Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

Mia Mottley
Opposition Leader Mia Mottley (r)

This evening was the turn of the Leader of the Opposition Mia Mottley to respond to the budget. Like Prime Minister David Thompson, she is a bright young Barbadian who have committed to render to public service. Barbadians will desperately hope that under the leadership of these two young Barbadians our country will be able to steer a path to calm waters. We made the point in our previous blog, and it is worth repeating that the global economic turbulence will surely test our resilience as a people.

We were able to listen to much of what the Opposition Leader had to say this evening. No Barbadian will ever say that that she is not comfortable on the public stage. Here debating antics were as to be expected and we score her a ten. While we have a passing interest in some of her rebuttals, we will wait to hear the government side before we fully critique the budget presentation. However it seems that she has pinned the bulk of her argument on the decision that the government should fore go excise tax to buffer the shock of rising oil prices.

Many who have visited the BU and BFP in recent months would have surmised that the current state of the global economy, and the uncertainty of oil pricing have led to an unprecedented current state of affairs. In such a situation old modalities will not work. The challenge to sustain our nation will call for an awakening of every Barbadian to the fact that our current consumption behaviour which we have come to enjoy must of necessity change. Barbados for all it has achieved has failed to use our revered intellect to build out capacity in the economy to stop our reliance on tourism. We have also failed to enable the environment to build a strategy to achieve food security. Last but not least we have failed to enable the environment to grow alternate energy sources.

It is the view of the BU household that over the next two or three years, a bi-partisan approach maybe required to leverage against the knowledge and experience which is posited in the former government. If we accept that government is a continuum, then our country maybe disadvantaged by operating in the traditional partisan mode. So far in her reply Opposition Leader Mia Mottley has prosecuted with flair. But we feel in our gut that at this juncture in our history we need to hear a little more. The survival of our beautiful country depends on valued contributions from all members of our parliament.

So off we go to listen to the rest of the debate.


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

136 responses to “Opposition Leader Mia Mottley Responds To Budget 2008”


  1. My Gawd! What has happened to our former prime Minister!???

    He is on TV now taking part in the debate…. A shadow of himself.

    He turned up when George Payne departed.


  2. ha ha ha you see he Andrew he has changed! He cam’t castigate no body more!

  3. Getting it off my chest.... Avatar
    Getting it off my chest….

    This is so funny, all the party hacks are now bobbing and weaving to try to get away from the fact that they have suddenly been made to look like fools.

    They don’t want to post their assets so they obfuscate with notions about the formatting of the statement. They do not say anything about the salient point. THEY HAVE NOW LOST THE MORAL HIGH GROUND ON THE ISSUE OF POLITICIANS DECLARING THEIR ASSETS. In fact they are now on the defensive. As you can clearly see as they attempt to parse Mia’s statement on the matter, or find some loophole.

    Andrew? What do you want? The woman showed you exactly how government could reduce the price of gasolene and diesel immediately without impacting on government finances. She showed that they could have zero rated a wider basket of foods months ago, and the list goes on and on and on. Face your boy Davey is looking downright amateurish.

    David? This is not your finest hour on the blog. I’ll grant you the post was made before her speech was over, but your bias is showing. After MONTHS of campaigning for politicians to declare their assets, one of them does it and you immediately dismiss it as a gimmick???? You need to check yourself.

    What you also may have missed is that Mia has removed from Davey the ability to revalue the economy later in his term and say that it was due to his management. Sorry Davey! If you were holding that one back for the future you’ve missed that opportunity as well.

    More and more the DLP is being exposed as a bunch of bumbling amateurs who can only try to convince people how “bad” things were under the BLP as they send prices up and Bajans standard of living down.


  4. Pleaseeeeee they sending our standard of living down when they raped the treasury and rape health, rape the immigration policies rape people when they dont lie down for houses and etc.

    I had to get that off my chest!


  5. Andrew. Which debate were you listening to? I read all your posts and you are a stranger from the truth.


  6. I must say that the level of debate reach an unprecedented low with the presentation of the PM in waiting Freundel Stuart. Is this type of behaviour should come from an Attorney General and someone who act as Prime Minister. I feel all right thinking Barbadians regarding of political allegiance should reject this dismal performance by someone who should no better. David of BU what your feelings?


  7. TMY be scared, be very, very scared, I know I am.


  8. Tell me Why

    Stranger from the truth??

    Well she ent say nutting new.

    And you want to tell me that Michael Lashley didn’t show up Mia’s declaration of assets for the bogus document it was??
    Other bloggers observed it too (or are u only reading my comments)

    And u want to tell me that Owen looks his old vibrant self??

    Which one ent true??


  9. Andrew, you must not be living on the same planet that we are. There is currently no code for ITAL and asset declaration, so who is to say Mia is wrong? The Dlp surely can’t. She set the standard, they must now come better. The way I figure, all this partisan nonsense MUST be put aside, this is not a joke time, things are only to get worse. Mia did what was right ,but late,under the sircumstances, no DLP member can critisize what they have not done.


  10. Damm the budget lasted two days before its being changed? It hasn’t even been adopted as yet. This is either the most responsive gov’t ever or one of the most confuse in the planning.


  11. No one is perfect and it takes a big man to make changes and admit that he was wrong.

    Mr. Arthur never did that he cussed every body!


  12. Hello!
    I am a lady of 22, I found you hear and picked interest in you.
    My name is Joy .I wish to be in love relationship with you
    and may be discover ourselves as real partners for life. Please send your email address in my inbox ;; And not site please
    With this email adderss( joy200muoka@yahoo.com )
    Thanks from my heart;
    Yours in love,
    Joy.


  13. Well, well, well. Mia was the only one with enough balls to declare her assets.

    It is not a criminal offense for Bajans to hold assets overseas. How can it be when every PM goes overseas asking the diaspora to invest in Barbados. So you mean to say that my Bajan sister in New York can hold assets there but I cannot?


  14. Sorry I meant testicular fortitude.


  15. I am usually told by my parents that I do not pay enough attention to the political process. As such I forced myself to watch the “Reply to Budgetary Proposals” broadcast on CBC channel at 1:30 pm Wednesday July 9. The parliamentarian who had the floor at the time was Mr George Payne who happens to be my constituency representative. Mr Payne’s televised contribution to the proceedings was accompanied by frequent outburst of laughter coming from other parliamentarians. The member of the house seated next to Payne subsequently fell asleep with his face propped in is hands. The speaker of the house asked Mr Payne to refrain from incorrectly addressing the Prime Minister without using the term “ honourable”. After which Mr Payne continued to refer to the prime minister as he saw fit.
    I gathered from the reactions of the other parliamentarians and the speaker that these occurrences are common place in the house of assembly. However I found it quite appalling that the members of the Parliament the leaders of our nation could not find the dignity and self respect required to conduct themselves like the educated and refined persons they portray themselves to be. What kind of example are parliamentarians setting for the populous when the ignore directives from the speaker? When they cannot give one another the common courtesy of maintain consciousness during the National Budget. I was in the Barbados Cadet Corps before I left Queen’s College and one of the things I learned from the Corps was to fix your own house before you fix others. I wonder how the parliamentarians plan to maintain our great nation in a state of prosperity when they cannot maintain a professional atmosphere in the house. I think each politician in this country needs to approach our political proceedings with more reverence and respect if they truly intend to assist our nation or inspire any level of respect from the younger Barbadians looking on.


  16. Freundel staurt was his masterful self.

    David thompson hit all the right notes and showed his desire to be responsive to the people by adressing the concerns of the new rental drivers fee.

    He asnwered the queries raised by the leader of the opposition unlike owen arthur’s approch which was to ignore these questions – and all this was done without slander and inneundo.

    Actually listening to the contributions of the DLP members which were all good to my mind – at least the ones I heard – it displayed to me a determination by the DLP to return barbados once again to the moral center.


  17. Anonymous after the way Freundel Stuart (mainly) and the other barnyard animals from the DLP behaved so help us all. It really saddened me how despicable they behaved. I shudder to think that Freundel Stuart of all people is actually the AG/Acting PM. Shame on it all


  18. Redds, some persons on both size represented their constituencies and themselves well. Stop being buyous and lets deal with the truth (for a change).


  19. REDDS was Mia ever AG/DEP PM of this country? Man you can’t compare the two.


  20. I never saw a debate before until this week, but Freundel Stuart left a lot to be desired, not just him Estwick also two animals if ever I seen some. I am making no excuses can you honestly defend these two actions. I don’t want it to be an indictment on the voters but I would be ashamed if I lived in their constituencies and help them get to parliament. It amazes me that they all stand up and thank their constituents for sending them to parliament but to have to behave so, I would be shaking my head, what does it say about the constituents.


  21. Like it or not estwick and stuart were EXCELLENT!

    Even the Bs at work talking about them why are you being so partisan!

    I thought the Bs had their highlights as well; Du good do bad; Owen was subdued but for me it was a statesman speech.

    But he has aged dramatically!

    However, I waas very impressed with most of the debators.


  22. LIKE IT OR NOT

    THIS IS NOT A BUDGET

    THIS IS A MUGGET

    BARBADOS HAS BEEN MUGGED BY A BANDELERO

  23. Someone said the 'BLP Stalwart' Avatar
    Someone said the ‘BLP Stalwart’

    It is clear to me that Mia’s approach is practical and at the same time sensitive to the challenges facing Barbados. On the same note, I feel a bit reserved in saying that the DLP leadership is not one of inspiration but one of IMF dogma. Who will protect us as citizens from the excessive of taxation? David clearly shows that he does not think in terms of alternatives. I have one clear choice and it has not only been demonstrated in her response to this thing called a 2008 budget, it has been manifested in every arena of public service for which the good lady commits herself. It is time P.M. Thompson learns that he must think out of the box because in a real sense, Barbadians will need a visionary leader who can inspire. The honeymoon is over.


  24. two thirds majority two thirds majority we gine win by two thirds majority!

    You remember those words up UWI (a student) wa slistening hmmmmmmmm


  25. Chris Halsall

    The Debate will be published in the Gazette sometime soon, if you know someone who works in a government dept. ask them for a copy.


  26. @queen.

    Thank you. Deeply.

    So, there is such a thing as the Gazette in Barbados. And, according to yourself, such a publication is available to anyone who works in a government dept, or who has the privilege of knowing someone who works therein…

    So, pray tell… What about those who *don’t* work in a government dept., or knows anyone therein? Is this a document available to the public? And what exactly is meant by “soon”?

    Please note that a Google search for “Barbados Gazette” reveals that the first publishers of such a document were David Harry and Samuel Keimer in 1731. And that our Constitution (Chapter 3) refers to such a publication…

    Please forgive me for this, but I am finding a serious disconnect here….

    Is our public information easily available to us? Or is it not? (Sadly, this is a rhetorical question….)


  27. @Chris

    The Gazette is available to any member of the public from the government printery, for a fee od course.


  28. @David.

    I know this, of course (why do you think I asked about it?). (Hint: ask questions to which you know the answers…)

    And, truth be told, there is a great deal of other critical information which is only available (for a fee), if one knows what to ask for. Including (for example) our statutory instruments (SIs), our census results, our spectrum allocation and our telephony numbering allocation, et al…

    What I find most interesting is that even the availably of this information (for a fee) is not generally known to most.

    And, of course, even if one knows of the information being available (in paper-only form, of course), its access generally involves a human physically going to the office involved to pay for, and retrieve, said information (on sheets of dead trees!!!)…

    If Barbados is serious about Transparency, it might consider making available to *everyone*, via this wonderful thing called the Internet, the information which might be of interest to *anyone* and *everyone*.


  29. Chris,

    It is a fact the Gazette is not really known of except in the public sector. Every dept. in govt receives them at least twice a month. They contain info such as who was appointed in govt, who has retired, who was granted a licence to sell liquor, who has been granted work permits, a report of what took place in parliament, etc. I must say it calls for interesting reading but I do not know why it is not readily available to the public or why the govt Printing dept or even GIS does not inform the public about it. but that being said, some civil servants don’t even see it either, even tho they should have access to it.


  30. @queen: Thank you for this.

    IMHO, we live in a country, and a region, where people are discouraged from asking questions. Ignorance is the expected; the nominal; the easy to manage…

    And our governments do nothing to encourage anything different. Gods forbid they make information easily available… As an alternative example, it is the enforced policy of the USA that *any* data or information generated with public funds are made (easily) available to the public. “Easily” now means Internet accessible.

    This example of the Gazette is a perfect demonstration. This is a critical publication, and yet very few know about it, let alone have access to it, let alone read it…

    If I may, there are things known as Statutory Instruments. These are often used by a government to apply deltas (read: changes) to their laws. And yet, our SIs are not readily available to the public unless you know to ask for them. (And show up in person, wait a great deal of time, pay some amount of money, and receive the information on *paper*!)

    Therefore, one may be able to download from the Internet the Laws of Barbados, but without access to the relevant SIs, a full understanding of same cannot be reached.

    Personally, I’m a very empirical kind of person. I listen very closely to everything I’m told, but then I tend to run sanity checks. Let me please present a couple now:

    http://www.google.com/search?q=barbados+queen's+printer
    http://www.google.com/search?q=Barbados+Government+Printing+Office
    http://www.google.com/search?q=Barbados+“Statutory+Instrument”

    Again, personally, I consider Google to be a serious test. If you can’t find information desired via Google, then it likely doesn’t exist.

    I would like to thusly argue the following: we, the people of Barbados, do not know our own laws.

    And if we don’t, then how can we expect anyone outside our shores to be able to determine same, and, by deduction, have confidence in investing herein?

    Namaste All


  31. Sigh… This is why I hate CMSs which don’t present a “Preview” button along side the “Submit” button…

    WRT my immediate above, please Google for:

    Barbados Queen’s Printer
    Barbados Government Printing Office
    Barbados “Statutory Instrument”

    Also note, in the Geek: s/couple/few/


  32. I not sure what was there to be impressed buy with the Opposition Leaders Political Gimicktry stunt she use as a budget reply… Barbadians really deserve better and thats the truth..


  33. I thought the Budget was fair, balanced and redistributive in nature. It showed that there is a keen difference between the two parties.

    I thought Mia Mottley’s reply was weak in that it rambled and was unstructured.

    I am not offended by people like Redd. They are there for five years and, like it or not, Barbados has a great leader.


  34. Blogs are great for getting people’s ideas and thoughts across, no matter what. So if someone wants to comment on Mia’s or anyone else’s appearance so be it. These people want to become prime minister and will have to represent the country on the international stage if they succeed. I should make it clear that like most younger Bajans, I do not have an affinity to a particular party. I will always vote for the person I think will do the better job. If said person proves me wrong, I have no qualms in voting them out. I have read the PM’s entire budget and although I am no expert, I was impressed. If the DLP deliver 1/2 of the measures in the budget during their term in office…props to them, they’d have done a good job. Barbados cannot sit by and do business as usual. Our main earner tourism, while apparently growing, is doing so at a much less fast rate as some of our competitors like St. Lucia, Cuba etc. Our attitude that this is the sweetest 166 square miles on earth has meant that we have rested on our laurels and been content with what we have, without making radical changes in the way we do things to make the country a better place for everyone. Dont get me wrong, I love bim, but I also think that we have nowhere realised our potential and can be so much better. I think the DLP have shaken things up which is exactly what we need. I am now, for the time being a DLP supporter, but the DLP should be aware that the minute the cracks, stupid mistakes, lies and thievery begin (if it does) I will switch my vote faster than the flyovers get ban!! I encourage everyone out there to do the same.

  35. Wishing In Vain Avatar
    Wishing In Vain

    KC my compliments to you for a very mature approach to your politics.

    Like you I to am very aware of the need to keep this country honest and on the right track, we were shown the worst display of what gross corruption and arrogance could lead a great country.

    We are working hard on getting it back on track with every effort to cut out stealing in Gov’t as was the program under the rule of the blp.

  36. Wishing In Vain Avatar
    Wishing In Vain

    We are now 189 Days into the DLP running the affairs of this country but yet the blp are still living in the past and have not yet come to grips that the were kicked out of office on the 15 th Jan 2008.

    For had they been aware of that fact I hardly think that on the 22 nd July and 189 days forward their website would still be so dated with the nonsense as below.

    Cabinet
    The Rt. Hon. Owen S. Arthur, M.P.
    Prime Minister
    Minister of Finance and Economic Affairs
    Minister for the Civil Service and Culture

    The Hon. Mia A. Mottley, M.P.
    Deputy Prime Minister
    Minister of Economic Affairs and Development

    The Hon. Dame Billie A. Miller, M.P.
    Senior Minister
    Minister of Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade

    The Hon. Kerrie Symmonds, M.P.
    Minister of State in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade

    The Hon. Noel Lynch, M.P.
    Minister of Tourism and International Transport

    Senator The Hon. Erskine Griffith, G.C.M, J.P.
    Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development

    The Hon. Gline A. Clarke J.P., M.P.
    Minister of Public Works

    The Hon. Reginald Farley, M.P.
    Minister of Housing, Lands

    The Hon. Cynthia Forde, M.P.
    Minister of State in the Ministry of Education, Youth Affairs & Sports

    The Hon. Elizabeth Thompson, M.P.
    Minister of Energy and the Environment

    The Hon. Rawle C. Eastmond, J.P. M.P.
    Minister of Labour and Social Security

    The Hon. Dr. Jerome Walcott, M.P.
    Minister of Health

    The Hon. Trevor Prescod, M.P
    Minister of Social Transformation

    The Hon. Anthony P. Wood, M.P.
    Minister of Education, Youth Affairs & Sports

    The Hon. Dale Marshall, M.P.
    Attorney General & Minister of Home Affairs

    Senator The Hon. Lynette Eastmond
    Minister of Commerce, Consumer Affairs and Business Development

    Rev. The Hon. Joseph Atherley JP MP
    Minister of State, Prime Minister’s Office

    The Hon. Clyde A. Mascoll, M.P.
    Minister of State, Ministry of Finance

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading