One of the valid talking points to come out of Ralph Thorne crossing the floor is the opportunity it presents to strengthen the Democratic Labour Party (DLP), especially post 2018. The blogmaster has been mulling over the extent Prime Minister Mia Mottley is partly responsible for compromising the parliamentary system of Barbados and in the process good governance of the country.

Joseph Atherley like Thorne crossed the floor in 2018 to occupy the position of leader of the opposition lamented then that his political party was not given access to a subvention of $150,000 to assist political parties. In the case of Ralph Thorne there can be no denying that the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) – under whose banter he represented – contested the last general election. Should he be accepted as a member of the DLP, notwithstanding the unnecessary protracted process, the subvention should be released to the DLP.

The blogmaster is willing to wager when the late Prime Minister Owen Arthur supported the creation of the subvention, he did not in his widest imagination envisaged a member of the duopoly incapable of winning a single seat contested, in not one but two general elections. The question has been asked of Prime Minister Mia Mottley several times to the effect – in light of the peculiar circumstances that have led to the good governance framework of Barbados being compromised, why not cut the DLP and any other political party meeting a predetermined criteria some slack to be able to access the subvention.

Barbados finds itself in a very odd and strange place, a government with all the seats. On paper, a supposedly talented Cabinet; constant, almost 24-hour hyper communication from government and like Poonka and he donkey – all over the place. Yet an animal farm mentality pervades throughout the government using media to control the story, while the actual results are meagre. All the results bragged about, debt restructuring has come back to haunt us in the very ways that some have warned

DLP President Gives Gov’t Failing Grade For Good Governance

it is no secret because the Barbados Labour Party (BLP) won all 30 seats in 2018 and 2022 it compromised the working of our parliamentary system. Atherley tried his best to breath life into the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) and it must be stated his two selections – Chrystal Drakes and Caswell Franklyn – to the Senate performed above expectations. However, after he lost his deposit in 2022 the BLP has been making it up as things happen. Since then committees of parliament integral to a living breathing democracy has been in the ‘intensive care unit’. Civic minded Barbadians should not be happy about the continuing state of affairs.

While our esteemed globe trotting Prime Minister has been accumulating the accolades in the international arena, a not fit for purpose governance model continues to expose Barbados. Exposed because it forces political parties, including the DLP, to become more dependent than already is the case on donors in the private sector to finance political operations. Mottley has always had the authority to amend the rule that could make the subvention available but ‘Bigworks’ has been a naughty lady.

This is a from the heart appeal to Prime Minister Mia Mottley to make the subvention available in some form to political parties. What is a democracy without dissent? What do you want your legacy to read Prime Minister? Is it enough to include in your memoirs you defeated a porakey DLP party twice at the polls? That you borrowed heavily from the IMF and IDB to stabilize the economy? How about if the pages also read that in an attempt to avert a constitutional crisis and fix a hobbled parliamentary system, you in all magnanimity addressed the issue of financing for political parties. Prime Minister every other words uttered from your mouth are good governance and transparency. Time to support the talk with meaningful action.

Good governance with good intentions is the hallmark of our government. Implementation with integrity is our core passion.

Narendra Modi

20 responses to “Mottley maybe choking political opposition”

  1. Terence M Blackett Avatar
    Terence M Blackett

    @David

    Great piece especially as cited in the introductory paragraph where you opined with verbose candour: “A not fit for purpose governance model continues to expose Barbados…”

    In a day & age where political expediency, honest debate & unapologetic transparency should be the hallmark of a just society – exposed in plain view are the “MAFIA TACTICS” of those who are in charge…

    I do not care who sings whose praises – Barbados is in a right ‘ole “MESS” with “CORRUPTION” in every facet of the institutions of the nation!!!

    #CapitalismIsDEAD*!!!

  2. Terence M Blackett Avatar
    Terence M Blackett

    THE MOTTLEY CREW WHO RUN BARBADOS IS APTLY DESCRIBED IN THIS TRINIDAD & TOBAGO #Kaiso:

    #SnakesInTheBalizay

  3. Terence M Blackett Avatar
    Terence M Blackett

    I am frankly “EXHAUSTED” by these “GASLIGHTING”, “DOGWHISTLING” #PoLIEticians who have forgotten that “CHARITY BEGINS AT HOME” – FOR YOU CANNOT CLEAN SOMEBODY’S ELSE BACKYARD WHEN YOURS FULL OF CRAP”…

    I have little to #NO_RESPECT for these #DirtyBasterds (HERE) or anywhere else for that matter…

    They are “MASCOTS”, “CHIMPANZEES IN MONKEY SUITS” putting a show for their “WHITE ELITE MASTERS & OVERLORD AUDIENCES”!!!

    The Barbados #MottleyCrew are just another “BUNCH OF DOZY MASCOTS” playing to the public gallery!!!

    I am not the only one who thinks this:


  4. @TB

    Politicians come from among us, we create them just like we do the zr culture. It is probably more about how the people usurp its role in the absence of leadership.


  5. DLP’s new role now is to concentrate on becoming credible and strong opposition.
    The Government provides them ammunition every time they sell the public short.
    Tax money should be spent providing services to the public and not servicing Government debt.


  6. Is this the same TB?
    Getting a different reading from what I have seen here for years.


  7. Ms. Mockley just took advantage of the corruption that has existed in Barbados post independence which has stifled opposition.

    If it wasn’t her it would have been another.

    If there was any fight left in the “opposition” it would have raised hell over the 30-0 nullity.

    It hasn’t.

    Ralf Thorne is just another Reverent Joe, a waste of time.

    Barbados is dead politically, a few zombies and blood suckers walking about is all that is left!!


  8. The mere fact that the Democratic Labour Party still remains relevant after two comprehensive and brutal defeats, is a testimony to the entrenched and apparently irremovable dominance of the BLPDLP in our political culture.
    Even their most severe critics must admit that they are now more institutions than political parties.
    There is a lot of intellectual foolery surrounding the latest squabble in this BLPDLP family.
    Both Thorne and Mia are the products of these institutions. Mottley , Thompson and the rest remind clear thinking people of Napoleon’s puppies on Animal Farm, raised to be pit bulls in a decaying political country.
    Thorne is exactly where his political broughtupcy wants him and where he wants to be. The same can be applied to Mia.It’s bordering on the laughable to read and observe the partisan antics regarding this latest family squabble.
    All that has happened here is that a family member was in some trouble and another family member bailed them out.
    All is well in the family.


  9. BE CALM JOHN
    FEAR NOT
    EVERYTHING IS PROGRESSING BACKWARDS IN BIMSHIRE AND EVERYWHERE ELSE
    EVERYTHING IS PROGRESSING BACKWARDS TO CHAOS AND CONFUSION UNIVERSALLY
    WE ARE NOW IN THE LAST DAYS OF THE LAST DAYS IN PREPARATION FOR THE RISE OF THE ANTICHRIST, THE IMPOSTOR WHO WILL COME PROMISING TO SOLVE ALL THE PROBLEMS OF THE WORLD.

    WE HAVE NOW ENTERED THE STADIUM FOR THE LAST LAP


  10. The quest for a narrative that will resonate continues. Y’all ain’t gine like the outcome. Strap in or down.


  11. @Enuff

    You resorting to intimidation ?


  12. Should have read : in a politically decaying culture. Not country. Thanks.


  13. GP
    February 20, 2024 at 9:08 am
    2 Votes

    BE CALM JOHN
    FEAR NOT
    EVERYTHING IS PROGRESSING BACKWARDS IN BIMSHIRE AND EVERYWHERE ELSE
    EVERYTHING IS PROGRESSING BACKWARDS TO CHAOS AND CONFUSION UNIVERSALLY
    WE ARE NOW IN THE LAST DAYS OF THE LAST DAYS IN PREPARATION FOR THE RISE OF THE ANTICHRIST, THE IMPOSTOR WHO WILL COME PROMISING TO SOLVE ALL THE PROBLEMS OF THE WORLD.

    WE HAVE NOW ENTERED THE STADIUM FOR THE LAST LAP

    ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    I know GP, I know!!

    But you can’t grudge me a little sport.

  14. Terence M Blackett Avatar
    Terence M Blackett

    @David

    “Politicians come from among us, we create them just like we do the zr culture. It is probably more about how the people usurp a role in the absence of leadership…”

    “MADE IN BARBADOS” – “RADICALIZED IN MASSA’S BRUTISH HOUSE”…

    All 4 one & God 4 all…

    #Classic

    Staying silent about “EVIL”, is “EVIL”!!!

    Doing “NOTHING” about #Evil_Is_Suicide!!!

    While dancing on the head of a needle – the “MASSES” plant their hopes that a “CHANGE WILL COME” but hopes are “CRASHED” & apathy seeps in!!!

    The never-ending cycle of “SOUL DESTRUCTION” & moral fragmentation!!!

    #EinsteinianScience: “DOING THE SAME ‘OLE, SAME ‘OLE & EXPECTING A DIFFERENT RESULT…”

    #SMDHID


  15. This is a moot point!

    For whether the subvention is had or not, any party likely to win will be heavily relying on the big money men.

    A leading company, for example, use to give one million each, at an early time, for manifestos. Even if one argues for publicly funded elections, and this writer so agrees, national ‘institutions’ should not be dependent on handouts.

    This problem is vastly more fundamental.

    That you have a DLP which existed, for more than 50 years, and has no newspaper, no internal capabilities to conduct studies, no cadre of writers, no internal revenue generating ability to pay the minimal costs of operations, have always meant that not only elections funding is required, especially when in opposition, both the DLP and BLP will continue to be beggars to corporate interests.

    What is more, is that this same DLP was happy to be led by people who have no means of supporting the party.

    And we may go on.

    But this problem of a subvention does not address a culture of failure represented by the party system. And if neither party can support and grow itself, what is the country really doing?

    150K is a pittance in these circumstances and only serves as a means of making and keeping political and economic small-mindedness alive and well.

    Paupers selling pipedreams,are these parties.


  16. They say “Never get into a debate when it comes to religion or politics” however, reading some of these comments I feel compelled to also throw my pennies worth in.

    Politicians are needed, how else can a country run! Politicians are humans just like you and me, the difference is they know how to baffle brains with bullshit and take from the needy, the days are gone where you will ever encounter a good, honest and godly politician, I think the last one Barbados had was Errol Barrow. He was Barbados and Barbados was what he lived for, “truth, justice and a better life for his people” all of which is a thing of the past. If Barbadians want to see change they first have to get rid of the cancer that is keeping them suppressed and unable to grow and that is CORRUPTION, corruption in politics corruption in the legal system and corruption that is been taught to the younger generation which is our future, the future of Barbados.

    Barbados needs a strong person that could and would stand up to CORRUPTION and don’t become corrupt themselves and while the present government is in power, who knows how to place the cat amongst the pigeons to cause confusion and chaos whenever they feel threatened, that seems to be a far cry away.

    A sheriff is needed to clean up DODGE!!


  17. It says a lot Prime Minister Mottley would feed the current dysfunction by accepting the full subvention. Action speaks louder than words.

    Thorne: DLP will survive

    Political leader says decision on subvention up to executive, council

    THE DEMOCRATIC LABOUR PARTY (DLP) will survive without the State-allocated subvention, says its political leader Ralph Thorne.

    He, however, is calling for tough campaign financing laws to ensure there is greater transparency.

    Thorne, who recently resigned as a member of the Barbados Labour Party (BLP), crossed the floor of Parliament and rejoined the DLP as its political leader, was responding to a question on whether the Dems will be going after half of the $150 000 subvention allocated to parties elected to Parliament.

    Defer

    “I will defer to the administration of the DLP and if they take a decision to apply for that, I will accept it, but I will treat that as an administrative matter to be dealt with by the executive and general council of the party.

    “The subvention is always welcomed, but the party will survive whether we have a subvention or not. The life of this party is not going to be dependent on the subvention,” Thorne told the DAILY NATION yesterday after he met with residents in Olive Lodge Road, Holders Hill, St James, who were protesting a cell tower erected in their community.

    Clerk of Parliament Pedro Eastmond had previously said the ruling BLP received the $300 000 subvention.

    “A total funding of $300 000 is allocated to political parties elected to Parliament. For example, when there were two political parties represented in Parliament, $150 000 each was allocated to the two political parties.

    Allocation

    “It should be noted that these parties would have had to contest the election as a political party and gain a seat in Parliament. As there is only one political party gaining all the seats from the last election, that allocation goes to the lone political party based on my earlier exposition,” Eastmond said.

    Thorne said there needs to be greater transparency surrounding the financing of political parties.

    “I think we need to have campaign financing laws in place so that subventions will never be an issue and undue influences on parties will never be an issue. Contributing to campaigns secretly has to end because it injures the democratic process.

    “People tend to have an undue influence on the political process when you don’t have campaign financing laws,” he added.

    (TG)

    Source: Nation


  18. In a related matter.

    Subventions need oversight

    THE TERM TRANSPARENCY in government may seem to be an overworked concept when in reality it is the sine qua non of good and accountable governance.

    This is obviously the raw spot caused by the remarks of Leader of the Opposition Ralph Thorne last week in Parliament and subsequent indignation of his opponents regarding the issue of a $500 000 State subvention to the Barbados Alliance to End Homelessness.

    The issue goes beyond this particular beneficiary since too little is known of the subventions the State gives to civil society.

    The Third Sector is becoming increasingly important in supporting and delivering services in our society as it tackles the bothersome issues of the day.

    Their work with the homeless, health campaigns, ex-prisoners, battered and abused women, and feeding the hungry, among other causes, highlight such valiant efforts.

    Some of these groups, service clubs and religious organisations depend on volunteers to achieve their objectives, a few are good at fund-raising to help meet their goals, but many need financial assistance to stay afloat.

    The question arises, however, as to whether there is rigorous oversight to understand the benefits and potential risks of their efforts on society.

    It is evident that no single non-governmental organisation (NGO) in Barbados can achieve its mission and goals on its own.

    Unfortunately, we have multiple NGOs pursuing the same goals with little apparent inquisitiveness about each other.

    There is therefore redundancy caused by overlapping and duplication among such groupings in our very small nation where there is a greater demand for charity than available funding to support the efforts.

    Collaboration and working crosssector with Government and the private sector can result in a win-win on the things that matter most to the NGOs and the public. However, the leadership of these groups must think big and be ready to accept change.

    The administration recognises that it may not be able to respond to needs as efficiently and effectively as the Third Sector and may see subventions to NGOs as a viable pathway to its objectives.

    There is need for a clearly defined policy on how subventions are to be allocated to recipients who should be audited, meet compliance requirements and in some cases have a Government appointee on the board of trustees.

    Government should establish a Register of Beneficiaries of State subventions outlining the amount given and the intended life of the arrangement. The principal officers should be named and there should be rigid stipulations on exactly how the funds must be used.

    The rationale for choosing the recipients should be made clear since only worthiness must matter and that there be no appearance of preferential treatment to any NGO.

    In an era when fiscal responsibility is a priority, there must be no gaping holes in how the taxpayers’ funds are utilised, and this must include grant funding allocated to charities and civil society. A parliamentary discussion on subventions would be a truly seminal moment.

    Source: Nation

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading