Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

While addressing the last annual general conference of her union, the General Secretary of the Barbados Workers’ Union (BWU), Toni Moore, complained about what she saw as union busting tactics being employed by Cost-U-Less. She sought to connect the granting of duty free concessions by Government as the reason why that company felt “empowered” to engage in such tactics.

To be honest, that reasoning escaped me but somehow it was sufficient to bring down the ire of the Honourable Chris Sinckler, on her. And in a nonsensical retort, while addressing his party faithful he claimed that it was logical to conclude that since Government has given the General Secretary and the BWU tax concessions on a Mercedes Benz, Ms Moore felt empowered to be bashing Government.

If that is the quality of the reasoning of the person who holds the portfolio of Minister of Finance, it is no wonder that the country is in such dire straits. The General Secretary has raised an issue that impinges on the constitutional rights of workers. Any half decent minister of the Crown would have been grateful for that information and join her in an effort to protect the dignity of the workers of this country, whom he is sworn to serve. What has made this minister so cocky that he can make light and be so disrespectful of the genuine concerns of the people whose votes he would be seeking in the upcoming elections.

Even though his behaviour is below that expected of a senior political figure, he has drawn attention to two issues, tax concessions and union busting. They are too serious to be sidestepped by the dismissive twattle of a government minister, who is more interested in providing comic relief for party members, at a branch meeting, than dealing with fundamental workers’ rights issues.

Union busting has become so pervasive, especially during this prolonged recession and the authorities have failed to adequately deal with the problem for the sake of maintaining jobs. Ms Moore has correctly stated that people are losing jobs because they have committed the cardinal sin of becoming union members.

In accordance with section 40A of the Trade Union Act, it is a crime to dismiss a worker because he has become a member of a trade union. However, in my experience, the police were not aware that it constitutes a criminal offence. Unfortunately, when such a matter is reported to police, they do not take it seriously and no action is taken against the offending employer.

In an attempt to put the General Secretary on the back foot, the minister revealed that BWU had benefited from tax concessions on a Mercedes Benz. However, in my opinion, while trying to embarrass Ms Moore, the minister effectively shot himself in the foot. He must now explain the basis for granting tax concessions on high end vehicles for the two major unions.

Before I go further, I must make it clear that I am not accusing any trade unionists of wrongdoing, by accepting charity from employers. But to me, as the Americans would say, the optics are bad.

If you were to hire a lawyer to represent you in a matter, and thereafter, discover that your representative was taking undisclosed gifts from your opponent. How would you feel? Now pray tell me, how is that different for trade unions to take undisclosed concessions/gifts from the employer, especially when the law requires disclosure.

In accordance with the Duties, Taxes and Other Payments (Exemption) Act, the Minister of Finance may, by order, exempt any person, business or undertaking from the payment of any duty, tax or other money. However, section 4 of that act provides that any such order is subject to negative resolution.

Section 41.(2) of the Interpretation Act explains, when a statutory instrument is subject to negative resolution, it must be laid in Parliament for forty days, and during that period, either house can by resolution vote to annul the instrument. Any such order must also be published in the Official Gazette.

I have made a diligent search and can find no evidence that any such order was ever published. I am therefore asking the honourable minister, when did he comply with the law, in relation to granting tax concessions on motor vehicles for the leaders of major trade unions? And if he had not done so, why the secrecy?

Champagne taste and mauby pockets have brought trade unions into disrepute.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

93 responses to “The Caswell Franklyn Column – Trade Unions Accepting Bribes/Concessions from Government”


  1. Caswell

    Is there a single honest man or woman in all of Gideon?

    Pachamama will save us all if you could show us one, just one!

    This is the nature of endemic corruption, it compromises the entire society

    Those who make a living from it, whether official or unofficial

    Those gone to the grave and those yet unborn

    But for Pachamama all are just as guilty and will be appropriately judged.

  2. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger. Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger.

    Why must all of them drive mercedes at taxpayer’s and union members expense, which are not suitable for the island’s many potholed roads.

    Violating the rights of the majority population starts with both governments, neither of them have ever observed, enforced or respected the basic humans rights of workers to join unions…then they enable, encourage and condone local and foreign employers to do the same.

    …. most of the employers in Swan and Tudor streets and other areas are gunrunning, drug dealing criminals, but they are allowed, by bith governments, to violate employee’s rights and prevent them from joining unions.

  3. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger. Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger.

    …but they are allowed, by BOTH governments, to violate employee’s rights and prevent them from joining unions.


  4. Should luxury auto imports be banned completely?

    Communist countries (Cuba, North Korea) and countries short on foreign exchange (Iran) have prohibited imports of luxury autos for lengthy periods.

    Seems to me that many places in the Caribbean and Africa cannot justify importing expensive cars when they do not always have enough foreign exchange for life-saving medical supplies and diagnostic equipment.

    Why do most Barbadians support the right of wealthy individuals and their enablers to divert scarce resources to such questionable purposes?

  5. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Pachamama

    Corruption is all around us like the air we breathe. It has become so entertwined into the fabric of society that it has become the norm. People are just not offended by it.

  6. Bajan Free Party/CUP-PCP Violet Beckles Plantation Deeds from 1926-2017 land tax bills and no Deeds,BLPand DLP Massive land Fruad and PONZ Avatar
    Bajan Free Party/CUP-PCP Violet Beckles Plantation Deeds from 1926-2017 land tax bills and no Deeds,BLPand DLP Massive land Fruad and PONZ

    Well Well, Those types of cars give you a better chance of living in an accident which allows you to keep living to get the gifts and to serve the people better,

    So without the help of the crook MOF, they may not recover a good hit by COW s trucks, As you know many of People in positions were nearly killed by COWs trucks on the roads of Barbados and some have died.

    These Hits are used as mere accidents to write you off the Books, I only drive American
    made cars in Barbados, the Imports in Barbados are made of foil and buckle like a belt,

    If the Union dont act like a Union the People in the Union can show their voice when time to vote this crook and the rest out of office in to the hands of a real DPP.

  7. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger. Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger.

    “So without the help of the crook MOF, they may not recover a good hit by COW s trucks.”

    Cow’s new trucks are also bought with taxpayer’s dollars and pensioner’s stolen NIS money.

    I now completely understand why trinis are taking to facebook to bring down the 2 year old Rowley government.


  8. To stay focused on the point how is it possible for the NUPW and BWU to negotiate with government at the bargaining table if said government waived the duty on a luxury vehicle? This not about attacking Toni Moore, it is about principle. The last sentence is meant for Dennis Johnson.

  9. Armando Rodriguez Avatar
    Armando Rodriguez

    While we are at it ………could someone explain why the former head of a trade union in Barbados had the distinction of have flown more times on the BA Concorde than any other Barbadian?


  10. Was British Airways unionized?

  11. Armando Rodriguez Avatar
    Armando Rodriguez

    David

    Relevance of that question/point?


  12. How does receiving a complimentary seat on the Concorde compromise the work of the unionist?


  13. @Caldwell

    Do I detect a small note of gealosly, you have not received your tax free Mercedes courtesy of MOE.

    I agree with you corruption in Barbados is now totally out of hand, the question is what can be done to correct this issue. We good fire every politician, civil servant, union leader etc, however more corrupt individuals would step forward as replacements. Barbados has to totally change its mindset, this however is not likely to happen. Welcome along for the ride on the DOWNWARD SPIRAL INTO THE ABYSS. Things are not going to improve in the near future, there is a better than average probability we are presently seeing the GOOD TIMES.


  14. @Caswell not Caldwell

    DAM SPELL CHECKER.

  15. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Wily Coyote

    No jealousy at all. And in any event, I don’t have anywhere to park it.

    Seriously, I am not a quid pro quo kind of guy so I would not contemplate asking the minister, plus I prefer a Toyota.

    Sent from my iPad


  16. Why the sudden focus on the General Secretary of the BWU? Is the duty free concession for her personal car or is she entitled to say “That is not my car. It belongs to the Barbados Workers Union and its members and when I leave office the car will not go with me but remain for the next General Secretary”. Further, the last car was inspected by the authorized dealers and their conclusion is that the car, while unsuitable for our roads, has reached its expiry date and would be too costly to repair. Anyway, she may be there for a very long time. Now I know that the GS would not be so stupid to offer such an explanation UNLESS she was of the opinion that she was speaking to fellow idiots.


  17. Well well
    Do you even understand trini politics? I don’t think you do. The “Trinis” looking to bring down the PNM are of a yellow political persuasion and majority Indian.

  18. Well Well @ Consequences Observing Blogger Avatar
    Well Well @ Consequences Observing Blogger

    enuff…..do you really think it makes a difference, do you really think it is better under PNM since there is no majority population to speak of , same number of indo, black…it is same old for all, ecept for governments enabling a 1 percent, tsame PNM with Duprey and CL Financial…

    even having a majority population as Barbados does makes no difference who is elected now does it, exchanging D for B…all corruption is the same…..same corruption with both governments and Parris/CLICO et al…when ya find a difference let me know.

    to my understanding of trini politics, in the 80s, when it was a real hole, i lived there for more than a couple years, so i guess i would understand a little more than someone who never did.

  19. Armando Rodriguez Avatar
    Armando Rodriguez

    Why do you assuming it was complimentary seats?

    By all account it dozens of trips


  20. Help us to understand the benefit and motivation for the complimentary trips.


  21. Lion and the lamb, lion and the lamb, lion and the lamb. PM Stuart will be vindicated over and over again.


  22. Political considerations, political decisions, political decisions


  23. David

    As the BA union rep at the time of Concorde I was not aware of anyone enjoying multiple free trips on Concorde, however I do know at that time we enjoyed the highest airline salary in Bim.


  24. Mercedes, BMW, Miele washer and Hansgrohe-shower are the tools to bribe Barbadians into hell.

    No wonder the German trade surplus is higher than the Chinese!


  25. FearPlay October 8, 2017 at 10:50 AM #

    Why the sudden focus on the General Secretary of the BWU? Is the duty free concession for her personal car or is she entitled to say “That is not my car. It belongs to the Barbados Workers Union and its members and when I leave office the car will not go with me but remain for the next General Secretary”. Further, the last car was inspected by the authorized dealers and their conclusion is that the car, while unsuitable for our roads, has reached its expiry date and would be too costly to repair. Anyway, she may be there for a very long time. Now I know that the GS would not be so stupid to offer such an explanation UNLESS she was of the opinion that she was speaking to fellow idiots.

    So Funny that you would resort to defending the indefensible . using dialogue to convince yourself

    However when the PM had his car change when the same analogy that is being presented by you was offered there was a loud and long ruckus coming from the inner bellies of you and other BLP operatives have you got no shame


  26. There is also a diference between private money and taxpayers money.

    By breaking the law and setting up the precedence of granting duty free cars to unions leaders, the government at the time of Dennis Clarke and Walter Maloney (Sir Roy was probably getting a duty car for decades)…………….the government at the time wanted the NUPW to agree to a secret deal of a wage freeze.

    So to take away the priviledge now may be to expose what happened in secret. Remember that the workers were never told by Walter Maloney or Dennis Clarke about this deal until the government reneged and laid off 3000 workers.

    These wildboys should be damned for all eternity.


  27. Sorry Prodigirl

    This government of rational thinking PM and ministers is here to stay !

    Term 3 begins in 2018 !!!!

    Don’t mind your myopic prediction that this DLP government of 2013 was to collapse since December 2013 !!!

    Well we got news for you …….Dems NOW……Dems AGAIN…..

    Tek dat !!!!


  28. Prodigirl

    Wait until the blast of war is sounded……!

    Mia Mottley, if she does not come back from England with her LEC……she is in big TROUBLE !!!!!!

    So you & Miller better make sure she brings it back

    BLP jokers 🤹🏻‍♂️🤹🏻‍♂️🤹🏻‍♂️🤹🏻‍♂️🤹🏻‍♂️🤹🏻‍♂️

  29. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Prodigal Son

    Toni sought to explain her acceptance of duty free concessions from Government by saying that it was going on for 30 years. All she did is to confirm that BWU was accepting bribes for 30 years.

    Sent from my iPad


  30. You cant be that much of an idiot not to be aware that a LEC is earned from tertiary institutions in the Caribbean?

    JA

  31. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger. Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger.

    Lol….


  32. Brek Up dem

    Nobody is interested in your gutter talk……we are listening to what is factual like the dire position in which you incompetent morons have put this country. By the way, what is the revenue from the killer NRSL to be used for? Care to tell BU?

    Eddie Abed was required listening today but I guess you did not hear a word as you idiots do not like to hear how you have destroyed our fair land.

    If you all are so confident of a third term, why are you afraid to call the election?

    After all it is not a problem, you dems are never giving up the government…………….


  33. Abed and his ilk are ungrateful for fourtern years they feasted off the fatted calf and now it is time to pay back he gets on radio and cries belly hurt. sumbody needs to tell that ole goat Country First


  34. Yes Prodigal,Eddie Abed sure spoke the truth,the whole truth and nothing but the truth today on VOB Sunday Brasstacks.The man was incisive and devastating in his overview of this DLP administration since 2008.I think his comment is worth repeating on VOB,even if as talking points by David Ellis,Dennis Johnson or Peter Wickham

  35. William Skinner Avatar

    Caswell is very late to the party. Once upon a time the General Secretary of the Barbados Workers Union , used to drive nothing less than a Jaguar ! Perhaps Caswell should go back and find out if the jag was also duty free. This is nit picking of the highest order. if the cars belong to the union and not the officials, such a magnanimous act on the part of successive governments, is really in the workers interest because its the workers who actually pay to run the union , vehicles included.
    It is most unfortunate, that a MOF, who has so much on his plate can find time to be embroiled in such pig urine. The bottom line is this : If the cars belong to the union and the duties saved the union X amount of money, that is a saving to the workers.


  36. Angela

    It is time you told those of your ilk that it is high time they put Barbados first, ahead of the dlp.

    It is abundantly clear that your party has lost its moral authority to lead this country.

    Your party has mismanaged the resources of this country and has impoverished a once proud nation.

    Gosh…….if you all had any love for country, you would have admitted that we cannot get a thing right:

    QEH is an absolute mess, a doctor told me that at times they do not have even a sheet of paper to write notes and that some have to resort to running around the floors to find essentials………and we wonder why so many obituaries are in the Sunday Sun?

    The roads are a total mess…….potholes galore mashing up people’s cars

    The country is in a horrible state……..where is the dlp’s pride?

    Education is in a state of horror for those who work in it and at the last minute Fumble floating an equivalent to the ERT….right…..as if that has functioned so good…..

    Garbage is piled up all over Barbados as a result of the shortage of trucks

    This MOF has imposed 42 taxes on Barbadians since he became minister and what do we have to show………20 downgrades……….

    And you dare talk about Eddie Abed feasting on the fatted calf……..look yardfowl, the only people who got to partake in the fatted calf are people of your ilk. All one hears as one goes around the country is about corruption.

    This dlp has forever destroyed people’s faith in politicians because of your greed and incompetence.

    You……..tell Fumble call the damn election do!

  37. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    William

    You lost me. The unions should rely on itself and not expect bribes from employers. If they can’t afford a Mercedes then buy a Toyota. According to your reasoning when Chefette gives the union food that is also saving the union money but the staff get little or no representation.

    Sent from my iPad


  38. @Caswell

    Did you not hear Dennis Johnson last week share that one reason he stopped posting to BU is because he didn’t understand why some in the forum attacked Toni Moore because of the car etc etc etc? In other words the comments of a view supported by Carl Moore who frequents BU pages daily convinced him. Thought better of DJ although it might have something to do with pressure from work.

    Obviousy William has bought in to this line of reasoning to which he is entitled of course.


  39. Caswell Franklyn October 8, 2017 at 8:44 PM #
    When I was a medical student 40 years ago we had to go around with the Chief Public Health Officer inspecting restaurants, shops, Goddard Flight Kitchen etc
    He forbade us from taking any food or drink…….as he saw them as bribes to cause him to be less strict. He was a pleasant man of principle.
    Your note resonates with me and caused me to think of that rotation 40 years ago.

    I agree with you.
    I fear that there are not many like those leading Public Health inspectors then


  40. For comrade Skinner’s benefit Comrade Bobby Morris always cautioned his people to accept only a glass of water if theythey must when collective bargaining was ongoing. The moral of the story, do not allow oneself to be compromised.

  41. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    I haven’t listened to Brasstacks in three years.

  42. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    When I am negotiating I walk with my own water.


  43. David
    talking about Chefette
    I stumbled onto something last year and lost 10 lbs and abandoned what i had done
    I stumbled onto perhaps the same thing recently and loss 14 lbs without trying
    today i stumbled on the Biochemistry and will pursue it for a month or two before reporting to BU readers
    in the meantime our fat folk may have their fried chicken but leave out the fries bread and other carbs completely
    our fat folk can make any needed glucose from gluconeogenesis and run on ketone bodies in order to triple fat loss

  44. William Skinner Avatar

    @ Caswell & David

    Pardon me if I do not see a government extending a helping hand to the Trade Union as a bribe. This is nothing new because everybody in Barbados knows that Sir. Frank drove a jaguar for years and I have never met anyone, who said that any duty free breaks stopped him from developing the BWU.
    I have benefited tremendously from attending many free lectures given by BWU where the union used its own resources to enlighten the masses. On occasion after the lectures patrons were given some refreshment by the unions . Am I now a bribe taker? It is my understanding that religious organizations also benefit from tax breaks. Is that corruption too? In other words, the BWU has been an outstanding contributor to the national good, and we can really be grown up, and understand that a practice that has been in effect for over three decades has certainly not placed us on the precipice of economic destruction.
    Sir Roy Trotman was my teacher, my mentor and adviser for much of my early years. He drove a very ordinary car and on becoming Gen. Secretary of the BWU, he was given the top end motor car that comes with the office. Am I to assume that because it was duty free, he accepted a bribe ?
    Caswell et al are now clutching at straws. All of the corruption that is now prevalent has roots and Caswell cannot claim ignorance because he knows better than most on this blog that both the BLP and DLP have elements of corruption . That is why I maintain that the level of corruption now being exposed cannot have miraculously sprang up in 120 months !!!
    So to beat up the BWU for a tax break on a motta car is pure political nick picking.
    Gimme a break !!


  45. William Skinner

    You are the nitpicker

    So let us deal with substantive issues.

    Was it not the BWU, and others, which compromised workers rights, under your mentor Leroy Trotman, to form partnerships with business and government.

    We doubt Frank Walcott would have done that

    During that time the level of wage demands and industrials actions seemed to have been strictly constrained.

    There was no consideration for shares in enterprises in exchange for such massive concessions from workers to business, government.

    It was the same Leroy Trotman who preferred to be begging the local corporatists to let him become PM in the period of the early 1990’s when Sandiford was under pressure and workers could have had more material interests which were worthy of his protection.

    Forgive us, we can’t claim to have known Frank Walcott well, but we never got the impression that he was the kinds of man who would so easily be inveigled by largesse from people with whom he was to have serious negotiations with.

    We always saw him as too proud a man. Maybe we were wrong.

    In any event the appearance of corruption should be avoided at all costs by people purporting to be representing workers’ interests.

    You William Skinner, like to say one cannot run with the hare and hunt with the hound. Or something like that, is your old adage not applicable here.

    You should have told that to Trotman.

    In any event both you and the recipients of government largesse are dealing with small potatoes. A duty free car here and another one there merely serves to divide leadership from the rank and file. If you are unable to see that that smacks of corruption of the union ideal we must arrive at the conclusion that you have lost your ideological moorings. It represents nothing less than conquest by corrupting.

    We would prefer to see the union leadership/s catching the bus and the ordinary workers receiving whatever benefits are in the offing.

    And we could continue to excoriate you all day………………………

  46. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    William

    You are not naive but in this instance you let your hero worship of Sir Roy to cloud your judgment.

    Do you know that workers at Sandy Lane went underrepresented for years because certain officer at BWU were able to get a room for the night.

    Do you know that at the former Heywoods officers from BWU frequently entertained their lady friends to dinners and as a result workers could not get proper representation.

    Do you know anything about the relationship between McEnearney and Freekz Customz.

    Oh, by the way, could you tell me who gave the BWU its first Mercedes and then what happen to the workers’ grievances thereafter.

    Speak to what you know not about what you believe to be so because you have elevated mere mortals, and corrupt mortals at that, to sainthood.

    Sent from my iPad

  47. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    William

    I do not nitpick and I have no problem with anyone getting a tax break. My problem comes when the tax break is given clandestinely. Let me be clearer, the Minister broke the law when he gave both NUPW and BWU duty free waivers, in the manner that he did. Ask yourself, why do it illicitly when there was a legal mechanism to do it? The answer is simple, the unions and government did not want the workers to know that they were being deceived by the cozy relationship between the unions and Government.

    Sent from my iPad


  48. David October 8, 2017 at 4:52 PM

    You cant be that much of an idiot not to be aware that a LEC is earned from tertiary institutions in the Caribbean?

    David

    Now you have finally sprang into action !!

    I agree with you !!!

    So her buddy – Edmund Hinkson – admitted that she has no LEC !!

    And she claimed she was admitted to the local Bar in 1987.

    Yet the Legal Education Act of 1985 …..states inter alia ….that all persons admitted to practice in the Caribbean from 1st January, 1985 must have an LEC from one of the Caribbean Law Schools – even if they achieved their Law Degree from an accredited institution outside the region.

    So how come this woman who claimed – she studied & got her Law Degree in 1987 in England – did not follow the 1985 LEC Act – and go to one of the regional law schools ?????

    Something smells fishy….,…don’t you think 💭…..Davito ????

    Do continue checking & asking questions !!!!!

    I beginning to hear 👂 the sound 🔊 of the BLAST …….of war in me ears 👂 !!


  49. David

    Dig and unearth the mystery to MAM and this supposed Law Degree that she claims to possess !!!

    http://m.sknvibes.com/news/newsdetails.cfm/10892

    Following the news link above – an Attorney at Law with an LEC qualification – should know what is an Expert Witness !!

    Don’t you think ????

  50. Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger. Avatar
    Well Well & Consequences Observing Blogger.

    Many will sell they mamas to be seen driving a mercedes, the blight of the easily bribed negros.

    Dont talk about the ministers who love free rooms at top hotels for their clandestine affairs, they would sell their children…to be in a Crane or Sandy Lane room.

    Or all of them who love free meals and drinks even from the lowly fast food dumps that I wont eat at, they would sell out the whole population for that level of bribery,…..they have always been known to take bribes, just one step up from beads and trinkets…for selling out their own..

    The minds that still see nothing wrong with that level of corruption in 2017 are the minds who allowed and enabled it to flourish for 40 years…that is why the island has reached this level of depravity, it all started with public officials and their selfishness, greed and covetousness. . ..and those who see nothing wrong with the practice.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending