Tony Marshall, Chairman of the National Insurance Board

One issue which has resurfaced coming out of the recent miscommunication by the National Insurance Scheme (NIS) to pensioners is the unavailability of a recent NIS certified financial report. A check of the NIS Website shows the most recent financials posted as at 2007.  Governments over the years have always borrowed from the NIS fund but the current economic hardship has forced the government to lean on the fund in an unprecedented way; or so it seems.

The importance of the NIS to the stability of a Barbados society cannot be underscored enough. Why should Barbadians in 2011 not expect our government to implement necessary systems to ensure a timely certified financial statement of the NIS fund? Barbadians need, as a matter of urgency, to leverage the education provided to us. One way which we can do so is to hold our government and others who hold public office more accountable.  The fact that this government and others gone before continue to hoodwink Barbadians by dillydallying over the implementation of Freedom of Information (FOI) and Integrity Legislation are two good examples.

Barbadians should note carefully the strategic goals of the NIS:

  1. To ensure timely processing of benefits
  2. To maximise compliance in terms of collection and achieve full compliance
  3. To maximise return on investment for the Fund
  4. To ensure efficient world-class customer service
  5. To establish a cadre of competent, efficient and highly motivated work force
  6. To improve internal and external communication at the Board

Item 6 is of special interest in light of the recent communications fiasco which has embarrassed the NIB, Minister Byer-Suckoo and by extension the government. More importantly the role of the NIS Board to realize item 3 is difficult for the public to measure because of the unavailability of current certified financials. The explanation offered by government spokesmen that in the low interest rate environment which is prevailing investments in public projects offer the best opportunity for better yields is a risky policy.

The  NIB is headed by retired banker Tony Marshall, head of management studies at UWI, Cave Hill Justin Robinson and others who are highly qualified to know what is required of managing Barbados’ most important fund. We need more transparency in how the NIS is being managed and if the public is to judge by the fiasco which reared its head last week, we should become very concerned.


  1. What a mess!

    The same government which Persaud heavily criticised has come to his rescue.

    Explains why his public mouthings on VoB have subsided in recent times.


  2. While you may thank a doctor who saves you from a heart attack if he/she cause it in the first place you sue him for malpratice so it never happens again. That is what sandi did. least he didn’t try to pass of the blame


  3. sorry it not been approved but needs final approval of the executive board which should have any problem.


  4. The NIS is now being asked to fund a takeover of the Almond Beach Hotels Group. After all these fundings would we have money to pay us pensioners?


  5. @Scout: “The NIS is now being asked to fund a takeover of the Almond Beach Hotels Group.

    Is the NIS being asked? Or told?

    @Scout: “After all these fundings would we have money to pay us pensioners?

    Well, the Smart Money of course would only invest in what they gain control over. And/or are assured of a reasonable rate of return.

    Is this “smart money”? Or just our money???

  6. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    It’s “our money” going down the drain! BTW, where is the foreign exchange (forex) to finance these acquisitions and investment partnerships. The foreign reserves (despite the book-keeping fudging) are under tremendous pressure where the rate of outflow from the bucket is greater than the rate of inflow. Next year we will witness a state of affairs where the forex level falls below 8 weeks of requirements.

    We should try to make these hotel / villa projects attractive enough to entice foreign investors. We definitely need the foreign currency inflows to finance our appetites for foreign goods and services. Grant them special status (casinos / private beaches /private ladies and gentlemen clubs?) Don’t, with your hypocrisy, tell me that these things are foreign and anathema to Bajans? If Bajans are so religiously outraged by these suggestions they should forced the government to forgo tax revenues by closing down the lottery and whorehouses and strip joints in Bridgetown and its surroundings.

    Let the religious Right take over these failing visitor establishments and turn them into places of worship where manna from the Sky would fall and they can feed the starving masses instead of imported rice, wheat flour, meat and medicine.


  7. @millertheanunnaki: “It’s “our money” going down the drain! BTW, where is the foreign exchange (forex) to finance these acquisitions and investment partnerships. The foreign reserves (despite the book-keeping fudging) are under tremendous pressure where the rate of outflow from the bucket is greater than the rate of inflow. Next year we will witness a state of affairs where the forex level falls below 8 weeks of requirements.

    Can you prove that?

    That is meant to be funny, and serious, at the same time.

    I’m very serious when I say that….


  8. Tourism in Barbados is at such a low, that AA has reduced their flights to this country by 50%, BA has reduced their flights by 30%, yet my Min of Tourism is constantly on my TV campaigning about the drastic RISE in the tourist industry. Mr Minister, we acknowledge that these are hard times, so come to us truthfully, your party fooled us in 2008, now you really expect to come with the same line of rubbish again? You should know the saying ” fool me once; shame on you, fool me twice; shame on me.” I’m not about to be fooled the second time, so tell ALL your ministers level with the voting public and hope for trhe best, but for the sake of this country, don’t try fooling us again.


  9. @Caswell et al

    What does the Act/financial rules declare about the NIS Board producing Audited Financial Statements?


  10. @The Scout

    To the best of recollection AA has reduced the number of flights from 9 to 7.


  11. David
    I just came from the airport and I enquired from a senior person there, it seems AA only flies in on Friday Saturday and Sunday, occasionally on Wednesday, if they have enough passengers.


  12. @The Scout: “I just came from the airport and I enquired from a senior person there, it seems AA only flies in on Friday Saturday and Sunday, occasionally on Wednesday, if they have enough passengers.

    What are your thoughts on the Fly Overs here in Bim?

    Should we spend tens of millions of dollars for a solution which will probably not actually work, but will cost a great deal of money?


  13. That the dallas flight scout ? AA.com still showing daily flight to mia


  14. @anthony… Are you making a joke? I will laugh if you are.

    Of *course* American Airlines flies daily to Miami International Airport.

  15. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    David

    Section 33 of the National Insurance and Social Security Act states:

    (1) the Board shall
    (a) in each year prepare a report on its activities in the last preceding year and shall furnish such report to the Minister not later than the thirtieth day of June;
    (b) submit to the Minister every account, certified by the Auditor-General pursuant to section 30, together withthe report of the Auditor-General thereon, within one month of such certification; and
    (c) submit annually to the Minister an account of the securities in which moneys forming part of the Fund are for the time invested

    (2) The Minister shall cause a copy of every report of account submitted to him pursuant to this section to be laid on the table of both Houses.


  16. From the Auditor general report 2010 http://bao.gov.bb/themes/marinelli/files/Auditor%20General%20Report%202010.pdf

    National Insurance Fund
    4.18 The accounts of the National Insurance Fund for the financial years 2003
    to 2009 are in arrears. As I indicated in my previous report the Department
    is making an effort to bring the accounts up-to-date. Financial statements
    for the financial years 2003 to 2005 have been submitted. The Audit Office
    is seeking assistance from the private sector to assist in bringing these
    audits up to date.


  17. This absolutely amazing.


  18. @Caswell

    He had the balls to take the necessary action. The severence payment was considered to generous and you are quite aware the business commnunity had considered it to be burdensome. The public service was bloated and you are quite aware of that,

    The govt which you supported re-bloated the public service inflicting excessive expnditure on the people of barbados, amassed massive debts and consequently contribute to the financail squeeze we find ourselves in. I know you can get the information. So show the growth of our debt under your govt over the 14 years it was in power, the number of public employees over the years and the wage bill starting in 1994 and ending in 2007

  19. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    What is absolutely amazing is that they could find time to bother old people with nonsense about opening bank accounts while so much substantive work could be in arrears, but worse yet, no heads have rolled for this state of affairs.


  20. @Caswell

    who placed the substantive diredtor in that position?


  21. @Obediant

    What does the blame game achieve?

  22. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ CH:

    No, I can’t prove it scientifically. But my assessment of the prevailing local economic conditions and lack of confidence and growth in the international money markets lead me to conclude that the days of Barbados’ easy access to foreign money are coming to an end.

    The main generators of forex are not working at the levels required to maintain a positive net position over the next 10 to 12 months. Reduced tourism receipts and sugar earnings, dwindling FDI, lack of growth in int’l business and falling remittances from overseas Bajans will have a significant impact on the reserves. Given a lack of confidence in the local economy you can expect foreign-owned companies to seek to reduce exposure by remitting management fees and profits to parent companies. Barbados has very limited flexibility in reducing demand for foreign currency outflows. Many goods and services that make up the body of the local economy are largely imported, petroleum products, for example. From the large financial institutions to the little shop in the village all depend on a constant flow of forex.

    Unless Barbados can quickly turn around the current net outflow this Xmas might be our last Merry One.

    Sorry to be so gloomy in my prognostication but nothing around us points to an optimistic outcome both locally and in those Western economies on which we are economically yoked.

  23. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    @ Obediant:

    I have no problem with your request made to Caswell. But in the interest of balance and fair play a similar exercise should be conducted for the more recent period 2008 to September 2011. Then the man in the middle will be in a more informed position to make a reasonable assessment of the parties’ performance.


  24. Sinckler pull that ‘rabbit’ out the hat!!


  25. Perhaps a dumb question but are we (the people) happy at the flagrant abuse of the rules by the principals of the NIS Fund?

    BU has always stated that these times are ripe for opposition politics but are we hearing them on these serious matters?

    Then again the current state of the NIS Fund is a perpetuation of what was under a BLP government anyway.


  26. David
    Some things are best amplified by the other power brokers within the political establishment.

  27. Caswell Franklyn Avatar
    Caswell Franklyn

    Obediant

    There you go putting lipstick on the pig again.
    It had nothing to do with Sandiford’s balls: it was his brain that was not functioning adequately that landed the country in the IMF mess.
    The business community thought that the severance payments benefits were too generous. What did you expect from those skinflints: they wanted to work the best years out of workers and then get rid of them with pittance. Sandiford facilitated that. Severance payments were structured in such a way that employers would not use it as a first option if they were required to restructure their businesses. Sandiford fixed something that was not broken at the behest of people who could make campaign contributions. Don’t you realize that both parties give lip-service to protecting workers’ rights while deminishing their benefits in favour of the employers aided and abetted by the unions, BWU in particular.


  28. @ David

    I noticed the Pierhead Marina issue on yesterdays front page, but nothing from BU?

    $40 million to design plus $12 million already paid for a design, $60 to pay out contractor awarded the contract and then $505 million to build the marina. At $617 million that one hell of an expensive marina, probably the ost expensive on the planet.


  29. @millertheanunnaki: “Sorry to be so gloomy in my prognostication but nothing around us points to an optimistic outcome both locally and in those Western economies on which we are economically yoked.

    Don’t apologize.

    Being honest is healthy.


  30. @ David

    I am neither.

    Can anyone justify this project, with or without its scandals, at this time? This surely cannot be a priority at this time unless of course the NIS is going to help fund this one as well.


  31. @david
    He doesn’t want to see the bigger picture but i pull down the tables fro him
    @ obediant

    Government total employees temporary and permanent wages in millions

    1991 24.6
    1992 22.3
    1993 21
    1994 21.9 410.9
    1995 22.9 435.7
    1996 23.9 462.9
    1997 25.2 503.5
    1998 25 530.6
    1999 26.9 579.9
    2000 25 601.5
    2001 26.7 606.5
    2002 27.7 641.9
    2003 27.9 571.2
    2004 27.5 645.5
    2005 28.2 687.5
    2006 27.1 698.6
    2007 26.3 809.0
    2008 26.6 832.7
    2009 26.6 861.1
    1Q 2010 30.9 no 2010 annual figure available 860.2

    Total government debt in thousands difference between start date and end date at change of governments
    1991 1947913
    1992 1991666
    1993 2324302
    1994 2497982 550069
    1995 2508908.5
    1996 2721676.61
    1997 2763552.42
    1998 2852629.9
    1999 2949102.98
    2000 3259162.45
    2001 3705319.8
    2002 3964681.78
    2003 4092603.77
    2004 4253688.88
    2005 4927885.98
    2006 5021419.53
    2007 5651384.16 3153402.16
    2008 6372872.988
    2009 7392359.758
    2010 8268343.87
    Q2 2011 8738600 3087215.84

    Total external government debt total domestic government debt ( guarantee+ special loans + PPP etc in thousand) total debt. difference between start date and end date
    1991 34700 960870.2 995570.2
    1992 195221.5 1102542.8 1297764.3
    1993 893625.1 1551334.3 2444959.4
    1994 893635.5 1896792 2790427.5 1794857.3
    1995 870773.3 1858623.5 2729396.8
    1996 1244633.4 2067488.9 3312122.3
    1997 1196461.2 2227002.2 3423463.4
    1998 1172856.3 2347762.2 3520618.5
    1999 1355445 2322300 3677745
    2000 1898869.1 2545499.6 4444368.7
    2001 2266496.6 2608670.8 4875167.4
    2002 2321342.7 2967462.7 5288805.4
    2003 2475060.2 3159630.8 5634691
    2004 2434620.8 3288524.1 5723144.9
    2005 2695445.5 4102478 6797923.5
    2006 2990902 4206260.6 7197162.6
    2007 3,130,244.00 4,900,894.10 8031138.1 5240710.6
    2008 3,486,784.18 5,421,975.00 8908759.18
    2009 4,009,439.98 6,378,763.00 10388202.98
    2010 4,484,553.32 7,112,251.90 11596805.22 3565667.12


  32. @ obediant

    I do not usually go off the topic, but in this instance I feel that I should. Ya know when you have to respond to some of the nonsense you people write, and it is not in favour of the DLP, you are labelled as a BLP.

    Mr. obediant sir, you are always quick to bring the same points to each and every topic presented on the blog for discussion, which is “blame the BLP”. I must agree with another commentator on this blog who wrote that the BLP did nonsense and they paid the ultimate price by being convincingly voted out of office. The BLP is the opposition because they were punished for their wrong doings.

    What sense does it make for you to keep on with your “blame the BLP nonsense, when in the absence of freedom of information and integrity legislation, your party is under serious scrutiny? Are you aware that in the absence of integrity legislation, any individual who carefully and reasonably assess many of the decisions made by the DLP, can assume that there are elements of corruption abound?
    If they are so squeaky clean, why did they not introduce this legislation during their first 100 days in office, surely, they had six of the fourteen years in opposition to at least draft something so as to convince us that they were serious.
    If the DLP is so serious about their stance on corruption how come, after all the accusations and innuendo, no BLP parliamentarian has been brought before the law courts?
    Also, why did the Attorney General do a hatchet job on the integrity legislation bill that was brought before the house?

    THESE ARE QUESTIONS I WANT YOU TO ANSWER.


  33. @millertheanunnaki

    q3 figure won’t be available till oct 11 Q3 economic figure release by central bank. Did the figure we latest and best available figure from CB website.

  34. millertheanunnaki Avatar
    millertheanunnaki

    When are we going to do something about these corrupt politicians!

    What marina! This will never see the light of day. Who are the financiers? Don’t tell me the NIS? Unless we have foreign investors where is this money going to come from? I smell a rat! And Owen will know that the award of contract for this “re-design” phase is just a way of making certain people rich. Submit what has already been done and DB and friends can hold onto some kickbacks from the Treasury some of which would find its way into political campaign funding.

    Mr. PM why are going to put a stop to this downright thievery of taxpayers money before people take matters into their own hands. OSA, if you want to redeem yourself in the eyes of fair-minded and honest Bajans you must speak more vehemently on these matters and stop the rape of the Treasury.


  35. Christopher Halsall
    I don’t know where you get your information but AA has DRASTICALLY reduced it’s service to Barbados. In fact AA is in deep financial problems and is right now trying to link up with another airline to stay in business. AA is working with JetBue i heard to handle their passengers out of Barbados. This last pc of information is to me just a humor


  36. @ millertheanunnaki

    Is this non-sense so common place in Barbados, that you can be so matter of fact about it all?

    So you are saying this is just a total gimmick for some personal and political enrichment all at the expense of the taxpayers of Barbados? Say it ain’t so, please say it ain’t so.

    The dark murky world of politics, so can you trust OSA when he says he wants an enquiry into the matter?


  37. @Scout… Read my post again… I talked about Miami, not Barbados.


  38. There have been numerous developments over the last week or so on the CLICO matter. Has anyone heard the Opposition making a call on anything to do with CLICO? There have been more projects that are targeting NIS funds. Has anyone heard the Opposition speaking out on this?

    The obvious lack of access to CBC might be part of the reason but Owen Arthur did not have to use CBC to get his message across about the Marina. Why couldn’t he use Barbados today and the Nation to get his party’s views on CLICO and what should be done about that problem to the electorate?

    This current DLP Government is the worse one we have had since adult suffrage, bar none, and the BLP opposition is also the worse opposition party we have had over the same time frame.


  39. well they seem to have article about four season in tomorrow paper but your right if they don’t improve we just have to choose between the better of two lazy parties


  40. must i tell you again that both political parties are piggybacking on former legacies and have nothing substantial to offer other than to kill the fatted or as it is now lean calf and have therefore outlived their usefulness. there has to be another way otherwise there would be no calf to kill eventually.


  41. anthony |

    F#ck friend … those figures make absolutely no sense to me …


  42. Well well, Tony Marshall lives on … I wonder what his present position is on reverse mortgages ..!


  43. IS it true that Tony Marshall is a snob ?
    IS it true that are a lot of snobs in top positions in Barbados?
    IS it a requirement that you be a snob in order to fill certain positions ???.
    IS it true that you have to hate people (Blacks -especially) to portray yourself as ‘ somebody’ in order to be a top person in top positions???
    WHY is the society not dealing with ISSUES ??


  44. @Just Asking

    Is is true that you dont seem to have much between your ears?

    Is it true that you dont add anything to the discussions on this blog?

    Is is true thatt your self esteem is low>

    Bonny would ask this question, are you a shoite?

    @Bonny

    why this idiot attacking your swoite man? Is it because he envy him for his analytical and oratorial skills?

  45. Random Thoughts Avatar

    The position on reverse mortgages is that no only shall the banks indenture the parents, but the children as well, and the children’s children.

    Believe me that if reverse mortgages ever become widespread that banks will charge very, very, very hefty fees, and Barbadian families who used to own property will find that their property is heavily mortgaged to some bank in the Great White North, and the banksters here who get their who get paid big salaries and fees offa emcumbering the middle class.

    Don’t be so foolish as to think reverse mortgages are designed to help us. Reverse mortgages are designed to put big money into the hands of banksters.


  46. @Obediant

    We do not need a partisan argument when discussing the NIS Fund, it is too important to regulate the discussion to that level.


  47. @Art

    If the dlp is involved in corruption then the leader of your party can use Pac to investigate.

    The point is a draft integrity bill has been done, get your party to cooperte, i bet you they wont.

    If u understand how legislation is drafted, you wont expect that govt could have achieved that in 100 days, that was a wish, the govt has to wait on the drafters.

    You want the public to ignore the sources of some of the problems we are experiincing, but barbadains are not stupid, Eric Williams always say for us to understand the present, we must study and understand the past, Too bad people like you have difficulty in referencing the past. Barbdos is a society and not an economy.

    By the way, i am not easily fooled. I have stated that I have voted for the DLP all my life except once. People like u want to hide your allegiance to the blp and think you can blind people, U should have no fear, we on this blog are either sympathetic to the b or the d.


  48. @Anthony

    The point i wanted made is that expenditure has bee rising through the ages. If u have a morgate and your income/revenue has fallen through no fault ot your own what do u expect|? By the way you now need to show the revenue for the periods to complete the equation.

    By the way u have no shpwn the growth of employment in the Public Service.


  49. Reverse Mortgages are a Tony Marshall campaign … He was foisting this on the BARP membership who couldn’t give a goat’s ball about leaving shit behind! Cash in and spend the rest of your parasite lives spending foreign ex and cruising the world … Foreign exchange that very very few of you has ever gained any experience earning … Live big for the last and die, who gives a shit about Banksters …

Leave a Reply to Checkit-OutCancel reply

Trending

Discover more from Barbados Underground

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading