Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

I recently spent a week in Belize and was distressed to observe that the contagion affecting other CARICOM countries has spread there. It seems no CARICOM country was spared from someone’s harmful agenda.

When I arrived in Belize and the immigration officer saw my Barbados passport, he said enthusiastically, “Welcome Home.” He then explained that I could work in Belize and stay as long as I wished. I have worked in almost every Caribbean country and normally had to explain to immigration officers the work I was planning to do. Not in Belize. I felt welcomed and every interaction I had with Belizeans was pleasant.

THE GOOD.

Barbados, Belize, Dominica, and St. Vincent and the Grenadines passed a Caribbean Community (Free Movement of Nationals) Act allowing citizens of those countries to live, work, vote and access educational, health and other services in each other’s countries from 1st October 2025.

Belize has a population of approximately 430,000 with a land area of approximately 8,867 square miles, which is over 50 times the size of Barbados. Our currencies have the same value: BD$1 = BZ$1 and we both speak English. It seems like a good fit. Thank-you Prime Minister Mottley.

THE BAD.

Despite this praiseworthy initial step, we need to carefully analyse foreseen consequences if we plan to expand this initiative. What is our plan if we extend it to Haiti with its 12 million population. If only 10% of them choose to relocate to Barbados, that is 1.2 million people. They would automatically become the majority and form whatever Government they wished – since they can vote.

Given the Government’s established precedent of: (i) confiscating private property, (ii) changing our laws to make that confiscation legal and (iii) unilaterally passing laws with no public discussion, a Haitian administration can justify doing the same.

THE UGLY.

The Haitians will likely support a political party that promises to: (i) transfer most crown land to the new immigrants on compassionate grounds, (ii) make the official language of Barbados the language of the majority – which would be French and (iii) make being proficient in French mandatory for working for the Government or applying for Government contracts. Have we thought this through with any rigour? We did not.

The meaningless speeches in the House of Assembly and Senate did not carefully analyse the bill. Instead, the speeches suggest aims of: (i) blindly passing the legislation quickly and (ii) accusing anyone requesting a careful analysis of the bill of being xenophobic. So, it passed quickly – evidencing the effectiveness of compliance through fear-of-attracting-a-slur. But back to the contagion.

THE CONTAGION.

I visited major lumber stores in Belize and found the highest grade of Southern Yellow Pine (SYP) being No.2, which should not be used on roofs due to multiple knots being in the same transverse plane – which are known breaking locations when timber is bent. Further, no timber pressure-treated against termites was found. Therefore, a hurricane is foreseen to result in unnecessary catastrophic damage – by someone’s design.

Unlike Barbados, Belizeans seem willing to improve their construction quality. Their willingness to improve touched me and I plan to assist them. While writing this, Venezuela was impacted by an earthquake. Multistorey buildings collapsed. Who is checking Barbadian: houses, schools, offices, hotels and stadiums to confirm that they are structurally stable before they are built? No one.

SACRIFICES.

We are the most backward Caribbean country in this regard. Whether intentionally or not, we are following someone’s script to ensure that a major hurricane or earthquake is catastrophic in Barbados. Almost every house and school in Barbados with a concrete floor or roof is unnecessarily vulnerable to collapse in an earthquake – when the cost to have prevented such an occurrence before construction was zero.

We are now so dead to this issue that we are willing to sacrifice our: families, friends, neighbours, employees, students and their teachers so that we can apathetically do nothing. The measure of our apathy is now at a certified lunatic level – but we do not seem to care.

Grenville Phillips II is a Doctor of Engineering and Chartered Structural Engineer. He can be reached at NextParty246@gmail.com


Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

15 responses to “Welcome Home”


  1. We will wait until the crisis occurs. We are a reactionary people, including our governments.

  2. Andrea Duguid Avatar

    The legislation has already passed. From what you have shared, we urgently need thorough impact assessments, enforceable migration safeguards, prompt implementation,regulation and enforcement of building codes, and open, non‑xenophobic, non-political public debate, scrutiny and transparency. I doubt that will happen. Egos were too big to accept pushback on deficiencies and in their haste to fulfill whatever their agendas were.


  3. @Andrea Duguid

    It won’t happen based on our historical past, but we must try to make it happen.

  4. Terence Blackett Avatar
    Terence Blackett

    I HAVE SUCH PROFOUND ADMIRATION & RESPECT FOR DR PHILLIPS, ALTHOUGH I DO NOT KNOW HIM PERSONALLY & HAVE ONLY BEEN BLESSED BY HIS PRESCIENT WISDOM & SIMPLE TOUCHES OF GRACE, MELLOWED BY HIS UNIMPEACHABLE PATRIOTISM & LOVE FOR THE SONS & DAUGHTERS OF OUR PEOPLE – IT IS HARD TO IGNORE HIS WARNINGS

    Let me not get all cushy, soft & emotional about what can only be described as a condition that has reached a point of possibly no return…

    Dr. Phillips embodies a Caribbean paradox…

    He is indeed a very deeply patriotic citizen who is scathingly critical of his country’s governance…

    He wants the Caribbean region 2 succeed, which is precisely why he warns so stridently against its failures…

    His challenge to all of us is to choose between comfortable, apathetic silence & difficult, uncomfortable action!!!

    He has made his choice…

    His work demands that we make ours – NOW!!!

    Permit me a mo’ to “UNPACK” the “GOOD”, “BAD” & “UGLY” – for this hits me just as hard as it does him!!!

    Let us begin

    Dr. Phillips’ latest piece, “WELCOME HOME”, is a characteristically sharp and unsettling challenge.

    He uses a personal, positive experience of Caribbean “UNITY” as a springboard to launch a two-pronged warning –

    (1) about the unexamined consequences of free movement

    (2) the other about the persistent, fatal negligence in building safety

    His challenge to all of us in the Caribbean is to wake up from apathy and confront these systemic failures before catastrophe forces us to.

    Dr. Phillips frames his argument using the “STRUCTURE” of a classic warning tale – The GOOD*, The BAD* and The UGLY*!

    The Good (The Invitation) –

    He begins with the genuinely positive experience of being welcomed to Belize as a fellow “CARICOM” citizen, thanks to the recent Free Movement Act.

    He acknowledges this as a praiseworthy step toward regional integration, crediting the MOTTLEY-CREW GOV*!

    The Bad (The Unseen Consequences) –

    He immediately pivots to a strategic blind spot.

    He poses a provocative hypothetical question, what if free movement is extended to Haiti (population of some 12 million souls); what happens if even 10% relocate to Barbados (population with some 280,000)?

    Answer: They would become the voting majority!

    He then points to a precedent he sees as established, government actions like confiscating private property and passing laws without public discussion, and suggests a future Haitian-Majority GOV* could use the same geopolitical tools!

    The Ugly (The Core Challenge) –

    His warning is not about nationality itself, but about institutional and regulatory collapse.

    He argues that a future government, of any composition, could in principal –

    (1) Transfer crown land to new immigrant groups.

    (2) Change the official language.

    (3) Mandate language proficiency for government work.

    His challenge is simple, “Have we thought this through with any rigour? We did not”!

    He criticizes the political process for rushing the legislation and silencing debate with accusations of xenophobia.

    For him, this pattern of unaccountable decision-making is the real “contagion”!

    Dr Phillip’s new warning is directly connected to his previous articles.

    He returns to his central, forensic critique – “Being Set-up to Fail” (Building codes ignored)!

    He observes the same construction failures (untreated, low-grade timber) in Belize.

    This confirms his fear that the problem is regional, not just national, and part of a wider “harmful agenda”!

    Also, “Draining the Cup of MADNESS*” (Trading construction for a creative economy).

    He implies that the same apathy and lack of rigorous analysis that led to poor economic strategy – now extends to migration policy and building safety!

    The core challenge to CARICOM* that he is explicitly asking –

    (1) Who is checking?

    “Who is checking Barbadian, houses, schools, offices, hotels and stadiums to confirm that they are structurally stable before they are built”?

    ANSWER: “No one.”

    (2) What are we willing to sacrifice?

    He states we are at a “CERTIFIED LUNATIC LEVEL” of apathy, willing to sacrifice families, students, and entire communities to “DO NOTHING”!

    (3) Are we following a script?

    He suggests we are “following someone’s script to ensure that a major hurricane or earthquake is catastrophic”!

    Dr. Phillips is performing a crucial, if uncomfortable, service.

    He is forcing a conversation that many would prefer to avoid.

    The “MIGRATION QUESTION” is a “RED HERRING” (and a Test)!

    His Haiti hypothetical is deliberately extreme!

    Its purpose is not to predict the future, but to expose the absence of strategic foresight – in the current governance of the “MOTTLEY-CREW GOV*”!

    He is using it as a stress test to prove his point about systemic recklessness.

    The fact that it provokes discomfort is, for him, evidence that the test is working.

    The “BUILDING CODE CRISIS” is the core issue!

    His expertise is in structural engineering, and this remains his most damning and irrefutable point.

    A state that does not ensure the basic safety of its built environment has failed its most fundamental duty of care.

    This is not about culture or economics; it is about life and death!

    His challenge is to make this a public priority.

    The “PATTERN OF UNACCOUNTABILITY” across all his articles, Dr. Phillips diagnoses a consistent failure of decision-making without rigorous analysis, public debate, and/or oversight!

    The “CONTAGION”” he fears is not Haitian immigration; it is this culture of willful ignorance and complacency that he believes has infected the entire region!

    If I were to accept his challenge and respond, (AS DR PHILLIPS KNOWS THAT I DO NOT SPARE MY FINGERTIPS) it would be to say the following –

    “My dear brother, you are right to sound the alarm!

    The risks you identify, in building safety and in unexamined policy – are existential!

    Your challenge forces us to look at the difference between performative governance and actual governance!

    However, your engineering mind sometimes treats policy as if it were a structural load, where the forces are predictable and the outcome is certain!

    “FORGIVE ME”!

    Politics and migration are messier, driven by human behavior, international relations, and unforeseen variables – areas for which you are not absent-minded to!

    The solution to the Haitian hypothetical is not to close borders, but to build robust institutions, including transparent impact assessments, independent oversight, and enforceable safeguards, that would make any future government, of any composition – accountable to the same high standards.

    Your real challenge to us is not about fearing a Haitian-majority government.

    It is about demanding that our current government, and all future ones, demonstrate the rigour, transparency, and care that you, as an engineer, know is the only way to build something that lasts.

    And finally, the “WELCOME HOME” you received in Belize was genuine.

    Our job is to build a home, across the region, that is safe, well-governed, and ready for all its children – whether they were born there or arrive tomorrow!

    On that ontological consonant note

    Semper Fidelis


  5. ANYBODY WHO COULD BE ALWAYS SO EFFUSIVE WITH PRAISE FOR ANYONE MUST BE OF NECESSITY A BORN C*NT.


  6. Substantively!

    The writer has not spent enough time in Belize to be expected to truly understood the nature of the country.

    We are quite sure that given his known tendencies that his judgements would have been markedly different as a result of longer lived experience.

    His is the impression one would best associate with a tourist.

    We dare say that all of his impressions about all other countries mentioned, except Barbados, cannot therefore qualify for the kinds of analyses presumed.

    With regret, they best qualify as the perceptions best known to the board of tourism.


  7. For clarity. The Caribbean is my market where I have worked for the past 35 years. I have rarely travelled as a tourist. My work assignments have normally been weeks to up to about 2 years in a country.


  8. @ de bad

    “What is our plan if we extend it to Haiti with its 12 million population? If only 10% of them choose to relocate to Barbados, that is 1.2 million people. They would automatically become the majority and form whatever government they wished – since they can vote.”

    ******
    Haiti is a full member of the Caribbean Community (CARICOM). It was admitted as the 15th member state on July 2, 2002, and is also recognised as a member of the CARICOM Single Market and Economy (CSME).

    The initial four-nation launch is viewed by CARICOM leaders as a blueprint. Prime Minister of Dominica Roosevelt Skerrit, along with other leaders, has stated their goal for all remaining CARICOM member states to join this historic step in the near future. Further regional expansion depends on individual nations adapting their legislative frameworks. However, expanding the agreement region-wide takes time.

    Other CARICOM nations, such as Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago, have cited internal constraints and legislative processes that have slowed their ability to immediately adopt the full free movement protocol.

    Can this organisation be selective without being biased ?


  9. Grenville Phillips.

    Take your back off de wall, it’s non-essential.


  10. Well, in the case of Belize you suggested that English was the spoken language, that you were warmly “welcomed home”. And in these are the principal locations where our critique was aimed.

    Yes, the official language of Belize is English, very true. But once you’ve been in Belize for a longer period of time you’ll find out that that is unrepresentative of the deeper truth.

    That truism is that the majority of people in Belize are bilingual. Indeed, if we had to make an unscientific guess we’ll have to say Spanish is as pervasise, if not more than, English. Indeed, a lot of the Spanish speakers know no English at all. Never spoke a word in English.

    Belize has México, to the north and Guatemala, to the west and south. These are vastly larger countries and at least as a linguistic consideration the cultural interactions would never suggest that the national language is as straight laced as suggested.

    There’s nobody in parliament, for instance, who is not bulingual. The PM addresses the country in both languages. Because of the reletively small population and large landmass viz a viz Barbados one can easily find Belizeans from all of the Spanish speaking countries in the Hemisphere. Belizeans could travel to neigbouring countries without a passport.

    The percieved warmth of your welcome is not uncommon to who most Belizeans are. outwardly, or surface level deep, no worse than Bajans, we’ll imagine. However, one cannot see that greeting as a measure of the deeper attitudes of Belizeans.

    For instance, if one was familiar with the murder rate, the brutality of murders, levels of cultural ruthlessness daily enacted, the clientslism endemic in politics and economics, and on and on, that perceived “welcome home” you got might have been better interpreted and understood.

    Radika Desea has argued that globalization has ended. And if she is right, like weee suspect she is, then one has to worry about the ability of CSME’s free movement of people regime to last beyond the epoch which birthed it in the first place.

    The last words are all yours!


  11. Radhika Desai!


  12. When I heard Belize was a country in the list for free movement with no requirement for documentation it was worrying.

    How many Bajans know that Belize has over 40 active gangs operating mainly in the Southside of the country? They model their activities like the U.S gangs, mainly around the drug trade and arms smuggling The two big ones are the George Street Bloods and the Ghost Town Crips. These guys make what we call gangs look like beginners. Yet we allow persons from Belize to enter here with their hands swinging and their passport. At the very least we should be asking ALL coming here for a Certificate Of Character from their police.

    Now that we are talking free movement, how many of the 15000 who have come here under this agreement, have found legal work and registered with the NISSS which was a condition of entry. No matter how many people ask for this information it is not forthcoming. Finally what legislation is in the agreement to repatriate persons who have not found legal work and registered with the NISSS, after a period say of six months? Again I expect a deafening silence as a reply.


  13. Keep up the good work @grenville.


  14. I was there for one week this last time. I have worked there before.

    The people speak formal English, a dialect of English like us and Spanish. I did not need to converse in Spanish or their dialect since we both understood standard English.

    There are gangs in almost every country – I did not go to do business with gangs.


  15. I do not agree with this decision. Our country and our population is so small that the impact could change the country almost overnight. I was more for the earlier arrangement that afforded more control over who exactly enters the island. Dominica and St. Vincent don’t pose a problem for me, but Belize is another story.

    Grenville is missing the point about the gangs. Every country has gangs. But some are more brutal than others. Some shoot the rival gang members dead, whereas some wipe out the whole family. Some kill quickly and mercifully. Others kill slowly and torturously.

    Ours mostly limit the warfare to rival soldiers and tend to kill quickly. Those who are not imvolved only have to fear stray bullets.

    I know which ones I’d rather deal with.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading