Banner promoting anonymous crime reporting with a phone and contact number 1 800 TIPS (8477), featuring the Crime Stoppers logo and a QR code for submitting tips.

← Back

Your message to the BLOGMASTER was sent

54 responses to “Strasbourg rules again: no human right to same-sex marriage”


  1. What has the European High Court ruling to do with the Constitution of the United States? This ruling by the European High Court is going to have little or no meaning to the states legislatures in the United States and the Supreme Court. We already know that the US Jurisprudence shapes the world’s penal system and from where is stands, it appears as though that the majority of Americans somehow supports Same-Sex-Marriage.

  2. Carl W Barker Avatar

    At present there are19 States with Legal Gay Marriage and 31 States with Same-Sex Marriage Bans. Do these figures constitute a majority? And by the way, in some states like California, SSM has not been approved by the electorate, but by the judiciary! Talk about democracy!


  3. this is an extraordinary case ,,,which might occur again and would be tested with similarties in other countries,,,naturally the Catholic diocese has pounced upon this as a proof,,,,,,,of agreement with religious doctrine,,but with clarity should not be interpreted as such,,,,,given that other countries have given the green light on same sex marriages..with consideration to human rights


  4. Who handed down this ruling, the European Court of Human Rights or the Catholic Church? Who carried the issue to the Court, the Catholic Church or an individual?


  5. Marriage as an institution that affords the possible for mankind to continue the existence of the species, MUST BE PRESERVED!


  6. Carl, progress has been made with respect to gay relation in America because prior to the 1960’s, the practiced of homosexuality was deemed illegal in every state within the United States. And as soon as the US Supreme Court, renders it decision on the issue of same – marriage, federal law which supersedes state law will finalized this issue once and for all.


  7. Have a couple of you commenting read the PDF document and equip yourself to challenge the European Human Rights Court ruling?

    Jesus, http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/webservices/content/pdf/003-4821870-5880860.


  8. Understood David..but all said and done,,,,, the decision by the court can be justifiably agreed by some or criticized ,,the FACT is that the court decision was interpreted by the Catholic diocese as a proof that human rights has no place in decision making as a right for same sex marriage,,however in my humble opinion after reading what was presented partially by the catholic,,, it would appear on face value that the ECHR discounted the relevancy of Human Rights in their decision,,which they did not , based on the the splinter evidence presented one would assume the defendant (fight) was seeking the legality of gender change and assuming same rights privileges.the court did not refuse or deny him such rights,,, only stated that human rights has already been considered ,,a right which he has already obtained legally by marriage,


  9. Oilman, you have spew a bunch of words which haven’t any empirical basis reality as we speak because the institution of marriage between a man a woman, has already been undermined worldwide. And how can you perserved something which has already been given a stamped of approval by certain countries? It’s like a girl who loses her virginity and tries to convince her boyfriend that she is still a virgin.


  10. Now, given the widely published sex scandal in the Catholic Church, many ought to agree that the Catholic Church is in no position to pontificate on the mechanics of morality.


  11. “Now, given the widely published sex scandal in the Catholic Church, many ought to agree that the Catholic Church is in no position to pontificate on the mechanics of morality.”

    Donkey that is the very first piece of sense you have ever posted on BU.

    Oilman you do not need marriage to continue the species. Most Bajans have been born out of wedlock, have been born out of adulterous relationships and many from incestuous relationships.


  12. In order for this ISSUE to be considered a ‘right’ it MUST be ‘RIGHT’ in the first place, otherwise it IS* WRONG*

    This is NOT a majority ‘RIGHT’ as voted in the USA;

    It IS WRONG ‘morally’ PHYSICALLY, and Spiritually!

  13. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Dompey

    Don’t get so animated you can still have your male friend, just that the ruling says countries cannot be forced to accept same sex marriage as a human right. Calm down you can still have your boyfriend.


  14. The fundamental reason I believe that same- sex -marriage has caused such contention, is based on the fact that gay and lesbian people want to be afforded the same Rights and Privileges other marriages, which are recognized by the state have. Now, furthermore, since there is this High Wall which separates Church and State, why is it necessary for the State to use a religious brand of Morality to invalidated same-sex-marriage? A Secular State which conveniently, utilizes a religious morality, to invalidate those things which affronts the conscience of a few, really undermines the true purpose of our democratic ideals.


  15. Caswell Franklyn

    To be quite frank, I am a very religious man but I would at any cost defend the Rights to: self- determination, self-perfection, self-realization, self-actualization; mental, intellectual as well as cognitive liberty.


  16. @ Caswell
    Thanks for that clarification…
    Dompey like he was about to go “bullistic”..


  17. well said dompey agree,,,,,,historical facts bears out that religion was the first god given institution for any and all of racist or discriminatory practices nothing has change,,the basic roots of racism still remains in tact in the church,the only order of business is that same sex marriage has now reopen the pandoras box.


  18. Thanks Caswell, the lack of comprehension skills being demonstrated is amazing. A couet hands down a ruling and instead of analyzing we are off about the Catholic church.


  19. What are the “mechanics” of morality? Where do you find the blueprint?

    The fact that some Roman (and other) priests are ‘fallen’ hardly deprives the institutional church from pronouncing upon morality. surely?

    Consider Paul Tillich – a leading 20c theologian who visited (with his wife) sex clubs, bonked his students and was addicted to porn. Did all that preclude him from being taken seriously as a theologian? Colin Wilson in ‘The Misfits’ says ‘yes’. RR would say ‘no’ – for reasons I’ll explain if anyone asks me.

    The UDHR refers to men and women having a right to marry. Subject to correction, it doesn’t actually say ‘each other’.

    The post (and Court) speaks of ‘understandings of marriage’. ‘Understandings’ to whom? Is the dispute about meanings (are there any absolutes?) or the way words are conventionally used. Is there any ‘game’ whose rules determine the appropriate use of the word ‘marriage’?

    But broadly, a case of festina lente.


  20. David…surely you cant expect everyone in a moment only to analyze a judgment over breakfast?

    And you see, when we start speaking about morality the root premise is that without religion there is no morality – hence my reference to ‘blueprint’ above. I don’t accept that you understand but it IS the common understanding.


  21. Ross, I would hardly equate one priest’s senseless pleasures with the sex -moslestation of thousands of innocent children and at the perverted hands of the Catholic- priesthood.


  22. The above ruling is profound and practical. It represents a triumph for reason, logic and commonsense over selfishness and personal idiosyncracies.

  23. Life changer + Avatar
    Life changer +

    @ David.
    Thank you…
    Faith, Jesus told us we would have hard times. He never promised us a prosperity gospel. He said we would face opposition, but he said he would be with us. If we are going to be faithful to his gospel, we must preach repentance—even when that repentance is culturally unwelcome. And we must preach that any sinner can be forgiven through the blood of Jesus Christ. That means courage and that means kindness. Sexual revolutionaries will hate the repentance. Buffoonish heretics, who want only to vent paranoia and rally their troops, will hate the kindness. So be it….


  24. So what are u saying balance that the church is without sin or blemish, to quote a famous and well know philosophizer, he who is without sin cast the first stone,,,,,do u think the church would pass the test…….the .ruling in itself does not answer the question of marriage as an institution should be permitted to dis avowed same sex marriages,,the judges ruling clings to a persuasion that even though the defendant has change his gender… by law he/she is still in good legal standing and no human rights violations have been denied,,,… Ross where are your legal views….it belive the judges tried to avoid going too far within reach of the same sex marriage issue in reference to this case , but rater use the defendant( pass) status to render judgement


  25. Ross, alot of secular -humanist are of the opinion that Morality is derived from Empathy for our fellow human being. But one could argue quite convincingly, that the understanding of Empathy varies from culture to culture. And that Religious- Morality is predicated on what the German philosopher Emanuel Kant, calls the Categorical-Imperative. This type of Religious- Morality stretches across cultures! For example, I know of no culture where the killing of an innocent human being is exclusively sanctioned without punitive consequences, and this is universal across the board.

  26. GEORGIE PORGIE Avatar

    BEA General Meeting on the Solid Waste Tax
    To:

    Dear Pastors and Church Leaders,

    At a recent Emergency Meeting of the Executive of the BEA to discuss the Municipal Solid Waste Tax it was recognized that Churches had started to receive their invoices and were perplexed at the sum required to be paid.

    The Executive of the BEA is announcing an emergency meeting for Thursday 31st July, 2014 at the Jackson Church of God for Pastors, Leaders and all concerned persons are asked to be present as we (the Church) discuss the Municipal Solid Waste Tax and its implications on the Church, its programmes and social commitments.

    Reality is, this tax will affect all. Everyone is asked to make a special effort to be present and be involved in the discussion. The Church must deal with this issue as a collective body as we look not only at the challenges but the possible solutions.

    We have to move pass idealism into realism.

    Please make contact with your membership and leadership so that they can share in this special meeting.

    See you in Jackson this Thursday night at 7:15 p.m.

    This is a time for the Church to be represented on an issue as critical and impacting as this current national topic.

    Barbados Evangelical Association

    The directions to the Jackson Church of God are as follows.

    1. For those coming from the directions of Bibby’s Lane, Lears

    From Bibby’s Lane (pass Nichols Bakery) to the junction which will take drivers onto Cane Garden, , Turn RIGHT at the junction. From Cane Garden there is a straight travel to Cane Wood Road, passing Do it Best and other businesses on the left . Towards the end of Cane wood Road, approaching the roundabout in Jackson, there is a Church on the left (Jackson Christian Mission ). Immediately before the Church there is a left turn. The Church will be in view on the Right.

    1. From Lears one would travel to the end of the woods. At the major stop turn RIGHT, followed by a quick LEFT at the junction which will take drivers onto Cane Garden. From Cane Garden there is a straight travel to Cane Wood Road, passing Do it Best and other businesses on the left. Towards the end of Cane wood Road, approaching the roundabout in Jackson, there is a Church on the left (Jackson Christian Mission ). Immediately before the Church there is a left turn. The Church will be in view on the Right.

    2. From those travelling from the direction of Hothersal Turning, proceed on the straight, passing St. Matthew’s Anglican Church until one reaches the Junction which will take drivers onto Cane Garden, Turn LEFT at the junction. From Cane Garden there is a straight travel to Cane Wood Road, passing Do it Best and other business on the left. Towards the end of Cane wood Road, approaching the roundabout in Jackson, there is a Church on the left (Jackson Christian Mission ). Immediately before the Church there is a left turn. The Church will be in view on the Right.

    3. Coming from Warrens, pass One Accord Plaza on left . Proceed to Jackson. Approaching the Roundabout keep to the RIGHT entering the roundabout. The Christian Mission Church is on the RIGHT. The Road leading to the Jackson Church of God is a matter of feet after passing the Christian Mission Church Church. Jackson Church of God will be in full view at this time.

    4. Coming from the direction of Sharon, keep LEFT on entering the Round about. Walkes Meat Depot is on the left entering the Roundabout and the Christian Mission Church is on the Right.(out of the roundabout). Turn RIGHT after passing the Christian Mission Church. Jackson Church of God will be in full view at this time.


  27. What we’re also dealing with here is what constitutes Right and Wrong, and the historical as well as the contemporary underdanding of these two metaphysical entities. Nonetheless, as it is often said: if we haven’t a religious standard upon which stand, how would Hitler have known that what he had done to the Jewish people was wrong? Question: regarding objective morality Ross…. Now, if I take a young child and cut it up into small pieces in front of you, would you say I did any thing wrong? Bearing in mind of course, that there is no such thing as Religious-Morality!


  28. Dompey

    Do we NEED God to be moral beings?

    And if I saw you killing a child I would kill you…………the question is why I would do that.

    Oh and Dompey…I wasn’t saying there was a moral equivalence between Tillich and priestly molestation. Tillich’s case raises similar issues however.

  29. Man Of Creation Avatar
    Man Of Creation

    Lordie
    Jesus was a Homo, betrayed with a Kiss, Disowned by all his Bum Chums

  30. GEORGIE PORGIE Avatar

    FELLAHS
    WUNNAHJ HAVE TO LEFF ME OUT HERE
    I AINT GET NO POWER POINT ON GOOGLE TO USE HERE LOL MURDAH


  31. Ross

    “Do we need God to be moral beings”

    The answer to your above question is yes Ross.

    Qusestion Ross: can you rationally justify your unconditional adherence to a timeless value without implicitely invoking the existence of God? explain? Not to deflect but I am sure you have heard of Richard Dawskins? Well on the way to a debate one day, a young man told Mr. Dawskin that he was contemplating suicide, what should he do? Do you want to hear what was Dawskin reply: he said to the you man check my wibesite. Now, is that the best advice the leading atheist in the world, can give to a child who is obviously in need of immediate spiritual or psychological intervention?


  32. There is a moral compass which moves for obvious reasons. The morality of an individual who is a Christian will have a different compass median compared to the agnostic or aethiest. The challenge at the national level is how do we represent individual moral positions as a collective one.


  33. David, whether you choose to admit it or not, both the atheist as well as agnostic, lives by some kind of religious-morality. If you ask an atheist or an agnostic what his or her position on homosexuality, or abortion, for that matter, more of than not it would be predicated on religious-values.

  34. GEORGIE PORGIE Avatar
    GEORGIE PORGIE

    The challenge at the national level is how do we represent individual moral positions as a collective one.

    thats easy David

    ALL WE HAVE TO DO IS ATTEND THE SCHOOL OF PROFESSOR BRASS BOWL AKA BUP, FOLLOW HIM WHO ASKS SEEKS AND FINDS AND WHO NOSE EVATING BOUT EVATING ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO PARABLES AND PROPHESY
    OH LOSS


  35. The atheist and the agnostic may not believe in the supernatural aspect of Christianity, but I would hazand and educational guess that the both of them live by other forms of the religious code.


  36. An agnostic or aethiest cannot be religious unless we are muddling faithbase with what it is to be religious.


  37. But Dompey – you’re begging the question – which is ‘Do you NEED the religious code to be moral?’

    Or to put it another way and taking in what David just said…..religiousness, which is in the heart of every man to a greater or lesser extent, leaves ‘religion’ way behind.

    Consider Buddhism.


  38. Sorry Dompey…I should have asked…by ‘god’ do you mean a divine legislator (like Fumble) or what? In any event, where did ‘His’ blueprint come from and how?


  39. And yet another…..re Tillich’s “senseless pleasure”….don’t you think that sexual pleasure makes perfect sense?

    (But I’m off now…see you DV in two days or so)


  40. Ross

    “Religiousness which is in the heart of every man….”

    Where does this so call religiousness, which out of no way, found itself into the heart of man; comes from Ross? Now, do recall the British philosopher John Locke, spoke about the Tabula Rasa? The mind being the blank Slate on which experience is written? The mind, heart or whatever you choose to call it, is without knowledge at birth, so explain this Religiousness which found itself into the mind void of knowledge/ experience?

  41. GEORGIE PORGIE Avatar
    GEORGIE PORGIE

    all you fellas need to go on google and get some power points


  42. PG, are you trying to be metaphorical here?

  43. GEORGIE PORGIE Avatar
    GEORGIE PORGIE

    dompey
    i nose nuttin ok? so i does have to go on google to get power points
    dis is de word of he who nose evating bout evating- his name is professor bup or professor brasss bowl

    since he nose evating why isnt he the archbishop or de prime minister?
    why dont no one go on his blog?

    why dont he tek ova and lead the brass bowls since he nose more dan all de udder brass bowls
    why all he can do is ask franklyn to bup?

    i is havin fun ok? u have fun 2 ok?
    lol

  44. GEORGIE PORGIE Avatar
    GEORGIE PORGIE

    I JUST GOOGLE THIS DOMPEY WUH YOU TINK?

    In a major structural change in West Indies’ first-class cricket structure, the six regional teams will be able to select players from all over the region, and possibly even from overseas. Whycliffe Cameron, the WICB president, said in a television interview that the changes – based on the recommendations of the Pybus Report – would bring a franchise structure to the regional first-class tournament, similar to that of the Caribbean Premier League. Last week, the WICB had already cut the first-class competition down to six teams by excluding Combined Campuses and Colleges.

    “We are moving towards a structure where we are going to have players from all over the region playing for different teams,” Cameron said. “Effective August and September we are going to have players from all over the region and potentially from outside the region who will be playing for these franchises and we are still going to call them Barbados, Jamaica and Trinidad.”

    Among the recommendations made by Richard Pybus, the WICB director, was also a draft system for first-class cricket. Under this system, each of the territorial boards will be allowed to retain and contract 10 players, with the rest of the region’s player pool going into a player draft for the teams to complete their 15-player squads.

    “We have announced that coming this year, with the new professional structure, teams will be able to select the best players from around the region,” Cameron said. “It is an interesting point however that these teams are going to fall directly under the auspices of the territorial boards.”


  45. Nonsense ==Cricket has now be totallly destroyed i


  46. @ GEORGIE PORGIE

    SO THE WEST INDIES WILL NOW HAVE COUNTY CRICKET WITH A QUOTA OF OVERSEAS PLAYERS.

    THEY MIGHT ALSO WANT TO GET A COACH WHO CAN TEACH THE FUNDAMENTALS OF TEST CRICKET BATTING AND BOWLING

  47. GEORGIE PORGIE Avatar
    GEORGIE PORGIE

    YES HANTS JUST LIKE THE CPL


  48. George Pogie

    I haven’t watch, neither have listen to cricket in the last thirty years. Because cricket as I see it, is just one more way of keeping a liberated Black people locked into a Colonialist-Tradition.

  49. GEORGIE PORGIE Avatar
    GEORGIE PORGIE

    sad
    you dont understand that its more than a game


  50. Good move by the WICB.

The blogmaster invites you to join the discussion.

Trending