โ† Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

The following is a press release from The Concerned Creative Citizens Group (CCCG)

John Roett, veteran musician leads the CCCG
John Roett, veteran musician leads the CCCG

The Concerned Creative Citizens Group (CCCG) wishes to inform the public that despite a very one sided debate, the current Cultural Industries Development Bill (CIDB) is of great concern to many of the creatives of this country. Our Group comprising of 1251 members, along with many experts (both here on island and overseas) plus lauded artists in Barbados feel that the Bill in its current form is not worthy of passage in our Parliament.

Despite repeated attempts to present ways in which to make the Bill better, numerous requests to the Ministry and Minister of Culture, Public Objections to this Bill in many of the Public Town Halls and Forums, we continue to be rebuffed and ignored. We have submitted documents to the Attorney General listing our objections with the bill, carefully and meticulously pointing out the ways in which it will fail to develop the Cultural Industries in any manner whatsoever, and in an effort to maintain absolute transparency, these documents have also been discussed with the Leader of the Opposition and the Shadow Minister of Culture

Our concerns are many and we list just some of them: lack of transparency, archaic guidelines for structuring of a board, the manner of designation of โ€˜Cultural Practitioner โ€˜status, the allowance for Government entities to apply for funding, excessive powers vested in the Minister, and that would be ANY Minister who may hold the position in the future.

There is also a glaring lack of synergy between other Ministries and Sectors of this Nation within the Bill, which only further highlights how ineffective this Bill will be, and how little serious thought appears to have been applied to its structure. In todayโ€™s world, we at the very least expect the Ministries of Education, Tourism, Foreign Affairs & Trade to be involved, as it should be blatantly obvious how essential such inclusion would be for the continued development, spread & support of the industry in order to reach and sustain an international standard.

We reject any notion that this Bill should be passed for reasons such as โ€œitโ€™s a startโ€ or that โ€œit can be amended laterโ€. This Bill is too important to be passed or rushed for any reason. Our objections did not start recently. This is a battle that we and many like us have been fighting for the last 15 + months. We invite the public and the press to view all of our objections and files sent onto Government at our Facebook Group Page. There is a โ€˜fileโ€™s section at top of the group page which has all suggested amendment papers worked on these last 15 months.

We urge you to make your voices heard, and to join us in our objection to the passage of this Bill.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


  1. Just ignore the trolls who are obviously achieving their objective. These are political hacks who try to disrupt conversations. Just ignore.I f BU were to be diverted by those who bray what would happen you think? Stay focused by exercising self discipline.


  2. Ezra
    If we have created an environment where only the politician and especially if he or she is a doctor or lawyer seem to have any sense, what do you expect in a bill outside the usual approach that the MINISTER must be front and center of all things.

    What they do not know is that that same environment shall cause everything to burst at the seams with social chaos.


  3. Lemuel…………we have reached that environment, the ministers (lawyers/doctors) continue to display to us on a daily basis their lack of sense or any intellectual capabilities beyond the petty practices that have succeeding in ruining the island. Remember, between both parties there are approximately 22 lawyers. All these lawyer/doctors and the island continues to be sold to the highest bidder, state owned entities/shares sold to outside entities, private businesses owned by foreign entities, tells us something is lacking in their intellectual abilities.


  4. too much talk -talk -talk -talk -Dennis Johnson and Carol Roberts getting paid to talk instead of playing Crop Over Music. Crop Over /Fireworks now about them and talk -not music and the artistes. Over 100 songs -you cant hear one third
    talk is at a premium
    talk cheap – (Bob Marley -said so : he repeated it)

    conclusion is that too much ignorance abounds
    so what you hoo-you hoo -you- hoo expect


  5. Dr. Honourebel

    continue to rebel
    women will always back women in public
    no matter how wrong
    women are something else
    careful how you trod with them
    they get personal and emotional
    just be careful
    De dawtas take a little longer to site up……….
    Gregory Isaacs
    where are the rebels ?
    homosexing and jonesing ?


  6. Even as we speak now the BADMC is taking a stand against the foreign importation of the chicken meats which government has moved from 20% to 184% as reported. I therefore cant understand why cultural practitioners can’t take a stand and lobby for support from our government. It is the same thing. How long have we been calling for more local music or 100% bajan station? As someone said though, through our political process James Paul is the only one who clearly represents an association in parliament. We continue to let the doctors, lawyers and economists convince us that they are the only ones that can run this country. We continue to operate on the premise of tribalism with political footballs in the broadcast sector so the independents who can only get recognition by public engagement will never be heard.


  7. Two U.S. Fast Food Outlets cry foul re their 180-odd% tax the government is putting on their unhealthy American food imports and immediately The Minister calls a meeting with Ministry of Agriculture and those outlets who feel wrongly ‘punished’. If these outlets close down perhaps at the most 100 people might be out of jobs, if that.

    Now the CCCG (on behalf of nearly 2000+ unfaired Barbadian creatives) who have studied and worked on the soon-to-be-passed Cultural Industries Bill, without remuneration for their time, for some 15 months pleading to be heard by The Minister of Culture, pleading to work for nothing with government for the good of the country, with all that pleading simply gone on deaf ears.

    All the creatives of this country want is a fair Bill for ALL creatives. Without a fair Bill for ALL nearly every creative on this island will not only continue to but will suffer more hardships than ever before, and further there will be more of a creative drain than in the past. Think about what that means? Perhaps God forbid…imagine a flawed Crop Over. Imagine a flawed festival of any kind. Imagine Music done. Imagine Art finish. Imagine Architecture done stop. Imagine Design out the window. Imagine Chefs gone to greener pastures. Imagine? Nope cannot imagine. Ya know why? ‘Cause imagination also gone through the eddoes. And yes! Even those who the Bill seems to favour better read between the lines!

    There is no doubt that both internationally and at home, the Bill is seen as horribly flawed. It just needs to be reviewed…I personally see no problem with that. The CCCG sees no real problem with that. Just some simple adjustments that are easy and would have ALL the creatives of the island happy as pappy. So what’s the beef? Cannot comprehend. But then perhaps I am just not intelligent enough to see how difficult this exercise would be.


  8. By the way please let it go on record that I am right there with Mr. James Paul and Ms. Bobbi McKay on their stand re the Fast Food Outlets. Wunnah want to come to Barbados…check Barbados First!!! Organize your needs here. It can be done and the crap about it cannot stand up to the quality of the US is well…just that crap! What quality? Pray tell!!!

    So please…do us a favour…organize to buy Bajan. I know this can be done…so peoples who own these franchises, if ya need help I am prepared to be a consultant on how to…for a fee of course! We are not poppets here on the island…at least I hope not!!


  9. Yagga…………..the dawtas may take a little longer to site up…………but the sons never site up at all.


  10. That’s the problem with small island ministers, they are willing to entertain international companies that are pushing fast food garbage riddled with cancer causing carcinogens on the people of the island, to save a couple jobs, eventually they will get 5000 cancer cases at the QEH burdening the health care system, while they continue to pose and posture. Which part of that scenario do they not see and understand?

    The minister of culture should really get a better pair of glasses, him and the parliamentarians should take a really long hard look at the creatives on the island and see that they are all BLACK, and treat them with respect.


  11. men homosexing and jonesing

    add pipe smoking, alcohalling and

    rebels needed
    conflict
    resolution
    growth


  12. I would say that people of all colours should be treated with respect when respect is due. Respect is due to ALL creatives of ALL colours. Creatives are the ones that just about produce all the goodness that life can bring…music, theatre, film, video, art, cuisine, sculpture, pottery, design, clothing and the list goes on and on. To disrespect creatives is to disrespect life.


  13. Rosemary………………the leaders in Barbados have an extremely bad reputation for showing very scant respect for their own people, it is something that is continually mentioned in international circles. Charity must be seen as beginning at home.


  14. yes Dennis
    less talk
    more music
    talk b4 crop over ; talk afta crop over

    but crop over start = music
    crop over start = talk stop

    stop favouring some songs over the others
    just play the music-
    headboard should play Carol
    Carol should play headboard

    wesley /brainwashed
    what competition what ?
    Bdos too small
    work together
    target the world

    ‘Yagga’ Rowe – euphemism for change


  15. why Carol Roberts and Dennis Johnson playing material by Red P.B
    LOOK
    new music
    150 songs

    Fire
    Fireworks –


  16. The whole framework of creativity needs to be looked at seriously. Throughout the Caribbean. I find it disgraceful what this St. Lucian living in Barbados had to go through as an artist…bad enough his treatment in St. Lucia but on returning home? And we here want to believe that all is well and will continue to be well (even better according to the Ministry of Culture once the Bill is passed) in the entrepreneurial spirit of creativity…hmmmm. Well blow me down.

    The Free Movement of Art and Artists
    May 15, 2013 by Katherine in Blog, Uncategorized | Permalink

    I am an artist, a writer and a project manager working in the manufacturing sector, living in the Caribbean; a community of small Independent island nations, linked by history, geography, similar cultures and a mingling of families and heritage unlike any other region in the world.

    The Caribbean Islands have come together in Trade blocks over the years, recognizing the need for economic strength amidst the new realities of the WTO trade reality. These Associations, the OECS, CARICOM and CARIFORUM being current versions are supposed to link our individual islands, into a cohesive group.

    As part of the development of the CARICOM region, each member nation has agreed that we need to put measures in place to allow for the free movement of people, goods, services and move toward a single currency for the region. Implementation has been slow, and at times at a dead standstill, depending on the political will of the member states, but there is still, for the most part, a recognized need, even if the methodology and timing is not agreed to.

    I am a CARICOM Skilled National. I am a St Lucian national, but I reside and work in Barbados. I write, perform, and paint here. But I am still St Lucian, and when a call went out for St Lucian artists living abroad to submit works of art for consideration to exhibit at the 2013 St Lucia Jazz and Art Festival this year, I was quick to submit digital photos of my best recent works, done here in Barbados. Very few people in St Lucia have ever seen my artwork, and the St Lucia Jazz Festival is an International event, offering exposure for my work, much greater than any individual exhibit that I could hold myself for visitors and local art buyers and I was thrilled when the Director of the Inner Gallery indicated that she would like to show three of my works during the festival.

    I never considered the venue to be one where I would be looking at a likely outright sale, but to have my works seen by a broader audience, and my first mixed media piece was well received at Pigeon Island, the main stage venue for the festival.

    So, having said all this, it sounds like a wonderful opportunity, and the experience should have been a wonderful one for an artist, correct?

    While the vision of the CARICOM community and the CSME are ideal and support the arts in theory (after all the first category of persons given freedom of movement were artists and journalists)โ€ฆ in practice, trying to put theory into reality in my case was horrendous, costly and made difficult by the border agencies which should be in place to enforce and enact the vision and ideal of the CSME.

    In order to make sure that I had something official to let the St Lucia Customs officials know that the works of art I was travelling with were made in the Caribbean, I made sure to go through the process of creating a CARICOM invoice and getting a Certificate of Origin issued for my three paintings. So in theory, shouldnโ€™t these items have been seen as Duty Free and as a St Lucian, I hoped that they would be seen as works done by a St Lucian, even if they were actually created here in Barbados. With freedom of movement, should it even matter?

    Being the honest person I am, I declared the paintings and the purpose of bringing them into the country. I indicated that they would be on display and offered for sale and returning back to Barbados after the festival if not sold.

    I was told I would have to leave a deposit on the possibility of them being sold, money which I could only collect by returning to the airport with the paintings when I was returning to Barbados, so that Customs could see that I had not sold them. I indicated that at the point of sale that taxes and duties could be charged, but to no avail. If I wanted to display my works- I had to give Customs $180.00 EC. If it was just a business-like transaction I would not have minded so much, but I was held up, my bags searched, and treated as if I were doing something wrong. When I had to exit Customs to get the cash from an ATM machine required by one Customs official, I was stopped rudely by another Customs Officer and asked where was I goingโ€ฆ and told I could not just leave the hall.

    Finally having turned over moneys to the Customs officials to โ€œholdโ€ for me, feeling that I was betting against my artwork getting sold, and as if I were smuggling contraband of some sort, I finally entered St Lucia, toting my artwork to get it over to The Inner Gallery so they could get the first two pieces up on display at Gaiety, before the exhibit began the following day.

    The ElderSelf-portrrait

    The works, as expected, were appreciated, but not sold during the exhibit, but I had at least achieved my main objective of showcasing my work to people who had never seen it before. I actually had close friends who have known me for years, say that they never knew my artwork was so good. LOL

    Hopefully there are more people like that in both St Lucia and the wider world now, who see my work as being of a high quality, and perhaps when I have a solo exhibit, they will actually buy a piece or offer me a commission. But until the practices of Customs start seeing the works of artists from within the region as goods which can move as freely as their creators are in theory supposed to be able to do, the only place I will be able to afford to exhibit my work will be in the country where I produce it. Unless I am prepared to pay to ship it and pay duty on itโ€™s โ€œvalueโ€, hoping they will sell, but at an a price high enough to cover these increased costs.

    So, on the way out of St Lucia, having spent my last morning collecting and repackaging my work, I arrived at the airport and knocked at the door to where my deposit was supposed to be awaiting me, and there was an incoming flight, so I was advised that I would not be able to be helped at that time, although I was also due to check in for my flight, and the same paintings that they needed to see were in my luggage.

    Just before the moment of truth, two officers came out and verified that I was indeed carrying back my work, and I was told to come back into the arrival hall as soon as I checked in, in order to obtain my refund.

    When I did, a third officer was there at the desk with my receipt, and she gestured for me to come stand in front of her at the desk. When I came around to her, she said, โ€œwhat is this all about?โ€ So, knowing I was supposed to be in the departure area already, I bit down my frustration and explained as briefly as possible what the deposit was for and that I was there to collect it back. She asked me to show her the paintings.

    Knowing full well that should I show my reaction, I would not improve my position, I explained that the gentleman who gave her the receipt she was holding had verified that the paintings were with me before I checked my luggage. The next fifteen minutes were spent by her walking slowly to the office, confirming my story, then walking elsewhere to collect a cash pan with my monies, and finally in returning said $180.00 EC to my hand so I could rush out and clear security for my flight back to Barbados.

    I would love to say that it ended there, but on arrival back into Barbados, of course not having learned my lesson in St Lucia, about how well honesty and full disclosure serve me in these circumstances, I also advised the Customs officers in Barbados of what I was carrying, and showed them the stamped Certificate of Origins and CARICOM invoices from Barbados.

    I had to take a box cutter, and remove all of the protective foam padding from my frames and paintings, and prove that they were what I said they were, and an officer actually stated to me that there was no proof that the frames and paintings that I was carrying were the same ones that I was bringing in, since there was no serial numbers or anything.

    I offered to show my signature on the works which stated the date and place they were done and pointed out that I had always followed a policy of disclosure to the Customs authorities. I asked if she thought I was bringing in a more expensive frame than the one I had taken out of Barbados, and then she said that she never said she doubted my truthfulness. Sure sounded that way to meโ€ฆI have never felt like a criminal before when travelling, but I was treated more like a smuggler than an artist.

    I am an artist howeverโ€ฆ. one who wanted to display works of art before a larger audience, to show my friends back home what only those who have visited me here in Barbados have seen of my work. I am not a thief or a criminal, nor am I someone with the funds to pay large deposits of monies to Customs on my own work.

    I am not sure where the all of various Governments are throughout the region in the development of their own Cultural Development Policies and legislatures but if the simple hosting of an exhibit can be so demoralizing to an artist on one trip, there needs to be some serious work on a regional cultural policy that involved sensitizing the customs officials about works of art and ensuring that regional creative and cultural work is seen with respect and that Artist can be free to move within the region. I am a part of a group of artists who are trying to give input into the Barbadosโ€™ CIB which is currently an imperfect document (for the artists) and I know St Lucia has progressed in the development of their own Cultural policy, but regionally, we need to be guided by what is best for the Cultural workers, if the Creative arts are to flourish, provide employment to individuals, options to our creative children, and contribute to our societies the way they should and could, given the support and respect that our efforts and works.

    One Love and Blessings,

    Kat


  17. As I keep saying Caribbean people are in the habit of treating each other like criminals and run away slaves, with absolutely no respect for each other.

  18. keeping it real Avatar
    keeping it real

    @ RP,
    Women arrive at GAIA with drugs in their stomachs and vagina the artist with wrapped up artwork should anticpate he would have to open his packages and remove foam. Its an inconvenience but drug runners use every device to get their contraband in you cant blame the Customs unless they locked him up without reason.


  19. It is not about opening the parcel to show what is in it…’keeping it real’…it is about how one is treated when having to do this. Common sense must prevail.


  20. CBC no better than VOB
    not playing the music
    old songs
    nuff ads
    bare talk
    ……….praise r p bag
    and that is Crop Over

  21. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    John Roett reminds me of CASWELL FRANKLYN, he has an opinion on everything, but no one takes him seriously.

    He has never done anything worthwhile in his life.


  22. Boy Carson- You are something else.You dont mix matters.You tell it straight.John Roett /Caswell Franklyn .what a combination
    lol

  23. ghost who walks Avatar
    ghost who walks

    Just Asking—–There was another chap on BU talking out of his arse on the makeover of the Empire theatre. Mikey somebody, he and Roett could be twins, each hammered the Minister of Culture while denying that they were.
    You have to look such chaps straight in eye and let them know its crap they’re speaking.
    They believe we were born big without education or the ability to seperate rubbish from common sense.


  24. As I asked before, why not discuss what the group is trying to achieve instead of the personal attacks, for they do nothing to intellectually stimulate discourse on the issue at hand. I must admit, I do find political yardfowls amusing. Those who matter in my life know the things I have done, take me seriously, and are well aware of the numerous instances in which I have proudly represented my country. Fortunately, neither “Carson”, Just asking”, or “ghost who walks” (so proud of the display of weakness in your cowardly anonymity) fall into that category of mattering to me, and appear more than likely to fit in easily with those who remain doomed to an eternity in obscurity and zero achievement, with their lips firmly sewn to someone’s ass. Sad to think that there are people in my country so blind and stupid as to render themselves helpless against individual thought and intelligent discussion for the betterment of our country, but are more content to be stifled by political affiliation and remnants of racism. Truly sad. Next!


  25. @Dennis FIREWORKS Johnson

    Would it not be a good program to have Minister Lashley agree to sit in Studio with members of the CCCG? Let the public hear the challenges/status of both sides. At the moment this CIB business is sequestered within the walls of two stakeholders, the general public (including key professionals) needsto be involved.


  26. David, we are well aware that nothing can be perfect, and that there will always be peripheral restraints and legal implications to be considered. We understand this totally.. We have also shown great RESPECT to everyone who has been a part of this draft Bill, for it at least shows a beginning to the understanding of who we are and what we do. So is it therefore too much to ask for the same respect to be shown to us? All we ask for is discussion to arrive at compromise, ultimately culminating in a Bill of which we can all be proud and that will benefit every creative person in the country, and by extension, the country itself.

  27. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    People like John Roett just looking for their fifteen minutes of fame.

    They can be ignored.

  28. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    JOHN ROETT

    “so proud of the display of weakness in your cowardly anonymity)”

    In case you didn’t notice, you are writing on an anonymous blog, joker.

    Tell me who is the Blog owner?

  29. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    Nothing you proposed makes any sense except to you.


  30. People have resorted to attacking John Roett, why?

    Because it is easier to do this than to debate the issue at hand, Dr The Honorable decided to go down a sexist, racist path in what I can only consider as the best of the worst Trolling. But this is to be expected, he can post under a pseudonym, a Nom de Plume, because heaven forbid that he use his real name to post the ignorance that he did.

    I choose to post the following under my name, as a member of the CCCG, an artist, an avid supporter of culture, a young entrepreneur, and as an individual that has fought against this Bill from the first Public Consultations, I will call a spade a spade, this is bill in its current form is worthless.

    It is incomplete, rushed and is essentially a piece of legislation that is being passed hurriedly to take advantage of the UNESCO Heritage Status we were recently awarded, and the funding that comes with that.

    It will not develop the Cultural Industries, and if we are being perfectly honest we do not even have a serious cultural industry, not one that has an impact on the economy. But that does not mean that we cannot, we can, and we can have one that can drive this country and it’s economy forward into the future.

    But we are missing far too much, and contrary to the beliefs of many people in Government, it cannot be “amended later” we have heard that tired talk for too many decades, we have legislation, a century old that should have been amended multiple times, but hasn’t. We ignore the creatives, who on their own have amassed and accrued a magnitude of wealth of knowledge, networks and contacts.

    The Gov’t relies on technocrats and bureaucrats who will attend the seminars, workshops, a conferences around the world, but often lack the ingenuity to take the ideas shared and discussed and implement them here at home.

    And so a rift is formed, one that has grown to the point where there is little to no trust of these ministries and statutory corporations. We have allowed politics to pervade and corrupt at every level. So much so that even ministries do not speak or work together on legislation that is obviously reaching across a cross section of Ministries.

    On this Cultural Industries Bill this is woefully apparent, in the Public Consultations, no one from the Ministries of Tourism, Foreign Affairs & Trade, Education, Finance. All of which aee essential if we are going to have a thriving C.I.

    At the consultations at Combermere Sen. Jepter Ince explained that this much lauded fund would be used to do exactly what BIDC, Invest Barbados, BTA and the NCF all already are mandated by LAW to already do.

    We need to start from scratch, we need to develop from a Primary School level real programs in the Arts, and carry them through to Secondary school, this allows for creative free thinking to be nurtured and encouraged, out of which true innovation and creativity are born, and from that comes a new entrepreneurial class. The one that we are so speak about so often but do not really understand what it means

    This Bill in its current form is not a Bill it is piece of paper with writing, it is a forgery, not worth the paper it is printed on, and yet, it is going to be used to benefit the few, and allow monies t be drawn that will not be used in any meaningful way. It is a counterfeit, a fake check, it is FRAUD, plain and simple.

    And it needs to be called such, and often.

    I want this Bill, the CCCG wants this Bill, the Creatives of Barbados want this bill, but not in its current form, not like this. Until then we will step up our campaign and be relentless in our attack.

    Mr Minister, and whichever of your cronies will read this, we are not taking this lightly, we attempted to be civil, to have civil discussions and consultations, for over a year now we have tried, written, called, reached out and have been rebuffed and rejected.

    Now we declare war, and we will be merciless.

    Enjoy it , I know we will

  31. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    What issues?

    Nothing of any substance has been raised!!!

  32. Carson C. Cadogan Avatar
    Carson C. Cadogan

    Omar

    I just wasted ten seconds of my life reading the hogwash that you wrote.


  33. What Issues?

    The act essentially calls for a National registry, that once approved as a cultural agency will allow you as an entrepreneur/practitioner to obtain funding and concessions. However despite repeated attempts to explain the need for this decision not to lie with the Minister, which brings the biggest plague thus far to the development of the Cultural Industries in Barbados, back into the mix.

    This leaves artists and cultural entrepreneurs susceptible and the Cultural Industries susceptible to the changing face of politics that goes with it.
    It continues to be a gift to specific industries and not the cultural industries as a whole, this can be clearly noted in the language at the top of Part 1;

    โ€œApproved culture projectโ€ continues to be vague and does not lay out specifics, by this measure a person claiming that they are going to make pepper sauce and tell a story about the process is a worthy project displaying our culture.

    โ€œapproved producer of audio-visual contentโ€ or โ€œapproved producerโ€ this is a gift to an already broken and heavily fragmented sector of Barbados in which serious lines have been drawn in the sand, in which the supposed main representative body of the industry suffers from infighting, favouritism that has caused many members of the community to pull out and not allow that body to speak for them. As a result it is clear that this is, meant to benefit those that have the ear of the current Minister and not the larger community.
    โ€œarts and heritage facilitiesโ€ the real meat, and reason for this bill, the lack of legislation in Barbados relating to Arts, Culture and Heritage has resulted in Barbados being fully able to benefit from the UNESCO status we recently received.
    Despite the bill spelling out that a โ€œcultural projectโ€ means a project undertaken by the cultural entrepreneur, practitioner OR Government Entity. It continues to be troubling. No Government Entity should be allowed to benefit from this bill or the funding associated with it, by this funding for Crop Over, NIFCA, The Barbados Food & Wine and Rum Festival, can all benefit from this even though they have budget allocated for this under their existing statutory corporations.

    The creation of this Cultural Industries Development Authority, that is bizarrely responsible for the โ€œpromoting assisting and facilitating the efficient development of the cultural industriesโ€ and โ€œdesigning and implementing suitable marketing strategies for the effective promotion of the cultural industriesโ€
    This is honestly an incredibly un-thought out idea, as it not only covers EXACTLY what the NCF was created and mandated for, but also doing the job of an entire industry that already exists in this country. It essentially reinvents the wheel but makes it oval instead of round.
    It again also falls into the same cursed trap that has caused the NCF to be the utterly despised and useless entity that it has now been known to be. Appointments by the Minister, again are problematic and have caused most of the talented people at the NCF to leave or be fired without cause, Politics and the Cultural Industries are two entities that should have as limited a role as possible. The Board of Directors role is by even the most basic definition of the role of a Board of Directors over-stepping its bounds by the language laid out in the Bill. It over-steps the legal authority of a Board and compromises the roles of the senior officers of the Authority.
    The language that outlines the responsibilities of the CEO essentially make the CEO the person that does the bidding of the Board and by extension the Minister. The CEO is supposed to not only guide the company forward by charting a clear path, goal and objections on a monthly, quarterly and annual basis. The Boardโ€™s role is to approve certain matters and advise in others, NOT be responsible for the execution of policy. Mixing these creates muddy waters that will only continue to stifle growth of the sector.
    This Bill again continues to place all power at the Minister, with no oversight of the hiring or firing process. This has causes MANY issues at the NCF and other Statutory Corporations, and MUST be avoided to ensure the authority functions properly.

    (I should also point out that I am upto page 16 and Music, Musicians, etc are not mentioned despite being the fastest growing and most recognised sector to date of the Cultural Industries.)

    The Fund:
    The fund as outlined in the bill is simply a repeat of what at least 3 current Statutory Entities currently are mandated to do (BIDC, Invest Barbados and the NCF) all of which have budgets and programmes currently doing this.

    PART VII
    Further proof of the bill being a gift to specific sectors, in this case the Audio-Visual Production & Motion Pictures.
    Should concessions be given to this sector yes, but as is being seen now in the USA this is essentially becoming a problem as companies are using this as a subsidy, or write off for the projects, which takes money out of the Treasury. These Tax Credits take money out of other sectors and the reason for them the purported Job Creation is often temporary.

    See: http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2013/02/22/as-oscar-nominated-hollywood-moguls-bag-tax-cuts-they-seek-to-raise-yours/

    PART VIII:
    Again this is what the bill is really about, Heritage and UNESCO at page 32 of 52 and there is no mention of the proper development of the sector from the ground up, not synergy between other essential Ministries such as Tourism, Foreign Affairs & Trade, Education, all of which are vital for the growth and sustainability of the industry they are claiming to help โ€œdevelopโ€.

    I will also note that there are no provisions other than the brief mention of possible fees that may or may not be implemented that allow this Authority to generate revenue other than through donations and funding from Government. This Authority is being proposed the entity that will oversee the growth of this new sector however it has no means to fund itself, generate revenue it should run as a corporation and find ways to generate revenue that can be put back into the treasury.

    First Schedule:
    A complete lack of term limits for the Chairman or Deputy Chairman or Board as a whole, โ€œabsolute power corrupts absolutelyโ€ but term limits help to limit this. It should not be at a period determined by a Minister but rather by a mandated time period by law, this prevents members from being victims to the whims of the political process.
    Section 19 of the first schedule is troubling in its language, it states that the acts or proceedings taken by the Board cannot be questioned on the grounds of and I quote,
    โ€œthe existence of any vacancy in the membership of or of any defect in the constitution of the Boardโ€
    or
    โ€œany omission, defect or irregularity that does not affect the merits of the caseโ€

    How is this determined, and who determines this? Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Immediately comes to mind when reading this section. This breeds cronyism and favouritism and will kill the industry. The Board should be questioned and be made to answer at any time, transparency is the only way to ensure the current creatives, support and utilise this bill. As it stands it will only breed further distrust.


  34. @John

    Good to see the CCCG sticking together.


  35. @ David
    Do you not think it would save everyone a lot of stress if you advised these artist people that the ONLY reason our Government passed this bill (and most others) is to access foreign funding to be added to the consolidated fund to pay for their 4×4 vehicles and wages?

    …they may not be aware of this reality …and may therefore be misled into thinking that the actual bill is intended to make sense or to actually produce results, when in fact it is just needed by the funding agency in order to disburse the blenzers….

    All they are doing is embarrassing the poor minister. Wuh even if the bill is made workable and sensible ….whe’ they going get money from to finance it…? ….dem can’t mean Sinckler’s blenzers…

    We are like the fellow who lost he little pick months ago, but who still getting loans from Tom Dick and Harry for sweet sounding “productive purposes” (like self improvement)……to buy some rice and sardines.

    …you know day does only run til night catch up wid it….


  36. @Bush Tea

    BU has posted many blogs highlighting that it is about accessing UESCO/EU funding which is drying up anyway. The CCCG in its postings has acknowledged this as well. It is why BU has been pushing for concessions for the film industry (External) to ensure the project gives itself a chance to be self financing. You are correct, if they have to wait on government funding it will languish low on the priority list given the state of the national coffers. Perhaps the spunk the CCCG is showing will become infectious ๐Ÿ™‚


  37. As expected, Carson, if that is his real name, goes down the same line of stupidity previously displayed, as even the facebook page with that name carries no picture, hence anonymity as per “just” and “ghost”. My post carries my real name, but it gets clearer to me that to try to engage “Carson” in a discussion of intellect is akin to having a battle of intelligence with an unarmed man. 15 minutes of fame…lol lol….at least I’m being given my needed daily dose of humour. Why not respond to the intelligence and knowledge of the issue at hand as shown by Omar?…oh wait…my bad….sorry.


  38. As I understand it,this bill is about funding and tax concessions for cultural industries in a tidy framework that also allows Barbados to access funding from International agencies.

    The bill will get passed and next election we can discuss which politicians benefited the most and how much International funding leaked into the political campaign.

    In the meantime I will be happy to purchase crop over music online. David can help by putting up links to websites that sell Barbados cropover music.


  39. @Hants

    Nurturing the cultural industries is NOT only about music.


  40. David I understand that.

    I would like to see Barbados get into the film production Industry like Toronto and Vancouver.

    I would also like to see Bajan “productions” funded as is done in Canada.


  41. @Hants Barbados is capable of having a Film Industry, like Vancouver & Toronto, but this Bill has to be more than just Film. A film industry cannot succeed in this country if we do not have the expertise in all of the other areas that make up the film industry, Sound Engineering, Make-up, Videography, Writing, Acting, Editing, Graphics, Art, Photography, Special Effects, Animation, etc

    This Bill is about everything it is the whole Ball of Wax, it is everything, and that is why it is too important to pass in its current form. All of the Cultural Industries and intricately connected, the bill must reflect this.

    Education is the most important, real programs that build and appreciation for the arts and culture, and programs that teach and train and develop that even further.

    Foreign Affairs should have cultural attache’s that export our artists, music, movies etc, once they are up to an international standard.

    Tourism is key, not only should be be searching within for the marketing, but also work to develop these industries by spending that money within the economy and use that to drive the CI forward. Local Musici
    ans, should be regulars in Hotels, the steel pan is not bajan, the stiltmen & limbo dancers while novel, are old and played out. The Landship is ours, homegrown and should be given new life, as should the Tuk Band. Our tourism product is not suffering because of competition, or poor marketing, it is suffering because people travel for more than just sea and sun, and after the sun sets we have nothing for them to do. The Cultural Industries are key to changing that.

    Finance needs to be involved and recognise not only is this the face of the new economy in Barbados, but represents greater variety within the economy and leaves us less vulnerable to external factors.

    We need synergy between our Ministries and through our Legislation.

    We need to understand this, if we are going to move forward.


  42. one question ,is this Parkinson woman a foreigner?
    if so she may have avoided the rapes and other things done to bajan young girls growing up in barbados ,hence her sight may be blinded to the reality of barbados.
    now let us really discuss this.,
    barbados has a made up culture ,copied from Trinidad which was copied from Brazil.
    now the true culture of barbados should be African,Irish,Scottish,English combined.as this is who is there now and always has been,
    there fore it should have things taken from these cultures involved.
    have you ever seen a African carnival??????? no.
    have you ever seen a Irish carnival?no
    and so on.
    so what you are doing is making a false culture where it would be much better to have the real thing.African dance and drums,warrior dances from Africa,
    spears includes.! Irish dance,highland games [Scottish games]English culture
    i suppose could be dressing up as high society English .and English armies raping and plundering the lands.which would be the reality of barbados culture.
    let us face it soca music and all that loud raga raga nasty music you play at crop over is horrible and has nothing to do with music.
    also let us face that bajans do not pick crops really any more.
    so you see you are just really copying Trinidad,
    although i have never been to Trinidad carnival i would certainly not want to attend for drunks and whores and loud obnoxious mus booming in my ear.
    plus i do not drink alcohol
    alcohol accounts for 85 % of all crime and murder worldwide..
    for the low class white trash tourist they may think this is fun,but it is actually
    disguising behavior made out to be fun ,party frenzy.
    it has nothing to do with barbados culture. it is just a way to keep bajans stupid and drunk.so the government keeps you down where they want you.
    now shut up and think filth and wuck up that is all you are worth to them.
    and you all do a wonderful job of showing your true colors on crop over day dont you??????????
    grow up kids.
    filth and lewdness is not a culture.it is lack or culture.


  43. here is your culture,
    http://youtu.be/nd_WPdc2Mgg


  44. also ask the world government about oil.!!!!!!!
    and why we need it as i am sure if synthetic oil can be made
    so can synthetic gasoline.interesting is it not.,
    http://youtu.be/Bes62O0Y5-w


  45. @mrcorrecto

    I am not really sure how that comment on rape and Rosemary makes any sense, so I will choose to ignore it.

    The Culture of a nation is not only made up of its roots but also its influences and immigrants population.Barbados and the whole Caribbean is a melting pot of cultures, ethnicities and people. To relegate it to simply African, Scottish, irish & English is entirely too simplistic. We have a large Immigrant East Indian population that migrated here in the early 1900’s We did trade with our Caribbean neighbours even during slavery, and so there was a cultural exchange.

    Carnival was traditionally a celebration held before lent, in mostly Catholic predominant countries, Barbados’ Carnival Roots aka our Crop Over tradition actually dates back to 1688, featuring music, singing and dancing. Also common were the grease pole climbs, eating and drinking competitions. We adopted a more Portuguese style of celebration in the 20th century.

    But this is besides the point, cultures adapting or inserting aspects of other cultures is not unheard of or wrong, or even taboo. What is needed to to harness this and hone it into a firm embodiment that we can call our own.


  46. Yes Barbados may not have the expertise in all activities which the CIB is meant the trap BUT it is not about current state but futiristics as well.


  47. @David

    I agree with you, which is why the Bill is in my opinion a fraud, because it does nothing for either the current state or the future. It omits large sectors of the Cultural Industries, and does not have a plan that will develop the CI as they move into the future.


  48. @Omar

    Agree with your last comment but in the notes by the CCCG it criticizes the weighting given to film in the CIB. The approach should be an all embracing Bill to nurture all activities in Arts.


  49. โ€œIn fact, power is very highly concentrated, decision-making is highly concentrated in small interpenetrating elites, ultimately based on ownership of the private economy in large measure, but also in related ideological and political and managerial elites. Since thatโ€™s the way the society effectively functions, it has to have political theology that explains that thatโ€™s the way it ought to function, which means that you have to establish the pretense that the participants of that elite know what they are doing, in our interest, and have the kind of understanding and access to information that is denied the rest of us, so that we poor slobs ought to just watch, not interfere. Maybe we can choose one or another of them every few years, but itโ€™s their job to manage things, not ours.โ€
    โ€” Noam Chomsky –

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading