
Governor, Dr. DeLilse Worrell’s Review of the Barbados Economy for the first six months of 2010 – Click link to watch video



Governor, Dr. DeLilse Worrell’s Review of the Barbados Economy for the first six months of 2010 – Click link to watch video
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Mia is not to be taken seriously, unless you are a BLP follower.
……………………………………………………………………………………….
Carson. I am not a BEE or DEE follower, but I am extremely concern with the country being on auto-pilot now David is out of the island. Are the statistics given by Mia right or wrong? I was listening for clarification from Governor of the Central Bank or even you and BT but to no avail. Hope that we are not getting half-baked reports during this financial crisis.
I am beginning to distrust the Central Bank. For a long time I have not trusted Mia Motley.
Opposition leader Mia Motley’s press conference on the Central Bank’s governor report has forced me to do some research on some of the numbers she mentioned and some of the numbers in the central bank governor’s report.
Ms Motley makes it sound as if the fiscal deficit is worsening. The numbers do not bear that out. The overall deficit is declining compared to the corresponding period last year(from $334.0 million in 2009 compared to $289.2 million in 2010). The current account deficit increase slightly from $172 million to $184 million. this is nothing to be alarmed about.
She also made a big fuss about the fictional figures in the Medium Term Plan. The Strategic Plan over which she presided was just as fictional.
Annonymous says there is nothing to be alarmed about and the deficit is not worsening. Here are the fiscal deficit numbers in the Governor’s report.
Year: Deficit
2005: $257.1m
2006: $128m
2007: $125.7m
2008: $408.3m
2009: $694.4m
2009, Jan-May, $334m
2010, Jan-May, preliminary, $289.2m.
When looking at these numbers bear in mind that annual government revenues are around $2,500m.
If you look at these numbers and say, dont worry, the deficit is coming down because the preliminary figures point to a $45m improvement on the same period last year, and ignore the underlying deterioration that this table above shows then you have been blinded by partisan politics.
The same could be said of the current account balance. In 2007 it was a deficit of $115.7m, in 2009, it was a deficit of $412.6m. That is the underlying trend.
In the first 5 months of 2009, our busy tourist season, the deficit was $174.4m, in the first five months of this year, the preliminary data shows a rise to $182.3m
Governor Worrrell will argue that we need to raise revenues and reduce expenditure in order to contract the economy enough to stop the reserves from falling. Reserves are what he is judged by. Consequently, he will be arguing for tax rises and in particular VAT rises. But if the underlying problem of our economy as Bush Tea and others on this blog have identified is a lack of competitiveness, then higher taxes, higher administrative prices and cost of living is going to improve the short-term reserve position at the expense of long-term economic growth. Who in the Government is mulling over these issues, debating with the Governor and ready instead to make the bold decisions on cutting Government waste from entities that political appointees control? Are you telling me that every last penny of my tax dollars are being spent wisely at the Transport Board, QEH and UWI?
I suspect the Governor will have his way because for whatever reason the Government appears to have resigned and is lying down on the floor waiting to be rolled over by external factors, the US and UK recession, Clico, the central bank, you name it. Stand Up guys and, as someone on this blog said, let us be master of our fate, not servants.
@Black Business
I agree with you that the trend is worrisome. Ms Motley should have explained the matter just as you did above and not rely solely on year -over- year comparisons. Remember some of us are not checking the statistics for trends etc. We are merely listening to/ reading the statements from our leaders.
The economy cannot bear any new taxes. If new taxes are imposed, Dr Worrell will solve the balance of payments problem but we will be in for serious unemployment and social problems.
If at all possible the Government must be prepared to hold the strain a little while longer. To the extent the the WTO rules allow, we must restrict imports and buy more from local suppliers even if prices are a little higher.
The banking system has excess liquidity and the Government should borrow from the commercial banks and support construction and agriculture. The fiscal deficit will have to stay high for a while but must be in a position to rebound when the international economy rebounds.
If we allow the economy to contract too much,it may not be in a good position to rebound. It would be like plants affected by severe drought. Even when the rains return the roots are dead and cannot recover. We must therefore ensure that life is left in the economy to rebound at a later date. It is only the Government that can play that role.
Forget the IMF and the rating agencies, it is our survival at stake. The government must ensure that unemployment does not raise much further.
@Anonymous – 2010/07/17 at 7:41 AM
This is where the argument for a national bank assumes relevance. The banks in Barbados are all* foreign owned. They will not lend to the government simply on demand, There is sovereign risk.
Its pretty simply, lets start by enquiring who really owns HMP Dodds or for those you who don’t know it by its legal name: Barbados Corrections Corporation. I think Barbadians should demand this as a the litmus test to lock up someone for fraud.
I believe that through the Companies Act we can find out the real owners of the company and as a back up lets trace the money US$15 Million paid every January to see where it ENDS UP. In whose bank account or accounts, maybe some people will have to resign.
@David
Have we reached so low that the commercial banks in Barbados would have trouble lending the Government of Barbados money because they perceive Barbados as likely to have problems repaying loans? If this is the case then we are really in trouble.
@Anonymous
Yes and no, it is where the global economic turbulence has caused us to be. These international financial institutions post-wall street meltdown adhere to international standards especially when it applies to risk. It is nothing personal.
David,
Under banking regulation, banks have to maintain minimum capital adequacy. In these calculations, government debt is viewed as the lowest risk, and is the instrument they can hold their capital in, consequently the local banks (legal subsidiaries of the international banks) have good appetite for Government paper. Lending from local banks is not our problem. International borrowing in foreign currency to pay for our imports is the bigger problem.
Here is the rub. First, with government debt growing so rapidly (plus $500m per year, as opposed to plus $150m per year a few years ago) this is “crowding out” loans to the private sector to invest and carry on business. So just having the banks lend to the Government is not a good thing if it takes up all of their appetite for lending.
The second thing is that credit ratings, for all their wrongs, effectively place a country “credit ceiling” on all lending. What this means is that if the Government is downgraded to “junk” status, every private borrower in Barbados will be considered as “junk” or worse. Consequently, a downgrade of the Government means a credit downgrade of all of us and raises the cost of borrowing for all of us and this increases the cost of doing business. That is why we have to avoid a credit downgrade. To do so, we need to stop debt rising faster than GDP and that means limiting the deficit to at least half of its size, which means getting it back to where it was in 2002-2007 and saving $250m per year.
Given that personal taxes raise $1000m, that would mean a rise in taxes of 25% or from a top rate of 35% to over 45% and that assumes that doing that would not lower income, requiring even higher percentage to raise the same dollar amount. I dont think that is possible.
Given that VAT raises $700m, that would mean a rise in VAT of 33% or from rates of 17% to 23%. That would help to crush the distributive trades sector.
Given that Government expenditure is $2900m, It would mean cutting government expenditure by 10%.
It would seem to me that it would be difficult to cut 25% of Govenrment expenditure, or 20%, but do any of us think that there is not at least 10% of waste or unnecessary programs in Government expenditure.
This should take the biggest burden of the fiscal adjustment and if it were announced that we would do this in a phased manner it would bring back some confidence that would support investment, rather than keeping business guessing, which is bad for investing decisions.
The problem is that much of the economically unnecessary expenditure serves a political purpose and that is why it is the sacred cow and why politicians routinely trade-off future economic growth than current votes. The patronage of government is government spending and Government indirectly employs 30% of the population and so everyone is either an employee or related to a Government employee. It is up to us to say enough is enough and demand a bold new vision for government expenditure.
small correction: lending to government from local banks is not the problem…not lending in general
@Black Business
Not sure what you mean by ‘Under banking regulation, banks have to maintain minimum capital adequacy.’
What BU knows; like credit unions banks have to keep a pool or percentage of their deposits in government securities. While it is true ‘government paper’ is low risk you must be aware that governments have been known to default on debt. Will foreign commercial bank in the prevailing economic conditions have an open appetite for government debt?
@Bush Tea
You think that CSME is the only common market plan in town? So when we form this common market, …suddenly everyone will want to buy our beer?
Ya joke!!
You don’t think that Jamaican beer and Guyanese beer will also be on sale here?
Do you know that those beers are made with labour paid at rates which are a fraction of ours?
Do you know that Trinidad’s energy costs are a fraction of ours?
Who will buy our expensive products
==========================================
Bush Tea I have read your comments and I am appalled that you could even cross the road unassisted. My recommendation is rest your brain a while and give it a chance, put some weedkiller on it to kill off the thorns of ignorance. If you continue at this pace you will infect others who are unsuspecting. You already have some believing that this is only about creating a legacy.
Are you suggesting that the only way we can sell beer is if it is the only one in the market, and by extension if we find a niche market int’lly that Bajan products will not have to compete. I sincerely hope that you are not one of the advisors to the DLP because they are short on strategic thinkers and economic managers and might be scraping the barrel. Stop hogging the trough of ignorance.
The whole world moving in trade blocs- common markets and some in single economies. China, India, Australia and other Asian countries – one massive trading bloc of 2.3b people; South America – 600m, EU 450,. The only people with the supreme belief that a bloc will harm rather than help are shortsighted and mastasized brains in the DLP and the unsuspecting. How the DLP get so I do not know because the orignial charge was lead by Their Excellencies Grantley Adams, and Errol Barrow. Sandiford signed the finished product – treaty of Chaguaramas.
Recommended material for reflection – Wisdom of the Ages: There is safety in numbers; Unity is strength; United we stand divided we fall; a bundle of sticks cannot easily be broken.
Warning: This wisdom is not helpful for those who do not have a plan or vision, an indicator of the presence of a virulent form of the ignorant disease caused by association with politically underdeveloped groups ; this wisdom would be a nuisance and irritant to this extreme condition.
Don’t rush to reply, ignorance may prompt you to write. Just think on these things.
@Black Business
We all know that the political connections must get their fair share of easy money from loose contracts with the government. ( From your style of writing I am certain you know of such things). Yes we really should start with expenditure control but that is near impossible when you are looking to win elections.
The workers also expect to get their “free” supplies of toilet paper, pens, ink, printing paper etc. Any politician who tries to stop this will be in trouble.
Let us start a campaign to reduce the “fat” in government contracting and the pilferage of government supplies of paper etc. If we could save 10% or 15% per year we would be well on our way to solving the fiscal deficit
David,
There is some mixing up of fiscal deficit and trade deficit going on here. They are related, but separate from a borrowing perspective.
Government debt is indeed risky in reality, but under banking regulation – we follow Basle I banking regulatory rules and are trying to move towards Basle II rules, government debt is treated as if it is low risk. (This is because Governments, unlike individuals and companies have powers of taxation.)
Although our banks are foreign owned, they are not foreign branches, regulated in foreign countries, they are local subsidiaries regulated by the Central Bank of Barbados and required to follow our regulation. (Our banking regulation and banking supervision is far from perfect but it is many times better than our virtually non-existent insurance regulation.) Consequently in their local operations these local banks will have an appetite for local government debt. Consequently, the problem of our local currency debt is not, currently at least, that nobody will lend, it is that it is depriving the private sector of borrowing and can only be sustainable through higher local taxes or lower local spending which politicians do not like and if they do not do will mean that we end up reneging on our commitments in some way (less pensions, less public services etc).
The problem of people not lending to us, will first arise where we need to borrow foreign currency, not local currency, in order to fund our trade deficit.
In this case we are borrowing outside of our banking system where there is no requirement of the banks to own Barbados credit risk and where the lenders follow the credit rating agencies view of our credit quality more closely than our own protestations. So the first lending restraint we are going to come up against is a result of the Government borrowing overseas to replenish our foreign exchange reserves because of the trade deficit.
Recently the Government borrowed US dollars to replenish our reserves – I think it was $100m – and the cost of borrowing rose because of the reduced willingness of foreign banks to lend to Barbados.
This is why the Governor will be focused on tax rises, because these will contract the economy to such an extent that we consume less, and therefore import less, and therefore have a lower trade deficit and therefore use up our foreign exchange reserves less and therefore have less need to borrow abroad. You can see why the Governor would want to do this, but there needs to be some offsetting policies to boost local growth otherwise this contraction will merely, as has been said, rob Peter to pay Paul, save our credit rating, but at the expense of unemployment where peoples skills and attitudes suffer long-term damage.
@Anonymous (why don’t you give yourself a name?)
You maybe correct, matters of economics and financial management have become a complex affair, who are we to argue with someone who seem to know what they are talking about. Two points of clarification arises out of your recent comment. Yes the Governor is trying to force contraction in imports which if successful will positively affect foreign reserves. You are aware that the distributive sector is responsible for double digit employment in Barbados? The Governor’s strategy if successful will push unemployment over 11% where it currently hovers. The final point you must be aware that Grenada defaulted on its government obligations in 2004?
@anonymous,I agree wid David.
why don’t you name yourself “econoguru”. or “muhguffie”.
You make interesting contributions.
Conrad and Black Business thanks for facts, and our further education. People need to take heed. Like Masta Rasta said we need all hands on deck. We are being treated to facts that further demonstrate that the priority of the DLP is politics not people. As demonstrated in the advice of Carson Cadogan that you should focus on politics not the economy, is definitely the mantra and strategic plan of the DEMS. DLP cannot account for this massive spending ( 1.6b in two years)with tangible productIve capcity for the country to produce jobs and earnings. NOTHING SIGNIFICANT TO SHOW.
People cling to a ‘dead DLP’. This current lot are masqueraders, doing what is politically expedient at the expense of the citizens. Errol Barrow put the country first; this army of occupation razing the ground, could not do worse than if they intended using scorch earth tactics – 140m annually in extra taxes to increase fatted calf; sever people’s employment to find jobs for supporters; create more inflation with raising oil prices, water, electricity, phone rates; divert business from small to large busInesses in construction. Oh god Clico, they should have listened to Mottley, this Clico mess will bite later. This made the impact of the recession worst – reduction in tourism, offshore and foreign direct investment. It weakened the capacity of companies and individuals to weather those storms.
My research on these matters show that BLP under Owen Arthur left this economy strong, and with competent management, would have weathered this storm better. Check IMF and Moody reports on B’dian economy during his tenure, not BLP speak. (Low unemployment 6%; high foreign reserves 2.8b; renewed infrastructure; productive capacity in kensington, Hilton, airport, seaport, prep for embassies in Brazil and China; coast guard, judicial centre, prison, Bridgetown, Oistins, s’town upgrades; new economic sectors such as culture, energy, agricultural initiatives). That is where our money went preparing for future growth. Our status was only downgraded after the disastrous steps by DLP. Every step the DLP is taking is further damaging the economy, the recovery, jobs, and screwing the people with high prices. Forget the budget now, Dees have nothing to offer us, time to ring the bell.
@ Anonymous – clap, clap, clap. so true brother, well said.
This problem is further complicated by the fact that the retail sector employs close to 9000 or more persons, so dampening spending when jobs are being lost will generate more unemployment, closure of businesses, which will further contract gov’t revenue, thus intensifying the downward spiral in the economy to reap a whirlwind.
Helpful as Four seasons will be it is only 1000 jobs, (7oo-800 are temporary). I had to laugh when Minister Lashley talked about the camps employing 1000 people, five weeks of work, dear Lord. Keep the jobs you have by easing pressure of high prices, high taxes, put more tax on selected luxury items to dampen foreign reserves drain, not across the board tax. God Lord think nuh.Anonymous if you could help them, do brother.
@ Bajan Truth
I have no reply for you. It is clear that you have nothing constructive to contribute – except for vague generalizations and political nonsense.
Bush Tea declared his political hand years ago now – (BBE yardfowl)….. so it is difficult to follow your BLP /DLP rants…. I thought that we were looking at these matters from academic / nationalistic perspectives.
Keep good.
@Anonymous,
You make some very interesting points, and I have a few questions:
You suggest that the Governor would be in favour of higher taxes – where is the evidence of this?
Also, where is the evidence that government borrowing is affecting the ability of the private sector to get credit from banks?
@ Anonymous and Black business
I noticed that the Central bank governor is speaking of the debt to GDP ratio excluding the NIS debt as was suggested by Mia Mottley and Arthur. if I remember correctly they both suggested measuring the economy that it had grown considerably since 10 years ago, if I am not mistaken and is not a 9b economy but might be more like 13b. Uncertain of the facts here. Has this been done as well? I would find it useful for comparison sake if you could provide comparative statistics using a common position to outline the size of the debt to GDP as at 2007 vs. 2009, so we can compare apples with apples.
Thanks looking forward to having that info, if you have it.
We tried to borrow some money recently from First Caribbean and Scotia for an investment my business was trying to make that would have earned foreign currency. Both declined, now maybe that was because they didnt like our credit, even though the company holds surplus funds with one of them, but they both said, smugly, that they have been inundated with requests for loans from Governments in the region an our own and that they could make a tidy business if all they did was lend to Government all day long. I will try and dig out some statistics about loans to the private sector – the central banks has these on their website somewhere – but my own experience has been one of being “crowded out” by Government debt. This is a well known phenomena around the world though I recognise some numbers will help.
What ratio should we use to look at debt? Debt to GDP, Debt to revised GDP, Debt to exports, Debt to what? What these ratios are trying to do is to compare debt with your capacity to pay the debt. They are about debt-sustainability. The thought is that if the economy has grown, your capacity to raise tax revenues has grown too and so you could borrow more than in the past in a sustainable manner.
It is likely that our GDP – a measure of the amount of economic activity that takes place in a year – is bigger than the official statistics because the way this is calculated is by seeing how much activity in each sector has grown and then weight each sectors growth by its relative size to get to an average growth rate and we add that to some estimate of the level of activity measured some time ago. The problem is that the relative size of our sectors has changed. It is likely that the old sector weights, overestimate the size of the slow-growing sugar industry and underestimate the size of the faster-growing financial sector or distributive trades sector. The study by CARTAC is supposed to have found that our GDP is some 30% larger. I suspect that using these new weights would also show that our economy contracted more than the old weights show because the previously fast growing sectors have been hardest hit in this recession.
If you assume that GDP is 30% bigger, it lowers the debt to GDP level, so that debt to GDP would have grown from 60% in 2007 to 74% in 2009. This makes the picture look more sustainable, but it does not change the picture of rapid deterioration. And I wonder about capacity to pay. A good measure to me would be the actual annual interest costs to service the debt as a percent of actual annual tax revenues and this has grown from 12.8% (out of every dollar of tax raised, 12.8 cents goes towards paying the interest on government debt) to 17.2% and this figure is flattered by the fact that interest rates came down because of the global recession and have only moved up on our debt since the Greek crisis in March of this year.
@Black Business,
I seriously doubt that commercial banks would prefer to lend most of their funds to government, if by “lend to government” you mean invest in treasury notes/debentures. From what I can tell the Barbados government is currently paying no more than 7.5% while the banks can earn well in excess of that on loans to businesses. The more that is lent to government the less profitable overall the bank is. Now if the banks can not find reasonable commercial projects to lend to, then they will be forced to park their surplus funds in government paper but I don’t think that we can therefore conclude that the government is crowding out the private sector.
In fact, the last Central Bank report says that the banking system is very liquid and banks are holding more cash (7.5% of deposits) than is required by the Central Bank (5% of deposits).
I will try to do some research and get back to you. Economics is not my field but I had decent training from a relatively decent university in the discipline.
On matter of the economy, if Black Business is referring to the informal sector, what we have is essentially a job /self employment creating sector but also a foreign exchange spending sector which is paying very little by way of taxes.
In times of balance of payments problems and problems with the fiscal deficit, we have to promote this sector as an employment creator and nothing more.
Gosh its hard to use the central bank website. So many of the pdf files dont download on my computer for some reason – maybe its my computer that is the problem.
However, there is some useful data on the commercial banks in the Governor’s package of report, charts and tables.
One of the problems of interpreting lending behaviour is that in the beginning of a recession you actually get a surge of borrowing as companies use of previously negotiated credit facilities. This is called “distress borrowing” as it is not really a measure of commercial bank willingness to lend.
So, you will see in the data a surge of lending between 2007 and 2008. Since 2008 however, there has effectively been no new lending to the private sector. Lending to the private sector by the commercial banks was at $5011m in 2008, $5074m in 2009, and in June 2010 it was $5036m. Lending today was less than at the end of last year and hardly higher than it was at the end of 2008.
The banks are quite liquid however. The total amount of domestic deposits have not grown since 2008 either, but they stand at $7614m.
Over this period, the commercial banks have increased their holdings of Government Treasury Bills by $120m.
So it is hard to get the full picture from this data, but we know a few things. The Government is borrowing substantially more than before, (plus $1bn since 2008 and $1.5bn since 2007) the commercial banks are liquid, (more deposits than private loans) but they are not increasing their lending to the private sector.
What does all this mean, comes back to something that someone else said. The first “budget constraint” we are going to hit is to do with our foreign exchange reserves, which relates to our current account deficit and credit rating.
The government will be able to borrow domestically for its domestic debt, in part because the commerical banks are liquid. But this borrowing merely postpones higher taxes or lower spending and, most probably, “crowds out” private investment in our future growth, by allowing the banks to make decent money simply by ignoring the private sector and lending to the best credit in the country, the government.
Dear Brutus,
Although lending to the private sector appears more attractive, with private borrowing rates of 10% compared with Government borrowing rates of 7.5% or less, it is not, as you know as simple as that. The banks have to put aside capital (dead money that earns no interest and therefore represents a sort of tax to them) against the risk of a private loan, but they put aside no risk for lending to the Government. Lending to the Government is attractive then from a capital perspective. It is also attractive from other perspectives – not alot of time and money has to be spent on originating and monitoring the loan compared with a private sector loan – and because it is government, there are better changes of a foreign bail out than a private loan, so a low risk, low cost 7.5% is competitive with a high risk, high cost 10%.
To be honest Brutus, I dont think I will be able to prove “crowding out” with the available data, though it is possible to prove the opposite is not happening – banks are not lending happily to the private sector and shunning government debt. It would be worth asking people on the blog what their experience of “credit conditions” has been and their experience of trying to get new loans from banks at this point.
@Black Business,
No, I disagree with you – I think it is indeed as simple as that. No bank is going to be profitable by lending only or primarily to government unless they are getting an unusually high return from the government lending.
The bank is restrained by capital requirements, but most of the banks have regulatory capital well in excess of the required ratio so there is no capital benefit in accumulating further government debt.
I would also think that there is no automatic link between the experience of bloggers in obtaining credit and the question of government crowding out private sector borrowing. However for what it is worth, my own experience is that the banks are falling over each other trying to lend money (both business and personal), especially to good credit risks (which is not limited to government).
Dear Brutus,
So why has lending to the private sector not gone up if they are falling over themselves to lend, but lending to government has?
My experience of trying to get loans has clearly been different from yours, you must have a vastly superior credit, for which I am respectful and envious, but I do not think it is common.
In terms of bank profitability, for lending to Government where they do not need to put aside capital it is the difference between what they have to pay on deposits and what they can charge for the lending. This is a very profitable spread today. Even at the best of times it is hard to get the Barbadian commercial banks to take commercial risks, so if they are being offered with a supply of easy profit, they will go for that.
VOB will have a talk show on the economy this morning, here is the line up expected to be on air:
SECTOR GROUPS
Achal Moorjani – Construction –
Keith Miller – Miller Publishing
Andy Armstrong – BCCI – Armstrong Agencies
David Neilands – Super Centre Group – BCCI –
Joel Richards – BMA – Trade Officer
Judy Lorne –BARVEN – PRO –
Lynette Holder – BSBA – CEO
COMMENTATORS
Hal Austin –Financial Analyst
Ronnie Yearwood – Political Science
George Brathwaite-Political Science
Randolph Sandiford –Manufacturer
Lindsay Holder – Economist
@ Brutus
Black Business is correct in pointing out that our GDP is underestimated .According to the IMF Article 1V Consultation on Barbados,the CARTAC study (not yet released)estimates that our GDP is underestimated by about 15%. This is significant as with a higher GDP our Debt/ GDP ratio would be seen as less unfavorable by bankers. The main sectors that are underestimated are financial services and tourism according to the IMF.
In reading the IMF Article 1V consultation I realized that generally our statistics are not up to scratch. Maybe it is time to set up a professional independent statistical department that can produce better quality statistics.
@Brutus
The IMF Article 1V consultation also contains information on the DEBT/ GDP ratio that notes the high proportion of government borrowing from the NIS. The problem is that the information is in percentages. Some simple work would have to be done to get information into a form that Joe Public can readily understand but all the information that is required is there. The data cover the period up to 2008.All that would be left would be to update for 2009.
I am confident that you can do this yourself. For consistency you should not adjust the 2009 data to reflect the underestimation of GDP. Use the information that is currently provided by the Central Bank and the Statistical Department.
I
@ BLACK BUSINESS AND BRUTUS
The banks prefer lending to gov’t at this time because with the crisis they will hedge against default on loans in the private sector. With gov’t, the rate is lower and so is the risk, as the economic climate is uncertain with no real end in sight. They banks have all been experiencing greater difficulties in loan repayments since late last year into this one. Mortgages, business loans, etc. The private sector has been trying to hold on to employment but have delayed further spending and investment so demand will have dropped as well.
This is why I have such a difficulty with the gov’t plan, it is not a cogent plan that makes sense nor has a reasoned strategy behind it. If you ask the private sector to hold strain and maintain employment which they have done even if they had to resort to short hours in some cases, why the hell do you raise their cost of business and cost of living to defeat the purpose – water rates, electricity, fuel, phone licenses and other feesetc.. Fuel problem increases the cost of inputs and services as all sectors respond to increase cost of business. Threaten them with competition when they are holding your employment figures, but you do not correct your own mistakes that contribute to price increases.
How does it make sense to say to people we want to encourage small business formation but you have cut funds to the institutions that lend to them and give technical assistance; you have to channelled more business to them from your gov’t spending, you have diverted business away from some small businesses such as- construction and by extesnion the people making doors and windows, tilers, electricians, plumbers, furniture manifaturers, food vendors, sell bed linens and stoves. Good grief!
This plan only seems to be about correcting their fiscal deficit without a parallel strategy to focus on you will support key sectors that will balance off the lash in tourism and financial services. As they get desperate they scatter shot – Brazil and China as a tourism market not metioned before not in the medium term plan. I can see Brazil if you must pursue a new marekt but China. New markets take time to develop, you cut the tourism budget, are you diverting money from existing markets to these areas. Please it is madness. They do not know what they are doing. Still keeping up the cosmetic activities that take away funds from areas urgently needing support to keep real jobs.
@Bajan Truth
The banks prefer lending to gov’t at this time because with the crisis they will hedge against default on loans in the private sector. With gov’t, the rate is lower and so is the risk, as the economic climate is uncertain with no real end in sight.
In theory the above quote makes sense but have you established this to be the case in Barbados?
@Bajan Truth,
All I am saying is that I do not think that any increase in lending to government is at the expense of lending to private businesses. The banks have surplus cash which is earning nothing for them.,Even though they are lending more to government (if this is indeed the case) they still have ample funds available for lending to the private sector. If they are not doing so then perhaps we need to look at other reasons.
For example, isn’t it possible that since the economy has slowed down there are fewer new projects for which businesses are trying to get finance? Many businesses would have postponed new capital projects until there is greater certainty about the timing of economic recovery.
Furthermore, isn’t it likely that a higher proportion of businesses seeking loans at this time are doing so for debt consolidation or because they are already having cash flow problems, which makes it less likely that they will get the loan?
Does anyone have an opinion of Hal Austin’s columns in the Nation? I find them usually to be quite outlandish and I see no evidence that he knows anything about finance or the economy. However he is billed as an award winning financial journalist so perhaps I am missing something.
@Brutus
Don’t let Bajan Truth confuse you. Have you read the local newspapers in recent days and weeks? Have you watch the local TV in recent days and weeks? There is a bank currently offering mortgages at 5.75%. Why do you think this is the case? On the local TV did you see a couple banks pushing loans at some low rate? All this add up to confirm what you are saying, the banks want to lend. Commonsense does indicate that in a recessionary period consumer confidence will be low hence we are where we are presently i.e.banks being liquid.
I have just finished listening to the Brass Tacks programme on VOB. If ever there was doubt about the lack of expertise on fiscal and macro-economic matters on the part of the DLP, the intervention by Senator Ince left no doubt.
Mr Mascoll was too arrogant, but Senator Ince was bold and certain but obviously very ignorant about the interpretation of government financial statistics.
@ David & Brutus
I said: The banks prefer lending to gov’t at this time because with the crisis they will hedge against default on loans in the private sector. With gov’t, the rate is lower and so is the risk, as the economic climate is uncertain with no real end in sight. They banks have all been experiencing greater difficulties in loan repayments since late last year into this one. Mortgages, business loans, etc. The private sector has been trying to hold on to employment but have delayed further spending and investment so demand will have dropped as well.
===============================
The banks prefer to lend to gov’t than private sector in a crisis – this is the traditional position or normal response in crisis. As opposed to the banks in B’dos right now have said they will not lend to private sector. Your point David. If there is excessive gov’t borrowing it limits available funds. What is happening in b’dos today is that banks have said they are having repayment problems from existing loans. So greater care and scrutiny is being done of new loans, and I should add, business loans. This does not mean they will not advertise, but their may be more discards of applications, but happily they will buy gov’t debt unless there is a downgrade to junk status. But my caveat to this position was in the statement that companies were holding on to employment, and therefore may be limiting new spending and investment etc and so DEMAND from the sector might be low, hence liquidity which was your point Brutus.
@ Anonymous
I was flabbergasted Jepta Ince did not even know the size of the economy he manages in the ministry of Finance. The old figure was 9b, since remeasuring based on your info it could be 11b. He does not know that it is a fiscal deficit not a physical deficit. He did not know the real deficit of B’dos over the years, he should have read this blog before he went on the programme. He did not understand the accounts of the gov’t unless he was trying to be disingenous to suggest that the gov’ts ‘s budget overruns included the off budget spending. This is a person Thompson added to the Ministry of Finance to help him in the management of the economy, a person he believes knows more than he does and the rest of his DLP team about managing the finances of the economy and just as much as Darcy; the person who came out and spoke on behalf of the gov’t.
Dear God we are in deep shite not doo doo. I am going to have to join Bonny in prayer for this nation.
@ Anonymous cont’d
I forgot to mention. David Ellis tried to give the goodly senator (Ince) a way out to save his face, but the ecstasy of his verbosity that he uses to the DEms that he knows more than he does, it fell apart on the programme. When pressed for facts, analysis and strategies, failed miserably. He was drunkened with his ignorance, and of the worst variety because he does not know that he does not know or he would not have called the programme. He tumbled down in the Paradise of his foolishness and probably left none the wiser.
@Bajan Truth
Your observation about Senator Ince not inspiring confidence is accepted. To be honest his performance was embarrassing unless he was labouring under some stricture from on high.
It boggles the mind that the government would chose/allow Jepter Ince to defend/explain its handling of the economy on today’s Brass Tacks program. His ineptitude and lack of understanding of the issues were brutally exposed for the world to hear. He was a disaster, an absolute embarassment. As Mascoll said sotto voce at one point: No wonder we are in such trouble, if Ince is the kind of intellect now influencing policy in the Ministry of Finance. Seriously, the government needs to muzzle the jackass.
What is even more frightening is that the national debt increased by $1.5billion in the last 2 1/2 years, with nothing to show for it, as Prof. Persaud pointed out and it seemed that Ince didn’t know what he was talking about, avoided the question and continued trying to blame the last administration for spending done by the present administration. It was surreal.
What is instructive is that Persaud agreed with Mascoll on every issue. Mascoll goes up a few notches in my book, because I have a lot of respect for the professor.
We are in worse trouble than we thought and the ship of state has no rudder.
Senator Ince, called in to help the the Government manage the economy said on today’s call-in that the size of the economy was $2.5bn. The danger is that by the time he is finished with it, it will be $2.5bn but the current estimates are that it is close to $9bn, so he is wrong not by +/-5%, 10% or 15% but over 300%.
Did you notice how the Prof was silent. I bet he was flabbergasted. Embarrassing man. Embarrassing.
Ince’s complete statement was ‘productive economy’.
Dear David,
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the measure of the productive economy.
It is a measure of the valued added product in the economy from one year to the next. It does not include for example an unproductive piece of land even if it is highly valued.
So, Ince thinks the productive part of the economy is $2.5bn, when it is $9bn. I wonder what he thinks the debt is. The debt level is $7.8bn, having risen by $1.5bn since end-2007.
The best that can be said is that he is a little confused and perhaps not batting in the right position – more no. 7 than an opener and perhaps a different game altogether. He seems to like political football.
Thanks Conrad, even David of BU could have delived a conversation on the size of the economy and the exercise by CARTAC to restate it. Didn’t Arthur deal with this matter in his speech at UWI?
Perhaps. I dont follow Owen so closely.
My worry about the restatement from a debt perspective is that it is only real if, at the end of the day, if forced to, we could tax it. If there are revenues there that can be taxed and we are under-recording it, then we should record it, but I thought the new numbers presented by the Governor includes all these restatements, its why the debt level left by the BLP is now at 77% odd, rather than the previous estimate of 85%. It means that under the old numbers, the current debt level would be around 114%, not far off Greece……
Anyway the point is we have a fiscal problem – whoever caused it – that we have to deal with. Given that we are a high cost economy, it is probably not best dealt with through higher VAT, levies or taxes as in the 2008 budget but expenditure cuts. It is probably best not to be capital expenditure which, if wisely spent would be an investment in the future, but current expenditure.
There has been a huge increase in current expenditure off-radar and this should be rolled back. It is probably too big to do this by chipping here and there so we need to be radical and reconsider how we pay and how we deliver for the services we want the state to provide. This is the kind of conversation the Government should be having with us. They should be out there speaking to us and listening to us about these choices. They should be on the call-ins and blogs explaining the real choices and suggesting some options. Can we afford to educate our lawyers from well-to-do families or those who go to work and pay tax abroad? How do we make the buses run with out such large subsidies? How do we make QEH serve people better without costing an arm and a leg.
Instead we have Senator Confused on the call-in, Senator Boyce in hiding and we are told, we just have to wait until America recovers as if we might as well never having become independent because there is nothing our government can do, except it seems add to our national debt by $1500m in just two and a half year years.
Dr Dooos perspective may be important in the economics of the situation.
@ Bajan Truth
‘He does not know that it is a fiscal deficit not a physical deficit. ‘
I thought I heard physical too but was willing to give the goodly Senator the benefit of the doubt, but you have confirmed that my hearing still intact.
The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.