Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

It started in 2018 after the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) handed the Democratic Labour Party (DLP) and the third parties an unprecedented 30 to zero drubbing in the general election. Many still believe a constitutional crisis was averted when Bishop Joe Atherley crossed the floor and a Leader of the Opposition (LoO) was recognized to ensure the business of parliament as outlined in the Constitution was carried out.

Who would have thunk it?

Prime Minister Mottley called a snap general election 18 months early and repeated a 30 to love win on 19 January 2022. On this occasion, no sitting MP seems willing to follow in the Bishop’s footsteps. The President of the Republic is unwilling to exercise discretion to appoint 2 Opposition Senators. Prime Minister Mottley in her infinite wisdom magnanimously has started the process to amend the Barbados Constitution to allow for the appointment of the 2 Opposition Senators from the losing political party that garnered the most votes. If that party refuses the opportunity to appoint slides to the next losing party. 

Here we are!

The news former Attorney General Adriel Brathwaite filed a motion with the Court to rule on the legitimacy of the Senate should not surprise political pundits if one listened to the position of interim President of the DLP Steve Blackett. With the amendment to the Constitution proceeding in the parliament the DLP would eventually be forced into position of accepting the offer to appoint 2 Opposition Senators which would contradict the publicly stated position of the DLP represented by interim President Steve Blackett. 

A couple interesting sidebar observations. The former AG Brathwaite is being represented by attorneys-at-law Garth Patterson and Michelle Russell. Last week Brasstacks talk show host Glyne Murray observed the lawyers keeping the most ‘noise’ in the Barbados space on the the constitutionality of parliament are of Jamaican lineage. In fairness to Russell and Patterson they have been residing in Barbados for a long time, however, the blogmaster understands Murray’s point given the large cohort of Barbadians lawyers educated with our tax dollars.

One of the reasons forwarded why Mottley called an early general election was to quell an uprising by a faction in the BLP. Is it reasonable to opine if a few BLP MPs are dissatisfied with Mottley’s leadership a golden opportunity now presents itself for the malcontents to express themselves by crossing the floor or sounding their voices?

Political Games

The matter has gone the route of the Court and whatever the decision at first instance is will likely progress to the CCJ. What we have is a people suffering from economic fatigue, COVID-19 fatigue and you may add to the maladies, post election fatigue. Is this another opportunities to blame lawyers? 

Former Brathwaite in his released stated in part that he felt “compelled to seek the intervention of the Courts to resolve this controversy, one that centres around issues of vital national importance, and goes to the root of our democracy.” The blogmaster notes the former AG has advised that the matter is being brought in his capacity as a private citizen. How convenient!

Why did this extract from Brathwaite’s statement pique the interest of the blogmaster? Under Brathwaite’s tenure as AG with responsibility for the judiciary, he left it in a worse condition than he found it. The political games that lawyer politicians play mean an already congested court system has to adjudicate a matter created by lawyers. 


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

494 responses to “To the Courts!”


  1. I am delighted that at last someone has the fortitude to step up and formally challenge the constitutional state of affairs presented by the 30-0 win in 2022. It was also good to hear Mr Patterson deal quite well with Gregory Nicholls on Brasstacks last Sunday. My Barbadian friend in the UK and I have been discussing this for the last 3 weeks.

    I’m very passionate about Barbados and am deeply concerned about where our democracy is heading. I firmly believe the genesis of the issue goes back to 2018. You don’t need to be a Constitutional expert to read and interpret the Constitution – expert lawyers in this field should be weighing in in their droves! Hence why I’m trying to understand it for myself and offer my 2 cents worth. I do not believe that Parliament was properly constituted even then, or now, for these reasons;

    One person crossing the floor to sit on the Opposition benches could not, without more, be enough to form a legitimate Opposition. The constitution, by s74(2), intended more than that.
    The President, in the use of her discretionary powers, cannot circumvent the requirements of s74(2) on route to s36(3) when s36(1) mandates that “The Senate shall consist of twenty-one persons who, […] have been so appointed in accordance with the provisions of this section”.
    It is inconceivable and an affront to democracy that Parliament should continue with no opposition – it is entirely unconstitutional by reason of s74.

    In my own simple terms without an elected opposition there is no constitutional power to appoint 2 Senators. Over a week ago I sent an article about this to Barbados Today and Nationnews, to try by some small means, to raise the issue. From what I can see they chose not to publish it.

    I can accept I maybe entirely wrong, but I want to see the matter formally adjudicated.

    Steve (LLB Hons) Employment Law Consultant


  2. This action by the former AG will lead to this matter being resolved the only way it should be. I do not understand why our President doesn’t act and do what she is constitutionally empowered to do.
    We all remember very well when a previous BLP administration tried to appoint a second DCOP and how that turned out.


  3. Watching with eagle eye the outcome
    The last high profile cases having to do with govt policies or procedure were cermoniously dismissed using language only known to the court as such to be with out merit
    Then.one being told the motion was filed within the wrong confines of jurisprudence
    It cannot be underlooked that the courts of Barbados are politically bias in making judgements which can be seen as in favour of not wanting to tinker or upset the status quo
    Sad as this might be a sore than is allowed to fester spreads to many organs of the body disallowing it to heal

  4. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    Fun and games. Smoke and mirrors. Neroes are fiddling . Let us hope Rome is not burning.


  5. @Steve Prescott

    Given the decision by the electorate to give all the seats to the BLP, what will it take to address the lacuna?


  6. Over to law courts

    Ex-AG challenging legality of Parliament’s opening with 18 senators
    by COLVILLE MOUNSEY
    colvillemounsey@nationnews.com

    ATTORNEY GENERAL Dale Marshall says he is “confident” that Government is on sound legal footing in its decision to convene Parliament with only 18 of the 21 senators sworn in, a matter which is now the subject of a constitutional court challenge brought by his immediate predecessor, Adriel Brathwaite QC.
    Brathwaite is being represented by attorneysat- law Garth Patterson QC and Michelle Russell, who have filed the action in the High Court under certificate of urgency yesterday.
    The development comes even though Parliament has already convened and is debating key amendments to the Constitution of Barbados.
    The former AG made it clear that his actions were not on behalf of any political party but was rather in the interest of maintaining democracy in the new republic.
    Marshall said he has already started the process of assembling a team of lawyers to plead the Government’s case.
    “I am confident that our position is sound and that the Senate is properly constituted, but I don’t have any issue at all with the challenge that has been posed by the former Attorney General. This is why our courts exist. They determine matters of conflict between individuals on a daily basis and in this case, it is a challenge posed by the former Attorney General against the Government, ” said Marshall.
    He added: “I am satisfied that the matter will be fully ventilated. I propose to engage a team of attorneys and I am working with that team now. I am reaching out to them to ensure that they are all available to represent the Government on this certificate of urgency and I look forward to the ruling of the court in due course.” Marshall argued that constitutional challenges were by no means unique to Barbados, noting that it was through such challenges that democracies evolve and mature. “While I have not yet seen the documents, it has been confirmed to me that an action has commenced in the High Court, challenging the legitimacy of the Senate and its capacity or ability to function as a Senate. I eagerly await seeing the document but let me say that as a matter of principle, I welcome all people challenging the various actions of the Government. These things are good for democracy, I don’t feel that it is in any way a challenge to my own functioning as Attorney General, as the chief legal advisor to the Government,” said Marshall.
    In the Judicial Review filed in the High Court yesterday, a copy of which was obtained by the DAILY NATION, it states that in making the case, the applicant relied on Sections, 35, 36, 37, 43, 49, 60(1), 62 (2) and 75 of the Constitution.
    It alleges that the Senate is not properly constituted and by extension, Parliament is not lawfully constituted or convened. This, according to the applicant, would mean any business that “Parliament purported to transact on or after February 4, 2022, including any law purportedly enacted by it, is invalid, null and void.”
    It is argued in the document that a failure by the President to appoint the two Opposition Senators “amounts to the wrongful abdication of her constitutional
    duty to proceed under section 36 to the appointment of all the Senators as soon as may be after every general election.”
    “The President has the power and the duty to act in her discretion in the exercise of her function of appointing two Senators to the Senate pursuant to sections 36(3), 62(2) and 75(a) of the Constitution. As the Barbados Labour Party won all thirty seats in the House of Assembly, there is no person qualified to hold the office of Leader of the Opposition. Accordingly, section 75(a) of the Constitution is engaged, and the President is required by sections 36 and 62(2) to proceed to the appointment of all twenty-one of the Senators, and not just eighteen Senators,” the application states.
    The attorneys for Brathwaite contend that awaiting the amendments to Section 75 and 37 of the Constitution, which were debated in the Lower House on Monday, is no justification for the President not discharging her duty.
    The amendments respectively allow for the party with the second highest number of votes to be allotted the two Opposition Senator seats in the absence of an Opposition Leader, as well as lowering the age that persons can serve as senators from 21 to 18.
    “No valid reason has been given by the President for her failure or refusal to appoint the two senators pursuant to section 36(3) and the reasonable inference is that the President has wrongfully declined to discharge her duty under that section because she is awaiting the proposed constitutional amendment to section 75. Nor has the President appointed the twelfth person that the Prime Minister is entitled to nominate as senator, and the reasonable inference is that she is awaiting the proposed constitutional amendment to section 37. These are not reasons that would justify the failure to discharge the
    constitutional mandate to the President under sections 36 and 62(2).”
    12,” the applicant contends.
    It added: “Consequently, the decision of the President to appoint the 4th day of February 2022, as the date for the commencement of a new session of Parliament pursuant to section 60 of the Constitution, which decision was made before the appointment by her of all twenty-one Senators in accordance with section 36(1), was an unreasonable and/or irregular and/ or improper exercise of discretion and/ or an abuse of power and/or was made in contravention of section 36 of the Constitution and was accordingly invalid, null and void.
    The said decision should be quashed accordingly.”

    Source: Nation


  7. A salute to Verla

    by CORA C. CUMBERBATCH

    THE DEMOCRATIC LABOUR PARTY (DLP) is once again in the political wilderness with no guide and a very dim light.
    The party of Errol Walton Barrow started to slip on that fateful night in 1985 when he announced to the executive council that Lloyd Erskine Sandiford would be the deputy leader of the DLP. I was sitting on his right and whispered, why?
    He whispered back his reason which was burnt in his ashes.
    After Barrow announced the date of General Elections for May 28, 1986, he called a meeting of all the candidates and gave them a serious tongue-lashing. Those candidates left George on fire and hit the ground running.
    The result was a landslide victory for the DLP, winning 24 of the 27 seats and ending a decade of Barbados Labour Party (BLP) rule.
    The party of Barrow in 1987 started the downward spiral after Sandiford took over as Prime Minister. By 1989, Richie Haynes (later Sir Richard) and three other parliamentarians left the DLP to form the National Democratic Party. I had already taken my exit from George Street.
    For years, the ambitious David Thompson wished long and too hard to lead the party.
    God granted it, and he was given the task of filling the seat in St John after Barrow’s death.
    No-confidence vote
    The then embattled Sandiford lost his perch after a noconfidence vote in 1994 and called the election in which the Party lost 19 of the 28 seats to the Owen Arthur-led BLP.
    Thompson won the leadership battle that was raging in George Street and his goal for Prime Ministership was finally realised in 2008 – but it was short-lived. He died in office after only two years.
    Freundel Stuart succeeded David Thompson in 2010. He went on to win his own mandate in 2013.
    Unfortunately, with only a one-seat majority in Parliament, Stuart had no wriggle room as Prime Minister and worked under the clear and present danger of being ousted by 11 eager colleagues.
    Silence then became Stuart’s best revenge.
    Despite the relentless opposition from BLP leader Mia Amor Mottley, Prime Minister Stuart was never rattled, and so the base of the Dear Loving People was weakened and the rest of the country reacted in silence on that fateful day in May 2018 when, like the boy on the burning deck, all but he had abandoned George Street. What a lonely, lonely picture Stuart presented that night. But I salute him. He was man enough to take full blame for the thrashing.
    Verla De Peiza stepped up to the plate and faced the challenges that needed to be addressed. She resuscitated the patient and brought George Street throbbing back to life.
    She fed and watered the patient and old friends started to pay their respect.
    I salute De Peiza for her leadership of the DLP during three short years and into a General Election with a full slate of candidates. However, sadly, she has resigned. The Dear Loving Party have not yet fully recovered. I remain hopeful that they will rally round the emblem during the next five years.
    Barbados is not a one-party state.
    Matter of urgency
    The DLP needs a political leader as a matter of urgency. A fresh face.
    Winning all the seats in Parliament is no real joy for Prime Minister Mottley who enjoys the cut and thrust of debates in and out of Parliament. The DLP will be better served in the Senate than to have no voice at all and I can think of two that might serve the party very well in the Upper House. Pick any two from Dr Ronnie Yearwood, Ryan Walters, Oldwin Skeete, Rasheed Belgrave, and Dawn-Marie Armstrong. Pick two, and let your voice be heard.
    The DLP needs purging. After January 19, it would be a shame to let silly human pride cause you to deny the party a voice where it matters for the next five years. It will be to your further demise if you allow uncommon sense to dictate your response. Interim leader, do you have another plan to survive in the wilderness without a light to guide your steps to safety – and even victory, next time around?
    The first big mistake you made was to jump the gun over the offer of two Senate seats without waiting for the legality of the offer to be confirmed.
    How do you plan to stay relevant after a second resounding thrashing? From what platform do you plan to speak on behalf of your base? Be big and enough to swallow your pride and walk back your words. Take the two seats.
    I should not have to remind you that in 1986 the Opposition BLP had only three seats in Parliament.
    In 1999 the Opposition DLP had only two seats in Parliament. But their
    voices of Opposition were never silent or silenced during those two periods because they always showed up and fought on behalf of their respective parties and were able to make their way back from those wilderness years. What is wrong with you guys in George Street? Do you think you can stay silent and wait for the next bell to ring to start presenting yourself to your base? Of course you can’t.
    Take the olive branch. Stay the course. There is always light at the end of the darkest, longest tunnel. Do not close your eyes and wait for the light to blind you. The most comforting thing to remember is that the DLP base is cracked, not broken, for within, it remains strong.
    The base lacked the enthusiasm to get out – not because they did not love their party, but because the party is too sick to get off the bed. It is not a final call for DNR. The loss is not the fault of De Peiza. So get up, mobilise and build back better.
    The DLP needs healing. Reverend Guy Hewitt, I have a word for you. You made a very serious blunder as any obvious political neophyte would. You had no clue when to hold or when to fold in politics and the outcome was the only possible one. That’s understandable. Everyone thinks highly of self in such matters and your inexperience is forgiven.
    But Rev, did you not first think to turn to God for guidance before you fired that first shot? After all, you did promise to serve Him above all others and above self. Did you not think to have a tête-à-tête with De Peiza before going public? Do you not know that arrogance is a very slow starter? Surely, you must know that a grave-digger has to start at the top and there is many a slip between the cup and the lip. So when you publicly challenged the De Peiza leadership at that crucial juncture, you immediately dug your own grave and then tumbled headlong into it. But it is not too late to try and claw your way back out.
    Reverend Hewitt, the DLP needs you, but you have to ask God to humble you and let Him have His will and way in your life. Did you not know? Have you not heard that Caesar was ambitious? There is still a place and a time for you. That time is now. You are alive and if you can and will swallow your pride, then check your ego at the gate in George Street; walk in humility, make amends, and you just might be in time to get to where you want to be. So go ahead and start the ball rolling.

    Cora C. Cumberbatch is a former Democratic Labour Party general secretary.


  8. Mixed views on Senate’s inconsistency

    by TRE GREAVES tregreaves@nationnews.com

    POLITICAL SCIENTIST Dr Kristina Hinds believes the President should have selected the two “Opposition” senators.
    However, attorney at law and constitution expert Gregory Nicholls says Dame Sandra Mason should stay above the political fray.
    These opposing views were made following the recent swearing-in of 18 senators, three short of the required 21 stated in the Constitution.
    While plans are being put in place to amend the law to allow 18-year-old Khaleel Kothdiwala to sit in the Senate, Prime Minister Mia Amor Mottley recently said the ball was in the Democratic Labour Party’s (DLP) court to select the additions, although that party won no seats during the last General Election.
    “I think the President can make this decision and I think it is a decision the President should make. After becoming a [Parliamentary] republic, I think we need to move away from thinking about our head of state as solely ceremonial because although there are a lot of ceremonial functions, the President does have some powers.
    “We are not accustomed to the previous Governor General exercising power because there was no need for it but I think this is a situation where there is the need for it and I would have liked to have seen this rather than falling back to this position to where the President acts like the Queen of England,” Hinds told the DAILY NATION.
    Section 35 of the Constitution states that Parliament shall consist of the President, a Senate and a House of Assembly. Section 36.1-4 states that the Senate consists of 21 individuals, 12 based on advice from the Prime Minister, two based on advice from the Opposition, and who are to be appointed by the President. The other seven senators shall also be appointed by the President.
    President’s right
    While pointing out that she was not a lawyer, Hinds said she believes the President would be in her right to make the additional appointments.
    “In our system, the President is generally guided by the Prime Minister, the Opposition leader but this power is vested in the President. It is the President that selects all of the senators, the President does it in consultation,” Hinds said.
    She also spoke out against what she said was an inconsistency between this year and 2018 when Delisle Bradshaw and John Williams were installed temporarily until a Constitutional amendment was made to allow for Rawdon Adams and Kay McConney to become senators. The latter two were not living in Barbados for the prescribed amount of time. The Constitution was amended to accommodate them.
    “It seems like an inconsistent kind of argument to say in this case to say you don’t need to have 21 people, but in 2018 you did,” Hinds added.
    However, during Brassstacks Sunday on Voice Of Barbados, Nicholls who was a guest said he agreed with Dame Sandra’s decision not to act in that way.
    “The President has exercised discretion not to appoint opposition senators so far and I agree with the President declining to make what is essentially a political judgment so that the President cannot be accused of resurrecting or launching the career of anyone in the DLP.
    “The President should stay above the political fray and not be required to make essentially a political decision,” Nicholls said on the call-in programme.
    During the programme which Sade Jemmott moderated and various callers weighed in on, Nicholls and Queen’s Counsel Garth Patterson engaged in a robust debate on the topic. Things got heated between the two who had differing interpretations on whether 18 senators. One often cut in when the other was speaking causing Nicholls at one point to threaten to leave the programme.
    Nicholls was adamant that 18 was sufficient for the Senate to be in place, while Patterson argued that it was not.
    “You have a situation on Friday where we have convened or purported to, with a Senate consisting of 18 persons. I am saying there is no Senate. Even if there were, the Constitution contemplates an election process for President and Deputy President.
    “Therefore, you’re going to disenfranchise the three who have a Constitutional right to participate in the election of its president and deputy president.
    So you are starting off on a bad footing when you have 18 persons making those kinds of decisions,” Patterson said.
    Patterson cited Section 49 of the Constitution which states that Parliament may, by an Act of Parliament passed by both Houses, alter the Constitution and said he was concerned that the Constitution was being played with.
    “The Constitution is like your ten commandments, you don’t tinker with them. You tinker if and when necessary. So for that profound measure, the constitution says I need a special majority, two-thirds of all members voting. That is a concern for me that the proposed amendments to the Constitution are proceeding without the full complement of the senate being constituted,” Patterson added.
    No Parliament
    In response, Nicholls said Patterson was conflating the issue.
    “Based on Garth’s analysis alone, there is no Parliament, because there is no leader of the Opposition and to my mind that flies in the face of the democratic process, the country has now gone through,” Nicholls said.
    Nicholls referenced Section 75 which speaks to vacancies, and said that there could be instances where Parliament could proceed without a full complement.
    “He places reliance on Section 36 and I think that is where the error in my judgement is being made. And it seems as if Garth has conflated Sections 35 and 36 to read into the text words that are not there or provisions that are not there.
    “If a member is not present or if there is a vacancy in the office of a senator or a member of the house or someone dies, it does not prevent the business of Parliament from proceeding to deal with the alteration of the Constitution. So I don’t agree with Garth’s assertion that that section means you must have all 21 persons in place because other parts of the Constitution speaks to the question of a vacancy, not prohibiting the business of either house from being carried out,” Nicholls said.

    Source: Nation


  9. Surprise at how some react to this issue. They would skirt or ignore the issue and conjure up an irrelevant discussion.

    First the question was raised “Is Garth an expert on constitutional law?”

    Now some raise the place of birth of the two lawyers. And act surprise that lawyers born in Barbados will not touch the issue or appear to support the actions of Mia.

    I will not speculate on the nationality of the lawyer who rushed to protect the rights of voters during the last election. He failed in his efforts, but should be commended.


  10. The following received from Alvin Cummins via Quick Note to Blogmaster.

    This problem began in 2018 when the euphoria of the 30-0 defeat of the DLP resulted with mandates of the Constiturion were ignored by the incoming administration. Section 40:1&2 mandate the selection of the President and Vice President of the Senate, be made by the Members of the Senate at their first sitting as a body. It is NOT within the purvue of the Prime Minister. It is pertinent to deduce that this behaviour might result in this act may morph into a convention that rubishes the worth of Constitutional mandates.


  11. Agreeing with Cora.
    Verla had a tough hand and played it best she could.

    Guy appears to be an opportunity who surfaces to only fight for his own cause.

    In the end, the DLP need to figure out having the two senators come from their camp.


  12. It is obvious that the undemocratic opposition now wants to reverse the elections and lead the people back into eternal slavery.

    People rise up and follow our supreme leader Mia Mottley! She alone stands between the despotism of the opposition and freedom. The people have the right to hound the DLP out of parliament completely, no matter what any lawyers say who are personal friends with criminals.


  13. The question being asked of the Court that which
    Is the Senate Constitutionally formed sufficient and enough to make decisions in the absence of two senators plus a leader of the opposition
    Let’s hear what this court would say as in alignment with the Constitutional
    Outside of using the Constitution as a guide and relies on thought of own purpose the Court would have failed miserably to protect the principles of the Constitution that gives directives and directions towards and for good governance


  14. This is not the issue, it is the different interpretations being applied. The Courts will have to be the arbiter which is what it is setup to do.


  15. No one can reverse the elections and there will be no rerun until we get other than 30-0.

    However, the rule of law must be maintained. Extending an offer to the DLP is just a part of the problem.

    Why does Mia create situations that called for amending the constitution (2018 – RA and another; 2022 – KK). for one thing or another.


  16. Please understand the issue appears to be made problematic because the President has not exercised discretion in the matter.


  17. This is another show trial as Courts do not have jurisdiction over Constitution Senate Parliament and Government matters.
    Barbados can and will update it’s Constitution anyway.


  18. Oh-ho! So this has nothing to do with Mia! It is about the President!

    Murdaaaaaah!


  19. One should always read before one comments.

    Soooo… all this could do is force the President to appoint two more Senators and Mia to appoint a seat warmer.

    Not what some people are celebrating at all.

    Murdaaaaaaah!


  20. DavidFebruary 10, 2022 8:59 AM

    Please understand the issue appears to be made problematic because the President has not exercised discretion in the matter.

    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    How does she appoint a leader of the opposition?

    The problems with the senate arise because there is no leader of the opposition!!

    The only real solution is to return to the polls.

    The BLP has discredited itself and every last one of them should resign in shame.

    That is how we get fresh elections.

    Only thing is the DLP might end up winning 30 – 0!!


  21. Boss, which side of the bed did you alight from this morning..?
    AC is correct when she opines “Is the Senate Constitutionally formed sufficient and enough to make decisions in the absence of two senators plus a leader of the opposition?”
    ~~~~~~~~~~~
    How is that NOT the issue?
    Except for those who are blinded by political preconceptions about what suits their position better, the question has to be…
    WHAT DOES THE CONSTITUTION SPECIFY? …and ‘is that what we are doing’.
    If is IS NOT, then it is illegal…. and must bring itself WITHIN the confines of the LAW.

    This has nothing to do with ‘convention’; with what makes sense; with what happened before, or even with what Mia wants…

    Enlightened societies CREATE laws that provides for sensible operations, but the POINT is that having CREATED those BASIC rules, we should not be willy nilly making tweaks and changes for petty reasons.
    This kind of DICTATORIAL behavior essentially says that ‘MY IDEA OF LAW’ is what counts and to Hell with the ESTABLISHED consensus …ie the ‘Constitution’.

    If YOU or other Bajans are HAPPY with such dictatorial behavior, then it confirms EVERYTHING that Bushie has been saying about brass bowlers.

    When AC becomes a voice of logic …we KNOW that our donkeys are in the mud…


  22. Actually, I feel 30 – 0 is a bought/manufactured result!!

    Same in Grenada and Mitchell have done it 3 times.

    It is unnatural and flies in the face of common sense.

  23. de pedantic Dribbler Avatar
    de pedantic Dribbler

    @David, absolutely the ONLY reason this issue is problematic is due to the inaction of the President!

    Her failure to execute her discretionary duty has magnified and hoisted aloft as a ‘truth’ the determination from the PM that two senate seats should be specifically prescribed by voting results DESPITE no such need based on our first past post system.

    The commentary that the President must stay above the political fray is clearly shown as mere nonsensical convenient verbiage when clearly her carefully crafted non-action is surely PREMISED on her belief that ‘opposition senators’ (in the absence of a LoO) should be based on this new formula being recommended by the PM…. THAT’S being part of the political fray.

    She is a former Justice and knows well the need to weigh facts and make tough decisions… that she has ALLOWED (how else can it be described) the PM to subvert her into this worrisome spectacle is shocking and misguided.

    Is the ‘unholy’ four( 4) year Presidential restriction the sword hanging above her non-acts…. Is that in play here!!!!

    This must END. She needs to execute her duty judiciously and promptly.


  24. The role of the PRESIDENT is to be an independent, NEUTRAL, representative of EVERYONE.
    That she has chosen to NOT appoint ‘opposition senators’ speaks of her wisdom and understanding of her role.

    When she become the sponsor of ‘opposition’ appointees, how the HELL does she then claim to be NEUTRAL when contentious matters of state arise… such as disputed laws to be proclaimed etc.

    THE WHOLE point of a ceremonial president is NEUTRAL REPRESENTATION OF ALL AND SUNDRY.

    How the Hell does she appoint political opposition?

    Steupsss…. Our father, which art in Heaven…..


  25. Actually, I feel 30 – 0 is a bought/manufactured result!!
    Same in Grenada and Mitchell have done it 3 times.
    It is unnatural and flies in the face of common sense.
    ~~~~~~~
    Absolutely Correct, and great logical thinking.
    The ROOT problem is a SERIOUSLY FLAWED Electoral system, which is based on archaic HUNDRED-YEAR-OLD rules.
    ‘Proportional Representation’ makes MUCH MORE sense from a societal point of view.
    HOWEVER, the POLITICIANS are much better able to manipulate the old ‘first past the post’ relic of a system…. so we can expect to suffer its flaws for a long time to come.
    Unfortunately, brass B’s are unable to see past the mendicancy of the state-welfare-ism which SUSTAINS the political IDIOCY that we have inherited.


  26. TheOGazertsFebruary 10, 2022 7:05 AM

    Agreeing with Cora.
    Verla had a tough hand and played it best she could.

    Guy appears to be an opportunity who surfaces to only fight for his own cause.

    In the end, the DLP need to figure out having the two senators come from their camp.

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    Grasshopper

    The DLP can’t constitutionally get any senators for the simple reason they won no seats.

    They don’t want seats in senate without earning them.

    They have made that plain since 2018, why would they suddenly change now.

    Besides, it makes no political sense given what is likely to happen!!

    Give the DLP some credit for foresight and understanding.

    Their performance may suck but on this issue they are 100% right.

    They just have to let natural events unfold.

    They have a big fish on the line and it is fighting … and tiring itself out.

    If events unfold as they are likely to they will just reel it in!!

    …. and then the time for the harpoon will come.

    Politics is after all a blood sport!!


  27. This is what we are watching if I am not mistaken!!

  28. de pedantic Dribbler Avatar
    de pedantic Dribbler

    Secondly @David I was waiting for de “Jamaican” thing dat… 🤣🤣 …As sure as the WI getting their backsides beaten in India I knew that type sledging would be heard on ‘this boisterous field’

    But based on your comments above it seems Murray actually said it in a positive light tho… he was sledging de Bajans fah trute if I read you correctly! 🤦🏾‍♂️

    And BTW tho interesting that “One of the reasons forwarded why Mottley called an early general election was to quell an uprising by a faction in the BLP. Is it reasonable to opine if a few BLP MPs are dissatisfied with Mottley’s leadership a golden opportunity now presents itself for the malcontents to express themselves by crossing the floor“. …. that’s not as practical as it sounds … as you know quite well… being as astute as u are.

    And also @Bushie is correct .. AC was generally right (this time, after days of piffle) but woe-betide us when she is the voice of reason!

    Looka, gotta go. Lata.


  29. @Bush Tea

    Do we know this to be an issue given the divide by members of the legal fraternity? The blogmaster will wait for the ruling.


  30. The role of the president is to act in situation where as in this scenario an anomaly is presented. In the same way Sir Paul in Grenada acted when the government was removed by the PRM.

  31. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ Donna
    The matter will be solved when the President exercises her discretion as outlined in the Constitution. Matters should not be escalated by other parties attempting actions that are not permissible under the Constitution of Barbados. If one starts wrong ,one will end wrong. Execute the Rule of Law maxim. In this issue the Constitution is the Supreme law. One does not have to be a lawyer or Constitutional lawyer to understand the procedures in this artificially created crisis.What are the real objectives of these maneuvers.?


  32. What does a flawed system have to pragmatically addressing the issue hand? There is a debate on a new constitution promised, in the meantime and in between time what?


  33. @Dee Word

    One senses Murray made the slight slur more as a reflection on the large army of Bajan lawyers and given credence to what a republic should mean for the natives.


  34. Bushie
    Ole boar I bow to.your superior intelligence
    AC only went to Stan pipe school and drop out in first grade

  35. de pedantic Dribbler Avatar
    de pedantic Dribbler

    Wait one sec… @Bush Tea did YOU write above: “WHAT DOES THE CONSTITUTION SPECIFY? …[…] must bring itself WITHIN the confines of the LAW.*

    Excuse me for interpreting that to mean you wanted to follow the dictates of the law WHEREVER they lead!

    So further excuse me for being confused by your contradiction of your own words just minutes later to defy the CLEARLY DEFINED LEGAL AUTHORITY TO THE PRESIDENT to write:

    “The role of the PRESIDENT is to be an independent, NEUTRAL, representative of EVERYONE.[…]That she has chosen to NOT appoint ‘opposition senators’ speaks of her wisdom and understanding of her role.[…] When she become the sponsor of ‘opposition’ appointees, how the HELL does she then claim to be NEUTRAL when contentious matters of state arise… such as disputed laws to be proclaimed etc.”

    These debates devole to a level of illogic that baffles me so I’ll step back.

    But if u would please explain for me WHY the constitution GIVES the President the ability to select those senators as if she had been advised by the opposition leader?

    Please explain what is an opposition member OTHER than ANYONE who is not a BLP MP or publicly ‘registered as BLP?

    Please explain to me what DISCRETION means?

    And tell us what laws to be proclaimed could the President opine about and STEP WAY outside her remit but right here refuses to act on the law DIRECTLY within her remit?….. What side of the bed did YOU get up on boss… yah tossing and turning badly!

    Anyhow, you will not answer I expect. This is not about the interest and true benefits of Barbaods but entrenched positions of whatever bias… I really don’t have the energy for that BS…. No more… too old for those games. So carry on smartly.

    I gone

  36. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David Bu at 10 :13 AM

    All systems have perceived flaws. The so called revised constitution will have flaws. Therefore those who are looking forward to tampering with the existing Constitution to remove unforeseen and orchestrated crises will disappoint many..
    We need to understand what is really going on here. Stop and breathe. Shit does happen.


  37. The objective by Mia was to snatched the power out of the hands of the President
    The President silence on this issue has exposed her weakness and not understanding the power of authority given to her by the Constitution
    Her understanding if such would not have allowed the PM to place an offer on the table to the dlp
    It also is mind-boggling how Mia herself a lawyer would used the word ” offer” in her comments words not found within the Constitution and with good reason
    A word which connects and attributes in legal terms to bribery or corrupt motives


  38. @David, though promised, the new Constitution will not be coming any time soon if the PM can manipulate the present one for her whims and fancies.


  39. @Vincent

    Man made constructs will have flaws, we agree. The challenge is for a discerning citizenry represented by government as lead to amend/improve as a changing environment demands.


  40. @Heather

    The blogmaster is not prepared to make such an assertion. Mottley is definitely in legacy build mode. We will have to continue citizen advocacy. There is a reason why we say a democracy requires eternal vigilance.

  41. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @dpD at 10: 31 AM
    I agree with every word in the above intervention. Too many of us are playing games with the issues. These are not Party Political matters. It goes fundamentally to whether we survive as a democracy or fulfill the prediction of a Banana Republic. It usually begins with lawlessness and betrayal of the trust the Electorate puts into the hands of politicians. Is this where we want to go? If not ,those who are prepared to renege their responsibilities will be judge very harshly by posterity.


  42. @ Dribbler
    Vincent answered your question.

    One only has to picture a cricket Umpire choosing the opening bowlers and then standing over the stumps adjudicating the game to understand the President’s position.
    Even if some IDIOT wrote somewhere that “in the absence of the opposing captain specifying who was the bowl, then the umpire can give the ball to whosoever he likes’
    …what would YOU do as Umpire?

    The whole thing is FLAWED…. as is to be expected of anything done by INCOMPETENTS. Unfortunately, when the flaws are exposed to the LIGHT of CCJ illumination, it will just let EVERYONE see what Bushy has been warning about Bajan Brass bowlery for YEARS now…

    …and it is NOT that Bushie ‘does not answer’, but the whacker get tek way.
    Bushie is really just running on fumes now… mostly just resigned to our fate…

  43. Vincent Codrington Avatar
    Vincent Codrington

    @ David Bu at 10 :41 AM
    Which one of these proposals that surfaced after the last General Elections passed the smell test of ” improvement.” Improvement for whom? The system behaved the way any competent political scientist expected. This is trivializing our version of democracy. What is this perceived flaw? Provisions have been made in the constitution to remedy it. Put them into effect and move on.


  44. @Vincent

    We have two issues:

    The vacant LoO
    Altering the constitution to allow an 18 year old to be appointed to the Senate.

    What is your definitive position on the two?


  45. @ Bush Tea February 10, 2022 9:43 AM
    (Quote):
    How is that NOT the issue?
    Except for those who are blinded by political preconceptions about what suits their position better, the question has to be…
    WHAT DOES THE CONSTITUTION SPECIFY? …and ‘is that what we are doing’.
    If is IS NOT, then it is illegal…. and must bring itself WITHIN the confines of the LAW.
    (Unquote).
    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    Excellent contribution there, Bush Tea!

    Your return to BU is most welcome.

    Those who have discerning eyes can see the fast turning of the banana republic from green to yellow.

    This young RoB is slowly turning into the republic of Mama Mia.

    How can a PM, chosen in a real-real parliamentary democracy, announce the filling of the posts of president and vice-president of a Senate long before it had time to come into being as an important organ of the State?

    Aren’t the members who have been duly appointed to a new Senate responsible for electing two fellow members to these position as Constitutionally demanded of them?

    Wasn’t this also a flagrant display of disrespect for the Supreme Law of RoB?

    But then again, who really “Cares” in the land of BBBs?


  46. DavidFebruary 10, 2022 10:13 AM

    What does a flawed system have to pragmatically addressing the issue hand? There is a debate on a new constitution promised, in the meantime and in between time what?

    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    So where are these pragmatists going to debate this new constitution when pragmatism dictates there is no Parliament?


  47. All fun and games! Lotta shite!

    Fact- an election was held.

    Fact- a government must come out of those elections.

    Fact- not one person, BU brass bowl or BU “sage” can tell me how that government can be formed unless the President appoints two senators or
    the current configuration continues.

    The proportional representation proposition cannot figure in this discussion. That is a whole other issue entirely.

    An election was held under the first-past-the-post system. A government MUST be formed in keeping those results.

    Any ideas?


  48. 30 – 0 is a farce in a Parliamentary Democracy which demands an opposition.

    There is no way to change the constitution to allow a 30 -0 result if you want to keep a Parliamentary Democracy.

    Others have done away with their parliaments to their chagrin.


  49. February 10, 2022 11:26 AM

    All fun and games! Lotta shite!

    Fact- an election was held.

    Fact- a government must come out of those elections.

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    Fiction.

    Suppose Guy Fawkes blows up the Parliament Buildings with all inside.

    It’s back to the polls.

    30 – 0 is equivalent to the Gunpowder Plot.

    Solution is back to the polls.


  50. in keeping WITH

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending