Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by Kevin Lashley
‘The credit union has 150,000+ members’’
‘’The credit union has 150,000+ members’’

“For the cause that lacks assistance, The wrong that needs resistance, For the future in the distance, And the good that I [BU] can do.”

I humbly submit that the cause that needs assistance right now is the impact of the middle-class and poor by the recent policies. More specifically I will speak towards the credit union movement.

I have been a humble servant for several years and the structure of the movement means it is a labour of sacrifice. Thus the structure of a credit union is that “profits” are returned to members compared to a bank where the profits are paid to a couple board members and because we are lacking an indigenous banking system not just BNB profits 40-60% are exported to shareholders. Herein lies my first point the credit in essence is a net saver of foreign exchange. Basically all profits of the credit union remain in the country. A policy such as taxing credit unions is therefore counter-productive and tantamount to shooting yourself in the foot as a government.

Secondly, the credit union provides credit to some people who may not receive credit from the Canadian/Trinidad banking loan system. Taxing credit unions will affect the structure of the credit union and less “ordinary” people will be able to get loans.

Thirdly, when the savings incentive was removed, the comment that was made is that credit unions are making a lot of money. The comment I believed lacked some insight. Firstly, all credit unions are not created equal. By this I mean this country has 3 major players and 30 odd medium to small players. Some with only $200,000 in cash. An incentive such as this stagnated growth for many credit unions in the area of savings – especially the small to medium sized ones. This occurred while the bank had “excess liquidity” yet their rates were not decreasing substantially, why? – because they still needed to export significant profits overseas. Therefore this should be reinstated if even at a tiered basis with the credit union’s size used as a reference.

Fourthly, the current administration criticized the last administration about selling BNB – partly justifiable. Why was it a justifiable criticism? The reason is while it (the sale) gained crucial foreign exchange, it weakened the local control with reference to the local market. To tax credit unions would weaken the same local market that this administration was saying would be weakened by the absence of an indigenous bank. We therefore will not be craftsmen of our fate but satellites of some. If we sell what we have and then weaken what remains, a take-off for this economy will be extremely difficult as others are growing.

Fifthly with reference to the Credit Union Bank – there was talk by the government about having a local bank. The easiest platform for a bank to be started from is the credit union movement in Barbados. The government even alluded to this in the manifesto. The government then has a better option in the future in terms of borrowing because it doesn’t have to borrow as much from a Canadian/Trinidadian bank and continue to keep some of the debt domestic.  Weakening your best platform is again shooting yourself in the foot.

Sixth, the deposit insurance that was promised has still not been delivered. So the credit union is being given a “belly searcher” and still not receiving the “good” that was promised.

Next, where does the “nuff money” that the credit union movement go. 1 – Teaching the ordinary man for free about financial services. 2. Dividends. 3 Making sure that if you die or you are disabled that insurance covers your loan. 4. Better rates for savings. I can also tell you where it won’t go – Canada/Trinidad.

Next when financial institutions are compared, job security is better in a credit union than at banks. Yet despite making significantly more profits than the credit unions, banks have been laying off more people. Why because of the inherent obligation to overseas shareholders. I asked a gentleman that works at a telecommunication company, why were the new entrants able to catch up so fast when they would have been here for way more years. He said the answer is simple – “the overseas shareholders have targets for profit” so there was no investment in the cables and hardware and people laid off for short term gains.
On a slightly unrelated note, why sell the BNTCL to a “wealthy local business man” when in a country where the stock market is haemorrhaging the opportunity could be used to give the Bajan middle class a place to invest by selling shares. The rate for gas in being increased and would give the middle-class a chance to benefit not just 1 “wealthy local business man”. This is why the gap between the poor and the wealthy is widened during economic turmoil. Sell shares in the airport as well to the ordinary man, not just the “Wealthy”.

In conclusion, you realize your opinion only counts if you are part of an eminent persons group and this is the scariest thing about Barbados is that your voice can’t be heard. My layman opinion is if you have a debt problem and you are taxing to gain revenue, you still have to ensure you have a platform to take off for your future if things ever improve and one of those platforms is the Credit Union Movement. At the end of the day all great economies survive base on the quality of their financial institutions. BNB is gone. What do you have left and what are you doing to encourage its growth? We talk about incentives for rum, what about incentives for our people? The credit union has 150,000+ members.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

57 responses to “Credit Unions the Forgotten Movement”


  1. @ Kevin
    Boss, one thing that really pisses Bushie off is a fellow walking quietly with a big stick …..and letting brass bowls piss all over him.
    …that is EXACTLY what the credit unions have been doing for the past ten years.

    How the hell do you have the VAST majority of voting Bajans as members; influence MILLIONS of dollars in deposits……and let jackasses determine how you operate…?…..only by being a brass bowl….

    Ever heard about lobby groups?
    Ever heard about targeted investments?
    Ever heard about focusing your members in directions that facilitate your (and therefore THEIR) interests?
    Ever heard about POLITICAL action groups?
    Ever heard about kicking butt…..?

    Steupsss….wunna wait and see if those political jackasses won’t put their sticky hands on wunna funds when they finally realize how deep the shit into which they are sinking really is….


  2. Was not Maxine a big up in the credit union movement?Are you suggesting then that at cabinet level her opinion is not counted?If this is the case the credit union movement need to review its association with those folk who only benefit when they are playing the blame game but when it comes to making an informed and intelligent contribution to the movement at the inside political level where giants walk and talk,nothing that’s favourably decisive to the modus operandi of the movement is sufficiently effective to literally bring home the bacon.The movement should have been able to rely on its big up member in the sanctum sanctorum..By their deeds,ye shall know them.

  3. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    When you lay down with dogs you will get bitten by fleas.

    The credit union movement has been doing everything possible, even illegal things, to facilitate the Government’s agenda. Why complain now when they use you and then discard you. A client does not have any obligation to a prostitute after he has paid for his five minutes.


  4. @Caswell

    It would be useful if you can to cite examples if you can.

  5. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David Thompson wanted someone to purchase CLICO Mortgage Finance Company to put some money in the pot so that some of his friends could loot CLICO. Who went forward and secured a loan from NIS to purchase that company for more than it was worth. They even paid $1.9 million as goodwill. I reported some of them to the Police for stealing credit-union funds. Thompson was able to call off the Police in exchange for them buying the albatross that is now around Public Workers’ neck.

    This is the same albatross that they are trying to unload on the movement to become an unnecessary co-op bank to provide an indigenous bank for the Government to loot.

    Hards ears you won’t hear…………..!

    >


  6. Own way ya gine feel


  7. “Thus the structure of a credit union is that “profits” are returned to members”
    I have been a credit union member for over 40 years and I have never seen these profits you speak about but I too HUMBLE SERVANT empathise with your concerns but as Bro Caswell aptly reminded you ‘hard ears you won’t hear’ AND I SAY da for lick yuh. Credit unionism has long been under threat first from the greedy management and then from the respective Governments aided and abetted by the same greedy management who have turned the large credit unions into banking empires themselves with the concomitant remuneration packages to boot at the expense of the benefits to which ordinary members were accustomed. The objective of credit unionism was to give the average member access to services which he/she would not have been able to access in the commercial banking system. I was appalled to discover that loans could be obtained at a cheaper rate in that very system credit unions were created to avoid. The much touted Xmas loans attract an unbelievable Shylock type interest rate from an institution which is supposed to facilitate and not deter. The Government might very well be operating like a mercenary but the credit union management is partly to blame for acting in some respects mercenary like themselves and drifting away for their own ends from the tenets of credit unionism.


  8. How does one blame credit union management when members – if they are so concerned – can call for change from the floor.


  9. Bro Caswell has spoken to this aberration time and time again but the same holds for effecting change in the political system and the Trade union movement.


  10. You can’t blame management if members have the opportunity to force change.


  11. “You can’t blame management if members have the opportunity to force change.”
    If your view is accepted then I suppose we can’t blame the Government either for swallowing their lies and keeping them in office. You know very well that several factors other than the right to change come into play In determining these outcomes.


  12. There are no other factors except an ignorant membership. We can’ t promote the credit union movement as a successful movement when it has long shifted from the philosophy of the founders. What is the status of the Courtney Blackman report on starting a credit union bank?


  13. There are no other factors except an ignorant membership
    ++++++++++
    David. You have just captured the genesis of Bushie’s Brass Bowl theory in a few brilliant words.

    @ balance
    You should be shame.
    You are correct….but you are guilty….
    …and a man of your influence too boot 🙂


  14. David

    As Malcolm X once said and I am paraphrasing now: “Freedom is not so easily given by the oppressor, it has to be fought for.” And we can sight many examples in history which testifies to this reality.The Abolitionist Movement fought on the behalf of black who were chained to the evil institution of slavery. Women in America fought for right to vote during the 1920’s with the help of the Women Suffrage Movement. Women in America fought for the right to attend university because prior to 1830 no university in America would admit women. So it is only through Civil – Protest and the Court – Pathway that we were able to demand a change in the existing state of affairs. In today’s world however, people use the social media engine to arouse the collective conscience of the public, which in term forces change.


  15. Dr.Martin Luther King Jr: ” when you impede the rich man’ s ability to make money, anything is negotiable.” I guess we can apply this manner of thinking to any business establishment but especially those with the highly skilled workers.


  16. The media plays an integral as well as a crucial role in our modern democracy today. ( the printed media did at one time but gone are those days) I was taught in my American Government class in college, that the media now constitutes the fourth arm of government, amongst the legislature, executive and judiciary. When President Obama wants to sway public opinion what does he do? I don’t think I need to answer that question because it is common knowledge. President Kennedy, and his advisors were amongst the first to exploit this new and ingenious way to appease to the public conscience.


  17. @Bush Tea & Caswell

    The credit union movement as well as the rise of the PSV sector has been credited fodr helping to enfranshise Black working class. What do we need to get back on track? Is taxing the movement a setback?


  18. @ David
    What do we need to get back on track?
    ++++++++++++++
    You must have hurt Caswell with that question David…..cause Bushie has been giving the answer now for YEARS….ever since calling Caswell’s name on this blog even before he KNEW about BU…

    Short answer …. BUP

    @ dompey
    domps…..it is a CLEAR sign that our asses in Barbados is in deep doo doo when you start making such sense as you have been doing of late….
    Shiite man, you are upsetting the apple cart…you may well force Bushie to resort to directing his abuse at ac again…
    Good points….
    …just one small point to note….
    NOBODY here of any import gives a s$&# about what the American government says, does or feels….or what was thought in your “American Government class” in college…. OK?
    If you got a point to make just make it….Steupsss


  19. “David | March 22, 2014 at 6:23 AM |
    There are no other factors except an ignorant membership. We can’ t promote the credit union movement as a successful movement when it has long shifted from the philosophy of the founders. What is the status of the Courtney Blackman report on starting a credit union bank?”

    There you have it- ignorant membership and as have been suggested by some-ignorant electorate as well.

    Don’t pay much attention to the mouthingof persons like Sir Courtney whose contribution to the country’s development vis a vis their exalted inflated status leaves much to be desired. The report is probably catching cobweb somewhere


  20. @ balance
    Following on to what you have posted….what do you think of the point made elsewhere by Well Well that the general problem is that the Real men and women have taken a back seat and allowed the wussies like Ross and Peter Wick to set the agendas?
    Caswell fought a good but loosing battle at your credit union…but he had little support……look who won….
    Do you think that if two others of your ilk had joined with Caswell (and in some cases covered his big mouth) that it would have made a big difference?
    With people of your capabilities, it only takes a few to overwhelm the lotta brass bowls….
    LOL
    ….YOU EVER see how a lawn does look before and AFTER a whacker gone through it….?

  21. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    The credit union movement if filled with people who are seeking to feather their own nest at the expense of the movement itself.

    Public Workers changed its by-laws so that a certain group can manipulate who gets elected. Once elected, you have to toe the line of nastiness or out you go. Take Dean St. Hill for example: he was a trusted lieutenant until he opposed a move that even he could not tolerate. The next meeting he was off the board for an infraction that they had been overlooking for some time.

    Some people at COB realized how successful Public Workers were at nastiness and they decided to fiddle with COB’s by-laws as well to achieve the same level of nastiness. They broke all rules, even attempting to change provisions of the Act, ably assisted by the incompetence of the Financial Services Commission. However, I filed a dispute, attempting to block the implementation of the by-law changes but came up against the FSC who was prepared to breach its own rules to facilitate those who were subverting the very essence of credit unions.

    They held a meeting, presided over by James Paul, that did not have a quorum and passed changes to the by-laws. The FSC was prepared to overlook that little detail. I was forced to file an appeal with the Financial Services Commission Appeals Tribunal and there is where the matter rests for now.

    >


  22. @Caswell

    Gezus!

    On Saturday, 22 March 2014, Barbados Underground wrote:

    >


  23. @ David
    You think it easy….?


  24. We will sit back and allow a shining light to fade without a fight? This is a movement which has benefited our. Black working class no? Caswell is this the Chairman of Committees of our parliament we are discussing?

    On Saturday, 22 March 2014, Barbados Underground wrote:

    >

  25. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    You better believe it.

    >


  26. C Franklyn’ post is emblematic of the nature of the problem. Those with regulatory authority are either unwilling or in collusion with wrong doers or so ignorant and unintelligent and so do not put a stop to wrong doing. It is unsettling to me that Barbadians are very naive and trusting of authority and/or afraid to stand up for truth and justice for fear of personal loss. Sometimes in a flash of irrational thought and frustration I think a real tsunami or a 9.0 earthquake may be the only solution.


  27. @Ping Pong

    For Caswell’s comment to have provoked such a violent response says it all. It goes back to the membership, like the parents who fail to attend PTA meetings, like the men who fail to support their children in the Scouts, Cadets etc. It is an abdication of individual responsibility which contaminates the whole; the consequence, a failed society eventually.

    On Saturday, 22 March 2014, Barbados Underground wrote:

    >


  28. @ Ping Pong
    Sometimes in a flash of irrational thought and frustration I think a real tsunami or a 9.0 earthquake may be the only solution.
    ++++++++++
    …don’t feel too bad.
    The BBEs have been forced into such a position on occasion too…
    Sometimes It may be the only way to deal with hardened brass bowls…


  29. Caswell………….is the Financial Services Commission monitoring the insurance companies on the island?? I understand that they got rid of the Supervisor of Insurance, who is doing due diligence on the companies, some are operating as ponzi schemes.

  30. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ Bush Tea | March 22, 2014 at 11:21 AM |
    “The BBEs have been forced into such a position on occasion too…
    Sometimes It may be the only way to deal with hardened brass bowls…”

    Is that the way you and your BBE friends feel about Bajans? Wishing such Sodom & Gomorrah type pestilence and destruction on your own brass bowl people?

    One wonders if you are also insulting Hants and Sarge in the Canadian Diaspora. Or is it just a misplaced myopic partisan perspective from you, Bushie?
    Yet you take great pleasure in vilifying the miller calling him all the names under heaven and as being jingoistic in his ‘un-patriotism when he wrote the following:

    Sith says on January 30, 2014 at 4:24 PM:
    “ Our major problem is that we have been living off of the back of a very overvalued currency. We are importing more than we can pay for without borrowing funds. We are no longer competitive in our main foreign exchange earner Tourism.”

    Miller the anunnaki replies on January 30, 2014 at 5:10 PM |
    “The message you are trying to convey is nothing new to the BU family although undeniably true and indeed pertinent as the zeitgeist of the ‘current’ Barbados.

    However, we are most surprised you are not being vilified as a prophet of doom and gloom marching backwards with a ‘red’ banner of negativity marked BLP by the likes of ac, Alvin C and the venomous Fractured and his entourage of cesspool mongers.

    Keep at it; keep pounding away at the Bajan wall of ignorance and stupidity of falsely protecting the naïve ‘sweet-livers’ from the realities of the modern economic world. A people unaware of the paradigm shift in economic realities which will soon hit them like a tsunami that would make Jamaica look like just a high wind.”


  31. Don’t mean to be offensive but this is what happens when barefoot thieves and hoes get put in a position to which they are not accustomed.A human deprived of water and subsequently shown water is tempted to drink like there is no tomorrow.So also with folk like James.

  32. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Well Well

    I have absolutely no confidence is the Financial Services Commission. It has been tainted with politics from inception. One of these days we are going to wake up and discover that there is a catastrophic failure of one of the institutions that is regulated by the FSC caused by its ineptness. Unfortunately, they amended the law to ensure the the FSC would not be held liable for its failure. It is remarkable that there is so much corruption in credit unions and the FSC is more concerned with how much food is served at board meetings.

    Boards meet after normal working and most members come straight from their regular jobs and go to midnight at times. Dinner is usually served. The silly commission is requiring reports on how much is eaten and overlooking how much is stolen.

    >


  33. @Caswell

    Warick Ward is a Central Banker isn’t he? He should be bringing best practices to the FSC.

    On Saturday, 22 March 2014, Barbados Underground wrote:

    >


  34. Cas……….no great surprise there, it looks like they don’t know, don’t care or are pretending not to know that the insurance companies are not regulated as they should be and some are breaking international laws.

    Someone called the FSC from New York recently to ask a question and they swore they did not know what the person was speaking about, and the question directly affects policy holders in Barbados.

  35. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    I don’t know Warrick Ward and only discovered that such a person exists when I received a letter dated January 24, 2014 signed by him informing me that the FSC had decided the matter I filed without hearing evidence, which is the basis of my appeal.

    >


  36. @miller etc.
    The message you are trying to convey is nothing new to the BU family although undeniably true and indeed pertinent as the zeitgeist of the ‘current’ Barbados
    ++++++++++++++
    A few people have been trying to inject a dose of reality into the proceedings here for some time as recently as Feb.10 I wrote the following in response to “Hants” after he wrote that Bajans think they are insulated from economic conditions in the rest of the world..

    “Talk to Kofi Annan he was the one who said Barbados is punching above its weight and many Bajans (yours truly included) felt proud that we were on the same playing field as the big boys. I was a fan of the sport where the rules were laid out by the Marquis of Queensbury and if I was thinking I would remember what happens to boxers who fight out of their weight class or who try to punch ‘above their weight”; they may have initial success but it catches up with you”.

    We who live in the diaspora have woken up and “smelled the coffee” but many Bajans are so myopic and intransigent that they can only see things in “B” or “D” and how it advances their narrow personal interests. We will continue to hope for the best but any prospect of meaningful change is remote before we all make our “Appointment in Samarra”


  37. Ping Pong

    The same can be said for ever human society in our world today; people put their unwavering trust in authority figures. ( you also did at one point in your life ) Now, the objects of our beliefs may vary tremendously but our propensity as well as our susceptibility to put our trust in the movers and shakers as well as the power brokers in society is quite commonplace. We were taught to think in these terms sir but through critical analysis/ thinking some are able to determine the difference.


  38. you go go Dompey…


  39. This is a brilliant contribution, one of the best I have read on BU. Should be compulsory reading for government ministers.


  40. @ Well, well
    There is no insurance supervision in Barbados worthy of the name. Don’t forget that the American Insurance Group, at the time the biggest insurance company in the world, established a subsidiary in Barbados for the explicit purpose of avoiding paying US tax.
    Then the insurance supervision, I think it was someone called Belgrave, came out and said that Barbados had the best supervision in the world.
    How about Carrington, the man who was in charge of the NIS when it could not get its books right, then went to the FSC on secondment, where he allegedly slammed the phone down on some people I know when they called up to speak to him.
    They would deliberately call back and claim they were cut off, and he would slammed the phone down again.
    This from as senior civil servant.


  41. It is unfortunate that this government which is comprised of two prominent credit unionists senators McClean and Sandiford-Garner overseas the movement which is being threatened and manipulated to such a degree.


  42. Hal……………..as i told you previously, it appears all types of international insurance laws are being violated in Barbados aided and abetted by those who should know better and are being paid by taxpayers to protect policyholders as well as claimants of these insurance companies that now believe they are a law unto themselves.

    There are some people i know who are not letting this slide.


  43. Hal…………..now we know why AIG, headquartered on Water Street downtown Manhattan had to have their asses bailed out by the US taxpayers, as two the 2 bit idiots calling themselves civil servants in Barbados, no one takes them seriously in the real world because they are just like the politicians/ministers, lacking in integrity.


  44. After reading all the fecal material, like a one-eyed jack, at that,that is being posted on BU, I am beginning to understand where all the flowers have gone. The credit union movement has lost its way, trying to become a banking St. Paul. It needs to get quickly to Straight Street.


  45. @david, you forget James Paul former President of COB, Stephen Lashley former President of Public Workers and Michael Carrington former board member of COB. Thus the Credit Union is not well represented by the so called grass root politicians.


  46. When Caswell speaks of punters owing obligations to tarts and Bush Tea speaks of getting off your ass and doing something I wonder whether we have entered a make-believe world of infantile role playing.


  47. Sergeant

    Barbadians are so myopic and intransigent in their outlook; that’s an understatement by any interpretation brother. How about infinitesimal and Lilliputian in their assessment of reality?

    Barbados have been on the front – burner for far too long and I could recalled with great reverence and some residue of arrogance, when we walked around proudly displaying this title.

    But now that we’re on the back – burner so to speak, we have some have founded it possible to cast blame on Tom, Dick, and Harry for what has obviously taken decades to materializes.

    And as I’ve said on numerous occasions before, we have never been in this position before; we were the luminous- crystal which attracted others to our shores in great numbers, but now that we have become that unkept diamond in the mud, that no one care to look at or search for. We have turned on each like the hyena on the African Savannah in search prey but only to be surrounded my his mortal enemy the lion.


  48. David, a house divided against itself cannot stand
    Abraham Lincoln

    So when are we going to have a national debate which deals fundamentally, with the diverse opinions with separates the two camps?


  49. @Caswell,
    Are these politicians manipulating the foreign banks the same way they do to the credit unions?

  50. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    They are not sophisticated to manipulate the foreign banks, you must realise that you are dealing with fools. They tend to destroy everything they put their hands on.

    >

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending