Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Senior Law Lecturer Jeff Cumberbatch – article reproduced from the Barbados Advocate – 04 October 2009

Over the past two weeks, this space has been concerned with exploring the phenomenon of local blogging and the susceptibility of contributors to actions for defamation. This is a developing area, and while it is currently accepted that the blogs enjoy no immunity from defamation and are unlikely ever to do so; yet there are some issues that remain in need of clarification if bloggers, blogmasters and those offended by published material are to understand clearly their rights and responsibilities in this regard.

This may assume even more significance in future, if current trends should hold true. In an article published on Monday last in Newsweek online, Daniel Lyons urges the authorities in the US not to bail out struggling newspapers under the contemplated Newspaper Revitalisation Act, but to let them die and get out of the way. He argues; “Nobody in their right mind believes the future of the news business involves paper and ink rather than pixels on a screen…” and he likens the proposed statute to “…introducing legislation to save horse-drawn carriages, or steam engines, or black-and-white TV. It’s stupid. It’s pointless. It won’t work.”

And in another article published on September 23 in The Silicon Valley Insider, Henry Blodget refers to a poll on newsmedia trustworthiness carried out by Sacred Heart University in Connecticut. This informs that nearly 8 out of 10 Americans would oppose any plan to spend tax dollars to aid failing newspapers, a result he attributes in part to “…because they don’t read newspapers anymore and in part because they think online news organisations are actually doing a fine job…”. For now, this is a debate we are not yet having, and it would be a bit of a stretch to describe any of the local blogs as a news organisation, but it is not especially difficult to contemplate a day when news will be mainly read on mobiles or computers rather than on “dead trees”, as print editions are now commonly referred to.

Given my clearly vested interest in this debate, it is one to which this column shall return in future, but it is mentioned at this stage merely to underscore further the importance of our current discussion.

Last week, we discounted the popular misconception that malice is ordinarily required for liability to ensue for defamation under our law. Another such misconception is that the publisher of defamatory material is safe so long as he or she does not refer to anyone by name. In fact, reference to the plaintiff does not depend on the intention of the defendant at all, but on whether the ordinary reader would think that it referred to the defamed individual. In one celebrated case, the court held that readers of a particular newspaper would ignore clear discrepancies of time and place, and justifiably think that the words referred to the plaintiff. Nor, that same case held, was it relevant that a witness who thought the story referred to the plaintiff did not believe it.

From reading a recent blog discussion on the topic, I gained the impression that there is also a popular belief that even if there should be court-ordered disclosure of the IP address of the defamatory publication, the owner of the computer may nevertheless escape liability unless it can be established by the plaintiff that he or she was indeed the publisher.

This point was litigated in a 2008 decision of the English High Court. In June 2007, a false Facebook profile was set up for the plaintiff, containing some private data such as his sexual preferences- “looking for whatever I can get” -, date of birth and political and religious views. Next day, a Facebook group was set up, with a link to the profile, containing material defamatory of the plaintiff. Both of these publications were established using the defendant’s IP address. But he denied being responsible for the publications, alleging that the offending pages must have been set up by someone using his computer without his permission.

The judge rejected this defence. On the evidence, the defendant’s alibi was “utterly implausible from start to finish” and he was held responsible for creation of the defamatory material. It is not, as most lay people seem to believe, a matter of “your-word-against-mine” and therefore there can be no determination of who is telling the truth. As I told a first-year medical students’ class yesterday morning, the court is bound to come to a decision, based on the evidence and its own instincts, as to which party is telling the truth.

One final point of significant interest is the liability of blogmasters for the publication of material considered defamatory. Under section 15 of the local Defamation Act, a defendant who is “not primarily responsible” for the publication of a statement shall not be held liable to any plaintiff defamed thereby unless the plaintiff can first establish that the defendant knew or had reason to believe that the statement was defamatory of him. However, according to the legislation, editors and publishers are primarily responsible for the publication; thus the question arises as to whether, in the local context, the blogmaster is to be treated as an editor or publisher.

For anyone familiar with discussion on the two major blogs, it is clear that those in charge of them exercise editorial responsibility “for the content of the statement or the decision to publish it”, given, especially in one case, the not infrequent assertion that a comment is awaiting moderation. A decision to publish therefore may be legally assumed to be the act of the blogmaster and not solely made by “a person for whose acts the operator is not responsible”.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

57 responses to “The Future Fourth Estate?”


  1. @Hants // January 11, 2010 at 12:10 PM . You know one? Me pass – me no know none. Thing is that it doesn’t matter if the CJ was a member or supporter of any political party. What matters is that EQUAL first, she/he should be a good administrator AND a first class jurist. You may argue that you cannot be a first class jurist without being a scholar, but out of caution, I put down that she/he has to be a first class scholar. Next, they must not be afraid to take on (a) the Registry and, if necessary, fire some people and (b) the executive and tell the politicians to go to hell. Probably as important as the administration and the scholorship is the willingness to engage counsel and make them toe the line – and to engage judges and insist on timely decisions or she/he will fire their sorry asses.

    Of the current crop, all the really competent ones are too old, except – and I have to agree – for Miss Chase. Miss Chase would be my choice – except I agree that she ain’t a gonna do it. Or at least I doubt she will do it. Pity. The fur would fly and the people of Barbados would finally get value for their money.


  2. @Amused

    You put the following to Jeff Cumberbatch:

    I am surprised, Jeff (given the thrust of your article – the replacement of the traditional Fourth Estate by the Internet) that you have not touched on this and on the the INTER-AMERICAN DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES ON FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION that comes out of the Organisation of American States and is binding on, among others, the USA – and on Barbados. Have a look at http://www.cidh.oas.org/declaration.htm.

    Effectively, it means that, in relation to matters of National interest and importance, Principle 8 sets out that “EVERY SOCIAL COMMUNICATOR HAS THE RIGHT TO KEEP HIS/HER SOURCE OF INFORMATION, NOTES, PERSONAL AND PROFESSIONAL ARCHIVES CONFIDENTIAL.” [Please note that it does not say "Reporter" or "Press"]

    So, Jeff, I do think that, absent this information, your article, while correct, is incomplete and might well suggest that matters affecting the Country ought to be withheld from the press and the blogs, as the courts would attempt to overset this international accord – WHICH THEY ARE PROHIBITED IN LAW FROM DOING! I am sure it was not your intention, but that is how what you have said may be applied in practical terms by those readers who do NOT have a legal background.

    Jeff Cumberbatch responded:

    International law creates binding obligations only between states. In order for those principles to apply in our courts, legislation to that effect would have to be enacted. Note that they are cast in fairly general language.

    It seems to us that this is a matter which needs closure.


  3. @David,

    The question which needs to be answered is whether or not existing legislation will uphold all (or the relevant) provisions of the INTER-AMERICAN DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES ON FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION.


  4. Awright.. de next CJ should be imported… from England!


  5. @David. Let us pick a country with a long history of rule of law to illustrate the point. Let us pick the country whose common law (generally) subsists in the English-speaking world. The laws of England and Wales. Can we agree there?

    Okay. England and Wales are part of the European Community. The European Community is made up of countries most of whom operate under Roman Law (which is best known for the presumption that you are guilty until proven innocent and other such things that we would find unacceptable).

    When the member states get together and sign an accord, although the legislation of England and Wales may not meet the provisons of that accord, the courts in England and Wales will take it into account. BECAUSE, if they do not, then the Judicial Committee of the House of Lords is no longer the final court of appeal. It is the European Court of Justice and they will hand down a decision in accordance with the accord in question that will act as a precedent in the courts of England and Wales and thus enforce the accord over the laws of England and Wales. IT HAS HAPPENED MANY TIMES.

    Indeed, Cherie Booth Q.C., better known to the world as Mrs Tony Blair, has appeared before them many times while her husband was in office in matters of employment law in an adverse position to the prevailing legislation in England and Wales. Read the Times Law Reports, all you members of the legal fraternity – you do not have far to go – they are available at the library of the Supreme Court of Barbados.

    The same is true of us and our accords with fellow members of the OAS and other treaty organisations to which we are signatories.

    However, the basic truth is that for us not to follow a worldwide trend that ensures and promotes such a basic human right as freedom of expression, would be completely retrograde to our economy in terms of investments, tourism….the lot.

    One of the reasons investors come to Barbados is because since the 1630s we have a strong system of government and institutions that has NEVER been taken over. In our own recent experience we saw Sandiford go to a no confidence vote – he did not try to cling to power or to mobilize the military in a coup. He went quietly, with dignity and in accordance with law and the Constitution the moment Dame Nita, acting on her own authority as GG, dissolved parliament.

    Owen Arthur, for all his dictatorial and quasi-royal attitudes, never for a moment tried to flout the Constitution – he was voted out – and he went with dignity.

    As has, correctly, been pointed out, the American Declaration of Independence has whole chunks of it lifted from its predecessor by 100 years and more – the Barbados Treaty of Austins (now Oistins).

    In the Western Hemisphere, we ARE the cradle of democracy and freedom. It started HERE, in relation to the West. Not the States, not Canada, not South America or any of the other West Indian islands. It started in BARBADOS.

    So what message do you think it will send if we flout an international accord the terms of which are generally being adopted, if not always applied, worldwide?

    There are courts for these things. Currently, Barbados is being sued by a private individual under a Barbados/Canada bi-lateral trade agreement. The individual, a Barbados resident, is Peter Allard, a Canadian national. I am not going to discuss the merits of that case here. What I am going to point out is that you can be sure that the international community and big businesses and investors have noted that Mr Allard continues his residency in Barbados, secure in the historic knowledge of Barbados’ rule of law, without threat or attempt of threat to his person or assets.

    I go further, if Mr Donald Best (sole officer of Nelson Barbados Group Ltd)decided to foresake the joys of Asia and his Asian partner, where he has, incidentally, lived for some years PREDATING by some years his accusation that he was forced to move there in the last weeks, he too would find his rights and freedoms protected.

    There are many Barbadians who, without fuss and fanfare, exert tremendous influence to ensure that Barbados remains the crade of freedom of the Western Hemisphere. They are the silent, but overpowering, majority that no wannabe politician and no court can afford to ignore.

  6. jeff cumberbatch Avatar
    jeff cumberbatch

    @ Amused,

    The comparison of England’s enforcement of European Community Law and a requirement for us to enforce international law is not apposite. As I said before, under our dualist system, we are not required to enforce international law until a statute to the same effect has been enacted locally. England, on the other hand, is part of a Community which has agreed to enforce the directives etc. of the European Parliament. Much as we would be if CARICOM issued legislation.

    Note too, that it was Mr Sandiford who advised the dissolution of Parliament in 1994 and that Dame Nita did not do so of her own volition.

    Finally, even though we like to think so, the American Declaration of Independence did not in fact copy the Treaty of Oistins but, instead, sourced most of its provisions from the Magna Carta, which similarly influenced the local Treaty.


  7. In what way is the Democratic Labour Party is delivering on its commitment to the people of Barbados as outlines in our Manifesto “Pathways to Progress?”

    Has it implemented its 90 and 100 day promises?

    With over 5,000 losing their jobs since 2008 and with prices increasing by more than 12% locally, while at the very same time – commodity prices on the world market came down and given the fiscal crisis created by the DLP where current expenditure is exceeding curent revenue (cash-flow crisis) how could Barbados be on a “Pathway to Progress?”

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending