DAVID A. COMISSIONG, President, Clement Payne Movement, Citizen of the Caribbean, and Lover of West Indies Cricket

How  shameful  it was to witness the gleeful rejoicing of the members of the West Indies cricket team in the wake of their fortuitous and totally undeserved victory over Scotland — a non- test status, associate member team of the International Cricket Council (ICC).

These men — supposed heirs to the  great West Indian cricketing tradition of such immortals as George Headley, Sir Frank Worrell, Sir Garfield Sobers, Clive Lloyd, and Sir Vivian Richards — seemingly had no qualms about celebrating the fact that it took  a manifestly erroneous umpiring decision, the intervention of a shower of rain, and the complicated calculations designed by Messers Duckworth and Lewis to “gift” them a 5 run victory over a Cricket team that is regarded as a minnow in international cricket!

But, as hurtful and shameful as this experience was, it should not have come as a surprise to any of us.

Let us recall that less than a year ago – on 20th June 2017 to be precise – Darren Sammy, our former West Indies cricket captain, prophetically warned us as follows:-

“I am very scared for the future of West Indies cricket …………I am scared that we might be relegated to the league of the Irelands and Scotlands, playing against these guys which is very, very sad — if something doesn’t change. And at the moment, the guy (Cricket West Indies president, Whycliffe “Dave” Cameron) has just been re-elected for another term. I can’t see it happening for us. It’s very sad for us.”

                                                                       (Published in the Nation Newspaper of Barbados on 21-06-17)

At the time, I came out publicly and stated that I totally agreed with Darren Sammy . West Indies cricket, I felt,  would go nowhere but DOWN under the immature, self-centered, and self-righteous leadership of current Cricket West Indies president Whycliffe “Dave” Cameron and the social class that he is a representative of.

I also took the opportunity to renew my call for the resignation of Mr Cameron – a call that I had first made when he presided over the backward decision to remove the Combined Campuses and Colleges (CCC) team from our regional one day cricket competition on the most ridiculous and frivolous of grounds, and I repeated the Call when his irresponsible and self-centred actions led to the abandonment of the West Indies cricket tour of India.

As far as I was concerned, the honourable and responsible thing for Mr. Cameron to do – in his capacity as President and leader of the WICB – was to publicly accept a considerable measure of responsibility for the Indian fiasco that had taken place; to publicly apologize to the Indian Cricket Board; and to resign from office.

Needless-to-say no such resignation was forthcoming then, and none ever will! And the reason it will not happen is not because of any special peculiarity of Mr. Cameron’s character or personality! Rather, it will not happen because the members of the Caribbean social class that Mr. Cameron belongs to simply do not behave in that manner!

The sad reality throughout our Caribbean is that a new bourgeois class has taken over the key leadership positions in Government, in the professions, and in important areas of national and regional life such as Cricket Administration. And it is such a self-absorbed class that its members find it extremely difficult to accept personal responsibility for anything, or to recognize that there are causes or institutions whose interests take precedence over their own personal individual interests.

These social elements have capitalized on the relative apathy and marginalization of the working class, and have constituted themselves into an entrenched elite or in-group, equipped with their own narrow group interests, and with a narrow, self-serving value system. Furthermore, many, if not most, members of this “class” have convinced themselves that they are entitled as of right to positions of privilege, wealth and comfort in our societies. This, in turn, is manifested in their unceasing jockeying for and pursuit of positions of status – privileged “jobs” – in national and regional political and Administrative structures, not least of which is the leadership and administrative structure of the WICB.

Many, if not most, of them are contemptuous of the working class base from which they have sprung. As a result, they possess no substantial roots in our region’s history of race and class struggle, and are therefore incapable of truly appreciating the value of the fruits of such struggles – whether such “fruits” are the sacred cultural institution of West Indies Cricket or — in the case of my island home of Barbados — the famous Barbadian system of free secondary and tertiary education!

The same social element that is incapable of perceiving that the interests of the people’s institution of West Indies Cricket dwarfs their own personal interests, is the same social element that – in national governments throughout our region – is incapable of recognizing and defending the precious social-democratic gains that generations of Caribbean sufferers struggled so hard to achieve.

We, the masses of Caribbean people—the so-called ordinary citizens of the Caribbean– therefore cannot simply sit back and expect these supposed leaders to act responsibility and selflessly, not even where our beloved game of West Indies Cricket is concerned. Left to Cameron and his ilk, they will complacently look on while the once mighty West Indies Cricket team is reduced to a genuine and certified “minnow” in contemporary international Cricket, as long as they –the so-called Administrators– can continue to enjoy an elevated social status and the financial rewards that go with that status.

Some form of determined mass activism has to emerge from the base of our societies if our Caribbean Community is to get back on track with its historic liberatory struggle!

If we truly want to preserve the WICB, West Indies Cricket, “free” education, public health care, welfare provisions, worker rights, national sovereignty, and the list goes on – the people at the base of our societies and such working class-based institutions as the trade unions and the grass-roots cricket organizations (like the “Barbados Cricket League“) will have to bestir themselves and unite around a concrete people’s agenda.

151 responses to “Our West Indian Cricket Shame Only Deepens”


  1. […] Barbados Underground […]


  2. I can’t speak to other territories but the qualities imbued in Barbadians of thrift, self reliance and supreme confidence in personal skill are things of the past.

    All the education, free or paid for can’t take the place of those qualities which came from the home and the environment in which a persons comes of age.

    Sir Garfield Sobers was not highly educated and there were constant jokes about his mental abilities but put him on a cricket field where skill, self confidence and a never say die attitude determine success and not many could compete.

    Oxford and Cambridge blues held him in awe!!

    Here’s the thing though … if you look at the foundations of cricket prowess of Barbadians look no further than The Lodge School, Harrison College and Combermere.

    I would suggest it wasn’t the “learning” in the class room that was important for success on the cricket field, rather the examples of the adults who reinforced the basic qualities of life promoted in the home.

    These examples and qualities also assured success in the class room as they did on the sports field!!

    Check this book!!

    https://www.amazon.com/Cricket-Nurseries-Colonial-Barbados-1865-1966/dp/9766400466/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1521873232&sr=1-1&keywords=cricket+nurseries+of+colonial+barbados

    Sir Garry didn’t make it to any of the Cricket Nurseries of Colonial Barbados … buuut … the whole society also provided the same nurturing the schools did.

    It is the society that has fallen away … the demise of cricket is just another symptom.


  3. Captain Short, Sir Clyde Walcott etc, the people at the head of the WICBC were not on their own responsible for the heyday of Cricket in Barbados/West Indies.

    They were part of a machine, the society, that produced the men with the qualities necessary for success.

    Looking to Cameron to be the source of success/failure is a waste of time … he is just another product of a fallen society.


  4. Anyone who acquires the title ‘Dave Cameron’ after the pusillanimous, cowardly, Britain hating waste of oxygen Dhimmi Dave Cameron, must truly be a minnow among men.


  5. Peter Short??He who started the destruction of West Indies cricket?I would ask John to provide the outstanding contribution of Short to WI cricket.


  6. John March 24, 2018 at 2:42 AM #

    In an indirect way you have touched upon the class divisions in cricket. In Barbados, the division between the BCA and the BCL; the division that allowed those schools mentioned to play division one cricket, while the others did not matter.
    I(n the UK, or more specifically England, e had the same thing up until 1968, gentlemen and players. Even the way you addressed tem was different: Mr Peter May versus Freddie Truman.
    But even the role of individuals was determined by class: the batsmen and slip fielders came from the home counties and Oxbridge, while the fast bowlers came out of Yorkshire coal mines.
    Today it is a bit more subtle. Neither Surrey (Brixton) or Middlesex (Ladbroke Grove) attract young people to play the game, which is what led to what I call the simplistic Tony Cozier myth – that young black men and women are not interested in cricket they prefer football and athletics because of money etc.
    Nonsense. They are not interested in cricket generally because they have been kept. Even in football and athletics it is the same; look at the arguments over black football managers and athletic coaches. Once again the working class do the heavy lifting while the ‘brains’ manage.
    So, CLR’s poetry of cricket was not even played out in the Caribbean. I have said her e before and say again: have we in Barbados ever produced a better batsman than Seymour Nurse. Why don’t we celebrate him the way we celebrate others? Doubt me, go back to hat historic game in the Park, Spartan versus Empire, with Wes Hall at his best. Nurse put so many lashes in him tears still come to my eyes when I think about it. That game represented the real spirit of cricket.


  7. For what it’s worth a colleague never tire of reminding anyone who would listen that he went to school at St Stephen’s Prinary with Seymour Nurse and nobody could get Seymour ‘out’.


  8. Gabriel March 24, 2018 at 6:27 AM #

    I am not surprised about this. There is a theory in management that what we become as adults was there when we were kids. Lots of sports people play, or have played, more than one game at a reasonable level. Nurse also played football for Barbados until he had to make a choice – and he was good at it. Garry Sobers(fast bowler, medium pacer, spinner, goal keeper, basketballer), etc.
    The best of all was Rudi Webster (Victor Ludorum almost every year of his senior years), cricketer, etc.

  9. Are-we-there-yet Avatar
    Are-we-there-yet

    It is’nt just a Cricket or a West Indies problem. It’s a universal problem!!

    Just look at the US and the shiiiite that the cowardly pusillanimous and venal Republicans have got them into, or Barbados and what the equally venal politically short sighted hierarchy has wrought here by allowing their madman to do foolishness and get away with it just like Trump is doingwith vengeance personified in the US.

    Its the times, people, the end times!

  10. Are-we-there-yet Avatar
    Are-we-there-yet

    Hal Austin @ 6:42 am.

    Therein lies a deeper truth. That of healthy minds in healthy bodies.

    The best athletes are also the best cricketers, footballers, etc, and when they find the time to pursue academic or other pursuits they also excel in them. A pity that in this day and age the availability of fortunes for outstanding athletes in various sports make it unnecessary for them to engage in games of the mind, politics, etc.


  11. Gabriel March 24, 2018 at 5:23 AM #
    Peter Short??He who started the destruction of West Indies cricket?I would ask John to provide the outstanding contribution of Short to WI cricket.

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    If we look to WICBC to lead the WI back to its golden years we have to ask who led them to and during their golden years and what they did that was special!!

    Otherwise, don’t look at WICBC or whoever for solutions!!

    When was Peter Short at his peak in WI cricket control?

    You will find it was during the golden years. That’s where you will find may others making their contribution.

    It is what is in the minds of the players that counts.

    If air is in there then we should not expect any performance, WICB, WICBC or whatever exists!!


  12. In an indirect way you have touched upon the class divisions in cricket. In Barbados, the division between the BCA and the BCL; the division that allowed those schools mentioned to play division one cricket, while the others did not matter.

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    Cricket is a sport/game and to play a sport/game you need free time!!!

    Any sport will begin with the “upper classes” because they have the time to play!!

    Depending on the popularity of the sport, members of other classes see the benefits of the sport and aspire to compete.

    It also applies to countries.

    We are watching 10 “low class” countries in this competition … the only exception being the WI … it isn’t a country …. but it is at the same level of performance for the moment as the others.

    That’s not to say WI or Afghanistan can’t win the upcoming world cup …. if I had to pick my favourite out of the two I would tend to Afghanistan because it has good spin bowlers who can expose any batsman at any level.

    Cricket is a game of glorious uncertainties and that is probably what attracts people to it.

    It is the game that at its highest level is as close to real life as it gets.


  13. @Gabriel March 24, 2018 at 5:23 AM “I would ask John to provide the outstanding contribution of Short to WI cricket.”

    John statement can be read as:

    @John March 24, 2018 at 2:54 AM “Captain Short, Sir Clyde Walcott etc…were not responsible…for the heyday of Cricket in Barbados/West Indies.


  14. @Are-we-there-yet March 24, 2018 at 6:47 AM “Its the times, people, the end times!”

    Don’t worry. It is NOT, repeat NOT the “end times” except that it is the end times for old people like me and for for old men like Trump and Stuart. I guarantee that within 15 years both Trump and Stuart will be dead of old age and affluence, and that the world with my children and grandchildren it it will go happily on without them, and that nobody except their children and spouses will miss them or even remember them.

    Why is it that old people always like to fool themselves about some mythical end times?

    Just because death is staring YOU and ME in the face is that some reason for the world to come to an end?

    The world went on quite happily long, long before we were born, and it WILL GO ON quite happily long, long after we are dead.

    End times what!!!

    Stupssseee!!!


  15. David Comissiong is indeed a specially blessed man.

    His clarity of thought and his community-centric predisposition goes totally against the grain …and he has been unusually consistent in this regard – for a non bushman.

    ‘Are-we-there-yet’ has however, filled in the major gap in David’s thinking at 6.47 am. above.

    The masses CANNOT rise up to do one shiite …..because the fight is not against flesh and blood (mere humans), but against the rulers, against the powers, against the world forces of this darkness, against the spiritual forces of wickedness in the heavenly places.

    If wunna think that it is a “coincidence” that such abject idiocy can be taking place from Barbados to Azerbaijan; from cricket to sewerage; from economics to international relations; from school children to royalty – and that this could be ‘normal’ in a world that has access to more wealth; more knowledge; better communications; better health and better EVERYTHING ….than EVER before in all of history….

    Then Bushie will need to revert to language even stronger than ‘brass bowls’
    ….perhaps even ‘RH brass bowls’……(though such a poster would be illegal…)

    The time is LONG PAST for a complete REVIEW of our circumstances …and for a completely NEW game plan ….one that actually takes into consideration the REALITIES on the ground.

    …..but unfortunately, the capacity for such strategic thinking is WAY beyond RH BBs….


  16. @ Simple Simon
    Your propensity to make illogical and dogmatic statements is mind boggling.

    Our ‘world’ is a living organism – just like you are.
    Just like all the cells in your body cycle through life death and new birth, so does the various constituents of our world undergo cycles of rebirth, life and death.

    Just because a particular cell in your head has seen multiple generations of brain cells die and been replaced before – is no logical basis to conclude that;

    “Simple Simon went on quite happily long, long before I (Celly) was born, and she WILL GO ON quite happily long, long after I (Celly) am dead.”

    Cause we all know that Simple S is going to die just now….

    Well mother Earth is in the exact same position… Her ass is sick; she is on life support; her ankles hurt; her lungs are polluted; her diet has been a mess…..

    AWTY is EXACTLY right….
    The end is near – and all the signs are that we may well be the last ‘cells’ alive to be eaten by the worms of her death…..


  17. We nearly whole-heartedly second this magisterial excoriation of backward Caribbean elites by David Comissiong.

    While Comissiong still seems hopeful that these renegade elites might still be brought to heel we have long loss such hope

    Indeed, we have consigned Caribbean elites to the leading edge of a certain antiquarian device. A device not unknown for intervening to transform thoroughly corrupted societies.

    Comissiong’s article should be required reading and deep study for all educational institutions everywhere in the Caribbean – from primary to tertiary.

    A full week, coming, must be set aside by them to meditate on its deepest meanings. Arising from such introspection there must be a firm determination excise the cancerous Caribbean elites – where ever they may be.

    We could never understand why the winning system, formal and informal, developed by Clive Lloyd and as continued by Vivian Richards had to be jettisoned.

    This clear break from a period of excellence could only be explained by the insatiable appetite of Caribbean elites to destructively locate ordinary Caribbean people to a place where we have long been while maintain their nearness to massa.

    Caribbean elites were always uncomfortable with an essentially Black, working class, team dominating world cricket for two decades.

    We use to witness their apologia, in the stands, as their discomfort level rise, when our great teams would crush all before them, especially while having ‘tea’ with their masters.

    The Englishmen used to be begging them, the Caribbean elites, for mercy; asking that the games should last the full five days; complaining that West Indies unparalleled success was not good for the game as a global institution.

    Something had to give. For no modern day formation of slaves, like the Caribbean elites, can long withstand the constant commands of their masters.

    The WICB(C) has been a monumental failure. It failed to brand the innate cricketing instincts of Caribbean people as a leading money maker. Caribbean cricket as the authentic form of the limited overs game. We live in a time where the rest of the world play Caribbean cricket better than Caribbean people and are the culture vultures we see with carnival and so on.

    This state of affairs is only possible when many are willing to be enemies within – Caribbean elites.

  18. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ John March 24, 2018 at 2:42 AM #
    “I can’t speak to other territories but the qualities imbued in Barbadians of thrift, self reliance and supreme confidence in personal skill are things of the past.”

    What jingoistic nonsense is this John? What are you suggesting here? That the “qualities” needed to succeed in sports and other human endeavours are ‘special’ to Barbados?

    How then do you explain the likes of Learie Constantine, George Headley,Vivian Richards, Clive Lloyd or Brian Lara; none of whom was a Bajan?

    Are you implying that there is a cultural DNA gene called the “Bajan in me” that these “foreigners” could have inherited from their ‘wandering’ Bajan born ancestors?

    As for Sir Garry, he succeeded ‘in spite of’ the Bajan social setup of his time.
    The man was born to be great and would have been treated as a demigod whether he was born in England, India or Australia.

    The great Sir Garry, and to a lesser extent Rihanna, just by happenstance, was born in Barbados just like Bob Marley, Usain Bolt and Mary Secole were born in Jamaica or Muhammad Ali and Jackie Robinson were born in the racially segregated USA.

    The glory days of Little England, just like those of the British Empire, are over; dead and gone as reflected in the ongoing political, social and economic decay of your once proud country.

    Barbados, in the early 1990’s, was considered the No.1 ‘developing’ country on the planet making it the 20th ‘best’ place to live on the planet according to the UN Human Development Index, after Israel at No.19 which miraculously is still ranked at No.19 whereas Barbados has slipped to No.54 as at 2017.

    Now stop living in the past and accept your status in the history being ‘created’ by your King Kong of All Clowns who now represents the embodiment of what it means to be a Bajan today; just the ‘humiliated’ laughingstock of the region with a growing ‘shitty’ image and now spreading like wild fire across the world.


  19. In the 50s and 60s we played cricket because there was not much else to do and it was cheap.

    We made our own bats balls and stumps.

    In the 60s cricket became more organized and schools like Kolij Cawmere and Lodge had proper equipment and pitches.

    At Kolij we had at least 3 masters who coached cricket.

    We played sport without the distraction of Television and the Internet.

    It is unrealistic to expect to produce cricketers in this modern era except those who are

    focused on swiping their way into T20 tournaments.


  20. @Hants

    Agree with you Hants. Then money flowed into the game and we didn’t integrate a relevant operating model to sustain the success. Since the Lloyd and Richards era we are still playing catch up.


  21. One can only imagine the pain of the former cricketers watching the WI celebration of reaching the word cup after scraping by the minnows. Watching the final tomorrow against Afghanistan will rub salt in the wound IF we lose and make true fans feel no better if we win. Let us not forget this is just the symptom of a decaying society.

  22. de pedantic Dribbler Avatar
    de pedantic Dribbler

    @Are-we, what in heaven’s name does DTrump know bout a bat and cricket ball😁…quite an interesting segue you made there ! Brother, dem is fighting words re “cowardly pusillanimous and venal …” . But to be fair to the venal president and his party the US Dems are not blameless for the current state of affairs….so as segues go… that leads to the second query..

    @Gabriel, whilst John prepares your query response perhaps you in turn could offer a response to the alternative query: what damaging acts did Short so singularly do as Pres to start the destruction of WI cricket?

    Was it that Des Haynes v Richardson captaincy matter….or was it the Brian Lara award travel back home on approval to leave the English tour debacle?? Of course those are simple threads in themselves but are knitted to more complex issues so I am keen to understand your facts of his incompetence.

    I hold no brief for the man but as I have said here before I distinctly recall the man showing great interest and guidance to the career of a very gifted regular Black boy and peer (who alas never made the WI team) and other lads over the years so that behaviour stands at odds to actively working to damage WI cricket. So just an enquiring mind needs clarity!

    And @Hal, your Nurse adoration is all good but he is not the first very talented person who was unable to reach and remain at primetime as long as he expected or get the respect and adoration of a wide audience.


  23. @ Hants – 9.04 am
    ….It is unrealistic to expect to produce cricketers in this modern era except those who are
    focused on swiping their way into T20 tournaments.
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Take ZERO….

    How does almost everyone else manage to do so?
    Are there no televisions in Australia? …no other sports in India? … no distractions in South Africa?

    Boss – there is just NO LEADERSHIP in the ‘West Indies’ (whatever the hell THAT is..)

    When a region can SET OUT to hire foreigners to manage, coach and train their team then we KNOW that we are dealing with RH BBs to BEGIN with….

    Only shiite results can follow….


  24. Nostalgia..
    Gone are the days when we were punching above our weight…
    Alas, we have discovered that we are not heavyweights but are flyweights
    Mournful is our cry.
    Truth like life is a bitch.


  25. For those who are comatose I insert the commas
    Truth, like life, is a bitch.


  26. comatose, I

  27. de pedantic Dribbler Avatar
    de pedantic Dribbler

    Mr Blogmaster, we sit in very different chairs in very different neigbourhoods but we review the same data (on cricket anyhow, I imagine ) … so perhaps its not so amazing that we have such different perspectives on that data.

    You said “[t]hen money flowed into the game and we didn’t integrate a relevant operating model to sustain the success. Since the Lloyd and Richards era we are still playing catch up.”

    That is a loaded statement that completely crunches many major commercial TV contract negotiations, marketing programs, legal and procedural matters and a slew of egotistical personalities into one sound bite.

    Yes, on the field we have played catch up since Lloyd and Richards but I cant agree that ” we didn’t integrate a relevant operating model to sustain the success”.

    I am sure Dinath Ramnarine’s And his team would scoff at that because you are suggesting that all the militant negotiations he did at the player level was for nought…

    And just as much the smart business guys would scoff, folks like Ken Gordon, Pat Rosseau as Presidents and CEOs like Roger Brathwaite and Donald Peters and others like Tony Marshall, Stephen Alleyne or the banking executive from the Leewards (whose name defeats me now) who were long standing Board members. Or even Chris Dehring who ran the world cup. All savvy people!

    It’s been easy for years to say that the WIBC was stagnant( and that may be accurate in some regards) but they also made tremendous modifications towards improvement and elected otherwise very successful businessmen who were simply unable to corral the monster of intracable island boards and then doubly intracable militant players.

    Relevant operational models were definitely in place…being able to execute on the lovely business plans was basically impossible, it always appeared to me!


  28. It amazes me that men and women of intellect cannot see beyond the next election. It is almost as if they have bowed their head so that they can see for just a few feet ahead and thus ignore the barren landscape ahead.

    Is it optimism or is it delusion?

    If it is optimism then they are inspiring. For they wake up each morning and attack the day with vigor as they seek to correct what is wrong with their world. But this is akin to wearing blinkers so that they can engage in Sisyphean tasks by pretending that it is a new boulder they roll uphill everyday.

    If it is delusion then they do an injustice to themselves and their children. They perpetrate the myth that our society can be fixed by the effort of a few. That the fix is simple. They tell us that that the Augean stables can be cleanse with shovels instead of unleashing the mighty river to sweep the sickness away.

    I have seen others use these words and I know that even with their blinkers that they have seen the light.
    Animal Farm
    Orwellian
    Wonderland

    Use your distant vision.

    Alas, poor me. I had Damascene moments. I saw the light and the path ahead and became a pessimist.


  29. @Dee Word

    On the emotive subject of cricket, politics and religion we will never all agree this we can be sure. Let us agree however that the results will always tell the tale.


  30. Quick question david where is your same energy for sandals and crane hotel or you to busy Worring about crying down the players that giving their all. Now if they win World Cup next year or make it far, people like you should have nothing to say. How long have West Indies been failing??? When last was they on top & no T20 don’t count.


  31. John
    Simon and Dribbler have both seen your failure to answer my query.As Dr Lawrence Nurse of the Hill would have said…’get to the effing point man’!


  32. Are you implying that there is a cultural DNA gene called the “Bajan in me” that these “foreigners” could have inherited from their ‘wandering’ Bajan born ancestors?
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    Read the book I suggested and you will see that organized cricket clubs in Barbados begun with the British Army in the early 19th century.

    The Army was Garrisoned in Barbados and it is from these beginnings that WI cricket spring.

    None of the early clubs survive.

    The oldest clubs around today date from the late 19th century.

    Trinidad became English in the 1790’s and Demerara about the same time, both driven by the need for land to produce sugar the price of which had trebled as a result of the destruction of the Haitian economy by the slaves.

    The sugar industry in Demerara and Trinidad were both developed from …. Barbados!!

    Links among the colonial territories were fostered by sugar.

    Pan boilers and engineers from Demerara made the annual trek to Barbados to work at the 50 odd sugar factories.

    The factories in all territories became centres for excellence and cricket was the natural sport.

    The sport promoted healthy competition and participation by more and more young men in the various centres for excellence … the sugar factories.

    Cricket season and crop season in Barbados went hand for a reason!!

    From the factories cricket spread as a sport to the environs.

    It was played more and more as it gained in popularity.

    Learie Constantine (Trinidad) and George Headley (Jamaica) were early participants in the early 20th century and reflect I believe the growing popularity of cricket after a century of its establishment.

    Clive Lloyd is a product of Guyana a generation later than LC and GH.

    Viv Richards from the “Combined Islands” came on to the scene with cricket already well established.

    I remember the poor relations and their constant complaints that none of them were getting a pick on the WI team.

    Remember the Shillingfords, Grayson and Irving and Mike Findlay etc.

    WI cricket was more about sugar and its relationships than you might imagine … the “big” colonies were “big” because of their sugar output …. even though Barbados is smaller than many of the “small” islands!!

    Whether we like to admit it or not there really is no longer a reason for the existence of West Indies cricket because there no longer is anything that binds the territories together!!

    Caricom is a joke.

    It was great while it lasted, including the golden years under the Peter Shorts, Clyde Walcotts etc etc.

  33. de pedantic Dribbler Avatar
    de pedantic Dribbler

    @John I see your 12 PM (on sugar industry) as prosaic ‘bilge’ water flowing from one of those steam pipes…good on way in to cool the boiler but and absolute affluence on the way out interpretation. You are an engineer so I presume your focus is about efficiency, skill and craftsmanship when you speak of “centers of excellence” sugar factories.

    Because on every other metric as evidenced by your Haitian rebellion reference the sugar industry was abject horror. Anyhow be that as it was and always will be!

    Your remark that “Whether we like to admit it or not there really is no longer a reason for the existence of West Indies cricket because there no longer is anything that binds the territories together..” is par for your course following on from your glorious accolaxes of the bygone era but let me offer another perspective…

    There is EVERY reason that a strong and dominant WI team MUST continue. This is the greatest period since the county cricket heyday for your athletes to turn their skill into money for homes, investment and a good standard of living.

    In fact there are more cricket millionaires and several very well off players in the region than at any other time in our history…now is EXACTLY the time to really focus on excellence and professionalism and make our teams supremely dominant!

    A dominant WI T20 or 50-Over side generates buzz and excitment and provides an ongoing platform for players to become major stars in the various competitions and leagues. Dash aside your rather discrimanatory assertion that cricket is a force to harbour kinship among workmates … LONG AGO ABSOLUTE BALDERDASH.

    These players are masters of their OWN destinity.


  34. What happened to Combined Colleges and Campuses?

    I’m always fascinated by seeing college sport from the USA on TV and (A) how it’s on TV and (B) there’s thousands of people in the stadium! We just don’t have that in England.

    Now you’ve got English county teams playing in West Indies domestic competitions which is great experience for our players but a bit weird for West Indies’ cricket!


  35. Cricketers can make their millions in the various T20 leagues around the globe if they are good enough!!

    They do not need WI cricket and WI cricket does not need them!!


  36. What have Pollard or Bravo or Gayle contributed to West Indies cricket?


  37. … and Narine??

  38. de pedantic Dribbler Avatar
    de pedantic Dribbler

    John your latest remarks simply show your clear lack of acuity on the subject ..carry on apace.

    But for your benefit those folks you mentioned played their initial inter island games like the former Lloyd or Viv or let’s say Gordon Greenidge in the same did.

    Folks like yourself you can’t see past their dyed in wool prejudices and old style models will continue to spew your illogic.

    The strength of WI cricket as a sports center still rests in the island nations coming together to fight as one team at the international level…ideally those that matter realize that completely.

    Carry on apace with your dogma, senor. I gone.


  39. Cricket, lovely cricket- if you want opinions on cricket visit Barbados where you will find at least 275,000 differing ones.

    The phrase comes to mind ‘Stick a fork in it its done” the rise of West Indian cricket was accidental, the fall predictable. That a collection of islands with a combined population of less than 10,000,000 could be world colossus in a particular arena was lightning in a bottle and the bubble was destined to burst. There were three cricketing nations at the top of the totem pole during the heyday of WI cricket; England which regarded the game as a way to past time between bouts of tea and crumpets with the occasional cucumber sandwich played in bucolic surroundings; Australia with its scrappy mentality and who played the game as an outgrowth of its convict heritage and WI, those unvarnished descendants of slaves who were anxious to bloody the nose of the British bulldog that looked down on the upstart colonials (wogs even). Even as the WI dominated England it never completely bested Australia save for the occasional triumph. Its descent began the moment money rather than prestige started to have an impact on the game. The advent of money was a clarion call for the other nations with vastly superior populations to mine and groom its talent for success which is now reflected in today’s results. The WI already fragmented group of islands where insularity is a way of life is now destined to be in the lower echelons of world cricket a proverbial minnow except for the occasional flourish which excites the populace for a few days only to sink back to the reality of the also run.

    Stick a fork in it its done.


  40. Looks like your view sides with that if the blogmaster just that you are more pessimistic!

    Dee Word take note.

  41. Are-we-there-yet Avatar
    Are-we-there-yet

    Simple Simon;

    You said “End times what!!! Stupssseee!!!” Let me explain.

    My understanding of the “end times” is not necessarily of an abrupt ending to the existence of Mankind on Earth but of a distinct historic break in almost every aspect of our lives that presages extremely important changes in the Earth and man’s relationship to it as guided by The Entity that would have created and maintained this wonderful Earth and our Cosmos.

    I think that God created the Cosmos and therefore Earth, Mankind, all living things and everything else that supports our being and that He has continued to oversee and guide the development of the Cosmos throughout the billions of years of time that this Earth and its coexistent Life has been in Existence.

    I think that Trump and his counterintuitively brainless actions, in a USA where dangerous technology exists that he controls. The Republicans in congress have consistently refused to live up to their sworn function to control any dangerous excesses of the President. Such excesses and the Congress’ inaction cannot be happenstance but I think are signposts to something that has been etched on the blueprint for the corrective destruction and rebirth of America and could possibly strongly affect the future of mankind and Earth as well. I think that this period in the progression of man’s interaction with Earth could be the most consequential one in the recent history of Mankind on Earth and could hasten our eventual destruction, given the capacity of a few nations like the USA, Russia and N-Korea, among others, to do so with uncontrolled use of their extremely dangerous weapons of mass and Earth destruction.

    The Stuart gambit of allowing Barbados to plunge into a situation where there is currently no Government and no room to manouver if, say, the reserves take an unexpected plunge in the next few weeks, is similarly symptomatic of counterintuitive brainless actions by a HoG who can apparently only explain it by reference to being the first PM in the region to do such and therefore be worthy of a laudable honour (especially since his other windmill of converting Barbados into a Republic has come to naught). But this is offered as merely another signpost not as a sign that Barbados can contribute significantly to an endtime-related cataclysm

    However, the countries of the world are currently providing examples of dysfunction that are far above the scale of any similar dysfunction recorded by our forbears and capable of destroying whole countries. The possibly mythical Atlantis was said to have been destroyed by its citizens (divided into two factions – those committed to service to self against those committed to service to others) using a death ray powered by the Sun, causing numerous tsunamis and earthquakes and volcanoes over the space of a couple of weeks. Current non-mythical doomsday weapons are thousands of times more powerful. In addition, serious science is admitting to the possibility that Earth could be struck by powerful Asteroids or Comets at any time and is also recognizing that several such occurrences contributed to the concept of Ages where mankind developed advanced civilizations that each crumbled when extraterrestrial objects impacted and brought them down.

    The few survivors brought them back up again in each case.

    Your, and my, grandchildren may therefore be among the lucky ones who will survive to provide for the rebirth of the Earth when there is a new end time or cataclysm.

    Who knows?

  42. Are-we-there-yet Avatar
    Are-we-there-yet

    dpD

    Oops!

    Just for the record, I think that Commissiong has once again penned a most perceptive article. I am not really a cricket fan but I think that the malaise in the Cricket arena in the West Indies merely mirrors the malaise in almost every sphere of endeavour where we might have excelled using pre-colonial and immediately post colonial resources.

    The drop in our effectiveness is almost certainly attributable to human resource availablilty and the inability of leadership to implement their strategic plans. The rest of the cricket playing and worshipping fraternity have caught up with us and have a wider base of potential players to select from and to keep employed on a full time basis.

    Cricket has moved on. We have’nt.


  43. The difference is all of the other countries are individually playing as countries.

    For example, the Irish play as the Irish and woe betide England if they ever get them in their cross hairs.

    The Australians just got caught cheating (again!!) …. the game is something personal to them.

    In each case, their identity matters to them and winning is everything.

    In each case they will play with their hearts on their sleeves … some will do whatever is necessary.

    The dwellers in the collection of territories in the West Indies don’t give a damn about each other!!

    …. there used to be a time when that was not so!!

    There was a time when the game was greater than the individual and the love for the game overcame the differences.

    Reduce the contest to dollars and cents …. throw in a sprinkling of politicians and few prima donnas and half ass historians …. recipe for disaster!!

    Sad thing is this lot tag on to the greatness of the past and are just not up to it.

    I don’t think they understand why the WI were great.

    If this lot ever learns to play the game as a sport and for the love of it … maybe we might see something other than what we see.

    We might just be able to teach the world a thing or three about sport and how to play it.

    How many West Indian cricketers got caught with a suspect action?

    How many got caught ball tampering?

    Sport is like “Black Panther” … it is for entertainment … it isn’t necessary to read any deep meanings into either … just enjoy.

  44. Are-we-there-yet Avatar
    Are-we-there-yet

    Oops!

    Just read over my 2:35 pm post

    The second sentence should read as follows:-

    I think that Trump and his counterintuitively brainless actions, in a USA where dangerous technology that he controls exists, may be signposts to imminent world changes, especially when one takes into account similar actions in some very important megastates and the stresses between these states.

  45. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ John March 24, 2018 at 12:00 PM #
    “Are you implying that there is a cultural DNA gene called the “Bajan in me” that these “foreigners” could have inherited from their ‘wandering’ Bajan born ancestors?
    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
    Read the book I suggested and you will see that organized cricket clubs in Barbados begun with the British Army in the early 19th century.
    The Army was Garrisoned in Barbados and it is from these beginnings that WI cricket spring.
    None of the early clubs survive.”

    Oh John, when are you going to give up your pursuit of your persistent comfort of living in the halcyon days of white supremacy in the colonies?

    Can’t a similar explanation be given to the rise of India (and by extension Pakistan and Sri Lanka) as cricketing ‘nations’ (and not to mention Australia and New Zealand) easily capable of overcoming the ‘West Indies’ today in that testing game?

    Certainly it cannot be only the fulcrum of the sugar factory which acted as the launch pad for West Indian cricketing greatness?

    What about the other ‘organized’ sports copied by the English to make them their own like football, rugby, tennis and hockey?

    Do you want it to be mentioned of the other activities introduced by your colonial masters that are suffering the same decaying syndrome as WI cricket like the boys’ scouts, girl guides and Anglican Church attendance?

    How do you explain Jamaica’s exceptional performance in track and field athletics compared to its global population size? Smoking weed and eating ‘ground’ food?

    Cricket (like nearly everything else in the ‘West Indies’ including tourism) depends on the guidance and control of those outside the region to survive and like the sugar industry which, according to you, gave birth to it would die an inevitable death just like the dodo bird on the island of Mauritius which, incidentally- despite its prospering modernized sugar industry- is not by any stretch of the imagination a well known cricketing nation; horse racing and all.


  46. Cameron Bancroft: Australia player admits to ball-tampering, Steve Smith knew in advance

    http://www.bbc.com/sport/cricket/43526870

  47. NorthernObserver Avatar
    NorthernObserver

    @AWTY
    yet Jamaican athletes, among others, from the same ‘West Indian states’ have excelled. They have dominated the track sprints, like how the WI fast bowlers once dominated. Not to mention those who competed for other countries.

    Cricket changed in the late 70’s. A TV owner, Packer, appreciated the value of broadcasting rights, and sought to shake up the market with his WSC. This was followed by “rebel” tours to S.Africa, first by England, then Sri Lanka and finally two by the West Indies. Also in 1982, to protect their own, English County Cricket limited teams to one overseas player. At the time, County Cricket was the major professional league, though others existed.

    Players were paid little. In the early 80’s, the West Indies could have fielded 2, or maybe 3, internationally competitive teams. The players went to S.Africa for the money. The WICB of the time, staunchly refused to expand or change the WI team make-up to allow for the numerous first class players they had.

    The disgrace which occurred in India was about money. And since the late 80’s, cricket has battled with how to integrate an old system (playing for your country) into a professional sport. It has been exacerbated by numerous leagues, playing a variety of forms of cricket with a variety of rules. It has been a rocky road.


  48. “A match and series slipping away and a ball that could not get past the bats of South Africa’s batsmen drove Australia’s captain Steven Smith to an orchestrated attempt to cheat by tampering with the ball, a task carried out by the team’s youngest member Cameron Bancroft with the use of adhesive tape to try to pick up some rough earth from the Newlands pitch.”

    What should be the penalty for these Australian CHEATERS ?


  49. This what happens when the game is played for the pure love of it.

    A great recognized by a great!!

    Notice, the great is not playing for country.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading