
    People would come to hear the gossip tonight but that will not transform into votes because you really did not do better in the last five years of your fourteen years in office.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending