Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

โ† Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Submitted by Pachamama
Will Clyde Mascoll take the spoils?
Will Clyde Mascoll take the spoils?

The Nation Newspaper today carries the essential components of an internal party memorandum from Owen Seymour Arthur (OSA) to Kerrie Symmonds. A memo which is reported to have expressed a โ€˜lack of confidenceโ€™ in Mia Amor Mottley (MAM) as leader of the Barbados Labour Party (BLP), the officialย  opposition, in the Parliament of Barbados. This comes after last fortnightโ€™s revelations that the same OSA had called a significant policy initiative by MAM as a โ€˜gimmickโ€™.ย  Indeed, these are amongst the most sever blows that have ever been delivered to any political leader in the history of Barbadian politics. Maybe in the history of Christendom.

Arthur’s animus towards Mottley is now clearly too deep for this party to present any semblance of a united front against a weakened Democratic Labour Party (DLP), far less play a larger role in helping the country to navigate the presently deep and widening economic circumstances. These public disclosures are indeed the tip of the iceberg of the deeply negative personal relationship between Arthur and Mottley that have built up over several years. Arthur has also expressed disappointment about the circumstances which led to Mottleyโ€™s most recent elevation to the leadership of the BLP, as happened after the elections.

Both Arthur and Mottley seem, for this moment, to be working for Fruendal Stuart and the governing Democratic Labour Party (DLP). Bobby Morrisโ€™s work, as a chief political adviser to Stuart, is being made much less difficult these days. For there is nothing that is more effective that this government could do to avoid a robust debate about the economy, than this public war of words between the titans in the BLP. A self-inflicted wound that harms the possibilities of the BLP forming the next government, as some are predicting those new elections could be expected long ahead of scheduled. Remember, we have had general elections only about six months ago. We would be the last to suggest that there is any large-scaled conspiracy between the parties involved. However, we are persuaded that factions will benefit from these events. In none of these scenarios would MAM benefit from Arthurโ€™s escalating and public broadsides. Neither will the BLP, in the short run.

Our leanings on the experience of a renowned Caribbean political consultant have led us to the determination that OSA still feels obligated to Mascoll, who may now be free of his academic pursuits. Mascoll, as a leader of the then DLP opposition, had assisted Arthur in ways which some still consider not to have been in the interests of the then opposition DLP. For this he has paid a high price. This personal obligation deeply inspires OSA to kill two birds with a single stone. That Arthur senses that an election may very well be the only way out of the political-economic crisis which the country now faces. In those circumstances, he is ill-prepared to allow his nemesis, from within, to be allowed an open field between herself and Ilaro Court. That Arthur has determined that there are slim pickings for leadership within the BLP but will be content to have Kerrie Symmonds be a placeholder with the understanding that he (Arthur) will demit office and create the circumstances in Saint Peter for Mascoll to be then elected and thereafter assume his โ€˜rightlyโ€™ place at the leadership of the BLP with the help of a still numerical majority, on the opposition benches, which Arthur believes he still controls. Then a general election could be justly called, in Arthur’s mind at least. For Mia, the political undertakers are busily preparing the arrangements and we predict no set of circumstances in which she will be able to avoid their intentions or the vengeance of the god of the BLP, Owen Seymour Arthur.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

128 responses to “Owen Arthur ‘Hits’ Mia Mottley, Again – Clyde Mascoll, Clear Heir Apparent, With Kerrie Symmonds as Placeholder”


  1. To much speculation passion as analysis. This is a simple matter, those two don’t like each other. Arthur thinks that Mia is unfit to lead this country and has said so. He has never retracted that opinion.

    Mind you, fights among people in opposition is nothing new. In mature democracies there are even fights for leadership of ruling parties. Have you ever heard of Julia Gillard and Kevin Rudd of Australia?


  2. Pachamama

    GO AND SLEEP DO !


  3. WHO IS THIS MaN CALLED OWEN ARTHUR……..Will the REAL OWEN SEYMOUR ARTHUR PLEASE STAND UP…….


  4. We continue with this fixation on the personalities. It says a lot about us.


  5. @ Caswell

    We beg to disagree. This matter is not at all simple. To us it represents the broader cultural dilemma facing the country. It involves issues of class and classism. Issues around the treatment of women. Sexual orientation. The very nature of leadership, itself. Surely, no one man in a party is generally seen as having the power to remove that party’s leader, not just once but twice. Given these facts and more we again beg to disagree.

  6. pieceuhderockyeahright Avatar
    pieceuhderockyeahright

    @ Caswell

    Or “Hilary Clinton and President Barach Obama?”

    @ Pachamama

    You said and i quote “Arthurโ€™s animus towards Mottley is now clearly too deep for this party to present any semblance of a united front against a weakened Democratic Labour Party (DLP)”

    Oh revered Incan goddess, do you really think that the masses of Bulbados, will vote other than the BLP, when the election bell comes?

    Do you think that the theosophical discourse that sometimes resounds within these cyberspace walls will for one moment even dent the inexorable removal of the DLP?

    I too thought that my stream of ole fogey piss would flood the shores of St Lucia when i recently releived myself at the sea during the church’s picnic on the beach, wrong answer!!

    The writing is on the wall, it is only which one will be at the helm when the bell is rung


  7. I am with you Cawell. Owen will tell you that he made Mia what she is today in the BLP and it is his responsibility to save Barbados from her.


  8. David | January 13, 2014 at 8:11 PM | We continue with this fixation on the personalities. It says a lot about us.

    is there another way to get around it,,the player is the main focus cause he (OSA) has opened a door which most thought he had slammed shut…….


  9. @ac

    Here is the point you keep missing, OSA CANNOT touch MAM unless he has the support of his BLP parliamentary colleagues.

    On 14 January 2014 00:22, Barbados Underground


  10. @ David
    You are right. But the next question becomes, to what ends!


  11. @Pacha

    Shouldn’t the question be whether Mottley’s leadership qualities insulate her from the challenges of her office?


  12. @ Caswell Franklyn,

    Caswell, you are known for your take on many topics. How is it that you believe that a rift in the main opposition, at a time when NATIONAL unity is paramount, is no big thing? Pachamama, is correct to analyse these matters because such analysis, is missing in the mainstream media. I agree that personalities often clash but in the scheme of things , this is a major development on our political scene.
    I am a bit surprise that you are so dismissive of this current situation, which may have far reaching consequences for the Opposition and by extension the political stability within our island state. You should realise that these are not normal times.
    Since many of us have concluded, myself included, that the Stuart administration has made a mess of things; we will look to the Opposition as an alternative administration. This is even more so because of the razor thing election result. If there is tremendous infighting within the Opposition, there would be a feeling of despair within the society and complete hopelessness would set in. I , as a unrelenting nationalist, am desirous of seeing this Mottley/Arthur rift settled in the interest of our island state.


  13. @ David
    No leader of any party in Barbados and especially in the circumstances in which the BLP now finds itself could have any leader who is stronger or perceived to have better leadership qualities than a former PM for 14 years.


  14. Pachamama

    You sound pretty but you are dealing in speculation. Arthur somehow believes that the person who leads the BLP in government is a gift from him. Over his years as PM, he identified several successors and when the were found wanting in his eyes, he took them down and they stayed down because he was PM and they feared the power of his office.

    Fortunately for Mia, he is no longer PM and she does not have to respond to Arthur’s wishes. When Mia first became Opposition Leader, she went about in a systematic way putting people in place as candidates who were loyal to her. That more so than anything else caused the BLP to lose the last general elections. Her candidates were just not good enough. They were not even tried and tested at the branch level.

    Arthur’s mistake was that he left Mia’s candidates in place when he took over as Opposition Leader to give the impression that all was well in the BLP. As a result, he tied his own hands by carrying a Mot(t)ley crew into the elections and lost to a weakened DLP.


  15. Let’s think logical, OSA has been keeping quite since general elections, he was just working in a advisory state . The question now is, why did MAM not accept his position of not sitting on the committee? In his consience, he saw no need, as so do I, for such a group at this stage, the horse has bolted. It appears the DLP government is doing things backwards, I’ve been saying for a while, the government needed to do a study before talking about layoffs, but the MOF had to make his statement before the IMF team left that day. One must now wonder how the IMF will accept the delay. Also it seems as though the P.M is gradually showing up the MOF, because the MOF when he talked about the layoffs, said it was discussed with the cabinet. The “user fee” at the QEH, he also said was a cabinet decision, yet the MOHG is now saying the government will not do such. The question is Is it the DLP government and the MOF two seperate entities?


  16. Missing what point.. DAVID..i am yet to hear any negative response from the BLP parliamentarians or even suggestions that they are not in favour of what OSA had done or said about their leader. either they are to afraid to say or they have given OSA there full backing which can also be an interpreted as to how they feel about MIA


  17. William Skinner

    I did not see your comment before my last.

    You must realise that the Barbadian electorate is very fickle and suffer from some sort of short term memory loss. You should remember that Sandiford made a colossal mess of this country during the years of his premiership but particularly coming on to the end, even his members turned against him. He dissolved Parliament in June and called elections in September. By that time people seemed to have forgotten the suffering inflicted upon them and the DLP still managed a face-saving loss in the 1994 elections.

    Unless elections are called when this matter is still a hot topic, it would not have any relevance in an election. The BLP has a way of coming together for elections. The only time it did not work was in the last elections because of Mia’s spoilt child behaviour. Some influential persons in the party has still not forgiven her for her conduct in the last elections which they attribute as the reason for their defeat at the polls. They are saying if she had only assisted Arthur Holder, Rev. Atherley or Godding-Edghill things would have been different.


  18. @ac

    Maybe you missed it but it was in the news that Kerri Symmonds, leader of BLP business, stated that MAM retains their support.

    On 14 January 2014 00:54, Barbados Underground


  19. @ David
    But David, what Kerrie is saying is the expected official party line. The point made by ac has to do with the deafening silence of Mottley’s parliamentary colleagues. And she is right, on the ONE.


  20. We think it is fair to surmise that her parliamentary colleagues have smelt the coffee brewing


  21. @Pacha

    In the Eager 11 episode how did the other DLP MPs respond and did it matter?


  22. What Barbados really need right now is a caretaker government. while OSA will be a good person to sit on any committee, one must remember that until recently, the MOF said he will not sit with OSA at anytime, not even in a dark room. When such careless statements can be made by such an important person in the governmet, do you really expect OSA in the evening of his days to come tail between his legs to sit with the MOF to advise him? Get real? The DLP government need to come off their high horse and set the stage to put Barbados first. Both parties have made their mistakes yet the DLP is trying even after six years to blame the BLP for everything. I see this government is not forward thinking, they saw problems in the horizon even before they took office in 2008, yet they fool the electorate with “pie-in- the- shy” promises that they could not keep. Towards the end of 2012, they had a 2/3 majority and could have adjusted the constitution to allow for the salary reduction, instaed they spreaded the humor that the BLP were going to layoff thousands of civil servants WHO IS DOING IT NOW.


  23. FJS may turn out to be the luckiest man in Bajan politics, yet. The only other lucky man like Stuart is possibly Goodluck Jonathan from Nigeria. For every where he goes someone dies or something and he gets to take over the top job.


  24. David
    The eager 11 affair was markedly different. There were no open and persistent assaults by the elephants in the DLP. Certainly, there was no recent history of a coup involving the same forces. And so on. Of course there would have been some similarities as well. The differences however out way the similarities in our mind

  25. Smooth Chocolate Avatar
    Smooth Chocolate

    When the fox could not get the grapes, he said they were sour, that is Owen Arthur in a nutshell, he is old now, unlike Mia, his time has pass, he needs to fully appreciate that he led the country for 14 years, was pompous enough to call elections months before due time because he believed he would have gotten back in. alast alack that was not to be and the rest is history. however, he is just like many leaders who refused to acknowledge that someone could do a better job, if given the opportunity, he sees Mia as a threat and she is because she is highly intelligent for one so young. he needs to take his lashes, lick his sores and hand the baton gracefully to the lady.


  26. i don’t believe that there was ‘A running ” away from the Issue in the eager 11,as a matter of fact those involved and those who were not were vocally open about what happen, and most did re affirm there support for the PM… furthermore ..and no one person involved in the eager 11 had as much influenced.and political say like OSA being a past PM well renowned . further more the eager 11 debacle pales in comparison to another decapitating and humiliation of MIA who had already felt the wrath of the unstoppable OSA.


  27. I am not a fan of OSA, but I just want to ask this question ” If someone had ask you to do something and refused, should that person still pronounce that you were doing it? Even if you went along , could you do justice to the office? MAM was wrong to force OSA’s hand. The whole matter is all very childish and this country cannot support such behavior right now.

  28. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Pachamama

    You certainly do not understand the dynamics at play. What nonsense about recent history of a coup are you talking about? If the same players or indeed any players attempt a coup on the Government side the Prime Minister have the big stick of dissolving parliament and calling elections to bring them in line. The Opposition Leader has neither carrot nor stick.

    >


  29. We speak of a coup within the BLP, as carried out by OSA against MAM just before the last election.


  30. @Pacha

    Are you sure the coup was carried out by OSA? Check you source again.


  31. I’ve said it before and I will say it again, I’ve lost confidence in both the BLP and the DLP, they are both playing before the voters but they are all for themselves. For the first time EVEN and against the advice of my parents, who told me to vote because in their earlier time neither could do, I WILL NEVER VOTE AGAIN IN THIS COUNTRY IF IT IS ONLY THE BLP OR DLP TO VOTE FOR


  32. The question is WHY has Owen chosen to attack Mia’s leadership at this crucial time in Barbados?

    In a democracy where there are only 2 viable political parties a strong opposition with strong leadership is critical to good governance.

    It is possible that Owen considers an “Eminent persons group” to be an elitist construct of a member of the “political class” of which Mia is a member.

    Mia’s address this evening was not very inspiring so maybe Owen’s judgment may have merit.


  33. To tell the truth I like like Mia real bad, but I like Clydie better, and I love Owen best of all.

    He’s my man.

    Smooch, smooch.

    Kerrie is ok.


  34. Our dilemma in all this is that the people are kept in the dark and there is no easy outlet like the talk shows seen on US TV that help in bringing issues to the fore and responses from wannabee representatives.We recognise that both political parties when in power assume full control of the one TV station in Barbados.That has to stop.
    MAM’s is a secure seat.Even if she is permitted to lead the BLP into an election and the party wins a majority,it does not mean that she will be the choice of the parliamentary group for the PM position.
    It is better that the issue of leadership be settled prior to the next election.
    There are peculiarities which would be non negotiable and that was made clear in a poll and by OSA and he will not go back on that issue.
    Did not Cammie have a full wardrobe of suits and his acceptance speech all prepared when he thought the GGship was within his reach.And what happened to put paid to that matter.These folk are still in our midst and still influential in party politics.The ship of state will continue to reflect the opinion of a broad mass of people,not one constituent assembly.The captains of industry have too much at stake to allow frivilous and reckless people to assume control of the privy purse.Not in bubaydus.It will not happen so OSA can afford to come public with his assessments and he will have a significant hearing and a serious following.For sure the DLP is finished.Its only a matter of time.The captains of industry have met and have spoken.

  35. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @Simple Simon | January 13, 2014 at 10:13 PM |

    If you want to see 80% voter abstinence in the next elections let them remove MAM from the leader of the BLP. And you know which party’s supporters would make up the bulk of that figure.
    OSA or his sidekicks cannot motivate the young people to vote.


  36. What did Mia see as the difference between the long standing social partnership, and her proposed group of eminent people. And what were these eminent pepole going to do that the social partnership cannot do?

    If Arthur did not wish to participate she had no business calling the man name in public.

    However she has been woman enough to apologise.

    But I doubt very much that Arthur has forgiven her.

  37. Fair and Balanced Avatar
    Fair and Balanced

    Would you believe that Ms. Mottley got the gall to query leaking of the letter. She is the same woman who will get in Parliament quoting from Cabinet Papers. Ask her which is more serious. Such righteous indignation is misplaced. When she was getting info from several Ministries she did not complain. She needs to counter Owenโ€™s charge that the process by she became Leader of the Opp was not above Board. That comes after she charged by her peers of taking the Partyโ€™s money and spending it unwisely


  38. Why canโ€™t you people recognize that the next election is constitutionally due in 2018?
    Unless something like a death or sickness of a sitting government MP or a crossing of the floor from the government side will there be an election.

    Owen Arthur would be 70+ by that time if he is still alive. So hold your horses Owen because as you know Prime Minister Stuart went right down to the wire with the last election date giving you and Peter Wickham stress. Without any of those scenarios above I think he going to the wire again.

    Suppose Mia cross the floor and the DLP elect her Prime Minister would that not cause the death of Owen. Maybe she could try that.


  39. Poor OSA. He is making such a fool of himself. Dementia like it setting in spurred on perhaps by the diabetes. His hatred for MAM is so pervasive that he cares not for the BLP or the country. Its Owen’s way or the highway. Silly little old man.
    A birdie told me he is calling up BLP Parliamentarians and threatening to sit as an independent in Parliament. I wonder if this is going to take effect from tomorrow.
    The BLP needs to rid itself of his destabilizing influence once and for all if the party is to regain the reins of government.

  40. Fair and Balanced Avatar
    Fair and Balanced

    Folks do not forget the hatred Mottley generated when she set about to canvass against a number of members of her own party in the lead up to the last General Elections.

    She targeted Arthur himself, she targeted Payne with financial and vehicles to the DLP Candidate she targeted Toppin, she targeted Marshall, she and Forde targeted Hinkson by sending her PARTY to canvass BLP homes with the DLP Candidate she targeted Symmonds by gaining the support of the woman whom Symmonds wounded to have her distributed copies of the writing she had filed against Symmonds when she was abused by him.

    So let’s not get confused there are enough BLP members of the Lower House who have good reason to support Arthur and her removal from the position of Leader of the Opposition, just ask Payne, Marshall,Hinkson,Arthur or Symmonds they saw and felt her at work in the last election.

  41. Fair and Balanced Avatar
    Fair and Balanced

    Sending her PA that should read

  42. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ *smh | January 13, 2014 at 10:42 PM |
    โ€œA birdie told me he is calling up BLP Parliamentarians and threatening to sit as an independent in Parliament. I wonder if this is going to take effect from tomorrow.โ€

    You would have thought he had learned his lesson from the dressing down and humiliation he got from Fumble in the last general elections.
    He is smelling the DLP loosing electoral blood and believes he can quench his burning taste for power and revenge to get back at Fumble.

    Maybe what Clone hypothesized about is just what’s going through the mind of OSA.
    โ€œUnless something like a death or sickness of a sitting government MP or a crossing of the floor from the government side will there be an election.โ€

  43. PLANTATION DEEDS FROM 1926 TO 2014 , MASSIVE FRAUD ,LAND TAX BILLS AND NO DEEDS OF BARBADOS, BLPand DLP=Massive Fruad Avatar
    PLANTATION DEEDS FROM 1926 TO 2014 , MASSIVE FRAUD ,LAND TAX BILLS AND NO DEEDS OF BARBADOS, BLPand DLP=Massive Fruad

    Let them fight and kill each other , We dont need them ,non of them

  44. Fair and Balanced Avatar
    Fair and Balanced

    Arthur will have no need to sit as an Independent he will return to his position of prominence as Leader of the Opposition.
    That is his rightful place Leader of the Opposition.


  45. The Winter Olympics are around the corner and Bajans are focused on other matters but OSA the cagey old fox has always had the ability to seize the moment so in homage to Sochi he planted a Gillooly on Mia.

    Opposition politics in Bim is a tough row to hoe especially for those who have been fed on the Royal Jelly , the DLP started the trend of the circular firing squad which has been appropriated by the BLP.

    Let the games continue.

  46. George C. Brathwaite Avatar
    George C. Brathwaite

    In my lifetime, I have put my feet in my mouth on several occasions. I pride myself on being loyal and a team player.
    That said, I am willing to rock the boat at this time out of respect for you but loyalty to the BLP.
    Indeed, I reserve the greatest respect for you Mr. Own S. Arthur. Arguably, you were one of the best, if not the best prime ministers Barbados has ever had.
    Nonetheless, Mr. Arthur you have erred once again. You have risked the BLP as an institution and caused confusion regarding its image.
    Your UWI performance coupled with the letter appearing in the newspaper and recent mouthing, compound a difficult situation of opposition politics in Barbados.
    In contradistinction to what you have done or achieved in 14 years wherein Barbados had achieved real progress, by setting up Mia Mottley as a target, you are placing all BEES at peril.
    It is painful to understand your rationale given the battles facing labour in Barbados and the challenges confronting Barbadians. It is not a politics of inclusion that is being practiced in 2014; but I would contend that the politics of exclusion and divisiveness have been rife under the DLP and this episode needs no assistance from you or your sharp tongue that eventually becomes repentant.
    Regardless of the faults or perception that there are faults carried by the one that you promoted as your deputy and publicly endorsed as leader on more than one occasion, it is baffling and almost seen as being malicious regarding Mia Mottley. Please remember that none of you are saints or clothed in purity.
    Mr. Arthur, with all due respect, it may be actually better that you take your exit at this time than to bring the BLP into disrepute or into any misguided conflict. Please resist any temptation to in any other way cause the thousands of persons that will often speak glowingly of you to lose faith in your capacity to be led by another.
    Again, regardless of if that individual is capable of reaching the high standards that you set, remember that you made some decisions that were unpopular but as leader your decisions were often carried and always without public drama.
    MWe can all agree that under the DLP, life has not been easy for Bees whose faces are known by DEMS.
    Mr. Arthur, have you considered the weight and burdens that you are likely to place on those persons from the rank and file of the BLP that supported you?
    Do you envisage the ridicule that will come to those that carried you when your weaknesses threatened your strengths? Can you remember those who fought side by side with you in the trenches only to emerge on the losing end of party politics both in 2008 and 2013?
    I may lose friends and supporters because of this input, but do you believe that the BLP as an institution and its followers ought to pay a price for your allegations which to date lack necessary evidence?
    I really like you Owen Arthur, but, Mia Mottley is the current political leader, chairperson of the BLP, and Leader of the Opposition, and she deserves the respect and opportunities that you once (and recently) enjoyed.
    Do you really think that you would have enhanced the ways that people may perceive you in and outside of Barbados? I think not.
    I shall take my heat from you and those that support your position. What I shall not do is to sit silent while you construct damage and danger at a time when Barbados is seeking positive alternatives and persons lifting themselves above selfishness.
    I shall continue to speak affirmatively on the progress that you created for Barbados and Barbadians, but I cannot and will not accept that you can disrespect my current political leader and political party in the way that you have done. I would rather plead and urge you to leave the contemporary political scene at this time.
    Owen, the shenanigans must stop now. Barbados and the BLP is bigger than you, Mia, or any of the individuals. The BLP will be as strong as its weakest link.
    Your underclothes are showing and sunset is fast approaching on your political life.
    I am sure that your brother, sister, or group of supporters will pass on my sentiments. I know that you may never speak to me again. However, it still stand that I like and respect you.
    I must call a spade a spade and I would rather remember you for your good works than for your sorry lamentations which now seem at least twice too often.
    I wish you well, and I do wish you a long and healthy life in retirement.


  47. It is interesting to see all the BLP yardfowls including Caswell trying to downplay this obvious fracture in the BLP.
    All of a sudden Owen Arthur is the worst man in the world who needs to go home, etc- all this from the same BLP supporters who a few months ago were saying that he was ready to lead Barbados for many years to come.
    Arthur has no confidence in Mottley and he knows why.

    Mottley is no victim – the woman tried to defeat some of her own party members last election because she knew it was an easier road to the leadership of the party if Owen lost. It is called eliminating your competition- that is why she went after Mascoll in 2008 and helped her buddy Chris.


  48. George Payne has been around politics for decades. Obviously when Payne charged that Mottley was helping his opponent he had clear evidence of this. Mottley tried to sabotage some of her fellow BLP candidates.

    Of course her paid political consultants drafted a response which she read on radio to Arthur’s letter but based on experience of working with her over the last 20 years , Arthur has reached the conclusion that she cannot be trusted especially if given power.


  49. @ George Brathwaite
    You will obviously have to deal with the other George ,GEORGE GRIFFITH who has publicly asked Mr Arthur to stay on and lead the party. It is clear that that George was preparing the way for another take-back-over by Arthur so you really have a problem .

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading